In the summer of 2006, the BC

Similar documents
This Week s Sur vey Re sults. Bi cy cle and Pe des trian Is sues. Dan iel B. Rathbone, Ph.D., P.E. Ed i tor/pub lisher

FIRE SAFETY CASE STUDY OF A RAILWAY TUNNEL: SMOKE EVACUATION

SKH 1093 RH Calibration Kit for SKH 2000 probes

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

Steelhead Society of BC. Thompson River Watershed Restoration and Enhancement Project #4 Nicola River Bank Stabilization and Enhancement Project

MCCAW REACH RESTORATION

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

BODY HARDWARE MASTER METAL DRAWER ASSORTMENTS

OKANAGAN RIVER RESTORATION INITIATIVE - FAQ

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

FISHERIES BLUE MOUNTAINS ADAPTATION PARTNERSHIP

Lakelse Sockeye Recovery Program

OBSOLETE DESIGN DATA. CONCENTRATE CONTROLLERS 2, 3", 4", 6" and 8" (50, 80, 100, 150, and 200 mm)

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

Ecology of Place: What salmon need Eric Beamer Skagit River System Cooperative. November 2010

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

Call To Action. & bb b b b. w w. œ œ œ J. &b b b b b. œ œ œ. œ œ. œ œ œ. ? b b b b b 4. j œ. j œ Ó n. œ j. œ j œ œ Ó Œ. œ j Ó Œ j œœ œ Ó.

OBSOLETE DESIGN DATA FOAM MAKER APPLICATION

Mid-Columbia Fisheries Enhancement Group Annual Report Fiscal Year 06: July 1, 2005 June 30, 2006

HIGH VOLTAGE FUSE LINKS

The in flu ence of trap type on eval u at ing pop u la tion struc ture of the semifossorial and so cial ro dent Octodon degus

IMPROVEMENT OF CaO-BASED SORBENT PERFORMANCE FOR CO 2 LOOPING CYCLES. Vasilije MANOVIC and Ed ward J. ANTHONY

Geomorphic Stream Classification A Classification of Natural Rivers, Rosgen, D.L.

Culvert Design for Low and High Gradient Streams in the Midwest. Dale Higgins, Hydrologist Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

Project Completion Abstract Fish Passage Activity ( Engineering Activities)

COA-F17-F-1343 YEAR END REPORT

Firth Creek Habitat Enhancement Project 1993

Restoring the Kootenai: A Tribal Approach to Restoration of a Large River in Idaho

Okanagan Sockeye Reintroduction

Prescription to Restore Stream 11 (Orphan Channel) in the Burman River Watershed, March 2007

Fish Habitat Restoration and Monitoring in Southeast Washington. Andy Hill Eco Logical Research, Inc.

Snorkel Observations of Winter Steelhead Trout Escapement to the Englishman River, Vancouver Island, 2005

3. The qualification raised by the ISRP is addressed in #2 above and in the work area submittal and review by the ISRP as addressed in #1.

(Revised February,2005) CULVERTS, BRIDGES, AND FORDS

United States Patent (19)

What a Wonderful World

Aquatic Organism Passage at Road-Stream Crossings CHUCK KEEPORTS FOREST HYDROLOGIST ALLEGHENY NATIONAL FOREST WARREN, PENNSYLVANIA

Cross-Vane Plan View FIN-UP Habitat Consultants, Inc. 220 Illinois Avenue Manitou Springs, CO (719) P.

MSHA s Guide to Equipment Guarding

Presented by Fred Halterman, URS Jennie Agerton, URS

Steelhead Sport Fishing Regulations Proposals Vancouver Island Region for April 1, 2007

TREATING RIVERS RIGHT & EXAMPLES OF BEST USE OF WOOD IN RESTORATION

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

PRE-SEASON PLANNING FOR FRASER SALMON and STOCKS OF CONCERN. Forum on Conservation and Harvest Planning for Fraser Salmon January 22, 2010

PROJECT TO INSTALL LARGE WOOD HABITAT STRUCTURES IN THE CARMEL RIVER USING CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME GRANT FUNDS

P.O. Box 65 Hancock, Michigan USA fax

Key Ward Information - Cowes South and Northwood (part of the Cowes cluster of wards)

Gauge Adapters. Senior 2 1 2" [63,5] Bolt Circle Adapt ers. 22 Series ISO 9001:2008 CERTIFIED. Low pressure applications. The Measure of Excellence

Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Division of Fish and Wildlife Section of Fisheries. Stream Survey Report. Luxemburg Creek.

San Lorenzo Valley Water District, Watershed Management Plan, Final Version Part I: Existing Conditions Report

Low Gradient Velocity Control Short Term Steep Gradient Channel Lining Medium-Long Term Outlet Control Soil Treatment Permanent [1]

Min ne sota Ground Wa ter As so ci a tion

ANNUAL SUMMARY OF SOUTH AFRICAN NOTICES TO MARINERS 2009 EDITION

Washington State Fish Passage Barrier Removal Projects. Casey Kramer, PE WSDOT State Hydraulics Engineer

OVERVIEW OF MID-COLUMBIA FISHERIES ENHANCEMENT GROUP

Shovelnose Creek Off-Channel Complex Berm Repair

Trout Unlimited Comments on the Scope of Environmental Impact Statement for the Constitution Pipeline Project, Docket No. PF12-9

Stream Assessment. Date. Data Collected by. Location. Name of Stream and River Basin. Stream Order. Streambank Materials. Streambank Vegetation

Aug. 5, 1952 T. G. BENNETT 2,605,917 HOISTING AND DUMPING APPARATUS FOR OYSTER DREDGES OR THE LIKE. Sne for Cattorneys

Rehabilitation of Grimes Creek, a Stream Impacted in the Past by Bucket-lined Dredge Gold Mining, Boise River Drainage, July 2008 to August 2011.

ANNUAL SUMMARY OF SOUTH AFRICAN NOTICES TO MARINERS 2014 EDITION

APPENDIX C VEGETATED EMERGENCY SPILLWAY. VERSION 1.0 March 1, 2011

Massachusetts Stream Crossing Case Studies

Suitable Applications Check dams may be appropriate in the following situations: To promote sedimentation behind the dam.

2009 Technical Luncheon August 18th Presented by API - Delta Chapter and SPE - Delta Section. Natural Gas: Enabling its Energy Future

Skeena Salmon. Skeena River Basin. Sockeye Escapement ( ) 1. Average number of spawners. Introduction. Total Accessible Stream Length (km)

JAP Additional Information Sheet

Creation of Fish and Wildlife Habitat on the Closed Salmon Harbour Mine in Minto, NB

nhc northwest hydraulic consultants water environment solutions VIA VIA COURIER December 8, 2003

MODEL HP-1+6+S HP-S-DIFF-TB TECHNICAL BULLETIN "HIGH" PRESSURE DIFFERENTIAL REDUCING REGULATOR CAUTION FEATURES

Fish Habitat Rehabilitation in the Englishman River, 2006

Salmon Enhancement Program

THE URBAN TRANSPORTATION MONITOR

Five Counties Salmonid Conservation Program - Fish Passage Design Workshop. February 2013

FISH PASSAGE IMPROVEMENT in California s Watersheds. Assessments & Recommendations by the Fish Passage Forum

United States Patent (19) Johnson

Incorporating Geomorphic Processes and Sediment Dynamics into Salmonid Habitat Restoration Design

Phase 1 Habitat Assessments

Cheakamus River IR 11 Floodplain Restoration Final Report Project Number 13.CMS.01

WFC 50 California s Wild Vertebrates Jan. 11, Inland Waters (Lakes and Streams) Lisa Thompson

Habitat Conditions, Design Strategies,

Kootenai River Habitat Restoration Program. Kootenai Tribe of Idaho - January 27, 2014 Presentation for Kootenai Valley Resource Initiative

Steelhead Stock Status Review British Columbia

Katsuji Haya, Dawn Sephton, Jennifer Mar tin, and Thierry Cho pin

Fisheries Sensitive Watersheds (FSWs)

Cushman Hydro Project Public Meeting. Cushman Fire Hall Dec. 6, 2018

SOUTH AFRICAN NOTICE TO MARINERS

2017 PRE-SEASON EXPECTATIONS: 2017 OBSERVATIONS TO DATE:

Don Pedro Project Relicensing

FINAL REPORT. Yonkers Creek Migration Barrier Removal Project Wonderstump Road Del Norte County. Submitted By:

Request Number IR1-12: Flow Passage. Information Request

Micro Hydropower and Fish.

Michigan Department of Natural Resources Status of the Fishery Resource Report Page 1

Sub-watershed Summaries

Ned Currence, Nooksack Indian Tribe

DEVELOPING AND IMPLEMENTING ENERGY AWARENESS SERVICES

Transcription:

Taming Stoltz Bluff: Long-term Fine Sediment Management on the Cowichan River Craig Wightman, Marc Gaboury, and Dave Murray In the summer of 2006, the BC Conservation Foundation (BCCF) and partners undertook an ambitious project that combined construction know-how, and innovation in the fields of fish biology, geomorphology, and engineering. The objective was to control sediment transport from a massive silt bluff upstream of Stoltz Pool that had been negatively affecting the Cowichan River. For years, fine sediment washed into the river from the base of the bluff resulting in reduced salmon egg-to-fry survival rates in the downstream river reaches. To remedy this situation, a project was proposed to construct a berm and terrace complete with a series of bendway weirs and bioengineering treatments to move river flows away from the base of the bluff and prevent further bank erosion. The pro ject team faced sig nif i cant chal lenges: divert 1 km of the Cowichan River; dry out the chan nel; move over 40 000 m 3 of river sed i - ment and 30 000 fish; and bypass over 3000 river recreationalists dur ing the sum mer. Early results from pro ject mon i tor ing are encour ag ing and show a sub stan tial reduc tion in sed i ment load ing. This arti cle out lines the his tory and back ground of the pro ject, describes its design and con struc tion, dis cusses some of the les sons learned, and out - lines ongo ing work being car ried out to mon i tor the effec tive ness of the pro ject. Background The Cowichan River (Fig ure 1) flows through an impor tant Van cou ver Island water shed with sig nif i cant ana - dro mous and res i dent fish resources con ser va tively val ued at $5 6 mil lion annu ally (Burt and Wightman 1997). The Cowichan water shed is the ances tral home of the Cowichan Tribes, whose peo - ple have tra di tion ally relied on the river s fish and other resources for food, social, and cer e - mo nial pur poses, and who are cur rently nego ti at ing with the fed eral and pro vin cial gov ern ments for a final agree ment under the BC Treaty pro cess. The Cowichan River provides exceptional habitat for coho, chum, and chinook salmon as well as steelhead, brown, and rainbow trout. In addi tion to being a major fish pro - ducer, the Cowichan River sup ports the local econ omy by pro vid ing water for indus trial, com mer cial, and domes - tic pur poses, and offers grow ing rec re ational use year-round. The Cowichan River s nat u ral cap i tal and eco nomic val ues, as well as its his tor i - cal impor tance to First Nations, have been rec og nized in its des ig na tion as a BC and Cana dian Her i tage River. Cat a lyst Paper Corp. owns and oper - ates a low-head weir at the out let of Cowichan Lake in sup port of their water licence for Crofton pulp mill oper a tions. The weir typ i cally goes on con trol in April or early May to cap - ture 1 m of snowmelt run off as addi tional stor age on the lake. Con se - quently, from spring to early fall (i.e., April to late Sep tem ber), flows in the Cowichan River are reg u lated to main - tain a licensed vol ume (tar get is 7 m 3 /s) in sup port of down stream water use and eco log i cal require - ments. Over the win ter, the weir s gates are fully opened and the river and lake lev els return to the nat u ral regime. The Cowichan River pro vides excep - tional hab i tat for coho, chum, and chi nook salmon as well as steelhead, brown, and rain bow trout. Cowichan fall chi nook and coho stocks are listed pri or i ties under the Can ada U.S. Pacific Salmon Treaty. Cowichan chi - nook are also an indi ca tor stock for spe - cies abun dance in the Geor gia Basin, and were listed as the num ber one pri or ity spe cies for rebuild ing in the Cowichan Recov ery Plan (CRP) (LGL 2005). Cowichan win ter steelhead are listed as a high pri or ity for increased con ser va tion efforts by the BC Min is try of Envi ron ment under the Greater Geor gia Basin Steelhead Recov ery Action Plan (Lill 2002). Besides its obvi ous impor tance for fish and other aquatic spe cies, the Cowichan River is an impor tant resource for the local com mu nity, includ ing tra di tional cul tural val ues, munic i pal and indus trial water sup ply, and rec re ational oppor tu ni ties. Obser - va tions by local anglers, fish er ies pro fes sion als, and geomorphologists indi cate that the Cowichan River s lower reaches have been sub ject to increased bank insta bil ity, ero sion, bedload move ment, and sed i men ta - tion in recent years (LGL 2005; KWL 2006). Stoltz Bluff is located on the left bank of the river, 27 km upstream of Cowichan Bay, within the Cowichan 30 Streamline Watershed Management Bulletin Vol. 11/No. 2 Spring 2008

District Regional Valley Cowichan Source: Figure 1. Map of the Cowichan River showing major landmarks. River Pro vin cial Park Reserve. The bluff is adja cent to the out side of a mean - der bend where an 800 m long, 50 60 m high deposit of gla cial sed i - ment is actively erod ing (Fig ure 2). The bluff con sists of mul ti ple lay ers of fine glaciolacustrine depos its interbedded with gla cial outwash mate rial. Nine major strata of dis tinct sed i ment tex ture were iden ti fied, rang ing from sand and gravel with some cob ble, to fine sand, silt, and clay. After insta bil i ties of the bluffs in the 1970s, early attempts at remediation were lim ited to wil low plant ing in exposed soils. The bluff was gen er ally sta ble for about two decades until the early 1990s, when major rain-on-snow events led to sig nif i cant toe ero sion and gully fail ures. This prompted a series of stud ies in the mid-1990s that pro vided options for sta bi liz ing the bluff and reduc ing its impacts on down stream fish hab i tats (NHC 1996; Newbury Hydrau lics 1997) and coin ci - den tally on the Cat a lyst pulp mill s water sup ply. Yet, none of the designs in these reports was imple mented, largely due to fund ing lim i ta tions and con flict ing views on the risk of chan nel change in response to hard river engi - neer ing mea sures. In 2004/05, field assess ments by Fish - er ies and Oceans Can ada deter mined that salmon egg-to-fry sur vival rates in the lower river reaches were dra mat i - cally lower than those in the upper river reaches. Test incu ba tors installed in the upper and lower mainstem (over ~40 km) found a mean egg-to-fry sur vival rate of 86% at the upper most site near Cowichan Lake (Green dale Road), com pared with mean sur viv als rang ing from 0.7 to 6.8% at three sam ple sites in the lower river (Burt et al. 2005). From a pro vin - cial fish er ies per spec tive, fine sed i ment from Stoltz Bluff was first iden ti fied as a poten tial hab i tat prob lem in the late 1960s (G.D. Tay lor and F.N. Axford, pers. comm.). This reduc tion in egg-to-fry sur vival between the upper and lower reaches of the river appeared to cor re late with an increase con cen tra tion of fine sed i ment in sus - pen sion and in the spawn ing grav els. There fore, fur ther sed i ment anal y sis was car ried out to quan tify these observed increases. In 2004, the Cowichan Stew ard ship Roundtable (CSRT), a multi-stake - holder com mit tee con sist ing of Cowichan Tribes, gov ern ment, indus - try, and com mu nity rep re sen ta tives, used rec om men da tions from the CRP to attract out side funds for under tak - ing a quan ti ta tive anal y sis of sed i ment con tri bu tions to the river, as a basis for ratio nal iz ing a com pre hen sive remediation plan. A sed i ment source study in 2004 iden ti fied Stoltz Bluff as the pri mary source of fine sed i ment to the river below Skutz Falls, and a 1990 chan nel avul sion at Block 51 as the major source upstream of the falls (LGL and KWL 2005). The report indi - cated that Stoltz Bluff appeared to have con trib uted about 10 000 28 000 m 3 /yr of fine sed i ment from 1993 to 2004. More over, the report found sig nif i cantly higher lev els of sand, silt and clay in streambed gravel sam ples taken about 9 km down stream of Stoltz, com pared with two other sam pling loca tions upstream of Stoltz and far ther down - stream near Duncan. Based on the find ings of the egg-to-fry sur vival and sed i ment sam pling, as well as the pri or ity of sed i ment man - age ment as a goal in the CRP, Stoltz Bluff became a top pri or ity in the frame work for over all water shed sed i - ment man age ment (BCCF 2007). Project Design and Construction Preliminary Concept The over all strat egy devel oped to tackle Stoltz Bluff was three-pronged approach. Phase 1 con sisted of river-based works to sta bi lize the toe of the bluff (KWL 2006); Phase 2 would focus on slope sta bi li za tion; and Phase 3 would con sider gully and upslope bio en gi neer ing/sta bi li za tion tech niques. As of Sep tem ber 2007, Phase 1 has been com pleted. Plans are to secure fund ing to begin Phases 2 and 3 in 2009. The objec tive of the Phase 1 works was to limit lat eral ero sion and under - cut ting of Stoltz Bluff by the river. The con cept design for Phase 1 included: a permanent access road for construction equipment, beginning at the upstream end of the Stoltz Pool provincial campground and proceeding along the left bank of the river (looking downstream) and along the toe of Stoltz Bluff. The access Continued on page 32 Streamline Watershed Management Bulletin Vol. 11/No. 2 Spring 2008 31

Environment of BC Ministry Continued from page 31 road also functions over the long term to stabilize the toe of smaller gullies on the bluff; a berm running parallel to the bluff toe (constructed primarily of gravels and cobbles excavated from the mainstem channel) to prevent ongoing toe erosion at the base of the bluff; 11 bendway weirs to reduce streamflow velocities and scour along the toe of the constructed berm while allowing for streambank planting between weirs; large riprap to protect the berm, and bioengineering between weirs (i.e., soil wraps with willow cuttings); a terrace between the berm and the toe of the bluff to store sediments resulting from surface erosion of the bluffs; a new mainstem channel on the inside of the meander curve; and bed-level rock sills at the upstream and downstream ends of the berm and terrace to provide grade control for the river channel. Figure 2. Stoltz Bluff (circa late 1990s), showing effects of toe erosion and upper slope runoff on sediment delivery to the Cowichan River. The chal lenge in devel op ing the design cri te ria was deter min ing what design flood would gov ern. Could over top ping of the ter race be per mit - ted and occa sional ter race dam age be tol er ated? Ini tially, design ing to a 20-year return period was con sid ered, but when top o graphic sur veys revealed that sub stan tial quan ti ties of river sed i ments needed to be relo - cated, it became pos si ble to raise the berm and pro tect the river works to the 200-year flood level, plus appro pri - ate free board. Hydraulic Modelling To set the berm design lev els, a river cross-sec tion was sur veyed upstream and down stream of the site and a MIKE 11 hydrau lic model (KWL 2006) was devel oped to model the streamflow dis tri bu tion between the mainstem and side chan nel. The hydrau lic model was then used to deter mine water lev els before and after the pro posed design for the 2-year and 200-year design floods, esti mated to have peak dis charges of 235 m 3 /s and 490 m 3 /s, respec tively. The pro posed design low ered the flood lev els pri mar ily due to the wider chan nel and removal of the cen tre sed i ment bar adja cent to Stoltz Bluff. Terrace and Berm The Phase 1 reha bil i ta tion works were con structed in the sum mer of 2006 (Fig ure 3). The berm was designed as a train ing berm with side slopes of 2 hor i zon tal to 1 ver ti cal. The 5 m wide berm crest (2 3 m above the mean bed level) was designed to be higher at the upstream end of the ter race to reduce the risk of over top ping. The upper end of the berm was pro tected with rip rap and tied into the exist ing slope to guard against the river scour - ing behind the berm and erod ing the newly con structed ter race. The berm ele va tion was set with stan - dard 0.6-m free board above the 200-year flood level while the con - structed ter race was set at the 2-year flood ele va tion to match the nat u ral floodplain ter race across the river. The lower ele va tion on the ter race max i - mized the vol ume of sed i ments that could nat u rally accu mu late on the ter - race from the bluffs. Dur ing future phases of the work, sed i ment col lected on the ter race will be reworked to con struct toe but tresses and con tain - ment berms. These future struc tures, con structed to the nat u ral angle of repose of the mate rial, will sta bi lize the toe of the bluffs to allow the upper slopes to nat u rally sta bi lize over time. Bank Protection and Bendway Weirs While the thought ini tially was to con - struct stan dard rip rap along the out bound slope of the berm, it was desir able to pro vide as nat u ral a sys - tem as pos si ble in the pro vin cial park. This pre sented an oppor tu nity to be inno va tive and show case bio en gi neer - ing tech niques and deflec tive weir approaches used in other juris dic tions. The goal was to even tu ally allow the riv er bank to nat u ral ize over time. By using bendway weirs and a flat ter berm slope, some bio en gi neer ing tech niques could be used between the weirs where veloc i ties were slower. After review ing the avail able research and the pros and cons on upstream point ing weirs ver sus down stream point ing guidebank weirs, the upstream approach was taken, pri mar - ily to reduce mate rial needs and result ing pro ject costs. The weirs were designed to pro trude from the new chan nel bot tom between 30 and 50% of the 2-year flow depth (approx. 0.7 m), extend about 12 m into the chan nel, and angle upstream at about 20º from the flow per pen dic u lar. Bioengineering A soil wrap (or veg e tated geogrid) was used between the bendway weirs to strengthen the bank while max i miz ing nat u ral veg e ta tion on the riv er bank. This wrap con sisted of bio de grad able coir geogrid and geofabrics inter laced with wil low brush lay ers and wil low live stak ing (Fig ure 4). Given that on-site soil con sisted of mainly sands and grav els, using this tech nique was a con cern in case the treat ment dried out dur ing hot, dry sum mers. To coun ter this, the brush lay er ing was lim ited to the lower part of the bank where wil lows could reach mois ture from subsurface chan nel flow. An irri - ga tion pro gram was also under taken dur ing the 2007 sum mer sea son. Instal la tion dif fi cul ties and tim ing were a chal lenge and resulted in mixed suc - cess. Where installed prop erly, the tech nique has per formed well; how - 32 Streamline Watershed Management Bulletin Vol. 11/No. 2 Spring 2008

ever, where wil low mate ri als were not handled properly, some plant mortality resulted. Importance of Geomorphology No major inter ven tion to a river can be done with out some upstream and down stream adjust ment. A major con - cern of the part ners, approval agen cies, and the down stream com - mu nity was the effects the Stoltz Bluff pro ject may have else where on the river due to energy trans fer. The design con sid ered geomorphic pro - cesses by incor po rat ing the fol low ing steps to min i mize the poten tial for down stream impacts: maintaining a channel bankfull width based on reference reaches upstream and downstream of the site; matching the radius of curvature to reference reaches; maintaining a channel gradient similar to the existing longitudinal slope; and maximizing the roughness of the river channel being constructed. Even with these design fea tures it is antic i pated that some wid en ing and ero sion of the chan nel will occur into the oppo site nat u ral river ter race, and some chan nel deg ra da tion may occur until the river again armours itself with larger cob ble mate rial. Environmental Protection during Construction LGL pre pared and obtained required approv als and per mits under the Water Act, Park Act, and Fish er ies Act (Houwers and Gaboury 2006). The selec tion of an expe ri enced and inno - va tive con trac tor (Johel Broth ers Con tract ing Ltd.) and the coop er a tion of envi ron men tal agen cies (par tic u larly BC Parks and Fish er ies and Oceans Can ada) enabled imple men ta tion of mea sures that min i mized harm ful effects to the flora and fauna of the Cowichan River and its ripar ian cor ri - dor. These included the fol low ing: 1. Instream con struc tion occurred dur ing the rec om mended fish er ies work win dow (July 10 to Sep tem - Figure 3. Stoltz Bluff berm, terrace, and bendway weirs in summer of 2007, one year after construction. ber 15, 2006), when flows were expected to be low (approx. 7 m 3 /s). This con struc tion win dow pro tected fall spawn ing salmon and also newly hatched steelhead, rain bow, and brown trout fry. The con struc tion foot print was min i - mized by restrict ing machin ery traf fic to a sin gle nar row cor ri dor in the park and along the river floodplain. An Envi ron men tal Mon - i tor was on site for any envi ron - men tally sen si tive work. 2. A bulk bag dam of 11 m woven bags filled with river grav els and cob ble was con structed across the mainstem to divert all river flows through an exist ing floodplain side chan nel. This allowed the in-chan - nel reha bil i ta tion works to be con - structed in iso la tion of river flows. River flows of 4 8 m 3 /s dur ing the con struc tion period were eas ily con veyed by the side chan nel, pro - vid ing a safe route for rec re ational users in watercraft to bypass the con struc tion area. 3. At the time of the flow diversion to the side channel, an estimated 25 000 30 000 fish were salvaged and transferred into the mainstem below the construction worksite. 4. Sed i ment con trol works were imple mented to min i mize the input of sus pended sed i ments to the Cowichan River below Stoltz Bluff through out the con struc tion phase. Sed i ment bar ri ers con - structed near the down stream end of the pro ject site from geotextile fil ter fab ric were reg u larly cleaned or replaced to ensure high water qual ity. Sed i ment was con trolled by pump ing silt-laden water from the main sed i men ta tion pond onto veg e tated floodplains. In addi tion, the bulk bag dam was removed over a three-day period (Sep tem - ber 6 8) to min i mize the sus - pended sed i ment load gen er ated from the re-watered mainstem chan nel. Upon com ple tion of con struc tion and re-wet ting of the mainstem, side chan - nel hab i tats and flow were re-estab lished through the con struc - tion of a low ele va tion rif fle at the inlet. Five large woody debris struc - tures were placed in the side chan nel to pro vide instream cover in fish-rear - ing pools. Lessons Learned and Value Added One pri mary les son learned on this pro ject was how effec tive the con trac - tor-pro ject man age ment team rela tion ship can be when a spirit of trust and co-oper a tion is pres ent. A Continued on page 34 Streamline Watershed Management Bulletin Vol. 11/No. 2 Spring 2008 33 Fern Dan

Kerr Wood L eida l Associates Ltd. Continued from page 33 Figure 4. Bioengineering bank stabilization treatments showing soil wrap, brush layering, live staking, and erosion control matting. time and mate ri als approach was used to share the risk with the con trac tor. Weekly cost con trol reports allowed the BCCF to make crit i cal deci sions if required and defer non-crit i cal items. This, cou pled with a well-sea soned con trac tor super vi sor, resulted in an esti mated sav ings to the pro ject of $300,000 below a fully ten dered con - tract price. While the pro ject has been very suc - cess ful to date, it was not with out its chal lenges. The avail able mate ri als on site did not allow for the access road to be con structed up to the esti mated 200-year water level as desired. It was not until a dona tion of fill from Island Tim ber lands Lim ited Part ner ship and TimberWest For est Corp. the fol low ing spring (April 2007) that the road was raised. The river works were com pleted on time and within bud get even though the TimberWest rock quarry was shut down more than once, due to for est fire con cerns, and rip rap sup plies dwin dled. Dur ing these times, the BC Min is try of Trans por ta tion kindly pro - vided rock from its quarry. Both of these dona tions show the impor tance of broad part ner ships and com mu nity involve ment in the suc cess of such large-scale pro jects. With the sud den onset of win ter and the high river lev els from Novem ber to March, com plet ing the bio en gi neer ing works proved to be a chal lenge. Works were sus pended due to the extremely high flows that pre cluded instal la tion until late spring, which was out side of the plant ing dor mancy win dow. The lack of fine-grained soils in the berm also made instal la tion dif fi cult. An irri - ga tion sys tem, installed to avoid hand water ing, proved to be too prob lem - atic and prone to van dal ism and was there fore dis carded in favour of a reg - u lar hand-water ing pro gram. Although the results of the bio en gi - neer ing treat ments were mixed, with suc cess rates for the brush lay er ing and live stak ing about 50% and 80%, respec tively, the pro ject team is pleased with the suc cess and more treat ments are planned. A valu able side-ben e fit of the pro ject to date has been the observed rec re - ational use of the access road by park vis i tors and rec re ational anglers. Vis i - tors have com mented on the scale of the con struc tion works and view ing oppor tu ni ties of the impres sive bluff for ma tion. Sport fish ers have bene fited by the cre ation of excel lent adult steelhead hold ing water off the ends of the bendway weirs. There has been a notice able increase in angling effort and catch in this short reach of the Cowichan River. The Importance of Monitoring An appar ent trend in the res to ra tion indus try is to focus on the con struc - tion of cap i tal works with out com mit ting enough resources to long-term mon i tor ing of a pro ject s effec tive ness. How do we deter mine that con structed pro jects are effec tive? Pro jects like the Stoltz Bluff require a well-designed mon i tor ing pro gram that involves water qual ity sam pling, hydrau lic sam pling of spawn ing redds, ben thic sam pling, sed i ment sam pling in spawn ing gravel areas, and ongo ing bathymetric, orthophoto, and (or) photopoint mon i tor ing. By mon i tor ing effec tive ness, it can be fully deter - mined whether the $1 mil lion spent for con struc tion in 2006 and 2007 has been the best use of lim ited resources. Lim ited pre- and post-con struc tion mon i tor ing in the river upstream and down stream of Stoltz Bluff (win ter of 2006/07) has found that sus pended sed i ment con cen tra tions down stream of the bluff were much lower than before the pro ject was con structed. Fish ing guides have also reported improved water clar ity in the Stoltz Bluff and down stream areas. These results are con sid ered anec dotal and will be improved through a more rig - or ous mon i tor ing pro gram in future Fund ing lim i ta tions in 2008 will likely restrict mon i tor ing to top o graphic sur - veys and pho to graphic evi dence of the vol ume of new sed i ment cap tured on the con structed ter race dur ing the win ter of 2007/08. This was ini tially done in the sum mer of 2007 when it was deter mined that nearly 6800 m 3 of sed i ment was retained on the ter - race in the win ter of 2006/07. Plans are under way to seek fund ing for a more inten sive mon i tor ing pro gram in 2009. With sup port, the hope is that the river will be mon i tored over sev eral years to fully deter mine the level of suc cess of the pro ject and refine plans for future pro ject phases. 34 Streamline Watershed Management Bulletin Vol. 11/No. 2 Spring 2008

Additional Information: A two-part video that fol lows the plan - ning and con struc tion phases of the pro ject is avail able at: Part 1: http://www.waterbucket.ca/wcp/sites /wbcwcp/doc u ments/media/35.wmv Part 2: http://www.waterbucket.ca/wcp/sites /wbcwcp/doc u ments/media/52.wmv For further Information, contact: Craig Wightman BC Min is try of Envi ron ment 3-1200 Prin cess Royal Ave nue Nanaimo, BC V9S 3Z7 Email: Craig.Wightman@gov.bc.ca Marc Gaboury LGL Ltd. Envi ron men tal Research Asso ci ates (LGL) 2459 Holyrood Drive Nanaimo, BC V9S 4K7 Email: mgaboury@lgl.com Dave Murray Kerr Wood Leidal Asso ci ates Ltd. Con sult ing Engi neers (KWL) 201-3045 Douglas Street Vic to ria, BC V8T 4N2 Email: dmurray@kwl.ca Acknowledgements James Craig, BC Con ser va tion Foun da tion John Walker, Black Label Con sult ing Jas Sandu, Johel Bros. Con tract ing Ltd. Mel Sheng and Brian Tutty, Fish er ies and Oceans Can ada Don Closson, BC Parks Ernie Elliott, Cowichan Tribes Kate Miller, Cowichan Val ley Regional Dis trict Cowichan Stew ard ship Roundtable Stefan Joyce, Craig Suther land, Erica Ellis, and Nigel Skermer, Kerr Wood Leidal References BC Conservation Foundation (BCCF). 2007. An enhanced business plan for the Georgia Basin Living Rivers Program. Prepared for the Living Rivers Trust Fund Advisory Group. 70 p. Burt, D.W. and J.C. Wightman. 1997. The fish resources of the Cowichan River and their economic value. Prepared for the B.C. Ministry of Environment, Lands and Parks, Nanaimo, B.C. 38 p. Burt, D.W., M. Wright, and M. Sheng. 2005. Cowichan River Chinook salmon incubation assessment, 2004 2005. Prepared for the Pacific Salmon Commission, Vancouver, B.C. 28 p. Houwers, C. and M. Gaboury. 2006. Rare plant assessment and active raptor nest search, Stoltz Bluff stabilization river erosion protection plan Cowichan River Provincial Park. Prepared for BC Parks, Nanaimo, B.C. Kerr Wood Leidal Associates Ltd. (KWL). 2006. Cowichan River Stoltz Bluff stabilization river erosion protection works design brief. Prepared for BC Conservation Foundation, Nanaimo, B.C. Kerr Wood Leidal Associates Ltd. and LGL Ltd (KWL and LGL). 2005. Cowichan River The FORREX Watershed Management Extension Program has recently conducted Watershed Management Information Needs Assessments for the Southern and Northern Interior regions of BC. The assessments were conducted through key-informant interviews with a range of parties involved in water-related issues in the respective regions. Reports based on both information needs assessments (Redding and Nickurak 2008, Redding et al. 2008) are now available on the FORREX Web site. While there was considerable overlap between information needs in both regions, some differences were apparent. Important themes requiring research and extension that emerged from these surveys include: reducing uncertainty around potential climate change impacts on water; quantifying the effects of forest disturbance (especially the mountain pine beetle infestation and harvesting) on water quantity and quality; sediment management. Final report prepared for Cowichan Treaty Office, Duncan, B.C. Lill, A.F. 2002. Greater Georgia Basin steelhead recovery action plan. Prepared for the Pacific Salmon Foundation. 107 p. LGL Ltd. 2005. Cowichan recovery plan. Draft prepared for Cowichan Tribes Treaty Office, Duncan, B.C. 170 p. + appendices. LGL Ltd. and Kerr Wood Leidal Asso ci ates Ltd. (LGL and KWL). 2005. Pre lim i nary sed i - ment man age ment review Stoltz Slide and Block 51. Pre pared for the BC Con ser - va tion Foun da tion, Nanaimo, B.C. 26 p. Newbury Hydraulics. 1997. Report on assessment and stabilization of the Cowichan River Stoltz slide reach. Prepared for the B.C. Ministry of Environment, Lands and Parks, Nanaimo, B.C. Northwest Hydraulic Consultants Ltd. (NHC). 1996. Cowichan River Stoltz Slide. Prepared for the BC Conservation Foundation, Surrey, B.C. 14 p. 2007 Watershed Management Information Needs Assessments Published increasing hydrologic knowledge and education for professional, the public, and First Nations; evaluating operational tools for predicting the effects of forest disturbance on water resources; increasing understanding of groundwater resources (inventory) and protection (legislation); developing water resource monitoring capacity. To access the reports, please see the below links: Redding, T. and K. Nickurak. 2008. 2007 North ern Inte rior needs assess - ment for water shed man age ment. FORREX For est Research and Exten sion Part ner ship, Kamloops, B.C. File Report No. 08 01. URL: http://www.forrex.org /publications/other/filereports /fr08-01.pdf Redding, T., S. Lepsoe, and M. Laurie. 2008. 2007 South ern Inte rior needs assess ment for water shed man age - ment. FORREX For est Research and Exten sion Part ner ship, Kamloops, B.C. File Report No. 08 02. URL: http://www.forrex.org /publications/other/filereports /fr08-02.pdf Streamline Watershed Management Bulletin Vol. 11/No. 2 Spring 2008 35