i MARTIN R. GLICK* A Professional Corporation H. JOSEPH ESCHER III MARLA J. MILLER HOWARD, RICE, NEMEROVSKI, CANADY, ROBERTSON & FALK

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "i MARTIN R. GLICK* A Professional Corporation H. JOSEPH ESCHER III MARLA J. MILLER HOWARD, RICE, NEMEROVSKI, CANADY, ROBERTSON & FALK"

Dinah Cain
5 years ago
Views:

1 1 i MARTIN R. GLICK* H. JOSEPH ESCHER I 2 MARLA J. MILLER HOWARD, RICE, NEMEROVSKI, CANADY, ROBERTSON & FALK A Professional Corporation Three Embarcadero Center, th Floor San Francisco, California 1 Telephon~: / -00 *Counsel of Record Of Counsel: SCOTT HOVER-SMOOT Attorneys for Defendant-Appellant Activision, Inc. UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS HOvVARD R.ICE '\JEMEROVSKJ 12 FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT CANADY 1 ROBERTSON & FALK 1 THE MAGNAVOX COMPANY, a corporation, and SANDERS ASSOCIATES, No. -2 INC., a corporation, Plaintiffs-Appellees, vs. ACTIVISION, INC., a corporation, Defendant-Appellant. ACTIVISION, INC.'S DESIGNATION OF APPENDIX Fed. R. App. P.0 Local Rule 12 rial for inclusion in its Appendix. For convenience, the following abbreviations are used in citations throughout the Designation of 2 Appendix : TT 2 // Trial transcript, volume -page (June, session Appellant Activision, Inc. designates the following mate- -1-

2 HC'WARD rjce 12 :--JEMERO'vSKJ CANADY 1 l\ober.tson & FALK I TT / a.m. Trial transcript, August, morning sess1on 1 - TT / _ p. m. Trial transcript, August, afternoon session Dep. Plf's Resp. to Def's First Set Plf's Supp. Resp. DESIGNATIONS: Findings of Fact. Deposition Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 1-1, dated February, 1 Plaintiff's Supplemental Response to Defendant's Interrogatories, dated May, 1 Stipulation of the Parties Regarding Undisputed Facts, dated May 1,. Plf's Third Supplemental Response to Defendant's Interrogatories, dated September, 1 at 2. TT 1-, lines -12; TT / 1 a.m. at, lines 1-1. TT / 12 p.m. at 2, line -, line 1;, line - 1, line (Higinbotham. TT / 12 p. m. at 2, line 1-1, line (Higinbotham; TT / 12 p.m. at 10, line - 11, line (Thacker; Ex. E. TT / 12 p.m. at, line 2-, line 2 (Higinbotham. Ex. BD (Spiegel patent; Ex. DQ (Examiner's discussion of Spiegel i Baer reissue; TT / 12 p.m. at 1, line - 1, line (Thacker; Mayer Dep. (/ /, Activision at, line -, line 12;, lines -;, lines 1-. Lipper Dep. (/ 1/ 2, APF at, 1-1; Mayer Dep. (/ /, Activision at -, -. TT 2-, line - 2-, line (Baer. 2 TT -, line - -1, line ; -, line - -, line (Baer; Ex. CA (Baer, September memo. TT 2-, line - 2-1, line ; 2-2, line - 2-, line 2 2 (Baer. -2-

3 He "WARD ~C E 12 :--.JEMEROVSI<J CANADY 1 PDBERT0N & FALK TT -, lines 1- (Baer; Ex. HD (Baer Disclosure Sheet at 2. TT 2-1, lines - (Baer. TT -, lines -; -1, line - -, line 1 (Baer; Harrison Dep. (1 11, Bally at 0. TT -, lines 1-1 (Baer. TT -, lines 1- (Baer. TT -, line 1 - Games; Ex. HD. -1, line 2 (Baer; Ex. CD (Summary of Major Ex. DA (Baer-1 patent; Ex. IU; TT 1 12 p.m. at 12, line 2-12, line (Thacker. TT -1, lines -; -1, lines -; -0, lines -. TT -12, line - -1, line (Baer. TT -1, line , line. TT -2, lines - (Baer. TT -, line - -, line 1; TT -12, line - -1, line 2; Ex. JL- (Baer. TT -1, line - -12, line 1 (Baer; Ex. JL- (Baer. TT -, line , line 12; -1, lines -; -0, lines - (Baer; Ex. JL- (Baer; Ex. DU (Seligman argument for Baer-1 reissue at 1; Ex. DX (Seligman argument for Baer-1 reissue at. TT -1, line , line ; -1, line , line 1 (Baer; TT -0, line - -1, line 2 (Ribbens. Ex. DZ (Baer Supplemental Declaration. TT -12, line 2 - at. -12, line (Baer; Ex. CF (Rusch Notebook Ex. CJ (Rusch Disclosure Sheet at 1 (#; Ex. HT (Rusch First Progress Report; Harrison Dep. (1 21, Bally at 2-. TT -12, lines 1- (Baer. TT -11, lines - (Baer. --

4 HONARD f\jce 12 NEME.ROVSKJ C'\NADY 1 ROBEI\TSON & FALK TT -11, lines 1- (Baer; Ex. JL- ( Sel igman Supp. Amendment to Response to Opposer's 2nd Paper. Ex. HD (Baer Disclosure Sheet ; Ex. HT ( Ru sch First Report ; Ex. HU (Status Report ; Ex. HV (Sanders Stop Order; Ex. HW (Rusch Final Report. Ex. HW (Rusch Final Report at. Ex. CJ (Rusch Disclosure Sheet at 1. Judicial Notice: Ex. M; Ex. GY (excerpt from textbook. TT -, lines -1. TT -1, line - -1, line 2 (Thacker. Exs. CT, CU, CV, CW (excerpts from ' 2 file wrapper. Exs. DH, DI (excerpts from '0 file wrapper. Ex. DI (excerpt from '0 file wrapper. Ex. JL- at 12- (Professor Kayton. Ex. JL- (Seligman. TT -2, line - -2, line 1 (Baer. TT -1, lines 1-1 (Baer; Etlinger Dep. (/ /, Bally at, ; Ex. HD (Baer Disclosure Sheet at 1 (~; Ex. HW (August Rusch Final Report at 1,. TT / 12 p. m. at 12, lines -1 (Thacker. TT -0, line - -1, line 1 (Baer; TT / 12 p.m. at 1, line 12-1, line (Higinbotham; Harrison Dep. (/ /, Bally at, Q. -, Q. 2; 0-1, Q. 21. TT / 12 p.m. at 1, line - 1, line (Higi nbotham ; TT / 12 p.m. at 12, line 1-1, line ; 1, line - 1, line (Thacker. TT / 12 p.m. at 1, line - 1, line (Higinbotham ; TT / 12 p.m. at 12, line 1-1, line (Thacker. TT / 12 p.m. at 1, line - 1, line (Thacker. TT -, line - -0, line (Russell; Ex. Q. TT -2, line - -, line (Russell. --

5 HCWARD!\ICE 12 NEMEROv'SK.I CANADY 1 1\!...I BER.TSON & FALK 1 A ProlruiO rtgi (orporatjon TT -, line - -1, line (Russell; TT / 1 a.m. at, line - 10, line (Thacker. TT -2, line - -, line 2; -, line , line (Russell; Ex. HA; Green Dep. (/ 2/, CD! at,, 1-. Lawrence Dep. (/ /, Activision at 1-, -. Lawrence Dep. (/ /, Activision at -, 1-; / 2/ at 1-1 ; TT / 1 a. m. at 10, line 1-12, line (Thacker. Lawrence Dep. (/ 2/, Activision at -2, 2-0, -, -. Lawrence Dep. (/ 2/, Activision at 1- ; Smith Dep. (/ 2/, Activision at -1. Brown Dep. (/ /, CD! at 12-1, 2, -, -; Ex. C; TT / 1 a.m. at, line - 0, line 1 (Thacker. Brown Dep. (/ /, CD! at -, -2. Drumheller Dep. (/ 1/, Activision at -, - ; Mullarky Dep (/ 2/, CDI at -; TT / 1 a. m. at 0, line 1-1, line 2 (Thacker.-- TT / 1 a.m. at 2, line -, line (Thacker; Lechner Dep. (/ 2/, CDI at, ; Cooke Dep. (/ 2/, CDI at -1. TT / 1 a.m. at 2, line -, li~e TT / 12 p.m. at 12, lines -1 (Thacker. 2 (Thacker. TT -, line - -, line 1 (Russell; TT / 12 p.m. at, line -, line 2 (Nielsen. TT / 1 a.m. at 1, lines 1-2 (Thacker. TT -1, lines - (Baer ; Ex. JL-1 (Anderson's Opening Statement, CD!. TT -11, lines 1-; -12, lines -; -1, lines -. Ex. CP (Magnavox license support schematics ; TT -, - (Baer. TT -, line - -, line (Baer. 2 TT -1, line - -2, line 1 (Briody; TT -, lines -; -, lines 2- (Bushnell; TT / 1 a.m. at, lines - (Crane TT -, line - -, line (Briody; TT -, lines 2-2 (Bushnell; Fritsche counterdesignation at,. --

6 HCWARD RICE 12 NEMERC>\ISKJ CAI'\JADY 1 ROBEIUSON t:.. FALK 1 A Proi#BION Co'J'(rouo" TT -, lines 1- (Levy. Ex. IC. TT -, line - -, line (Briody. TT -- -, line (Bushnell. TT -0, line 1- -, line 1 (Bushnell. TT -, line - -, line (Bushnell. TT -, line , line ; -, line 1 - -, line (Bushnell. TT -, line - -, line (Bushnell. TT -, lines 2-1; -0, lines 2-1 (Bushnell. DM (Coleco license}; DN (Atari license; TT -, line - -, line (Bushnell. TT -12, lines 1-, -; -1, line - -12, line (Briody. TT -2, lines -1 (Levy. TT -12, lines - (Briody ; Mayer Dep. (1 1, Activ ision at,,. TT 1 1 p.m. at 20, line 2-22, line ;, lines - (Lopez. Ex. DC (Seligman. Ex. JL- (Baer Canadian affidavit- May, 12. Ex. DS at 0; Ex. ID (Mayer affidavit}; Ex. DY (Examiner's Statemen~ from file wrapper. I TT -1, lines - (Baer; Ex. JL-1 (Anderson's Opening Statement, CDI; Plf's Resp. to Def's First Set (#1. Ex. JL-; Ex. CJ. TT -2, line - -, line (Ribbens. TT -, line - -, line (Ribbens. TT -, line - -, line (Ribbens. --

7 HL"'WARD!\ICE 12 NEMERO/SKJ CANADY 1 RLIBE!USON & FALK 1 A Pro lnsru~l CotNratHn TT -1, lines -1; TT 1 1 p.m. at, line 2 -, line (Thacker. TT -2, lines - (Ribbens. Ex. GT; Ex. IE. TT -, line 1- -, line (Ribbens. TT -, line - -1, line 2 (Thacker. TT 1 12 a.m. at, line 2 -, line ; (Thacker; TT 1 12 p.m. at, line -, line (Nielsen. Ex. JT; Ex. HZ. TT -1, line - -12, line 12; -11, line , line (Thacker; Ex. GW (ROM Chip photograph. TT -1, line 1- -1, line (Thacker. TT 1 1 a.m. at 2, line -, line (Crane. TT -, line - -, line (Thacker; TT 1 12 a.m. at, lin 2-, line ; 2, line - 2, line 1 (Thacker. TT 1 12 a.m. at, line 2-, line 2 (Thacker. TT -, lines - (Ribbens. TT 1 12 a.m. at, line -, line (Thacker. TT 1 12 a. m. at, lines -1 (Thacker. TT -, line - -, line (Ribbens; TT -1, line - -10, line (Thacker. TT -, line - -2, line 12; -, line - -, line (Ribbens. TT -, line - -0, line 1 (Ribbens. TT -, lines 1- (Ribbens; TT 1 1 a.m. at 2, lines 2- (Thacker. TT -2, lines - (Ribbens; TT 1 12 a.m. at, line 2-, line (Thacker. TT 2 a.m. at, line -, line (Thacker; TT a.m. at, line 2-0, line 2 (Crane. --

8 !I :I 2 H<..NV.ARD RJCE 12 NEMEROVSK.J CANADY 1 ROBER.TSON & FALK 1 A PN>I~rvtl Corporot" TT / 12 a.m. at 1, line 12-, line 2 (Thacker. TT / 1 a.m. at, line -, line (Crane. TT -, line 1 - -, line ; -2, line - -2, line (Ribbens; TT / 12 a.m. at, line 1-2, line 1 (Thacker. TT / 1 p. m. at, lines -1 (Thacker. TT / 12 a.m. at, line - 2, line 1 (Thacker. TT / 12 a.m. at, line -, line 2 (Thacker. TT / 12 a.m. at, line -, line 2 (Thacker. Ex. DN-1; TT / 1 p.m. at 2, line - 2, line 12 ( Lehrberg. TT -1, line - -12, line (Briody. Ex. DN; Ex. DM; Ex. EI. TT -11, line , line (Thacker. Ex. cs ('2 file wrapper at 1 1; Ex. cv. Ex. cs ('2 file wrapper at 1, 1. Ex. cs ( '2 file wrapper at. Ex. cu (Seligman; Ex. DJ (Seligman. Ex. DG ( '0 file wrapper at 2 (Rusch Declaration. Ex. DF (Rusch-2 patent. TT / 1 a.m. at 2, line 2 -, line 12 (Crane; -, line - -1, line ; -1, line - -, l i ne 1; -, line - -, line ; -, lines - (Baer. TT / 1 a.m. at, line - TT / 1 a.m. at, lines 1- (Crane. TT / 1 a.m. at, line - Resp. at 12-1 (#1}., line 2 (Crane; Ex. FT., line (Crane; Plf's Supp. TT / 1 a.m. at, lines -2 (Crane}; Plf's Supp. Resp. at 12-1 ( #1. TT / 1 a.m. at 1, line (Baer. 2, line (Crane; TT -, lines --

9 HONARD!\ICE 12 NEMEROVSKI CANADY 1 ROBER.TSON & FALK. 1 A P,ofrwo rw~l Co rporw~non TT 1 1 a.m. at, line -, line 2 (Crane. TT 1 1 a.m. at, line - 1, line 1 (Crane. TT 1 1 a.m. at 2, line -, line (Crane. I TT 1 1 a.m. at, line at 12-1 (#1. -, line (Crane; Plf's Supp. Resp.l TT 1 1 a. m. at, line - 1, line 1 (Crane. Plf's Answers to Interrogatory No. as supplemented in February 1, March 1 and September 1. TT 1 1 a.m. at 1, line 2-, line (Crane. TT 1 1 a.m. at, line - Resp. at 12-1 (#1., line (Crane; Plf's Supp. TT 1 1 a.m. at, line -, line (Crane. TT 2-2, lines 2- (Baer; Ex. CU (Seligman; Ex. DJ (Seligman ; Ex. CS ('2 file wrapper. TT -1, line - -1, line (Levy. TT 1 1 a.m. at, line -, line (Crane. TT -, line - TT -2, lines -1 (Levy. -12, line ; Ex. IO; Ex. IP; Ex. IQ. Plf's Third Supp. Response to Defendant's Interrogatories, dated September, 1 (#. I --

10 TT -, lines - ; -, lines 1- (Ribbens ; TT -1, lines - (Levy; TT -12, lines - (Briody. I-!OvVARD 1\JCE 12 NEME.RO./SKJ CANADY 1 ~IBEIUSON & FALK 1 DATED: April, MARTIN R. GLICK* H. JOSEPH ESCHER I MARLA J. MILLER HOWARD, RICE, NEMEROVSKI, CANADY, ROBERTSON & FALK A Professional Corporation By: ~~~ hc( RTIN R. GLICK -. Attorneys for Defendant- Appellant Activision, Inc / -0Jb --

11 DECLARATI ON OF SERVICE 2 I declare that I am employed in the County of San ~ Francisco, California. I am over the age of eighteen (1 years and not a party to the within cause. Mv business address is... Three Embarcadero Center, th Floor, San Francisco, CA 1. 1-GVARD RJCE NEMEFOvSKJ CANADY ROBEKT"(\J & FALK.. ~ c On April,, I served the attached ACTIVISION, INC.' DESIGNATION OF APPENDIX (Fed. R. App. P. 0/Local Rule 12 by placing a true copy thereof enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid and depositing said envelope in a United States Mail Box in San Francisco, California, addressed as follows : Theodore W. Anderson, Esq. Neuman, Williams, Anderson & Olson w. washington Street Chicago, Illinois 002 I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct and was executed at San Francisco, California on April ~'

Case 2:03-cv R -CT Document 28 Filed 03/15/04 Page 1 of 5

Case 2:03-cv R -CT Document 28 Filed 03/15/04 Page 1 of 5 Case :03-cv-0744-R -CT Document Filed 03/15/04 Page 1 of 5 1 HOWARD L. GANZ (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) AMY B. REGAN (Admitted Pro Hac Vice) PROSK1\.UER ROSE LLP 1585 Broadway 3 New York, NY 10036-899 Telephone: