Citation for final published version: Publishers page:

Save this PDF as:
 WORD  PNG  TXT  JPG

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Citation for final published version: Publishers page: "

Transcription

1 This is an Open Access documen downloaded from ORCA, Cardiff Universiy's insiuional reposiory: hp://orca.cf.ac.uk/38772/ This is he auhor s version of a work ha was submied o / acceped for publicaion. Ciaion for final published version: Disney, Sephen Michael and Towill, Denis Royson Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain. Inernaional Journal of Operaions & Producion Managemen 23 (6), pp / file Publishers page: hp://dx.doi.org/ / <hp://dx.doi.org/ / > Please noe: Changes made as a resul of publishing processes such as copy-ediing, formaing and page numbers may no be refleced in his version. For he definiive version of his publicaion, please refer o he published source. You are advised o consul he publisher s version if you wish o cie his paper. This version is being made available in accordance wih publisher policies. See hp://orca.cf.ac.uk/policies.hml for usage policies. Copyrigh and moral righs for publicaions made available in ORCA are reained by he copyrigh holders.

2 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Vendor Managed Invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo level supply chain S.M. Disney and D.R. Towill Logisics Sysems Dynamics Group, Cardiff Business School, Cardiff Universiy, Aberconway Building, Colum Drive, Cardiff, CF10 3EU, UK. Tel: +44(0) , Fax: +44(0) Absrac This paper compares he bullwhip properies of a Vendor Managed Invenory (VMI) supply chain wih hose of a radiional serially-linked supply chain. The emphasis of his invesigaion is he comparaive impac he wo srucures have on he Bullwhip Effec generaed. Paricular aenion is paid o he manufacurer s producion ordering aciviies as demonsraed using a simulaion model based on difference equaions. Each of he four imporan sources of he Bullwhip Effec is documened and considered in urn. The analysis shows ha wih VMI implemenaion wo sources of he Bullwhip Effec may be compleely eliminaed, i.e. raioning and gaming or he Houlihan Effec, and he order baching effec or he Burbidge Effec. VMI is also significanly beer a responding o rogue changes in demand due o he Promoion Effec or o price induced variaions. However he effec of VMI on demand signal processing induced bullwhip or he Forreser Effec is less clear cu. The paper concludes ha on balance VMI offers a significan opporuniy o reduce he Bullwhip Effec in real-world supply chains. Key Words Bullwhip Effec, Vendor Managed Invenory, Supply Chain Dynamics, Producion and Invenory Conrol. 1. Inroducion I is well esablished ha removing an echelon in a supply chain can be of grea benefi in improving dynamic performance (Wikner, Towill and Naim, 1992). This is because here is poenial for a wo-fold improvemen. This is firsly due o eliminaion of delays in boh informaion and maerial flow. Secondly a decision-

3 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / making aciviy ha cusomarily increases disorion in he order waveform as i is flows upsream is eliminaed (Towill and del Vecchio, 1994). VMI is one pracical way of seeking o obain he benefis of echelon eliminaion. Hence he need for a deailed invesigaion using he radiional supply chain as a benchmark o be beered via a suiable design. As Maloni and Benon (1997) have indicaed, here exiss a large amoun of lieraure on he conceps of supply chain parnerships projecing exremely opimisic views abou heir promise as win-win parnerships wihou any rigorous analysis o suppor he cause of opimism. This paper is a response o he shorfall in research ha adops a more rigorous analyical approach o examine supply chain parnership issues. Performance Meric Order lead ime (days) (from cusomer s order enry o delivery) On Time Deliveries (% of orders delivered on ime) Invenory Turnover Rae Toal Overhead Cos (index) Tradiional Supply Chain (1996) New Supply Chain Sraegy (NMS) (1998) Supply Chain Nework wih PipeChain (2000) % 98% 99.8% Table 1. Impac of he Change Supply Chain Sraegy and Implemenaion of NMS PipeChain Version of VMI a Ericsson Radio Sysems (Source: Gusafsson and Norrman, 2001) I is already known ha when properly implemened, VMI healhily impacs he boom line, for example, as shown in Table 1 (Gusafsson and Norrman, 2001). Noe ha here has been a wo-sage programme of supply chain re-engineering supporing he inroducion of VMI. This is via changed responsibiliy for orders (NMS phase) followed by oal pipeline conrol (Pipechain phase). However here are boh posiive and negaive aspecs of implemening he NMS/Pipechain mode of VMI. These are lised in Table 2, and he downside is a warning o poenial users falsely hinking ha implemenaion is sraighforward and rivial. I is good o see ha benefis are visible

4 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / wihin monhs. Bu in a global BPR Programme, Towill and McCullen (1999) have observed significan improvemens in supply chain performance occurring on a yearby-year basis for some ime afer changeover. Hence o maximise impac i is essenial o ensure ha adequae monioring sysems are in place. These will firsly ensure ha regeneraion o previous working pracices is avoided, and secondly o help ensure ha beneficial learning curve effecs are forhcoming. A. The Upside Main benefis visible shorly afer an implemenaion (monhs) The invesmen pays off shorly (monhs) The cusomers and suppliers in he nework have gained a greaer knowledge and undersanding of each ohers working processes and businesses The sofware ool is fas o implemen (weeks-monh) The users of he sofware ool rely on he sysem and find i logical and process oriened The work load for he people working wih operaive logisics has been less flucuaing B. The Downside Alhough he concep is easy o undersand, acceping he change of working procedures and shif of responsibiliy akes ime Even hough a sandard inerface is used o inegrae he ERP sysems i mus be adaped o he process. This should no be underesimaed, i creaes work and akes ime The sofware ool does no fi cerain businesses (e.g. shor erm relaionships wih suppliers and seldom supply) Table 2. Posiive and Negaive Experiences of Implemening NMS/PipeChain Version of VMI a Ericsson Radio Sysems (Source: Gusafsson and Norrman, 2001) The paricular emphasis of his paper is he relaive impac hese wo supply chain srucures have on he Bullwhip Effec, (Lee, Padmanabhan and Whang, 1997a and b) generaed in he supply chain, which is invesigaed using a simulaion model. Focussing on a one supplier, one cusomer relaionship paricular aenion is given o he manufacurer s producion scheduling aciviies. To achieve his aim, an overview of a radiional supply chain and a VMI supply chain is given. The Bullwhip Effec is hen oulined and he various causes are highlighed. Nex, he wo supply chain

5 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / srucures are compared wih respec o he Bullwhip Effec, wih each source being invesigaed in urn in order o verify he research findings. This gives confidence o he poenial VMI sysem performance benefis via ime-series displays readily idenified by managers as comparaors wih presen day dynamic behaviour. 2. Using Bullwhip o Assess VMI Capabiliy The magniude of he Enerprise Resource Planning (ERP) inerface problem currenly facing he manufacuring indusry is well known in he lieraure (Thaler, 1999). Table 3 liss some of he snags already noed by Lee and Whang (2000). I is clear ha subsanial financial invesmen is required o move forward in his respec. Bu who pays for he new communicaion sysem? Whereas he UK DTI/CBI expecancy of parnering arrangemens was of benefis o be equally shared (Towill and Naim, 1993), presen-day cusomer pressures have ended o negae his aim. For example, Clark and Hammond (1997) infer ha in much VMI experience o dae, cos-benefi analysis is arguably ha he supplier bears he cos of implemenaion, bu he cusomer reaps he benefi. Similar conclusions may be drawn from he sudy by Lamming (2001) on he Japanese supply chain relaionships in recession. He saes ha suppliers canno now rely on reaining business in his new environmen. Insead hey mus work in innovaive ways so as o enable heir cusomers o concenrae on real-ime, marke driven configuraion of producs coupled wih minimum socks in heir supply chains (Lamming, 2001). When implemened properly VMI is clearly a sep in he righ direcion. In a recen seminal paper, Buxey (2001) has argued ha producion sraegy drives he planning process. By having a clear view of wha ha sraegy should be, managemen decisions regarding order fulfilmen, capaciy requiremens, workforcemanning levels (and skills) become simpler and more ransparen. The whole business is hen much more readily aligned wih he producion sraegy. As Buxey poins ou, he sraegy is decided in he knowledge of cusomer requiremens aking boh shor erm and medium erm horizons ino accoun. A careful review of he Case Sudies repored in Buxey (2001) suggess ha generally he producion sraegy seleced is he simples and mos robus capable of saisfying requiremens. I is clear ha VMI has much o offer in his scenario. Working closely wih he end cusomer reduces uncerainy ha in urn enables simpliciy and reliabiliy of operaions.

6 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / POTENTIAL SNAGS MULTIPLE STANDARDS INFLEXIBILITY LIMITED FUNCTION FIXED OPERATING MODE COST DESCRIPTION There are muliple indusry-specific sandards. So a company wih muliple business ineress has o face dealing wih muliple sandards. EDI is designed on a one-size-fis-all basis. I may no mee he exac needs of any paricular supply chain. EDI is primarily designed around ransacion processing. I may no cope wih oher kinds of informaion sharing such as daabases, bar codes, images ec. EDI is bach operaed. I works only in operaional windows. There is a high financial cos and high resource cos o insalling EDI. This discourages small and medium size companies. Table 3. Poenial EDI Implemenaion Snags or Why VMI May No Happen Overnigh (Source: Auhors Based on Lee & Whang, 2000) We have seleced Bullwhip as a measure of performance because i is a ransparen and readily idenifiable meric ha can be used o esablish if a course of acion has been beneficial o he sysem. In ha sense i is analogous o he use of elapsed ime as an independen and unambiguous meric used for assessing process re-engineering programmes (Thomas, 1990; Salk and Hou, 1990). Recen advances in cosing he bullwhip effec include predicions from an OR model developed by Meers (1997). He concludes ha avoidable on-coss range from 10% o 30% (depending on bullwhip source) calculaed a he manufacuring sage alone. As Fisher, Hammond, Obermeyer and Raman (1997) poin ou, he on-coss hroughou he chain can be very subsanial, especially where an arificially high load is placed on sysem capaciy. So in ha sense he Meers (1997) figures can be regarded as underesimaes. However, in our search herein for generic soluions we concenrae on bullwhip reducion alone. We believe i is a valid meric for VMI insigh and exploiaion in cusomer/vendor negoiaions and in subsequen sysem re-design. I is simple enough o saisfy he Buxey (2001) need for basing producion sraegy around rules-of-humb. A he same ime i is a meaningful driver owards cos reducion (Meers, 1997).

7 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Overview of a Tradiional Supply Chain A supply chain is a sysem consising of maerial suppliers, producion faciliies, disribuion services, and cusomers who are all linked ogeher via he downsream feed-forward flow of maerials (deliveries) and he upsream feedback flow of informaion (orders), (Sevens, 1989). As shown in Figure 1, in a radiional supply chain each player is responsible for his own invenory conrol and producion or disribuion ordering aciviies. One fundamenal characerisic and problem ha all players in a radiional supply chain (such as reailers, disribuors, manufacurers, raw maerial suppliers) mus solve is jus how much o order he producion sysem o make (or he suppliers o supply) so as o enable a supply chain echelon o saisfy is cusomers demands. This is he producion/invenory conrol problem. Yarn maker Order flucuaions are ypically +/-40% (hence amplificaion here+2x2x2=8 imes greaer hen markeplace variabiliy) Direcion of demand amplificaion and increasing variabiliy and uncerainy as he waveform moves upsream Fabric maker Order flucuaions are ypically +/-20% Garmen maker Order flucuaions are ypically +/-10% High sree reailer Flow of orders upsream Order flucuaions are ypically +/-5% Flow of maerials downsream Figure 1. Sequenial Informaion Flow Causing Bullwhip in a Tradiional Clohing Supply Chain (Source: Towill and McCullen, 1999, based on he descripion by Salk and Hou, 1990) Cusomers According o Axsäer (1985), he purpose of a producion/invenory conrol sysem (he mehod used o conrol invenory levels and producion raes) is o ransform incomplee informaion abou he marke place ino co-ordinaed plans for producion and replenishmen of raw maerials. The producion/invenory conrol problem is

8 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / ackled by praciioners inspecing daa relaing o demands, invenory levels and orders in he pipeline. Then, eiher in a srucured, mahemaical way (for example, by using a decision suppor sysem wih properly engineered, well designed replenishmen rules), or in a less formal way (by using heir own experience and judgemen), hey place orders up he supply chain. The srucure of he radiional supply chain shown in Figure 1 has developed parly as a resul of he need for a company o be in conrol of is own asses and parly because, unil recenly, i has been uneconomic o pass vas amouns of informaion around he sysem. The radiional supply chain is characerised by each player in he supply chain basing his producion orders or delivery orders solely on his sales o his cusomer, on his own invenory levels and, someimes, on WIP (pipeline) arges. Each echelon in he supply chain only has informaion abou wha heir cusomers wan and no on which producs he end cusomer is acually buying oday. The clohing supply chain shown in Figure 1 ypifies his sae of affairs. I especially does no allow suppliers o gain any insigh ino wha heir cusomers are ordering o cover heir own Cusomer Service Level (CSL) and cos requiremens and wha he cusomers are ordering o saisfy immediae cusomer demand (Kaipia, Holmsröm and Tanskanen, 2002). This lack of visibiliy of real demand leads o a double-guessing culure. I can and does cause a number of problems in a supply chain if i is no properly designed and even hen flucuaions in he supply chain canno be compleely eliminaed. Such a sae of affairs cerainly causes he Forreser Effec, as a paricular player over-orders in response o genuine changes in demand o accoun for his invenory deviaions ha resul from he producion/disribuion lead-ime. This over-ordering is hen amplified up he supply chain, creaing wide (and wild) flucuaions in he demand signal as i passes hrough he supply chain. Those shown in Fig. 1 are ypical of real-world supply chains (Olsmas, Edghill and Towill, 1988). As we shall see laer, an amplificaion of demand of 2:1 is ypical as orders pass hrough a single supply chain echelon. Our purpose herein is o look furher ino he causes of his phenomenon, and o see how VMI helps o reduce his amplificaion on a source-by-source basis. 4. The Bullwhip Effec The Bullwhip Effec is a new erm (bu no a new phenomenon since i has been debaed in he lieraure for over four decades) coined by Lee, Padmanabhan and

9 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Whang (1997a, b). I refers o he scenario where he orders o he supplier end o have larger flucuaions han sales o he buyer. This disorion subsequenly propagaes upsream in an amplified form. Generally speaking, he furher upsream he echelon, he more disored and amplified is he waveform. Lee e al (1997a and b) sae ha here are five fundamenal causes of Bullwhip; non-zero lead-imes, demand signalling processing, price variaions, raioning and gaming, and order baching. In any pracical supply chain hese may all be presen and inerac as shown in Fig. 2. Noe ha we consider boh zero lead-ime and demand signal processing o be he essence of he well-known Forreser effec (Forreser, 1961). I is our inenion in his paper o show how each of hese bullwhip sources is affeced by he inroducion of VMI. This will be done using a dynamic model of a paricular VMI sysem capable of represening curren indusrial pracice. The Bullwhip Effec Price flucuaions or he Promoion Effec Demand signal processing and non-zero lead-imes or he Forreser Effec Raioning and gaming or he Houlihan Effec Order baching or he Burbidge Effec Figure 2. Four Major Causes of he Bullwhip Effec (Source: Disney and Towill, 2001) Demand signal processing has in he pas been called he Demand Amplificaion or he Forreser Effec afer Jay Forreser (1961) who encounered he problem and subsequenly demonsraed i via DYNAMO simulaion. The Forreser Effec is also encompassed by Serman s bounded raionaliy, (Serman, 1989), erminology ha is common in he field of psychology as used o describe players sub-opimal bu

10 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / seemingly raional decision making behaviour. This paricular source of bullwhip was fully undersood and he phenomenon well described and publicised by Salk and Hou (1990). I is hus clear ha he Boson Consulancy Group were fully conversan wih he exisence of bullwhip problems, which hey hen sudied furher and proposed soluions specific via a dynamic simulaion. Order baching is also known as he Burbidge Effec (Burbidge, 1991). I refers o he pracise of placing orders up he supply chain (or on he various manufacuring processes) in baches. The philosophy behind his acion is o gain economies of scale in se-up aciviies (such as seing up a specific machine or placing and receiving an order). I is ofen he resul of he applicaion of an Economic Order Quaniy calculaion or similar echnique. Burbidge discusses he problems his causes on he shop floor in considerable deail. To deal wih hese problems Towill (1997) oulined he conribuions of Forreser and Burbidge for avoiding he Bullwhip Effec brough ogeher in an inegraed approach ermed Forridge. The Inpu-Oupu diagram in Figure 3 highlighs he roo causes of demand amplificaion ha can be aribued o eiher he Forreser Effec or he Burbidge Effec and in some cases boh. Burbidge Effec Forreser Effec Supply chain Avoidable demand amplificaion Figure 3. FORRIDGE Inpu-oupu diagram of demand amplificaion resuling from evidence provided by Jay Forreser and Jack Burbidge (Source: Towill, 1997) Wihin he producion conex, raioning and gaming, or he Houlihan Effec was highlighed by Houlihan (1987) who recognised ha as shorages or missed deliveries occur in radiional supply chains, cusomers overload heir schedules or orders. This in urn places more demands on he producion sysem ha ineviably leads o more unreliable deliveries. Cusomers hen increase heir safey sock arge in a vicious

11 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / circle ha furher disors he demand signal, giving rise o he Bullwhip Effec. Houlihan has summarised his phenomenon as he Flywheel effec as shown in Fig. 4. This simple diagram conveys, in erms readily recognised by op managemen, he dilemma facing producion schedulers in radiional supply chains, such as previously repored in an auomoive secor Case Sudy (Edghill, Olsmas and Towill, 1988). I deserves o be much more widely known and used. Capaciy overload Shorages Demand disorion Over-ordering Safey sock increase Unreliable delivery Fig. 4. The Houlihan Flywheel Describing One Aspec of Bullwhip (Houlihan, 1988) Price variaions or he Promoion Effec refers o he pracise of offering producs a reduced prices so as o simulae demand. Assuming an elasic demand, his creaes emporary increases in orders where cusomers ake advanage of his opporuniy and forward buy or sock up. However his has serious impacs on he dynamics of he supply chain, as when he price is released from he discouned level, demand slumps, creaing a perceived need for furher discouning in order o simulae demand. A famous real-world example is due o Fisher e al (1997), wih he resuling ime-series being shown in Fig. 5. As can be seen, he enicemen of a discoun offered by Campbells Soups o he reailer caused an unpredicable change in behaviour o which all suppliers have o

12 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / respond. This produces a ypical bullwhip profile wih demand being amplified as i is passed upsream. As can be seen from Fig. 5, his self-induced bullwhip requires a peak capaciy well over wice he average demand. The resulan on-coss are considerable for all players in he chain, including overime, shif premiums, qualiy variances, and addiional disribuion, handling and sorage charges. Furhermore, acual poin-of-sales daa suggess ha adapive level scheduling would be sufficien o mee real demand. CASES OF CHICKEN NOODLE 5 SOUP (X10 ) FALSE DEMAND PEAK INDUCED BY SUPPLIER DISCOUNT! SHIPMENTS ACTUAL CONSUMPTION July 1s June 30h WEEKS Fig. 5. Example of a Price Discoun Induced Bullwhip Recorded in Campbell s Soups Supply Chain (Source: Fisher, Hammond, Obermeyer and Raman, 1997) 5. Measuring The Bullwhip Effec in Real Supply Chains Many auhors have recenly suppored using saisical measures of he Bullwhip Effec, for example, Chen, Ryan and Simchi-Levi (2000). Herein ORATE refers o he orders placed on our supplier and CONS represens sales or consumpion by our cusomer. The bullwhip effec meric of choice is hen:

13 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Bullwhip 2 ORATE 2 CONS / / ORATE CONS 2 2 ORATE CONS Eq 1 Where; 2 is he uncondiional variance of he orders (subscrip ORATE) and consumpion (CONS). is he uncondiional mean of he orders (subscrip ORATE) and consumpion (CONS). We may expec, as we are considering a single cusomer and supplier ha he uncondiional means are idenical and hus hey cancel. There is already a considerable amoun of evidence in he lieraure ha bullwhip exiss in real-world supply chains (as disinc from simulaion model resuls). Fransoo and Wouers (2000) used saisical echniques o measure he Bullwhip Effec experienced in a grocery supply chain. They considered he pracical aspecs of using he sandard deviaion raios (raher hen he variance) as a bullwhip measure and concluded ha four Bullwhip merics should be used. These focus on: a specific produc for a specific oule; a specific produc demand aggregaed across all oules; aggregaed producs for individual oules; aggregaed oules agains aggregae producs. Fransoo and Wouers (2000) highligh he fac ha each bullwhip measure is useful for invesigaing somewha differen circumsances. For example, Table 4 summarises he Bullwhip merics esimaed in heir paricular grocery supply chain. The four mehods of calculaion clearly enables bullwhip o be associaed in urn wih specific producs and/or specific oules as required by he sysems designer.

14 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Coefficien of Variaion Esimaed for Individual Producs and Aggregaed Oules Aggregae Producs and Aggregae Oules Aggregae producs and Individual Oules Aggregae Producs and Aggregae Orders Produc Oule Bullwhip Weighed Average Bullwhip 1 A A B B (A+B) (A+B) (1+2) A (1+2) (B) (1+2) (A+B) Table 4. Bullwhip Found in a Grocery Supply Chain (Fransoo and Wouers 2000) Noe ha Bullwhip Facors yield imporan insighs ino he real-world behaviour of he differen players in he chain. This is shown in Table 5, based on a European reail supply chain (Holmsröm, 1997). He analysed he orders flowing upsream from he reail oules righ hrough he various echelons and ulimaely back o he facory. Using he bullwhip measure (Eq 1) Holmsröm sudied in deph a raffic building (high volume, low margin) produc and a low raffic (low volume, high margin) produc. This esablished ha he downsream players (shops and wholesalers) are he bigges culpris in he paricular sense of bullwhip generaion. Furhermore he decision-makers exhibi lile difference in heir aiude o ordering policies for eiher he low margin or he high margin producs, wih Bullwhip Facors a around 3 o 1 a each sage. No so he facory scheduler who clearly maches he ordering policy o SKU. He visibly reas he wo producs differenly, and significanly dampens down he demand volailiy in he facory orders placed for he high volume produc. This is mos likely o have been achieved via some version of level scheduling (Suzaki, 1987). In conras, he same scheduler is quie prepared o induce furher subsanial bullwhip ino he sysem when considering he low volume produc. Finally, deliveries from he facory also exhibi some bullwhip bu i is of a smaller order of magniude han ha generaed by he downsream players

15 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / High Volume Low Margin Supply Chain Produc Echelon Coefficien of Commens on Variaion Waveforms Reailer 2.60 Primarily Forreser Effec Wholesaler 2.88 Forreser and Burbidge Effecs Facory 0.72 Levelled Planner Scheduling Facory 1.67 Forreser and Producion/ Burbidge Disribuion Effecs Low Volume High Margin Produc Coefficien of Commens on Variaion Waveforms 3.14 Primarily Forreser Effec 3.05 Forreser and Burbidge Effecs 2.39 Pronounced Burbidge Effec 1.25 Pronounced Burbidge Effec Table 5. Acual Demand Amplificaion Recorded wihin a Real-World Supply Chain (McCullen and Towill, 2001, based on resuls by Holmsröm, 1997) The composie Bullwhip Facor over he enire reail chain is obained here by muliplying ogeher he bullwhip a each sage. The resul is 9:1 for he high volume produc, bu nearly 29:1 for he low volume produc. These resuls show ha demonsraor bullwhip values of 2 or 3 o 1 per sage as recorded by Serman (1989) during he playing of he MIT Beer Game are realisic benchmarks. This is good o verify, as criics of he game have doubed is real-world relevance. In erms of generaion of insigh he reail supply chain resuls pus he value of he game ino a new and enhanced perspecive. Inspecion of he ime series presened by Holmsröm (1997) also enables some commen o be made on likely causes of he bullwhip in his reail supply chain. Those in Table 5 follow from he observaions by McCullen and Towill (2001). They argue ha Forreser Effecs appear o dominae downsream ordering, wih Burbidge Effecs becoming much more eviden as he waveform propagaes upsream. 6. Overview of a VMI Supply Chain In recen years, many companies have been compelled o improve heir supply chain operaions by sharing demand and invenory informaion wih heir suppliers and cusomers. Differen indusries have coined differen erms for VMI, bu all are based essenially on he same idea. VMI is a supply chain sraegy whereby he vendor or supplier is given he responsibiliy of managing he cusomer s sock. For clariy he erm disribuor for he cusomer in he VMI relaionship and manufacurer for

16 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / he supplier or vendor is he VMI relaionship will be used. VMI has become more popular in he grocery secor in he las 15 years due o he success of reailers such as Wal-Mar. Addiionally, i is only relaively recenly ha he necessary informaion and communicaion echnology has become economically available o enable he sraegy, alhough Holmsröm (1998) has shown ha i can be readily enabled via fax or s and spreadshees. As proof, Disney, Holmsröm, Kaipia and Towill (2001) have implemened VMI in a real-world supply chain using daa available from a popular ERP sysem and a spreadshee based decision suppor sysem. Moreover, VMI is no a new philosophy. I was iniially discussed by Magee (1958, pp 298) in a presenaion of a concepual framework for designing a producion conrol sysem. Quoing direcly from he ex (as i propheically and very concisely porrays wha we believe VMI acually is): Frequenly here is argumen as o who should conrol invenories. For example, should i be he sales organisaion or (some) oher uni ha draws on he socks and wans o be sure hey are here, or he operaion ha supplies he sock poin and wans o feed i economically? There is probably no resoluion o his quesion as saed; he difficuly is ha boh have a legiimae ineres. I is possible o resae he quesion slighly and reach a soluion. The user has o be sure he maerial he needs is here. He has corresponding responsibiliy o sae wha his maximum and minimum requiremens will be. Once hese limis are acceped as reasonable, he supplier has he responsibiliy of meeing demand wihin hese limis, making whaever use he can of he flexibiliy he invenory provides. Thus boh have a share in he responsibiliy for and conrol over a sock uni. One specifies wha he maximum and minimum demands on he sock uni will be; he oher has he responsibiliy of keeping he sock uni replenished bu no overloaded as long as demand says wihin he specified limis, Magee (1958, pp298). VMI comes in many differen forms. Familiar names are Quick Response (QR), (Lee, So and Tang, 2000), Synchronised Consumer Response (SCR), Coninuous Replenishmen (CR), Efficien Consumer Response (ECR), (Cachon and Fisher, 1997), Rapid Replenishmen (RR), Collaboraive Planning, Forecasing and

17 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Replenishmen (CPFR), Holmsröm e al, (2000) and Cenralised Invenory Managemen (Lee, Padmanabhan and Whang, 1997a), he erminology depending on secor applicaion, ownership issues and scope of implemenaion. However, in essence, hey are all specific applicaions of VMI ha is summarised concepually in Figure 6. This is he sysem o be used o benchmark bullwhip reducion. Business Targes VMI Conrols Service Levels Sales (CONS) Infinie Maerial Socks Producion Orders Facory Order Rae (ORATE) Facory (COMRATE) Facory Compleions Despach This Number Compleions Se Targe Sock (TINV) Finished Goods Socks (FINV) Despaches Se GIT Sock GIT Se Targe Sock, R Deliveries Toal Sysem Sock (SINV) Vending Socks(DINV) Producion lead-ime Disribuion lead-ime Figure 6. Overview of he VMI Scenario Noe ha we do no consider hose supply chain scenarios ha exploi only he daa abou end consumer demand in he ordering decisions o be rue VMI. We erm his kind of supply chain as possessing informaion sharing and i is a disinc (bu equally valid) sraegy. However, he lack of cusomer invenory informaion in he suppliers ordering decision makes i a fundamenally differen sysem. Examples of informaion sharing can be found in Yu, Yan and Cheng (2001), Chen, Drezner, Ryan and Simchi-Levi (2000), Lee, So and Tang (2000) and Mason-Jones and Towill (1997). 7. Descripion of he VMI Supply Chain Simulaion Model The difference equaions required o model our version of he VMI scenario are shown in Appendix 1. These difference equaions can quickly be urned ino a mahemaical model of he VMI supply chain by using z-ransforms. The formulaion and exploiaion of such a mahemaical model is no presened in his conribuion due o space resricions bu can be found in Disney (2001) and Disney and Towill

18 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / (2001 and 2002). Herein, he difference equaion represenaion will be exploied. The difference equaions may be quickly realised by ineresed readers in spreadshee applicaions such as Microsof Excel. Difference equaions can also be implemened in sandard compuer languages wih relaive ease, as shown in Disney and Towill, (2001). The specific flavour of VMI ha he difference equaions represen in Appendix 1 is ermed VMI-APIOBPCS, or Vendor Managed Invenory, Auomaic Pipeline, Invenory and Order Based Producion Conrol Sysem. The VMI erm in VMI-APIOBPCS reflecs he mos significan fac abou a VMI supply chain, i.e. ha he disribuor (he cusomer in he VMI relaionship) passes invenory informaion and Poin of Sales (POS) daa o heir suppliers raher han orders, (Kaipia e al (2002), Corill (1997)). The acual invenory a he cusomer is hen compared o a re-order poin ha has been agreed on by boh paries. This reorder poin is se o ensure adequae availabiliy wihou building up excessive socks. I riggers a replenishmen order ha is delivered o he cusomer if he acual invenory is below he re-order poin in each planning period. Each pary also agrees he order-up-o poin, O. The dispaches beween he wo echelons are equal o he order-up o level, O, minus he re-order poin, R, and he dispaches can be of a consan or varying size wihin his framework. The re-order poin is se dynamically so as o reflec perceived changes in demand. This is done by exponenially smoohing (over Tq ime unis) he sales signal and muliplying i by a consan (G) ha ensures appropriae cusomer service levels a he disribuor, aking ino accoun he ransporaion lead-ime beween he wo paries in he supply chain. Exponenial smoohing was chosen as he forecasing mechanism because i is; simple o implemen in compuer sysems (requiring less daa sorage), readily undersood and he mos favoured echnique by boh indusrialiss and academics. I should be noed ha he ne change in he re-order poin from one ime period o anoher is added o he sales signal and he vendor reas his a demand. So, when demand is increasing and he disribuors re-order poin grows, he supplier or vendor reas he sock (re-order poin) requiremens a he disribuor as demand and incorporaes ha ino his forecass and sock levels, as he clearly should do. Obviously, he negaive argumen also applies, i.e. when he re-order poin is reducing in size over ime, demand signals o he manufacure reflec his.

19 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / The APIOBPCS erm reflecs he componens of he srucure of he ordering decision a he VMI supplier. In words i is le our producion orders be equal o he sum of hree componens; he forecased demand, (exponenial smoohed over Ta ime unis), a fracion (1/Ti) of he difference beween arge sock and acual sock and a fracion (1/Tw) of he difference beween arge WIP and acual WIP. 8. Descripion of he Tradiional Supply Chain Simulaion Model The APIOBPCS model, John, Naim and Towill (1994), was chosen o represen a radiional supply chain. This was due o a number of reasons. Firsly i was fel imporan ha i is desirable ha like (APIOBPCS) is compared o like as much as possible (VMI-APIOBPCS) in order o gain as much undersanding as possible on he fundamenal srucure of VMI. Secondly APIOBPCS was chosen for VMI and he radiional supply chain, as i is recognised as good pracice, incorporaes all commonly available forms of informaion, represens human behaviour (Serman, 1989 and Naim and Towill, 1995) and is a well-undersood member of he IOBPCS (Towill, 1982) family. The APIOBPCS model can be expressed in words as oulined in he previous secion. I incorporaes hree variables; Ta, a parameer ha describes how quickly demand is racked in he forecasing mechanism, Ti, a parameer ha describes of much of he discrepancy beween acual invenory and arge invenory levels should be added o he producion/ disribuion order rae and Tw, a parameer ha describes how much of he discrepancy beween acual WIP and arge WIP levels should be added o he producion/ disribuion order rae. Individual echelons, or APIOBPCS models, can be linked ogeher o form a supply chain, by coupling he ORATE signal of he consuming echelon o he CONS signal of he supplying echelon, as recognised by Burns and Sivazlian (1978) and furher exploied by Towill and del Vecchio (1994). The difference equaions required o model a wo-level APIOBPCS supply chain (for example in a spreadshee) are shown

20 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / in Appendix 2. Like he VMI model he producion and disribuion delays are arbirarily assumed o be of four ime unis. 9. Impac of VMI on he Promoions Induced Bullwhip To invesigae he impac of VMI on he promoions induced Bullwhip Effec, he Facory Order Rae response of he wo supply chain srucures o a sep inpu will be used. This produces a very rich picure of he associaed sysem dynamics. Undersanding he dynamic response o a sep inpu will hereby yield insigh ino how he sysem will be affeced by various promoions. As here are an infinie number of designs for VMI and radiional supply chains ha migh be compared, previous bes pracise designs will be used o compare he wo supply chains via he sep response. The following designs were chosen o represen good designs of a radiional supply chain wih a producion lead-ime of 4 ime periods; John e al (1994) recommended seings (Ta=8, Ti=4, Tw=8). This was derived using classical conrol heory and simulaion and may be considered o a fairly conservaive deign. Disney e al (1997) recommended seings (Ta=8, Ti=4, Tw=15). This was based on a Geneic Algorihms search, using Laplace ransforms, simulaion wih he aim of minimising he Forreser Effec, invenory holding, seleciviy, whils maximising robusness o errors in esimaion of WIP levels and producion leadimes. Naim and Towill (1995) values of (Ta=8, Ti=4, Tw=4). These were derived from inspecing Serman s (1989) Beer Game derived opimum seings. This may be considered o a reacive version of he John e al (1994) seings. Disney (2001) recommended seings (Ta=4, Ti=7, Tw=28). This was based on he full soluion based search using z-ransforms and simulaion aimed a balancing he Forreser Effec and invenory holding requiremens.

21 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Operaional Seing Parameers of Opimum VMI Sysem G ~ W # Ta Ti Tq Tw ~ G =Re-order poin level # W=Weighing funcion used in opimisaion rouine o rade-off producion capaciy requiremens agains sock requiremens Table 6. Sample Opimum Parameer Values for VMI Sysem Simulaion As oulined earlier, he VMI sraegy has 5 key parameers Tq - he forecasing parameer used o generae he re-order poin, G - he gain on he forecas generaed by Tq use o calculae he re-order poin, Ta - he forecasing parameer used o forecas demand by he manufacurer, Ti he fracion of invenory error accouned for in a single order and Tw he fracion of he WIP error accouned for in a single order ha deermine he dynamic response of he sysem. The erms Ta, Ti, Tq and Tw depend on he parameer G ha is independenly se o reflec he desired CSL given he ransporaion lead-ime beween he manufacurer and he disribuor, via he reorder poin equaion. A full-scale opimisaion procedure (Disney (2001) and Disney and Towill (2002)) has been applied o hese parameers for a range of raios of producion adapaion coss (due o he Forreser Effec) o he associaed invenory holding coss and for differen values of he re-order poin G. The resuling opimal parameer seings for Ta, Ti, Tq and Tw for he case when G= 1 and 4 are shown in Table 6. There is a complex relaionship beween hese parameers for example; higher values of G generally induce more bullwhip ino he manufacurer s orders. Furhermore, higher values of Tq help o reduce he bullwhip experienced by he manufacurer bu a he expense of longer invenory seling ime. I is no our inenion o explore his here. In his Secion i is sufficien o illusrae he VMI sysem sep response for he case where producion adapaion and invenory holding coss were given equal imporance, for he wo designs chosen o represen good

22 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / soluions for a VMI supply chain. Hence he bes pracice seings for he VMI supply chain used were; The opimum parameer seing when he disribuor has a re-order poin level se a 1 planning periods average demand, (i.e. G=1, Ta=6, Ti=7, Tq=6, Tw=42) The opimum parameer seing when he disribuor has a re-order poin level se a 4 planning periods average demand, (i.e. G=4, Ta=4, Ti =14, Tq=4, Tw=63) I can be seen from inspecion of Figure 7 ha he VMI design ouperforms he radiional supply chain, wih less peak overshoo, faser seling ime and a generally quicker response. ORATE VMI, Ta=6, Ti=7, Tq=6, Tw=42, G=1 VMI, Ta=4, Ti=14, Tq=4, Tw=63, G=4 APIOBPCS, Ta=8, Ti=4, Tw=8 APIOBPCS, Ta=8, Ti=4, Tw=15 APIOBPCS, Ta=8, Ti=4, Tw=4 APIOBPCS, Ta=4, Ti=7, Tw= Time Figure 7. Impac of VMI on he Promoions Bullwhip Effec 10. Impac of VMI on Sysem Induced Bullwhip Effec We now esimae he impac of VMI on Forreser source induced bullwhip. In Table 7 we have compared VMI and radiional supply chains across a range of performance merics. The peak ORATE overshoo is he simple measure of bullwhip already me in Fig. 7. Noe ha for compleeness Table 7 includes hree opimal soluions for each of he wo values of G (1 and 4). These are for raios of producion

23 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / adapaion/invenory holding coss W = 0.01; W = 1.0; and W = 100. The reason for his is ha W = 0.01 approximaes an agile sysem; W = 100 approximaes a lean (level scheduling) sysem; whils W = 1.0 is a compromise soluion. As noed by Chrisopher and Towill (2000) here are occasions where agile is he bes business soluion, and where lean is he bes business soluion, and where some mix is required. For he opimal VMI supply chains, he bullwhip is reasonably unaffeced by varying W for a given value of G. This is because he opimisaion programme (Disney, 2001) drives he VMI parameers o yield he bes possible response. (As we have seen in Table 6, he parameer seings o achieve his goal are subsanially differen.) If he peak ORATE overshoo is 2.5, hen X is a bullwhip effec of 150% and so on. So comparing he opimal VMI sysem wih he neares equivalen radiional supply chain i.e. G = 1, W = 1.0, and wih VMI opimal parameer seing, we see VMI reduces he bullwhip effec from 144% o 69%. Some auhors (for example Chen, Ryan and Simchi-Levi [2000]) use he raio of order and sales variance as a bullwhip measure, ohers (for example Fransoo and Wouers (2000) have been using raios involving he sandard deviaion. Whils boh concepually similar, he variance raio is preferred as his can be calculaed direcly from a sysem s ransfer funcion, Disney and Towill (2001) or efficienly enumeraed wih difference equaions. Hence in Table 6 we have included an esimae of variance obained via evaluaion of sysem noise bandwidh (Towill, 1982). This bullwhip measure has been reduced from 0.93 (Tradiional supply chain) o 0.46 (VMI sysem), a facor of 2 o 1. So on boh bullwhip measures using VMI is a grea improvemen in coping wih Forreser sourced bullwhip. 11. The Impac of VMI on he Houlihan Effec In he VMI supply chain he responsibiliy for managing he sock a he cusomer s premises clearly lies wih he manufacurer. Therefore, he Houlihan Effec is compleely eliminaed as he manufacurer is generaing he despaches in he supply chain raher han he disribuor. Wih his configuraion i is no possible o game agains yourself. VMI has he advanage ha on-ime delivery does no need o be moniored, because for as long as here is sock availabiliy a he disribuor, no one cares (including he end cusomer) if a delivery is missed. In fac, i is unlikely ha

24 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / Bullwhip Measures Sysem Performance Peak ORATE overshoo Noise Bandwidh/ 2 (calculaed from real ime series) Opimal VMI supply chain G=0 G=1 G=4 Design 1 G=0, W=1 equivalen Tradiional supply chain Design 2 John e al (1994) Design 3 Disney e al (1997) Ta Ti Tw Ta Ti Tw Ta Ti Tw W=1 W=0.01 W=1 W=100 W=0.01 W=1 W= Table 7. Impac of VMI on Forreser Sourced Bullwhip Effec

25 Disney, S.M. and Towill, D.R., (2003) Vendor-managed invenory and bullwhip reducion in a wo-level supply chain, Inernaional Journal of Producion and Operaions Managemen. Vol. 23, No. 6, pp ISSN: DOI: / he disribuor would even know if a delivery is on ime, as he does no even generae orders o compare agains shipmens. VMI has anoher unique advanage over he radiional supply chain; i aligns he necessary measures of performance required in he VMI supply chain o he cusomer expecaions, which has also been noiced by Kaipia, Holmsröm and Tanskanen (2002). This comes from he fac ha he only wo measures ha are imporan in he VMI supply chain (a leas in a logisical sense), are wheher here is a los sale due o a sock-ou a he disribuor and how much invenory here is in he supply chain, as his influences he coss o he end consumer. So clearly VMI eliminaes one very common source of bullwhip. I is also arguably he mos enuous and irriaing source of bullwhip. More ofen han no i is enflamed by secrecy, lack of rus, and he general adversarial naure of radiional supply chains. 12. The Impac of VMI on he Burbidge Effec The Burbidge Effec in a radiional supply chain can be avoided by despaching every ime period only he requiremens for ha ime period. However, i is ofen he case ha under such condiions he ransporaion (or receiving faciliies) cos is hugely inflaed. Thus, companies ofen resor o a baching menaliy, hereby inroducing a huge source of Bullwhip Effec ino he supply chain. If only he curren ime period s requiremens are despached hen, as shown in Fig. 8, he amoun ranspored will need o change every ime period. So here is an apparen conflic beween reducing bullwhip and obaining economies of scale on ransporaion coss. However, he way a VMI supply chain copes wih he Burbidge Effec in an innovaive manner, is also shown in Figure 8. This is because VMI allows baching o occur in he ransporaion aciviy beween he manufacurer and he disribuor, wihou inroducing he order baching effec ino he producion order rae. This is enabled by VMI because of he way he informaion flow is srucured. Recall ha in a VMI supply chain he sock posiion a he disribuor is compared o a re-order poin and if he sock posiion is below he re-order poin hen a despach quaniy is ranspored o he disribuor. This is one side of an IF. THEN rule. Capuring he oher side of he IF. THEN rule is done by adding o he disribuor s sock he

Morningstar Investor Return

Morningstar Investor Return Morningsar Invesor Reurn Morningsar Mehodology Paper March 3, 2009 2009 Morningsar, Inc. All righs reserved. The informaion in his documen is he propery of Morningsar, Inc. Reproducion or ranscripion by

More information

Paul R. Drake Management School, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK

Paul R. Drake Management School, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK The curren issue and full ex archive of his journal is available a www.emeraldinsigh.com/0960-0035.hm Analysis of he bullwhip effec wih order baching in muli-echelon supply chains Maloub Hussain College

More information

KEY CONCEPTS AND PROCESS SKILLS. 1. An allele is one of the two or more forms of a gene present in a population. MATERIALS AND ADVANCE PREPARATION

KEY CONCEPTS AND PROCESS SKILLS. 1. An allele is one of the two or more forms of a gene present in a population. MATERIALS AND ADVANCE PREPARATION Gene Squares 61 40- o 2 3 50-minue sessions ACIVIY OVERVIEW P R O B L E M S O LV I N G SUMMARY Sudens use Punne squares o predic he approximae frequencies of rais among he offspring of specific crier crosses.

More information

Stock Return Expectations in the Credit Market

Stock Return Expectations in the Credit Market Sock Reurn Expecaions in he Credi Marke Hans Bysröm * Sepember 016 In his paper we compue long-erm sock reurn expecaions (across he business cycle) for individual firms using informaion backed ou from

More information

EXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELY-SPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES

EXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELY-SPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES EXAMINING THE FEASIBILITY OF PAIRED CLOSELY-SPACED PARALLEL APPROACHES Seven J. Landry and Amy R. Priche Georgia Insiue of Technology Alana GA 30332-0205 ABSTRACT Paired closely-spaced parallel approaches

More information

What the Puck? an exploration of Two-Dimensional collisions

What the Puck? an exploration of Two-Dimensional collisions Wha he Puck? an exploraion of Two-Dimensional collisions 1) Have you ever played 8-Ball pool and los he game because you scrached while aemping o sink he 8-Ball in a corner pocke? Skech he sho below: Each

More information

The safe ships trajectory in a restricted area

The safe ships trajectory in a restricted area Scienific Journals Mariime Universiy of Szczecin Zeszyy Naukowe Akademia Morska w Szczecinie 214, 39(111) pp. 122 127 214, 39(111) s. 122 127 ISSN 1733-867 The safe ships rajecory in a resriced area Zbigniew

More information

An Alternative Mathematical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluation in Clean Water

An Alternative Mathematical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluation in Clean Water An Alernaive Mahemaical Model for Oxygen Transfer Evaluaion in Clean Waer Yanjun (John) He 1, PE, BCEE 1 Kruger Inc., 41 Weson Parkway, Cary, NC 27513 Email: john.he@veolia.com ABSTRACT Energy consumpion

More information

Guidance Statement on Calculation Methodology

Guidance Statement on Calculation Methodology Guidance Saemen on Calculaion Mehodology Adopion Dae: 28 Sepember 200 Effecive Dae: January 20 Reroacive Applicaion: No Required www.gipssandards.org 200 CFA Insiue Guidance Saemen on Calculaion Mehodology

More information

Sources of Over-Performance in Equity Markets: Mean Reversion, Common Trends and Herding

Sources of Over-Performance in Equity Markets: Mean Reversion, Common Trends and Herding The Universiy of Reading THE BUSINESS SCHOOL FOR FINANCIAL MARKETS Sources of Over-Performance in Equiy Markes: Mean Reversion, Common Trends and Herding ISMA Cenre Discussion Papers in Finance 2003-08

More information

Dual Boost High Performances Power Factor Correction (PFC)

Dual Boost High Performances Power Factor Correction (PFC) Dual Boos High Performances Power Facor Correcion (PFC) C. Aaianese, Senior Member, IEEE - V. Nardi, Member, IEEE - F. Parillo - G. Tomasso, Member, IEEE Deparmen of Auomaion, Elecromagneism, Compuer Science

More information

QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE. Optimal Time Series Momentum QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE

QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE. Optimal Time Series Momentum QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE F INANCE RESEARCH CENTRE QUANTITATIVE FINANCE RESEARCH CENTRE Research Paper 353 January 15 Opimal Time Series Momenum Xue-Zhong He, Kai Li and Youwei

More information

Urban public transport optimization by bus ways: a neural network-based methodology

Urban public transport optimization by bus ways: a neural network-based methodology Urban Transpor XIII: Urban Transpor and he Environmen in he 21s Cenury 347 Urban public ranspor opimizaion by bus ways: a neural nework-based mehodology M. Migliore & M. Caalano Deparmen of Transporaion

More information

DYNAMIC portfolio optimization is one of the important

DYNAMIC portfolio optimization is one of the important , July 2-4, 2014, London, U.K. A Simulaion-based Porfolio Opimizaion Approach wih Leas Squares Learning Chenming Bao, Geoffrey Lee, and Zili Zhu Absrac This paper inroduces a simulaion-based numerical

More information

Market timing and statistical arbitrage: Which market timing opportunities arise from equity price busts coinciding with recessions?

Market timing and statistical arbitrage: Which market timing opportunities arise from equity price busts coinciding with recessions? Journal of Applied Finance & Banking, vol.1, no.1, 2011, 53-81 ISSN: 1792-6580 (prin version), 1792-6599 (online) Inernaional Scienific Press, 2011 Marke iming and saisical arbirage: Which marke iming

More information

The t-test. What We Will Cover in This Section. A Research Situation

The t-test. What We Will Cover in This Section. A Research Situation The -es 1//008 P331 -ess 1 Wha We Will Cover in This Secion Inroducion One-sample -es. Power and effec size. Independen samples -es. Dependen samples -es. Key learning poins. 1//008 P331 -ess A Research

More information

KINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION

KINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION chaper KINEMATICS IN ONE DIMENSION Secion 2.1 Displacemen Secion 2.2 Speed and Velociy 1. A paricle ravels along a curved pah beween wo poins P and Q as shown. The displacemen of he paricle does no depend

More information

MODEL SELECTION FOR VALUE-AT-RISK: UNIVARIATE AND MULTIVARIATE APPROACHES SANG JIN LEE

MODEL SELECTION FOR VALUE-AT-RISK: UNIVARIATE AND MULTIVARIATE APPROACHES SANG JIN LEE MODEL SELECTION FOR VALUE-AT-RISK: UNIVARIATE AND MULTIVARIATE APPROACHES By SANG JIN LEE Bachelor of Science in Mahemaics Yonsei Universiy Seoul, Republic of Korea 999 Maser of Business Adminisraion Yonsei

More information

Real-time Stochastic Evacuation Models for Decision Support in Actual Emergencies

Real-time Stochastic Evacuation Models for Decision Support in Actual Emergencies Real-ime Sochasic Evacuaion Models for Decision Suppor in Acual Emergencies ARTURO CUESTA, DANIEL ALVEAR, ORLANDO ABREU and DELFÍN SILIÓ Transpors and echnology projecs and processes Universiy of Canabria

More information

Rolling ADF Tests: Detecting Rational Bubbles in Greater China Stock Markets

Rolling ADF Tests: Detecting Rational Bubbles in Greater China Stock Markets Singapore Managemen Universiy Insiuional Knowledge a Singapore Managemen Universiy Disseraions and Theses Collecion (Open Access) Disseraions and Theses 2008 Rolling ADF Tess: Deecing Raional Bubbles in

More information

SIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE

SIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE 1 h Inernaional Conference on Sabiliy of Ships and Ocean Vehicles 591 SIMULATION OF WAVE EFFECT ON SHIP HYDRODYNAMICS BY RANSE Qiuxin Gao, Universiy of Srahclyde, UK, Gao.q.x@srah.ac.uk Dracos Vassalos,

More information

What is a Practical (ASTM C 618) SAI--Strength Activity Index for Fly Ashes that can be used to Proportion Concretes Containing Fly Ash?

What is a Practical (ASTM C 618) SAI--Strength Activity Index for Fly Ashes that can be used to Proportion Concretes Containing Fly Ash? 2017 World of Coal Ash (WOCA) Conference in Lexingon, KY - May 9-11, 2017 hp://www.flyash.info/ Wha is a Pracical (ASTM C 618) SAI--Srengh Aciviy Index for Fly Ashes ha can be used o Proporion Concrees

More information

Economic Growth with Bubbles

Economic Growth with Bubbles Economic Growh wih Bubbles AlberoMarin,andJaumeVenura March 2010 Absrac We develop a sylized model of economic growh wih bubbles. In his model, financial fricions lead o equilibrium dispersion in he raes

More information

LSU RISK ASSESSMENT FORM Please read How to Complete a Risk Assessment before completion

LSU RISK ASSESSMENT FORM Please read How to Complete a Risk Assessment before completion Please read How o Complee a Risk Assessmen before compleion EVENT OR ACTIVITY BEING RISK ASSESSED (add name of even where relevan) NAME OF DEPARTMENT Squad Training Neball DATE OF COMPLETION OF RISK ASSESSMENT

More information

Protecting the African Elephant: A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of. Ivory Trade

Protecting the African Elephant: A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of. Ivory Trade Proecing he African Elephan: A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade G. Cornelis van Kooen Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Vicoria P.O. Box 1700, Sn CSC Vicoria, BC V8W 2Y2 Canada Email: kooen@uvic.ca

More information

ITG Dynamic Daily Risk Model for Europe

ITG Dynamic Daily Risk Model for Europe December 2010 Version 1 ITG Dynamic Daily Risk Model for Europe 2010 All righs reserved. No o be reproduced or reransmied wihou permission. 121610 29140 These maerials are for informaional purposes only,

More information

Flow Switch LABO-VHZ-S

Flow Switch LABO-VHZ-S Flow Swich S Volumeric flow swiching Almos no effec from differing viscosiies Versaile, configurable swiching oupu in push-pull design Robus consrucion Compac design Characerisics he VHZ gearwheel flow

More information

Measuring Potential Output and Output Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya

Measuring Potential Output and Output Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya Universiy of Connecicu DigialCommons@UConn Economics Working Papers Deparmen of Economics Ocober 2005 Measuring Poenial Oupu and Oupu Gap and Macroeconomic Policy: The Case of Kenya Angelica E. Njuguna

More information

Economics 487. Homework #4 Solution Key Portfolio Calculations and the Markowitz Algorithm

Economics 487. Homework #4 Solution Key Portfolio Calculations and the Markowitz Algorithm Economics 87 Homework # Soluion Key Porfolio Calculaions and he Markowiz Algorihm A. Excel Exercises: (10 poins) 1. Download he Excel file hw.xls from he class websie. This file conains monhly closing

More information

Performance Attribution for Equity Portfolios

Performance Attribution for Equity Portfolios PERFORMACE ATTRIBUTIO FOR EQUITY PORTFOLIOS Performance Aribuion for Equiy Porfolios Yang Lu and David Kane Inroducion Many porfolio managers measure performance wih reference o a benchmark. The difference

More information

Machine Learning for Stock Selection

Machine Learning for Stock Selection Machine Learning for Sock Selecion Rober J. Yan Compuer Science Dep., The Uniersiy of Wesern Onario jyan@csd.uwo.ca Charles X. Ling Compuer Science Dep., The Uniersiy of Wesern Onario cling@csd.uwo.ca

More information

FORECASTING TECHNIQUES ADE 2013 Prof Antoni Espasa TOPIC 1 PART 2 TRENDS AND ACCUMULATION OF KNOWLEDGE. SEASONALITY HANDOUT

FORECASTING TECHNIQUES ADE 2013 Prof Antoni Espasa TOPIC 1 PART 2 TRENDS AND ACCUMULATION OF KNOWLEDGE. SEASONALITY HANDOUT FORECASTING TECHNIQUES ADE 2013 Prof Anoni Espasa TOPIC 1 PART 2 TRENDS AND ACCUMULATION OF KNOWLEDGE. SEASONALITY HANDOUT February 2013 MAIN FACTORS CAUSING TRENDS Increases in populaion. Seady inflaion.

More information

Proceedings of the ASME 28th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering OMAE2009 May 31 - June 5, 2009, Honolulu, Hawaii

Proceedings of the ASME 28th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering OMAE2009 May 31 - June 5, 2009, Honolulu, Hawaii Proceedings of he ASME 28h Inernaional Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arcic Engineering OMAE29 May 31 - June 5, 29, Honolulu, Hawaii OMAE29-79385 ANALYSIS OF THE TUNNEL IMMERSION FOR THE BUSAN-GEOJE

More information

The Trade Performance Index. Technical notes. May Market Analysis Section International Trade Center (ITC) Geneva, Switzerland

The Trade Performance Index. Technical notes. May Market Analysis Section International Trade Center (ITC) Geneva, Switzerland The Trade Performance Index Technical noes May 27 Mare Analysis Secion Inernaional Trade Cener (ITC) Geneva, Swizerland 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Trade Performance Index has been developed a ITC s Mare Analysis

More information

Dynamics of market correlations: Taxonomy and portfolio analysis

Dynamics of market correlations: Taxonomy and portfolio analysis Dynamics of marke correlaions: Taxonomy and porfolio analysis J.-P. Onnela, A. Chakrabori, and K. Kaski Laboraory of Compuaional Engineering, Helsinki Universiy of Technology, P.O. Box 9203, FIN-02015

More information

WHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY

WHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY Proceedings of he 2010 Join Rail Conference JRC2010 April 27-29, 2010, Urbana, Illinois, USA JRC2010-36236 WHO RIDE THE HIGH SPEED RAIL IN THE UNITED STATES THE ACELA EXPRESS CASE STUDY Zhenhua Chen The

More information

Smart Beta Multifactor Construction Methodology: Mixing versus Integrating

Smart Beta Multifactor Construction Methodology: Mixing versus Integrating THE JOURNAL OF SPRING 2018 VOLUME 8 NUMBER 4 JII.IIJOURNALS.com ETFs, ETPs & Indexing Smar Bea Mulifacor Consrucion Mehodology: Mixing versus Inegraing TZEE-MAN CHOW, FEIFEI LI, AND YOSEOP SHIM Smar Bea

More information

Zelio Control Measurement Relays RM4L Liquid Level Relays

Zelio Control Measurement Relays RM4L Liquid Level Relays Zelio Conrol Measuremen elays FNCTIONS These devices monior he levels of conducive liquids. They conrol he acuaion of pumps or valves o regulae levels; hey are also suiable for proecing submersible pumps

More information

Asset and Liability Management, Caisse. a manager of public debt

Asset and Liability Management, Caisse. a manager of public debt Asse and Liabiliy Managemen by CADES, a manager of public deb Name Deparmen & affiliaion Mailing Address e-mail address(es) Phone number 331 55 78 58 19, 331 55 78 58 00 Fax number 331 55 78 58 02 Eric

More information

ScienceDirect. Cycling Power Optimization System Using Link Models of Lower Limbs with Cleat-Shaped Biaxial Load Cells

ScienceDirect. Cycling Power Optimization System Using Link Models of Lower Limbs with Cleat-Shaped Biaxial Load Cells Available online a www.sciencedirec.com ScienceDirec Procedia Engineering 72 ( 20 ) 8 7 The 20 conference of he Inernaional Spors Engineering Associaion Cycling Power Opimizaion Sysem Using ink Models

More information

CHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS

CHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS CHARACTERIZATION AND MODELING OF A PROPORTIONAL VALVE FOR CONTROL SYNTHESIS Osama. OLABY, Xavier. BRN, Sylvie. SESMAT, Tanneguy. REDARCE and Eric. BIDEAX Laboraoire d Auomaique Indusrielle - hp://www-lai.insa-lyon.fr

More information

Methods for Estimating Term Structure of Interest Rates

Methods for Estimating Term Structure of Interest Rates Mehods for Esimaing Term Srucure of Ineres Raes Iskander Karibzhanov Absrac This paper compares differen inerpolaion algorihms for consrucing yield curves: cubic splines, linear and quadraic programming,

More information

CONTROL VALVES IN TURBO-COMPRESSOR ANTI-SURGE SYSTEMS

CONTROL VALVES IN TURBO-COMPRESSOR ANTI-SURGE SYSTEMS CONTROL VALVES IN TURBO-COMPRESSOR ANTI-SURGE SYSTEMS keninrol CONTROL VALVES IN TURBO-COMPRESSOR ANTI-SURGE SYSTEMS CONTROL VALVES IN TURBO-COMPRESSOR ANTI-SURGE SYSTEMS 0 KOSO KENT INTROL SUPPLIES A

More information

Betting Against Beta

Betting Against Beta Being Agains Bea Andrea Frazzini and Lasse H. Pedersen * This draf: Ocober 5, 2010 Absrac. We presen a model in which some invesors are prohibied from using leverage and oher invesors leverage is limied

More information

Time & Distance SAKSHI If an object travels the same distance (D) with two different speeds S 1 taking different times t 1

Time & Distance SAKSHI If an object travels the same distance (D) with two different speeds S 1 taking different times t 1 www.sakshieducaion.com Time & isance The raio beween disance () ravelled by an objec and he ime () aken by ha o ravel he disance is called he speed (S) of he objec. S = = S = Generally if he disance ()

More information

WORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI st CENTURY

WORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI st CENTURY CEPREMAP WORLD GROWTH AND INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL FLOWS IN THE XXI s CENTURY A prospecive analysis wih he INGENUE 2 model by he INGENUE TEAM Michel AGLIETTA and Vladimir BORGY (Cepii), Jean CHATEAU (Ocde),

More information

Breeding Incentive Programs and Demand for California Thoroughbred Racing: The Tradeoff Between Quantity and Quality. Martin D.

Breeding Incentive Programs and Demand for California Thoroughbred Racing: The Tradeoff Between Quantity and Quality. Martin D. Breeding Incenive Programs and Demand for California horoughbred Racing: he radeoff Beween Quaniy and Qualiy by Marin D. Smih Deparmen of Agriculural and Resource Economics Universiy of California, Davis

More information

Name Class Date. Step 2: Rearrange the acceleration equation to solve for final speed. a v final v initial v. final v initial v.

Name Class Date. Step 2: Rearrange the acceleration equation to solve for final speed. a v final v initial v. final v initial v. Skills Workshee Mah Skills Acceleraion Afer you sudy each sample problem and soluion, work ou he pracice problems on a separae shee of paper. Wrie your answers in he spaces provided. In 1970, Don Big Daddy

More information

INSTRUCTIONS FOR USE. This file can only be used to produce a handout master:

INSTRUCTIONS FOR USE. This file can only be used to produce a handout master: INSTRUCTIONS OR USE This file can only be used o produce a handou maser: Use Prin from he ile menu o make a prinou of he es. You may no modify he conens of his file. IMPORTNT NOTICE: You may prin his es

More information

AN ANALYSIS OF THE ECONOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY

AN ANALYSIS OF THE ECONOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY AN ANALYSIS OF THE ECOMIC EFFECT OF A ROAD DIET IN ELIZABETHTOWN AND GEORGETOWN, KENTUCKY MARCH 2014 This repor was produced a he reques of he Ron Sco, Ciy Manager for Danville, Kenucky, under he supervision

More information

Development of Urban Public Transit Network Structure Integrating Multi-Class Public Transit Lines and Transfer Hubs

Development of Urban Public Transit Network Structure Integrating Multi-Class Public Transit Lines and Transfer Hubs Developmen of Urban Public Transi Nework Srucure Inegraing Muli-Class Public Transi Lines and Transfer Hubs Zhenbao Wang 1, Anyan Chen 2 1College of Civil Engineering, Hebei Universiy of Engineering Handan,

More information

Instruction Manual. Rugged PCB type. 1 Terminal Block. 2 Function. 3 Series Operation and Parallel Operation. 4 Assembling and Installation Method

Instruction Manual. Rugged PCB type. 1 Terminal Block. 2 Function. 3 Series Operation and Parallel Operation. 4 Assembling and Installation Method Rugged PCB ype Insrucion Manual 1 Terminal Block Funcion.1...4.5.6.7 Inpu volage range Inrush curren limiing Overcurren proecion Overvolage proecion Oupu volage adjusmen range Isolaion Remoe ON/OFF E9

More information

A Statistical, Age-Structured, Life-History-Based Stock Assessment Model for Anadromous Alosa

A Statistical, Age-Structured, Life-History-Based Stock Assessment Model for Anadromous Alosa American Fisheries Sociey Symposium 35:275 283, 2003 2003 by he American Fisheries Sociey A Saisical, Age-Srucured, Life-Hisory-Based Sock Assessmen Model for Anadromous Alosa A. JAMIE F. GIBSON 1 Acadia

More information

2nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transport Technology For Regional Competitiveness

2nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transport Technology For Regional Competitiveness nd Regional Conference On Enhancing Transpor Technology For Regional Compeiiveness SESSION C TBLE OF CONTENTS PREFCE... 4 ORGNISING COITTEE... 5 KEYNOTE DDRESS... 6 Session : UTOOTIE... 7 Session B : ERONUTICS...

More information

Centre for Investment Research Discussion Paper Series. Momentum Profits and Time-Varying Unsystematic Risk

Centre for Investment Research Discussion Paper Series. Momentum Profits and Time-Varying Unsystematic Risk Cenre for Invesmen Research Discussion Paper Series Discussion Paper # 08-0* Momenum Profis and Time-Varying Unsysemaic Risk Cenre for Invesmen Research O'Rahilly Building, Room 3.0 Universiy College Cork

More information

FIVE RISK FACTORS MODEL: PRICING SECTORAL PORTFOLIOS IN THE BRAZILIAN STOCK MARKET

FIVE RISK FACTORS MODEL: PRICING SECTORAL PORTFOLIOS IN THE BRAZILIAN STOCK MARKET Revisa Caarinense da Ciência Conábil, ISSN 1808-3781 - eissn 2237-7662, Florianópolis, SC, Brazil, v. 16, n. 48, p. 81-98, May/Aug. 2017 doi: 10.16930/2237-7662/rccc.v16n48.2376 Available a hp://revisa.crcsc.org.br

More information

Overreaction and Underreaction : - Evidence for the Portuguese Stock Market -

Overreaction and Underreaction : - Evidence for the Portuguese Stock Market - Overreacion and Underreacion : - Evidence for he Poruguese Sock Marke - João Vasco Soares* and Ana Paula Serra** March 2005 * Faculdade de Economia da Universidade do Poro ** (corresponding auhor) CEMPRE,

More information

Is the Decline in the Frequency of Draws in Test Match Cricket Detrimental to the Long Form of the Game? # Liam J. A. Lenten *

Is the Decline in the Frequency of Draws in Test Match Cricket Detrimental to the Long Form of the Game? # Liam J. A. Lenten * Is he Decline in he Frequency of Draws in Tes Mach Cricke Derimenal o he Long Form of he Game? # Liam J. A. Lenen * Deparmen of Economics and Finance La Trobe Universiy Absrac The frequency of draws in

More information

RECOMMENDATION FOR INTERCHANGEABLE STUD BOLTS AND TAP END STUDS FOR API SPEC 6A FLANGES

RECOMMENDATION FOR INTERCHANGEABLE STUD BOLTS AND TAP END STUDS FOR API SPEC 6A FLANGES Issue Dae: June 6 15 Revision B June 2010 RECOMMENDAION FOR INERCHANGEABE UD BO AND A END UD FOR AI EC 6A FANGE ECHNICA REOR R501 Revision B AWHEM publicaions may be use by anyone esiring o o so. Every

More information

A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Details and Extended Results

A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Details and Extended Results WORKING PAPER 2006-03 Resource Economics and Policy Analysis (REPA) Research Group Deparmen of Economics Universiy of Vicoria A Dynamic Bioeconomic Model of Ivory Trade: Deails and Exended Resuls G. Cornelis

More information

Clemco Industries Corp. ISO 9001 Certified

Clemco Industries Corp. ISO 9001 Certified Clemco Indusries Corp. ISO 9001 Cerified 6 cuf Classic Blas Machines Exclusively from... SIMPLE, RUGGED, RELIABLE More han 75 years of reliable field service have made Clemco blas machines he preferred

More information

EFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY

EFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY EFFECTS OF WIND SPEED ON WIND TURBINE AVAILABILITY S. Faulsich 1, P. Lyding 1, P. J. Tavner 2 1 Fraunhofer Insiue for Wind Energy and Energy Sysem Technology (IWES) 2 Energy Group, School of Engineering,

More information

Managing the abundance of bison in Yellowstone National Park, winter Chris Geremia, P. J. White, and Rick Wallen September 12, 2011

Managing the abundance of bison in Yellowstone National Park, winter Chris Geremia, P. J. White, and Rick Wallen September 12, 2011 Managing he abundance of bison in Yellowsone Naional Park winer 2012 Chris Geremia P. J. Whie and Rick Wallen Sepember 12 2011 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Background Yellowsone Naional Park (YNP) developed a plan

More information

connection Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod technology with specialist manufacturers from around the world

connection Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod technology with specialist manufacturers from around the world Making he connecion Glen Smale discusses racing engine con rod echnology wih specialis manufacurers from around he world Making he connecion necessary beween he op end and he boom end of he racing engine

More information

Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development Animal and Plant Health Regulatory Directorate

Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development Animal and Plant Health Regulatory Directorate Minisry of Agriculure and Rural Developmen Animal and Plan Healh Regulaory Direcorae Checklis for saus of slaugherhouses for cale, sheep and goas (General informaion) i Addis Ababa Ehiopia 1 1. Background

More information

Reexamining Sports-Sentiment Hypothesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Istanbul

Reexamining Sports-Sentiment Hypothesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Istanbul Reexamining Spors-Senimen Hypohesis: Microeconomic Evidences from Borsa Isanbul Ka Wai Terence Fung +, Ender Demir, Chi Keung Marco Lau And Kwok Ho Chan * Absrac This paper examines he impac of inernaional

More information

Sensors and Actuators A: Physical

Sensors and Actuators A: Physical Sensors and Acuaors A 144 (2008) 354 360 Conens liss available a ScienceDirec Sensors and Acuaors A: Physical journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locae/sna A micro-robo fish wih embedded SMA wire acuaed

More information

INSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL

INSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL IMPORTANT SAFETY INSTRUCTIONS SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLEASE READ THE ENTIRE CONTENTS OF THIS MANUAL PRIOR TO INSTALLATION AND OPERATION. BY PROCEEDING WITH LIFT INSTALLATION AND OPERATION YOU AGREE THAT

More information

Making Sense of Genetics Problems

Making Sense of Genetics Problems Bio 101 Ms. Bledsoe Making Sense of Geneics roblems Monohbrid crosses Le s sar wih somehing simle: crossing wo organisms and waching how one single rai comes ou in he offsring. Le s use eas, as Mendel

More information

SWIMMING POOL HEAT PUMP UNITS. Installation & Instruction Manual DURA - series

SWIMMING POOL HEAT PUMP UNITS. Installation & Instruction Manual DURA - series SWIMMIG POO HEAT PUMP UITS Insallaion & Insrucion Manual DUA - series ev. 1.12 29.07.2014 Conens SWIMMIG POO HEAT PUMP UITS... 1! Conens... 2! 1. Preface... 3! 2. Specificaions... 4! 2.1 Technical daa

More information

Coefficients of Propeller-hull Interaction in Propulsion System of Inland Waterway Vessels with Stern Tunnels

Coefficients of Propeller-hull Interaction in Propulsion System of Inland Waterway Vessels with Stern Tunnels hp://www.ransnav.eu he Inernaional Journal on Marine Navigaion and Safey of Sea Transporaion Volume 8 Number 3 Sepember 214 DOI: 1.12716/11.8.3.8 Coefficiens of Propeller-hull Ineracion in Propulsion Sysem

More information

THE PERSISTENCY OF INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION BENEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL

THE PERSISTENCY OF INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION BENEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL ASIA ACADEMY of MAAGEMET JOURAL of ACCOUTIG and FIACE AAMJAF, Vol. 10, o. 1, 151 165, 014 THE PERSISTECY OF ITERATIOAL DIVERSIFICATIO BEEFITS: THE ROLE OF THE ASYMMETRY VOLATILITY MODEL Ung Sze ie 1*,

More information

29 B ROUTE Bus Times Summer NOTES a = Time at Vicarage Way. * = On Schooldays bus operates up to 5 minutes later.

29 B ROUTE Bus Times Summer NOTES a = Time at Vicarage Way. * = On Schooldays bus operates up to 5 minutes later. Brighon Lewes Ringmer / Touris Aracions Lewes for Hisoric own wih Casle; Isfield for Lavender Line Railway; for Spa Valley Railway, Paniles CiySAVER ickes are only valid beween Brighon and Falmer. nework

More information

US 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017

US 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 US009615553B2 (12) Unied Saes Paen Coniglio e al. (10) Paen No.: (45) Dae of Paen: US 9,615,553 B2 Apr. 11,2017 (54) ARTIFICIAL

More information

Improvement of individual camouflage through background choice in ground-nesting birds

Improvement of individual camouflage through background choice in ground-nesting birds This is he pre-proof acceped version of he manuscrip, he full version can be accessed for free here. Improvemen of individual camouflage hrough background choice in ground-nesing birds Auhors: Marin Sevens*1,

More information

COIN th JRC Annual Training on Composite Indicators and MCDA 22-26/09/2014, Ispra IT. Dorota Weziak-Bialowolska.

COIN th JRC Annual Training on Composite Indicators and MCDA 22-26/09/2014, Ispra IT. Dorota Weziak-Bialowolska. Doroa Weziak-Bialowolska 1h JRC Annual Training on Comosie ndiaors and MCDA Doroa Weziak-Bialowolska 1h JRC Annual Training on Comosie ndiaors and MCDA Normalizaion vs. denominaion 1 h JRC Annual Training

More information

World War 2 when Japan

World War 2 when Japan Chaper 30 Reading Guide Chaper 30 Reading Guide A Second Global Conflic and he End of he European World Order A Second Global Conflic and he End of he European World Order Name: Name: Name: Due Dae: Wednesday,

More information

MULTIVARIATE RISK-RETURN DECISION MAKING WITHIN DYNAMIC ESTIMATION

MULTIVARIATE RISK-RETURN DECISION MAKING WITHIN DYNAMIC ESTIMATION Economic Analysis Working Papers.- 7h Volume Number 11 MULIVARIAE RISK-REURN DECISION MAKING WIHIN DYNAMIC ESIMAION Josip Arnerić 1, Elza Jurun, and Snježana Pivac, 3 Universiy of Spli, Faculy of Economics,

More information

Population size and exploitation of giant squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 1835) in the Gulf of California, Mexico*

Population size and exploitation of giant squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 1835) in the Gulf of California, Mexico* SCI. AR., 65 (): 75-8 SCIENIA ARINA 2 Populaion size and exploiaion of gian squid (Dosidicus gigas D Orbigny, 835) in he Gulf of California, exico* ENRIQUE ORALES-BOJÓRQUEZ, AGUSÍN HERNÁNDEZ-HERRERA 2,

More information

INVERTER HEATPUMP FOR SWIMMING POOLS

INVERTER HEATPUMP FOR SWIMMING POOLS IVE HEATPUMP FO SWIMMIG POOS Insallaion & Insrucion Manual hea pumps 0-0071-1611 Table of conens 1. Preface 3. Specificaions.1 Performance Daa. Dimensions 6 3. Insallaion and Connecion 3.1 Hea Pump ocaion

More information

I t ' 4 ti. t ti. IQ:::: mass x heat of fusion (or heat of vaporization) I HEAT AND ITS MEASUREMENT. t t. t f I I I. Name

I t ' 4 ti. t ti. IQ:::: mass x heat of fusion (or heat of vaporization) I HEAT AND ITS MEASUREMENT. t t. t f I I I. Name HEAT AND TS MEASUREMENT Name a (or energy) can be measured in unis of calories or joules. When here is a,,,,,,nperaure change (AT), hea (Q) can be calculaed using his formula: During a phase change, we

More information

OPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY GO-KART

OPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY GO-KART Journal of Ecological Engineering Volume 17, Issue 5, Nov. 016, pages 90 95 DOI: 10.1911/998993/65454 Research Aricle OPTIMAL ENERGY SOURCE FOR AN ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY GO-KART Pior Zbigniew Filip 1,

More information

A Simple Approach to Dynamic Material Balance in Gas-Condensate Reservoirs

A Simple Approach to Dynamic Material Balance in Gas-Condensate Reservoirs Oil & Gas Science and Technology Rev. IFP Energies nouvelles, Copyrigh 23, IFP Energies nouvelles DOI:.256/ogs/2222 Vol. 69 (24), No. 2, pp. 37-37 A Siple Approach o Dynaic Maerial Balance in Gas-Condensae

More information

On convexity of SD efficiency sets - no short sales case

On convexity of SD efficiency sets - no short sales case 4. mezinárodní konference Řízení a modelování finančních rizik Osrava VŠB-U Osrava Ekonomická fakula kaedra Financí.-. září 008 On conveiy of SD efficiency ses - no shor sales case Miloš Kopa Absrac his

More information

INSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL

INSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL EUROPEN USERS 400V 0Hz SUPPLY DETILS RE IN- CLUDED WITH ELECTRICL CONTROL BOX. DISREGRD SUPPLY WIRING DETILS IN THIS MNUL IMPORTNT SFETY INSTRUCTIONS SVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLESE RED THE ENTIRE CONTENTS

More information

DIMENSIONS AC Road travel

DIMENSIONS AC Road travel DIMENSIONS AC 10009 Road ravel 04 DIMENSIONS AC 10009 Lifing operaion OUTRIGGER BASES TO CHOOSE FROM: A 13.54m x 13.538m B 12.0m x 12.0m (NEW) C 9.671m x 9.885m 05 HA /SSL (HA50) AC 10009 AC 10009 17 HA

More information

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS USING CORRECTED INITIAL VELOCITY DURING OVERHEAD SMASH

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS USING CORRECTED INITIAL VELOCITY DURING OVERHEAD SMASH Journal of Engineering Science and Technolog Special Issue on AASEC 6, Ocober (7) 9-5 School of Engineering, Talor s Uniersi COMPARATIVE STUDY OF VELOCITY REDUCTION ON FEATHER AND SYNTHETIC SHUTTLECOCKS

More information

Original Article. Physiological characteristics and physical fitness of girls at the beginning of classes at the volleyball sports school

Original Article. Physiological characteristics and physical fitness of girls at the beginning of classes at the volleyball sports school Journal of Physical Educaion and Spor (JPES), 17(4), Ar 276, pp. 2467-2471, 2017 online ISSN: 2247-806X; p-issn: 2247 8051; ISSN - L = 2247-8051 JPES Original Aricle Physiological characerisics and physical

More information

DIN, EN, ASTM. Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам. Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту ASME 16.48

DIN, EN, ASTM. Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам.  Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту ASME 16.48 Металлопрокат и трубы по стандартам DIN, EN, STM Поставляем металлопрокат по стандарту SME 16.48 Для заказа металлопроката или получения консультации обращайтесь по следующим контактам: Россия: +7 (495)

More information

R410A Rotary Compressor Bearing Design Considerations

R410A Rotary Compressor Bearing Design Considerations Prde Universiy Prde e-pbs Inernaional Compressor Engineering Conference School of Mechanical Engineering 1998 R41A Roary Compressor Bearing Design Consideraions J. R. Lenz Tecmseh Prodcs Company Follow

More information

An Autonomous Blimp for the Wall Following Control.

An Autonomous Blimp for the Wall Following Control. An Auonomous Blimp for he Wall Following Conrol. Seung-Yong Oh *,**, Chi- Won Roh *, Sung- Chul Kang *, Eun-ai Kim ** * Inelligen Roboics Research Cener, Korea Insiue of Science an echnology, Seoul, Korea

More information

MANAGING THE BULLWHIP EFFECT. Joseph H. Wilck, IV. Ph.D. Dual Degree, Industrial Engineering and Operations Research, College of Engineering

MANAGING THE BULLWHIP EFFECT. Joseph H. Wilck, IV. Ph.D. Dual Degree, Industrial Engineering and Operations Research, College of Engineering MANAGING THE BULLWHIP EFFECT Joseph H. Wilck, IV Ph.D. Dual Degree, Industrial Engineering and Operations Research, College of Engineering ABSTRACT The bullwhip effect is the inherent increase in demand

More information

Cal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P.

Cal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P. Cal. 7T85 INSTRUCTIONS (P. 3) BEDIENUNGSANLEITUNG (S. 27) INSTRUCTIONS (P. 51) ISTRUZIONI (P. 75) INSTRUCCIONES (P. 99) INSTRUÇÕES (P. 123) (147 ) You are now he proud owner of a SEIKO Analogue Quarz Wach

More information

Genetic Mapping Exercise - Extra Credit. Do not work together - each person to do their own work.

Genetic Mapping Exercise - Extra Credit. Do not work together - each person to do their own work. Geneic Mapping Execise - Exa Cedi Name Secion # Do no ok ogehe - each peson o do hei on ok. hen loci of diffeen allelic goups ae on he same chomosome, linkage occus bu is no absolue. Cossing-ove alays

More information

Architectural PORTFOLIO CALL FOR ENTRIES SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM. Presented by. See back page for photo credits.

Architectural PORTFOLIO CALL FOR ENTRIES SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM. Presented by. See back page for photo credits. rchiecural PORTFOLIO T H I R T Y - F I F T H N N U L 2017 CLL FOR ENTRIES See back page for phoo credis. Presened by SCHOOLDESIGNS.COM Receive naional acclaim for YOUR EDUCTION DESIGN PROJECTS WWW.SUMG.COM

More information

DRINKING WATER PIPE SYSTEM. The blue line

DRINKING WATER PIPE SYSTEM. The blue line DRINKING WATER PIPE SYSTEM The blue line Hanbook 2014 Inex The following coonly use abbreviaions are foun in his caalogue. Abbreviaion Descripion Uni A Cross-secional area 2 Ousie iameer of pipe i Insie

More information

INSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL

INSTALLATION AND OPERATION MANUAL EUROPEN USERS 400V 50Hz SUPPLY DETILS RE INCLUDED WITH ELECTRICL CONTROL BOX. DISREGRD SUPPLY WIRING DETILS IN THIS MNUL IMPORTNT SFETY INSTRUCTIONS SVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS PLESE RED THE ENTIRE CONTENTS

More information

SeriouslyFun! It s Business asunusual. Presented by CORAL HOSPITALITY. Contact our meeting and conference planners today.

SeriouslyFun! It s Business asunusual. Presented by CORAL HOSPITALITY. Contact our meeting and conference planners today. DESTINATIONS Presened by CORAL HOSPITALITY I s Business asunusual I s all abou keeping ha compeiive edge. When you ravel for business, he independenly-owned and operaed desinaions under Coral managemen

More information

Wall Lot. Priority. Public Parking. Center. Vallejo St. P ac if ic Walton Square. Ja ck so n. Chinatown. B a tte r. M o n tg o K e ar n y G ra n t A

Wall Lot. Priority. Public Parking. Center. Vallejo St. P ac if ic Walton Square. Ja ck so n. Chinatown. B a tte r. M o n tg o K e ar n y G ra n t A F ilb m b G re e n S ve Vallejo WORKSHOP #1 OUTOES Exploraorium Prioriy uodesk roadcas ener Prioriy roadw Fall 2014 Workshops Summy Law Offices ay The Waefron Resauran & afe oquea Golden Gaeway ommons

More information

MillSlicer PMC Phalaborwa AG Mill Ini4al Installa4on Trends and Results

MillSlicer PMC Phalaborwa AG Mill Ini4al Installa4on Trends and Results MillSlicer PMC Phalaborwa AG Mill Ini4al Installa4on Trends and Results The following items obtained from the first couple days of system installaion are presented in the next several slides: I. PMC Single

More information