QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE. Optimal Time Series Momentum QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE

 Patience Carpenter
 6 months ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE Research Paper 353 January 15 Opimal Time Series Momenum XueZhong He, Kai Li and Youwei Li ISSN
2 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM XUEZHONG HE, KAI LI AND YOUWEI LI *Finance Discipline Group, UTS Business School Universiy of Technology, Sydney PO Box 13, Broadway, NSW 7, Ausralia **School of Managemen Queen s Universiy Belfas, Belfas, UK Absrac. We develop a coninuousime asse price model o capure he ime series momenum documened recenly. The underlying sochasic delay differenial sysem faciliaes he analysis of effecs of differen ime horizons used by momenum rading. By sudying an opimal asse allocaion problem, we find ha he performance of ime series momenum sraegy can be significanly improved by combining wih marke fundamenals and iming opporuniy wih respec o marke rend and volailiy. Furhermore, he resuls also hold for differen ime horizons, he ouofsample ess and wih shorsale consrains. The ouperformance of he opimal sraegy is immune o marke saes, invesor senimen and marke volailiy. Key words: Momenum, reversal, porfolio choice, opimaliy, profiabiliy. JEL Classificaion: G1, G14, E3 Dae: January 1, 15. Acknowledgemen: Financial suppor from he Ausralian Research Council (ARC) under Discovery Gran (DP13131) is graefully acknowledged. We would like o hank Li Chen, Blake LeBaron, Michael Moore, Bern Øksendal, Lei Shi, Jun Tu and Zhen Wu for helpful commens and suggesions. The usual caveas apply. Corresponding auhor: Kai Li, Finance Discipline Group, UTS Business School, Universiy of Technology, Sydney, 1
3 HE, LI AND LI Opimal Time Series Momenum Absrac We develop a coninuousime asse price model o capure he ime series momenum documened recenly. The underlying sochasic delay differenial sysem faciliaes he analysis of effecs of differen ime horizons used by momenum rading. By sudying an opimal asse allocaion problem, we find ha he performance of ime series momenum sraegy can be significanly improved by combining wih marke fundamenals and iming opporuniy wih respec o marke rend and volailiy. Furhermore, he resuls also hold for differen ime horizons, he ouofsample ess and wih shorsale consrains. The ouperformance of he opimal sraegy is immune o marke saes, invesor senimen and marke volailiy. Key words: Momenum, reversal, porfolio choice, opimaliy, profiabiliy. JEL Classificaion: G1, G14, E3
4 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 3 1. Inroducion Recenly, Moskowiz, Ooi and Pedersen (1) empirically invesigae ime series momenum (TSM) ha characerizes srong posiive predicabiliy of a securiy s own pas reurns. This paper aims o heoreically examine how o opimally explore TSM in financial markes. We exend he sandard geomeric Brownian asse pricing model o incorporae a moving average momenum componen and a meanrevering fundamenal componen ino he drif. By sudying a dynamic asse allocaion problem, we derive he opimal invesmen sraegy of combining momenum and mean reversion in closed form, which includes pure momenum and pure meanrevering sraegies as special cases. To demonsrae he opimal performance of his sraegy, we esimae he model o monhly reurns of he S&P 5 index and use boh he uiliy of porfolio wealh and Sharpe raio o measure he performance of various rading sraegies. We show ha sraegies based on he pure momenum and pure meanreversion models canno ouperform he marke bu he opimal sraegy of combining hem can. We compare he performance of he opimal sraegy wih he TSM sraegy used in Moskowiz e al. (1) and show ha he opimal sraegy ouperforms he TSM and passive holding sraegies in he empirical lieraure. Essenially, in conras o a TSM sraegy based on rend only, he opimal sraegy akes ino accoun no only he rading signal based on momenum and fundamenals bu also he size of posiion, which is associaed wih marke volailiy. This paper conribues o he lieraure in hree main ways. Firs, we find ha he performance of TSM sraegy can be significanly improved by combining wih marke fundamenals. To demonsrae he ouperformance, we derive a subopimal porfolio purely based on he TSM effec. We find ha his porfolio is no able o ouperform he marke porfolio and he opimally combined porfolio. Wihou considering he fundamenals, he pure momenum porfolio is highly leveraged, and hence suffers from higher risks. For comparison, we also derive anoher subopimal porfolio, he pure meanrevering porfolio, by ignoring he TSM effec. We find ha his porfolio is based conservaively on fundamenal invesmens, leading o a sable growh rae of porfolio wealh, bu is no able o explore he price rend, especially during exreme marke periods, and hence underperforms he opimal porfolio. In addiion o he above modelbased resuls, we furher invesigae he modelfree performance of he TSM. We consruc he TSM porfolio following Moskowiz e al. (1) o verify he heoreical analysis. We find ha our opimal sraegy ouperforms he TSM sraegy wih respec o Sharpe raio and cumulaive excess reurn. Second, o he bes of our knowledge, his paper is he firs o heoreically examine he ime horizon effec on momenum rading. The ime horizon plays a crucial
5 4 HE, LI AND LI role in he performance of momenum sraegies, which have been invesigaed exensively in he empirical lieraure. 1 However, due o he echnical challenge, here are few heoreical resuls concerning he ime horizon. The asse pricing model developed in his paper akes he ime series momenum effec direcly ino accoun. Therefore hisorical prices underlying he ime series momenum componen affec asse prices, resuling in a nonmarkov process characerized by sochasic delay differenial equaions (SDDEs). This is very differen from he Markov asse price process documened in he lieraure (Meron 1969, 1971) in which i is difficul o model he ime series momenum sraegy explicily. In he case of Markov processes, he sochasic conrol problem is mos frequenly solved using he dynamic programming mehod and HJB equaion. However, solving he opimal conrol problem for SDDEs using he dynamic programming mehod becomes more challenging because i involves infiniedimensional parial differenial equaions. The only oher way o solve he problem is o apply a ype of Ponryagin maximum principle, which was developed recenly by Chen and Wu (1) and Øksendal e al. (11) for he opimal conrol problem of SDDEs. By exploring hese laes advances in he heory of he maximum principle for conrol problems of SDDEs, we derive he opimal sraegies in closed form. This helps us o sudy horoughly he impac of hisorical informaion on he profiabiliy of differen sraegies based on differen ime horizons, in paricular of ime series momenum rading sraegies based on moving averages over differen ime horizons. Third, we show ha, in addiion o price rend, posiion size is anoher very imporan facor for momenum rading. The opimal posiion size derived in his paper is deermined by he level of rading signals and marke volailiy. In he empirical lieraure, momenum rading only considers he rading signals of price rend and akes a consan posiion o rade. We show ha, if we only consider he sign of rading signals indicaed by he opimal sraegy and ake a uni posiion o rade, he porfolio is no able o ouperform he opimal porfolio for all ime horizons. The robusness of he performance of he opimal sraegy is also esed for differen sample periods, ouofsample predicions, shorsale consrains, marke saes, invesor senimen and marke volailiy. This paper is closely relaed o he lieraure on reversal and momenum, wo of he mos prominen financial marke anomalies. Reversal is he empirical observaion ha asses performing well (poorly) over a long period end subsequenly o underperform (ouperform). Momenum is he endency of asses wih good (bad) recen performance o coninue ouperforming (underperforming) in he shor erm. Reversal and momenum have been documened exensively for a wide variey of asses. On he one hand, Fama and French (1988) and Poerba and Summers (1988), 1 See, for example, De Bond and Thaler (1985) and Jegadeesh and Timan (1993).
6 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 5 among many ohers, documen reversal for holding periods of more han one year, which induces negaive auocorrelaion in reurns. The value effec documened in Fama and French (199) is closely relaed o reversal, whereby he raio of an asse s price relaive o book value is negaively relaed o subsequen performance. Mean reversion in equiy reurns has been shown o induce significan marke iming opporuniies (Campbell and Viceira 1999, Wacher and Koijen, Rodríguez and Sbuelz 9). On he oher hand, he lieraure mosly sudies crosssecional momenum. 3 More recenly, Moskowiz e al. (1) invesigae TSM ha characerizes srong posiive predicabiliy of a securiy s own pas reurns. For a large se of fuures and forward conracs, Moskowiz e al. (1) find ha TSM based on excess reurns over he pas 1 monhs persiss for beween one and 1 monhs hen parially reverses over longer horizons. They provide srong evidence for TSM based on he moving average of lookback reurns. This effec based purely on a securiy s own pas reurns is relaed o, bu differen from, he crosssecional momenum phenomenon sudied exensively in he lieraure. Through reurn decomposiion, Moskowiz e al. (1) argue ha posiive auocovariance is he main driving force for TSM and crosssecional momenum effecs, while he conribuion of serial crosscorrelaions and variaion in mean reurns is small. Inuiively, a sraegy aking ino accoun boh he shorrun momenum and longrun mean reversion in ime series should be profiable and ouperform pure momenum and pure meanreversion sraegies. This paper esablishes a model o jusify his inuiion heoreically and empirically. The apparen persisen and sizeable profis of sraegies based on momenum and reversal have araced considerable aenion, and many sudies have ried o explain he phenomena. 4 Exending he lieraure, his paper develops an asse price model by aking boh mean reversion and ime series momenum direcly For insance, Jegadeesh (1991) finds ha he nex onemonh reurns can be negaively prediced by heir lagged muliyear reurns. Lewellen () shows ha he pas oneyear reurns negaively predic fuure monhly reurns for up o 18 monhs. 3 Jegadeesh and Timan (1993) documen crosssecional momenum for individual U.S. socks, predicing reurns over horizons of 3 1 monhs using reurns over he pas 3 1 monhs. The evidence has been exended o socks in oher counries (Fama and French 1998), socks wihin indusries (Cohen and Lou 1), across indusries (Cohen and Frazzini 8), and he global marke wih differen asse classes (Asness, Moskowiz and Pedersen 13). 4 Among which, he hreefacor model of Fama and French (1996) can explain longrun reversal bu no shorrun momenum. Barberis, Shleifer and Vishny (1998) argue ha hese phenomena are he resul of he sysemaic errors invesors make when hey use public informaion o form expecaions of fuure cash flows. Models Daniel, Hirshleifer and Subrahmanyam (1998), wih single represenaive agen, and Hong and Sein (1999), wih differen rader ypes, aribue he under reacion o overconfidence and overreacion o biased selfaribuion. Barberis and Shleifer (3) show ha syle invesing can explain momenum and value effecs. Sagi and Seasholes
7 6 HE, LI AND LI ino accoun and demonsraes he explanaory power of he model hrough he ouperformance of he opimal sraegy. This paper is largely moivaed by he empirical lieraure esing rading signals wih combinaions of momenum and reversal. 5 Asness, Moskowiz and Pedersen (13) highligh ha sudying value and momenum joinly is more powerful han examining each in isolaion. 6 Huang, Jiang, Tu and Zhou (13) find ha boh mean reversion and momenum can coexis in he S&P 5 index over ime. In his paper, we show heoreically ha a combined TSM and reversal sraegy is opimal. This paper is also inspired by Koijen, Rodríguez and Sbuelz (9), who propose a heoreical model in which sock reurns exhibi momenum and meanreversion effecs. They sudy he dynamic asse allocaion problem wih consan relaive risk aversion (CRRA) uiliy. This paper differs from Koijen e al. (9) in wo respecs. Firs, our modelling of TSM is differen. In Koijen e al. (9), he momenum is calculaed from he enire se of hisorical reurns wih geomerically decaying weighs. This effecively reduces he pricing dynamics o a Markovian sysem, bu i is difficul o explicily sudy he impacs of differen lookback periods on momenumrelaed rading sraegies. In his paper, we measure momenum by he sandard moving average over a moving window wih a fixed lookback period, which is consisen wih he momenum lieraure. Second, our focuses are differen. Koijen e al. (9) focus on he performance of he hedging demand implied by he model. In our paper we focus on he performance of he opimal sraegy compared o he marke, TSM, and meanreversion rading sraegies. The paper is organized as follows. We firs presen he model and derive he opimal asse allocaion in Secion. In Secion 3, we esimae he model o he S&P 5 and conduc a performance analysis of he opimal porfolio. We hen invesigae he ime horizon effec in Secion 4. Secion 5 concludes. All he proofs and he robusness analysis are included in he appendices.. The Model and Opimal Asse Allocaion In his secion, we inroduce an asse price model and sudy he opimal invesmen decision problem. We consider a financial marke wih wo radable securiies, (7) presen an opion model o idenify observable firmspecific aribues ha drive momenum. Vayanos and Woolley (13) show ha slowmoving capial can also generae momenum. 5 For example, Balvers and Wu (6) and Serban (1) show empirically ha a combinaion of momenum and meanreversion sraegies can ouperform pure momenum and pure meanreversion sraegies for equiy markes and foreign exchange markes respecively. 6 Theyfindhaseparaefacorsforvalueandmomenumbesexplainhedaaforeighdifferen markes and asse classes. Furhermore, hey show ha momenum loads posiively and value loads negaively on liquidiy risk; however, an equalweighed combinaion of value and momenum is immune o liquidiy risk and generaes subsanial abnormal reurns.
8 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 7 a riskless asse B saisfying db = rd (.1) B wih a consan riskless rae r, and a risky asse. Le S be he price of he risky asse or he level of a marke index a ime where dividends are assumed o be reinvesed. Empirical sudies on reurn predicabiliy, see for example Fama (1991), have shown ha he mos powerful predicive variables of fuure sock reurns in he Unied Saes are pas reurns, dividend yield, earnings/price raio, and erm srucure variables. Following his lieraure and Koijen e al. (9), we model he expeced reurn by a combinaion of a momenum erm m based on he pas reurns and a longrun meanreversion erm µ based on marke fundamenals such as dividend yield. Consequenly, we assume ha he sock price S follows ds S = [ φm +(1 φ)µ ] d+σ S dz, (.) where φ is a consan, measuring he weigh of he momenum componen m, σ S is a wodimensional volailiy vecor (and σ S sands for he ranspose of σ S), and Z is a wodimensional vecor of independen Brownian moions. The uncerainy is represened by a filered probabiliy space (Ω,F,P,{F } ) on which he wodimensional Brownian moion Z is defined. As usual, he meanreversion process µ is defined by an OrnseinUhlenbeck process, dµ = α( µ µ )d+σ µ dz, α >, µ >, (.3) where µ is he consan longrun expeced reurn, α measures he rae a which µ converges o µ, and σ µ is a wodimensional volailiy vecor. The momenum erm m is defined by a sandard moving average (MA) of pas reurns over [,], m = 1 ds u S u, (.4) where delay represens he ime horizon. The way we model he momenum in his paper is moivaed by he TSM sraegy documened recenly in Moskowiz e al. (1), who demonsrae ha he average reurn over a pas period (say, 1 monhs) is a posiive predicor of fuure reurns, especially he reurn for he nex monh. This is differen from Koijen e al. (9), in which he momenum M a ime is defined by M = e w( u)ds u, S u which is a geomerically decaying weighed sum of he pas reurns over [,]. The advanage of M is ha he resuling price process is a Markovian process. However, i suffers from some drawbacks. Firs, M is no a weighed average since he weighs over [,] do no sum o 1. Second, M is no a moving average of pas reurns wih a fixed ime horizon as commonly used in he empirical lieraure on momenum.
9 8 HE, LI AND LI Third, he reurn process and he momenum variable in he discreizaion of Koijen e al. s model have he same expression. 7 On he oher hand, he momenum m inroduced in (.4) overcomes hese drawbacks. I is a sandard moving average over amovingwindow[,]wihafixedlookbackperiodof(> )andheweighssum o 1. I is also consisen wih momenum sraegies used in he empirical lieraure ha explore price rends based on he average reurns over a fixed lookback period. The resuling asse price model (.) (.4) is characerized by a sochasic delay inegrodifferenial sysem, which is nonmarkovian and lacks analyical racabiliy. We show in Appendix A ha he price process of (.) (.4) almos surely has a unique coninuously adaped pahwise soluion and he asse price says posiive for given posiive iniial values over [, ]. We now consider a ypical longerm invesor who maximizes he expeced uiliy of erminal wealh a ime T(> ). Le W be he wealh of he invesor a ime and π be he fracion of he wealh invesed in he sock. Then i follows from (.) ha he change in wealh saisfies dw W = { π [φm +(1 φ)µ r]+r } d+π σ S dz. (.5) Weassume hahepreferences ofheinvesor canberepresened byacrrauiliy index wih a consan coefficien of relaive risk aversion equal o γ. The invesmen problem of he invesor is hen given by [ W 1 γ T 1 ] J(W,m,µ,,T) = sup E, (.6) (π u) u [,T] 1 γ where J(W,m,µ,,T) is he value funcion corresponding o he opimal invesmen sraegy. We apply he maximum principle for opimal conrol of sochasic delay differenial equaions and derive he opimal invesmen sraegy in closed form. The resul is presened in he following proposiion and he proof can be found in Appendix B. Proposiion.1. For an invesor wih an invesmen horizon T and consan coefficien of relaive risk aversion γ, he opimal wealh fracion invesed in he risky asse is given by π u = φm u +(1 φ)µ u r σ S σ S + (z u) 3 σ S p 3 uσ S σ, (.7) S where z u and p u are governed by a backward sochasic differenial sysem (B.6) in Appendix B.. Especially, when γ = 1, he preference is characerized by a log uiliy 7 As a resul, here is an idenificaion problem. To solve he problem, Koijen e al. (9) esimae he model using a resriced maximum likelihood mehod o ensure ha he model implied auocorrelaion fis he empirical auocorrelaion srucure of sock reurns.
10 and he opimal allocaion o socks is given by OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 9 π = φm +(1 φ)µ r σ S σ. (.8) S This proposiion saes ha he opimal fracion (.7) invesed in he sock consiss of wo componens. The firs characerizes he myopic demand for he sock and he second is he ineremporal hedging demand (see, for insance, Meron 1971). When γ = 1, he opimal sraegy (.8) characerizes he myopic behavior of he invesor wih log uiliy. This resul has a number of implicaions. Firs, when he asse price follows a geomeric Brownian moion process wih meanreversion drif µ, namely φ =, he opimal invesmen sraegy (.8) becomes π = µ r σ S σ. (.9) S This is he opimal invesmen sraegy wih meanrevering reurns obained in he lieraure, say for example Campbell and Viceira (1999) and Wacher (). In paricular, when µ = µ is a consan, he opimal porfolio (.9) collapses o he opimal porfolio of Meron (1971). Second, when he asse reurn depends only on he momenum, namely φ = 1, he opimal porfolio (.8) reduces o π = m r σ S σ. (.1) S If we consider a rading sraegy based on he rading signal indicaed by he excess reurn m r only, wih = 1 monhs, he sraegy of long/shor when he rading signal is posiive/neaive is consisen wih he TSM sraegy used in Moskowiz e al. (1). By consrucing porfolios based on monhly excess reurns over he pas 1 monhs and holding for one monh, Moskowiz e al. (1) show ha his sraegy performs he bes among all he momenum sraegies wih lookback and holding periods varying from one monh o 48 monhs. Therefore, if we only ake fixed long/shor posiions and consruc simple buyandhold momenum sraegies over a large range of lookback and holding periods, (.1) shows ha he TSM sraegy of Moskowiz e al. (1) can be opimal when mean reversion is no significan in financial markes. On he one hand, his provides a heoreical jusificaion for he TSM sraegy when marke volailiies are consan and reurns are no meanrevering. On he oher hand, noe ha he opimal porfolio (.1) also depends on volailiy. This explains he dependence of momenum profiabiliy on marke condiions and volailiy found in empirical sudies. In addiion, he opimal porfolio(.1) defines he opimal wealh fracion invesed in he risky asse. Hence he TSM sraegy of aking fixed posiions based on he rading signal may no be opimal in general.
11 1 HE, LI AND LI Third, he opimal sraegy (.8) implies ha a weighed average of momenum and meanrevering sraegies is opimal. Inuiively, i akes ino accoun he shorrun momenum and longrun reversal, boh wellsuppored marke phenomena. I also akes ino accoun he iming opporuniy wih respec o marke rend and volailiy. In summary, for he firs ime, we have provided heoreical suppor for opimal sraegies ha combining of momenum and reversal in a simple asse price model. The simple model and closedform opimal sraegy (.8) faciliae model esimaion and empirical analysis. In he res of he paper, we assume γ = 1. 8 We firs esimae he model o he S&P 5 and hen evaluae and demonsrae empirically he performance of he opimal sraegy comparing i o he marke and oher rading sraegies recorded in he lieraure. 3. Model Esimaion and Performance Analysis In his secion we firs esimae he model o he S&P 5. Based on hese esimaions, we hen use uiliy of porfolio wealh and he Sharpe raio o examine he performance of he opimal sraegy (.8), comparing i o he performance of he marke index and he opimal sraegies based on pure momenum and pure meanreversion models. To provide furher evidence, we conduc ouofsample ess on he performance of he opimal sraegy and examine he effec of shor sale consrains, marke saes, senimen and volailiy. In addiion, we also compare he performance of he opimal sraegy o ha of he TSM sraegy Model Esimaion. In line wih Campbell and Viceira (1999) and Koijen e al. (9), he meanreversion variable is affine in he (log) dividend yield, µ = µ+ν(d µ D ) = µ+νx, where ν is a consan, D is he (log) dividend yield wih E(D ) = µ D, and X = D µ D denoeshedemeaneddividendyield. Thusheassepricemodel(.)(.4) becomes ds = [ φm +(1 φ)( µ+νx ) ] d+σ S SdZ, dx = αx d+σ X dz, (3.1) where σ X = σ µ /ν. The uncerainy in sysem (3.1) is driven by wo independen Brownian moions. Wihou loss of generaliy, we follow Sangvinasos and Wacher 8 For γ 1, he opimal porfolio (.7) can be solved numerically, which leads o furher esimaion errors when esimaing he model. To reduce esimaion error and have a beer undersanding of he resuls, we ake he advanage of he closedform soluion and consider γ = 1.
12 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 11 (5) and assume he Cholesky decomposiion on he volailiy marix Σ of he dividend yield and reurn, ( ) ( ) σ S σ S(1) Σ = =. σ X(1) σ X() σ X Thus, hefirs elemen of Z is heshock o hereurn andhesecond is hedividend yield shock ha is orhogonal o he reurn shock. To be consisen wih he momenum and reversal lieraure, we discreize he coninuousime model (3.1) a a monhly frequency. This resuls in a bivariae Gaussian vecor auoregressive (VAR) model on he simple reurn 9 and dividend yield X, R +1 = φ (R +R 1 + +R +1 )+(1 φ)( µ+νx )+σ S Z +1, (3.) X +1 = (1 α)x +σ X Z +1. Noe ha boh R and X are observable. We use monhly S&P 5 daa over he period January 1871 December 1 from he home page of Rober Shiller ( shiller/daa.hm) and esimae model (3.) using he maximum likelihood mehod. We se he insananeous shor rae r = 4% annually. As in Campbell and Shiller (1988a, 1988b), he dividend yield is defined as he log of he raio beween he las period dividend and he curren index. The oal reurn index is consruced by using he price index series and he dividend series. The esimaions are conduced separaely for given ime horizon varying from one o 6 monhs. Empirically, Moskowiz e al. (1) show ha he TSM sraegy based on a 1monh horizon beer predics he nex monh s reurn han oher ime horizons. Therefore, in his secion, we focus on he performance of he opimal sraegy wih a lookback period of = 1 monhs and a onemonh holding period. The effec of ime horizon varying from one o 6 monhs is sudied in he nex secion. For comparison, we esimae he full model (FM) (3.) wih φ, he pure momenum model (MM) wih φ = 1, and he pure meanreversion model (MRM) wih φ =. For = 1, Table 3.1 repors he esimaed parameers, ogeher wih he 95% confidence bounds. For he pure momenum model (φ = 1), here is only oneparameerσ S(1) obeesimaed. Forhefullmodel, asoneofhekeyparameers, i shows ha he momenum effec parameer φ., which is significanly differen from zero. This implies ha marke index can be explained by abou % of he momenum componen and 8% of he meanrevering componen. Oher parameer 9 To be consisen wih he momenum and reversal lieraure, we use simple reurn o consruc m and also discreize he sock price process ino simple reurn raher han log reurn.
13 1 HE, LI AND LI Table 3.1. Parameer esimaions of he full model (FM), pure momenum model (MM) wih = 1, and pure meanreversion model (MRM). Parameer α φ µ ν FM (%) Bounds (%) (.3,.95) (8.7, 31.) (.6,.46) (.6, 1.) MM (%) Bounds (%) MRM (%) Bounds (%) (.7, 1.3) (.31,.43) (.46,.46) Parameers σ S(1) σ X(1) σ X() FM (%) Bounds (%) (3.95, 4.4) (4.4, 3.93) (1.9, 1.39) MM (%) 4.3 Bounds (%) (4.9, 4.38) MRM (%) Bounds (%) (3.97, 4.5) (4., 3.9) (1.3, 1.4) esimaes in erms of he level and significance in Table 3.1 are consisen wih hose in Koijen e al. (9). We also conduc a loglikelihood raio es o compare he full model o he pure momenum model (φ = 1) and pure meanreversion model (φ = ). For he pure momenum model, he es saisic (131) is much greaer han 1.59, he criical value wih six degrees of freedom a he 5% significance level. For he pure meanreversion model, he es saisic (6) is much greaer han 3.841, he criical value wih one degree of freedom a 5% significance level. Therefore he full model is significanly beer han he pure momenum model and he pure meanreversion model. This implies ha he (full) model capures shorerm momenum and longermreversion inhemarke index andfis hedaabeer hanhepuremomenum and pure meanrevering models. 3.. Economic Value. Based on he previous esimaions, we examine he economic value of he opimal porfolio in erms of he uiliy of he porfolio wealh, comparing i o hose of he marke index and of he pure momenum and pure meanreversion models. We evaluae he performance of a porfolio (or sraegy) in erms of he Sharpe raio in he nex secion. In he following performance analysis, we focus on he log uiliy preference for he invesor. 1 1 Since he model is nonmarkovian, he opimal invesmen sraegy for CRRA uiliy funcions in general involves a sysem of fullcoupled forwardbackward sochasic differenial equaions
14 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM P /1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (a) Marke index R /1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (b) Marke reurn ln W * ln W π * /1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (c) Porfolio weigh 5 1/1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (d) Uiliy Figure 3.1. The ime series of marke index (a), he simple reurn of he S&P 5 (b); and he ime series of he opimal porfolio (c) and he uiliy (d) of he opimal porfolio wealh from January 1876 unil December 1 for = 1. In (d), he uiliies of he opimal porfolio wealh and he marke index are ploed in solid red and dashdoed blue lines respecively. We firs compare he realized uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh invesed in he S&P 5 index based on he opimal sraegy (.8) wih a lookback period = 1 monhs and onemonh holding period o he uiliy of a passive holding invesmen in he S&P 5 index wih an iniial wealh of $1. As a benchmark, he log uiliy of an invesmen of $1 o he index from 11 January 1876 o December 1 is equal o For = 1, we calculae he moving average m of pas 1monh reurns (FBSDEs), which are difficul o deal wih analyically and are usually analyzed numerically. For analyical racabiliy and o avoid simulaion errors, we consider log uiliy when examining he performance of he opimal sraegy. We show ha even he opimal sraegy associaed wih log uiliy can significanly ouperform he TSM sraegy and he marke index. Bu due o he above limiaion, he effec of hedging demand is no considered here and lef for fuure research. 11 Considering he robusness analysis for varying from one o 6 monhs in he nex secion, all he porfolios sar a he end of January 1876 (6 monhs afer January 1871).
15 14 HE, LI AND LI a any poin of ime based on he marke index from January 1876 o December 1. Wih an iniial wealh of $1 a January 1876 and he esimaed parameers in Table 3.1, we calculae he monhly invesmen of he opimal porfolio wealh W based on (.8) and record he realized uiliies of he opimal porfolio wealh from January 1876 o December 1. Based on he calculaion, we plo he index level and simple reurn of he S&P 5 index from January 1876 unil December 1 in Fig. 3.1 (a) and (b). Fig. 3.1 (c) repors he opimal wealh fracions π of (.8) and Fig. 3.1 (d) repors he evoluion of he uiliies of he opimal porfolio wealh over he same ime period, showing ha he opimal porfolios ouperform he marke index measured by he uiliy of wealh * π ln W * ln W 5 1/1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (a) Porfolio weigh of PM 3 1/1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (b) Uiliy of PM * π ln W * ln W.144 1/1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (c) Porfolio weigh of MRM 1 1/1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (d) Uiliy of MRM Figure 3.. The ime series of he opimal porfolio weigh and he uiliy of he wealh for he pure momenum model wih = 1 (a) and (b) and he pure meanreversion model (c) and (d) from January 1876 unil December 1. Nex, we compare he economic value of he pure momenum and pure meanrevering sraegies o ha of he marke index. For he pure momenum model, based on he esimaed parameers in Table 3.1, Fig. 3. (a) and (b) illusraes he ime series of he porfolio weighs and he uiliies of he opimal porfolio for he pure momenum model from January 1876 o December 1. Compared o he
16 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 15 full model illusraed in Fig. 3.1, he leverage of he pure momenum sraegies is much higher, as indicaed by he higher level of π. The opimal sraegies for he pure momenum model suffer fromhigh risk and performworse han he marke and hence he opimal sraegies of he full model. Similarly, based on he esimaes in Table 3.1, Fig. 3. (c) and (d) illusraes he ime series of he porfolio weigh and he uiliy of he wealh of he opimal porfolio for he pure meanreversion model from January 1876 o December 1, showing ha he performance of he sraegy is abou he same as he sock index bu worse han he opimal sraegies (.8). Noe ha in his case here is no much variaion in he porfolio weigh and he opimal porfolio does no capure he iming opporuniy of he marke rend and marke volailiy. Therefore, boh he pure momenum and pure meanreversion sraegies underperform he marke and he opimal sraegies of he full model ln W * ln W /1945 1/1975 1/51/1 Figure 3.3. The ime series of he uiliy of opimal porfolio wealh and ha of he marke index porfolio from January 1945 unil December 1. There are wo ineresing observaions from Fig Firs, he opimal sraegies and index reurns are posiively correlaed in general. In fac, he correlaion is abou.335. Second, Fig. 3.1 (d) seems o indicae ha he improved uiliies of he opimal porfolio wealh were mainly driven by he Grea Depression in he 193s. This observaion is consisen wih Moskowiz e al. (1), who find ha he TSM sraegy delivers is highes profis during he mos exreme marke episodes. To clarify his observaion, we also examine performance using daa from January 194 o December 1 o avoid he Grea Depression periods. We reesimae he model, conduc he same analysis, and repor he erminal uiliies of he opimal porfolios in Fig. 3.3 over his ime period. I shows ha he opimal sraegies sill ouperform he marke index over his ime period. This indicaes ha he ouperformance of he opimal sraegy is no necessarily due o exreme marke episodes, such as he Grea Depression. Laer in his secion, we show ha he ouperformance is in fac immune o marke condiions.
17 16 HE, LI AND LI ln W * ln W One Side es Saisics /1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (a) Average uiliy 1/1876 1/196 1/1976 1/1 (b) Onesided saisics Figure 3.4. (a) Average uiliy and (b) onesided es saisics based on 1, simulaions for = 1. To provide furher evidence for he economic value of he opimal sraegy, we conduc a Mone Carlo analysis. For = 1 and he esimaed parameers, we simulae model (3.1) and repor he average porfolio uiliies (he solid red line in he middle) based on 1, simulaions in Fig. 3.4 (a), ogeher wih 95% confidence levels (he wo solid green lines ouside), comparing o he uiliy of he marke index (he doed blue line). I shows ha firs, he average uiliies of he opimal porfolios are beer han ha of he S&P 5. Second, he uiliy for he S&P 5 falls ino he 95% confidence bounds and hence he average performance of he opimal sraegy is no saisically differen from he marke index a he 95% confidence level. We also plo wo black dashed bounds for he 6% confidence level. I shows ha, a he 6% confidence level, he opimal porfolio significanly ouperforms he marke index. Fig. 3.4 (b) repors he onesided es saisics o es lnw > lnw SP5. The saisics are above.84 mos of he ime, which indicaes a criical value a 8% confidence level. Therefore, wih 8% confidence, he opimal porfolio significanly ouperforms he marke index. In summary, we have provided empirical evidence of he ouperformance of he opimal sraegy (.8) compared o he marke index, pure momenum and pure meanreversion sraegies The Sharpe Raio. We now use he Sharpe raio o examine he performance of he opimal sraegy. The Sharpe raio is defined as he raio of he mean excess reurn on a porfolio and he sandard deviaion of he porfolio reurn. When he Sharpe raio of an acive sraegy exceeds he marke Sharpe raio, we say ha he acive porfolio ouperforms or dominaes he marke porfolio (in an uncondiional meanvariance sense). For empirical applicaions, he (expos) Sharpe raio is usually esimaed as he raio of he sample mean of he excess reurn on he porfolio and he sample sandard deviaion of he porfolio reurn (Marquering and Verbeek 4). The average monhly reurn on he oal reurn index of he S&P 5 over
18 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 17 he period January 1871 December 1 is.4% wih an esimaed (uncondiional) sandard deviaion of 4.11%. The Sharpe raio of he marke index is.1. For he opimal sraegy (.8), he reurn of he opimal porfolio wealh a ime is given by R = (W W 1)/W 1 = π 1R +(1 π 1)r. (3.3) Table 3. repors he Sharpe raios of he passive holding marke index porfolio and he opimal porfolios from January 1886 o December 1 for = 1 ogeher wih heir 9% confidence inervals (see Jobson and Korkie 1981). I shows ha, by aking he iming opporuniy (wih respec o he marke rend and marke volailiy), he opimal porfolio ouperforms he marke. We also conduc a Mone Carlo analysis based on 1, simulaions and obain an average Sharpe raio of 6.1% for he opimal porfolio. The resul is consisen wih he ouperformance of he opimal porfolio measured by porfolio uiliy (wih an average erminal uiliy of 8.71 for he opimal porfolio). Table 3.. The Sharpe raios of he opimal porfolio and he marke index wih corresponding 9% confidence inerval and he Sharpe raio of he opimal porfolio based on Mone Carlo simulaions. Opimal porfolio Marke index Mone Carlo Sharpe raio (%) Bounds (%) (1.86, 9.84) (1.88, 6.1) (5.98, 6.7) In summary, we have used wo performance measures and provided empirical evidence of he ouperformance of he opimal sraegy(.8) compared o he marke index, pure momenum and pure meanreversion sraegies. The resuls provide empirical suppor for he analyical resul on he opimal sraegy derived in Secion. In he following secion, we conduc furher empirical ess on hese resuls. We firs conduc ouofsample ess on he predicaion power of he model and hen examine he performance of he opimal sraegy wih shorsale consrains, marke saes, senimen and volailiy OuofSample Tess. We implemen a number of ouofsample ess for he opimal sraegies by spliing he whole daa se ino wo subsample periods and using he firs sample period o esimae he model. We hen apply he esimaed parameers o he second porion of he daa o examine he ouofsample performance of he opimal sraegies. In he firs es, we spli he whole daa se ino wo equal periods: January 1871 o December 1941 and January 194 o December 1. Noice he daa in he wo periods are quie differen; he marke index increases gradually in he firs period buflucuaeswidelyinhesecondperiodasillusraedinfig. 3.1(a). Wih = 1,
19 18 HE, LI AND LI Fig. 3.5 (a) and (b) illusraes he corresponding ime series of he opimal porfolio and he uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh from January 194 o December 1, showing ha he uiliy of he opimal sraegy grows gradually and ouperforms he marke index. 4 3 * 1 π ln W * ln W 3 1/194 1/197 1/1 (a) The porfolio weigh: 1/194 1/1 1 1/194 1/197 1/1 (b) The uiliy: 1/194 1/ * π ln W * ln W 6 1/8 1/9 1/1 1/11 1/1 1/1 (c) The porfolio weigh: 1/8 1/1 1 1/8 1/9 1/1 1/11 1/1 1/1 (d) The uiliy: 1/8 1/1 Figure 3.5. The ime series of ouofsample opimal porfolio weighs and uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh (he solid lines) from January 194 unil December 1 in (a) and (b) and from January 8 o December 1 in (c) and (d) wih = 1 compared o he uiliy of he marke index (he doed line). Many sudies (see, for example, Jegadeesh and Timan 11) show ha momenum sraegies perform poorly afer he subprime crisis in 8. In he second es, we use he subprime crisis o spli he whole sample period ino wo periods and focus on he performance of he opimal sraegies afer he subprime crisis. The resuls are repored in Fig. 3.5 (c) and (d). I is clear ha he opimal sraegy sill ouperforms he marke over he subsample period, in paricular, during he financial crisis period around 9 by aking large shor posiions in he opimal porfolios. We also use daa from he las 1 years and years as he ouofsample es and find he resuls are robus.
20 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 19 As he hird es, we implemen he rolling window esimaion procedure o avoid lookahead bias. For = 1, we esimae parameers a each monh by using he pas years daa andrepor he resuls in Fig. C.1 in Appendix C. We hen repor he ime series of he index level (a), he simple reurn of he oal reurn index of S&P 5 (b), he opimal porfolio (c), and he uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh (d) in Fig. C. of Appendix C, showing a srong performance of he opimal porfolios over he marke. We also implemen he ouofsample ess for he pure momenum and pure meanreversion models(no repored here) and find ha hey canno ouperform he marke in mos ouofsample ess (las 1, and 71 years), bu do ouperform he marke for ouofsample ess over he las five years. We also repor he resuls of ouofsample ess of he pure momenum in Fig. C.4 and he pure mean reversion in Fig. C.6 based on he year rolling window esimaes in Fig. C.3 and Fig. C.5 respecively, in Appendix C. We also implemen he esimaions for differen window sizes of 5, 3 and 5 years (no repored here) and find ha he esimaed parameers are insensiive o he size of rolling window and he performance of sraegies is similar o he case of year rolling window esimaion. Overall, he ouofsample ess demonsrae he robusness of he ouperformance of he opimal rading sraegies compared o he marke index, pure momenum and pure meanreversion sraegies Shorsale Consrains and Transacion Coss. Invesors ofen face shorsale consrains. To evaluae opimal sraegies under such consrains, we consider hem when shor selling and borrowing (a he riskfree rae) are no allowed. The porfolio weigh π in his case mus lie beween zero and 1. Since he value funcion is concave wih respec o π, he opimal sraegy becomes, if π <, Π = π, if π 1, 1, if π > 1. (3.4) Table 3.3. The erminal uiliy of he porfolio wealh, Sharpe raio, mean and sand deviaion of he porfolio weighs for he opimal porfolios wih and wihou shorsale consrains, comparing wih he marke index porfolio. Uiliy Sharpe Raio Average weighs Sd of weighs Wih consrains Wihou consrains Marke index 5.76.
21 HE, LI AND LI Table 3.3 repors he erminal uiliies and he Sharpe raio of he opimal porfolio wih and wihou shorsale consrains, compared o he passive holding marke index porfolio. I shows ha, based on he wo performance measures, he opimal porfolio wih shorsale consrains ouperforms boh he marke and he opimal porfolios wihou shorsale consrains. Therefore, consrains can improve performance. This observaion is consisen wih Marquering and Verbeek (4 p. 419) who argue ha While i may seem counerinuiive ha sraegies perform beer afer resricions are imposed, i should be sressed ha he unresriced sraegies are subsanially more affeced by esimaion error. To suppor his argumen, we also examine he mean and sandard deviaion of he opimal porfolio weighs and repor he resuls in Table 3.3 wih and wihou shorsale consrains. I shows ha, wih he consrains, he mean of he opimal porfolio weighs is high while he volailiy is low. On he oher hand, wihou consrains he mean of he opimal porfolio weighs is low bu he volailiy is high, which seems in line wih Marquering and Verbeek s argumen. In addiion, we examine he effec of ransacion coss. Wih a ransacion cos of.5% or 1%, we find lile change in he erminal uiliies and he Sharpe raios Marke Saes, Senimen and Volailiy. The crosssecional momenum lieraure has shown ha momenum profiabiliy can be affeced by marke saes, invesor senimen and marke volailiy. For example, Cooper, Guierrez and Hameed (4) find ha shorrun (six monhs) momenum sraegies make profis in an up marke and lose in a down marke, bu he upmarke momenum profis reverse in he long run (13 6 monhs). Hou, Peng and Xiong (9) find momenum sraegies wih a shor ime horizon (one year) are no profiable in a down marke, bu are profiable in an up marke. Similar profiabiliy resuls are also repored in Chordia and Shivakumar (), specifically ha common macroeconomic variables relaed o he business cycle can explain posiive reurns o momenum sraegies during expansionary periods and negaive reurns during recessions. Baker and Wurgler (6, 7) find ha invesor senimen affecs crosssecional sock reurns and he aggregae sock marke. Wang and Xu (1) find ha marke volailiy has significan power o forecas momenum profiabiliy. For TSMs, however, Moskowiz e al. (1) find ha here is no significan relaionship of TSM profiabiliy o eiher marke volailiy or invesor senimen. To invesigae he performance of opimal sraegies under differen marke saes, we follow Cooper e al. (4) and Hou e al. (9) and define marke sae using he cumulaive reurn of he sock index (including dividends) over he mos recen 36 monhs. We label a monh as an up (down) marke monh if he hreeyear reurn of he marke is nonnegaive (negaive). We compue he average reurn of
22 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 1 he opimal sraegy and compare he average reurns beween up and down marke monhs. We see from Table D.1 in Appendix D ha he uncondiional average excess reurn is 87 basis poins per monh. In up monhs, he average excess reurn is 81 basis poins and i is saisically significan. In down monhs, he average excess reurn is 11 basis poins; his value is economically significan alhough i is no saisically significan. The difference beween down and up monhs is basis poins, which is no significanly differen from zero, based on a wosample es (pvalue of.87). We hen implemen he ime series analysis by regressing he excess porfolio reurns on a consan, an upmonh dummy and he excess marke reurn. We repor he resuls in Table D. in Appendix D for he opimal sraegy, he pure momenum sraegy, pure meanreversion sraegy and he TSM sraegy in Moskowiz e al. (1) for = 1 respecively. Excep for he TSM, which earns significan posiive reurns in down markes, boh consan erm α and he coefficien of he upmonh dummy κ are insignifican, indicaing ha he average reurn in down monhs and he incremenal average reurn in up monhs are boh insignifican for all oher sraegies; hese resuls are consisen wih hose in Table D.1. The resuls are robus when we replace he upmonh dummy wih he lagged marke reurn over he previous 36 monhs (no repored here). We also conrol for marke risk in up and down monhs, wih similar resuls. Simple predicive regression of excess porfolio reurns on he upmonh dummy indicaes ha he marke sae has no predicive power on porfolio reurns. The resuls are also robus for he CAPMadjused reurn. Compared wih he findings in Hou e al. (9), where crosssecional momenum reurns are higher in up monhs, we do no find significan differences beween up and down monhs for he sraegies from our model and he TSM. Among hese only he TSM shows significan reurns in down monhs. In erms of he effecs of invesor senimen on porfolio performance, we regress he excess porfolio reurn on he previous monh s senimen index consruced by Baker and Wurgler (6). We find (see Table D.6 in Appendix D) ha invesor senimen has no predicive power on porfolio reurns. We also examine he predicabiliy of marke volailiy o he porfolio reurn. The ime series analysis of regressing he excess porfolio reurn on he pas monh s volailiy or on he pas monh s volailiy condiional on up and down marke sae, suggess ha marke volailiy has no predicive power on porfolio reurns (see Tables D.7 and D.8 in Appendix D). Overall, we find ha reurns of he opimal sraegies are no significanly differen inupanddownmarke saes. Wealso findha bohinvesor senimen andmarke volailiy have no predicive power for he reurns of he opimal sraegies. In fac, he opimal sraegies have aken hese facors ino accoun and hence he reurns of
23 HE, LI AND LI he opimal sraegies have no significan relaionship wih hese facors. Therefore, he opimal sraegies are immune o marke saes, invesor senimen and marke volailiy Comparison wih TSM. We now compare he performance of he opimal sraegy o he TSM sraegy of Moskowiz e al. (1). The momenum sraegies in he empirical sudies are based on rading signals only. We firs verify he profiabiliy of he TSM sraegies and hen examine he excess reurn of buyandhold sraegies when he posiion is deermined by he sign of he opimal porfolio sraegies (.8) wih differen combinaions of ime horizons and holding periods h. For a given lookback period, we ake long/shor posiions based on he sign of he opimal porfolio (.8). Then for a given holding period h, we calculae he monhly excess reurn of he sraegy (, h). Table E.1 in Appendix E repors he average monhly excess reurn (%) of he opimal sraegies, skipping one monh beween he porfolio formaion period and holding period o avoid he onemonh reversal in sock reurns, for differen lookback periods (in he firs column) and differen holding periods (in he firs row). The average reurn is calculaed in he same way as in Moskowiz e al. (1). We calculae he excess reurns of he opimal sraegies over he period from January 1881 (1 years afer January 1871 wih five years for calculaing he rading signals and five years for holding periods) o December 1. For comparison, Table E. in Appendix E repors he average reurns (%) for he pure momenum model. 1 Noice ha Tables E.1 and E. indicae ha sraegy (9,1)performshebes. Thisisconsisen wihhefindinginmoskowizeal.(1) ha sraegy (9, 1) is he bes sraegy for equiy markes alhough he 1monh horizon is he bes for mos asse classes. Table 3.4. The Sharpe raio of he opimal porfolio, marke index, TSM and MMR for = 1 wih corresponding 9% confidence inerval. Opimal porfolio Marke index TSM MMR Sharpe raio (%) Bounds (%) (1.86, 9.84) (1.88, 6.1) (4.1, 3.96) (.18, 8.15) Nex we use he Sharpe raio o examine he performance of he opimal sraegy π of (.8) andcomparei ohepassive index sraegyandwo TSM sraegies: one follows from Moskowiz e al. (1) and he oher is he TSM sraegy based on he 1 Noice he posiion is compleely deermined by he sign of he opimal sraegies. Therefore, he posiion used in Table E. is he same as ha of he TSM sraegies in Moskowiz e al. (1).
24 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 3 sign of he opimal sraegies sign(π ) as he rading signal (insead of he average excess reurn over a pas period), which is called momenum and meanreversion (MMR) sraegy for convenience. For a ime horizon of = 1 monhs, we repor he Sharpe raios of he porfolios for he four sraegies in Table 3.4 from January 1881 o December 1. I shows ha he TSM sraegy underperforms he marke while he MMR sraegy ouperforms i. The opimal sraegy also significanly ouperforms all he momenum, meanreversion and TSM sraegies. Noe ha he only difference beween he opimal sraegy and he MMR sraegy is ha he former considers he size of he porfolio posiion, which is inversely proporional o he variance, while he laer always akes one uni of long/shor posiion. This implies ha, in addiion o rends, he size of he posiion is anoher very imporan facor for invesmen profiabiliy. Following Moskowiz e al. (1), we examine he cumulaive excess reurn. Tha is, he reurn a ime is defined by ˆR +1 = sign(π ).144 ˆσ S, R +1, (3.5) where.144 is he sample sandard deviaion of he oal reurn index and he exane annualized variance ˆσ S, for he oal reurn index is calculaed as he exponenially weighed lagged squared monh reurns, ˆσ S, = 1 (1 δ)δ i (R 1 i R ), (3.6) i= here he consan 1 scales he variance o be annual, and R is he exponenially weighed average reurn based on he weighs (1 δ)δ i. The parameer δ is chosen so ha he cener of mass of he weighs is i=1 (1 δ)δi = δ/(1 δ) = wo monhs. To avoid lookahead bias conaminaing he resuls, we use he volailiy esimaes a ime for ime +1 reurns hroughou he analysis.
25 4 HE, LI AND LI 1 8 Opimal Sraegy Passive Long TSM Sraegy Growh of $1 (log scale) Figure 3.6. Log cumulaive excess reurn of he opimal sraegy and momenum sraegy wih = 1 and passive long sraegy from January 1876 o December 1. Wih a 1monh ime horizon Fig. 3.6 illusraes he log cumulaive excess reurn of he opimal sraegy (.8), he momenum sraegy and he passive long sraegy from January 1876 o December 1. I shows ha he opimal sraegy has he highes growh rae and he passive long sraegy has he lowes growh rae. The paern of Fig. 3 in Moskowiz e al. (1 p.39) is replicaed in Fig. 3.6, showing ha he TSM sraegy ouperforms he passive long sraegy. 13 In summary, we have shown ha he opimal sraegy ouperforms he TSM sraegy of Moskowiz e al. (1). By comparing he performance of wo TSM sraegies, we find ha he TSM sraegy based on momenum and reversal rading signal is more profiable han he pure TSM sraegy of Moskowiz e al. (1) Time Horizon Effecs The resuls in he previous secion are based on a ime horizon of = 1 monhs. In his secion, we examine he effec of a ime horizon varying from one o 6 monhs on he ouperformance of he opimal sraegies. The impac of ime horizon on invesmen profiabiliy has been exensively invesigaed in he empirical lieraure, for example, De Bond and Thaler (1985) and Jegadeesh and Timan 13 In fac, he profis of he diversified ime series momenum (TSMOM) porfolio in Moskowiz e al. (1) are o some exen driven by he bonds when scaling for he volailiy in equaion (5) of heir paper, and hence applying he TSM sraegies o he sock index may have fewer significan profis han he diversified TSMOM porfolio. 14 This paper sudies he S&P 5 index over 14 years of daa, while Moskowiz e al. (1) focus on he fuures and forward conracs ha include counry equiy indexes, currencies, commodiies, and sovereign bonds. Despie a large difference beween he daa invesigaed, we find similar paerns for he TSM in he sock index and replicae heir resuls wih respec o he sock index.
26 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 5 (1993). Because of he closedform opimal sraegy (.8), we are able o explicily examine he dependence of he opimal resuls on differen ime horizons. α 1 x (a) Esimaes of α φ (b) Esimaes of φ 5 x µ ν (c) Esimaes of µ (d) Esimaes of ν σ S(1) (%) σ X(1) (%) σ X() (%) (e) Esimaes of σ S(1) (f) Esimaes of σ X(1) (g) Esimaes of σ X() Figure 4.1. The esimaes of (a) α; (b) φ; (c) µ; (d) ν; (e) σ S(1) ; (f) σ X(1) and (g) σ X() as funcions of Model Esimaions and Comparison. The esimaions are conduced separaely for given a ime horizon. Fig. 4.1 repors he esimaed parameers in monhly erms for ranging from one monh o five years, ogeher wih he 95% confidence bounds. Fig. 4.1 (b) shows ha he momenum effec parameer φ is
27 6 HE, LI AND LI significanly differen from zero when ime horizon is more han half a year, indicaing a significan momenum effec for beyond six monhs. 15 Noe ha φ increases o abou 5% when increases from six monhs o hree years and hen decreases gradually when increases furher. This implies ha marke reurns can be explained by boh he momenum (based on differen ime horizons) and meanrevering componens. Oher resuls in erms of he level and significance repored in Fig. 4.1 are consisen wih Koijen e al. (9). Obviously, he esimaions depend on he specificaion of he ime horizon. To explore he opimal value for, we compare differen informaion crieria, including Akaike (AIC), Bayesian (BIC) and Hannan Quinn (HQ) informaion crieria for from one monh o 6 monhs in Fig. F.1 of Appendix F. The resuls imply ha he average reurns over he pas 18 monhs o wo years can bes predic fuure reurns and he explanaory power for he marke reurns is reduced for longer ime horizons. This is consisen wih sudies showing ha shorerm (one o wo years), raher han longerm, momenum beer explains marke reurns. Combining he resuls in Figs 4.1 (b) and F.1, we can conclude ha marke reurns are beer capured by shorerm momenum and longerm reversion. To compare he performance of he opimal sraegies wih he pure momenum sraegiesfordifferen, weesimaehemodel wihφ = 1. Forhepuremomenum model(φ = 1),hereisonlyoneparameerσ S(1) obeesimaed. Fig. F.(a)repors heesimaes of σ S(1) andhe 95%confidence bounds for [1,6]. I shows ha as increases, he volailiy of he index decreases dramaically for small ime horizons and is hen sabilized for large ime horizons. I implies high volailiy associaed wih momenum over shor ime horizons and low volailiy over long ime horizons. We also compare he informaion crieria for differen (no repored here) and find ha all he AIC, BIC and HQ reach heir minima a = 11. This implies ha he average reurns over he previous 11 monhs can predic fuure reurns bes for he pure momenum model. This is consisen wih he finding of Moskowiz e al. (1) ha momenum reurns over he previous 1 monhs beer predic he nex monh s reurn han oher ime horizons. In addiion, we conduc he loglikelihood raio es o compare he full model o he pure momenum model (φ = 1) and o he pure meanreversion model for differen. We repor he loglikelihood raio es resuls in Fig. F. (b), which show ha he full model is significanly beer han he pure momenum model and pure meanreversion model for all. 15 For from one o five monhs, φ is indifferen from zero saisically and economically. Correspondingly, for small lookback periods of up o half a year, he model is equivalen o a pure meanreversion model. This observaion is helpful when explaining he resuls of he model for small lookback periods in he following discussion.
28 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM * 8 ln W T * ln W T * 1 ln W T (a) (b) (c) Figure 4.. The erminal uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh (a) from January 1876 o December 1, (b) from January 1945 o December 1, and (c) he average erminal uiliy of he opimal porfolios based on 1 simulaions from January 1876 o December 1, comparing wih he erminal uiliy of he marke index porfolio (he dashdoed line). 4.. The effec on performance. For = 1,,,6, based on he esimaions of he full model over he full sample, Fig. 4. (a) repors he uiliy of erminal wealh, compared o he uiliy of he marke porfolio a December 1. I shows ha he opimal sraegies consisenly ouperform he marke index for from five o monhs. 16 The corresponding uiliies are ploed in Fig. F.4. We observed from Fig. 3.1 (d) for = 1 ha he improved erminal uiliies of he opimal porfolio wealh migh be driven by he Grea Depression in he 193s. To clarify his observaion, we also examine performance using he daa from January 194 o December 1 o avoid he Grea Depression period. We reesimae he model, conduc he same analysis, and repor he erminal uiliies of he opimal porfolios in Fig. 4. (b) over his ime period. I shows ha he opimal sraegies sill ouperform he marke and he performance of he opimal sraegies over he more recen ime period becomes even beer for all ime horizons. Consisen wih he resuls obained in he previous secion, he ouperformance of he opimal sraegy is no necessarily due o exreme marke episodes, such as he Grea Depression. 16 When is less han half a year, Fig. 4. (a) shows ha he opimal sraegies do no perform significanly beer han he marke. As we indicae in foonoe 15, he model wih a small lookback period of up o half a year performs similarly o he pure meanreversion sraegy. Noe he significan ouperformance of he opimal sraegy wih a onemonh horizon in Fig. 4. (a). This is due o he fac ha he firs order auocorrelaion of he reurn of he S&P 5 is significanly posiive(ac(1) =.839) while he auocorrelaions wih higher orders are insignificanly differen from zero. This implies ha he las period reurn could well predic he nex period reurn.
29 8 HE, LI AND LI We also conduc furher Mone Carlo analysis on he performance of he opimal porfolios based on he esimaed parameers in Fig. 4.1 and 1, simulaions and repor he average erminal uiliies in Fig. 4. (c). The resul displays a differen erminal performance from ha in Fig. 4. (a). In fac, he erminal uiliy in Fig. 4. (a) is based on only one specific rajecory (he real marke index), while Fig. 4. (c) provides he average performance based on 1, rajecories. We find ha he opimal porfolios perform significanly beer han he marke index (he dashdoed consan level) for all ime horizons beyond half a year. In paricular, he average erminal uiliy reaches is peak a = 4, which is consisen wih he resul based on he informaion crieria in Fig. F.1, paricularly he AIC. Therefore, according o he uiliy of porfolio wealh, he opimal sraegies ouperform he marke index for mos of he ime horizons...15 Opimal Sraegy Passive Holding.1.1 Sharpe Raio.1.5 Sharpe Raio (a) (b) Figure 4.3. The Sharpe raio of he opimal porfolio (he solid blue line) wih corresponding 9% confidence inervals (a), he average Sharpe raio based on 1, simulaions (b) for [1,6], compared o he passive holding porfolio of marke index (he doed black line) from January 1881 o December 1. As he second performance measure, Fig. 4.3 (a) repors he Sharpe raio of he passive holding marke index porfolio from January 1881 o December 1 and he Sharpe raios of he opimal porfolios for from one monh o 6 monhs ogeher wih heir 9% confidence inervals (see Jobson and Korkie 1981). If we consider he opimal porfolio as a combinaion of he marke porfolio and a riskfree asse, hen he opimal porfolio should be locaed on he capial marke line and hence should have he same Sharpe raio as he marke. However Fig. 4.3 (a) shows ha, by aking he iming opporuniy (wih respec o he marke rend and marke volailiy), he opimal porfolios (he doed blue line) ouperform he marke (he solid black line) on average for ime horizons from six o monhs. The resuls are surprisingly consisen wih ha in Fig. 4. (a) under he uiliy measure. We also
30 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 9 conduc a Mone Carlo analysis based on 1, simulaions and repor he average Sharpe raios in Fig. 4.3 (b) for he opimal porfolios. I shows he ouperformance of he opimal porfolios over he marke index based on he Sharpe raio for he lookback periods of more han six monhs. The resuls are consisen wih ha in Fig. 4. (c) under he porfolio uiliy measure. In addiion, we show in Fig. F.3 ha he pure momenum sraegies underperform he marke in all ime horizons from one monh o 6 monhs. Therefore, we have demonsraed he consisen ouperformance of he opimal porfolios over he marke index and pure sraegies under he wo performance measures * ln W T (a) Terminal uiliy 3 1 ln W 1 6 1/8 4 1/1 (b) Series of uiliy Figure 4.4. The erminal uiliy of he wealh for he opimal porfolio, compared o he passive holding marke index porfolio (he doed line), wih ouofsample daa from January 8 o December 1 for [1,6] The effec on he ouofsample ess. For from one monh o 6 monhs, Fig. 4.4 repors he ouofsample uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh from January 8 o December 1. I clearly shows ha he opimal sraegies sill ouperform he marke index for ime horizons up o wo years. We repor addiional ouofsample ess in Appendix F.4 and rolling window esimaes in Appendix F The effec on shorsale consrains. For differen ime horizon, Fig. 4.5 (a) and (b) repor he erminal uiliies of he opimal porfolio wealh and he Sharpe raio for he opimal porfolio wih and wihou shorsales consrains, respecively, comparing wih he passive holding marke index porfolio. We also examine he mean and sandard deviaion of he opimal porfolio weighs and repor he resuls in Fig. 4.5 (c) and (d) wih and wihou shorsale consrains. The resuls for = 1 in he previous secion also hold. Tha is, wih he consrains, he opimal porfolio weighs increase in he mean while volailiy is low and sable. On he oher hand, wihou consrains, he volailiy of he opimal porfolio
31 3 HE, LI AND LI Wih Consrains Wihou Consrains Passive Holding Wih Consrains Wihou Consrains Passive Holding * 8 ln W T 6 4 Sharpe Raio (a) Terminal uiliy (b) Sharpe raio Average Weighs Wih Consrains Wihou Consrains Sandard Deviaion of Weighs Wih Consrains Wihou Consrains (c) Mean of porfolio weighs (d) Sandard deviaion of porfolio weighs Figure 4.5. The erminal uiliy of wealh (a) and he Sharpe raio (b) for he opimal porfolio, he mean (c) and he sandard deviaion of he opimal porfolio weighs, wih and wihou shorsale consrains, compared wih he marke index porfolio. weighs varies dramaically, which seems in line wih he argumen of Marquering and Verbeek (4) Comparison wih TSM wih differen ime horizons. As in he previous secion for = 1, we use he Sharpe raio o examine he performance of he opimal sraegy π in (.8) and compare wih he passive index sraegy and wo TSM sraegies for ime horizons from 1 monh o 6 monhs and one monh holding period. We repor he Sharpe raios of he porfolios for he four sraegies in Fig. 4.6 (a). 17 For comparison, we collec he Sharpe raio for he opimal porfolio and he passive holding porfolio repored in Fig. 4.3 and repor he Sharpe raios of he TSM sraegy using a solid green line and of momenum and meanreversion sraegy using a doed red line ogeher in Fig. 4.6 (a) from January 1881 o December 1. We have hree observaions. Firs, he TSM sraegy ouperforms 17 The monhly Sharpe raio for he pure meanreversion sraegy is.5, slighly higher han ha for he passive holding porfolio (.11).
32 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 31 he marke only for = 9,1 and he momenum and meanreversion sraegy ouperform he marke for shor ime horizons 13. Second, by aking he meanreversion effec ino accoun, he momenum and meanreversion sraegy performs beer han he TSM sraegy for all ime horizons. Finally, he opimal sraegy significanly ouperforms boh he momenum and meanreversion sraegy (for all ime horizons beyond four monhs) and he TSM sraegy (for all ime horizons)...15 Opimal Sraegy Passive Holding Momenum and Mean Reversion TSM Sraegy Opimal Sraegy Passive Long TSM Sraegy.1 1 Sharpe Raio (a) Average Sharpe raio (b) Terminal log cumulaive excess reurn Figure 4.6. (a) The average Sharpe raio for he opimal porfolio, he momenum and meanreversion porfolio and he TSM porfolio wih [1,6] and he passive holding porfolio from January 1881 unil December 1. (b) Terminal log cumulaive excess reurn of he opimal sraegies and TSM sraegies wih [1,6] and passive long sraegy from January 1876 o December 1. Fig. 4.6 (b) shows he erminal values of he log cumulaive excess reurns of he opimal sraegy (.8) and he TSM sraegy wih [1,6], ogeher wih he passive long sraegy, from January 1876 o December I shows ha he opimal sraegy ouperforms he TSM sraegy for all ime horizons (beyond four monhs), while he TSM sraegy ouperforms he marke for small ime horizons (from abou wo o 18 monhs). The erminal values of he log cumulaive excess reurn have similar paerns o he average Sharpe raio repored in Fig. 4.6 (a), especially for small ime horizons. 18 Noe ha he passive long sraegy inroduced in Moskowiz e al. (1) is differen from he passive holding sraegy sudied in he previous secions. Passive long means holding one share of he index each period; however, passive holding in our paper means invesing $1 in he index in he firs period and holding i unil he las period.
33 3 HE, LI AND LI 5. Conclusion To characerize he ime series momenum in financial markes, we propose a coninuousime model of asse price dynamics wih he drif as a weighed average of mean reversion and moving average componens. By applying he maximum principle for conrol problems of sochasic delay differenial equaions, we derive he opimal sraegies in closed form. By esimaing he model o he S&P 5, we show ha he opimal sraegy ouperforms he TSM sraegy and he marke index. The ouperformance holds for ouofsample ess and wih shorsale consrains. The ouperformance is immune o he marke saes, invesor senimen and marke volailiy. The resuls show ha he profiabiliy paern refleced by he average reurn of commonly used sraegies in much of he empirical lieraure may no reflec he effec of porfolio wealh. The model proposed in his paper is simple and sylized. The weighs of he momenum and meanreversion componens are consan. When marke condiions change, he weighs can be imevarying. Hence i would be ineresing o model heir dependence on marke condiions. This can be modelled, for example, as a Markov swiching process or based on some raional learning process (Xia 1). The porfolio performance is examined under log uiliy in his paper. I would be ineresing o sudy he ineremporal effec under general power uiliy funcions. We could also consider incorporaing sochasic volailiies of he reurn process ino he model. Finally, an exension of he model o a muliasse seing o sudy crosssecional opimal sraegies would be helpful o undersand crosssecional momenum and reversal.
34 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 33 Appendix A. Properies of he Soluions o he Sysem (.) (.4) Le C([,],R) be he space of all coninuous funcions ϕ : [,] R. For a given iniial condiion S = ϕ, [,] and µ = ˆµ, he following proposiion shows ha he sysem (.)(.4) admis pahwise unique soluions such ha S > almos surely for all whenever ϕ > for [,] almos surely. Proposiion A.1. The sysem (.)(.4) has an almos surely coninuously adaped pahwise unique soluion (S,µ) for a given F measurable iniial process ϕ : Ω C([,],R). Furhermore, if ϕ > for [,] almos surely, hen S > for all almos surely. Proof. Basically, he soluion can be found by using forward inducion seps of lengh as in Arriojas, Hu, Mohammed and Pap (7). Le [,]. Then he sysem (.)(.4) becomes ds = S dn, [,], dµ = α( µ µ )d+σ µ dz, [,], (A.1) S = ϕ for [,] almos surely and µ = ˆµ. where N = [ φ s s dϕ u ϕ u + (1 φ)µ s ] ds + σ S dz s is a semimaringale. Denoe by N,N = σ S σ Sds, [,], he quadraic variaion. Then sysem (A.1) has a unique soluion S = ϕ exp { N 1 N,N }, µ = µ+(ˆµ µ)exp{ α}+σ µexp{ α} exp{αu}dz u for [,]. This clearly implies ha S > for all [,] almos surely, when ϕ > for [,] almos surely. By a similar argumen, i follows ha S > for all [,]almossurely. ThereforeS > forall almossurely, byinducion. Noe ha he above argumen also gives exisence and pahwiseuniqueness of he soluion o he sysem (.)(.4). Appendix B. Proof of Proposiion.1 To solve he sochasic conrol problems, here are wo approaches: he dynamic programming mehod (HJB equaion) and he maximum principle. Since he SDDE is no Markovian, we canno use he dynamic programming mehod. Recenly, Chen and Wu (1) inroduced a maximum principle for he opimal conrol problem of
35 34 HE, LI AND LI SDDE. This mehod is furher exended by Øksendal e al. (11) o consider a onedimensional sysem allowing boh delays of moving average ype and jumps. Because he opimal conrol problem of SDDE is relaively new o he field of economics and finance, we firs briefly inroduce he maximum principle of Chen and Wu (1) and refer readers o heir paper for deails. B.1. The Maximum Principle for an Opimal Conrol Problem of SDDE. Consider a pasdependen sae X of a conrol sysem { dx = b(,x,x,v,v )d+σ(,x,x,v,v )dz, [,T], (B.1) X = ξ, v = η, [,], where Z is a ddimensional Brownian moion on (Ω,F,P,{F } ), and b : [,T] R n R n R k R k R n and σ : [,T] R n R n R k R k R n d are given funcions. In addiion, v is a F ( )measurable sochasic conrol wih values in U, where U R k is a nonempy convex se, > is a given finie ime delay, ξ C[,] is he iniial pah of X, and η, he iniial pah of v( ), is a given deerminisic coninuous funcion from [,] ino U such ha η sds < +. The problem is o find he opimal conrol u( ) A, such ha J(u( )) = sup{j(v( ));v( ) A}, (B.) where A denoes he se of all admissible conrols. The associaed performance funcion J is given by [ T ] J(v( )) = E L(,X,v,v )d+φ(x T ), where L : [,T] R n R k R k R and Φ : R n R are given funcions. Assume (H1): he funcions b, σ, L and Φ are coninuously differeniable wih respec o (X,X,v,v ) and heir derivaives are bounded. In order o derive he maximum principle, we inroduce he following adjoin equaion, dp = { (b u X ) p +(σx u ) z +E [(b u X + ) p + +(σx u + ) z + ] +L X (,X,u,u ) } d z dz, [,T], (B.3) p T = Φ X (X T ), p =, (T,T +], z =, [T,T +]. We refer readers o Theorems.1 and. in Chen and Wu (1) for he exisence and uniqueness of he soluions of he sysems (B.3) and (B.1) respecively.
36 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 35 Nex, define a Hamilonian funcion H from [,T] R n R n R k R k L F (,T+ ;R n ) L F (,T +;Rn d ) o R as follows, H(,X,X,v,v,p,z ) = b(,x,x,v,v ),p + σ(,x,x,v,v ),z +L(,X,v,v ). Assume (H): he funcions H(,,,,,p,z ) and Φ( ) are concave wih respec o he corresponding variables respecively for [,T] and given p and z. Then we have he following proposiion on he maximum principle of he sochasic conrol sysem wih delay by summarizing Theorem 3.1, Remark 3.4 and Theorem 3. in Chen and Wu (1). Proposiion B.1. (i) Le u( ) be an opimal conrol of he opimal sochasic conrol problem wih delay subjec o (B.1) and (B.), and X( ) be he corresponding opimal rajecory. Then we have max v U Hu v +E [H u v + ],v = H u v +E [H u v + ],u, a.e., a.s.; (B.4) (ii) Suppose u( ) A and le X( ) be he corresponding rajecory, p and z be he soluion of he adjoin equaion (B.3). If (H1), (H) and (B.4) hold for u( ), hen u( ) is an opimal conrol for he sochasic delayed opimal problem (B.1) and (B.). B.. Proof of Proposiion.1. We now apply Proposiion B.1 o our sochasic conrol problem. Le P u := lns u and V u := lnw u. Then he sochasic delayed opimal problem in Secion becomes o maximize E u [Φ(X T )] := E u [lnw T ] = E u [V T ], subjec o { dxu = b(u,x u,x u,π u )du+σ(u,x u,π u )dz u, u [,T], X u = ξ u, v u = η u, u [,], (B.5) where X u = P u µ u, σ = σ S σ µ, b = V u π u σ S φ (P u P u )+(1 φ)µ u (1 φ) σ S σ S α( µ µ u ) [ ]. φ +π u (P u P u )+ σ S σ S φ+(1 φ)µ u r +r π u σ S σ S
37 36 HE, LI AND LI Then we have he following adjoin equaion dp u = { (b π X ) p u +(σx π ) z u +E u [(b π X u+ ) p u+ +(σx π u+ ) z u+ ] } +L X du zu dz u, u [,T], where p T = Φ X (X T ), p u =, u (T,T +], z u =, p u = (p i u ) 3 1, (b π X u+ ) = φ u [T,T +], φ π u+ z u = (z ij u ) 3, (σ π X ) = (σ π X u+ ) = 3 3. (b π X ) =, Φ X (X T ) = φ φ π u (B.6), 1 φ α (1 φ)πu, L X =, e (1 γ)v T The Hamilonian funcion H is given by [ φ H = (P u P u )+(1 φ)µ u (1 φ) σ S σ ] S p 1 u +α( µ µ u)p u { + π u σ S σ S [φ +π u (P u P u )+ σ S σ S φ+(1 φ)µ u r ] } +r ( ) ( ) ( ) +σ S zu 11 +σ zu 1 zu 1 µ +π zu σ S zu 31, zu 3 so ha H π π = π u σ S σ S + φ (P u P u )+ σ S σ S φ+(1 φ)µ u r +σ S I can be verified ha E u [H π π u+ ] =. Therefore, Hπ π +E u[hπ π u+ ],π { [ =π u πu σ S σ S + φ (P u P u )+ σ S σ ] S φ+(1 φ)µ u r p 3 u +σ S Taking he derivaive wih respec o π u and leing i equal zero yields π u = φ (P u P u )+ σ S σ S φ+(1 φ)µ u r σ S σ S = φm u +(1 φ)µ u r σ S σ S + σ S(1)z 31 u +σ S()zu 3 p 3 uσ S σ S ( ( + σ S(1)zu 31 +σ S()zu 3 p 3 u σ S σ S, z 31 u z 3 u p 3 u z 31 u z 3 u ). ) }. (B.7) where z u and p u are governed by he backward sochasic differenial sysem (B.6). This gives he opimal invesmen sraegy.
38 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 37 Especially, if γ = 1, he uiliy reduces o a log one and Φ X (X T ) =. 1 Since he parameers and erminal values for dp 3 u are deerminisic in his case, we can asser ha zu 31 = z3 u = for u [,T], which leads o p3 u = 1 for u [,T]. Then he Hamilonian funcion H is given by [ φ H = (P u P u )+(1 φ)µ u (1 φ) σ S σ ] S p 1 u +α( µ µ u )p u { + π u σ S σ S [φ +π u (P u P u )+ σ S σ S φ+(1 φ)µ u r ] } +r p 3 u ( ) ( ) +σ S zu 11 +σ zu 1 zu 1 µ, zu and he opimal sraegy is given by which is myopic. πu = φm u +(1 φ)µ u r σ S σ, S Appendix C. Addiional ouofsample ess and Rolling Window Esimaions In his appendix, we provide some robusness analysis o ouofsample ess and rolling window esimaions. C.1. Rolling Window Esimaions. For fix = 1, we esimae parameers of (3.) a each monh by using he pas years daa o avoid lookahead bias. Fig. C.1 illusraes he esimaed parameers. The big jump in esimaed σ S(1) during is consisen wih he high volailiy of marke reurn illusraed in Fig. C. (b). Fig. C.1 also illusraes he ineresing phenomenon: ha he esimaed φ is very close o zero for hree periods of ime, implying insignifican momenum bu significan meanreversion effec. By comparing Fig. C.1 (b) and (e), we observe ha he insignifican φ is accompanied by high volailiy σ S(1). Fig. C. illusraes he ime series of (a) he index level and (b) he simple reurn of he oal reurn index of S&P 5; (c) he opimal porfolio and (d) he uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh from December 189 o December 1 for = 1 wih year rolling window esimaed parameers. The index reurn and π are posiively correlaed wih correlaion.6. In addiion, we find ha he profis are higher afer he 193s.
39 38 HE, LI AND LI α φ..1. 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (a) Esimaes of α.1 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (b) Esimaes of φ x µ ν /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (c) Esimaes of µ.5.1 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (d) Esimaes of ν σ S(1) (%) 4 3 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/ σ X(1) (%) /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/ σ X() (%) /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (e) Esimaes of σ S(1) (f) Esimaes of σ X(1) (g) Esimaes of σ X() Figure C.1. The esimaes of (a) α; (b) φ; (c) µ; (d) ν; (e) σ S(1) ; (f) σ X(1) and (g) σ X() for = 1 based on daa from he pas years. Fig. C.3 illusraes he esimaes of σ S(1) for he pure momenum model (φ = 1) based on daa from he pas years; he big jump in volailiy is due o he Grea Depression in he 193s. Fig. C.4 illusraes he ime series of (a) he opimal porfolio and (b) he uiliy of wealh from December 189 unil December 1 for = 1 for he pure momenum model wih he year rolling window esimaed σ S(1). By comparing Fig. C.3 and Fig. C.4 (b), he opimal sraegy implied by he pure momenum model suffers huge losses during he high marke volailiy period.
40 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM P /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (a) R /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (b) * π ln W * ln W /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (c) 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (d) Figure C.. The ime series of (a) he index level and (b) he simple reurn of he oal reurn index of S&P 5; (c) he opimal porfolio and(d) he uiliy of wealh from December 189 unil December 1 for = 1 wih year rolling window esimaed parameers σ S(1) (%) /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 Figure C.3. Esimaes of σ S(1) for he pure momenum model (φ = 1) based on daa from he pas years. However, Fig C. illusraes ha he opimal sraegy implied by he full model makes big profis during he big marke volailiy period. Fig. C.5 illusraes he esimaed parameers for he pure meanreversion model based on daa from he pas years.
41 4 HE, LI AND LI 15 1 * π ln W * ln W /1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (a) 1 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (b) Figure C.4. The ime series of (a) he opimal porfolio and (b) he uiliy of wealh from December 189 unil December 1 for = 1 for he pure momenum model wih year rolling window esimaed parameers α µ 16 x ν (a) Esimaes of α (b) Esimaes of µ (c) Esimaes of ν σ S(1) (%) σ X(1) (%) σ X() (%) (d) Esimaes of σ S(1) (e) Esimaes of σ X(1) (f) Esimaes of σ X() Figure C.5. The esimaes of (a) α; (b) φ; (c) µ; (d) ν; (e) σ S(1) ; (f) σ X(1) and (g) σ X() for he pure meanreversion model based on daa from he pas years. Fig. C.6 illusraes he ime series of he opimal porfolio and he uiliy of wealh from December 189 unil December 1 for he pure meanreversion model wih
42 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM * π ln W * ln W 6 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (a) 4 1/1891 1/1941 1/1991 1/1 (b) Figure C.6. The ime series of (a) he opimal porfolio and (b) he uiliy of wealh from December 189 unil December 1 for he pure meanreversion model wih year rolling window esimaed parameers. year rolling window esimaed parameers. Afer eliminaing he lookahead bias, he pure meanreversion sraegy canno ouperform he sock index any longer. Appendix D. Regressions on he Marke Saes, Senimen and Volailiy D.1. Marke Saes. Firs, we follow Cooper e al. (4) and Hou e al. (9) and define marke sae using he cumulaive reurn of he sock index (including dividends) over he mos recen 36 monhs. 19 We label a monh as an up (down) marke monh if he marke s hreeyear reurn is nonnegaive (negaive). There are 1,165 up monhs and 478 down monhs from February 1876 o December 1. Table D.1. The average excess reurn of he opimal sraegy for = 1. Observaions (N) Average excess reurn Uncondiional reurn 1, (.37) Up marke 1, (4.9) Down marke (.87) 19 The resuls are similar if we use he alernaive 6, 1 or 4 monh marke sae definiions, even hough hey are more sensiive o sudden changes in marke senimen. We exclude January 1876 in which here is no reurn o he opimal sraegies.
43 4 HE, LI AND LI We compue he average reurn of he opimal sraegy and compare he average reurns beween up and down marke monhs. Table D.1 presens he average uncondiional excess reurns and he average excess reurns for up and down marke monhs. The uncondiional average excess reurn is 87 basis poins per monh. In up marke monhs, he average excess reurn is 81 basis poins and i is saisically significan. In down marke monhs, he average excess reurn is 11 basis poins; his value is economically bu no saisically significan. The difference beween down and up monhs is basis poins, which is no significanly differen from zero based on a wosample es (pvalue of.87). 1 We use he following regression model o es for he difference in reurns: R r = α+κi (UP)+β(R r)+ǫ, (E.1) where R = (W W 1)/W 1 in(3.3) is hemonh reurnof he opimal sraegy, R r is he excess reurn of he sock index, and I (UP) is a dummy variable ha akes he value of 1 if monh is in an up monh, and zero oherwise. The regression inercep α measures he average reurn of he opimal sraegy in down marke monhs, and he coefficien κ capures he incremenal average reurn in up marke monhs relaive o down monhs. We also replace he marke sae dummy in (E.1) wih he lagged marke reurn over he previous 36 monhs (no repored here), and he resuls are robus. Table D.. The coefficiens for he regression (E.1). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM α (1.46) (1.34) (.1) (3.3) κ (.6) (.1) (.3) (.63) β (1.48) (14.6) (.97) (6.39) Table D. repors he regression coefficiens for he full model, he pure momenum model, pure meanreversion model and he TSM sraegy in Moskowiz e al. (1) for = 1 respecively. Excep for he TSM, which earns significan posiive reurns in down marke, boh α and κ are insignifican for all oher sraegies; he resuls are consisen wih hose in Table D.1. 1 The pvalues for he pure momenum sraegy, pure meanreversion sraegy and TSM are.87,.87 and.67 respecively.
44 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 43 Table D.3. The coefficiens for he regression (E.). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM α (1.44) (1.3) (.18) (3.9) κ (.11) (.9) (.14) (.81) β (1.9) (1.7) (3.84) (4.3) β (.16) (5.31) (34.88) (14.63) To furher conrol for marke risk in up and down marke monhs, we now run he following regression: R r = α+κi (UP)+β 1 (R r)i (UP)+β (R r)i (DOWN)+ǫ. (E.) The regression coefficiens are repored in Table D.3. These resuls are similar o hose in Table D.. Table D.4. The coefficiens for he regression (E.3). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM α (1.) (1.8) (.14) (3.3) κ (.7) (.8) (.14) (.53) We also run he following regression: R r = α+κi 1 (UP)+ǫ, (E.3) and Table D.4 repors he coefficiens. We find ha he dummy variable of up marke monh has no predicive power for reurns of all sraegies. Table D.5. The coefficiens for he regression (E.4). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM α (1.46) (1.34) (.1) (3.3) κ (.6) (.1) (.3) (.63)
45 44 HE, LI AND LI We also sudy he beaadjused reurns: R r = αcapm +β CAPM (R r)+ε, R r β CAPM (R r) = α+κi (UP)+ǫ, (E.4) and Table D.5 repors he coefficiens. Again, he difference of reurns beween up and down monhs is no significan for all he sraegies. Compared wih findings in Hou e al. (9), where crosssecional momenum reurnsarehigherinupmonhs, wedonofindsignificandifferencesbeweenupand down monhs for he sraegies from our model and he TSM. Among he sraegies from our model and he TSM, only he TSM has significan reurns in down marke monhs. Table D.6. The coefficiens for he regression (E.5). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM a (1.77) (1.74) (1.49) (.57) b (1.) (.87) (1.1) (1.48) D.. Invesor Senimen. In his subsecion, we examine he relaionship beween he excess reurn of he opimal sraegies and invesor senimen by running he following regression: R r = a+bt 1 +ǫ, (E.5) where T is he senimen index measure used by Baker and Wurgler (6). The daa on he BakerWurger senimen index from 7/1965 o 1/1 is obained from he Jeffrey Wurglers websie (hp://people.sern.nyu.edu/jwurgler/). Table D.6 repors he coefficiens. The resuls sugges ha senimen index has no predicive power for reurns of opimal sraegies and of he TSM. We also examine monhly changes of he level of senimen by replacing T wih is monhly changes and heir orhogonalized indexes. The resuls are similar. Table D.7. The coefficiens for he regression (E.6). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM α (1.6) (1.11) (1.) (.78) κ (.5) (.5) (1.1) (1.48)
46 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 45 D.3. Marke Volailiy. Finally, we examine he predicabiliy of marke volailiy for profiabiliy. Firs, we run he following regression: R r = α+κˆσ S, 1 +ǫ, (E.6) where he exane annualized volailiy ˆσ S, is given by (3.6). Table D.7 repors he resuls. We see ha volailiy has no predicive power for reurns of opimal sraegies and of he TSM. Table D.8. The coefficiens for he regression (E.7). Full model Pure momenum Pure mean reversion TSM α (.7) (.36) (.8) (1.19) κ (1.34) (1.33) (.8) (.7) κ (1.8) (1.75) (.84) (.53) Second, we run he regression by following Wang and Xu (1): R r = α+κ 1ˆσ + S, 1 +κ ˆσ S, 1 +ǫ, (E.7) where ˆσ + S, (ˆσ S, ) is equal o ˆσ S, if he marke sae is up (down) and oherwise equal o zero. Table D.8 repors he coefficiens. The resuls are similar o hose in Table D.7 even if we disinguish volailiy in up and down marke monhs. Appendix E. Comparison wih Moskowiz, Ooi and Pedersen (1)
47 46 HE, LI AND LI Table E.1. The average excess reurn (%) of he opimal sraegies for differen lookback period (differen row) and differen holding period h (differen column). ( \ h) (1.8) (1.84) (3.9) (.83) (1.84) (.4) (.63) (.9) (.66) (.93) (.93) (.93) (.93) (.93) (.93) (.93) (.93) (.93) (1.93) (.8) (.6) (1.75) (.88) (.58) (.3) (.53) (.) (3.7) (3.1) (.8) (1.45) (.41) (1.16) (.17) (.) (1.11) (1.85) (1.4) (.8) (.4) (.76) (1.3) (.41) (.3) (1.46) (.3) (.51) (.79) (.6) (.61) (.34) (.4) (.3) (.15) (.35) (.59) (.5) (.43) (.44) (.81) (.49) (.4) (.64) (1.74) (1.3) (1.6) (.93) (.43) (.1) (.4) (.7) (.86) (.5) (.6) (.81) (1.) (1.41) (.49) (.55) (.69) (.9) Appendix F. The Effecs of Time Horizons F.1. Informaion Crieria. We presen differen informaion crieria, including Akaike (AIC), Bayesian (BIC) and Hannan Quinn (HQ) informaion crieria for from one monh o 6 monhs in Fig. F.1. We see ha he AIC, BIC and HQ reach heir minima a = 3,19 and respecively. Also, we observe a common increasing paern of he crieria level for longer.
48 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 47 Table E.. The average excess reurn (%) of he opimal sraegies for differen lookback period (differen row) and differen holding period h (differen column) for he pure momenum model. ( \ h) (.14) (.89) (1.34) (1.5) (1.37) (.1) (.) (.4) (.57) (1.61) (.16) (1.91) (.) (1.17) (.69) (.7) (.45) (1.38) (.78) (.79) (3.1) (.9) (1.34) (.75) (.6) (.4) (.77) (3.91) (3.78) (.6) (1.76) (.66) (1.5) (.38) (.1) (1.1) (.35) (1.67) (.94) (.13) (.86) (1.63) (1.) (.95) (1.88) (.9) (.4) (.81) (1.3) (1.6) (.88) (.13) (.4) (.39) (.1) (.19) (.3) (.) (.1) (.4) (.18) (.37) (.33) (.74) (.73) (.4) (.) (.4) (.83) (.1) (.61) (.55) (.54) (.84) (1.41) (1.77) (.15) (1.36) (.6) (.) (.34) AIC BIC HQ (a) AIC (b) BIC (c) HQ Figure F.1. (a) Akaike informaion crieria, (b) Bayesian informaion crieria, and (c) Hannan Quinn informaion crieria for [1,6]. F.. The Esimaion and Loglikelihood Raio Tes for he Pure Momenum Sraegy. We presen he esimaion of parameer σ S(1) for he pure momenum model in Fig. F.(a) for [1,6]. We also presen he resuls of he
49 48 HE, LI AND LI loglikelihood raio es o compare he full model o he esimaed pure momenum model (φ = 1) and pure meanreversion model wih respec o differen in Fig. F. (b), where he solid red line shows he es saisic when compared o he pure momenum model. The saisic is much greaer han 1.59, he criical value wih six degrees of freedom a he 5% significance level. The dashdoed blue line illusraes he es saisic when comparing o he pure meanreversion model. The es saisic is much greaer han 3.841, he criical value wih one degree of freedom a 5% significance level σ S(1) (%) Likelihood raio es Pure Momenum Pure Mean Reversion (a) The esimaes of σ S(1) (b) The loglikelihood raio es Figure F.. The esimaes of σ S(1) for he pure momenum model (a) and he loglikelihood raio es (b) for [1,6]. F.3. The Performance for Differen Time Horizons. To compare wih he performance of he pure momenum sraegies o he marke index, based on esimaed parameers in Fig. F., we repor he erminal uiliies of he porfolios of he pure momenum model a December 1 in Fig. F * ln W T Figure F.3. The uiliy of erminal wealh of he pure momenum model for [1,6]. For = 1,,,6, Fig. F.4 illusraes he evoluion of he uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh (he dark and more volaile surface) and of he passive holding
50 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM 49 index porfolio (he yellow and smooh surface) from January 1876 unil December 1. I indicaes ha he opimal sraegies ouperform he marke index for from five monhs o monhs consisenly. Figure F.4. The uiliy of he opimal porfolio wealh from January 1876 unil December 1 comparing wih he passive holding porfolio for [1,6]. F.4. The Ouofsample Tes for Differen Time Horizons. To see he effec of he ime horizon on he resuls of ouofsample ess, we spli he whole daa se ino wo equal periods: January 1871 December 1941 and January 194 December 1. For given, we esimae he model for he firs subsample period and do he ouofsample es over he second subsample period. We repor he uiliy of erminal wealh for [1,6] using sample daa of he las 71 years in Fig. F.5. Clearly he opimal sraegies sill ouperform he marke for [1, 14] * 4 ln W T Figure F.5. The uiliy of erminal wealh for [1,6] based on he ouofsample period January 194 o December 1. F.5. Rolling Window Esimaes for Differen Time Horizons. We also implemen rolling window esimaions for differen ime horizons. Fig. F.6 illusraes he correlaions of he esimaed σ S(1) wih (a) he esimaed φ and he reurn of he opimal sraegies for (b) he full model, (c) he pure momenum model and (d)
51 5 HE, LI AND LI Correlaions Correlaions (a) (b) Correlaions (c) Correlaions (d) Figure F.6. The correlaions of he esimaed σ S(1) wih (a) he esimaed φ and he reurn of he opimal sraegies for (b) he full model, (c) he pure momenum model and (d) he TSM reurn. he TSM reurn for [1, 6]. Ineresingly, higher volailiy is accompanied by a less significan momenum effec wih small ime horizons ( 13). Bu φ and σ S(1) are posiive correlaed when he ime horizon becomes large. One possible reason is ha a long ime horizon makes he rading signal less sensiive o changes in price and hence he rading signal is significan only when he marke price changes dramaically in a high volailiy period. Fig. F.6 (c) and (d) show ha he profiabiliy of he opimal sraegies for he pure momenum model and he TSM sraegies are sensiive o he esimaed marke volailiy. The reurn is posiively (negaively) relaed o marke volailiy for shor (long) ime horizons. Bu Fig. F.6 (b) shows ha he opimal sraegies for he full model perform well even in a highly volaile marke.
52 OPTIMAL TIME SERIES MOMENTUM Figure F.7. The fracion of φ significanly differen from zero for [1,6]. We also sudy oher ime horizons. We find ha he esimaes of σ S(1), σ X(1) and σ X() are insensiive o bu he esimaes of φ are sensiive o. Fig. F.7 illusraes he corresponding fracion of φ, which is significanly differen from zero for [1,6]. I shows ha he momenums wih 3 monh horizons occur mos frequenly during he period from December 189 unil December * ln W T Figure F.8. The uiliy of wealh from December 189 o December 1 for he opimal porfolio wih [1,6] and he passive holding porfolio wih year rolling window esimaed parameers. Fig. F.8 (a) illusraes he uiliy of wealh from December 189 unil December 1 for he opimal porfolio wih [1,6] and he passive holding porfolio. Especially, he uiliy of erminal wealh illusraed in Fig. F.8 (b) shows ha he opimal sraegies work well for shor horizons and he erminal uiliy reaches is peak a = 1.
Morningstar Investor Return
Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper March 3, 2009 2009 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion by
More informationStock Return Expectations in the Credit Market
Sock Reurn Expecaions in he Credi Marke Hans Bysröm * Sepember 016 In his paper we compue longerm sock reurn expecaions (across he business cycle) for individual firms using informaion backed ou from
More informationOverreaction and Underreaction :  Evidence for the Portuguese Stock Market 
Overreacion and Underreacion :  Evidence for he Poruguese Sock Marke  João Vasco Soares* and Ana Paula Serra** March 2005 * Faculdade de Economia da Universidade do Poro ** (corresponding auhor) CEMPRE,
More informationBetting Against Beta
Being Agains Bea Andrea Frazzini and Lasse H. Pedersen * This draf: Ocober 5, 2010 Absrac. We presen a model in which some invesors are prohibied from using leverage and oher invesors leverage is limied
More informationMarket timing and statistical arbitrage: Which market timing opportunities arise from equity price busts coinciding with recessions?
Journal of Applied Finance & Banking, vol.1, no.1, 2011, 5381 ISSN: 17926580 (prin version), 17926599 (online) Inernaional Scienific Press, 2011 Marke iming and saisical arbirage: Which marke iming
More informationCentre for Investment Research Discussion Paper Series. Momentum Profits and TimeVarying Unsystematic Risk
Cenre for Invesmen Research Discussion Paper Series Discussion Paper # 080* Momenum Profis and TimeVarying Unsysemaic Risk Cenre for Invesmen Research O'Rahilly Building, Room 3.0 Universiy College Cork
More informationDYNAMIC portfolio optimization is one of the important
, July 24, 2014, London, U.K. A Simulaionbased Porfolio Opimizaion Approach wih Leas Squares Learning Chenming Bao, Geoffrey Lee, and Zili Zhu Absrac This paper inroduces a simulaionbased numerical
More informationEconomics 487. Homework #4 Solution Key Portfolio Calculations and the Markowitz Algorithm
Economics 87 Homework # Soluion Key Porfolio Calculaions and he Markowiz Algorihm A. Excel Exercises: (10 poins) 1. Download he Excel file hw.xls from he class websie. This file conains monhly closing
More informationPerformance Attribution for Equity Portfolios
PERFORMACE ATTRIBUTIO FOR EQUITY PORTFOLIOS Performance Aribuion for Equiy Porfolios Yang Lu and David Kane Inroducion Many porfolio managers measure performance wih reference o a benchmark. The difference
More informationRolling ADF Tests: Detecting Rational Bubbles in Greater China Stock Markets
Singapore Managemen Universiy Insiuional Knowledge a Singapore Managemen Universiy Disseraions and Theses Collecion (Open Access) Disseraions and Theses 2008 Rolling ADF Tess: Deecing Raional Bubbles in
More informationKEY CONCEPTS AND PROCESS SKILLS. 1. An allele is one of the two or more forms of a gene present in a population. MATERIALS AND ADVANCE PREPARATION
Gene Squares 61 40 o 2 3 50minue sessions ACIVIY OVERVIEW P R O B L E M S O LV I N G SUMMARY Sudens use Punne squares o predic he approximae frequencies of rais among he offspring of specific crier crosses.
More informationAn Alternative Mathematical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluation in Clean Water
An Alernaive Mahemaical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluaion in Clean Waer Yanjun (John) He 1, PE, BCEE 1 Kruger Inc., 41 Weson Parkway, Cary, NC 27513 Email: john.he@veolia.com ABSTRACT Energy consumpion
More informationWhat the Puck? an exploration of TwoDimensional collisions
Wha he Puck? an exploraion of TwoDimensional collisions 1) Have you ever played 8Ball pool and los he game because you scrached while aemping o sink he 8Ball in a corner pocke? Skech he sho below: Each
More informationGuidance Statement on Calculation Methodology
Guidance Saemen on Calculaion Mehodology Adopion Dae: 28 Sepember 200 Effecive Dae: January 20 Reroacive Applicaion: No Required www.gipssandards.org 200 CFA Insiue Guidance Saemen on Calculaion Mehodology
More informationDynamics of market correlations: Taxonomy and portfolio analysis
Dynamics of marke correlaions: Taxonomy and porfolio analysis J.P. Onnela, A. Chakrabori, and K. Kaski Laboraory of Compuaional Engineering, Helsinki Universiy of Technology, P.O. Box 9203, FIN02015
More informationThe safe ships trajectory in a restricted area
Scienific Journals Mariime Universiy of Szczecin Zeszyy Naukowe Akademia Morska w Szczecinie 214, 39(111) pp. 122 127 214, 39(111) s. 122 127 ISSN 1733867 The safe ships rajecory in a resriced area Zbigniew
More informationFIVE RISK FACTORS MODEL: PRICING SECTORAL PORTFOLIOS IN THE BRAZILIAN STOCK MARKET
Revisa Caarinense da Ciência Conábil, ISSN 18083781  eissn 22377662, Florianópolis, SC, Brazil, v. 16, n. 48, p. 8198, May/Aug. 2017 doi: 10.16930/22377662/rccc.v16n48.2376 Available a hp://revisa.crcsc.org.br
More informationReexamining SportsSentiment Hypothesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Istanbul
Reexamining SporsSenimen Hypohesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Isanbul Ka Wai Terence Fung +, Ender Demir, Chi Keung Marco Lau And Kwok Ho Chan * Absrac This paper examines he impac of inernaional
More informationMeasuring Potential Output and Output Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya
Universiy of Connecicu DigialCommons@UConn Economics Working Papers Deparmen of Economics Ocober 2005 Measuring Poenial Oupu and Oupu Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya Angelica E. Njuguna
More informationMachine Learning for Stock Selection
Machine Learning for Sock Selecion Rober J. Yan Compuer Science Dep., The Uniersiy of Wesern Onario jyan@csd.uwo.ca Charles X. Ling Compuer Science Dep., The Uniersiy of Wesern Onario cling@csd.uwo.ca
More informationINSTRUCTIONS FOR USE. This file can only be used to produce a handout master:
INSTRUCTIONS OR USE This file can only be used o produce a handou maser: Use Prin from he ile menu o make a prinou of he es. You may no modify he conens of his file. IMPORTNT NOTICE: You may prin his es
More informationMethods for Estimating Term Structure of Interest Rates
Mehods for Esimaing Term Srucure of Ineres Raes Iskander Karibzhanov Absrac This paper compares differen inerpolaion algorihms for consrucing yield curves: cubic splines, linear and quadraic programming,
More informationKINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION
chaper KINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION Secion 2.1 Displacemen Secion 2.2 Speed and Velociy 1. A paricle ravels along a curved pah beween wo poins P and Q as shown. The displacemen of he paricle does no depend
More informationRealtime Stochastic Evacuation Models for Decision Support in Actual Emergencies
Realime Sochasic Evacuaion Models for Decision Suppor in Acual Emergencies ARTURO CUESTA, DANIEL ALVEAR, ORLANDO ABREU and DELFÍN SILIÓ Transpors and echnology projecs and processes Universiy of Canabria
More informationWHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY
Proceedings of he 2010 Join Rail Conference JRC2010 April 2729, 2010, Urbana, Illinois, USA JRC201036236 WHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY Zhenhua Chen The
More informationTime & Distance SAKSHI If an object travels the same distance (D) with two different speeds S 1 taking different times t 1
www.sakshieducaion.com Time & isance The raio beween disance () ravelled by an objec and he ime () aken by ha o ravel he disance is called he speed (S) of he objec. S = = S = Generally if he disance ()
More informationSIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE
1 h Inernaional Conference on Sabiliy of Ships and Ocean Vehicles 591 SIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE Qiuxin Gao, Universiy of Srahclyde, UK, Gao.q.x@srah.ac.uk Dracos Vassalos,
More informationEXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELYSPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES
EXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELYSPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES Seven J. Landry and Amy R. Priche Georgia Insiue of Technology Alana GA 303320205 ABSTRACT Paired closelyspaced parallel approaches
More informationName Class Date. Step 2: Rearrange the acceleration equation to solve for final speed. a v final v initial v. final v initial v.
Skills Workshee Mah Skills Acceleraion Afer you sudy each sample problem and soluion, work ou he pracice problems on a separae shee of paper. Wrie your answers in he spaces provided. In 1970, Don Big Daddy
More informationScienceDirect. Cycling Power Optimization System Using Link Models of Lower Limbs with CleatShaped Biaxial Load Cells
Available online a www.sciencedirec.com ScienceDirec Procedia Engineering 72 ( 20 ) 8 7 The 20 conference of he Inernaional Spors Engineering Associaion Cycling Power Opimizaion Sysem Using ink Models
More informationUrban public transport optimization by bus ways: a neural networkbased methodology
Urban Transpor XIII: Urban Transpor and he Environmen in he 21s Cenury 347 Urban public ranspor opimizaion by bus ways: a neural neworkbased mehodology M. Migliore & M. Caalano Deparmen of Transporaion
More informationWhat is a Practical (ASTM C 618) SAIStrength Activity Index for Fly Ashes that can be used to Proportion Concretes Containing Fly Ash?
2017 World of Coal Ash (WOCA) Conference in Lexingon, KY  May 911, 2017 hp://www.flyash.info/ Wha is a Pracical (ASTM C 618) SAISrengh Aciviy Index for Fly Ashes ha can be used o Proporion Concrees
More informationTHE PERSISTENCY OF INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION BENEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL
ASIA ACADEMY of MAAGEMET JOURAL of ACCOUTIG and FIACE AAMJAF, Vol. 10, o. 1, 151 165, 014 THE PERSISTECY OF ITERATIOAL DIVERSIFICATIO BEEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL Ung Sze ie 1*,
More informationProceedings of the ASME 28th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering OMAE2009 May 31  June 5, 2009, Honolulu, Hawaii
Proceedings of he ASME 28h Inernaional Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arcic Engineering OMAE29 May 31  June 5, 29, Honolulu, Hawaii OMAE2979385 ANALYSIS OF THE TUNNEL IMMERSION FOR THE BUSANGEOJE
More informationA Statistical, AgeStructured, LifeHistoryBased Stock Assessment Model for Anadromous Alosa
American Fisheries Sociey Symposium 35:275 283, 2003 2003 by he American Fisheries Sociey A Saisical, AgeSrucured, LifeHisoryBased Sock Assessmen Model for Anadromous Alosa A. JAMIE F. GIBSON 1 Acadia
More informationInstruction Manual. Rugged PCB type. 1 Terminal Block. 2 Function. 3 Series Operation and Parallel Operation. 4 Assembling and Installation Method
Rugged PCB ype Insrucion Manual 1 Terminal Block Funcion.1...4.5.6.7 Inpu volage range Inrush curren limiing Overcurren proecion Overvolage proecion Oupu volage adjusmen range Isolaion Remoe ON/OFF E9
More informationCHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS
CHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS Osama. OLABY, Xavier. BRN, Sylvie. SESMAT, Tanneguy. REDARCE and Eric. BIDEAX Laboraoire d Auomaique Indusrielle  hp://wwwlai.insalyon.fr
More informationPaul R. Drake Management School, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK
The curren issue and full ex archive of his journal is available a www.emeraldinsigh.com/09600035.hm Analysis of he bullwhip effec wih order baching in muliechelon supply chains Maloub Hussain College
More informationWORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI st CENTURY
CEPREMAP WORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI s CENTURY A prospecive analysis wih he INGENUE 2 model by he INGENUE TEAM Michel AGLIETTA and Vladimir BORGY (Cepii), Jean CHATEAU (Ocde),
More information2nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transport Technology For Regional Competitiveness
nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transpor Technology For Regional Compeiiveness SESSION C TBLE OF CONTENTS PREFCE... 4 ORGNISING COITTEE... 5 KEYNOTE DDRESS... 6 Session : UTOOTIE... 7 Session B : ERONUTICS...
More informationMaking Sense of Genetics Problems
Bio 101 Ms. Bledsoe Making Sense of Geneics roblems Monohbrid crosses Le s sar wih somehing simle: crossing wo organisms and waching how one single rai comes ou in he offsring. Le s use eas, as Mendel
More informationFlow Switch LABOVHZS
Flow Swich S Volumeric flow swiching Almos no effec from differing viscosiies Versaile, configurable swiching oupu in pushpull design Robus consrucion Compac design Characerisics he VHZ gearwheel flow
More informationLSU RISK ASSESSMENT FORM Please read How to Complete a Risk Assessment before completion
Please read How o Complee a Risk Assessmen before compleion EVENT OR ACTIVITY BEING RISK ASSESSED (add name of even where relevan) NAME OF DEPARTMENT Squad Training Neball DATE OF COMPLETION OF RISK ASSESSMENT
More informationZelio Control Measurement Relays RM4L Liquid Level Relays
Zelio Conrol Measuremen elays FNCTIONS These devices monior he levels of conducive liquids. They conrol he acuaion of pumps or valves o regulae levels; hey are also suiable for proecing submersible pumps
More informationManaging the abundance of bison in Yellowstone National Park, winter Chris Geremia, P. J. White, and Rick Wallen September 12, 2011
Managing he abundance of bison in Yellowsone Naional Park winer 2012 Chris Geremia P. J. Whie and Rick Wallen Sepember 12 2011 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Background Yellowsone Naional Park (YNP) developed a plan
More informationDevelopment of Urban Public Transit Network Structure Integrating MultiClass Public Transit Lines and Transfer Hubs
Developmen of Urban Public Transi Nework Srucure Inegraing MuliClass Public Transi Lines and Transfer Hubs Zhenbao Wang 1, Anyan Chen 2 1College of Civil Engineering, Hebei Universiy of Engineering Handan,
More informationCONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS
CONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS keninrol CONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS CONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS 0 KOSO KENT INTROL SUPPLIES A
More informationA Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Details and Extended Results
WORKING PAPER 200603 Resource Economics and Policy Analysis (REPA) Research Group Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Vicoria A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Deails and Exended Resuls G. Cornelis
More informationUS 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 US009615553B2 (12) Unied Saes Paen Coniglio e al. (10) Paen No.: (45) Dae of Paen: US 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017 (54) ARTIFICIAL
More informationSensors and Actuators A: Physical
Sensors and Acuaors A 144 (2008) 354 360 Conens liss available a ScienceDirec Sensors and Acuaors A: Physical journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locae/sna A microrobo fish wih embedded SMA wire acuaed
More informationAN ANALYSIS OF THE ECONOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY
AN ANALYSIS OF THE ECOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY MARCH 2014 This repor was produced a he reques of he Ron Sco, Ciy Manager for Danville, Kenucky, under he supervision
More informationCoefficients of Propellerhull Interaction in Propulsion System of Inland Waterway Vessels with Stern Tunnels
hp://www.ransnav.eu he Inernaional Journal on Marine Navigaion and Safey of Sea Transporaion Volume 8 Number 3 Sepember 214 DOI: 1.12716/11.8.3.8 Coefficiens of Propellerhull Ineracion in Propulsion Sysem
More informationImprovement of individual camouflage through background choice in groundnesting birds
This is he preproof acceped version of he manuscrip, he full version can be accessed for free here. Improvemen of individual camouflage hrough background choice in groundnesing birds Auhors: Marin Sevens*1,
More informationEFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY
EFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY S. Faulsich 1, P. Lyding 1, P. J. Tavner 2 1 Fraunhofer Insiue for Wind Energy and Energy Sysem Technology (IWES) 2 Energy Group, School of Engineering,
More informationPopulation size and exploitation of giant squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 1835) in the Gulf of California, Mexico*
SCI. AR., 65 (): 758 SCIENIA ARINA 2 Populaion size and exploiaion of gian squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 835) in he Gulf of California, exico* ENRIQUE ORALESBOJÓRQUEZ, AGUSÍN HERNÁNDEZHERRERA 2,
More informationR410A Rotary Compressor Bearing Design Considerations
Prde Universiy Prde epbs Inernaional Compressor Engineering Conference School of Mechanical Engineering 1998 R41A Roary Compressor Bearing Design Consideraions J. R. Lenz Tecmseh Prodcs Company Follow
More informationconnection Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod technology with specialist manufacturers from around the world
Making he connecion Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod echnology wih specialis manufacurers from around he world Making he connecion necessary beween he op end and he boom end of he racing engine
More informationCal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P.
Cal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P. 123) (147 ) You are now he proud owner of a SEIKO Analogue Quarz Wach
More information29 B ROUTE Bus Times Summer NOTES a = Time at Vicarage Way. * = On Schooldays bus operates up to 5 minutes later.
Brighon Lewes Ringmer / Touris Aracions Lewes for Hisoric own wih Casle; Isfield for Lavender Line Railway; for Spa Valley Railway, Paniles CiySAVER ickes are only valid beween Brighon and Falmer. nework
More informationOriginal Article. Physiological characteristics and physical fitness of girls at the beginning of classes at the volleyball sports school
Journal of Physical Educaion and Spor (JPES), 17(4), Ar 276, pp. 24672471, 2017 online ISSN: 2247806X; pissn: 2247 8051; ISSN  L = 22478051 JPES Original Aricle Physiological characerisics and physical
More informationClemco Industries Corp. ISO 9001 Certified
Clemco Indusries Corp. ISO 9001 Cerified 6 cuf Classic Blas Machines Exclusively from... SIMPLE, RUGGED, RELIABLE More han 75 years of reliable field service have made Clemco blas machines he preferred
More informationGenetic Mapping Exercise  Extra Credit. Do not work together  each person to do their own work.
Geneic Mapping Execise  Exa Cedi Name Secion # Do no ok ogehe  each peson o do hei on ok. hen loci of diffeen allelic goups ae on he same chomosome, linkage occus bu is no absolue. Cossingove alays
More informationI t ' 4 ti. t ti. IQ:::: mass x heat of fusion (or heat of vaporization) I HEAT AND ITS MEASUREMENT. t t. t f I I I. Name
HEAT AND TS MEASUREMENT Name a (or energy) can be measured in unis of calories or joules. When here is a,,,,,,nperaure change (AT), hea (Q) can be calculaed using his formula: During a phase change, we
More informationSWIMMING POOL HEAT PUMP UNITS. Installation & Instruction Manual DURA  series
SWIMMIG POO HEAT PUMP UITS Insallaion & Insrucion Manual DUA  series ev. 1.12 29.07.2014 Conens SWIMMIG POO HEAT PUMP UITS... 1! Conens... 2! 1. Preface... 3! 2. Specificaions... 4! 2.1 Technical daa
More informationCOMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS USING CORRECTED INITIAL VELOCITY DURING OVERHEAD SMASH
Journal of Engineering Science and Technolog Special Issue on AASEC 6, Ocober (7) 95 School of Engineering, Talor s Uniersi COMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS
More informationINSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL
IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUCTIONS SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLEASE READ THE ENTIRE CONTENTS OF THIS MANUAL PRIOR TO INSTALLATION AND OPERATION. BY PROCEEDING WITH LIFT INSTALLATION AND OPERATION YOU AGREE THAT
More informationAn Autonomous Blimp for the Wall Following Control.
An Auonomous Blimp for he Wall Following Conrol. SeungYong Oh *,**, Chi Won Roh *, Sung Chul Kang *, Eunai Kim ** * Inelligen Roboics Research Cener, Korea Insiue of Science an echnology, Seoul, Korea
More informationOPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLYFRIENDLY GOKART
Journal of Ecological Engineering Volume 17, Issue 5, Nov. 016, pages 90 95 DOI: 10.1911/998993/65454 Research Aricle OPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLYFRIENDLY GOKART Pior Zbigniew Filip 1,
More informationOptimal Staged SelfAssembly of General Shapes
Opimal Saged SelAssemly o General Shapes Cameron Chalk, Eric Marinez, Roer Schweller 3, Luis Vega 4, Andrew Winslow 5, and im Wylie 6 Deparmen o Compuer Science, Universiy o eas Rio Grande Valley, Brownsville,
More informationVERTICAL DOUBLE TEAM TECHNIQUE ON POWER / COUNTER ( DUECE / TREY )
VERICAL DOUBLE EA ECHNIQUE ON POER / COUNER ( DUECE / REY ) COACHING POIN: GE HIP O HIP IH KNEES ORKING NORH & SOUH; 4 HANDS ON DL & 4 EYES ON LBer. I. POS (INSIDE BLOCKER): GAIN VERICAL LEVERAGE (YOUR
More informationDeciding When to Quit: ReferenceDependence over Slot Machine Outcomes
Deciding When to Quit: ReferenceDependence over Slot Machine Outcomes By JAIMIE W. LIEN * AND JIE ZHENG * Lien: Department of Economics, School of Economics and Management, Tsinghua University, Beijing,
More informationINVERTER HEATPUMP FOR SWIMMING POOLS
IVE HEATPUMP FO SWIMMIG POOS Insallaion & Insrucion Manual hea pumps 000711611 Table of conens 1. Preface 3. Specificaions.1 Performance Daa. Dimensions 6 3. Insallaion and Connecion 3.1 Hea Pump ocaion
More informationPredicting Exchange Rates Out of Sample: Can Economic Fundamentals Beat the Random Walk?
Predicting Exchange Rates Out of Sample: Can Economic Fundamentals Beat the Random Walk? Jiahan Li Assistant professor of Statistics University of Notre Dame Joint work with Wei Wang and Ilias Tsiakas
More informationWorld gold prices and stock returns in China: insights for hedging and diversification strategies
World old price and ock reurn in Cina: ini for edin and diverificaion raeie Moamed El Hedi Arouri, Amine Laiani, Duc Kuon Nuyen To cie i verion: Moamed El Hedi Arouri, Amine Laiani, Duc Kuon Nuyen. World
More informationINSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL
EUROPEN USERS 400V 0Hz SUPPLY DETILS RE IN CLUDED WITH ELECTRICL CONTROL BOX. DISREGRD SUPPLY WIRING DETILS IN THIS MNUL IMPORTNT SFETY INSTRUCTIONS SVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLESE RED THE ENTIRE CONTENTS
More informationDIN, EN, ASTM. Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам. Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту ASME 16.48
Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам DIN, EN, STM Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту SME 16.48 Для заказа металлопроката или получения консультации обращайтесь по следующим контактам: Россия: +7 (495)
More informationPrice convergence in Europe from a macro perspective: Trends and determinants ( )
DNB WORKING PAPER Prie onvergene in Europe from a maro perspeive: Trends and deerminans (19602003) Riemer P. Faber and Ad C.J. Sokman No. 12/Oober 2004 Prie onvergene in Europe from a maro perspeive:
More informationDRINKING WATER PIPE SYSTEM. The blue line
DRINKING WATER PIPE SYSTEM The blue line Hanbook 2014 Inex The following coonly use abbreviaions are foun in his caalogue. Abbreviaion Descripion Uni A Crosssecional area 2 Ousie iameer of pipe i Insie
More informationParametric Asset Allocation
Parametric Asset Allocation Thomas Dangl, Arne Westerkamp, Josef Zechner April 19, 2013 VERY PRELIMINARY AND INCOMPLETE! We study how a simple asset allocation policy in which the investment weights are
More informationArchitectural PORTFOLIO CALL FOR ENTRIES SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM. Presented by. See back page for photo credits.
rchiecural PORTFOLIO T H I R T Y  F I F T H N N U L 2017 CLL FOR ENTRIES See back page for phoo credis. Presened by SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM Receive naional acclaim for YOUR EDUCTION DESIGN PROJECTS WWW.SUMG.COM
More informationParametric Tax Managed RU 3000 Fiduciary Services Parametric Portfolio Associates
Paramric Tax Managd U 3000 Paramric Porfolio Associas 1918 8h Avnu, Sui 3100 Sal, Washingon 98101 Syl: SubSyl: Firm AUM: Firm Sragy AUM: US Larg Cap Blnd $159.3 billion $6.1 billion Yar Foundd: GIMA Saus:
More informationMillSlicer PMC Phalaborwa AG Mill Ini4al Installa4on Trends and Results
MillSlicer PMC Phalaborwa AG Mill Ini4al Installa4on Trends and Results The following items obtained from the first couple days of system installaion are presented in the next several slides: I. PMC Single
More informationCentrifugal Fans belt driven. TD_CFBADY_EN Issue 1.1 EN July 2013 ADY
enrifugal ans bel driven TD_DY_N Issue 1.1 N July 013 DY 1 Nicora ebhard S.p.. cerifi es ha he fan shon herein is licensed o bear he Seal. The raings shon are based on ess and procedures performed in
More informationPREDICTING the outcomes of sporting events
CS 229 FINAL PROJECT, AUTUMN 2014 1 Predicting National Basketball Association Winners Jasper Lin, Logan Short, and Vishnu Sundaresan Abstract We used National Basketball Associations box scores from 19911998
More informationExercise 8. Panel Data (Answers) (the values of any variable are correlated over time for the same individuals)
ercse 8. Panel Daa Answers. Gven m a,.,. I follows ha Varm m s Varm Varm s  Covm, m s Wh anel daa s lkel ha Covm, m s > he vales of an varable are correlaed over me for he same ndvdals Wh ooled daa hen
More informationGame, set and match: The favoritelong shot bias in tennis betting exchanges.
Game, set and match: The favoritelong shot bias in tennis betting exchanges. Isabel Abinzano, Luis Muga and Rafael Santamaria Public University of Navarre (SPAIN) June 2015 Abstract: We test for the existence
More informationTHE NINTH INFANTRY DIVISION ASSOCIATION
THE.'2 Gregory Ave., W...wk.n. N.J. 07087 THE NINTH INFANTRY DIVISION ASSOCIATION AriAinn Dues; $5.00 per year $ 1.50 wiii be earmarked o pay for he Oeofoil Voiume XXXIV NUMBER: MAYJUNE 1979 Commemoraion
More informationAnalysis of Shear Lag in Steel Angle Connectors
University of New Hampshire University of New Hampshire Scholars' Repository Honors Theses and Capstones Student Scholarship Spring 2013 Analysis of Shear Lag in Steel Angle Connectors Benjamin Sawyer
More informationNonlife Actuarial Models. Chapter 7 Bühlmann Credibility
Nonlife Actuarial Models Chapter 7 Bühlmann Credibility Learning Objectives 1. Basic framework of Bühlmann credibility 2. Variance decomposition 3. Expected value of the process variance 4. Variance of
More informationThe final set in a tennis match: four years at Wimbledon 1
Published as: Journal of Applied Statistics, Vol. 26, No. 4, 1999, 461468. The final set in a tennis match: four years at Wimbledon 1 Jan R. Magnus, CentER, Tilburg University, the Netherlands and Franc
More informationPowerlaw distribution in Japanese racetrack betting
Powerlaw distribution in Japanese racetrack betting Takashi Ichinomiya Nonlinear Studies and Computation, Research Institute for Electronic Science, Hokkaido University, Sapporo 0600812, Japan. Abstract
More informationModelling and Simulation of Environmental Disturbances
Modelling and Simulation of Environmental Disturbances (Module 5) Dr Tristan Perez Centre for Complex Dynamic Systems and Control (CDSC) Prof. Thor I Fossen Department of Engineering Cybernetics 18/09/2007
More informationGIS Strategic 10 Dividend Select UMA Global Investment Solutions  Strategic Portfolios
Global Invsmn Soluions  Sragic Porfolios 2000 Wschsr Av. Purchas, Nw York 10577 Syl: SubSyl: Firm AUM: Firm Sragy AUM: US Larg Cap Valu $137.0 million Yar Foundd: GIMA Saus: Firm Ownrship: ProfssionalSaff:
More information110 Year Municipal Ladder Select UMA Nuveen Asset Management
110 Yar Municipal Laddr Nuvn Ass Managmn 333 Ws Wackr Driv Chicago, Illinois 60606 Syl: US Tax Fr Cor SubSyl: Inrmdia Trm Munis FI Firm AUM: $171.7 billion Firm Sragy AUM: $969.0 million Yar Foundd:
More informationQueue analysis for the toll station of the Öresund fixed link. Pontus Matstoms *
Queue analysis for the toll station of the Öresund fixed link Pontus Matstoms * Abstract A new simulation model for queue and capacity analysis of a toll station is presented. The model and its software
More informationPrediction Market and Parimutuel Mechanism
Prediction Market and Parimutuel Mechanism Yinyu Ye MS&E and ICME Stanford University Joint work with Agrawal, Peters, So and Wang Math. of Ranking, AIM, 2 Outline WorldCup Betting Example Market for
More informationEffect of Supplemental Signal on StartUp Lost Time at Signalized Intersection
Effect of Supplemental Signal on StartUp ost ime at Signalized Intersection Yongfeng Ma and Jian u Jiangsu Key aboratory of Urban IS, Southeast University, Si Pai ou No.2, Nanjing 210096, China Abstract.
More informationOutline. Overview of globalization. Global outlook for real economic activity & inflation. Risks to the outlook
2017 International Economic Outlook Everett Grant Research Economist Globalization & Monetary Policy Institute Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas October 2017 The views expressed are those of the author and
More informationPERSONAL VERSION. Readers are kindly asked to use the official publication in references.
PSONAL VSION Ths s a so called personal verson auhors s anuscrp as acceped for publshng afer he revew process bu pror o fnal layou and copyedng of he arcle. Bu, H & Vrk, N S 204, ' Lqudy and asse prces:
More informationCarol Tomé CFO and Executive Vice President, Corporate Services
Carol Tomé CFO and Executive Vice President, Corporate Services Financial Overview December 6, 2017 1 Discussion Overview Fiscal 2017 Financial Guidance Our View of the Economy and State of the U.S. Housing
More information