MODEL SELECTION FOR VALUEATRISK: UNIVARIATE AND MULTIVARIATE APPROACHES SANG JIN LEE


 Homer Stewart
 10 months ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 MODEL SELECTION FOR VALUEATRISK: UNIVARIATE AND MULTIVARIATE APPROACHES By SANG JIN LEE Bachelor of Science in Mahemaics Yonsei Universiy Seoul, Republic of Korea 999 Maser of Business Adminisraion Yonsei Universiy Seoul, Republic of Korea 004 Submied o he Faculy of he Graduae College of he Oklahoma Sae Universiy in parial fulfillmen of he requiremens for he Degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE December, 005
2 COPYRIGHT By Sang Jin Lee December, 005 ii
3 MODEL SELECTION FOR VALUEATRISK: UNIVARIATE AND MULTIVARIATE APPROACHES Thesis Approved: Timohy L. Krehbiel Thesis Adviser B. Wade Brorsen Zhigang Zhang A. Gordon Emslie Dean of he Graduae College ii
4 Acknowledgemen This hesis is meaningful o me in wo aspecs; firs, hrough his hesis, I have had a chance o summarize wha I learned in he Maser of Science in Quaniaive Financial Economics program a Oklahoma Sae Universiy. Second, my longerm objecive has been achieved. I finished my undergraduae degree in 999 jus afer he Asian financial crisis. Afer ha crisis, everyhing in he Korean financial marke changed. Korea moved from a Japanese business model o an American model. The rules of he game changed. A ha ime I decided ha someday I would go o he US o learn he new rules. This hesis is a produc of beginning o learn hem. However, wihou people who suppored and helped me, I can no imagine ha I would have finished his hesis. I have had hree pillars o suppor his work: my hesis commiee, friends and coworkers, and my family. As an academic pillar, I m indebed so much o my commiee members; Dr. B. Wade Brorsen, Dr. Zhigang Zhang, and my advisor Dr. Timohy L. Krehbiel. Dr. Krehbiel iniiaed his sudy and helped me hroughou he enire process. Dr. Zhang gave me good knowledge and advice and Dr. Brorsen gave me a lo of producive criics in finalizing his projec. I am especially lucky o have had a chance o work wih Dr. Brorsen who is a wellrespeced scholar. My friends and coworkers are anoher pillar. I hanks my friends, especially Yong Su Jang, Yoon Suk Sung, Dong Ho Choi, Sung Jun Kim, Woo Ju Jo, Jun Sung iii
5 Bae, who has been my friends since high school, Dr. Ki Bum Bhin, Su Jong Im, Seung Wan Kim, Jae Min Shin and his wife, who are undergraduae colleagues, Dr. Hong Jin Whang and his wife, Wei Sun and his wife, Arun Aravind, who are friends in Oklahoma Sae Universiy. I also hank o my coworkers in Korea who gave suppor and aenion; Myung Sook Jung, Chung Gi Wi, Hee Jun Yu, Won Sik Jung, Jung Hun Lee, Mi Hoe Kim, wih whom I enered he company in he same year, Dr. Jong Yong Kim, Mr. Hyung Bok Seo, Mr. Su Il Kim, Mr. Jae Ik Moon, Mr. Chang Rae Jo, who were my bosses in he company. I should express my special hanks o Mr. Kwang Sik Kim, who moivaed me and helped me hroughou my whole sudy. Besides hem, here are so many ha I feel sorry ha I can no lis all heir names individually because of he limiaion of paper. The final and mos imporan pillar is my family, my elder broher and his wife, grandmoher, moher, and faher. Wihou heir suppor, everyhing in my life including his work would be impossible. I would like o name Dr. Trish Macvaugh as my family. To me, she is moher in he US because during my sudy, she lisened o me, cheered me up, and encouraged me. As you can see, his is no a work compleed by myself; wihou any one of hem, i would have been impossible for me o finish his work. I also would like o express my graiude o my company, Financial Supervisory Service in Korea, for allowing me ime o sudy. Sang Jin Lee iv
6 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chaper Page. Inroducion.... ValueaRisk...6. Single Asse...6. Porfolio VaR Evaluaion Models Univariae Model Equally Weighed Moving Average Model Exponenially Weighed Moving Average Model GARCH Model Hisorical Simulaion Model Mulivariae Models Orhogonal GARCH Model Dynamic Condiional Correlaion Model Backesing Rolling Backesing Procedure Proporion of Failures Tes Runs Tes Daa... v
7 6. Empirical Resul Univariae Approach Dow Jones Indusrial Average Hypoheical Porfolio Mulivariae Approach Correlaion Esimaion of Mulivariae Models Mulivariae Approach Univariae Approach vs. Mulivariae Approach Conclusion...50 REFERENCES...53 APPENDIX A. Univariae Approach vs. Mulivariae Approach Using he EWMA Model...56 B. Principal Componen Analysis (PCA)...58 C. GARCH Model Fiing Resuls Using Various Compuer Sofware Packages...60 D. The Lengh of Periods of Backesing Trials...64 vi
8 LIST OF TABLES Table Page 3. Number of Parameers Needed According o he Number of Asses Descripive Saisics of DJIA Daily Reurns Reurns Sored from he Bigges o he Smalles Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Univariae Models for DJIA Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Univariae Models for he Hypoheical Porfolio Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Mulivariae Models for he Hypoheical Porfolio Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Univariae and Mulivariae Models for he Hypoheical Porfolio Mean and Sandard Deviaion of he VaR esimaes...46 C. Coefficiens Used o Simulae Daa Se...6 C. Descripive Saisics of Simulaed Daa Se...6 C.3 GARCH Model Fied Resuls...63 vii
9 LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page. VaR Esimae and Profi/Loss Disribuion The Procedure of he Rolling Backesing Hisograms and Plos of he DJIA and he Porfolio QQPlo of he DJIA and he Hypoheical Porfolio VaR Esimaes for DJIA when $00 was invesed (Lef Tail) VaR Esimaes for DJIA when $00 was Invesed (Righ Tail) VaR Esimaes for DJIA wih Realized Loss (Lef Tail) VaR Esimaes for DJIA wih Realized Loss (Righ Tail) VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio when $00 was invesed (Lef Tail) VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio when $00 was invesed (Righ Tail) VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio wih Realized Loss (Lef Tail) VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio wih Realized Loss (Righ Tail) Correlaions Using Various Models Porfolio Sandard Deviaion and Scaled Average Correlaions and Volailiy using he DCC model Porfolio Sandard Deviaion and Scaled Average Correlaions and Volailiy using he OGARCH model...40 viii
10 6. Excepion Occurrence of DCC and GARCH (Normal) Excepion Occurrence of OGARCH and GARCH (Normal)...49 C. Plos of Simulaed Daa Se...6 D. The resul of he PF Tes (Lef Tail, Univariae)...64 D. The resul of Backesing Trials among GARCH Models (Lef Tail)...66 D.3 The resul of Backesing Trials among GARCH Models (Righ Tail)...66 ix
11 CHAPTER INTRODUCTION ValueaRisk (VaR) is he mos popular ool in risk managemen because i is easy o communicae and easy o comprehend. The imporance of VaR is rapidly increasing because he inernaional agreemen in banking indusry he, socalled, Basel Accord heavily uses VaR mehodology. To manage marke risk, he Basel Accord requires a financial insiuion o have capial in proporion o he oal value of is riskadjused asse which is basically measured by VaR in he inernal models approach. This rule is acceped by he Group of Ten (G0) counries and many oher counries. So, banks in hose counries evaluae heir risk exposure using his VaR mehodology. Jorion (000) inuiively defined VaR as he summary of he wors loss over a arge horizon wih a given level of confidence. For example, he chief financial officer of a financial company migh say ha he VaR of he bank is $0 million a a 95 percen confidence level over one day horizon, which means ha here is a 5% probabiliy for a loss greaer han $0 million o happen under normal marke condiions. So, since VaR is a single number summarizing he amoun of risk he company is exposed o, i is very easy o undersand and communicae. G0 counries are Belgium, Canada, France, Germany, Ialy, Japan, he Neherlands, Sweden, Unied Kingdom, and he Unied Saes, plus Luxembourg and Swizerland.
12 However, he VaR mehodology requires disribuional assumpions for he relevan risk facors. Moreover, he VaR esimae depends on no only he asses class consiuing porfolio, bu also he model used o esimae he volailiy of hose asses. In his regard, i is valuable o invesigae which volailiy model produce superior risk measuremen for a given porfolio. In he pas sudy, Sarma e al (003) sudied he model selecion for VaR esimaion in he S&P 500 and India s NSE50. Using a wosage model selecion procedure, hey compared he performance of candidae volailiy models such as equally weighed moving average(eqma) model, exponenially weighed moving average(ewma) model, he GARCH model, and he hisorical simulaion(hs) model. They found ha he EWMA model worked bes among hose models. Angelidis and Alexandros (004) analyzed he applicaion of several volailiy models o forecas daily VaR boh for single asses and porfolios. They considered models such as he GARCH model, he EWMA model, he exponenial GARCH model, he hreshold ARCH model, he exreme value heory (EVT), and he HS model. They found ha he bes model depended on porfolio. Some researchers warned of limiaions of he VaR approach in risk managemen. Bedder (995) examined eigh VaR esimaes for hree hypoheical porfolios. He found ha VaR is very effecive measure in risk managemen, bu since i depends on parameers, daa, assumpions, and mehodology, i migh be dangerous in is applicaion. Hendricks (996) compared differen VaR evaluaion approaches using simulaed daa from eigh foreign exchange markes. He concluded ha in almos all cases hese approaches covered he risk ha hey were inended o cover. However, he also observed
13 ha VaR esimaes from differen approaches were quie differen, which also implies ha VaR approach is overall good ool for risk managemen, bu needs some cauions in applicaion. The comparison of he univariae approach wih he mulivariae approach of VaR evaluaion migh also be a very ineresing quesion. In evaluaing he porfolio VaR, he mulivariae model can have some advanages over he univariae model. According o Bauwens e al. (004), one advanage of a mulivariae model is ha once we ge he covariance marix by he mulivariae approach, we do no need o calculae again he covariance marix even if he weighs of each asse are changed; under he univariae model, we should evaluae he variance of porfolio again whenever he weighs of each asse are changed. Anoher advanage is ha a mulivariae model may improve he evaluaion performance in updaing he variances and correlaions by considering he individual characerisics of he porfolio s componens and esimaing heir linear comovemen. According o he Longin and Solink (995), he markes become more closely relaed during periods of high volailiy. In his period, considering he individual correlaion among socks migh increase he model accuracy. So, i is a good research quesion wheher mulivariae models perform beer han univariae models. In he lieraure of he mulivariae VaR approach, Manfredo and Leuhod (999) invesigaed various VaR esimaion echniques for he agriculural enerprise porfolio; he EQMA model, he EWMA model, he GARCH model, he implied volailiy model, and he HS model as univariae model, and consan condiional correlaion model as mulivariae models. They found ha he EWMA model and he HS model provided reasonably good esimaes. Brooks and Persand (000) found ha he mulivariae 3
14 GARCH(,) model worked bes o ge a VaR esimae relaive o oher models like he HS model, he RiskMerics approach, and he modified RiskMerics approach using daily closing sock prices of five Souheas Asian counries. Engle (00) compared VaR esimaes from various mehods such as he BEKK model, he Dynamic Condiional Correlaion (DCC) model, and he orhogonal GARCH (OGARCH) model, he mulivariae EQMA model, and he mulivariae EWMA model. He observed ha he DCC model overall performed bes o evaluae VaR under he various siuaions. Rombous and Verbeek (004) examined he usefulness of he mulivariae semiparameric GARCH models for porfolio selecion under a ValueaRisk (VaR) consrain. They also examined several alernaive mulivariae GARCH models for daily reurns on he S&P 500 and NASDAQ indexes. To ell a good model from a bad model, we need some crieria. One obvious propery ha a good model should have is predicabiliy. Tha is, a good model should do a good job in predicing fuure risk exposure. Anoher crierion is wheher he model uses all informaion available. If a predicion model does no use all informaion available, is predicion abiliy will be lowered, which means ha he model is inferior. There are various saisical mehods based on hese ideas. We will review hem in he laer secion. So, his hesis will address wo quesions:. Which univariae models are appropriae o evaluae VaR of he Dow Jones Indusrial Average (DJIA).. Considering mulivariae volailiy models such as he DCC model and he O GARCH model, which incorporae condiional correlaions among asses, as BEKK came from Baba, Engle, Kraf and Kroner who were conribuors o he model. 4
15 well as univariae models, which models are appropriae o evaluae VaR for a hypoheical porfolio. For he firs quesion, we will focus on he univariae model. Afer ha, we will urn our aenion o he mulivariae model for he second quesion. For hese quesions, we need some judging crieria, which will be inroduced laer. In he following secions, we will review he VaR conceps, which will be followed by a review of he various mehods o evaluae VaR. Afer ha, we will move o he model discerning crieria. The empirical resul of he univariae models will be presened and discussed firs. Then, he resul of he mulivariae models will follow, and he comparison of boh models will be discussed. Then, we will draw some conclusions and implicaions. This hesis is differen from he exising sudies from wo poins: daa and comparison. This hesis uses wo ses of daa: he DJIA and a hypoheical porfolio. Mos pas research used a porfolio consising of wo, hree or, a mos, five socks. Bu, in his hesis we use a hypoheical porfolio consising of 30 socks o es he performances of he mulivariae models. One oher poin is ha i seems ha lile sudy has been done abou he comparison of he mulivariae VaR esimae mehods wih he univariae VaR esimae mehods using he same porfolio in he VaR lieraure. So, he mos disincive poin of his hesis is ha comparison. This will allow us o deermine he value of condiional correlaion esimaion in his VaR applicaion. 5
16 CHAPTER II ValueaRisk Jorion (000) formally defines VaR as he descripion of he quanile of he projeced disribuion of gains and losses over he arge horizon. If c is he seleced confidence level, VaR corresponds o he c lowerail levels. Mahemaically, i can be formulaed like his: VaR c = f ( x) dx () where x is a random variable of he profi/loss of porfolio, f(x) is he disribuion of x, and c is he seleced confidence level. If he profi/loss disribuion of porfolio is assumed o follow a normal disribuion wih zero mean, hen we can ge a VaR esimae in a very easy way as follows.. Single Asse If he profi/loss disribuion of an asse is assumed o follow a normal disribuion wih zero mean, hen VaR = z c V 0 σ () where z c is he criical value a confidence level c, V 0 is he iniial value of he porfolio, and σ is he esimaed sandard deviaion of he porfolio s reurn. For insance, assume 6
17 ha he iniial value of an asse is $, he reurn of he asse follows a normal disribuion wih zero mean and sandard deviaion of σ. The omorrow s VaR esimae a 95% confidence level over one day horizon is.645σ in figure. Figure.: VaR Esimae and Profi/Loss Disribuion. Porfolio In he porfolio heory, he reurn ( r p ) of a porfolio is defined as follows: r p = n i= w r i i (3) where n is he number of asses in he porfolio, r i is he reurn of ih asse for i =..n, and w is he weigh of ih asse in he porfolio for i =..n. The variance ( σ ) of he i porfolio can be calculaed as follows: p 7
18 n i= n n σ = ( w σ ) + w w σ (4) p i i i= j= i j where σ i is he variance of ih asse, σ i, j is he covariance beween ih asse and jh asse. In equaion (4), he firs erm is called diversifiable risk or nonsysemaic risk which can be eliminaed hrough diversificaion and he second erm is called undiversifiable risk or sysemaic risk which can no be eliminaed hrough diversificaion. To invesigae he power of diversificaion 3, we consider a sraegy where weighs are equal o /n. Then n n n p = σ i + n i= n i= j= n i j i j σ σ (5) We define he average variance ( σ ) and average covariance ( C ) of he asses as i, j i, j σ = n n i= σ i C = n( n ) n n i= j= i j σ i, j (6), hen porfolio variance can be expressed as n σ p = σ + C. (7) n n Here, when he number of asses in he porfolio increases, he firs erm, nonsysemaic risk, will disappear, bu he second erm, sysemaic risk, will converge o C. In general, we can say ha he risk of a welldiversified porfolio comes from only sysemaic risk or covariance par in equaion (7). The variance of he porfolio can be expressed in he marix form as 3 You can see more deailed discussion on his in Chaper 8 of Bodie e al (00). 8
19 σ σ, n w [ ] w σ = p w w... wn (8) σ n, σ n wn or σ = w Σ w p where w is he vecor of he weighs of he porfolio, and Σ is he covariance marix. If risk facors follow a normal disribuion wih zero mean, he VaR of he porfolio can be calculaed as VaR p = z V 0 σ p (9) We noe ha he relaion beween he mean and he sandard deviaion depends on he lengh of he ime horizon. Since he volailiy grows wih he square roo of ime and he mean wih ime for independen idenically disribued processes, he mean will dominae he volailiy over long horizons. Over shor horizons, such as a day, volailiy dominaes. This provides a raionale for focusing on volailiy ignoring expeced reurns or assuming ha hose are zero when we evaluae VaR measures using daily daa. In his hesis, since we will use he daily reurns of 30 socks, we also assume ha he expeced reurn of he daily reurn of each sock is zero. The expeced reurn of he porfolio can be assumed zero because he expeced reurn of he porfolio is he weighed average of he expeced reurns of he socks. This leads us o jus focus on he sandard deviaions of he socks and porfolio o evaluae VaR. 9
20 CHAPTER 3 VaR Evaluaion Models There are wo approaches o evaluae he VaR in a porfolio sense. The firs approach is o creae a univariae reurn series for he porfolio using he weigh of each asse, and hen we can use univariae models which will be reviewed. The oher approach is o esimae a mulivariae variancecovariance marix, and hen we can evaluae VaR by using equaion (7). We will use five univariae models and wo mulivariae models o evaluae VaR. Five univariae models are he EQMA model, he EWMA model, he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion, he GARCH model wih a disribuion, and he HS model 4. As mulivariae models, we will use he OGARCH model and he DCC model because hese can be easily applied o a porfolio consising of many asses. In fac, mos frequenly used and cied mulivarie volailiy models are he Vech 5 model, he BEKK model, he DCC model, and he OGARCH model. However, as indicaed in Table 3., he Vech model and he BEKK model are pracically no available for a porfolio consising of many asses, which leads us o use jus he DCC model and he OGARCH model. 4 Here, we do no consider he Mone Carlo simulaion mehod because we will use he linear porfolio, in which case he resul from he Mone Carlo simulaion should be he same as he resul from variancecovariance approach. 5 Vech is he name of a mahemaical operaor. 0
21 Table 3.: Number of Parameer Needed According o he Number of Asses #. Asses Vech Model BEKK Model DCC Model n n( n + ) n( n ) n( n + ) n OGARCH Model 3 n n 30 43, Noe ha in his able we assume ha he lags of all ARCH and GARCH parameers are 3. Univariae Models We will review five models: he EQMA model, he EQMA model, he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion, he GARCH model wih a disribuion, and he HS model. 3.. Equally Weighed Moving Average Model The simples one is he equally weighed moving average model, where oday s volailiy is calculaed by he average of he volailiy over he given ime window. The mahemaical formula is 6 m ( ) σ = (0) r i m i= where σ is he sandard deviaion, n is he number of daily rae changes used o calculae sandard deviaion, r is daily reurn. In fac, his model gives equal weigh /m o each volailiy of he pas. So, ha is why his model is called equally weighed moving average model. 6 By using m insead of m in he denominaor, we assume ha he volailiy esimae in equaion (5) is he maximum likelihood esimaor, no he unbiased esimaor. See Hull (003) chaper 7.
22 3.. Exponenially Weighed Moving Average Model I seems more reasonable o assume ha oday s volailiy is more affeced by he more recen evens. To incorporae his ino he model, we should give more weigh o he more recen evens and less weigh o he laer evens. One of hese weigh schemes is an exponenial scheme. The model using his exponenial weigh scheme is = ( ) + λ r λσ σ () where σ is he sandard deviaion for day n, r is he daily shock for day n, and λ is he decay facor 7. In he ieraive way, we can easily show ha 8 m σ = ( λ) λ ( r i ) () i=, which shows ha he weighs for he r s decline a rae λ as we move back hrough ime. This model is called exponenially weighed moving average model. According o he echnical documen of he RiskMerics (996), i uses he EWMA model wih λ = 0.94 for updaing daily volailiy esimaes. In his hesis, we used λ = 0.94 because we used daily daa GARCH Model There is anoher weigh scheme called generalized auoregressive condiional heeroskedasiciy (GARCH) model, which is proposed by Bollerslev (986). The GARCH (p,q) process is hen given by 7 We noe ha since in his hesis he expeced mean of he price is assumed o be zero, he daily shock is equal o he daily reurn, ha is, ε n = r n for day n. So, hereafer he daily shock means he daily reurn, and vice versa. 8 Here, we assume ha he volailiies before ime (m) are so small ha hey can be ignored.
23 ε ψ ~ Ν(0, σ ), σ = α + 0 q i= α ε i i + p i= β σ i i (3) where p 0, q > 0, α 0 > 0, α 0, β 0. When p=q=0, ε is simply whie noise. I is i i generally acceped ha in mos cases GARCH(,) model is enough o model he volailiy of financial marke. So, we will use GARCH(,) model in his hesis, and hereafer GARCH model means GARCH(,) model. The meaning of GARCH model is ha oday s volailiy(σ ) is updaed by yeserday s volailiy(σ  ) and yeserday s shock(ε  ). We noe ha in fac he EWMA model is a paricular case of he GARCH(,) model where α 0 =0, α =  λ, and α = λ. Anoher variaion of he sandard GARCH model is o use he suden disribuion insead of normal disribuion as he condiional disribuion which he daily reurn follows. In fac, he condiional disribuion as well as he uncondiional disribuion of he daily reurn is generally considered o have faer ails han a normal disribuion. So, if we use he suden disribuion insead of a normal disribuion as he condiional disribuion he daily reurn follow, we are supposed o ge more realisic resul Hisorical Simulaion model The hisorical simulaion mehod uses hisorical daa o build he disribuion of he risk facor, and hen evaluae VaR from ha disribuion. In he case of he single index, we ge hisorical movemens or series of reurns ( r, =,.., n ) of he index. Based on hose movemens, we can ge he simulaed omorrow s value of he index V n+ as: 3
24 n+ = ( r + ) Vn (4) V * where =,.., n and Vn is he oday s porfolio value. Afer ha, we can consruc he disribuion of he change in he porfolio ( = Vn + Vn = ( r + ) * Vn Vn = r,,.., n ). = And, hen sor r ( =,.., n) observaions from he bigges loss o he bigges gain. This arrangemen can be considered as he disribuion of he risk facor. If we wan o ge 95% VaR, he 5h quanile of ha disribuion is wha we wan o ge. 3. Mulivariae Model. In mulivariae models, we migh consider weigh schemes ha are similar o weigh schemes in he univariae models like a moving average and GARCH. However, we noe ha if we use he mulivariae variancecovariance marix proposed by RiskMerics (00), equally and exponenial weighed schemes produce he same resul in boh approaches 9, ha is, he volailiy from he univariae reurn series is always equal o he volailiy from he mulivariae variancecovariance marix because hey use he same mehods in updaing he volailiy and he covariance. So, we will review jus wo GARCH ype models: he OGARH model and he DCC model. 3.. Orhogonal GARCH Model According o Alexander (00), he orhogonal mehod uses principal componen analysis (PCA) approach o consruc covariance marices 0. In he orhogonal GARCH model, he imevarying covariance marix H of he original sysem is approximaed by H = AD A' (5) 9 Comparison beween univariae approach and mulivariae approach is in appendix A. 0 See he appendix B for deails of PCA approach. 4
25 where A is he marix of rescaled facor weighs and D is he imevarying diagonal marix of variances of he principal componens of original mulivariae series. The diagonal marix D of variances of principal componens is esimaed using a GARCH model. We noe ha basically PCA echnique is a linear ransformaion from one space measured on realworld basis ino he oher space measured on socalled principal componen basis. In he laer world, we can analyze realworld daa in a differen poin based on principal componens, which are muually orhogonal; hence we don need o pay aenion o correlaion beween componens. So, he correlaions in he real world are ransformed ino he variances of he principal componens. Hence, analyzing dynamics of variances of principal componens implicily incorporae dynamics of correlaions of realworld daa. 3.. Dynamic Condiional Correlaion model Engle (00) proposed a new class of mulivariae GARCH models named dynamic condiional correlaion model. The DCC model evolved from he consan condiional correlaion (CCC) model by Bollerslev (990). The CCC model esimaes condiional covariance marix H as: H = D RD where D = diag } (6) { h i, where R is a consan correlaion marix, ime series of asse i in he porfolio a ime. h i, is he condiional covariance of univariae 5
26 The DCC model assumes he correlaion marix is imevarying, ha is, R insead of consan R and uses he GARCH scheme o incorporae ha imevarying propery of he correlaion ino he model as follows: H = D R D where D = diag } { h i, R = diag{ Q } Q diag{ Q } (7) Q M N M N = ( α ) ( m β n Q + α m ε mε m ) + βnr m= n= m= n= where H is a imevarying covariance marix, α m is he ARCH coefficien, β n is he GARCH coefficien, M is he order of ARCH parameer, N is he order of GARCH parameer, Q is he uncondiional covariance of he sandardized residuals, and ε m is he sandardized residual from univariae ime series, and diag {X} mean a diagonal marix of marix X. According o Engle (00), ifα 0, β 0, and ( M m= posiive, hen N α m β n ) 0, hen R will be posiive semidefinie. If any one of hem is n= R will be posiive definie. Engle and Sheppard (00) saed ha he DCC model was designed o allow for wo sage esimaion. In he firs sage, univariae GARCH models are esimaed for each residual series. Then, in he second sage, residuals, ransformed by heir sandard deviaion esimaed during he firs sage, are used o esimae he parameers of he dynamic correlaion. m n 6
27 CHAPTER 4 Backesing We can ge he various VaR esimaes depending on he model we used o measure volailiy. So, we need some crieria o decide which is beer. According o Campbell (005), a good model should have wo properies based on he resul of rolling backesing; uncondiional coverage propery and independence propery. 4. Rolling Backesing Procedure Firs, we will describe rolling backesing. The following example will bes explain he procedure of rolling backesing. Suppose we have 500 observaions of pas reurns of a porfolio and we use 000 observaions o esimae omorrow s VaR esimae. Using observaions from he firs o he 000h, we go omorrow s VaR esimae of $,000 and he omorrow s realized observaion or he 00s observaion is $,00, hen we say ha an excepion is realized or here is an excepion; if he 00s observaion is less han he VaR esimae, we say ha here is no excepion. Nex, using observaions from he second o he 00s, we can do he same comparison wheher he VaR esimae is exceeded by he 00nd observaions or nex day s realized loss of he porfolio. Coninuing his comparison from he 500h o he 499h observaion wih 500h Some auhors use a erm, exceedance insead of excepions because he realized loss exceeds he expeced loss or he VaR esimae. 7
28 observaion, each comparison is regarded as one backesing. Then we have A oal of 500 backesings. The procedure is described in figure. Wih his binomial sequence (excepion or noexcepion), we can do he uncondiional coverage propery and independence propery. Figure 4.: The Procedure of he Rolling Backesing 4. Proporion of Failures Tes Uncondiional coverage propery means ha he number of realized VaR excepions of rolling backesing wih pas daa mus be equal o he expeced number of VaR excepions indicaed by he VaR model wihin saisical olerance. For example,  day 99% VaR wih 500 backesing rials expecs 5 excepions (= (  99%) 500). If he realized excepion is ou of he range in which boh are saisically equal, hen we can conclude ha he model is inappropriae. Kupiec (995) proposed he proporion of failures (PF) es as he uncondiional coverage, which we will use in his hesis. The LR saisic for esing he null hypohesis ha he realized raio (p) of he excepions of VaR over he pas daa is equal o he probabiliy p* of he excepions of VaR is he following: * nx * x x nx x x PF = Ln [( p ) ( p ) ] + Ln[( ) ( ) ] (8) n n The null hypohesis of he saisical es is ha he number of excepions is 0. 8
29 where x is he realized number of excepions in he sample, n is he oal number of backesing rials. Under he null hypohesis, p = p*, he PF es has a chisquare disribuion wih degree of freedom. If he null hypohesis is rejeced because he realized raio is greaer han he expeced raio, we can say ha he model underesimaes VaR. On he oher hand, he null hypohesis is rejeced because he realized raio is less han he expeced raio, we can say ha he model overesimaes VaR. One possible reason of underesimaion is ha he disribuion of he reurn series of financial asse usually has a faer ail han he normal disribuion and he model fails o incorporae ha fa fail fully. 4.3 Runs Tes Independence propery means ha he excepions of he backesing should occur in a random way. If he occurrence of he excepions is no disribued randomly across ime, we can find some paerns, which a good model should incorporae wih is predicion schemes. In his hesis we will use he runs es o es a randomness of he excepions 3. Runs can be defined as a sequence wihin a series in which one of he alernaives occurs on consecuive rials. Using he example of a coin oss, if a series look like his: H H T H H T T T H T, hen HH, T, HH, TTT, H, and T are runs. The null hypohesis of a runs es is wheher he disribuion of a series of binary evens in a populaion is random. In order o calculae he es saisics, one mus deermine he number (n,n ) of imes each of he wo alernaives appears in he series and he 3 You can find more deails abou he runs es in Sheskin (003). 9
30 number(r) of runs in he series. The basic idea of a runs es is ha he number of runs should be wihin he appropriae range for he series o be random. In he above example, he number (n ) of heads is 5 and he number (n ) of ails is 5, and he number(r) of runs is 6. If he number of runs is oo small, say,, hen i migh be difficul o say ha he series is random because he series should be H H H H H T T T T T or T T T T T H H H H H. The normal disribuion can be employed wih a large sample size o approximae he exac disribuion of he runs es as he following: nn r [ + ].5 n + n z = (9) n n (n n n n ) ( n + n ) ( n + n where r is he number of run, n is he number represening alernaive which can be defined as nonexcepion occurrence of backesing rials in his hesis, and n is he number represening alernaive which can be defined as excepion occurrence of backesing rials in his hesis. In he example above (n =5, n =5, r=), zscore is , which obviously resuls in rejecing he null hypohesis or nonrandomness. Possible reasons of he rejecion of null hypohesis are clusering of excepions and increase of he number of excepions. As excepions are clusered, he number of runs will decrease, and as he number of excepions increases, n will decrease and n will increase in equaion (9), which resuls in higher chance of he rejecion of null hypohesis. For example, when n is 353, n is 5, and r is 99, zsaisics is .835(pvalue=.0684). When n is 353, n is 5, and r is 00, zsaisics is .348(pvalue=.09). However, when n is 353, n is 5, and r is 99, zsaisics is .986(pvalue=.0034). ) 0
31 CHAPTER 5 Daa We will use he DJIA index o address which univariae VaR model performs bes. The DJIA daa came from he Yahoo finance websie. The ime horizon of daa is from 0/3/986 o /3/004 and he oal number of sample of he DJIA closing price is We used he daily logarihmic reurn such as R = 00 [log( P ) log( P )] (0) where P is he closing price on day. For he mulivariae analysis, a hypoheical porfolio is considered o compare he performance of a univariae model wih ha of a mulivariae model. We used 30 socks of he DJIA componens a /3/004 4 and gave he same weigh /30 o each sock o consruc he porfolio. We go daa from Cener for Research in Securiy Prices (CRSP). The ime horizon of daa is from 0/3/986 o /3004 and he number of observaions is We use he daily logarihmic reurn for each sock as follows: R i = 00 [log( Pi, ) log( Pi, )] (), 4 The roser of DJIA has changed over ime. So, we ook a snapsho a /3/004. The same company is idenified by he same PERMNO which is given by CRSP daabase. See daa descripion guide for he CRSP US sock daabase and he CRSP US indices daabase. Here is he lis of he companies: Alcoa Inc, AIG, American Express Inc, Boeing Co, Ciigroup Inc, Caerpillar Inc, Du Pon E I De Nem, Wal Disney Disney C, General Elecric Co, General Moors, Home Depo Inc, Honeywell Inl Inc, Hewle Packard Co, IBM, Inel Cp, Johnson And Johns Dc, JP Morgan Chase Co, Coca Cola, Mcdonalds Cp, 3M Company, Alria Group Inc, Merck Co Inc, Microsof Cp, Pfizer Inc, Procer Gamble Co, SBC Communicaions, Unied Tech, Verizon Commun, Wal Mar Sores, Exxon Mobil Cp. 5 The daa for Alria Group was no available. So, all he daa for ha day were removed.
32 where P i, is he adjused price for facors like sock spli and spinoffs, and includes dividend because we wan o focus on he price movemens which are no caused by corporae evens such as sock spli and spinoffs. Table 5. shows he descripive saisics. The hisograms and plos are in figure 5.. Here, we wan o noe several facs. Firs, boh means of he DJIA daily reurns and he hypoheical porfolio are so small relaive o sandard deviaion ha our assumpion o ignore he mean of daily reurns seems reasonable. Secondly, LjungBox Q es saisics show ha here are auocorrelaions also in boh cases. ARCH LM es saisics show ha here are ARCH effecs in boh cases. Thirdly, JarqueBera es saisics show ha he uncondiional disribuion of daily reurns is far from normal in boh cases. We can also confirm ha by he hisograms in figure 5.. Finally, we would like o pay aenion o he ail propery of boh porfolios. The lef ail and he righ ail of boh porfolios are faer han hose of a normal disribuion as indicaed in he QQplo of figure 5.. Also, we can observe ha he lef ails of boh are more deviaed from he normal disribuion han he righ ail. In Table 5. and figure 5., hough he bigges and he smalles reurn of he DJIA are respecively greaer and less han hose of he hypoheical porfolio, overall he hypoheical porfolio has a faer ail han he DJIA.
33 Table 5.: Descripive Saisics of DJIA Daily Reurns Variables DJIA Hypoheical Porfolio Observaions Mean Maximum Minimum Sd. Dev Skewness Kurosis ,697.4 a 88,.9 JarqueBera (<.000) b (0.0000) Q() (<.000) (<.000) ARCHLM (<.000) (<.000) a Bold means ha he number is saisically significan. b The number in parenhesis is pvalue. Figure 5.: Hisograms and Plos of DJIA and Porfolio 3
34 Table 5.: Reurns Sored from he Bigges o he Smalles Percenile DJIA Hypoheical Porfolio Bigges % % % % % % % % Smalles Figure 5.: QQPlo of he DJIA and he Hypoheical Porfolio 4
35 CHAPTER 6 Empirical Resul We examine he univariae reurn series of he DJIA index and he hypoheical porfolio of 30 socks using univariae models. Then, we examine he mulivariae reurn series of 30 socks using mulivariae models. For each examinaion, we invesigae he lef ail of he disribuion of a porfolio value which is relevan o he holder of a long posiion. We also invesigae he righ ail which is relevan o he holder of a shor posiion. 6. Univariae Approach We will consider wo univariae reurn series; one is from he DJIA for he firs research quesion and he oher is from he hypoheical porfolio consising of 30 socks for he second quesion. 6.. Dow Jones Indusrial Average We backesed he appropriaeness of 99% day VaR calculaed from each univariae model in he secion 3.. We used 000 observaions o calculae he VaR esimae a each backesing rial, so he oal number of backesing rials is 3583 [= 5
36 4583(he oal number of observaions) 000(observaions o ge one VaR backesing rial)]. The VaR esimae for each model is in figure 6. and figure 6. for each ail when we invesed $00 for each rial. In figure 6., he resuls using hree models (he EWMA model, he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion, and he GARCH model wih a  disribuion) seem very similar o each oher. Overall, he VaR esimae using EQMA is he smalles. In figure 6.3 and 6.4, you can compare he VaR esimae wih he realized loss. Though realized losses are smaller han VaR esimaes in mos cases, here are some cases ha realized losses are greaer han VaR esimaes, which cases are hough of as excepions. The resul of he PF es and runs es are presened in Table 6.. In he lef ail, all models excep he EQMA model were no rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level 6. All models excep he EWMA model and he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion were no rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. As a resul, wo models, he GARCH model wih a disribuion and he HS model were no rejeced wih boh ess. Among hese, he HS model show he neares number of excepions o he expeced number of excepions 36 which is % of he number of backesing rials 358. In he righ ail, all models excep he EQMA model were no rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level. All models were no rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. So, all models excep he EQMA model were no rejeced wih he PF es and he runs es. 6 Sricly speaking, we should say ha he null hypohesis of he PF es (or he runs es) relaed o a model was rejeced or no rejeced wih he PF es (or he runs es). Bu, in his hesis, if we have no problem in communicaion, for convenience, we would like o say ha a model was rejeced or no rejeced wih he PF es (or he runs es) o mean he same hing. 6
37 As a resul, in boh righ and lef ails he GARCH model wih a disribuion and he HS model were no rejeced wih boh he PF es and he runs es. Oher hree models were rejeced or inappropriae o evaluae VaR of he DJIA index porfolio wih respec o eiher he PF es or he runs es. Figure 6.: VaR Esimaes for DJIA When $00 was Invesed (Lef Tail) Figure 6.: VaR Esimaes for DJIA When $00 was Invesed (Righ Tail) 7
38 8 Figure 6.3: VaR esimaes for DJIA wih Realized Loss (Lef Tail) 8
39 9 Figure 6.4: VaR esimaes for DJIA wih Realized Loss (Righ Tail) 9
40 Table 6.: Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Univariae Models for DJIA PF Tes Runs Tes Tail Model Name Excepions Fsaisics pvalue No Excepions Excepions Runs z saisics pvalue Equally weighed(eqma) a Exponenially weighed(ewma) Lef GARCH (Normal Dis.) GARCH ( Dis.)* b Hisorical Simulaion* Equally weighed(eqma) Exponenially weighed(ewma)* Righ GARCH (Normal Dis.) * GARCH ( Dis.) * Hisorical Simulaion* a Bold means we rejec he null hypohesis in each es or model does no work well in each es a a 99% confidence level. b Aserisk means model work well in boh ess a he same ime a a 99% confidence level. 30
41 We noe ha as indicaed in he daa analysis of he DJIA, he disribuion of he DJIA reurns has a faer ail han a normal disribuion. And, he lef ail shows more deviaion from he normal disribuion han he righ ail (i.e. negaive skewness), which means ha he lef ail have more exreme evens or sronger volailiy clusering han he righ ail. In he lef ail, he EWMA model and he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion migh fail o incorporae volailiy clusering compleely and excepions were more likely o be clusered, so ha he null hypoheses of he runs ess of hose models were rejeced. However, in he lef ail he models such as he GARCH model wih a  disribuion and he HS model, which are more like o incorporae exreme evens or volailiy clusering, were no rejeced wih he runs es as well as he PF es. In he righ ail which has less exreme evens or weaker volailiy clusering han he lef ail, no only he GARCH model wih a disribuion and he HS model, bu also he EWMA model and he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion were no rejeced wih he runs es, which means ha hese models can handle appropriaely exreme evens or volailiy clusering in he righ ail. 6.. Hypoheical Porfolio We will compare he univariae models wih he mulivariae models using he same porfolio because we wan o know wheher he mulivariae models are more appropriae o evaluae VaR han he univariae models or condiional covariance esimaion improves risk measuremen. For he univariae models, we creaed he single 3
42 porfolio reurns using 30 socks giving /30 weigh o each sock as menioned in he daa secion. So, here, we will analyze he univariae hypoheical porfolio firs. We backesed he appropriaeness of 99% day VaR calculaed from each univariae model in he secion 3.. We used 000 observaions o evaluae VaR a each backesing rial, so he oal number of backesing rials is 358 [= 458(he oal number of observaions) 000(observaions o ge one VaR backesing rial)]. The VaR esimaes for each model are in figure 6.5 and 6.6 for each ail when we invesed $00 for each rial. In hose figures, he resul using hree models (he EWMA model, he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion, and he GARCH model wih a  disribuion) seem very similar o each oher. Overall, he VaR esimaes using he EQMA model are he smalles. In figure 6.7 and 6.8, you can compare VaR esimaes wih realized losses. Though realized losses are less han VaR esimaes in mos cases, here are some cases ha realized losses are greaer han VaR esimaes, which cases are hough of as excepions. The resul of he PF es and he runs es are in Table 6.. In he lef ail, all models excep he EQMA model were no rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level. However, only EWMA model was no rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. As a resul, in lef ail he only EWMA model was no rejeced wih boh ess. In he righ ail, only HS model was no rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level. However, all models were no rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. So, in he righ ail only HS model was no rejeced wih boh ess. 3
43 In sum, all models were rejeced wih he PF es or wih he runs es in he lef or righ ail, which means no model is appropriae o evaluae VaR of he univariae hypoheical porfolio of 30 socks for boh ails. Figure 6.5: VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio when $00 was Invesed (Lef Tail) Figure 6.6: VaR Esimaes Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio when $00 was Invesed (Righ Tail) 33
44 34 Figure 6.7: VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio wih Realized Loss (Lef Tail) 34
45 35 Figure 6.8: VaR Esimaes for Univariae Hypoheical Porfolio wih Realized Loss (Righ Tail) 35
46 Table 6.: Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Univariae Models for he Hypoheical Porfolio PF Tes Runs Tes Tail Model Name Excepions Fsaisics pvalue No Excepions Excepions Runs z saisics pvalue Equally weighed(eqma) a Exponenially weighed(ewma)* b Lef GARCH (Normal Dis.) GARCH ( Dis.) Hisorical Simulaion Equally weighed(eqma) Exponenially weighed(ewma) Righ GARCH (Normal Dis.) GARCH ( Dis.) Hisorical Simulaion* a Bold means we can rejec he null hypohesis in each es a a 99% confidence inerval. b Aserisk means model work well in boh ess a he same ime a a 99% confidence level. 36
47 We noe ha he resuls of he hypoheical porfolio are differen from he DJIA in wo aspecs; one is ha he EWMA model and wo GARCH models are rejeced wih he PF es in he righ ail, which may be caused by he fac ha in he righ ail he disribuion of he hypoheical porfolio reurn has a faer ails han ha of he DJIA reurn as indicaed a he daa analysis secion. The faer ail makes i difficul for models o adequaely esimae VaR wih respec o boh he PF es. The oher is ha in he lef ail he GARCH model wih a disribuion and he HS model were rejeced wih he runs es hough hese models were no rejeced wih he PF es. We noe ha in he DJIA case he number of runs is 9(GARCH model wih  disribuion) and 75(HS model), bu in he hypoheical porfolio ha number dropped o 83(GARCH model wih disribuion) and 73(HS model), which means ha excepions are more clusered in he hypoheical porfolio, which resuled in he rejecion of randomness null hypohesis. 6. Mulivariae Approach The correlaion beween reurns of asses in a porfolio is an essenial characerisic of mulivariae models. So, firs we will discuss he correlaion esimaion of mulivariae models. Then, we will discuss he empirical resul of mulivariae approach in calculaing he VaR esimae. 6.. Correlaion Esimaion of Mulivariae Models Figure 6.9 shows average correlaion using various models; he firs panel is calculaed by he DCC model, he second panel by OGARCH model, and he ohers are 37
48 calculaed over sliding windows of 6(6 monh), 500( years), and 000(4 years). As he ime window increases in he panel 3 o 5 of figure 6.9, he graph of he esimaed correlaion is less erraic and correlaions are more cenered o he overall mean. The overall level of correlaion using he DCC model based on he pas 000 observaions is analogous o he correlaion using sliding windows of 000 observaions, bu he graph using he DCC model is more erraic han ha of he graph using sliding windows of 000 observaions. Overall, he correlaion esimaed by he DCC model seems reasonable. Figure 6.0 and 6. show porfolio sandard deviaion and he average volailiies of 30 socks and average correlaion among 30 socks which are calculaed using he DCC model and he OGARCH model over he enire horizon of daa respecively, where for he comparison purpose we muliplied 6 o he average correlaion. Firs, we noe ha he Longin and Solnik s (995) observaion ha he correlaion rises in periods of high volailiy seems o hold over he enire period. Second, he average volailiy of socks represens a diversifiable risk or nonsysemaic risk of he porfolio and he average correlaion represens an undiversifiable or sysemaic risk of he porfolio 7. In his regard, in figure 6.0 and 6. we can also observe how he sandard deviaion of he porfolio esimaed by he DCC model and he OGARCH model incorporae he nonsysemaic risk and sysemaic risk. In figure 6.0 and figure 6., we also noe ha sysemaic risk (=porfolio sandard deviaion average volailiy) is a more dominan componen in porfolio variance han variances of each sock, non 7 Rigorously speaking, sysemaic risk of a porfolio is he average covariance of socks. However, since correlaion is he mos inegral componen of covariance, we can say ha correlaion represens sysemaic risk. 38
49 sysemaic risk because he porfolio consiss of 30 socks, so his is a relaively welldiversified porfolio. Figure 6.9: Correlaions using Various Models 39
50 Figure 6.0: Porfolio Sandard Deviaion and Scaled Average Correlaions and Volailiy Using he DCC Model Figure 6.: Porfolio Sandard Deviaion and Scaled Average Correlaions and Volailiy Using he OGARCH Model 40
51 6.. Mulivariae Approach In his subsecion, we will analyze he mulivariae approach of evaluaing he VaR esimae of he porfolio consising of 30 socks, he resul of which is in Table 6.3. The comparison of his resul wih he resul from he univariae hypoheical porfolio consising of he same 30 socks will le us address he second research quesion. We backesed he appropriaeness of 99% day VaR calculaed from mulivariae model in he secion 3.. We used 000 observaions o evaluae VaR a each backesing rial, so he oal number of backesing rials is 358 [= 458(he oal number of observaions) 000(observaions for geing one VaR backesing)]. The resul of he PF es and he runs es are in Table 6.3. In he lef ail, boh he DCC model and he OGARCH model were no rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level. Bu, boh were rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. As a resul, boh mulivariae models were rejeced wih he PF es or wih he runs es. In he righ ail, boh he DCC model and he OGARCH model were no rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level. Boh also were no rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. So, boh models were no rejeced wih boh ess ime in he righ ail. In sum, wo mulivariae models were rejeced wih he PF es or wih he runs es in he lef or righ ail, which means ha boh models are inappropriae o evaluae VaR of he hypoheical porfolio for boh ails hough boh models are appropriae o evaluae VaR of he hypoheical porfolio jus for righ ail. One possible reason of his resul is ha hose models failed o incorporae volailiy clusering in he lef ail as in he univariae hypoheical porfolio case. 4
52 Table 6.3: Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Mulivariae Models for he Hypoheical Porfolio Tail Model Name Excepions PF Tes Runs Tes Fsaisics pvalue No Excepions Excepions Runs z saisics pvalue Lef DCC a OGARCH Righ DCC* b OGARCH* a Bold means we can rejec he null hypohesis in each es a a 99% confidence inerval. b Aserisk means model work well in boh ess a he same ime a a 99% confidence level. 4
53 6.3 Univariae vs. Mulivariae Table 6.4 represens he resuls of he PF es and he runs es of univariae and mulivariae models for he hypoheical porfolio, which are reproduced from Table 6. and Table 6.3. In he lef ail, he EQMA model was rejeced wih boh he PF es and he runs es a a 99% confidence level. The oher models excep he EWMA model and he EQMA model were no rejeced wih he PF es, bu were rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. Only EWMA model was no rejeced wih boh he PF es and he runs es in he lef ail. In he righ ail, he EQMA model, he EWMA model, and he GARCH models were rejeced wih he PF es a a 99% confidence level hough hese models were no rejeced wih he runs es a a 99% confidence level. The HS model and wo mulivariae models were no rejeced wih boh ess a a 99% confidence level. Overall, in he righ ail he HS model and wo mulivariae models were no rejeced wih boh ess a a 99% confidence level. If we consider boh lef and righ ail a he same ime, all models could be rejeced wih he PF es or wih he runs es. The EWMA model could be rejeced wih he PF es in he righ ail hough ha model was no rejeced wih boh ess in he lef ail. On he oher hand, he HS model and wo mulivariae models were no rejeced wih boh ess in he righ ail, bu could be rejeced wih he runs es in he lef ail. So, we could rejec all models considered in his hesis wih he PF es or wih he runs es in he lef or righ ail, which means ha no univariae and mulivariae models are appropriae o evaluae VaR of he hypoheical porfolio for boh ails. 43
54 Table 6.4: Resul of he PF es and Runs es of Univariae and Mulivariae Models for he Hypoheical Porfolio * Resuls are reproduced from Table 6. and Table 6.3 Tail Model Name Excepions PF Tes Runs Tes Fsaisics pvalue z saisics pvalue Equally weighed(eqma) a Exponenially weighed(ewma)* b Univariae model GARCH (Normal Dis.) Lef GARCH ( Dis.) Mulivariae model Univariae model Hisorical Simulaion DCC OGARCH Equally weighed(eqma) Exponenially weighed(ewma) GARCH (Normal Dis.) Righ GARCH ( Dis.) Mulivariae model Hisorical Simulaion* DCC* OGARCH* a Bold means we can rejec he null hypohesis in each es a a 99% confidence inerval. b Aserisk means model was no rejeced wih boh ess a he same ime a a 99% confidence level. 44
55 We noe ha wo mulivariae models were no rejeced in boh ails if we consider only PF es, which means ha he way he DCC model and he OGARCH model incorporae he condiional correlaion movemens of he individual socks as well as he condiional variance can improve a leas he uncondiional propery of models compared wih he way of parameric univariae models such as he EWMA model and he univariae GARCH models. Since he inernaional sandard, Basel Accord, in he banking indusry considers only uncondiional coverage propery in is risk managemen regulaory mandaes, wo mulivariae models could be useful in ha applicaion. In addiion, we would like o discuss he paern of excepions of he PF es resul using he DCC model, he OGARCH model, and he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion. Figure 6. compares binomial sequences of excepions occurring in rolling backesing of he VaR esimaes using he GARCH model wih a normal disribuion and he DCC model. Figure 6.3 shows he same hing in he case of he OGARCH model insead of he DCC model. In he sem diagrams of figure 6. and 6.3, means ha excepion occurs a ha poin. In boh figures, he average correlaion is calculaed using he DCC model. The circle means ha excepion occurs a ha poin in ha ail and ha model, bu excepion does no occur in he same ail in he oher model. In figure 6., he overall paerns of excepions resuling from he DCC model look ineresing; more excepions occur when correlaion increases. However, in he case of GARCH model wih a normal disribuion, more excepions occur when correlaion decreases. The VaR esimae using he DCC model is above he VaR esimae using he GARCH model when correlaion decreases. On he oher hand, when correlaion increases, he siuaion is reversed; he VaR esimae using he GARCH model is above 45
56 he VaR esimae using he DCC model, which means ha he change of he VaR esimaion using he DCC model is smaller han he change of he VaR esimaion using he GARCH model when correlaion changes. In Table 6.5, he VaR esimae using he DCC model has he leas sandard deviaion among hree models. The reason is ha as you can see in he specificaion of he DCC model in equaion (7), he DCC model uses he GARCH specificaion in modeling he condiional correlaion, which resuls in he long memory of correlaion or slow response o he change of correlaion. Table 6.5: Mean and Sandard Deviaion of he VaR esimaes Variables GARCH(Normal) DCC model OGARCH model Mean Sandard Deviaion As a resul, we noe ha he performance improvemen of DCC models relaive o univariae models occurs in he period when correlaion decreases, which is he opposie observaion we expec; in fac, we expeced ha he performance improvemen would occur when correlaion increased. Comparing he OGARCH model wih he univariae GARCH model, our calculaion resul indicaes ha he VaR esimaes using he OGARCH model seem more sensiive o marke caasrophic even or marke risk because only he seveneenh (backesing rial 303 in figure 6.3) ou of he bigges hiry VaR esimaes using he 46
57 univariae GARCH model is greaer han he VaR esimaes using he OGARCH model on he same day. However, in figure 6.3 he occurrence paern of excepion resuling from he OGARCH model is no much differen from he occurrence paern of excepion resuling from he GARCH model in caasrophic evens (around backesing rials 000 hrough 3000) Compared wih he DCC model wih respec o correlaion, he OGARCH model seems o have shorer memory han he DCC model. The early backesing horizon of he VaR esimae using OGARCH model in figure 6.3 seems o remember he pas big correlaion caused by he Black Monday sock crash, which you can check in figure 6.0. So, in ha horizon he VaR esimae using he OGARCH model is greaer han he VaR esimae using he univariae GARCH model. However, afer ha period, he OGARCH model looks more ap o respond o he change of correlaion, even more han he univariae GARCH model. As a resul, all univariae models and mulivariae models were rejeced wih he PF es or wih he runs es in he lef or righ ail. However, if we consider only he PF es, which is more imporan han he runs es wih respec o real applicaion, he mulivariae models, he DCC models and he OGARCH model, were no rejeced in boh ails. We noe ha he performance improvemen of DCC models relaive o univariae models wih respec o he PF es occurred when correlaion decreased. The performance improvemen of OGARCH model also occurred when correlaion decreased, bu overall VaR esimaes using OGARCH model were greaer han he VaR esimae using he univariae GARCH model when correlaion increased. 47
58 48 Figure 6.: Excepion Occurrence of DCC and GARCH (Normal) 48
59 49 Figure 6.3: Excepion Occurrence of OGARCH and GARCH (Normal) 49
The ttest. What We Will Cover in This Section. A Research Situation
The es 1//008 P331 ess 1 Wha We Will Cover in This Secion Inroducion Onesample es. Power and effec size. Independen samples es. Dependen samples es. Key learning poins. 1//008 P331 ess A Research
More informationMorningstar Investor Return
Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper March 3, 2009 2009 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion by
More informationStock Return Expectations in the Credit Market
Sock Reurn Expecaions in he Credi Marke Hans Bysröm * Sepember 016 In his paper we compue longerm sock reurn expecaions (across he business cycle) for individual firms using informaion backed ou from
More informationKEY CONCEPTS AND PROCESS SKILLS. 1. An allele is one of the two or more forms of a gene present in a population. MATERIALS AND ADVANCE PREPARATION
Gene Squares 61 40 o 2 3 50minue sessions ACIVIY OVERVIEW P R O B L E M S O LV I N G SUMMARY Sudens use Punne squares o predic he approximae frequencies of rais among he offspring of specific crier crosses.
More informationEconomics 487. Homework #4 Solution Key Portfolio Calculations and the Markowitz Algorithm
Economics 87 Homework # Soluion Key Porfolio Calculaions and he Markowiz Algorihm A. Excel Exercises: (10 poins) 1. Download he Excel file hw.xls from he class websie. This file conains monhly closing
More informationRolling ADF Tests: Detecting Rational Bubbles in Greater China Stock Markets
Singapore Managemen Universiy Insiuional Knowledge a Singapore Managemen Universiy Disseraions and Theses Collecion (Open Access) Disseraions and Theses 2008 Rolling ADF Tess: Deecing Raional Bubbles in
More informationQUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE. Optimal Time Series Momentum QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE
QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE Research Paper 353 January 15 Opimal Time Series Momenum XueZhong He, Kai Li and Youwei
More informationINSTRUCTIONS FOR USE. This file can only be used to produce a handout master:
INSTRUCTIONS OR USE This file can only be used o produce a handou maser: Use Prin from he ile menu o make a prinou of he es. You may no modify he conens of his file. IMPORTNT NOTICE: You may prin his es
More informationAn Alternative Mathematical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluation in Clean Water
An Alernaive Mahemaical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluaion in Clean Waer Yanjun (John) He 1, PE, BCEE 1 Kruger Inc., 41 Weson Parkway, Cary, NC 27513 Email: john.he@veolia.com ABSTRACT Energy consumpion
More informationSources of OverPerformance in Equity Markets: Mean Reversion, Common Trends and Herding
The Universiy of Reading THE BUSINESS SCHOOL FOR FINANCIAL MARKETS Sources of OverPerformance in Equiy Markes: Mean Reversion, Common Trends and Herding ISMA Cenre Discussion Papers in Finance 200308
More informationMarket timing and statistical arbitrage: Which market timing opportunities arise from equity price busts coinciding with recessions?
Journal of Applied Finance & Banking, vol.1, no.1, 2011, 5381 ISSN: 17926580 (prin version), 17926599 (online) Inernaional Scienific Press, 2011 Marke iming and saisical arbirage: Which marke iming
More informationWhat the Puck? an exploration of TwoDimensional collisions
Wha he Puck? an exploraion of TwoDimensional collisions 1) Have you ever played 8Ball pool and los he game because you scrached while aemping o sink he 8Ball in a corner pocke? Skech he sho below: Each
More informationBetting Against Beta
Being Agains Bea Andrea Frazzini and Lasse H. Pedersen * This draf: Ocober 5, 2010 Absrac. We presen a model in which some invesors are prohibied from using leverage and oher invesors leverage is limied
More informationDYNAMIC portfolio optimization is one of the important
, July 24, 2014, London, U.K. A Simulaionbased Porfolio Opimizaion Approach wih Leas Squares Learning Chenming Bao, Geoffrey Lee, and Zili Zhu Absrac This paper inroduces a simulaionbased numerical
More informationDynamics of market correlations: Taxonomy and portfolio analysis
Dynamics of marke correlaions: Taxonomy and porfolio analysis J.P. Onnela, A. Chakrabori, and K. Kaski Laboraory of Compuaional Engineering, Helsinki Universiy of Technology, P.O. Box 9203, FIN02015
More informationMULTIVARIATE RISKRETURN DECISION MAKING WITHIN DYNAMIC ESTIMATION
Economic Analysis Working Papers. 7h Volume Number 11 MULIVARIAE RISKREURN DECISION MAKING WIHIN DYNAMIC ESIMAION Josip Arnerić 1, Elza Jurun, and Snježana Pivac, 3 Universiy of Spli, Faculy of Economics,
More informationKINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION
chaper KINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION Secion 2.1 Displacemen Secion 2.2 Speed and Velociy 1. A paricle ravels along a curved pah beween wo poins P and Q as shown. The displacemen of he paricle does no depend
More informationITG Dynamic Daily Risk Model for Europe
December 2010 Version 1 ITG Dynamic Daily Risk Model for Europe 2010 All righs reserved. No o be reproduced or reransmied wihou permission. 121610 29140 These maerials are for informaional purposes only,
More informationTime & Distance SAKSHI If an object travels the same distance (D) with two different speeds S 1 taking different times t 1
www.sakshieducaion.com Time & isance The raio beween disance () ravelled by an objec and he ime () aken by ha o ravel he disance is called he speed (S) of he objec. S = = S = Generally if he disance ()
More informationPerformance Attribution for Equity Portfolios
PERFORMACE ATTRIBUTIO FOR EQUITY PORTFOLIOS Performance Aribuion for Equiy Porfolios Yang Lu and David Kane Inroducion Many porfolio managers measure performance wih reference o a benchmark. The difference
More informationMethods for Estimating Term Structure of Interest Rates
Mehods for Esimaing Term Srucure of Ineres Raes Iskander Karibzhanov Absrac This paper compares differen inerpolaion algorihms for consrucing yield curves: cubic splines, linear and quadraic programming,
More informationCentre for Investment Research Discussion Paper Series. Momentum Profits and TimeVarying Unsystematic Risk
Cenre for Invesmen Research Discussion Paper Series Discussion Paper # 080* Momenum Profis and TimeVarying Unsysemaic Risk Cenre for Invesmen Research O'Rahilly Building, Room 3.0 Universiy College Cork
More informationWHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY
Proceedings of he 2010 Join Rail Conference JRC2010 April 2729, 2010, Urbana, Illinois, USA JRC201036236 WHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY Zhenhua Chen The
More informationScienceDirect. Cycling Power Optimization System Using Link Models of Lower Limbs with CleatShaped Biaxial Load Cells
Available online a www.sciencedirec.com ScienceDirec Procedia Engineering 72 ( 20 ) 8 7 The 20 conference of he Inernaional Spors Engineering Associaion Cycling Power Opimizaion Sysem Using ink Models
More informationMachine Learning for Stock Selection
Machine Learning for Sock Selecion Rober J. Yan Compuer Science Dep., The Uniersiy of Wesern Onario jyan@csd.uwo.ca Charles X. Ling Compuer Science Dep., The Uniersiy of Wesern Onario cling@csd.uwo.ca
More informationRealtime Stochastic Evacuation Models for Decision Support in Actual Emergencies
Realime Sochasic Evacuaion Models for Decision Suppor in Acual Emergencies ARTURO CUESTA, DANIEL ALVEAR, ORLANDO ABREU and DELFÍN SILIÓ Transpors and echnology projecs and processes Universiy of Canabria
More informationGuidance Statement on Calculation Methodology
Guidance Saemen on Calculaion Mehodology Adopion Dae: 28 Sepember 200 Effecive Dae: January 20 Reroacive Applicaion: No Required www.gipssandards.org 200 CFA Insiue Guidance Saemen on Calculaion Mehodology
More informationReexamining SportsSentiment Hypothesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Istanbul
Reexamining SporsSenimen Hypohesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Isanbul Ka Wai Terence Fung +, Ender Demir, Chi Keung Marco Lau And Kwok Ho Chan * Absrac This paper examines he impac of inernaional
More informationFIVE RISK FACTORS MODEL: PRICING SECTORAL PORTFOLIOS IN THE BRAZILIAN STOCK MARKET
Revisa Caarinense da Ciência Conábil, ISSN 18083781  eissn 22377662, Florianópolis, SC, Brazil, v. 16, n. 48, p. 8198, May/Aug. 2017 doi: 10.16930/22377662/rccc.v16n48.2376 Available a hp://revisa.crcsc.org.br
More informationMeasuring Potential Output and Output Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya
Universiy of Connecicu DigialCommons@UConn Economics Working Papers Deparmen of Economics Ocober 2005 Measuring Poenial Oupu and Oupu Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya Angelica E. Njuguna
More informationOverreaction and Underreaction :  Evidence for the Portuguese Stock Market 
Overreacion and Underreacion :  Evidence for he Poruguese Sock Marke  João Vasco Soares* and Ana Paula Serra** March 2005 * Faculdade de Economia da Universidade do Poro ** (corresponding auhor) CEMPRE,
More informationTHE PERSISTENCY OF INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION BENEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL
ASIA ACADEMY of MAAGEMET JOURAL of ACCOUTIG and FIACE AAMJAF, Vol. 10, o. 1, 151 165, 014 THE PERSISTECY OF ITERATIOAL DIVERSIFICATIO BEEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL Ung Sze ie 1*,
More informationFORECASTING TECHNIQUES ADE 2013 Prof Antoni Espasa TOPIC 1 PART 2 TRENDS AND ACCUMULATION OF KNOWLEDGE. SEASONALITY HANDOUT
FORECASTING TECHNIQUES ADE 2013 Prof Anoni Espasa TOPIC 1 PART 2 TRENDS AND ACCUMULATION OF KNOWLEDGE. SEASONALITY HANDOUT February 2013 MAIN FACTORS CAUSING TRENDS Increases in populaion. Seady inflaion.
More informationAsset and Liability Management, Caisse. a manager of public debt
Asse and Liabiliy Managemen by CADES, a manager of public deb Name Deparmen & affiliaion Mailing Address email address(es) Phone number 331 55 78 58 19, 331 55 78 58 00 Fax number 331 55 78 58 02 Eric
More informationProceedings of the ASME 28th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering OMAE2009 May 31  June 5, 2009, Honolulu, Hawaii
Proceedings of he ASME 28h Inernaional Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arcic Engineering OMAE29 May 31  June 5, 29, Honolulu, Hawaii OMAE2979385 ANALYSIS OF THE TUNNEL IMMERSION FOR THE BUSANGEOJE
More informationSmart Beta Multifactor Construction Methodology: Mixing versus Integrating
THE JOURNAL OF SPRING 2018 VOLUME 8 NUMBER 4 JII.IIJOURNALS.com ETFs, ETPs & Indexing Smar Bea Mulifacor Consrucion Mehodology: Mixing versus Inegraing TZEEMAN CHOW, FEIFEI LI, AND YOSEOP SHIM Smar Bea
More informationSIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE
1 h Inernaional Conference on Sabiliy of Ships and Ocean Vehicles 591 SIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE Qiuxin Gao, Universiy of Srahclyde, UK, Gao.q.x@srah.ac.uk Dracos Vassalos,
More informationEconomic Growth with Bubbles
Economic Growh wih Bubbles AlberoMarin,andJaumeVenura March 2010 Absrac We develop a sylized model of economic growh wih bubbles. In his model, financial fricions lead o equilibrium dispersion in he raes
More informationName Class Date. Step 2: Rearrange the acceleration equation to solve for final speed. a v final v initial v. final v initial v.
Skills Workshee Mah Skills Acceleraion Afer you sudy each sample problem and soluion, work ou he pracice problems on a separae shee of paper. Wrie your answers in he spaces provided. In 1970, Don Big Daddy
More informationWhat is a Practical (ASTM C 618) SAIStrength Activity Index for Fly Ashes that can be used to Proportion Concretes Containing Fly Ash?
2017 World of Coal Ash (WOCA) Conference in Lexingon, KY  May 911, 2017 hp://www.flyash.info/ Wha is a Pracical (ASTM C 618) SAISrengh Aciviy Index for Fly Ashes ha can be used o Proporion Concrees
More informationCHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS
CHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS Osama. OLABY, Xavier. BRN, Sylvie. SESMAT, Tanneguy. REDARCE and Eric. BIDEAX Laboraoire d Auomaique Indusrielle  hp://wwwlai.insalyon.fr
More informationMaking Sense of Genetics Problems
Bio 101 Ms. Bledsoe Making Sense of Geneics roblems Monohbrid crosses Le s sar wih somehing simle: crossing wo organisms and waching how one single rai comes ou in he offsring. Le s use eas, as Mendel
More informationA Statistical, AgeStructured, LifeHistoryBased Stock Assessment Model for Anadromous Alosa
American Fisheries Sociey Symposium 35:275 283, 2003 2003 by he American Fisheries Sociey A Saisical, AgeSrucured, LifeHisoryBased Sock Assessmen Model for Anadromous Alosa A. JAMIE F. GIBSON 1 Acadia
More informationThe safe ships trajectory in a restricted area
Scienific Journals Mariime Universiy of Szczecin Zeszyy Naukowe Akademia Morska w Szczecinie 214, 39(111) pp. 122 127 214, 39(111) s. 122 127 ISSN 1733867 The safe ships rajecory in a resriced area Zbigniew
More informationFlow Switch LABOVHZS
Flow Swich S Volumeric flow swiching Almos no effec from differing viscosiies Versaile, configurable swiching oupu in pushpull design Robus consrucion Compac design Characerisics he VHZ gearwheel flow
More informationThe Trade Performance Index. Technical notes. May Market Analysis Section International Trade Center (ITC) Geneva, Switzerland
The Trade Performance Index Technical noes May 27 Mare Analysis Secion Inernaional Trade Cener (ITC) Geneva, Swizerland 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Trade Performance Index has been developed a ITC s Mare Analysis
More informationUrban public transport optimization by bus ways: a neural networkbased methodology
Urban Transpor XIII: Urban Transpor and he Environmen in he 21s Cenury 347 Urban public ranspor opimizaion by bus ways: a neural neworkbased mehodology M. Migliore & M. Caalano Deparmen of Transporaion
More informationBreeding Incentive Programs and Demand for California Thoroughbred Racing: The Tradeoff Between Quantity and Quality. Martin D.
Breeding Incenive Programs and Demand for California horoughbred Racing: he radeoff Beween Quaniy and Qualiy by Marin D. Smih Deparmen of Agriculural and Resource Economics Universiy of California, Davis
More informationInstruction Manual. Rugged PCB type. 1 Terminal Block. 2 Function. 3 Series Operation and Parallel Operation. 4 Assembling and Installation Method
Rugged PCB ype Insrucion Manual 1 Terminal Block Funcion.1...4.5.6.7 Inpu volage range Inrush curren limiing Overcurren proecion Overvolage proecion Oupu volage adjusmen range Isolaion Remoe ON/OFF E9
More informationLSU RISK ASSESSMENT FORM Please read How to Complete a Risk Assessment before completion
Please read How o Complee a Risk Assessmen before compleion EVENT OR ACTIVITY BEING RISK ASSESSED (add name of even where relevan) NAME OF DEPARTMENT Squad Training Neball DATE OF COMPLETION OF RISK ASSESSMENT
More informationZelio Control Measurement Relays RM4L Liquid Level Relays
Zelio Conrol Measuremen elays FNCTIONS These devices monior he levels of conducive liquids. They conrol he acuaion of pumps or valves o regulae levels; hey are also suiable for proecing submersible pumps
More informationManaging the abundance of bison in Yellowstone National Park, winter Chris Geremia, P. J. White, and Rick Wallen September 12, 2011
Managing he abundance of bison in Yellowsone Naional Park winer 2012 Chris Geremia P. J. Whie and Rick Wallen Sepember 12 2011 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Background Yellowsone Naional Park (YNP) developed a plan
More informationEXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELYSPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES
EXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELYSPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES Seven J. Landry and Amy R. Priche Georgia Insiue of Technology Alana GA 303320205 ABSTRACT Paired closelyspaced parallel approaches
More informationOn convexity of SD efficiency sets  no short sales case
4. mezinárodní konference Řízení a modelování finančních rizik Osrava VŠBU Osrava Ekonomická fakula kaedra Financí.. září 008 On conveiy of SD efficiency ses  no shor sales case Miloš Kopa Absrac his
More informationDual Boost High Performances Power Factor Correction (PFC)
Dual Boos High Performances Power Facor Correcion (PFC) C. Aaianese, Senior Member, IEEE  V. Nardi, Member, IEEE  F. Parillo  G. Tomasso, Member, IEEE Deparmen of Auomaion, Elecromagneism, Compuer Science
More informationA Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Details and Extended Results
WORKING PAPER 200603 Resource Economics and Policy Analysis (REPA) Research Group Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Vicoria A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Deails and Exended Resuls G. Cornelis
More informationIs the Decline in the Frequency of Draws in Test Match Cricket Detrimental to the Long Form of the Game? # Liam J. A. Lenten *
Is he Decline in he Frequency of Draws in Tes Mach Cricke Derimenal o he Long Form of he Game? # Liam J. A. Lenen * Deparmen of Economics and Finance La Trobe Universiy Absrac The frequency of draws in
More informationDevelopment of Urban Public Transit Network Structure Integrating MultiClass Public Transit Lines and Transfer Hubs
Developmen of Urban Public Transi Nework Srucure Inegraing MuliClass Public Transi Lines and Transfer Hubs Zhenbao Wang 1, Anyan Chen 2 1College of Civil Engineering, Hebei Universiy of Engineering Handan,
More informationPaul R. Drake Management School, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK
The curren issue and full ex archive of his journal is available a www.emeraldinsigh.com/09600035.hm Analysis of he bullwhip effec wih order baching in muliechelon supply chains Maloub Hussain College
More informationCOIN th JRC Annual Training on Composite Indicators and MCDA 2226/09/2014, Ispra IT. Dorota WeziakBialowolska.
Doroa WeziakBialowolska 1h JRC Annual Training on Comosie ndiaors and MCDA Doroa WeziakBialowolska 1h JRC Annual Training on Comosie ndiaors and MCDA Normalizaion vs. denominaion 1 h JRC Annual Training
More informationCONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS
CONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS keninrol CONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS CONTROL VALVES IN TURBOCOMPRESSOR ANTISURGE SYSTEMS 0 KOSO KENT INTROL SUPPLIES A
More information2nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transport Technology For Regional Competitiveness
nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transpor Technology For Regional Compeiiveness SESSION C TBLE OF CONTENTS PREFCE... 4 ORGNISING COITTEE... 5 KEYNOTE DDRESS... 6 Session : UTOOTIE... 7 Session B : ERONUTICS...
More informationRECOMMENDATION FOR INTERCHANGEABLE STUD BOLTS AND TAP END STUDS FOR API SPEC 6A FLANGES
Issue Dae: June 6 15 Revision B June 2010 RECOMMENDAION FOR INERCHANGEABE UD BO AND A END UD FOR AI EC 6A FANGE ECHNICA REOR R501 Revision B AWHEM publicaions may be use by anyone esiring o o so. Every
More informationWORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI st CENTURY
CEPREMAP WORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI s CENTURY A prospecive analysis wih he INGENUE 2 model by he INGENUE TEAM Michel AGLIETTA and Vladimir BORGY (Cepii), Jean CHATEAU (Ocde),
More informationCoefficients of Propellerhull Interaction in Propulsion System of Inland Waterway Vessels with Stern Tunnels
hp://www.ransnav.eu he Inernaional Journal on Marine Navigaion and Safey of Sea Transporaion Volume 8 Number 3 Sepember 214 DOI: 1.12716/11.8.3.8 Coefficiens of Propellerhull Ineracion in Propulsion Sysem
More informationAN ANALYSIS OF THE ECONOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY
AN ANALYSIS OF THE ECOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY MARCH 2014 This repor was produced a he reques of he Ron Sco, Ciy Manager for Danville, Kenucky, under he supervision
More informationWorld War 2 when Japan
Chaper 30 Reading Guide Chaper 30 Reading Guide A Second Global Conflic and he End of he European World Order A Second Global Conflic and he End of he European World Order Name: Name: Name: Due Dae: Wednesday,
More informationPopulation size and exploitation of giant squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 1835) in the Gulf of California, Mexico*
SCI. AR., 65 (): 758 SCIENIA ARINA 2 Populaion size and exploiaion of gian squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 835) in he Gulf of California, exico* ENRIQUE ORALESBOJÓRQUEZ, AGUSÍN HERNÁNDEZHERRERA 2,
More informationI t ' 4 ti. t ti. IQ:::: mass x heat of fusion (or heat of vaporization) I HEAT AND ITS MEASUREMENT. t t. t f I I I. Name
HEAT AND TS MEASUREMENT Name a (or energy) can be measured in unis of calories or joules. When here is a,,,,,,nperaure change (AT), hea (Q) can be calculaed using his formula: During a phase change, we
More informationEFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY
EFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY S. Faulsich 1, P. Lyding 1, P. J. Tavner 2 1 Fraunhofer Insiue for Wind Energy and Energy Sysem Technology (IWES) 2 Energy Group, School of Engineering,
More informationSensors and Actuators A: Physical
Sensors and Acuaors A 144 (2008) 354 360 Conens liss available a ScienceDirec Sensors and Acuaors A: Physical journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locae/sna A microrobo fish wih embedded SMA wire acuaed
More informationGenetic Mapping Exercise  Extra Credit. Do not work together  each person to do their own work.
Geneic Mapping Execise  Exa Cedi Name Secion # Do no ok ogehe  each peson o do hei on ok. hen loci of diffeen allelic goups ae on he same chomosome, linkage occus bu is no absolue. Cossingove alays
More informationClemco Industries Corp. ISO 9001 Certified
Clemco Indusries Corp. ISO 9001 Cerified 6 cuf Classic Blas Machines Exclusively from... SIMPLE, RUGGED, RELIABLE More han 75 years of reliable field service have made Clemco blas machines he preferred
More informationINSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL
IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUCTIONS SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLEASE READ THE ENTIRE CONTENTS OF THIS MANUAL PRIOR TO INSTALLATION AND OPERATION. BY PROCEEDING WITH LIFT INSTALLATION AND OPERATION YOU AGREE THAT
More information29 B ROUTE Bus Times Summer NOTES a = Time at Vicarage Way. * = On Schooldays bus operates up to 5 minutes later.
Brighon Lewes Ringmer / Touris Aracions Lewes for Hisoric own wih Casle; Isfield for Lavender Line Railway; for Spa Valley Railway, Paniles CiySAVER ickes are only valid beween Brighon and Falmer. nework
More informationImprovement of individual camouflage through background choice in groundnesting birds
This is he preproof acceped version of he manuscrip, he full version can be accessed for free here. Improvemen of individual camouflage hrough background choice in groundnesing birds Auhors: Marin Sevens*1,
More informationUS 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 US009615553B2 (12) Unied Saes Paen Coniglio e al. (10) Paen No.: (45) Dae of Paen: US 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017 (54) ARTIFICIAL
More informationconnection Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod technology with specialist manufacturers from around the world
Making he connecion Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod echnology wih specialis manufacurers from around he world Making he connecion necessary beween he op end and he boom end of he racing engine
More informationOriginal Article. Physiological characteristics and physical fitness of girls at the beginning of classes at the volleyball sports school
Journal of Physical Educaion and Spor (JPES), 17(4), Ar 276, pp. 24672471, 2017 online ISSN: 2247806X; pissn: 2247 8051; ISSN  L = 22478051 JPES Original Aricle Physiological characerisics and physical
More informationR410A Rotary Compressor Bearing Design Considerations
Prde Universiy Prde epbs Inernaional Compressor Engineering Conference School of Mechanical Engineering 1998 R41A Roary Compressor Bearing Design Consideraions J. R. Lenz Tecmseh Prodcs Company Follow
More informationCOMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS USING CORRECTED INITIAL VELOCITY DURING OVERHEAD SMASH
Journal of Engineering Science and Technolog Special Issue on AASEC 6, Ocober (7) 95 School of Engineering, Talor s Uniersi COMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS
More informationA Simple Approach to Dynamic Material Balance in GasCondensate Reservoirs
Oil & Gas Science and Technology Rev. IFP Energies nouvelles, Copyrigh 23, IFP Energies nouvelles DOI:.256/ogs/2222 Vol. 69 (24), No. 2, pp. 3737 A Siple Approach o Dynaic Maerial Balance in GasCondensae
More informationOPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLYFRIENDLY GOKART
Journal of Ecological Engineering Volume 17, Issue 5, Nov. 016, pages 90 95 DOI: 10.1911/998993/65454 Research Aricle OPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLYFRIENDLY GOKART Pior Zbigniew Filip 1,
More informationCal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P.
Cal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P. 123) (147 ) You are now he proud owner of a SEIKO Analogue Quarz Wach
More informationDIN, EN, ASTM. Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам. Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту ASME 16.48
Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам DIN, EN, STM Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту SME 16.48 Для заказа металлопроката или получения консультации обращайтесь по следующим контактам: Россия: +7 (495)
More informationHenry Kendall College Team (FIRST TEAM)
Henry Kendall College 1895 Team (FIRST TEAM) TULSA GOLDEN Hurricane fooball Tulsa s Fooball 1895: The Legacy Begins The legacy of Tulsa fooball began when he Bacone School for Indians and Henry Kendall
More informationMinistry of Agriculture and Rural Development Animal and Plant Health Regulatory Directorate
Minisry of Agriculure and Rural Developmen Animal and Plan Healh Regulaory Direcorae Checklis for saus of slaugherhouses for cale, sheep and goas (General informaion) i Addis Ababa Ehiopia 1 1. Background
More informationAn Autonomous Blimp for the Wall Following Control.
An Auonomous Blimp for he Wall Following Conrol. SeungYong Oh *,**, Chi Won Roh *, Sung Chul Kang *, Eunai Kim ** * Inelligen Roboics Research Cener, Korea Insiue of Science an echnology, Seoul, Korea
More informationVERTICAL DOUBLE TEAM TECHNIQUE ON POWER / COUNTER ( DUECE / TREY )
VERICAL DOUBLE EA ECHNIQUE ON POER / COUNER ( DUECE / REY ) COACHING POIN: GE HIP O HIP IH KNEES ORKING NORH & SOUH; 4 HANDS ON DL & 4 EYES ON LBer. I. POS (INSIDE BLOCKER): GAIN VERICAL LEVERAGE (YOUR
More informationWorld gold prices and stock returns in China: insights for hedging and diversification strategies
World old price and ock reurn in Cina: ini for edin and diverificaion raeie Moamed El Hedi Arouri, Amine Laiani, Duc Kuon Nuyen To cie i verion: Moamed El Hedi Arouri, Amine Laiani, Duc Kuon Nuyen. World
More informationOptimal Staged SelfAssembly of General Shapes
Opimal Saged SelAssemly o General Shapes Cameron Chalk, Eric Marinez, Roer Schweller 3, Luis Vega 4, Andrew Winslow 5, and im Wylie 6 Deparmen o Compuer Science, Universiy o eas Rio Grande Valley, Brownsville,
More informationINSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL
EUROPEN USERS 400V 0Hz SUPPLY DETILS RE IN CLUDED WITH ELECTRICL CONTROL BOX. DISREGRD SUPPLY WIRING DETILS IN THIS MNUL IMPORTNT SFETY INSTRUCTIONS SVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLESE RED THE ENTIRE CONTENTS
More informationArchitectural PORTFOLIO CALL FOR ENTRIES SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM. Presented by. See back page for photo credits.
rchiecural PORTFOLIO T H I R T Y  F I F T H N N U L 2017 CLL FOR ENTRIES See back page for phoo credis. Presened by SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM Receive naional acclaim for YOUR EDUCTION DESIGN PROJECTS WWW.SUMG.COM
More informationINVERTER HEATPUMP FOR SWIMMING POOLS
IVE HEATPUMP FO SWIMMIG POOS Insallaion & Insrucion Manual hea pumps 000711611 Table of conens 1. Preface 3. Specificaions.1 Performance Daa. Dimensions 6 3. Insallaion and Connecion 3.1 Hea Pump ocaion
More informationSWIMMING POOL HEAT PUMP UNITS. Installation & Instruction Manual DURA  series
SWIMMIG POO HEAT PUMP UITS Insallaion & Insrucion Manual DUA  series ev. 1.12 29.07.2014 Conens SWIMMIG POO HEAT PUMP UITS... 1! Conens... 2! 1. Preface... 3! 2. Specificaions... 4! 2.1 Technical daa
More informationDetermination of the Design Load for Structural Safety Assessment against Gas Explosion in Offshore Topside
Determination of the Design Load for Structural Safety Assessment against Gas Explosion in Offshore Topside Migyeong Kim a, Gyusung Kim a, *, Jongjin Jung a and Wooseung Sim a a Advanced Technology Institute,
More informationDIMENSIONS AC Road travel
DIMENSIONS AC 10009 Road ravel 04 DIMENSIONS AC 10009 Lifing operaion OUTRIGGER BASES TO CHOOSE FROM: A 13.54m x 13.538m B 12.0m x 12.0m (NEW) C 9.671m x 9.885m 05 HA /SSL (HA50) AC 10009 AC 10009 17 HA
More informationCentrifugal Fans belt driven. TD_CFBADY_EN Issue 1.1 EN July 2013 ADY
enrifugal ans bel driven TD_DY_N Issue 1.1 N July 013 DY 1 Nicora ebhard S.p.. cerifi es ha he fan shon herein is licensed o bear he Seal. The raings shon are based on ess and procedures performed in
More informationAverages. October 19, Discussion item: When we talk about an average, what exactly do we mean? When are they useful?
Averages October 19, 2005 Discussion item: When we talk about an average, what exactly do we mean? When are they useful? 1 The Arithmetic Mean When we talk about an average, we can mean different things
More informationVOLLEYBALL Match players ranking. KOR Korea
FIVB Men's Volleyball World Championship 20 Match: 31 Date: 05.09.20 Spectators: 1'000 Match duration: Start: 13:10 End: 15:13 : 2:03 Teams Sets 1 2 3 4 5 CUB 3 Set duration 0: 0:29 0: 0:31 1:47 Spike
More information