IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA Revised FINAL ROLL AUG/SEPT 2018 (01 June 2018) The number of the Judge to whom in each case the judgment has been allocated is designated by dark shading JUDGES - AUG/SEPT 2018 1 Maya P 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Seriti JA
2 10 11 Willis JA 12 Saldulker JA 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Tuesday: 14 August 2018 JUDGMENT WRITING SEMINAR Wednesday: 15 August 2018 1. Nkosingisizile Patrick Mnthungwa v The State 123/2018 (MP) 2 8 18 20 21 AND 2. Lesiba Simon Kekana v The State 37/2018 (LP)
3 2 8 18 20 21 3. Ntshaveheni Samuel Nndwambi v The State 168/2018 (LT) 4 12 24 Saldulker JA 4. Oupa Stanley Maphanga v The State 607/2017 (GJ) 5 7 14 AND 5. Kutluoano Uriah Maleka v The State 1209/2017 (GJ) 5 7 14 Thursday: 16 August 2018 6. The Black Sash Trust & others v The Chief Executive of the South African Social Security Agency & others 752/2017 (GP) AND 3 6 7 10 22
4 7. The Minister of Social Development of the Republic of South Africa & others v Net 1Applied Technologies South Africa (Pty) Ltd & others 825/2017 (GP) 3 6 7 10 22 8. MEC for Health, Western Cape v Sinethemba Qole obo Iminathinkosi Qole 928/2017 (WCC) Friday: 17 August 2018 4 5 8 16 17 9. The Black Sash Trust & others v The Chief Executive of the South African Social Security Agency & others 752/2017 (GP) 3 6 7 10 22 AND 10. The Minister of Social Development of the Republic of South Africa & others v Net 1Applied Technologies South Africa (Pty) Ltd & others 825/2017 (GP) 3 6 7 10 22
5 11. Hans Seuntjie Matoto v Free State Gambling and Liquor Authority & others 987/2017 5 15 18 21 25 12. Ishmael Jiyane v The State 943/2017 (GP) 9 12 14 20 23 Seriti JA Saldulker JA Monday: 20 August 2018 13. Steven Ngomane & 27 others v City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality & another 734/2017 (GP) 1 16 18 22 25 Maya P 14. Life Healthcare Group (Pty) Ltd v Dr Abdool Samad Suliman 529/2017 (KZD) 2 8 9 10 12 Seriti JA Saldulker JA
6 15. Special Pensions Appeal Board & another v Nathaniel Mashilo Masemola 1171/2017 (GP) 3 7 13 17 24 Tuesday: 21 August 2018 16. The Road Accident Fund v Christopher Michael Kerridge 1024/2017 (ECG) 2 16 19 22 25 17. Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Digicall Solutions (Pty) Ltd 927/2017 (WCC) 3 8 13 15 23 18. Sasol Oil Proprietary Limited v The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Services 923/17 (Tax Court) 4 5 6 21 24
7 Wednesday: 22 August 2018 Thursday: 23 August 2018 19. Leola Sharon Meyer N O & others v Big Five Developments (Pty) Ltd & another 1017/2017 (GJ) 2 16 17 19 20 20. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Services v Respublica (Pty) Ltd 1025/2017 (GP) 5 10 14 21 23 Friday: 24 August 2018 21. Truworths Limited v Primark Holdings 989/2017 (GP) 1 10 11 16 18 Maya P Willis JA
8 22. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Mustek Limited 1010/2017 (GP) 4 5 6 14 17 23. Odette Botha v The State 1074/2017 (GJ) 7 9 15 22 23 Seriti JA Monday: 27 August 2018 24. Nederburg Wines (Pty) Ltd v Frans Nero & others 1084/2017 (LCC) 2 8 14 19 21 25. Four Wheel Drive Accessory Distributors CC v Leshni Rattan N O 1048/2017 (KZD) 4 15 20 22 23
9 26. John Owen Brankin v Granville Essafrau & others 934/2017 (GJ) 5 7 13 24 25 Tuesday: 28 August 2018 27. Shelley Pather v Ismail Dockrat 941/2017 (GP) 1 12 13 19 20 Maya P Saldulker JA 28. Ajay Sooklal v Thales South Africa (Pty) Ltd 866/2017 (GJ) 3 7 16 18 25 29. The Minister of Safety and Security & another v Marius Schuster & another 114/2018 (ECG) 6 8 11 17 22 Willis JA Wednesday: 29 August 2018
10 30. Ngobeni Tsundzuka Emmanuel v The State 1041/2017 (GJ) 2 8 10 14 17 31. Johannes Petrus Louis Grimbeek v Mziwandile Alfred Jakobo 922/17 (FB) 4 7 12 13 24 Saldulker JA 32. Dumisani Innocent Sima v The State 166/2018 (KZP) 9 11 16 21 23 Seriti JA Willis JA Thursday: 30 August 2018 33. The Refugee Appeal Board of South Africa & others v Paul Joseph Mutombo Mukungubila 185/2018 (GP) 1 10 14 22 24 Maya P 34. The Attorneys Fidelity Fund Board of Control v Prevance Capital (Pty) Ltd
11 917/17 (GP) 3 17 18 19 20 35. Andile Silatha v Minister of Corrections Services 1040/2017 (ECP) 5 9 11 15 16 Seriti JA Willis JA Friday: 31 August 2018 36. Buffalo City Metropolitan Municipality v Nurcha Development Finance (Pty) Ltd & others 378/2017 (ECE) 4 9 21 23 25 Seriti JA 37. Langstone Rexson Gumbi & others v The State 414/2017 (GP) 5 10 19 20 24 38. Nieuco Properties 1005 (Pty) Ltd & another v Trustees for the time being of the Inkululeko Community Trust & others
12 872/2017 (GP) 6 12 16 18 22 Saldulker JA Monday: 3 September 2018 39. M Du Bruyn N O & others v Andreas Stefanus Jacobus Karsten 929/2017 (GP) 2 21 22 23 25 40. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Services v Amawele Joint Venture CC 908/2017 (GP) 4 10 14 16 18 41. Apiwe Magqeya obo Kwanga Magqeya v Member of the Executive Council for Health, Eastern Cape 699/2017 (ECM) 5 7 8 13 15 Tuesday: 4 September 2018
13 42. Meshack Famanda v The State 930/2017 (GJ) 1 18 25 AND Maya P 43. Nico Manuel Khoza & another v The State 1267/2017 (NWM) 1 18 25 Maya P 44. Sentinel Retirement Fund & another v Richard Masoanganye & others 1003/2017 (GJ) 4 6 12 14 21 Saldulker JA 45. Gavin Charlton Harvey N O & others v Georgina Elizabeth Crawford N O & others 1016/2017 (WCC) Wednesday: 5 September 2018 5 7 15 16 20 46. The Attorneys Fidelity Fund Board of Control v Joost Heystek van der Westhuizen 1379/2016 (GP)
14 1 8 10 19 20 Maya P 47. Andre Fischer v Ubomi Ushishi Trading CC & others 1085/2017 (WCC) 2 6 12 22 24 Saldulker JA 48. Yellow Star Trading 1154 (Pty) Limited v Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries & another 1124/2017 (WCC) 3 11 13 15 17 Willis JA Thursday: 6 September 2018 49. The Commissioner of the South African Revenue Services v Volkswagen of South Africa (Pty) Ltd 1028/2017 (Tax Court) 3 9 10 11 17 Seriti JA Willis JA 50. Estelle Rossouw v Jacobus Petrus Hanekom 741/2017 (WCC)
15 4 7 16 18 24 51. Umfolozi Sugar Planters Ltd & others v Isimangaliso Wetland Park Authority & others 873/2017 (KZN) 5 14 21 23 25 Friday: 7 September 2018 52. Centre for Child Law & others v Media 24 Ltd & others 871/17 (GP) 1 11 13 18 19 Maya P Willis JA Monday: 10 September 2018 53. The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Services v Rynette Pieters & others 1026/2017 (WCC) 3 7 8 11 13 Willis JA
16 Tuesday: 11 September 2018 54. Gesiena Maria Botha N O & another v The National Director of Public Prosecutions 920/17 (NCK) 8 13 17 22 23 Wednesday: 12 September 2018 55. A B & another v Pridwin Preparatory School & others 1134/2017 (GJ) 2 6 19 22 24 56. AFGRI Operations Limited v Dipaleseng Local Municipality 708/2017 (GJ) 3 10 14 16 18 Thursday: 13 September 2018
17 57. Mzimkhule Martiens Monde v Jacobus Johannes Viljoen N O & others 1162/2017 (LCC) 1 13 19 22 24 Maya P 58. Propell Specialised Finance (Pty) Ltd v Attorneys Insurance Indemnity Fund NPC 1147/2017 (WCC) 4 12 15 17 23 Saldulker JA Friday: 14 September 2018 59. CTP Limited & others v The Director General Department of Basic Education & others 447/2018 (GP) 2 11 15 17 23 60. James Churchill Haslam & another v Matthew Robert Lester 1167/2017 (ECG) 3 6 16 20 24 Willis JA
18 Monday: 17 September 2018 Tuesday: 18 September 2018 Wednesday: 19 September 2018 Thursday: 20 September 2018 Friday: 21 September 2018 Monday: 24 September 2018 Tuesday: 25 September 2018 Wednesday: 26 September 2018
19 Thursday: 27 September 2018 Friday: 28 September 2018