Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy"

Transcription

1 International Journal of Perforability Engineering Vol. 8, No., July, pp. -. RAMS Consultants Printed in India Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy GREGORY LEVITIN and KJELL HAUSKEN. The Israel Electric Corporation Ltd., Israel. Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Stavanger, Norway (Received on March, and revised on Septeber, and May 9, ) Abstract: A defender allocates its resource between defending an object passively by deploying false targets, and striking preventively against an attacker seeking to destroy the object. With no preventive strike the defender allocates its entire resource to deploying false targets, which the attacker cannot distinguish fro the genuine object. If the defender strikes preventively, the attacker s vulnerability depends on its protection and on the defender's resource allocated to the strike. If the attacker survives, the object s vulnerability depends on the attacker s revenge attack resource allocated to the attacked object. An optiization odel is presented for aking a decision about the efficiency of the preventive strike based on the estiated attack probability, dependent on a variety of odel paraeters. The optial nuber of false targets to deploy and the optial subset of targets to attack are deterined. Keywords: Vulnerability, active defense, passive defense, attack, protection, contest intensity. Introduction Defending against external ipacts and especially against intentional external ipacts has attracted considerable research effort in recent years. One can distinguish between active and passive defense. Soe easures aied at itigating the effect of external attacks, such as protective shields, are by their nature defensive. Other easures can generate active defense which eans exerting effort when certain conditions are et. See [] for a review of earlier research in this area, classifying according to syste structure, defense easures, and attack tactics and circustances. Two subcategories within defense easures are false targets and preventive strike. The preventive strike can be an effective easure of active defense aied at destroying the potential attacker and, thus, preventing the defended object fro destruction. However, the preventive strike can inflict a revenge strike which causes expenditure of the defender's resources that could be used for passive defense. Thus, the optial balance between the passive and active defense can considerably iprove the survivability of the defended object. Earlier research has considered how a defender balances between protecting an object passively and striking preventively against an attacker, equipped with one or ultiple attack facilities, seeking to destroy the object. In this paper the defender deterines a balance between striking preventively and deploying false targets to distract the attacker. Unlike the previous works, we assue that the object already has soe given protection and the defender distributes the reaining resource between the preventive strike and the false targets. The attacker cannot distinguish the genuine object fro the false targets. First we assue that the attacker attacks all targets. Thereafter we assue that the attacker ay attack a subset of the targets. In any attack against a group of targets the attacker distributes its effort evenly aong the targets. This corresponds to the case when the attacker cannot direct the attack exactly against certain targets, but against a group of targets (for exaple, area coverage weapon attack against a group of separated targets). * Corresponding author s eail: kjell.hausken@uis.no

2 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken This paper analyzes the defender s objective of iniizing the probability of destruction of an object it controls. The object ay be an asset, a collection of assets, an infrastructure, a country, etc. The defender s two strategies are to defend passively or strike preventively, and, if the latter, which resource fraction to allocate to the preventive strike. It is soeties suggested that attack is the best defense, but not always. This paper seeks to deterine when it is optial to stay on the defensive and await the blow, and when it is optial to go on the offensive and strike preventively. Our focus is on the quite challenging defense optiization where the defender has a fixed resource which can be used passively or actively. The attacker has two resources, one resource that is used for attack, and one that is used to protect against a preventive strike by the defender. As an exaple, consider an airborne bober that has a ission to destroy soe caouflaged object. To dissipate the bob strike the defender deploys false targets. The bober can detect the targets with a given probability. If the targets are detected the bober distributes its load aong a subset of targets it chooses. The defender can strike preventively using short range anti-aircraft issiles. As the issile launchers are located near the defended targets, the preventive strike reveals the locations of targets and, therefore, if the bober, protected by an anti-issile syste survives the strike, it attacks for certain. The defender has to ake a choice between the passive defense (hoping that either it is not detected or that the object protection can survive the strike weakened by dissipation aong several targets) and active defense (hoping that the attacker is destroyed). When the defender builds its defense it should decide how its liited budget is distributed between deploying the false targets and deploying anti-aircraft systes. In this study we assue that the level of the object protection is a fixed exogenously given paraeter, which eans that the protection resource is independent fro the resource distributed between the false targets and the preventive strike. We analyze how the object protection affects the decision regarding the PS in the presence of the FT deployent option. Reference [] states that a preventive war is initiated in the belief that ilitary conflict, while not iinent, is inevitable, and that to delay would involve greater risk. In contrast, preeption is defined as an attack initiated on the basis of incontrovertible evidence that an eney attack is iinent. According to these two definitions, the focus in this paper is on preventive strike, and not on preeption. In related research [] draws on sociological and psychological research to consider risk governance, [] introduces huan factors into safety analysis, and [] balances hard and soft issues for the perforability of work teas. Section presents the odel when the attacker attacks all targets. Section assues that the attacker attacks a subset of the targets. Section illustrates the solution. Section considers the conservative defense strategy under uncertain contest intensities. Section concludes.. The Model (When the Attacker attacks all Targets) Noenclature PS FT r R t preventive strike false target total defender's resource total attacker's offensive resource effort with which the defended object is protected

3 Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy H nuber of FTs deployed by the defender H* optial value of H Q nuber of targets attacked at rando by the attacker * Q optial value of Q given H FTs are deployed H D attacker's protection resource c the cost of single false target T attacker's effort (resource) per attacked target σ ratio c/r between cost of FT and the total defender s resource τ ratio t/r between defender s protection effort and attacker s attack resource δ ratio D/r between attacker s protection effort and total defender s resource h axial possible nuber of deployed FTs (h= /σ ) v(h) conditional probability of the defended object destruction given it is attacked as well as H FTs V(H) conditional probability of the attacker's destruction given it is preventively attacked contest intensity in strike against the attacker contest intensity in attack against the defender z estiated probability of attack against the defender if there is no preventive strike threshold value of attack probability (iniu estiated attack probability when the preventive strike is justified) P ~ probability of destruction of the defended object in the case of no preventive strike P(H) probability of destruction of the defended object in the case of preventive strike against all targets G probability of destruction of the defended object in the revenge attack against Q randoly chosen targets W probability of destruction of the defended object under the optial defense strategy.. The Model Suppose the defender anticipates an attack fro the attacker. The attack can be directed against an object owned or controlled by the defender, or against the defender itself. The estiated probability of the attack is z. This probability can be elicited fro intelligence data, expert judgents, and previous statistics (this paper considers z as an exogenously given fixed paraeter). The defender can defend its object in two ways: ipleenting the preventive strike against the potential attacker (active defense) and deploying false targets to dissipate the attacker's resources (passive defense). In the case of the preventive strike, the defender distributes its resource r between strike effort and false targets. The cost of a single FT is c. Therefore, the axial nuber of FTs that can be deployed given the defender's resource r is r/c = /σ, defined as the largest integer not greater than /σ. If H /σ false targets are deployed, the reaining resource r-hc can be allocated to the preventive strike. If the attacker survives the preventive strike, it attacks the defender with probability (revenge attack), evenly distributing its attack resource aong all the targets. If x= (no preventive strike) the defender allocates its entire resource r into deploying h= /σ FTs. The defender has one free choice variable H, which iplies the aount r-hc allocated to the preventive strike. Hence the choice about the preventive strike deterines

4 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken the nuber of FTs deployed and vice versa. To focus explicitly on these strategic choices, we abstract away fro the defender s protection which is exogenously given. First, the defender akes only one decision at one point in tie, which either gives no preventive strike or a preventive strike with a resource allocation between the strike and FTs. This decision takes into account the agnitude of the attacker s attack which gets distributed across the genuine object and the FTs. Second, an alternative odel where the defender can decide different protections before and after its preventive strike gets ore coplicated, and is unrealistic when the attacker s revenge attack coes so quickly that the defender does not have the tie to change its protection. Especially protections such as bunkers, protective casings, and shields of various kinds in reote areas are not easily changed quickly. Consequently, first, we consider the cases when the deployent of ready FTs can be accoplished uch ore easily and quickly than protection enhanceent. Second, we consider the cases when the protection is liited by technology (for exaple, oving targets such as tanks or airplanes cannot have unliited protection and the decision about their protection is ade by the designer, not by the field coander) and the only way to iprove the defense of already protected object is to deploy FTs which can be done in battle conditions. The attacker has no free choice variables. We thus analyze the defense optiization. The vulnerability (conditional probability of destruction in the case of attack) of the attacked object is deterined by the coon ratio for of the attacker-defender contest success function [,7] T v =, () T + t where T is the attacker s effort, t is the defender s effort, v / T, v / t, and is a paraeter for the contest intensity. When =, t and T have no ipact on v regardless of their size which gives vulnerability v=. for any T> and t>. When <<, exerting ore effort than one s opponent gives less advantage in ters of vulnerability than the proportionality of the agents efforts specify. For exaple, T=, t=, =. gives v=.9 < /. When =, the efforts have proportional ipact on the v. When >, exerting ore effort than one s opponent gives ore advantage in ters of vulnerability than the proportionality of the agents efforts specify. For exaple, T=, t=, = gives v=.8 > /. Finally, = gives a step function where winner-takes-all. The paraeter can be illustrated by the history of warfare. Low intensity occurs in situations where neither the defender nor the attacker can get a significant upper hand. Exaples are the tie prior to cannons and odern fortifications in the fifteenth century, and entrenchent used with the achine gun in World War I [8]. High occurs when one or the other opponent ore easily can get the upper hand. Airplanes, tanks, and echanized infantry in World War II allowed both the offense and defense to concentrate firepower ore rapidly, which intensified the effect of force superiority. In the case of no preventive strike the defender allocates h= /σ FTs. The attacker distributes its resource evenly aong h+ targets achieving the per-target effort R T =. The probability of the destruction of the defended object P ~ is h + P ~ =zv(h) = T z z z = / =. () T + t + h + t R + τ h + (( ) ) ( ( ))

5 Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy In the case of preventive strike the defender exerts effort r-hc reaining after deploying H FTs into strike and the attacker exerts the effort D to defend its facility. The vulnerability of the attacker's facility is ( r Hc) V ( H ) = =, H h. () ( r Hc) + D + ( δ /( Hσ )) where has the sae interpretation as. In the revenge attack the attacker exerts the pertarget effort R/(H+). The vulnerability of the defended object in the revenge attack given the attacker survives the preventive strike is v( H ) =, H h. () + ( H + ) t / R) In the case of preventive strike the probability of destruction of the defended object is P( H) = ( V( H)) v( H) = =. () + (( r Hc)/ D) + ( H+ ) t/ R) + (( Hσ )/ δ) + (( H+ ) τ) In our first forulation the defender has to choose H, while D, t, z and R are exogenously given.. Solving the Model The defender optiizes its resource distribution in order to iniize the probability of destruction of the defended object: H*= arg (P(H) in). Coparing () and (), the H r / c preventive strike is justified if P(H*)< P ~, i.e., + (( H * σ ) / δ ) + (( H * + ) τ ) < z. () + (( h + ) τ ) It follows fro () that the defender should strike preventively if according to its estiates the probability of the attack against the defended object z exceeds the threshold value, where (( h + ) τ ) (( H * ) τ ) + zin =. (7) + (( H * σ ) / δ ) + + The probability of the object destruction given the optial defense strategy is W=in{ P ~, P(H*)}. We assue that the defender's evaluation of the probability z does not change between its choice of H and the attack. Thus, the decision regarding the preventive strike can be ade siultaneously with choosing the value of H based on (). We now proceed to analyze the ipact of the variation in the six paraeters σ, δ, τ, z,, on the decision variables H and Q, and on the dependent variables P, W, and.. Illustrating the Optial Defender's Decisions Fig. presents the values of P ~ (no PS) and P for H= and H= as functions of σ, when δ=., τ =, z=.8, ==. As the FT cost increases relative to the defender s resource, the probability of destruction increases. With no PS, the probability increases as a stepwise function. Indeed, in intervals when h= /σ reains unchanged, σ does not affect P ~. Depending on σ as well as on the nuber of FTs H, the probability P(H) can be lower or greater than P ~. The cobination of stepwise increasing P ~ (σ) and

6 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken onotonically increasing P(σ) causes situations when the difference P(σ)- P ~ (σ) changes its sign several ties with increase of σ. For exaple, for H=, P(σ)> P ~ (σ) when σ., P(σ)< P ~ (σ) when.9<σ., and again P(σ)> P ~ (σ) when σ>... P σ. No PS PS (H=) PS (H=) Figure : P ~ and P for H= and H= as functions of σ, when δ=., τ =, z=.8, ==. Figure presents P ~ for z=.8 and z=., P(H*) and corresponding values of h and H* as functions of σ, when δ=., τ =, ==. Depending on the relation between P ~ and P(H*) the defender decides whether to strike preventively or not. In this exaple the defender avoids the PS when z=. (except when.<σ<.9, where P ~ becoes slightly greater than P(H*)) and always strikes preventively when z=.8, which corresponds to high probability of the unprovoked attacker's strike. The defender always chooses H*<h in order to allocate soe resources to the PS. Both H* and h decrease in σ.. P σ. No PS (z=.8) No PS (z=.) PS.... σ. h H* Figure : P ~ for z=.8 and z=., P(H*) and corresponding values of h and H* as functions of σ, when δ=., τ =, ==. Figure presents P ~ for z=.7, P(H*), W and as functions of σ, when δ=., τ =, ==. It can be seen that (thick line) varies non-onotonically and the defender s choice of no PS vs. PS can change any ties as σ increases. Indeed, when >.7 (where.7 is shown with a thin horizontal line) the defender avoids PS, and when <.7 the defender strikes preventively.

7 Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy 7. P σ. No PS W PS..... σ. Figure : P ~ for z=.7, P(H*), W and as functions of σ, when δ=., τ =, ==. Figure presents W for z=., and H* as functions of σ, for τ =, == and different δ. The destruction probability W increases in σ, especially when the attacker enjoys a large resource advantage δ copared with the defender. has an overall decreasing trend except when δ is large. The non-onotonic behavior of akes the intuitive defender's decision about the optial defense strategy difficult. H* decreases in σ starting out at the largest level H*=9 when the attacker enjoys a large δ=.. The defender copensates for its resource inferiority by deploying any FTs.. W H* σ σ σ Figure :, H* and W for z=. as functions of σ, for τ =, == and different δ. Figure presents W for z=., and H* as functions of σ, for δ =., == and different τ. The second and third panels are qualitatively siilar to the second and third panels in Fig.. For the first panel W still increases in σ, as in Fig., but the defender prefers large τ in Fig in contrast to preferring low δ in Fig., and conversely for the attacker.. W..... τ :.... σ τ :.... σ. 7 H* τ :.... σ Figure :, H* and W for z=., as functions of σ, for δ =., == and different τ.

8 8 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken. Attacker chooses a subset of Targets to attack If the attacker survives the preventive strike, it observes H+ possible targets and cannot distinguish the object and the FTs. However the attacker can decide to attack a randoly chosen subset of targets concentrating its resource in the attack against fewer FTs and hoping that the defended object is aong the attacked targets. If the attacker attacks Q targets, Q H+, where Q is a free choice variable for the attacker, the per-target attack effort is T=R/Q and the probability that the defended object is attacked is Q/(H+). The vulnerability of the object in the case when it is attacked is v(h)=. The overall + ( Qτ ) probability of the object destruction in the case of the revenge attack is G(Q)= Q. (8) ( H + ) + ( Qτ ) Considering the worst possible scenario for the defender, we assue that for any H the attacker can always choose or guess the value of Q that axiizes the probability of the object destruction: Q Q* = arg ax G = [ ]. (9) H / σ ( H + ) + ( Qτ ) Differentiating with respect to Q we get G + ( ) Q τ = Q ( H + ) [ + ( Qτ ) ] () G If, > and axial destruction probability is achieved when Q=H+. In this Q case the attacker attacks all the targets and we have the situation considered in the previous section. G If >, = gives Q * = (for exaple, for = Q*=/τ). For the Q τ convenience of later discussion, we denote q =. Since Q is integer and cannot τ be greater than H+, we have: H + if q H + * Q = q if q < H +, G( q) > G( q + ) () H q + if q < H, G( q) < G( q + ) In the case of no preventive strike the probability of the destruction of the defended object P ~ is P ~ * * =zg( Q h,h) = zq h. () + ( ) + * ( h ) Qhτ In the case of preventive strike the probability of destruction of the defended object is * QH P( H ) = ( V ( H )) G( Q*, H ) =. () ( ) / * + Hσ δ H + + Q τ ( ) ( ) H

9 Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy 9 The defender optiizes its resource distribution in order to iniize the probability of destruction of the defended object: H*= arg (P(H) in). Coparing () and H h (), the preventive strike is justified if P(H*)< P ~ *,i.e., Q * * H < zq h () ( + ( H * ) / δ ) H * + + ( Q * τ ) H * ( ) + ( ) * h Qhτ The defender should strike preventively if according to its estiates the probability of the attack against the defended object z exceeds the threshold value, where * * h + QH * + ( Qhτ ) zin =. (( * ) / ) * * * + H σ δ H + Qh + ( QH * τ ) () The probability of object destruction given the optial defense strategy is W=in{ P ~, P(H*)}.. Illustrating the Solution of the Gae Figure presents W for z=.7,, H* and Q* as functions of σ, for δ =., =τ= and different. The destruction probability W increases in σ and decreases in the contest intensity in the attack against the defender. has an overall decreasing trend. Q* decreases in σ since Q* H*+. The attacker chooses Q*=H*+ when, and otherwise chooses Q* H*+ since a large contest intensity is costly inducing the attacker to concentrate its resource into attacking few eleents. When =, the attacker attacks only one eleent regardless of σ, despite any FTs being deployed. Figure 7 presents W for z=.7,, H* and Q* as functions of, for δ =., σ=.8, τ= and different. Again W decreases in, but can be inverse U shaped (e.g., when =) in. Hence when = the attacker benefits fro an interediate, while the defender benefits fro to be either low or high. With low the defender enjoys the deployent of any FTs, whereas with high fewer FTs ake the defender benefit fro concentrating its resource of protection.. W : 7 H* :.... σ.... :.... σ. 8 Q* 7.. :.... σ σ... Figure :, H*, Q* and W for z=.7, as functions of σ, for δ =., =τ= and different.

10 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken However, when both and are low which akes the contest over each target ore egalitarian in both contests, the attacker benefits despite the defender deploying any FTs. This latter result depends strongly on σ=.8 which restricts the defender to deploy axiu five FTs. is inverse U shaped.. W : : H*..8.. Q*..8.. :.. :.. Figure 7:, H*, Q* and W for z=.7, as functions of, for δ =., σ=.8, τ= and different. Figure 8 presents as function of, for =, σ=.8, τ= and different δ (when τ=) and τ (when δ=.). increases in δ and τ, and is increasing or inverse U shaped in. When the attacker s protection effort is low copared with the total defender s resource, or the defender s protection effort is low copared with the attacker s attack resource, the defender justifies the preventive strike for a lower estiated attack probability. When the contest intensity in the strike against the attacker is low, the defender justifies the preventive strike for a low estiated unprovoked attack probability, enjoying the ore egalitarian contest. When δ is large (above. in Fig. 8) and τ is sall (τ= in Fig. 8), increases towards when increases, aking the preventive strike unjustified even when the attacker is relatively certain to attack. The reason is that the defender is inferior in a double sense. Its protection effort is low and the attacker s protection effort is large. In this case the defender relies on deploying FTs instead, as we ll see in Fig. 9. For the reaining cobinations of δ and τ, is inverse U shaped in. For large the defender justifies the preventive strike even when the attack probability is low. The reason is that the defender is no longer inferior in a double sense, and if the attacker is eliinated, its object is secure τ : Figure 8: as function of, for =, σ=.8, τ= and different δ (when τ=) and τ (when δ=.).

11 Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy Figure 9 presents, H*, Q* and W for z=.8, as functions of τ, for σ =.8, == and different δ. It can be seen that W decreases in τ, causing decreasing destruction probability as the defender s protection effort increases relative to the attacker s attack resource. W is insensitive to δ when δ. The reason is that for δ, z ax becoes greater than z and the defender prefers the passive defense and avoids the PS. In this case the attacker's protection resource has no influence on the outcoe of its ission.. W H*..8.. τ... Q*..8.. τ τ τ.. Figure 9:, H*, Q* and W for z=.8, as functions of τ, for σ =.8, == and different δ. increases in δ and becoes independent of τ for large δ. Indeed with the growth of τ and δ the defender benefits fro increasing the nuber of FTs. At soe point it allocates as any as possible FTs H*=h and () takes the for, z [ ( ) ] in = + ( hσ ) / δ. In this case does not depend onτ. The attacker attacks all targets because Q*=H*+ is the solution of (9) for =.. Conservative Defense Strategy under Uncertain Contest Intensities In any practical situations the values of the contest intensities cannot be exactly deterined. Therefore, it would be useful to suggest a practical way to deterine the optial defense strategy for certain intervals of the contest intensities and. The ost conservative defense strategy is to assue that the actual values of and (belonging to exogenously defined intervals) are the ost favorable for the attacker. This approach is equivalent to assuing that the attacker can choose and within the given interval as free strategic variables. The inax defense strategy, thus, iniizes the axial probability of the object destruction W associated with a cobination of the ost unfavorable circustances (contest intensities and) and the ost harful attacker's choice of Q. Let Q H *(,) be the value of the attacker's effort distribution paraeter that axiizes the object destruction probability for the given H, and. The defender's strategy is to choose the nuber of FTs H* that iniizes W in the range in ax, in ax of contest intensities assuing that the attacker always chooses its best response Q H *(,):

12 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken ax W H * *, (, ),, ax W H *, (, ),, in ax in ax H H in ax in ax for any H H*. In order to solve the inax gae for any given ranges of the contest intensities the following procedure should be applied:. Find Q h *<h+, and in * ax that axiize P ~ ;. Assign P in =;. For each H=,, h.. Find Q H *<H+, in * ax and in * ax that axiize P(Q,H);.. If P(H)<P ax assign P ax =P(Q H *,H), H*=H;. If P ax < P ~, allocate H* FTs and strike preventively achieving W=P ax, otherwise allocate h FTs and abstain fro striking preventively achieving W= P ~.. Obtain = P ~ /(zp ax ). Figure presents, *, *, H*, Q H * and W for z=.7, as functions of τ and δ for σ =.8 and uncertain contest intensities that can take values in the ranges,. Fig. presents the sae functions for the case of two ties shorter ranges of the uncertain contest intensities (with the sae ean values):..,... One can see that the ost harful for the defender values of and can abruptly change with variation of τ and δ. Indeed, when the gae paraeters change, the defender and the attacker adjust their H and Q H accordingly, which causes variation of the effort balances in the attack and the preventive strike. When (-H*σ)<δ in (), the defender suffers fro the axial possible value of, otherwise the defender suffers fro the inial possible value of. When Q * H τ< in (), the inial possible value of is ost favorable for the defender, otherwise the axial possible value of is ost favorable for the defender. () W..8. H* τ τ.. δ.. : τ...7 Q H* * * τ τ τ...7 δ.. :.7 δ.. :.7 Figure :, *, *, H*, Q H * and W for z=.7, as functions of τ and δ for σ =.8, for,.

13 Preventive Strike vs. False Targets in Defense Strategy W τ...7 Q H * τ...7 * H* τ...7 * τ δ.. : τ δ.. : τ...7 Figure :, *, *, H*, Q H * and W for z=.7, as functions of τ and δ for σ =.8, for..,... Coparing Fig. with Fig. one can see that the defender benefits fro the reduction of the uncertainty of the contest intensities. Indeed, when..,.., W is always lower than when,.. Conclusion The article analyzes how a defender deterines a balance between defending an object passively by deploying false targets (decoys) and striking preventively against an attacker seeking to destroy the object. With no preventive strike the defender allocates its entire resource to passive protection. If the defender strikes preventively, the attacker s vulnerability depends on its protection and on the defender's resource allocated to the strike. If the attacker survives, the object s vulnerability depends on the attacker s revenge attack resource allocated to the attacked object. The attacker cannot distinguish the false targets fro the genuine object and can choose to attack a subset of the targets. The paper presents an optiization odel that can be used for aking a decision about efficiency of the preventive strike based on the estiated attack probability. The ethodology of analysis of influence of different odel paraeters on the optial defense strategy is deonstrated. It is shown that the preventive strike is beneficial for the defender when the deployent of FTs becoes expensive, when the probability of unprovoked attacker's strike is high and when the attacker s protection effort is low copared with the total defender s resource, or the defender s protection effort is low copared with the attacker s attack resource. It is also shown that the contest intensity paraeters and, for the attacker s vulnerability and the object s vulnerability, respectively, strongly influence the optial defense strategy. The inial estiated attacker's strike probability when the preventive strike is justified can depend on the contest intensity paraeters non-onotonically, which coplicates the analysis and akes intuition based decision aking ipossible. The contest intensity paraeters usually cannot be exactly evaluated in practice. We deonstrate the ost conservative approach of handling the uncertainty of the contest intensities in which the range of possible variation of and is deterined and the

14 Gregory Levitin and Kjell Hausken "worst case" defense strategy is obtained under the assuption that and take the values that are ost favorable for the attacker (in this case and can be considered as additional strategic variables that the attacker can choose within the specified ranges). References []. Hausken, K. and Levitin, G. Review of Systes Defense and Attack Models. International Journal of Perforability Engineering, ; 8(): -. []. Kroening, V. Prevention or Preeption? Towards a Clarification of Terinology, Project on Defense Alternatives Guest Coentary. Cabridge, MA: Coonwealth Institute,. []. Renn, O. and Sellke, P. Risk, Society and Policy Making: Risk Governance in a Coplex World. International Journal of Perforability Engineering, ; 7(): 9-. []. Kosowski, K.T. Functional Safety Analysis including Huan Factors. International Journal of Perforability Engineering, ; 7(): -7. []. Kuipers, B.S. Perforability of Work Teas: Balancing Hard and Soft Issues. International Journal of Perforability Engineering, 9; (): -. []. Tullock, G. Efficient Rent-Seeking, in Buchanan, J.M., Tollison, R.D., and Tullock, G., Toward a Theory of the Rent-Seeking Society, Texas A. & M. University Press, College Station, 98: 97-. [7]. Skaperdas, S., Contest success functions. Econoic Theory 7, 99 :8-9. [8]. Hirshleifer, J. Anarchy and Its Breakdown. Journal of Political Econoy, 99; (): -. Gregory Levitin (eail: levitin@iec.co.il) is presently a senior expert at the Reliability Departent of the Israel Electric Corporation and distinguished visiting professor at University of Electronic Science and Technology of China. His current interests are in operations research and artificial intelligence applications in defense and reliability. In this field Prof. Levitin has published ore than 7 papers and four books. He is senior eber of IEEE and chair of the ESRA Technical Coittee on Syste Reliability. He is associate editor of IEEE Transactions on Reliability, Area Coordinator of International Journal of Perforability Engineering and eber of editorial boards of Reliability Engineering & Syste Safety, Journal of Risk and Reliability and Reliability and Quality Perforance. Kjell Hausken (eail: kjell.hausken@uis.no) is Professor of Econoics and Societal Safety at the University of Stavanger, Norway since 999. His research fields are strategic interaction, risk analysis, public choice, conflict, gae theory, terroris, inforation security, econoic risk anageent. He holds a Ph.D. fro the University of Chicago (99 99), was a Postdoc scientist at the Max Planck Institute (Cologne) , and a Visiting Scholar at Yale University He has published articles and is on the Editorial Board for Theory and Decision, and Defence and Peace Econoics. He has refereed for journals, and has advised five Ph.D. students.

An improvement in calculation method for apparel assembly line balancing

An improvement in calculation method for apparel assembly line balancing Indian Journal of Fibre & Textile Research Vol.38, Septeber 2013, pp 259-264 An iproveent in calculation ethod for apparel assebly line balancing F Khosravi 1, a, A H Sadeghi 1 & F Jolai 2 1 Textile Departent,

More information

Integration of Lean Approaches to Manage a Manual Assembly System

Integration of Lean Approaches to Manage a Manual Assembly System Open Journal of Social Sciences, 204, 2, 226-23 Published Online Septeber 204 in SciRes. http://www.scirp.org/journal/jss http://dx.doi.org/0.4236/jss.204.29038 Integration of Lean Approaches to Manage

More information

MODELLING THE EFFECTS OF PEDESTRIANS ON INTERSECTION CAPACITY AND DELAY WITH ACTUATED SIGNAL CONTROL

MODELLING THE EFFECTS OF PEDESTRIANS ON INTERSECTION CAPACITY AND DELAY WITH ACTUATED SIGNAL CONTROL MODELLING THE EFFECTS OF PEDESTRIANS ON INTERSECTION CAPACITY AND DELAY WITH ACTUATED SIGNAL CONTROL ABSTRACT Zong Tian, Ph.D., P.E. Feng Xu, Graduate Assistant Departent of Civil and Environental Engineering

More information

Wave Force on Coastal Dike due to Tsunami

Wave Force on Coastal Dike due to Tsunami Wave Force on Coastal Dike due to Tsunai by Fuinori Kato 1, Shigeki Inagaki 2 and Masaya Fukuhaa 3 ABSTRACT This paper presents results of large-scale experients on wave force due to tsunai. A odel of

More information

IMPROVED SPECTRAL WAVE MODELLING OF WHITE-CAPPING DISSIPATION IN SWELL SEA SYSTEMS

IMPROVED SPECTRAL WAVE MODELLING OF WHITE-CAPPING DISSIPATION IN SWELL SEA SYSTEMS Proceedings of OMAE 2004: 23rd International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering 20-25 June 2004, Vancouver, Canada OMAE2004-51562 IMPROVED SPECTRAL WAVE MODELLING OF WHITE-CAPPING

More information

AN OPTIMIZATION MODEL AND ALGORITHM OF STUDENTS' PHYSICAL FITNESS TEST SEQUENCE

AN OPTIMIZATION MODEL AND ALGORITHM OF STUDENTS' PHYSICAL FITNESS TEST SEQUENCE 28 th February 203. Vol. 48 3 2005-203 JATIT & LLS. All rights reserved. ISSN: 992-8645 www.jatit.org E-ISSN: 87-395 AN OPTIMIZATION MODEL AND ALGORITHM OF STUDENTS' PHYSICAL FITNESS TEST SEQUENCE JINSONG

More information

Race car damping 2. Fig-1 quarter car model.

Race car damping 2. Fig-1 quarter car model. Race car daping A nuber of issues ago I wrote an article on exploring approaches to specify a race car daper. This article is the second in that series and we shall be following on fro where we left off.

More information

Simulating the effects of fatigue and pathologies in gait

Simulating the effects of fatigue and pathologies in gait Siulating the effects of fatigue and pathologies in gait T Koura 1, A Nagano, H Leung 3 and Y Shinagawa 4 1,3 Departent of Coputer Engineering and Inforation Technology, City University of Hong Kong, 83

More information

Estimation of the Effect of Cadence on Gait Stability in Young and Elderly People using Approximate Entropy Technique

Estimation of the Effect of Cadence on Gait Stability in Young and Elderly People using Approximate Entropy Technique MEASUREMENT SCIENCE REVIEW, Volue 4, Section 2, 4 Estiation of the Effect of Cadence on Gait Stability in Young and Elderly People using Approxiate Entropy Technique M. Arif *, Y. Ohtaki **, R. Nagatoi

More information

Recommendations on Two Acceleration Measurements with Low Strain Integrity Test

Recommendations on Two Acceleration Measurements with Low Strain Integrity Test Recoendations on Two Acceleration Measureents with Low Strain Integrity Test Liqun Liang, PhD., P.E., 1 Scott Webster, P.E., 2 and Marty Bixler, P.E. 3 1 Pile Dynaics Inc., 3725 Aurora Rd, Cleveland, Ohio

More information

Simulating Method of Ship s Turning-basins Designing

Simulating Method of Ship s Turning-basins Designing International Journal on Marine Navigation and Safety of Sea Transportation Volue 5 Nuber 2 June 2011 Siulating Method of Ship s Turning-basins Designing J. Kornacki Szczecin Maritie University, Szczecin,

More information

Guide to Target Archery Rounds, Scoring, Handicaps and Classifications

Guide to Target Archery Rounds, Scoring, Handicaps and Classifications Guide to Target Archery Rounds, Scoring, Handicaps and Classifications 2016 Contents 1Target Archery Rounds...3 1.1Iperial Outdoor Rounds...4 1.2Metric Outdoor Rounds...5 1.3Indoor Rounds...6 1.4Shooting

More information

Exercise 1 Network Planning Design. Teresa Grilo Dep. of Engineering and Management Instituto Superior Técnico Lisbon, Portugal

Exercise 1 Network Planning Design. Teresa Grilo Dep. of Engineering and Management Instituto Superior Técnico Lisbon, Portugal Exercise 1 Network Planning Design Teresa Grilo Dep. of Engineering and Manageent Instituto Superior Técnico Lisbon, Portugal SCM/IST 1 SCM/IST IST Lisbon Ana Ana Carvalho 2015 2015 Introduction Find the

More information

Guide to Target Archery Rounds, Scoring, Handicaps and Classifications

Guide to Target Archery Rounds, Scoring, Handicaps and Classifications Guide to Target Archery Rounds, Scoring, Handicaps and Classifications Produced by Malcol North (Herts Group of Archery Coaches) Page 1 of 11 Contents 1Target Archery Rounds...3 1.1Iperial Outdoor Rounds...3

More information

CARPET BOWLING m

CARPET BOWLING m Rules of the Gaes Carpet Bowling CARPET BOWLING 1. These rules, as published by R.W. Hensall & Sons Ltd. of Victoria, Australia, shall be considered the official rules for the Alberta 55 Plus Gaes and

More information

Projectile Motion Lab (2019)

Projectile Motion Lab (2019) Nae: Date: Partner(s): Period: Projectile Motion Lab (2019) Object: Measure the velocity of a ball using two Photogates and coputer software for tiing. Apply concepts fro two-diensional kineatics to predict

More information

An Indian Journal FULL PAPER ABSTRACT KEYWORDS. Trade Science Inc.

An Indian Journal FULL PAPER ABSTRACT KEYWORDS. Trade Science Inc. [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] ISSN : 0974-7435 Volue 10 Issue 24 BioTechnology 2014 An Indian Journal FULL PAPER BTAIJ, 10(24), 2014 [15430-15434] Mechanical analysis of tennis racket and ball during

More information

A parametric study of an offshore concrete pile under combined loading conditions using finite element method

A parametric study of an offshore concrete pile under combined loading conditions using finite element method 32 A paraetric stud of an offshore concrete pile under cobined loading conditions using finite eleent ethod J.A. Eicher, H. Guan 1 and D. S. Jeng School of Engineering, Griffith Universit Gold Coast Capus,

More information

Stable bipedal walking with a swing-leg protraction strategy

Stable bipedal walking with a swing-leg protraction strategy To cite this article: Bhounsule, Pranav A., and Zaani, Ali. Stable bipedal walking with a swing-leg protraction strategy. Journal of Bioechanics 51 (017): 13-17. Stable bipedal walking with a swing-leg

More information

Unit Activity Answer Sheet

Unit Activity Answer Sheet Geoetry Unit Activity Answer Sheet Unit: Extending to Three Diensions This Unit Activity will help you eet these educational goals: Matheatical Practices You will use atheatics to odel real-world situations.

More information

501 Interchange Design Interchange Design Considerations... 10

501 Interchange Design Interchange Design Considerations... 10 5 Interchange Design Table of Contents 51 Interchange Design... 1 51.1 General...1 51.2 Interchange Type...1 51.2.1 Diaond Interchanges... 1 51.2.1.1 Tight Urban Diaond Interchange (TUDI)... 1 51.2.1.2

More information

The Handtmann Armaturenfabrik. Safety without compromise. Safety valves for liquids, gases, and steam

The Handtmann Armaturenfabrik. Safety without compromise. Safety valves for liquids, gases, and steam The Handtann Araturenfabrik Safety without coproise for liquids, gases, and stea f Safety Valves FoodSafe Tradition Meets Innovation fro Handtann are first choice for hygienically sensitive product areas

More information

GENERAL ARTICLES. Xing Wang

GENERAL ARTICLES. Xing Wang A Granger causality test of the causal relationship between the nuber of editorial board ebers and the scientific output of universities in the field of cheistry Xing Wang Editorial board ebers, who are

More information

Pressure Redistribution Mattresses

Pressure Redistribution Mattresses Integrider coparative attress features Heel Slope The ost powerful solution for your ost vulnerable patients or residents For critical care patients/residents, the Integrider delivers. Here s how: Better

More information

3D simulation of ship motions to support the planning of rescue operations on damaged ships

3D simulation of ship motions to support the planning of rescue operations on damaged ships Procedia Coputer Science Volue 51, 2015, Pages 2397 2405 ICCS 2015 International Conference On Coputational Science 3D siulation of ship otions to support the planning of rescue operations on daaged ships

More information

Design of Saddle Support for Horizontal Pressure Vessel Vinod Kumar, Navin Kumar, Surjit Angra, Prince Sharma

Design of Saddle Support for Horizontal Pressure Vessel Vinod Kumar, Navin Kumar, Surjit Angra, Prince Sharma World Acadey of Science, Engineering and Technology Vol:8, No:, 0 Design of Saddle Support for Horizontal Pressure Vessel Vinod Kuar, Navin Kuar, Surjit Angra, Prince Shara International Science Index,

More information

NUMERICAL STUDY OF WAVE-CURRENT INTERACTION USING HIGH RESOLUTION COUPLED MODEL IN THE KUROSHIO REGION

NUMERICAL STUDY OF WAVE-CURRENT INTERACTION USING HIGH RESOLUTION COUPLED MODEL IN THE KUROSHIO REGION NUMERICAL STUDY OF WAVE-CURRENT INTERACTION USING HIGH RESOLUTION COUPLED MODEL IN THE KUROSHIO REGION Hitoshi TAMURA Frontier Research Center for Global Change/JAMSTEC 373- Showaachi, Kanazawa-ku, Yokohaa,

More information

A RISK MODEL FOR ASSESSING THE SHIP SINKABILITY IN UNCERTAIN CONDITIONS

A RISK MODEL FOR ASSESSING THE SHIP SINKABILITY IN UNCERTAIN CONDITIONS Mirosław Gerigk Gdańsk University of Technology A RISK MODEL FOR ASSESSING THE SHIP SINKABILITY IN UNCERTAIN CONDITIONS Abstract: The paper concerns the ship safety in daaged conditions. The existing ethods

More information

I though clearly subject to heredity, is not inherited in a simple Mendelian

I though clearly subject to heredity, is not inherited in a simple Mendelian STUDIES OF A SIZE CROSS IN MICE w. E. CASTLE, W. H. GATES, AND S. C. REED Bussey Institution, Harvard University, Boston, Massachusetts and Louisiana State University, Baton Roug~, Louisiana Received August

More information

Schedule A. Measurement Requirements for Oil and Gas Operations

Schedule A. Measurement Requirements for Oil and Gas Operations Schedule A Measureent Requireents for Oil and Gas Operations Directive PNG017 August 1, 2017 Version 2.1 Governing Legislation: Act: The Oil and Gas Conservation Act Regulation: The Oil and Gas Conservation

More information

On Runway Capacity and Wake Vortex Safe Separation Distance (SSD)

On Runway Capacity and Wake Vortex Safe Separation Distance (SSD) On Runway Capacity and Wake Vortex Safe Separation Distance (SSD) L.M.B.C. Capos CCTAE (Center for Aeronautical and Space Science and Tecnology), Instituto Superior Tecnico, Lisbon Technnical University.

More information

Design of Pedal Driven Unit: An unconventional alternative Energy Source

Design of Pedal Driven Unit: An unconventional alternative Energy Source Design of Pedal Driven Unit: An unconventional alternative Energy Source M. S. Giripunje 1, Dr. C. N. Sakhale, S. K. Undirwade 3, S. N. Waghaare 4 1 3 4 Abstract Increasing load shedding, insufficiency

More information

A Numerical Prediction of Wash Wave and Wave Resistance of High Speed Displacement Ships in Deep and Shallow Water

A Numerical Prediction of Wash Wave and Wave Resistance of High Speed Displacement Ships in Deep and Shallow Water การประช มว ชาการเคร อข ายว ศวกรรมเคร องกลแห งประเทศไทยคร งท 18 18- ต ลาคม 547 จ งหว ดขอนแก น A Nuerical Prediction of Wash Wave and Wave Resistance of High Speed Displaceent Ships in Deep and Shallow Water

More information

Dewpoint Internal Gas Pressure and Chemical Composition of the Gas Within the Free Volume of DWPF Canistered Waste Forms (U)

Dewpoint Internal Gas Pressure and Chemical Composition of the Gas Within the Free Volume of DWPF Canistered Waste Forms (U) a WSRCMS960244 OOdF 940804(cg Dewpoint Internal Gas Pressure and Cheical Coposition of the Gas Within the Free Volue of DWPF Canistered Waste Fors (U) by J R Harbour Westinghouse Savannah River Copany

More information

Basics of Flow measurement using Hot-film anemometer

Basics of Flow measurement using Hot-film anemometer Basics of Flow easureent using Hot-fil aneoeter Version 1.0 1/9 Inhaltsverzeichnis: 1. Definitions 1.1. Air Velocity 1.2. Aount (of Gas) 1.. Flow 1..1. Mass flow rate 1..2. Voluetric flow rate 1... Standard

More information

Ripple Tank: Instruction Manual

Ripple Tank: Instruction Manual Ripple Tank: Instruction Manual The Ripple Tank coprises the following individual parts: Assebly of the ripple tank: Water Tank.......1pcs Detachable legs....3pcs Angular holders.......2pcs Plate fitting...1pcs

More information

Game Theory (MBA 217) Final Paper. Chow Heavy Industries Ty Chow Kenny Miller Simiso Nzima Scott Winder

Game Theory (MBA 217) Final Paper. Chow Heavy Industries Ty Chow Kenny Miller Simiso Nzima Scott Winder Game Theory (MBA 217) Final Paper Chow Heavy Industries Ty Chow Kenny Miller Simiso Nzima Scott Winder Introduction The end of a basketball game is when legends are made or hearts are broken. It is what

More information

The Timing and Deterrence of Terrorist Attacks 1. Keywords: Terrorism, terror capacity, threat, conflict, dynamics, contest success function

The Timing and Deterrence of Terrorist Attacks 1. Keywords: Terrorism, terror capacity, threat, conflict, dynamics, contest success function The Timing and Deterrence of Terrorist Attacks 1 Kjell Hausken Faculty of Social Sciences University of Stavanger N-4036 Stavanger, Norway kjell.hausken@uis.no Jun Zhuang Department of Industrial and Systems

More information

The water outgassing rate of internal surfaces of vacuum systems

The water outgassing rate of internal surfaces of vacuum systems Journal of Physics: Conference Series PAPER OPEN ACCESS The water outgassing rate of internal surfaces of vacuu systes Recent citations - Soe probles of the vacuu technique developent L N Rozanov and A

More information

An Application of Signal Detection Theory for Understanding Driver Behavior at Highway-Rail Grade Crossings

An Application of Signal Detection Theory for Understanding Driver Behavior at Highway-Rail Grade Crossings An Application of Signal Detection Theory for Understanding Driver Behavior at Highway-Rail Grade Crossings Michelle Yeh and Jordan Multer United States Department of Transportation Volpe National Transportation

More information

Weight Optimization and Finite Element Analysis of Pressure Vessel Due to Thickness

Weight Optimization and Finite Element Analysis of Pressure Vessel Due to Thickness 2017 IJSRSET Volue 3 Issue 2 Print ISSN: 2395-1990 Online ISSN : 2394-4099 Theed Section: Engineering and Technology Weight Optiization and Finite Eleent Analysis of Pressure Vessel Due to Thickness Rashi

More information

Operating Instructions

Operating Instructions Table of Contents Table of Contents... 2 Conventions Used in this Manual... 4 1. Introduction...5 1.1. Notes on this anual... 6 1.2. Modes Covered by this Manual... 6 2. Basic Operation...7 2.1. Turning

More information

Linear Seakeeping High Sea State Applicability

Linear Seakeeping High Sea State Applicability Proceedings of the 16 th International Ship Stability Workshop, 5-7 June 2017, Belgrade, Serbia 1 Linear Seakeeping High Sea State Applicability Tiothy C. Sith, Naval Surface Warfare Center Carderock Division,

More information

RAPID developments in image-guided radiation therapy offer. Irregular Breathing Classification From Multiple Patient Datasets Using Neural Networks

RAPID developments in image-guided radiation therapy offer. Irregular Breathing Classification From Multiple Patient Datasets Using Neural Networks IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IN BIOMEDICINE, VOL. 16, NO. 6, NOVEMBER 2012 1253 Irregular Breathing Classification Fro Multiple Patient Datasets Using Neural Networks Suk Jin Lee, Student

More information

Name: Answer Key Date: Regents Physics. Waves

Name: Answer Key Date: Regents Physics. Waves Nae: Answer Key Date: Regents Physics Test # 13 Review Waves 1. Use GUESS ethod and indicate all vector directions. 2. Ters to know: echanical wave, transverse wave, longitudinal wave, surace wave, electroagnetic

More information

A SEMI-PRESSURE-DRIVEN APPROACH TO RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT OF WATER DISTRIBUTION NETWORKS

A SEMI-PRESSURE-DRIVEN APPROACH TO RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT OF WATER DISTRIBUTION NETWORKS A SEMI-PRESSURE-DRIVEN APPROACH TO RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT OF WATER DISTRIBUTION NETWORKS S. S. OZGER PhD Student, Dept. of Civil and Envir. Engrg., Arizona State Univ., 85287, Tempe, AZ, US Phone: +1-480-965-3589

More information

Exploring fisheries dynamics according to different quota governance mechanisms: application to the bay of Biscay common sole fishery

Exploring fisheries dynamics according to different quota governance mechanisms: application to the bay of Biscay common sole fishery IIFET 2014 Conference, 7-11 July 2014, Brisbane, Australia Exploring fisheries dynaics according to different quota governance echaniss: application to the bay of Biscay coon sole fishery Manuel Bellanger,

More information

Reliability Analysis Including External Failures for Low Demand Marine Systems

Reliability Analysis Including External Failures for Low Demand Marine Systems Reliability Analysis Including External Failures for Low Demand Marine Systems KIM HyungJu a*, HAUGEN Stein a, and UTNE Ingrid Bouwer b a Department of Production and Quality Engineering NTNU, Trondheim,

More information

[2005] IEEE. Reprinted, with permission, from [Wang, S.W. Su, B.G. Celler, and A.V. Savkin, Modeling of a Gas Concentration Measurement System,

[2005] IEEE. Reprinted, with permission, from [Wang, S.W. Su, B.G. Celler, and A.V. Savkin, Modeling of a Gas Concentration Measurement System, [2005] IEEE. Reprted, with perission, ro [Wang, S.W. Su, B.G. Celler, and A.V. Savk, Modelg o a Gas Concentration Measureent Syste, Engeerg Medice and Biology Society, 2005. IEEE-EMBS 2005. 27th Annual

More information

Effect of Nozzle Type on the Performance of Bubble Augmented Waterjet Propulsion

Effect of Nozzle Type on the Performance of Bubble Augmented Waterjet Propulsion Fourth International Syposiu on Marine Propulsors Effect of Nozzle Type on the Perforance of Bubble Augented Waterjet Propulsion SMP 15, Austin, Texas, USA, June 015 Xiongjun Wu 1, Jin-Keun Choi, Abigail

More information

A Fair Target Score Calculation Method for Reduced-Over One day and T20 International Cricket Matches

A Fair Target Score Calculation Method for Reduced-Over One day and T20 International Cricket Matches A Fair Target Score Calculation Method for Reduced-Over One day and T20 International Cricket Matches Rohan de Silva, PhD. Abstract In one day internationals and T20 cricket games, the par score is defined

More information

Brian P. Casaday and J. C. Vanderhoff Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah

Brian P. Casaday and J. C. Vanderhoff Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah P. SIMLATIOS OF ITERAL WAVES APPROACHIG A CRITICAL LEVEL Brian P. Casaday and J. C. Vanderhoff Brigha Young niversity, Provo, tah. BACKGROD Internal gravity waves exist abundantly in our world in stably-stratified

More information

Planning Daily Work Trip under Congested Abuja Keffi Road Corridor

Planning Daily Work Trip under Congested Abuja Keffi Road Corridor ISBN 978-93-84468-19-4 Proceedings of International Conference on Transportation and Civil Engineering (ICTCE'15) London, March 21-22, 2015, pp. 43-47 Planning Daily Work Trip under Congested Abuja Keffi

More information

FUBA RULEBOOK VERSION

FUBA RULEBOOK VERSION FUBA RULEBOOK 15.07.2018 2.1 VERSION Introduction FUBA is a board game, which simulates football matches from a tactical view. The game includes its most important details. The players take roles of the

More information

Legendre et al Appendices and Supplements, p. 1

Legendre et al Appendices and Supplements, p. 1 Legendre et al. 2010 Appendices and Supplements, p. 1 Appendices and Supplement to: Legendre, P., M. De Cáceres, and D. Borcard. 2010. Community surveys through space and time: testing the space-time interaction

More information

==================================================

================================================== The contribution of some of the determinants of tactical maps as indicators of increasing the effectiveness ofactivity offensive to the players under the weight of "75 kg"competition actual fighting "kumite"

More information

Quality Planning for Software Development

Quality Planning for Software Development Quality Planning for Software Development Tom Walton Alcatel Networks tom.waltoniliiialcatel.com Abstract A historical project is used as a reference model for the verification planning process. The planning

More information

Goldsmiths Company Mathematics Course for Teachers. Game Theory. Dr. Reto Mueller

Goldsmiths Company Mathematics Course for Teachers. Game Theory. Dr. Reto Mueller Goldsmiths Company Mathematics Course for Teachers Game Theory Dr. Reto Mueller r.mueller@qmul.ac.uk Game Theory is the study of strategic decision making Game Theory is the study of mathematical models

More information

ESTIMATION OF THE DESIGN WIND SPEED BASED ON

ESTIMATION OF THE DESIGN WIND SPEED BASED ON The Seventh Asia-Pacific Conference on Wind Engineering, November 8-12, 2009, Taipei, Taiwan ESTIMATION OF THE DESIGN WIND SPEED BASED ON UNCERTAIN PARAMETERS OF THE WIND CLIMATE Michael Kasperski 1 1

More information

Limits of Wave Runup and Corresponding Beach- Profile Change from Large-Scale Laboratory Data

Limits of Wave Runup and Corresponding Beach- Profile Change from Large-Scale Laboratory Data University of South Florida Scholar Coons Geology Faculty Publications Geology 1-21 Liits of Wave Runup and Corresponding Beach- Profile Change fro Large-Scale Laboratory Data Tiffany M. Roberts University

More information

DRAW: each of the following (use the drawing of the baseball diamond, as needed, showing where each player plays):

DRAW: each of the following (use the drawing of the baseball diamond, as needed, showing where each player plays): 19 LESSON # 7 (You ll need to go to a baseball diaond.) DRAW: each of the following (use the drawing of the baseball diaond, as needed, showing where each player plays): A Pitcher A Batter A Fielder Fielding

More information

The Environmental Impact of Skiing on Mont Lozère (IB Diploma Option G)

The Environmental Impact of Skiing on Mont Lozère (IB Diploma Option G) The Environental Ipact of Skiing on Mont Lozère (IB Diploa Option G) Discover Ltd. Tibers, Oxted Road, Godstone, Surrey. RH9 8AD www.discover.ltd.uk Discover Ltd 2009 1 The Environental Ipact Of Skiing

More information

Queue analysis for the toll station of the Öresund fixed link. Pontus Matstoms *

Queue analysis for the toll station of the Öresund fixed link. Pontus Matstoms * Queue analysis for the toll station of the Öresund fixed link Pontus Matstoms * Abstract A new simulation model for queue and capacity analysis of a toll station is presented. The model and its software

More information

Effect of Surface Morphing on the Wake Structure and Performance of Pitching-rolling Plates

Effect of Surface Morphing on the Wake Structure and Performance of Pitching-rolling Plates Effect of Surface Morphing on the Wake Structure and Perforance of Pitching-rolling Plates Yan Ren 1, Geng Liu 2 and Haibo Dong 3 Departent of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering University of Virginia,

More information

arxiv: v1 [cs.lg] 15 Mar 2019

arxiv: v1 [cs.lg] 15 Mar 2019 A Ranng Model Motivated by Nonnegative Matrix Factorization with Applications to Tennis Tournaents Rui Xia 1, Vincent Y. F. Tan 1, Louis Filstroff 2, and Cédric Févotte 2 1 Departent of Matheatics, National

More information

Jurnal Teknologi A MODIFIED ARTIFICIAL POTENTIAL FIELD METHOD FOR RIVERINE OBSTACLES AVOIDANCE. Full Paper. Mei Jian Hong, M. R.

Jurnal Teknologi A MODIFIED ARTIFICIAL POTENTIAL FIELD METHOD FOR RIVERINE OBSTACLES AVOIDANCE. Full Paper. Mei Jian Hong, M. R. Jurnal Teknologi A MODIFIED ATIFICIAL POTENTIAL FIELD METHOD FO IVEINE OBSTACLES AVOIDANCE Mei Jian Hong, M.. Arshad* Underwater, Control and obotics esearch Group (UCG), School of Electrical and Electronic

More information

Sensor Technologie A TEMPOSONICS. R Series CANbasic C207. Operating Manual. Configuration and CAN-Bus Coupling. page PL.

Sensor Technologie A TEMPOSONICS. R Series CANbasic C207. Operating Manual. Configuration and CAN-Bus Coupling. page PL. Sensor Technologie TEMPOSONICS R 551040 A R Series 2004 CANbasic C207 Operating Manual Configuration and CAN-Bus Coupling page 1 Operating anual for CANbasic C207 Connecting diagra: RP-x-xxxxM-D6x-1-C207

More information

Buletinul Ştiinţific al Universităţii "POLITEHNICA" din Timişoara Seria HIDROTEHNICA TRANSACTIONS on HYDROTECHNICS

Buletinul Ştiinţific al Universităţii POLITEHNICA din Timişoara Seria HIDROTEHNICA TRANSACTIONS on HYDROTECHNICS Buletinul Ştiinţific al Universităţii "POLITEHNICA" din Tiişoara Seria HIDROTEHNICA TRANSACTIONS on HYDROTECHNICS To 55(69), Fascicola, 010 Experiental Stand for the Study of Unsteady Water Flow through

More information

Numerical simulation on fluctuation in wellhead pressure of geothermal well

Numerical simulation on fluctuation in wellhead pressure of geothermal well Wellhead pressure (MPa) PROCEEDINGS, Thirty-Ninth Workshop on Geotheral Reservoir Engineering Stanford University, Stanford, California, February 4-6, 014 SGP-TR-0 Nuerical siulation on fluctuation in

More information

HAND CALCULATION METHOD FOR AIR SUPPLY RATES IN VESTIBULE PRESSURIZATION SMOKE CONTROL SYSTEM

HAND CALCULATION METHOD FOR AIR SUPPLY RATES IN VESTIBULE PRESSURIZATION SMOKE CONTROL SYSTEM International Journal on ngineering Perforance-Based Fire odes, Volue, Nuber, p.7-40, 999 HAND AUATION MTHOD FO AI SUPPY ATS IN PSSUIZATION SMOK ONTO SYSTM M. Kujie Nikken Sekkei td, 4-6- Koraibashi, huo-ku,

More information

april 25-30, 2012 at the Friends & Family registration

april 25-30, 2012 at the Friends & Family registration april 25-30, 2012 at the Friends & Faily registration FRIENDS AND FAMILY REGISTRATION 2012 CHEERLEADING WORLDS USASF/IASF encourages Friends and Faily to attend! We want to offer you the sae great travel

More information

Drift Characteristics of a Moored Conductivity Temperature Depth Sensor and Correction of Salinity Data

Drift Characteristics of a Moored Conductivity Temperature Depth Sensor and Correction of Salinity Data 282 J O U R N A L O F A T M O S P H E R I C A N D O C E A N I C T E C H N O L O G Y VOLUME 22 Drift Characteristics of a Moored Conductivity Teperature Depth Sensor and Correction of Salinity Data KENTARO

More information

Modern volleyball aspects

Modern volleyball aspects Modern volleyball aspects Table of contents Aims 3 Introduction 4 Part 1 Men s volleyball of top level. Main indicators 5 Part 2 Women s volleyball of top level. Main indicators 29 Part 3 Men s and Women

More information

Tactical Combat Rules By David Newport

Tactical Combat Rules By David Newport Tactical Combat Rules By David Newport Tactical Combat is a game covering company and battalion level actions using 20 th century weapons. The game was designed for World War II action, but it handles

More information

S L G. Chapter 12: The Behavior of Gases. I. First Concepts a. The 3 states of matter most important to us: solids, liquids, and gases.

S L G. Chapter 12: The Behavior of Gases. I. First Concepts a. The 3 states of matter most important to us: solids, liquids, and gases. Chapter : he ehaior of Gases I. First Concepts a. he 3 states of atter ost iportant to us: solids, liquids, and gases. S L G b. Real Gases and Ideal Gases i. Real gases exist, ideal gases do not ii. Under

More information

Bubble Augmented Propulsion with a Convergent-Divergent Nozzle

Bubble Augmented Propulsion with a Convergent-Divergent Nozzle 30 th Syposiu on Naval Hydrodynaics Hobart, Tasania, Australia, -7 Noveber 014 Bubble Augented Propulsion with a Convergent-Divergent Nozzle Jin-Keun Choi, Xiongjun Wu, and Georges L. Chahine (DYNAFLOW,

More information

Fail Operational Controls for an Independent Metering Valve

Fail Operational Controls for an Independent Metering Valve Group 14 - System Intergration and Safety Paper 14-3 465 Fail Operational Controls for an Independent Metering Valve Michael Rannow Eaton Corporation, 7945 Wallace Rd., Eden Prairie, MN, 55347, email:

More information

100gk Abseil Position Drop Test Dates: 21 st & 22 nd May 2012 Venue: Gridins Training Centre, Lithuania

100gk Abseil Position Drop Test Dates: 21 st & 22 nd May 2012 Venue: Gridins Training Centre, Lithuania 100gk Abseil Position Drop Test Dates: 21 st & 22 nd May 2012 Venue: Gridins Training Centre, Lithuania Testers: C Parkin - Auditor/Assessor, Arturas Vengalis - L3 Training Manager Gridins) V Toas Daugintis

More information

Efficacy of Static and Dynamic Distance Perception on Kumite Performance in Karate

Efficacy of Static and Dynamic Distance Perception on Kumite Performance in Karate World Journal of Sport Sciences 3 (S): 205-209, 2010 ISSN 2078-4724 IDOSI Publications, 2010 Efficacy of Static and Dynamic Distance Perception on Kumite Performance in Karate Ahmed M. Abd El-Kader Department

More information

Investigation of Winning Factors of Miami Heat in NBA Playoff Season

Investigation of Winning Factors of Miami Heat in NBA Playoff Season Send Orders for Reprints to reprints@benthamscience.ae The Open Cybernetics & Systemics Journal, 2015, 9, 2793-2798 2793 Open Access Investigation of Winning Factors of Miami Heat in NBA Playoff Season

More information

Offside. Judging Involvement in Play Ohio South Module A On-Line Intermediate Referee Recertification Training

Offside. Judging Involvement in Play Ohio South Module A On-Line Intermediate Referee Recertification Training Offside Judging Involvement in Play 2014 Ohio South Module A On-Line Intermediate Referee Recertification Training CJK 1999 World Cup Offside Scenario 2014 Mod A.ppt OFFSIDE VIDEO The following video is

More information

Draft BS EN Stationary source emissions - Determination of the water vapour in ducts - Standard reference method

Draft BS EN Stationary source emissions - Determination of the water vapour in ducts - Standard reference method Draft for Public Coent PRIATE CIRCULATION EH//1_14_0146 For coent - Action Due Date: 015/0/3 For 36 DPC: 14 / 3093551 DC BSI Group Headquarters 389 Chiswick High Road London W4 4AL Date: 8 October 014

More information

The Performance-Enhancing Drug Game. by Kjetil K. Haugen. Molde University College Servicebox 8, N-6405 Molde, Norway

The Performance-Enhancing Drug Game. by Kjetil K. Haugen. Molde University College Servicebox 8, N-6405 Molde, Norway The Performance-Enhancing Drug Game by Kjetil K. Haugen Molde University College Servicebox 8, N-6405 Molde, Norway E-mail: Kjetil.Haugen@hiMolde.no Journal of Sports Economics (2004) 5:67-86 1 Athens

More information

MXV. Vertical Multi-Stage In-Line Pumps. Construction. Applications

MXV. Vertical Multi-Stage In-Line Pumps. Construction. Applications MXV Construction Vertical ulti-stage pups with suction and delivery connections of the sae diaeter and arranged along the sae axis (in-line). Corrosion-resistant bearing sleeves lubricated by the puped

More information

Simple Time-to-Failure Estimation Techniques for Reliability and Maintenance of Equipment

Simple Time-to-Failure Estimation Techniques for Reliability and Maintenance of Equipment F E A T U R E A R T I C L E Simple Time-to-Failure Estimation Techniques for Reliability and Maintenance of Equipment Key Words: Reliability and maintenance, time-to-failure estimation, reactive maintenance

More information

A Hare-Lynx Simulation Model

A Hare-Lynx Simulation Model 1 A Hare- Simulation Model What happens to the numbers of hares and lynx when the core of the system is like this? Hares O Balance? S H_Births Hares H_Fertility Area KillsPerHead Fertility Births Figure

More information

RoboCupJunior Soccer Rules for Big Field SuperTeams 2014

RoboCupJunior Soccer Rules for Big Field SuperTeams 2014 RoboCupJunior Soccer Rules for Big Field SuperTeams 2014 RoboCupJunior Soccer Technical Committee 2014: Katsumi Masaoka (Japan), CHAIR, k-mac@sea.plala.or.jp Luis José López (Mexico), llopez@tecnovanguardia.com

More information

Lecturer at Hydraulic Engineering, Vietnam Maritime university Address, Haiphong, Vietnam 2

Lecturer at Hydraulic Engineering, Vietnam Maritime university Address, Haiphong, Vietnam 2 OVERTOPPING FOR RUBBLE MOUND BREAKWATER ARMOURED WITH THE NEW BLOCK RAKUNAIV Le Thi Huong Giang 1, Thieu Quang Tuan 2, Pha Van Trung 3 1,3 Lecturer at Hydraulic Engineering, Vietna Maritie university Address,

More information

D.N. COLLEGE, HISAR Lesson Plan

D.N. COLLEGE, HISAR Lesson Plan D.N. COLLEGE, HISAR Lesson Plan Name of Assistant Professor: Mrs Vipula Class and Section: B.A 1 st Sem Subject: Defence Studies Lesson Plan: 14 weeks (from August, 2018 to November, 2018) Week 1 Chapter

More information

Impacts of climate change in coastal systems in Europe. PESETA-Coastal Systems study. Dr Julie A. Richards & Prof Robert J.

Impacts of climate change in coastal systems in Europe. PESETA-Coastal Systems study. Dr Julie A. Richards & Prof Robert J. Ipacts of cliate in al systes in Europe. PESETA- Systes study Dr Julie A. Richards & Prof Robert J. Nicholls EUR 24130 EN - 2009 The ission JRC-IPTS is to provide custoer-driven support to the EU policy-aking

More information

Factors determining the decrease in surface wind speed following the evening transition

Factors determining the decrease in surface wind speed following the evening transition Q. J. R. Meteorol. Soc. (2003), 129, pp. 1945 1968 doi: 10.1256/qj.02.163 Factors deterining the decrease in surface wind speed following the evening transition By A. LAPWORTH Met Of ce, Cardington, UK

More information

Advanced Sulfur Control Concepts in Hot-Gas Desulfurization Technology

Advanced Sulfur Control Concepts in Hot-Gas Desulfurization Technology t DE-AC2Z -94MC32-- Advanced Sulfur Control Concepts in Hot-Gas Desulfurization Technology Quarterly Report January - March 3,998 By: Douglas P Harrison Work Perfored Under Contract No: DE-AC2-94MC32 For

More information

We can use a 2 2 array to show all four situations that can arise in a single play of this game, and the results of each situation, as follows:

We can use a 2 2 array to show all four situations that can arise in a single play of this game, and the results of each situation, as follows: Two-Person Games Game theory was developed, starting in the 1940 s, as a model of situations of conflict. Such situations and interactions will be called games and they have participants who are called

More information

Guide to WSH Obligations for Shipmasters and Contractors for Anchorage Works

Guide to WSH Obligations for Shipmasters and Contractors for Anchorage Works Guide to WSH Obligations for Shipasters and Contractors for Anchorage Works Year of issue: 2014 Guide to WSH Obligations for Shipasters and Contractors for Anchorage Works Contents Section 1 Master s Obligations

More information

Honest Mirror: Quantitative Assessment of Player Performances in an ODI Cricket Match

Honest Mirror: Quantitative Assessment of Player Performances in an ODI Cricket Match Honest Mirror: Quantitative Assessment of Player Performances in an ODI Cricket Match Madan Gopal Jhawar 1 and Vikram Pudi 2 1 Microsoft, India majhawar@microsoft.com 2 IIIT Hyderabad, India vikram@iiit.ac.in

More information

ASSESSING THE RELIABILITY OF FAIL-SAFE STRUCTURES INTRODUCTION

ASSESSING THE RELIABILITY OF FAIL-SAFE STRUCTURES INTRODUCTION ASSESSING THE RELIABILITY OF FAIL-SAFE STRUCTURES Abraham Brot * Abstract: A computer simulation method is described, that can be used to assess the reliability of a dual-path fail-safe design. The method

More information

IWAS World Junior Games 2014

IWAS World Junior Games 2014 24 March 2014 Dear Friends, 10 th IWAS WORLD JUNIOR GAMES 2014, Stoke Mandeville, Great Britain 2 to 8 August Thank you to all the Nations for your overwheling support. To date IWAS has received entries

More information

Fish Farm Consent Modelling. Poll na Gille

Fish Farm Consent Modelling. Poll na Gille Poll na Gille February 2014 Report Written by Environental Manager Marine Harvest Scotland Fars Office Blar Mhor Industrial Estate Fort Willia, PH33 7PT Tel: + 44(0)1397 70 1550 Fax: + 44(0)1397 70 1174

More information

Annex 7: Request on management areas for sandeel in the North Sea

Annex 7: Request on management areas for sandeel in the North Sea 922 ICES HAWG REPORT 2018 Annex 7: Request on management areas for sandeel in the North Sea Request code (client): 1707_sandeel_NS Background: During the sandeel benchmark in 2016 the management areas

More information

Safety of railway control systems: A new Preliminary Risk Analysis approach

Safety of railway control systems: A new Preliminary Risk Analysis approach Author manuscript published in IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management Singapour : Singapour (28) Safety of railway control systems: A new Preliminary Risk Analysis

More information