Analysis!of!Rainforest!Alliance!Report!on!the!Verification!of!Progress!Related!to!Enabling!Activities! for!the!guyana"norway!redd+!agreement!!!
|
|
- Stewart Waters
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 April14,2011 HansBrattskar Director NorwegianInternationalClimateandForestInitiative(NICFI) TensieWhelan ExecutiveDirector RainforestAlliance AnalysisofRainforestAllianceReportontheVerificationofProgressRelatedtoEnablingActivities fortheguyana"norwayredd+agreement DearAmbassadorBrattskarandMs.Whelan: TheaboveorganizationshaveworkedinGuyanaandhavefolloweddevelopmentstherecloselyfor thepastdecade,andinsomeinstancesevenlonger.beingfamiliarwiththesituationinguyanaand withthenorway"guyanamemorandumofunderstanding(mou),wewouldliketoshareour analysisandconcernswiththerainforestalliance srecentreportontheverificationofprogresson EnablingActivitiesundertheREDD+Agreement.Theobjectiveofthebriefanalysisattachedtothis letteristosupportthestrengtheningofthemouanditsimplementation. Ourover"ridingconcernisthattheRainforestAlliancereportdoesnotprovideanaccuratepictureof progressontheground.itreliesheavilyonstatementsmadebygovernmentofficialsandon governmentdocuments,ratherthanonindependentverificationofthosestatements,oronthe progressoftheenablingactivities.thisisinpartduetothelimitationsofthefieldworkconducted, astheteamspentonlyonedayoutsideofgeorgetownandthereforehadextremelylimited exposuretoinputfromactorsintheinteriorofthecountry.yetthisiswheretheinitiativescurrently beingconsideredbytheguyanaredd+investmentfund(grif)willhavemostimpact.otherkey concernsinclude: Thereportconcludeswithrespecttosomeindicatorsthatframeworksareinplaceandbeing implemented,whilstsimultaneouslyacknowledgingalackofinformationonwhichtobasean assessment. Itpresentsasuperficialassessmentoffundamentalproblemsrelatingtoindigenouspeoples rightsandtenure. Page1of7
2 Itfailstoaccuratelydiagnoseproblemsregardingpublicavailabilityofinformationand incorrectlyequates outreach with consultation. Itunderminesthenotionofindependence,bydecliningtoeitherreviewimportantindependent literature,orraiseconcernsregardingself"censorshipandanonymityofpersonsinterviewed. OuranalysisdoesnotreflectanexhaustiveanalysisoftheRainforestAllianceReport,butaddresses someofourmainconcerns.therainforestallianceconsiderstheframeworkforitsreport,issued March10,2011,asaworkingdraft,andrequestsinputtoimproveit i.weprovideouranalysisasa contributiontoastrengthenedverificationprocessandfuturereporting. Wewouldbehappytodiscussanypointwithyouinmoredetail,andlookforwardtoyourresponse. Sincerely, GlobalWitness ForestManagementTrust ForestPeoplesProgramme RainforestFoundationNorway RainforestFoundationUK RainforestFoundationUS Page2of7
3 AnalysisofRainforestAllianceReportontheVerificationofProgressRelated toenablingactivitiesfortheguyana"norwayredd+agreement WewelcomesomeimportantpointstheReportmakes: ItrightlyverifiesthatrobustsafeguardsarelackinginboththeREDD+process(underthe WorldBank"coordinatedForestCarbonPartnershipFacility(FCPF)andinthePresident slow CarbonDevelopmentStrategy(LCDS)process ii,andrecommendsaddressingtheissuein futureprogressreports. Itrecognizesthat thereducedlevelofconsultationin2010hasalsocreateduncertaintyas tothestateofredd+activitiesoverall iii (thoughasdescribedbelow,itdoesnotaddress seriousflawsintheconsultationprocessitself). ItcallsontheGovernmentofGuyana(GOG)toprovideclearerinformationtothepublic,an issueweandmanyothershavebroughtupseveraltimesincludingthenear"absenceof responsefromthepresident sofficeofclimatechange(occ)toquestionsraisedduringthe initialconsultationsandquestionsandcommentsraisedinthepressontheocc sprogress reports; iv thereportfurtherreferencesthelackofprovisionofinformationonthe constraints,limitations,challenges v relatedtoredd+investments andhowthelackof informationleadstouncertainty. vi ItcorrectlyidentifiestheseriousdisconnectbetweentheGuyanaForestryCommission(GFC) REDD+planningandtheOCCLCDSinitiative. vii However,wearedeeplyconcernedaboutanumberoffundamentalissuesrelatedtotheReport: Itbasesverificationofcompliancewithenablingconditionslargelyonviewsandreportsof governmentrepresentatives,consultantsandmembersofthemulti"stakeholdersteering CommitteeoftheLCDS.Thelistofpersonsinterviewedshowsalargeproportionof governmentofficials viii,whilealmosthalfofallmeetingsduringtheverificationmissionwere alsowithgovernment(11outof23meetings). ix Withoutgoingthroughaconcertedeffortto reachstakeholderswhomaybeintimidatedtocomeforward,thisisinsufficienttoreflectin abalancedwaytheviewsofallstakeholders.ingeneral,thereportseemstosimplytickoff whethersomethingisreportedintheoccprogressreports,withoutevaluatingiftheentry isameaningfulactivitywithrespecttothe enabler.inseveralcases,government documentsarecitedasverificationofactivitiesundertaken,withinsufficientdouble" checkingastowhethertheactivitiesindeedtookplace,orachievedthedesiredresults x.for example,theformationofcommittees,suchasfortheredd"plusgovernancedevelopment Plan,isclaimedasprogressbytheGOG,andRainforestAllianceverifiestheGOGassurance, buttherearenopublicminutestoconfirmthatthesecommitteeshavebeenactive.a methodologybasedonobtaining,cross"checkingandverifyinginformationfrommultiple sourcesshouldhavebeenutilizedandrigorouslyapplied xi. Page3of7
4 Therewasinsufficienttimeinthefield:theRainforestAllianceverificationprocesswas limitedduetotimeandfundingconstraints.thispreventedtheteamfromspendingtimein theinteriorand constrainedfieldworkintheinteriorofguyananecessaryformore definitivereviewofperformancerelatedtoenablingindicators xii.theteamspentoneday visitingtheamerindiancommunityofsaintcuthbertandtheregion10forestproducer s Association,bothrelativelynearGeorgetown.Thelackoftimeintheinteriortherefore underminesthevalidityofthereport,andcontributedtothelackofstakeholdervoicesinit. Itrecognizesalackofcrucialinformationonsomeindicators,yetstilldrawsconclusions: therainforestalliancepointsoutinseveralplacesthatthereisessentiallynoinformationon whichtomeasureprogressontheindicators.thisisparticularlytrueinthecaseofenabling Indicator#1(StrategicFramework),wherenoneoftheindicatorsonfinancialplanningor reportingwereinplace xiii,andinenablingindicator#4(financialmechanism)asfundshad notbeendisbursedthroughthegrifprocessatthetimefieldworkwasconducted.these accuratestatementsshouldnot,however,leadtothereport sconclusionregardingenabling Indicator#1that Astrategicframeworkisinplaceandbeingimplemented. xiv Indeed,the factthatprogressonsomeoftheenablingindicatorscouldnotbeverifiedduetotimingor delaysinfundingmeanstheyshouldnotbeinthescopeoftherainforestalliance verificationreport,butthattheymustberigorouslyaddressedinthenextroundof verification.similarconcernsaretrueforthe Opt"in mechanism;adraftdocumentwas preparedbytheoccinmarch2010,thoughmostpeoplehaveneverseenit,asithasnot beeninthepublicdomain. xv TheverificationofEnablingIndicator#6ontherightsofindigenouspeoplesandlocal forestcommunitiesisdeficient:thesummaryanalysisandassessmentofthisindicatordo notverifywhetherornotrightsarebeingrespectedinreddandlcdsprocessesaslaidout inthemou.theverificationteamwasexpectedtouse writtenrecords toassess attainmentofthisindicator,butdoesnotappeartohaveexaminedindependentreports thatpinpointthefailureofcurrentredd+orlcdsplanstoupholdfundamentalrights(e.g. indigenouspeoples righttofreepriorinformedconsent(fpic)islargelyconfinedtotitled lands,contrarytotheinternationalobligationsofguyanathatitmustalsorespectthisright inrelationtountitledcustomarylands).problemswithrightsframeworksinguyanaare describedinnumerousdocumentsinthepublicdomain xvi,includingonthewebsiteof ForestPeoplesProgramme,andhavebeencommunicatedtotheWorldBank,UNDPand Inter"AmericanDevelopmentBank,includingcommentsontheincompatibilityofnational legislationwithboththenationalconstitutionandinternationalstandards.whilethe RainforestAlliancereportnotesthat...Guyana spolicyonlandrightshasbeencriticizedby theunitednations xvii therootofthismatterandguyana sfailuretoadequatelysafeguard indigenouspeoples landandterritorialrightsarenotspelledoutbytheverificationteam. Thereportappearstosuggestincorrectlythatrightsarebeingaddressedadequately,but thatgogissimplynotcommunicatingthispointeffectively. xviii Independentevidence showstheproblemsaremorefundamentalinnature,andrequireanintegratedapproach includinglegislativereformandtheimplementationofthelong"stallednationalpolicyon integratedlanduseplanning. Page4of7
5 Itfailstoaccuratelydiagnoseproblemsregardingpublicavailabilityofinformation: Althoughinsomeinstancesthereportexpressesconcernaboutthelackofpubliclyavailable information(seeabove),it verifies thatkeydocumentslinkedtothelcdsandguyana" NorwayMoUare publiclyavailable,wheninpracticetheyarenotreadilyavailableinthe publicdomaininguyana xix.assertionsbygovernmentofficialsthatdocumentsare public couldbecross"checkedinastraightforwardwaybytalkingtopeopleatthevillageleveland alsowithorganizationsoutsidethemulti"stakeholdersteeringcommittee(e.g.regarding theseptember2010draftredd+governancedevelopmentplan):auditorsappearnotto havecarriedoutbasictriangulationtocross"checkthevalidityofinformationgathered.as thereportrightlypointsout,thegogreliesoverlyontheuseofwebsitesformaking informationavailable xx butthesesitesgivealmostnoinformationaboutworkinprogress.in addition,reportsandotherdocumentsonthelcdsandgfcwebsitesoftenseemtobe delayed,removed,unavailable,orinaccessible.thelackoftimeintheinteriorisespecially relevanthere,asinformationthatispubliclyavailableontheinternetisnotactuallypublicly availabletocommunitiesintheinteriorwhohavenoaccesstointernet,butwhostandtobe affectedbytheplans,regardlessofwhetherthey opt"in ornot.thisisafundamental shortcomingintheverificationprocess.inthemostrecentminutes(for26january2011)of themulti"stakeholdersteeringcommittee,theoccacknowledgesthatevensomemembers ofthecommitteedonotunderstandsomeoftheissues,despitehavingattended37 meetings. Itincorrectlyequates outreach with consultation :Thereportinseveralplacesseemsto treat outreach (informationsharing)with consultation (i.e.askingpeopleandgroupsfor theirviews,iftheyhavequestionsandansweringthoseandaddressingconcerns). Verificationhasfundamentallyfailedtoassesstowhatextentmeaningfulpublicmulti" stakeholderconsultationhastakenplace,ifany.thereportalsoreliesheavilyonthe previousreportbytheinternationalinstituteofenvironmentanddevelopment(iied),which itselfcameunderpublicscrutiny xxi.theiiedreportconcludedthatthe2009consultations were preliminary only.inannex1totheiiedreport, Opinionontheparticipationof IndigenousPeoplesinLCDSProcess,Multi"StakeholderSteeringCommitteememberDavid Jamesstatedthatthe2009consultations couldbedescribedaspartofthefirststageofthe FPICprocesswhichwasprimarilytoshareinformationwiththecommunitiesandalsoto receiveinitialfeedback.whiletherainforestalliancereportassertsthatintense stakeholderinteraction tookplacein2009,thereismuchevidence xxii toshowthat effectiveconsultationhasnottakenplacesofaroneitherredd+orthelcds.thejobofthe auditoristoassesswhetheranactivityhasoccurredornotandifithas,todeterminethe qualityandeffectivenessoftheaction.again,thisiswherethelackoftimespentinthe interiorofguyanaisafundamentalflawinthereport.fromourexperience,mostlocal peoplehavelittleornounderstandingofthesepoliciesandhavenotbeenconsulted. Finally,theAuditorsseemtomistaketheMulti"StakeholderSteeringCommitteewith multi" stakeholderconsultation,whenthisbodyisjustonemechanismforpublicengagement, whichisinanyeventlimitedinitsabilitytoraisecriticisms(minutesofthemulti"stakeholder SteeringCommitteecanverifythis xxiii ).Thereportdoesnotreviewtheextenttowhichinput fromstakeholdershasbeenaddressedorincorporated forexample,thelackofpublic responsefromtheocctohundredsofstakeholderquestions. Page5of7
6 Itfailstoreviewimportantindependentliteratureandcivilsocietydocuments:Thereport doesnotcitenorlistanypresscoverage,independentngoreportsnorreferenceany statementsbyforestuserssuchasminersorloggers,theamerindianpeoplesassociationor communityleaders xxiv Itdoesnotraiseconcernsregardinganonymityofpersonsinterviewed:requestsfor anonymityaremostlikelyduetothelackofopennesstocriticalquestioninginguyana, wherethosewhodoraisecritiquesarequiteoftenlabeledasanti"government,anti" development,andunpatriotic xxv.thisobviouslyhasachillingeffect,anditisworthnoting thathalfofthosewhorequestedanonymitywereindigenous xxvi. ii RainforestAlliance(2011)VerificationofprogressrelatedtoenablingactivitiesfortheGuyana"Norway REDD+agreement,March10,2011atoverallconclusions,page4 ii Ibid,Indicator#1,page4. iii Ibid.Atoverallconclusions,Indicator#2,page4. iv Ibid,atOtherSummaryObservations,page5. v Ibid,seeSpecificObservation12"2010,page38,forexample. vi Ibid,seeIndicator1.2,pages vii Ibid.atIndicator1.6,page20inVerificationofEnablingIndicators.Indeed,acontinuedsourceofconfusion, notonlyinguyana,isthereferencetoredd+indifferentcontexts.theguyanaforestrycommission(gfc) hasbeeninvolvedintheworldbank"coordinatedforestcarbonpartnershipfacility.inthemay2010version ofthepresident slowcarbondevelopmentstrategy(lcds),thepresident sofficeofclimatechange(occ) listsgfcactivitiesasintegraltothelcds,althoughthelcdsisnowbeingportrayedasrelatedtoavoided deforestation.however,neitherthegfcnortheocchavemadeanyexplicitcommitmenttostabilizeor reduceemissionsofforestcarbon. viii Ibid.atsection3.5,pages14"15 ix Ibid.atsection3.4,pages13"14 x Ibid"seeverificationofEnablingIndicators1.4,1.7,2.3,andtheconclusionsofIndicator2. xi AsimilarmethodologywasrecentlyusedbytheEfecamissionforUSAIDontimberlegalityverification, whichmayproveusefulinfutureverificationreports. xii Ibid,atOtherSummaryObservationsOBS6/10,page6. xiii Ibid,Indicator1,pages xiv Ibid,page23. xv SeeIndicator2.2,page26,andIndicator6.2,page38. xvi Seeforexample:APAlettertoNORAD,March10,2010;CERDrecommendationsontheAmerindianAct, March21,2006. xvii Ibid.atIndicator2.2,page25 xviii Ibid.atIndicator6.1,pages37"38 xix ExamplesincludethefirsttwoversionsoftheLCDS,foursetsofMSSCminutesfrom2010,theFCPFR"PIN andr"planandfirstversionofther"pp,thetrevin/nasi(cifor)andcedergren(fao)consultancyreports from2009,theoriginalmckinsey&companyreportfrom2008,theemptyresponsespageonthelcds website. xx Ibid,seeIndicator6.1,page38. xxi StabroekNews,May4,2010.Membersoftheevaluationteamservedongovernmentdelegationsto FCPF/PC4andCOP"16,andwereseenasmembersofthegovernmentteamsduringconsultationsinthe interior. xxii Forexample:MSSCminutes,letterstothepress,questionstothePresidentviaGlobalWitnessanddirectly inthepress. Page6of7
7 xxiii SeeforexampletheMSSCminutesfrom16Marchand13April2010,whichreferexplicitlytotheneedfor themssctopresentaunifiedfrontincondemningthecriticismraisedinanapaworkshopstatementfrom March2010,aswellastheAPAasawhole.However,thelinksontheLCDSwebsitenolongerwork,further underliningtheproblemsaddressedhere. xxiv e.g.apastatementsmadeinmarch2010inaworkshoponlcdsanddevelopmentplanning;apaletterto NORAD,March2010;FPPbriefingofNovember2009;FPPE"newsletterarticlesof2010;REDDMonitor Articles;analysesbyJohnPalmer,includingStabroekNews4November2010;RainforestFoundation"UK paper.oncost"curves,november2010;andjanettebulkan,stabroeknewson04may2010. xxv Seereports,almostdaily,intheGuyanapress,andthereactionstotherecentlettersenttoMinisterErik SolheimbyGuyaneseacademics,researchers,andpoliticians. xxvi Ibid,page14. Page7of7
The Sports Betting Champ s Never Lost NFL Super Bowl Betting System
The Sports Betting Champ s Never Lost NFL Super Bowl Betting System Here s the Never Lost NFL Super Bowl Betting System. In a nutshell, you will be betting that once an underdog covers the spread in the
More informationMethod statement for. The installation of. Precast Concrete Piles. (Site Name).
Method statement for The installation of Precast Concrete Piles At (Site Name). 1 of 5 Standard Operating Procedures for Pile Driving. This method statement will outline how the authorised/ competent operatives
More informationRules & Regulations on Membership Approved (January 28, 2017) a. Regular Members shall meet all requirements in the ASA By-Laws and the following;
1. Membership Requirements Rules & Regulations on Membership Approved (January 28, 2017) a. Regular Members shall meet all requirements in the ASA By-Laws and the following; i. Must file with the ASA annually
More informationSample Sailing Instructions for Sanctitoned Lightning Class Championship Regattas
Sample Sailing Instructions for Sanctitoned Lightning Class Championship Regattas I. ORGANIZING AUTHORITY II. RULES III. NOTICE TO COMPETITORS IV. CHANGES TO SAILING INSTRUCTIONS V. SIGNALS MADE ASHORE
More informationCASH PRIZE SCHEME PREAMBLE
1 SCHEME PREAMBLE The Government through the Ministry of Youth and Sports encourages athletes to achieve the highest level of performance in the international arena. The Cash Prize Scheme is an incentive
More informationDatabank. India Census 1881
Institute for Social and Economic Change 7. Data Available in Microfiche Form: Databank Census of India data from 1871-1951 is available in microfiche form. India Census 1872 Name of the State Vol. Part
More informationABB NASOM Fun Run 2017
ABB NASOM Fun Run 2017 Day/date: Sunday/February 19, 2017 Time: 6.30 am 10.00 am Venue: Perdana Botanical Garden (Lake Gardens) A. Race Info a. Apparel Adult XXL XL L M S XS Children XL L M S b. Race Categories
More informationMATH TIMESAVERS By: STEVAN KRAJNJAN THIS BOOK BELONGS TO:
THIS BOOK BELONGS TO: MATH TIMESAVERS By: STEVAN KRAJNJAN Stop searching for those difficult-to-find, often-used forms and reproducible sheets for your math program. Math Timesavers has them all (K-8).
More informationPlease refer to the ISAF website for the details of the submissions on this agenda/referred to in these minutes.
Windsurfing & Kiteboarding Committee Agenda The Windsurfing & Kiteboarding Committee will meet at 09:30 13:30 hours on Sunday 4 November 2012 at the Royal St George Yacht Club, Dun Laoghaire, Dublin, Ireland
More informationYour grade may then be calculated by the following formula (Daily Points + Test Scores) / (# of days * 4 + # of tests * 100)
Martin Luther High School Physical Education 2017 2018 Mr. Taylor Rules: 1. Follow all rules as printed in the student handbook 2. The student will be in the gym in proper uniform no later than five minutes
More informationDEFINITION OF PENALTIES
C. AAU Nationals/AAU Junior Olympic Games: Your entry must be completed online and all entry fees sent to the AAU. You must also send a copy of what you are entering for the AAU National/AAU Junior Olympic
More informationDEFINITION OF PENALTIES
V. Technical Coach A. You must be an AAU member. B. You must complete the PCA training online for all coaches. C. You must follow the AAU Baton Twirling Rules that have been set forth. D. You must wear
More informationRhythmic Gymnastics Tournament. Carramba Cup , Katowice, Poland
Rhythmic Gymnastics Tournament Carramba Cup 2019 01-03.02.2019, Katowice, Poland It s our pleasure to invite you to 8th international Rhythmic Gymnastics Tournament Carramba Cup 2019 Goal: Place and date:
More informationTHE NATURAL RESOURCES BODY FOR WALES WATER RESOURCES ACT 1991 THE WALES ROD AND LINE (SALMON AND SEA TROUT) BYELAWS 2017
THE NATURAL RESOURCES BODY FOR WALES WATER RESOURCES ACT 1991 THE WALES ROD AND LINE (SALMON AND SEA TROUT) BYELAWS 2017 The Natural Resources Body for Wales in exercise of powers vested in it by section
More information2017 DISCOVERY CUP OFFICIAL RULES
2017 DISCOVERY CUP OFFICIAL RULES Tournament Headquarters will be located at the Discovery Sports Center at the Maryland SoccerPlex located at 18031 Central Park Circle, Boyds, MD 20841. I. TOURNAMENT
More informationMANUFACTURING TECHNICAL INSTRUCTIONS - SAFETY FALL HAZARD CONTROL REQUIREMENTS SERIES & NO. SMI - 157
1 of 6 1.0 PURPOSE To establish minimum requirements and guidelines for controlling hazardous exposure of personnel to falls from working elevations in conformance with Federal and State OSHA rules and
More informationOFFICIAL RULES AND REGULATIONS 2017
OFFICIAL RULES AND REGULATIONS 2017 I. UMPIRES The league will use A.S.A. Umpires for all regular season and playoff games. If no umpire shows for the game: Please call Rob Keane (516-375-8910), Dennis
More informationCity of Roseville - Adult Softball League Rules
City of Roseville - Adult Softball League Rules Summer, 2014 I. Season Format a. Mens Double Headers - All mens leagues will play a 10 week (20 game) regular season. There will be a regular season and
More information2016 YMCA YOUTH BASKETBALL RULES
2016 YMCA YOUTH BASKETBALL RULES I. PLAYING TIME a. All players must receive equal playing time regardless of previous experience or skill level. b. Playing time may not be limited by a player s inability
More informationTRADE SHOW AND CONVENTION INSTALLER AGREEMENT
TRADE SHOW AND CONVENTION INSTALLER AGREEMENT APRIL 1, 2015 - MARCH 31, 2018 SIGN, DISPLAY AND ALLIED CRAFTS LOCAL UNION NO. 510 GREATER SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA TABLE OF CONTENTS ARTICLE PAGE ACCRUED BENEFITS
More informationNRHSAA GIRLS GYMNASTICS
NRHSAA GIRLS GYMNASTICS 2015-2016 IMPORTANT: The policies that follow are specific to this sport and must be adhered to by every member of the NRHSAA. Each sport policy is numbered. Many of the Policies
More informationMILLER, Kelly. Digital Howard University. Howard University. MSRC Staff
Howard University Digital Howard @ Howard University Manuscript Division Finding Aids 10-1-2015 MILLER, Kelly MSRC Staff Follow this and additional works at: http://dh.howard.edu/finaid_manu Recommended
More informationLESS LETHAL, FLASH SOUND DIVERSIONARY DEVICE, CHEMICAL AGENTS INSTRUCTOR CERTIFICATION COURSE OVERVIEW AND INSTRUCTIONAL GOALS COURSE OVERVIEW
LESS LETHAL, FLASH SOUND DIVERSIONARY DEVICE, CHEMICAL AGENTS INSTRUCTOR CERTIFICATION COURSE OVERVIEW AND INSTRUCTIONAL GOALS COURSE LENGTH: 40 Hours 5 Days 29 Hours Classroom 11 Hours Practical COURSE
More informationTHE LIFE OF THOMAS HARDY
THE LIFE OF THOMAS HARDY THE LIFE OF THOMAS HARDY COMPILED LARGELY FROM CONTEMPORARY NOTES, LETTI!:RS, DIARIES, AND BIOGRAPHICAL MEMORANDA, AS WELL AS FROM ORAL INFORMATION IN CONVERSATIONS EXTENDING OVER
More informationDepartment of Biology Work Sheet Respiratory system
Department of Biology Work Sheet Respiratory system 1. Name the following : i. A muscular sheet separating the thoracic and abdominal cavities. ii. A respiratory tube supported by cartilaginous rings.
More informationNRHSAA GIRLS BASKETBALL
NRHSAA GIRLS BASKETBALL 2015-2016 IMPORTANT: The policies that follow are specific to this sport and must be adhered to by every member of the NRHSAA. Each sport policy is numbered. Many of the Policies
More informationBOOKS BY A. L. ROWSE
THE ENGLISH SPIRIT BOOKS BY A. L. ROWSE Literature WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE: A BIOGRAPHY SHAKESPEARE'S SONNETS: Edited with an Introduction and Notes CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE: A BIOGRAPHY SHAKESPEARE'S SOUTHAMPTON:
More informationGAS CYLINDERS RULES, 2004
GAS CYLINDERS RULES, 2004 In exercise of the powers conferred by sections 5 and 7 of the Explosives Act, 1884 (4 of 1884) and in suppression of the Gas Cylinders Rules, 1981, except in respect things done
More informationATTACHMENTS : LANDSCAPE MAPS AND PHOTO ESSAY
PAERATA - PUKEKOHE STRUCTURE PLAN : BACKGROUND INVESTIGATIONS AND VISUAL ASSESSMENT ATTACHMENTS : MAPS AND PHOTO ESSAY Opus International Consultants Ltd Landscape Architecture and Urban Design Level 3
More informationTOUR PROGRAMME OF CERAP
A.S. Bist Sr. AO, MPGWB3110285 H.S. Husain AAO, MPGWW2111783 Sunil Jha AAO MPGWW3111352 Months October Nov. December Transit to Nagda 10-10- (Night) 1. Central Excise Range-I, Nagda M/s Grasim Industries
More informationRules of Play March 2, 2018
Rules of Play March 2, 2018 Table of Contents I. Definitions... 2 II. Equipment... 3 III. Eligibility... 4 IV. Divisional Eligibility... 5 V. Seasonal Play... 5 VI. WS Berths... 6 VII. WS Berth Tournaments
More information13 th ANNUAL HILO minibig INDOOR SOCCER TOURNAMENT Edith Kanakaole Multi Purpose Stadium January 29 th 31 st, Rules and Regulations
13 th ANNUAL HILO minibig INDOOR SOCCER TOURNAMENT Edith Kanakaole Multi Purpose Stadium January 29 th 31 st, 2016 Rules and Regulations The Hilo minibig, is a Futsal style indoor soccer event utilizing
More informationRebreather Training Council Standard
: WARNING - IMPORTANT NOTICE - DISCLAIMER Scuba diving (Recreational and Technical) is a potentially dangerous activity that can result in serious injury and death. Diving with Rebreathers amplify inherent
More informationCHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION TO RELIABILITY
i CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION TO RELIABILITY ii CHAPTER-1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction: In the present scenario of global competition and liberalization, it is imperative that Indian industries become fully
More informationTHE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA HOUSE BILL
PRINTER'S NO. 1 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA HOUSE BILL No. 1 Session of 01 INTRODUCED BY GAINEY, DEAN, O'BRIEN, BULLOCK, KINSEY, McNEILL, V. BROWN, FRANKEL, SCHLOSSBERG, McCARTER, KIM, STURLA,
More informationCity of Roseville - Adult Softball League Rules
City of Roseville - Adult Softball League Rules Summer 2017 I. Season Format a. Double Headers - All double header leagues will play a 10 week (20 game) regular season. There will be a regular season and
More informationFAIRFIELD COUNTY SWIMMING LEAGUE TABLE OF CONTENTS
APPENDIX TABLE OF CONTENTS Appendix I FCSL Swimming & Diving Records 2-3 Appendix II History of the Fairfield County Swimming League 4-5 Appendices III: A, B, C The Championship Teams: Swimming Champions,
More informationChapter Two: Travel Agents, Tour Operators, Contracts and Legal Rights What You Need to Know... 9
Table of Contents Chapter One: Where to Sue: Changing the Playing Field Contractually... 1 I. Forum Selection Clauses... 3 II. Cruise Passenger Contracts... 3 III. Federal Forum Selection Clauses... 4
More informationEuropean Seniors Basketball Association (ESBA) REGULATIONS for Championship Pula 2018 (edited on March 14, 2018)
European Seniors Basketball Association (ESBA) REGULATIONS for Championship Pula 2018 (edited on March 14, 2018) I. GENERAL REGULATIONS 1. The rules of the current Regulations apply for championships organized
More informationKRAV MAGA LEVEL 1 CURRICULUM
KRAV MAGA LEVEL 1 CURRICULUM I. Fighting Stance a. This is the posture the defender takes preparing for a confrontation b. Foot Positions 1. Assuming defender is right handed, he should stand with his
More informationKRAV MAGA LEVEL 1 CURRICULUM
KRAV MAGA LEVEL 1 CURRICULUM Technique Breakdown I. Fighting Stance a. This is the posture the defender takes preparing for a confrontation b. Foot Positions 1. Assuming defender is right handed, he should
More informationInitial Review of Research Policy and Procedure
Effective: July 16, 2008 Revised: May 10, 2016 Revision: 4 Responsibility: OIRB Page 1 of 14 Table of Contents Policy Procedures Submission and Screening Assigning Reviewers Convened IRB review Expedited
More informationTHE MEMOIRS. JACQUES CASANOVA de SEINGALT
THE MEMOIRS OF JACQUES CASANOVA de SEINGALT 1725-1798 THE RARE UNABRIDGED LONDON EDITION OF 1894 TRANSLATED BY ARTHUR MACHEN TO WHICH HAS BEEN ADDED THE CHAPTERS DISCOVERED BY ARTHUR SYMONS. [Transcriber's
More informationOldrich Jindra coaching clinics. Drillbook Full ice 1-0
Oldrich Jindra coaching clinics Drillbook Full ice 1-0 Mag.Oldrich Jindra www.oldrich-jindra.com Full ice 1-0 Use drills like an option to work at skills, teach skills, not drills! Mag.Oldrich Jindra Philosophy
More informationAppendix: Tables. Table XI. Table I. Table II. Table XII. Table III. Table IV
Table I Table II Table III Table IV Table V Table VI Random Numbers Binomial Probabilities Poisson Probabilities Normal Curve Areas Exponentials Critical Values of t Table XI Table XII Percentage Points
More informationRAPPAHANNOCK RIVER YOUTH FOOTBALL LEAGUE
RAPPAHANNOCK RIVER YOUTH FOOTBALL LEAGUE CONSTITUTION & BY-LAWS Updated August, 2016 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Article I: Article II: Article III: Article IV: Article V: Article VI: Article VII: Article VIII:
More informationTitle: NFPA 70E Effective Date: 12/8/2014 Control Number: THG_0053 Revision Number: 1 Date: 10/26/2015 Annual Review Completed: 5/13/2015 NFPA 70E
Title: NFPA 70E Effective Date: 12/8/2014 Control Number: THG_0053 Revision Number: 1 Date: 10/26/2015 Annual Review Completed: 5/13/2015 CONTENTS NFPA 70E I. INTRODUCTION II. PURPOSE III. SCOPE IV. ENGINEERING
More informationNRHSAA GIRLS RUGBY
NRHSAA GIRLS RUGBY 2014-2015 IMPORTANT: The policies that follow are specific to this sport and must be adhered to by every member of the NRHSAA. Each sport policy is numbered. Sometimes within a sport
More informationTable of Contents. Foreword... xix. Preface...xxii. Section I Usage of Online Surveys and Measurements
Table of Contents Foreword... xix Preface...xxii Section I Usage of Online Surveys and Measurements Chapter I E-Survey Methodology / Karen J. Jansen, Kevin G. Corley, and Bernard J. Jansen... 1 Chapter
More informationBRN4D RULES & GUIDELINES (Effective July 1, 2017 June 30, 2018)
BRN4D RULES & GUIDELINES (Effective July 1, 2017 June 30, 2018) I MEMBERSHIP Membership dues will be $50.00 annually and include a monthly newsletter. Membership for each additional horse shall be $35.00
More informationQUARTERLY REPORT July - September Quarter SERIES NO. SDT:
QUARTERLY REPORT July - September Quarter SERIES NO. SDT: 21-146 i Table 1: Value of Domestic Exports, Re-exports, Imports and Balance of Trade by Month...1 Table 2: Balance of Trade by Institutional Sector...1
More informationCity of Grand Forks Staff Report
City of Grand Forks Staff Report Committee of the Whole November 27, 2017 City Council December 4, 2017 Agenda Item: Federal Transportation Funding Request Highway Safety Improvement Program Submitted
More informationNRHSAA GIRLS HOCKEY
NRHSAA GIRLS HOCKEY 2015-2016 IMPORTANT: The policies that follow are specific to this sport and must be adhered to by every member of the NRHSAA. Each sport policy is numbered. Many of the Policies in
More informationRates of various Line materials and Labour charges used in cost sheets for general works
Rates of various Line materials and Labour charges used in cost sheets for general works SL.NO Particulars Unit Materials rate in Rs. Labour charges (Casual) in Rs 1 2 3 4 5 RCC Poles a) 9.5 M 350kg WL
More informationLAST PG: * WE RESERVE THE RIGHT * ZERO TOLERANCE POLICY
I. COACHES RULES... 1 II. SPORTSMANSHIP... 1 III. SPECTATING RULES... 2 IV. GYM SITES GUIDELINES... 2 V. NO PROTESTING... 2 VI. EJECTIONS/SUSPENSIONS... 2 VII. CLOCK/TIME... 2 VIII. MERCY RULE... 3 IX.
More informationMissouri State Cup Rules
Missouri State Cup Rules I. PURPOSE a. These are the rules of the Missouri Youth Soccer Association (MYSA) - Missouri State Cup for the 13 & Under through 19 & Under Boys and Girls Divisions. The US Youth
More information2.2 Sports School Program (SSP) to be defined as a school-based hockey program; the following minimum criteria shall be met:
6.13 SPORT SCHOOL POLICY AND PROCEDURE Effective Date: September, 2014 Revised: July 2016 1.0 Introduction The purpose of this document is twofold: a. to provide the Branch Policy related to Sport Schools,
More informationMinistry of Finance Bulletin
Ministry of Finance Bulletin ISSUED: July 2004 REVISED: July 2014 Bulletin PNG 001 www.fin.gov.bc.ca/rev.htm Royalty Programs for Deep Gas Wells Petroleum and Natural Gas Act Latest Revision: The revision
More informationLCW3-YFFL OFFICIAL RULES
Revised as of August 14, 2018 2018 Lake Charles Ward 3 Recreation LCW3-YFFL OFFICIAL RULES (The 7/8 Year Old Leagues) These rules and regulations were put in place by the Directors of Ward 3 Recreation.
More informationContents ... TEACHER GUIDE NCTM Content Standards Assessment Rubric... 6 How Is Our Resource Organized? The NCTM Principles & Standards...
Contents... TEACHER GUIDE NCTM Content Standards Assessment Rubric.. 6 How Is Our Resource Organized?. 11 The NCTM Principles & Standards 12 STUDENT HANDOUTS Number and Operations Drill Sheets Warm-Up
More informationCorinthian Yacht Club of Bellingham 2015 Racing Series Race Packet
Corinthian Yacht Club of Bellingham 2015 Racing Series Race Packet Series 1: April 16, 23, 30, May 7, 14 Series 2: May 21, 28, June 4, 11, 18 Series 3: June 25, July 2, 9, 16, 23 Series 4: July 30 August
More informationTable of Contents. Section Two: Power Point Presentation... 21
Table of Contents Chapter One: A Decade of Difference The (R)evolution of Animal Law... 1 Bruce A Wagman, Esq. Growing Up With Animal Law: From Courtrooms to Casebooks... 3 I. Introduction... 5 II. Puppyhood...
More informationLORD OF THE RINGS 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION TEXT COMPARISON
LORD OF THE RINGS 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION TEXT COMPARISON Text (boldface = corrected) Edition Page HC/HM 1v 2004 = HarperCollins & Houghton Mifflin 1 vol. hardback 50th anniversary editions (deluxe and
More informationOperating Engineers Agreement
2014-2016 Operating Engineers Agreement TABLE OF CONTENTS Click on any heading below to view text Section Page Parties to Agreement... 1 Purpose... 1 Article I- General Provisions... 1 Definitions... Par.
More informationCBR Rules & Guidelines
CBR Rules & Guidelines I MEMBERSHIP Membership dues will be $40 annually. Your membership covers the Open, Youth, and Senior classes as you run them at races. Annual membership will run from September
More informationDemetrios Rotisserie Hockey Pool Rules
Demetrios Rotisserie Hockey Pool Rules September 22 2016 A list of all rules and calculations that apply to the league The hockey pool rules that govern the current season [Draft] Section 1: Roster, Statistics,
More informationRules & Regulations. January 2011 Yukigassen Canada Inc.
Rules & Regulations Under the guidance, direction and permission from the Showa-Shinzan International Yukigassen, the rules herein are the Official Rules & Regulations for all sanctioned Yukigassen Canada
More informationOFFICIAL RULES TWENTY- SIXTH ANNUAL DUBERSTEIN BANKRUPTCY MOOT COURT COMPETITION
OFFICIAL RULES TWENTY- SIXTH ANNUAL DUBERSTEIN BANKRUPTCY MOOT COURT COMPETITION March 3-5, 2018 Table of Contents CONTACT INFORMATION... 1 ORGANIZATION OF THE COMPETITION... 2 CERTIFICATION... 2 TEAMS...
More informationSYLVANIA NORTH STARS SEASON PROGRAM DETAILS. TIER I AAA TIER II AA Girls (4/25/2017)
SYLVANIA NORTH STARS 2017-2018 SEASON PROGRAM DETAILS TIER I AAA TIER II AA Girls (4/25/2017) DEVELOP. COMPETE. HAVE FUN. I. Introduction The Sylvania North Stars/Sylvania Youth Hockey (SYH) is a not-for-profit
More informationNSC CUP Youth Tournament Rules May 26-27, 2018
NSC CUP Youth Tournament Rules May 26-27, 2018 1 The NSC CUP will be played under FIFA Laws and Regulations in effect January 1, 2017 as modified by the Minnesota Youth Soccer Association with the following
More informationNRHSAA GIRLS VOLLEYBALL
NRHSAA GIRLS VOLLEYBALL 2015-2016 IMPORTANT: The policies that follow are specific to this sport and must be adhered to by every member of the NRHSAA. Each sport policy is numbered. Many of the Policies
More informationCo-ed Flag Football Rules
Co-ed Flag Football Rules OBJECTIVE Every effort has been made by rule and appropriate penalty to eliminate contact, roughness, injury, unfair tactics and unsportsmanlike conduct. Rules alone, however,
More informationDISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE INQUIRIES. The Disciplinary Committee of the GBGB were in attendance at a meeting held on 10 th July
DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE INQUIRIES The Disciplinary Committee of the GBGB were in attendance at a meeting held on 10 th July 2012: Mr R Woodworth CBE (in the Chair) Mr J Akerman Mr K Salmon Dr A Higgins
More information2004 GALVANIZING LINE MARKET STUDY
2004 GALVANIZING LINE MARKET STUDY Final Report by: AIM Report No. 333 FOREWORD This Report was prepared by AIM Market Research. Neither AIM Market Research, nor any person acting on its behalf: a) makes
More informationUS Bank Stadium Minneapolis, Minnesota
US Bank Stadium Minneapolis, Minnesota FFL89 28th Super Bowl US 8.75 Canada 10.75 #1 Fantasy Football Magazine online only FFL89 Super Bowl rules. starting in 2016 Lineup note: A submitted lineup can not
More informationUpper body as upright as possible with knees slightly bent, much like the position used in fencing.
Handbook of Free Wrestling A. Birmann, 1876 Translated and summarised by P.T. Crawley, 2014 Context: In 1870 M. Birmann put together a collection of the most current grips of free and Swiss wrestling,
More informationKANSAS YOUTH SOCCER JUNIOR STATE CUP RULES OF COMPETITION
KANSAS YOUTH SOCCER JUNIOR STATE CUP RULES OF COMPETITION Table of Contents Section I. Purpose... 3 Section II. Format... 3 Section III. Age Divisions... 3 Section IV. Field & Dimensions... 3 Section V.
More informationi) Filtration machine, measuring equipment and other related machinery
5 MVA TRANSFORMER SERVICE AND MAINTENANCE FOR TATA CHEMICALS MAGADI. SAFETY MEASURES AND REQUIREMENTS i) A thorough site risk assessment to be done before commencement of work. ii) All personnel involved
More informationMEETING MINUTES REGULAR MEETING OF STHA BOARD OF DIRECTORS April 23, 2013
MEETING MINUTES REGULAR MEETING OF STHA BOARD OF DIRECTORS April 23, 2013 The Regular Meeting of the Board of Directors for the Southern Tier Hockey Association ( STHA ) was held on April 23, 2013 in Binghamton,
More informationMen s Premiership and Premiership A. League and Competition Rules
Men s Premiership and Premiership A League and Competition Rules 1. DEFINITIONS For the purposes of these L&C Rules, the following terms shall be defined as follows: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) (vii)
More informationRAYB 2018 A-LEAGUE Baseball League Rules General Rules: updated May 2018 All coaches must have a copy of these rules at all A-League games.
RAYB 2018 A-LEAGUE Baseball League Rules General Rules: updated May 2018 All coaches must have a copy of these rules at all A-League games. In general A-League follows the regular High School rules. The
More informationVENTURA COUNTY AIR POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
VENTURA COUNTY AIR POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD John C. Zaragoza Kathy I. Long Steve Bennett Mike Morgan Thomas Holden Brian Brennan Peter Foy Linda Parks Jonathan Sharkey Paul Miller Supervisor, District V
More informationLOJAS RENNER S.A. CNPJ/MF No / NIRE No PUBLICLY HELD COMPANY W/ AUTHORIZED CAPITAL
LOJAS RENNER S.A. CNPJ/MF No. 92.754.738/0001-62 NIRE No. 43300004848 PUBLICLY HELD COMPANY W/ AUTHORIZED CAPITAL MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING HELD ON JUNE 20 th, 2017 DATE, TIME AND VENUE:
More informationTitle: Fall Protection Effective Date: 5/20/2006 Control Number: THG_0003 Revision Number: 1 Date: 10/10/2015 Annual Review Completed: 5/13/2015
Title: Fall Protection Effective Date: 5/20/2006 Control Number: THG_0003 Revision Number: 1 Date: 10/10/2015 Annual Review Completed: 5/13/2015 Fall Protection CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION II. PURPOSE III.
More informationTexas Charter School Academic & Athletic League Flag Football Handbook Revised 8/30/11 (Indicated by red highlight) Table of Contents
A. Flag Football Calendar Texas Charter School Academic & Athletic League 2011-12 Flag Football Handbook Revised 8/30/11 (Indicated by red highlight) Table of Contents 1. Specifications a. Field b. Ball
More informationNaugatuck Youth Soccer Board of Directors Meeting Agenda April 12, :30pm Seifert Associates
Naugatuck Youth Soccer Board of Directors Meeting Agenda April 12, 2016 7:30pm Seifert Associates Attendance: Linda Pereira, Amy Keach, Nicole Rupwani, Roger Simoes, Joe Magalhaes, Vicki Krooss, Paula
More information2015 Fact Sheet Match Day Requirements
2015 Fact Sheet Match Day Requirements Match day requirements 1. Teams 1. Before the Match (a) The playing teams must be ready within 30 minutes of the scheduled starting time. (rule 72 xv, $100 fine also
More informationEAST ISLIP SOCCER CLUB 35th ANNUAL FALL CLASSIC TOURNAMENT October 7th and 8th, 2017
EAST ISLIP SOCCER CLUB 35th ANNUAL FALL CLASSIC TOURNAMENT October 7th and 8th, 2017 RULES All of the Tournament Games will be played in accordance with the Laws of the Game as issued by FIFA unless modified
More informationMen s Premiership and Premiership A. League and Competition Rules
Men s Premiership and Premiership A League and Competition Rules 1. DEFINITIONS For the purposes of these L&C Rules, the following terms shall be defined as follows: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) (vii)
More informationLIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
TEXT FIGURES MYCERINUS PYRAMID TEMPLE 1. Débris in great court. mud wall well preserved. section.................... 13 2 Débris in great court. low mud wall where granite block has been removed. section........
More information2017 T.A.A.F. State Invitational Kickball Tournament (Co-Ed Division)
2017 T.A.A.F. State Invitational Kickball Tournament (Co-Ed Division) Entry Packet and Information Hosted by The Colony Parks and Recreation Department 2017 T.A.A.F. Kickball Tournament DATES OF PLAY:
More informationRoad Safety Country Overview November Norway
Road Safety Country Overview November 2012 Norway Basic data Structure and Culture Table 1: Basic data of Norway in relation to the. (Sources: [1] OECD/ITF, 2011; [2] Eurostat; [3] DG-TREN, 2005; [4] CIA;
More informationBriefing: The free bus pass
Briefing: The free bus pass This briefing note provides information about the free bus pass in England and explains Age UK s views. (Policy on the bus pass is devolved to local administrations in Scotland,
More informationRoad Safety Country Overview November Poland
Road Safety Country Overview November 2012 Poland Basic data Structure and Culture Poland has a high population density but a low number of vehicles per person. Table 1: Basic data of Poland in relation
More information2018/2019 Missouri Presidents Cup Rules
2018/2019 Missouri Presidents Cup Rules I. PURPOSE a. These are the rules of the US Youth Missouri Presidents Cup. The Midwest Presidents Cup Championships and US Youth Soccer National Presidents Cup Championship
More informationCOMPUTATIONAL OCEAN ACOUSTIC TOOLBOX MANUAL. Computational Ocean Acoustics Toolbox (COAT) is a package written containing the following
COMPUTATIONAL OCEAN ACOUSTIC TOOLBOX MANUAL A 1 INTRODUCTION Computational Ocean Acoustics Toolbox (COAT) is a package written containing the following topics which are described in the preceding Chapters.
More informationCAROLINA JUNIOR HURRICANES SEASON PROGRAM DETAILS
CAROLINA JUNIOR HURRICANES 2018-2019 SEASON PROGRAM DETAILS TIER I AAA TIER II AA TIER II A Girls (4/9/2018) Raleigh Youth Hockey Association Page 1 of 18 I. Introduction... 3 II. 2018-2019 Programs by
More informationNRHSAA BOYS HOCKEY
NRHSAA BOYS HOCKEY 2015-2016 IMPORTANT: The policies that follow are specific to this sport and must be adhered to by every member of the NRHSAA. Each sport policy is numbered. Many of the Policies in
More informationCAROLINA JUNIOR HURRICANES SEASON PROGRAM DETAILS
2015-2016 SEASON PROGRAM DETAILS TIER I AAA TIER II AA TIER II A Girls (4/15/2015) I. Introduction... 3 II. 2015-2016 Programs by Tier... 3 III. Program Options by Age Group... 4 IV. Tryouts and Team Selections...
More informationECOLOGICAL REFERENCE POINTS
ECOLOGICAL REFERENCE POINTS FOR FORAGE SPECIES 1 The biological benchmarks, or reference points, used by fishery managers to judge the relative health of a fish population are, in the simplest terms, targets
More information