Page 1 of 11

Similar documents
LED LED Street Lamps. Industrial / Commercial LED "Corn" Lamps. 360 Beam Angle. Color 30=3000k 40=4000k 50=5000k 60=6000k.

SCHEDULE OF RATES. For Electric Service in Allegheny and Beaver Counties. (For List of Communities Served, see Pages No. 4 and 5) Issued By

Project Status Report

Telephone Fax

Football Lighting Policy & Requirements Season 2016

Leveraging Lighting - Increasing Your Bottom Line while Enlightening the Environment

FOR THE LIFE OF YOUR BUILDING

FOR THE LIFE OF YOUR BUILDING

ADA Transition Plan. City of Gainesville FY19-FY28. Date: November 5, Prepared by: City Of Gainesville Department of Mobility

BICYCLE FACILITIES INVENTORY: SUMMARY REPORT

STAKING TRAFFIC CONTROL SIGNAL SYSTEMS

Debenture Servicing Audit

Road Conversion Study Plumas Street

Office of the County Auditor 115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room 520 Fort Lauderdale, Florida FAX

CHAPTER 8 STAKING SIGNALS AND LIGHTING FIELD GUIDE. 8.1 Staking Traffic Control Signal Systems

APPENDIX A. GIS ANALYSIS FOR THE MRT

Review of Considerations and Requirements for Automated Enforcement

CITY OF COCOA BEACH 2025 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. Section VIII Mobility Element Goals, Objectives, and Policies

Order No. 55/18 CENTRA GAS MANITOBA INC.: PRIMARY GAS RATE APPLICATION, EFFECTIVE MAY 1, April 26, 2018

Cycling Master Plan Community Engagement Session WELCOME

NEW YORK STATE 2018 Observational Survey of Seat Belt Use

Stakeholder Communication and Public Involvement Plan

6.0 PEDESTRIAN AND BICYCLE FACILITIES 6.1 INTRODUCTION 6.2 BICYCLE DEMAND AND SUITABILITY Bicycle Demand

MANUAL OF TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL ON CITY STREETS

Johnwoods Street Closure Summary Response

Arterial Management Plan for US Route 250 and State Route 623

LRD SERIES. Specification LED Retrofit Downlight

Minutes - Standing Policy Committee on Public Works - January 13, 2003 REPORTS

Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) Process and Procedures Manual. September 2017

Lewelling Boulevard Improvements Response to Questions/Comments From October 9, 2001 Community Meeting

ONTARIO REGULATION 239/02 MUNICIPAL ACT MINIMUM MAINTENANCE STANDARDS FOR MUNICIPAL HIGHWAYS

CITY OF ALPHARETTA DOWNTOWN MASTER PLAN TRAFFIC EVALUATION

HCI-TT 250 W/942 NDL PB

Township of Springwater

Noise Assessment Technical Memorandum. City of Mississauga Rathburn Road Transit Priority Measures Transit Project Assessment Process

1. Discussion of Police Hiring Practices regarding Criminal Offences (30 min) 2. Street Lighting Master Plan Consultants Presentation (1 Hour)

Traffic Calming Policy

Simulation Analysis of Intersection Treatments for Cycle Tracks

Forza Operating, LLC, South Hammock Prospect Galveston County, Texas February 24, 2012 Lighting Plan For

WINTER CYCLING: THE EXAMPLE OF MONTREAL

Highway 111 Corridor Study

EUCLID AVENUE PARKING STUDY CITY OF SYRACUSE, ONONDAGA COUNTY, NEW YORK

GIS Based Non-Motorized Transportation Planning APA Ohio Statewide Planning Conference. GIS Assisted Non-Motorized Transportation Planning

Traffic Signal Redesign 50% Design Report

NM-POLICY 1: Improve service levels, participation, and options for non-motorized transportation modes throughout the County.

The procedures to be followed in undertaking Non-Emergency work depend on the degree of traffic disruption caused by the work.


BY-LAWS of the WINNIPEG MINOR HOCKEY ASSOCIATION INC. (Amended April 29, 2015)

Comparison of Turning Movement Count Data Collection Methods for a Signal Optimization Study. White Paper

APPENDIX 1: COURSE DESCRIPTIONS AND MAPS

Northbound San Jose Avenue & I-280 Off-Ramp Road Diet Pilot Project

Traffic Impact Statement

Scope of Work for Traffic Signal and Interconnect Design Services for Santa Rosa Road

S T A T I O N A R E A P L A N

SIROCCO. Robust high-pressure diecast aluminium housing. Computer aided design reflector. Graduated scale for accurate aiming.

WELCOME PTH 59N - PTH 101 INTERCHANGE FUNCTIONAL DESIGN STUDY PUBLIC INFORMATION SESSION MONDAY, JUNE 13, :00 P.M. - 8:00 P.M.

2.0 Existing Conditions

Texas Intersection Safety Implementation Plan Workshop JUNE 2, 2016

Bicycling Routes on Provincial Roads Policy

6. TITLE: Amendments to the Larimer County Land Use Code and the Larimer County Road Manual

Traffic Safety Advisory Committee - Proposed 2015 Initiatives

Magnolia Place. Traffic Impact Analysis. Prepared for: City of San Mateo. Prepared by: Hexagon Transportation Consultants, Inc.

architectural practice empowering first nations

12 RECOMMENDATIONS Road Improvements. Short Term (generally the next five years)

Our Plan to Restore Manitoba Hydro and Protect Manitobans

Residential Road_Lighting Class S5

Traffic Accident Data Processing

Traffic Study North Shore School District 112

122 Avenue: 107 Street to Fort Road

Glenn Avenue Corridor Traffic Operational Evaluation

CLOSING LOCATION: Proposals must be submitted by to

An Assessment of Potential Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions from Proposed On Street Bikeways

Canadian Sport Institute and Freestyle BC Athlete and Coach Nomination Criteria

VALVE CRITICALITY MODELING

Draft. Lecompton. Table of Contents. Background

The CIO Series. IT Projects Are Like Marriages in the View of Malcolm Simpkin, CIO of Aviva UK General Insurance C IO. March 2012

PEI PROPOSED CHANGE IN MEMBERSHIP MODEL:

2.2 TRANSIT VISION 2040 FROM VISION TO ACTION. Emphasize transit priority solutions STRATEGIC DIRECTION

Roadway Conditions as Contributing Factors in Florida Traffic Crashes

CITY OF OAKLAND. 27th Street Bikeway Feasibility and Design. Final Report (v3) March 23, Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.

MONROE COUNTY NEW YORK

Transportation Policy Manual

The Corporation of the City of Sarnia. School Crossing Guard Warrant Policy

Param Express. Param Sankalp December Newsletter winners. Key Activities Concluded. Watch Out For

1 Introduction. COPY John Denney FROM Chris Morahan DATE 2 November 2015 FILE 6-XT177.62/305DC SUBJECT Stanley Street Network Traffic Modelling

Woodward Hill Elementary School School Safety and Operation Review

Programmatic Categorical Exclusion Update Question & Answers

FORM A PASCO COUNTY ACCESS CONNECTION PERMIT APPLICATION

Bus and Transit Lane Review Update

FEASIBILITY REPORT ON RED LIGHT CAMERAS PLACED AT CENTRAL AVENUE AND H STREET.

Advanced Test Equipment Rentals ATEC (2832) OMS 600

PILOT PROJECT: 2018 YOUTH TEAM AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

APPENDIXB. Traffic Operations Technical Memorandum

WELCOME TO OPEN HOUSE # 1 June 14, 2017

Improving distillation tower operation

Board of Supervisors February 27, 2017

3 ROADWAYS 3.1 CMS ROADWAY NETWORK 3.2 TRAVEL-TIME-BASED PERFORMANCE MEASURES Roadway Travel Time Measures

City of Margate, Florida. Neighborhood Traffic Management Manual

Traffic Impact Analysis Chatham County Grocery Chatham County, NC

Military Road Safety Improvements

Transcription:

COW/MH-I-1a. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 21 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Outdoor Lighting Rate Tariff no. 2015-80 Issue: Basis for the Billing Determinant PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): The City of Winnipeg has been unable to obtain from Manitoba Hydro the count of shared pole luminaires and exclusive pole luminaires that Manitoba Hydro uses in billing the City of Winnipeg under the Outdoor Lighting Rate, nor the basis therefor. QUESTION: Please provide a detailed count of the luminaires used by Manitoba Hydro for billing purposes, including the type(s) of luminaire(s) at each location. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The count of luminaires is the ARL equivalent of the metered volume used to bill customers. There is no process analogous to certification of meters to provide confidence that the «meter reading» for the City of Winnipeg is correct. The City of Winnipeg wishes to obtain the information necessary to determine what the luminaire count is, what type of luminaire is located at each location and whether it should have confidence in the information relied upon by Manitoba Hydro for billing purposes. RESPONSE: The details requested are provided in the following tables. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. ROSSER AREA 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 64 100 W HPS SHARED 38 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 6 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 198 150 W HPS SHARED 6 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 37 250 W HPS SHARED 5 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 162 400 W HPS SHARED 44 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 657 70 W HPS SHARED 120 1337 FORT GARRY 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,160 100 W HPS SHARED 163 1000W HPS 1-60 EXCLUSIVE 104 1000W HPS 4-100 EXCLUSIVE 12 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 4 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 522 150 W HPS SHARED 122 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 28 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 650 250 W HPS SHARED 116 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 982 400 W HPS SHARED 4 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 2,895 70 W HPS SHARED 646 7,408 2015 03 12 Page 2 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. EAST KILDONAN 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 334 100 W HPS SHARED 610 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 18 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 187 150 W HPS SHARED 162 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 5 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 69 250 W HPS SHARED 6 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 196 400 W HPS SHARED 4 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,009 70 W HPS SHARED 205 2,805 NORTH KILDONAN 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 293 100 W HPS SHARED 90 1000W HPS 1-60 EXCLUSIVE 12 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 171 150 W HPS SHARED 70 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 115 250 W HPS SHARED 157 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 77 500 W INCAN FLOOD SHARED 1 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,797 70 W HPS SHARED 134 2,917 2015 03 12 Page 3 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. ST BONIFACE 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,156 100 W HPS SHARED 742 100 W INCANDESCENT 4 EXCLUSIVE 1000W HPS 1-60 EXCLUSIVE 31 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 36 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 719 150 W HPS SHARED 162 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 5 175 W MV SHARED 1 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 425 250 W HPS SHARED 205 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 457 400 W HPS SHARED 37 400 W MV FLOOD EXCLUSIVE 8 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 2,451 70 W HPS SHARED 571 7,010 ST VITAL 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 326 100 W HPS SHARED 542 1000W HPS 1-60 EXCLUSIVE 78 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 6 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 548 150 W HPS SHARED 257 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 214 250 W HPS SHARED 110 300 W INCANDESCENT 4 EXCLUSIVE 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 344 400 W HPS SHARED 23 400 W MV EXCLUSIVE 32 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 2,380 70 W HPS SHARED 1,171 6,035 2015 03 12 Page 4 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. CHARLESWOOD 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 258 100 W HPS SHARED 40 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 144 150 W HPS SHARED 274 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 26 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 78 250 W HPS SHARED 80 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 82 400 W HPS SHARED 4 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,072 70 W HPS SHARED 624 2,682 ST JAMES ASSINIBOIA 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 523 100 W HPS SHARED 675 1000W HPS 1-60 EXCLUSIVE 8 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 649 150 W HPS SHARED 419 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 6 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 280 250 W HPS SHARED 222 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 362 400 W HPS SHARED 20 70 W HPS 24HR EXCLUSIVE 10 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 3,415 70 W HPS SHARED 997 7,586 2015 03 12 Page 5 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. TUXEDO 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 68 100 W HPS SHARED 123 1000W HPS 1-60 EXCLUSIVE 2 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 325 150 W HPS SHARED 66 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 1 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 138 250 W HPS SHARED 8 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 160 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,029 70 W HPS SHARED 42 1,962 WEST KILDONAN 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 396 100 W HPS SHARED 419 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 6 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 363 150 W HPS SHARED 163 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 125 250 W HPS SHARED 90 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 399 400 W HPS SHARED 43 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,576 70 W HPS SHARED 347 3,927 2015 03 12 Page 6 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. TRANSCONA 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 414 100 W HPS SHARED 471 1000W HPS 2-100 EXCLUSIVE 2 1000W HPS 4-100 EXCLUSIVE 3 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 25 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 362 150 W HPS SHARED 68 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 148 250 W HPS SHARED 52 400 W HPS 4-100 EXCLUSIVE 60 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 347 400 W HPS SHARED 8 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 2,318 70 W HPS SHARED 232 4,510 OLD KILDONAN 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 260 100 W HPS SHARED 9 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 210 150 W HPS SHARED 3 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 2 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 44 400 W MV SHARED 1 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,121 70 W HPS SHARED 48 1,698 2015 03 12 Page 7 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. WCD STREETLIGHTS NORTH WEST 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,705 100 W HPS SHARED 625 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 522 150 W HPS SHARED 48 175 W MV SHARED 101 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,892 250 W HPS SHARED 25 250 W MV EXCLUSIVE 3 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 210 400 W HPS SHARED 10 400 W MV EXCLUSIVE 27 400 W MV SHARED 23 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 43 70 W HPS SHARED 1,204 6,438 WCD STREETLIGHTS NORTH EAST 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 522 100 W HPS SHARED 31 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 116 150 W HPS SHARED 78 175 W MV SHARED 34 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 104 250 W HPS SHARED 58 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 120 400 W HPS SHARED 6 400 W MV EXCLUSIVE - 400 W MV SHARED 11 70 W HPS SHARED 420 1,501 2015 03 12 Page 8 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. WCD STREETLIGHTS WEST CENTRAL 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,816 100 W HPS SHARED 590 100 W INCANDESCENT 85 EXCLUSIVE 100 W INCANDESCENT SHARED 1 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 3 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 487 150 W HPS SHARED 314 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 3 175 W MV SHARED 33 20 W COMP FLOR EXCLUSIVE - 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,153 250 W HPS SHARED 895 250 W MV EXCLUSIVE 57 250 W MV SHARED 12 300 W INCANDESCENT 3 EXCLUSIVE 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,054 400 W HPS SHARED 127 400 W METAL HALIDE 4 EXCLUSIVE 400 W MV EXCLUSIVE 32 400 W MV SHARED 95 500 W INCANDESCENT SHARED 1 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 786 70 W HPS SHARED 1,536 750 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 33 750 W HPS SHARED 1 9,121 STITTSVILLE LIGHTING 10 W LED EXCLUSIVE 895 895 2015 03 12 Page 9 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. WCD STREETLIGHTS SOUTH WEST 100 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 2,393 100 W HPS SHARED 45 1000W HPS EXCLUSIVE 17 150 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 446 150 W HPS SHARED 252 175 W MV EXCLUSIVE 16 175 W MV SHARED 253 200 W FLORESCENT EXCLUSIVE - 250 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 1,173 250 W HPS SHARED 305 400 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 265 400 W HPS SHARED 13 400 W MV EXCLUSIVE 17 400 W MV SHARED 3 70 W HPS EXCLUSIVE 287 70 W HPS SHARED 1,384 6,869 2015 03 12 Page 10 of 11

COW/MH-I-1a. ROSSER FORT GARRY EAST KILDONAN NORTH KILDONAN ST BONIFACE ST VITAL CHARLESWOOD ST JAMES ASSINIBOIA TUXEDO WEST KILDONAN TRANSCONA OLD KILDONAN WCD STREETLIGHTS NORTH WEST WCD STREETLIGHTS NORTH EAST WCD STREETLIGHTS WEST CENTRAL STITTSVILLE LIGHTING WCD STREETLIGHTS SOUTH WEST 1,337 7,408 2,805 2,917 7,010 6,035 2,682 7,586 1,962 3,927 4,510 1,698 6,438 1,501 9,121 895 6,869 74,701 2015 03 12 Page 11 of 11

COW/MH-I-1b. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 21 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Outdoor Lighting Rate Tariff no. 2015-80 Issue: Basis for the Billing Determinant PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): The City of Winnipeg has been unable to obtain from Manitoba Hydro the count of shared pole luminaires and exclusive pole luminaires that Manitoba Hydro uses in billing the City of Winnipeg under the Outdoor Lighting Rate, nor the basis therefor. QUESTION: Please provide a detailed explanation of the original source of the information used by Manitoba Hydro to determine the number of City of Winnipeg luminaires on shared and exclusive poles, including luminaires that were in place prior to Manitoba Hydro acquiring Winnipeg Hydro. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The count of luminaires is the ARL equivalent of the metered volume used to bill customers. There is no process analogous to certification of meters to provide confidence that the «meter reading» for the City of Winnipeg is correct. The City of Winnipeg wishes to obtain the information necessary to determine what the luminaire count is, what type of luminaire is located at each location and whether it should have confidence in the information relied upon by Manitoba Hydro for billing purposes. RESPONSE: At the time of the acquisition of Winnipeg Hydro, electronic files were received from the City of Winnipeg itemizing the lights within the former Winnipeg Hydro service area. Information from those files was used to update customer billing records. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 2

COW/MH-I-1b. Billing records for Area and Roadway lighting are updated when new lights are installed or removed, or the size or type of light is changed. Each update is recorded by field personnel on an Outdoor Light Connect or Disconnect Report and submitted to centralized staff for update of customer billing records. 2015 03 12 Page 2 of 2

COW/MH-I-1c. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 21 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Outdoor Lighting Rate Tariff no. 2015-80 Issue: Basis for the Billing Determinant PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): The City of Winnipeg has been unable to obtain from Manitoba Hydro the count of shared pole luminaires and exclusive pole luminaires that Manitoba Hydro uses in billing the City of Winnipeg under the Outdoor Lighting Rate, nor the basis therefor. QUESTION: Please provide a detailed explanation of the actions undertaken by Manitoba Hydro since its acquisition of Winnipeg Hydro to verify and update the luminaire count and classification (shared and exclusive) that constituted Winnipeg Hydro s records. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The count of luminaires is the ARL equivalent of the metered volume used to bill customers. There is no process analogous to certification of meters to provide confidence that the «meter reading» for the City of Winnipeg is correct. The City of Winnipeg wishes to obtain the information necessary to determine what the luminaire count is, what type of luminaire is located at each location and whether it should have confidence in the information relied upon by Manitoba Hydro for billing purposes. RESPONSE: Over the past several years, Manitoba Hydro has undertaken an intensive distribution asset data capture program that has surveyed all the poles and street light standards across the province. This provided an accurate count of all poles and street light standards in Manitoba. During the upcoming LED conversion, Manitoba Hydro plans on verifying: the number of fixtures replaced, the nominal wattage of the new light, and the exact location of each light. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 2

COW/MH-I-1c. Area and Roadway lighting information, including luminaire counts and classifications (shared and exclusive) has been recorded in Manitoba Hydro s GIS (geographic information system) mapping software. In addition to the verification which will take place during the LED conversion, future efforts will be directed toward reconciliation of the classification of lights between the GIS and customer billing records. 2015 03 12 Page 2 of 2

COW/MH-I-2.. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 21 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Bill Impacts Issue: Outdoor Lighting Rates Tariff 2015-80 PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): Manitoba Hydro is seeking different area and roadway lighting rates for the categories in this tariff. QUESTION: Please explain how Manitoba Hydro arrived at these proposed rates and provide the detailed calculations. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The methodology used to establish these rates has never been explained to the City of Winnipeg nor tested by the Public Utilities Board. It is also necessary to ensure the consistency of these rates with the new rates being established for the LED luminaires. RESPONSE: The proposed rates shown for Tariff 2015-80 (with the exception of the LED rates), Tariff 2015-81 and Tariff 2015-83 were derived by multiplying the existing rates by the proposed 3.95% rate increase and rounding the new rate to two decimal places, as shown in the following table. Please refer to Manitoba Hydro s response to PUB/MH I-49a for an explanation as to how the LED rates were derived. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 3

COW/MH-I-2.. May 2014 3.95% May 2015 Rates + increase = Rates OUTDOOR LIGHTING SHARED 100 INC $4.57 $0.18 $4.75 500 INC $11.96 $0.47 $12.43 175 MV $8.84 $0.35 $9.19 250 MV $10.12 $0.40 $10.52 400 MV $13.88 $0.55 $14.43 70 HPS $7.60 $0.30 $7.90 100 HPS $7.89 $0.31 $8.20 150 HPS $9.67 $0.38 $10.05 250 HPS $12.32 $0.49 $12.81 400 HPS $14.14 $0.56 $14.70 750 HPS $21.91 $0.87 $22.78 EXCLUSIVE 200 FLORESC. $9.93 $0.39 $10.32 20 COMPACT FL. $2.13 $0.08 $2.21 100 INC $9.93 $0.39 $10.32 150 INC $9.93 $0.39 $10.32 300 INC $14.16 $0.56 $14.72 500 INC $19.51 $0.77 $20.28 400 MH $23.77 $0.94 $24.71 175 MV $14.16 $0.56 $14.72 250 MV $16.03 $0.63 $16.66 400 MV $19.17 $0.76 $19.93 70 HPS $12.48 $0.49 $12.97 70 HPS 24 $14.03 $0.55 $14.58 100 HPS $13.16 $0.52 $13.68 150 HPS $14.86 $0.59 $15.45 250 HPS $17.13 $0.68 $17.81 400 HPS $23.77 $0.94 $24.71 400 HPS 2-100 $36.75 $1.45 $38.20 400 HPS 4-100 $26.99 $1.07 $28.06 750 HPS $34.76 $1.37 $36.13 1000 HPS $40.32 $1.59 $41.91 1000 HPS 1-60 $41.25 $1.63 $42.88 1000 HPS 2-100 $49.44 $1.95 $51.39 1000 HPS 4-100 $42.40 $1.67 $44.07 2015 03 12 Page 2 of 3

COW/MH-I-2.. May 2014 3.95% May 2015 Rates + increase = Rates FLOOD LIGHTING SHARED 100 INCF $5.18 $0.20 $5.38 150 INCF $5.18 $0.20 $5.38 300 INCF $9.44 $0.37 $9.81 500 INCF $12.71 $0.50 $13.21 250 MVF $11.70 $0.46 $12.16 400 MVF $14.30 $0.56 $14.86 500 QF $19.65 $0.78 $20.43 EXCLUSIVE 150 INCF $10.74 $0.42 $11.16 500 INCF $20.80 $0.82 $21.62 250 MVF $17.11 $0.68 $17.79 400 MVF $19.20 $0.76 $19.96 500 QF $24.91 $0.98 $25.89 SENTINELS FLAT RATE 175 W MW $10.10 $0.00 $10.50 400 W MW $16.71 $0.00 $17.37 100 W HPS $9.78 $0.00 $10.17 150 W HPS $12.96 $0.00 $13.47 RENTAL 175 W MW $6.74 $0.00 $7.01 400 W MW $9.21 $0.00 $9.57 100 W HPS $6.75 $0.00 $7.01 150 W HPS $9.21 $0.00 $9.57 2015 03 12 Page 3 of 3

COW/MH-I-3.. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 21 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Bill Impacts Issue: Outdoor Lighting Conversion to LEDs PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): The City of Winnipeg is unaware of Manitoba Hydro s plan for the replacement of F, CF, I, MH, MV and HPS luminaires with LED luminaires. QUESTION: Please provide Manitoba Hydro s detailed plan for the replacement of F, CF, I, MH, MV and HPS luminaires with LED luminaires. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The change to LED luminaires will have an impact on the City s billing. RESPONSE: As a service to cities, towns and municipalities, Manitoba Hydro provides, installs and maintains area and roadway lighting for public areas and roads for which the public authority pays a monthly tariff. In March of 2014, based upon successful pilot installations of LED lighting located across the province, including Churchill, Thompson, Brandon and Winnipeg (with installations on Overdale Street, Bruce Avenue, Collegiate Street, Farnham Road, and Regent Avenue), Manitoba Hydro officially launched the LED Roadway Lighting Conversion Program. With the recent awards of the material and labour contracts for the conversions, Manitoba Hydro will be developing the detailed implementation plan for the Province with conversions beginning concurrently within and outside of the City of Winnipeg. Under this program, Manitoba Hydro will convert 130,000 street and lane lights across the Province, primarily 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 2

COW/MH-I-3.. High Pressure Sodium (HPS) but also including a small portion of remaining Incandescent (I), Metal Halide (MH), and Mercury Vapor (MV), to LED over a seven year period. Fluorescent (F) and Compact Fluorescent (CF) lighting have already been converted to LED lighting. LED technology for high-mast lighting, such as that typically located around major intersections (750W and greater HPS), is only now advancing to become a safe viable alternative to HPS lighting. Manitoba Hydro is continuing to monitor these products and will be pursuing demonstration projects using the next generation of high-mast lighting to determine suitability for use under the replacement program. Prior to awarding the materials contract, the photometry details of the recommended vendor were shared with representatives of the Lighting Systems Branch of the Public Works Department to obtain their approval to ensure the product met City of Winnipeg technical requirements. With the labour contracts now in place, Manitoba Hydro will continue discussions with the Lighting Systems Branch to finalize processes and develop the detailed implementation schedule for the City of Winnipeg including discussion of street by street scheduling to ensure proper traffic management. The LED conversion schedule is expected to generally follow the existing HPS re-lamping schedule for Winnipeg with approximately 80,000 conversions being completed over the next four to five years. The conversion schedule for lighting outside of the City of Winnipeg is also expected to generally follow the existing HPS re-lamping schedule with adjustments in order to optimize operational efficiencies under a mass replacement. In addition, all new developments throughout the Province will be supplied with LED lighting. 2015 03 12 Page 2 of 2

COW/MH-I-4.. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 22 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Bill Impacts Issue: Flood Lighting Rate Tariff no. 2015-81 PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): Manitoba Hydro is seeking different area and roadway lighting rates for the categories in this tariff. QUESTION: Please explain how Manitoba Hydro arrived at these proposed rates and provide the detailed calculations. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The methodology used to establish these rates has never been explained to the City of Winnipeg nor tested by the Public Utilities Board. It is also necessary to ensure the consistency of these rates with the new rates being established for the LED luminaires. RESPONSE: Please refer to Manitoba Hydro s response to COW/MH-I-2. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 1

COW/MH-I-5.. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 22 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Bill Impacts Issue: Flood Lighting Conversion to LEDs PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): The City of Winnipeg is unaware of Manitoba Hydro s plan for the replacement of I, MV and Q luminaires with LED luminaires. QUESTION: Please provide Manitoba Hydro s detailed plan for the replacement of I, MV and Q luminaires with LED luminaires. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The change to LED luminaires will have an impact on the City s billing. RESPONSE: Manitoba Hydro continues to be responsible for maintaining floodlighting services installed prior to April 1, 1976. These floodlights are primarily Incandescent (I) and represent less than 0.01% of all lights to be replaced. These lights will be replaced during the later stages of the program once a suitable LED replacement has been identified. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 1

COW/MH-I-6.. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 24 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Bill Impacts Issue: Sentinel Lighting Rates Tariff no. 2015-83 PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): Manitoba Hydro is seeking different area and roadway lighting rates for the categories in this tariff. QUESTION: Please explain how Manitoba Hydro arrived at these proposed rates and provide the detailed calculations. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The methodology used to establish these rates has never been explained to the City of Winnipeg nor tested by the Public Utilities Board. It is also necessary to ensure the consistency of these rates with the new rates established for the LED luminaires. RESPONSE: Please refer to Manitoba Hydro s response to COW/MH-I-2. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 1

COW/MH-I-7.. Section: Tab 6, Appendix 6.3 Page No.: 24 of 25 Topic: Area and Roadway Lighting Subtopic: Bill Impacts Issue: Sentinel Lighting Conversion to LEDs PREAMBLE TO IR (IF ANY): The City of Winnipeg is unaware of Manitoba Hydro s plan for the replacement of HPS and MV luminaires with LED luminaires QUESTION: Please provide Manitoba Hydro s detailed plan for the replacement of HPS and MV luminaires with LED luminaires. RATIONALE FOR QUESTION: The change to LED luminaires will have an impact on the City s billing. RESPONSE: As roadway lighting represents the largest portion Manitoba Hydro s total inventory of lighting, the LED Roadway Lighting Conversion Program is initially focused on converting roadway lighting. Manitoba Hydro is currently investigating the technical requirements and options for LED Sentinel Lights which could be made available for new installations as well as for replacement as existing sentinel lights reach end of life. 2015 03 12 Page 1 of 1