Volume 1- Part C Main Report

Similar documents
31. Rosses Point Mini-Plan

OPEN HOUSE WELCOME Bronte Village Growth Area Review

RPS Dungarvan Rps No Townland Address Location Use NIAH 1 Abbeyside Strand Side South Saint Augustine's Catholic Church/Chapel

* 1 I am a person representing a relevant aspect of the public interest; or

RANDWICK CITY COUNCIL Residential Discussion Paper SUMMARY DOCUMENT

Appendix 10B Photographs (Including Historical Images)

3: 1470 Bronte Road, W.C. Inglehart Farm/Oakhurst

CRA PLANNING GROUP MINUTES OF MEETING

RPS No. WBC0149 NIAH Ref.: RPS No. WBC0150 NIAH Ref.: RPS No. WBC0151 NIAH Ref.: RPS No. WBC0152 NIAH Ref.

SIGNS - RULES Signs - Rules Structure of the Rules Section Activities Discretionary Activities

APPLICATION NUMBER A REQUEST FOR

APPELLANT S STATEMENT OF CASE

Douglas Land Use and Transportation Strategy (DLUTS) Summary. August 2013

Background paper (Local Government Act 1972 Section 100D)

DESIGN CODE. Enterprise West Harlow London Road North Design Code 21

PUBLIC EXHIBITION OF COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR COLLAROY-NARRABEEN BEACH AND FISHERMANS BEACH

Ref: LCAA7101 Offers in excess of 200,000. St Peter s Church Rooms, Fore Street, Port Isaac, Cornwall

ARIGNA. LEGEND Village Core. Post Office. Grave Yard. Arigna R.C. Chapel. Arigna Iron Works (in ruins)

Creswell Historic Buildings Survey Final Report

Black Bull Close Dunbar: Historical Summary

ZONING ORDINANCE UPDATE (ZOCO DRAFT ): ADMINISTRATIVE PRACTICES AND DETERMINATIONS RELATED TO BULK, COVERAGE AND PLACEMENT

STRATEGIC PLANNING FOR DEVELOPMENT OF THE OREGON SHORT LINE TERMINUS HISTORIC DISTRICT

QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL ROAD NAMING POLICY 1 AUGUST 2016

Circular Turning Space. 8 Significant Changes to the ICC A

Section 11: The Medina Estuary

September 9, Planning and Land Development Regulation Commission (PLDRC)

Newcastle Racecourse Masterplan. 1 Introduction. Completing the vision of a redeveloped Newcastle Racecourse Welcome to our exhibition.

BRUNTSFIELD HOUSE PRIME RESIDENTIAL / DEVELOPMENT / COMMERCIAL OPPORTUNITY

Isle of Purbeck, Dorset

House Site, Newton, Dulnain Bridge, PH26 3PA Offers over 80,000

Guide to the Cycle Enfield Public Consultation on Enfield Town. Produced by the Save Our Enfield Town Campaign Group

Proposed Holmby Westwood

Arapahoe Square Zoning + Design Standards & Guidelines Task Force Meeting 9 January 27, 2016

The History of the Recreation Residences on Mt. Hood National Forest. By Allie Wenzl Historian & Tribal Relations Advisor, Mt. Hood National Forest

Determination 2018/047 Regarding the code compliance of barriers to a pool at 32 St Andrews Drive, Hikuai

Your views are important. Please fill in a form before you leave. Or alternatively

November 13, Planning and Land Development Regulation Commission (PLDRC)

REPORT DP Development Approval & Planning Policy Department

Architectural Exemplars. Mevagissey NDP Issue 2.0 Garth Shephard 1

Traffic Assessment for Woodhaven Redevelopment. City of Rome Oneida County, New York. March 2, 2018

Non-required Fences Update

Bentleigh GLEN EIRA COUNCIL TRANSFORMATIONAL CONCEPTS 15

Appendix A. Road Classification Review of Outstanding Issues and Proposed Classifications (All Wards) Staff Report Road Classification System

Joseph Fichter Sculpture Proposal Horizon Drive District Grand Junction, CO. Proposal

The Hundred Parishes

14: 2197 Lakeshore Rd West, Bronte Athletic Field

Comments The Plan for Port Whitby

Grange House Stables HAMILTON ROAD, NEWMARKET.

CONTENTS LIST. cover. preliminary page

The following is submitted together with the plans and application for the staff and plan commission consideration of approval.

Design of Stanley Park S-Curve

SECTION 7.0 ZONE STANDARD. Standards for the following Zone categories are identified in the following Sections:

There are toilets at Manningtree Station, Flatford (close to the hump back bridge) and in Dedham.

Worksop Fairs and Markets

* 1 I am a person representing a relevant aspect of the public interest; or

For Your Own Safety. Please make a note below of the contact number that should be used in the event that you get lost or require other assistance

To: The results of these surveys have been analysed and are summarised within this Technical Note.

72 Crossrail Amendment of Provisions

TOWN OF WADENA. BY LAW No

Clyde Walkway Community Links: Nemphlar Moor Road to Braidwood

TOWN OF CHAPEL HILL POLICY AND PROCEDURES FOR TRAFFIC CALMING MEASURES

Highland Park Glengarry Court. Landscape design and Fencing rules

INFORMATION REPORT. Chair and Members Emergency and Community Services Committee. Skateboard Park Study (CES17031) (City Wide)

Decisions of the Area Planning Panel (Keighley and Shipley) on Wednesday, 18 October 2017

To: Planning Commission Date: September 19, 2012 From: By: Subject:

Page 1. To: City of Durango - Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - Natural Lands Preservation Advisory Board Highland Avenue Durango, Colorado

RECOMMENDED MOTION: I MOVE TO PASS SECOND READING AND ADOPT ORDINANCE 556, TO REMOVE NE 173RD STREET FROM THE DESIGNATED PEDESTRIAN-ORIENTED STREETS.

3.0 Future Conditions

Seelos Welcome Center Update & Appeal. Fr. Byron Miller, C.Ss.R. Director, National Shrine of Blessed Francis Xavier Seelos

Baseball and Books. Master of Architecture. Jacob Tuzzo

Three Springs Design Guidelines Fencing and Wall Standards

Neighborhood Design. City Council Update June 4, 2018

Modal Interrelationships: A bicycle lane is proposed between Harrington Ave and Swanns Station Rd.

Saltash, Cornwall - Railways, Rivers & Castles

CLOSED. Highlights of the Final Concept Design:

t 15 Lot 16 Lot 25 7 Lot 39 Lot 40 R.P B-3268 ot A

MEYDAN A GLIMPSE INTO THE FAMED ARABIAN EQUESTRIAN HERITAGE

Let s get a move on!

COBOURG HERITAGE COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA. Meeting Location: Committee Room. Date: April 8, 2015 THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF COBOURG

Chapter 3: Multi-Modal Circulation and Streetscapes

Shepherdswell - Dover

Sports Travel Experience Designed Especially for Maryland Youth Soccer Association U15 Boys. Soccer in Lisbon. April 14 - April 22, 2019

CITY OF TORONTO. BY-LAW No

Swimming Pool/Hot Tub Package

THE CORPORATION OF THE CITY OF KENORA BY-LAW NUMBER

ORDINANCE NO AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF FOLSOM AMENDING CHAPTER OF THE FOLSOM MUNICIPAL CODE CONCERNING SWIMMING POOLS, SPAS AND HOT TUBS

Heritage Research Report

ST MARY S CHAPEL, WYRE

RECOMMENDATION: 1) that the existing Traffic Bridge be replaced with a modern steel truss bridge as outlined in this report;

BOYNE CITY S HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL WALKING TOUR

Warfield Neighbourhood Plan: 4.4 Infrastructure

Austin Avenue Bridges Project. Public Meeting Summary

Chapter 5 Future Transportation

'Ready to go' Site to the rear of 77 Dollymount Avenue, Dollymount, Clontarf, Dublin 3, D03 H6K3

Upper Marlboro (79-019)

Walk 2 Village Hall - The Shippy - Woodhouse Farm - Village Hall

The Berwick-upon-Tweed Conservation Areas Advisory Group (CAAG)

Adrian J Tidbury - Estates and Valuation Surveyor Portfolio Development

High frequency bus services operating to Little Island; Creation of a new Park and Ride site and train station at North Esk;

Heron Lodge ~ Hurn Court ~ Christchurch ~ BH23 6BH. 16 High Street, Christchurch Dorset BH23 1AY

Transcription:

Volume 1- Part C Main Report Main Issues Raised on the Proposed Amendments to the Draft County Development Plan 2007 in relation to the Proposed Amendments to the Draft Record of Protected Structures

County Development Plan Review Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Volume 1 Part C November 2008 Introduction This Section of the Manager s Report deals with submissions relating to Proposed Change 7.5 which included additions, deletions or amendments to the Record of Protected Structures. The Section is divided into four subsections as follows: Section A: Proposed Change as per the Proposed Amendment Document 19 th September 2008 Section B: General Submissions Received Section C: Manager s Response on Submissions Received on Individual Structures relating to Proposed Change 7.5 Section D: Summary Table of Manager s Response to all Proposed Changes Section A includes the Proposed Change as per the Proposed Amendment Document which was published on 19 th September 2008. Section B relates to general submissions received relating to the Record of Protected Structure. Section C includes the Manager s response to submissions relating to individual proposed Record of Protected Structures. Sections D includes a summary table of all the proposed changes incorporated into the Proposed Change 7.5. The general submissions received supported the inclusion of the proposed additions to the Record of Protected Structure in the Proposed Amendment to the Draft County Development Plan. The submissions relating to individual proposed RPS raised a number of issues including support of the proposed change, amendments to the change and removal of a number of proposed RPS. In relation to the requests to remove a structure a number of issues were raised in relating to the merit of including the structure and the implications of the structure being included in the Record of Protected Structure. In some cases it is acknowledged that a building internally may lack any significant original features as a result of alteration and modernisation. However, the remainder of the building could have architectural merit and unusual features that merits its inclusion. A Section 57 Declaration can be sought on each structure by the owner where the Council will establish the extent of what is being protected. In each case the submission have been considered with advice from the Heritage Unit of Cork County Council in order to form the Manager s Response to the proposed change. 2 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members November 2008 County Development Plan Review Volume 1 Part C Section A: PROPOSED CHANGE NO. 7.5 AS PER PROPOSED AMENDMENT DOCUMENT 19 TH SEPTEMBER 2008 ADDITIONS, DELETIONS AND AMENDMENTS TO THE RECORD OF PROTECTED STRUCTURES: PROPOSED CHANGE It is proposed to make the changes as highlighted in column 3 of the following: Proposed Additions: Structure Description Templebreedy Fort RPS 1364 Kilmacoom House and Gateposts RPS 1363 Glebe House RPS 1306 Porridge House RPS 1362 Former Fever Hospital RPS 1318 PA Roches office, former bank RPS 1319 Farmyard buildings and residences RPS 1320 White Bridge over the Rr. Funcheon, built 1840's RPS 1321 Black bridge over the River Funcheon RPS 1322 17th Century Bridge, Ballypooreen Road RPS 1323 18th Century Bridge, Araglin Road RPS 1324 Kingston Farmhouse RPS 1325 Location Proposed Amendment Templebreedy Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Kilmacoom Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballyvourney Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballyvourney Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Brigown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Bank Place Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Mitchelstown Demesne Mitchelstown Demesne Mitchelstown Demesne Brigown/ Kilshanny Brigown/ Ballinamona Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Kilshanny Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Cork County Council 3

County Development Plan Review Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Volume 1 Part C November 2008 Former Workhouse wall/entrance RPS 1326 Ballaghderg Bridge, 17th Century (by Golf Club) RPS 1327 Gate lodge RPS 1328 Garrane House (Linen Mill) RPS 1329 RDC House on corner RPS 1330 Former CBS Monastery RPS 1331 Parochical House RPS 1332 Former Dispensary doctor's residence RPS 1311 Entrance gate to Church RPS 1333 Entrance gate to Church RPS 1334 Thatched Cottage RPS 1335 CBS School entrance gates RPS 1336 18th Century Kingston farmhouse RPS 1337 Kents Farmhouse RPS 1338 John Mullins thatched farmhouse RPS 1339 Kilshanny Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Garrane Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Garrane Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Garrane Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 George St/James St Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Brigown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Brigown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballinwillin Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Brigown/ Church Hill Brigown/ Convent Hill Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Curragh More Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Brigown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Coolenave Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballynamona Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballybeg Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Catholic Chapel of ease built 1840's RPS 1340 Ballygiblin Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Chapel of ease to Killacluig Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 4 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members November 2008 County Development Plan Review Volume 1 Part C Mitchelstown RPS 1341 18th Century Kingston farmhouse RPS 1342 Robinsons farmhouse, 19th Century RPS 1343 Former toll house RPS 1344 Former orphanage, RPS 1345 Former orphanage, RPS 1346 Weston Villa RPS 1347 18th Century Kingston farmhouse RPS 1348 Former Railway Hotel RPS 1349 John Mandeville Memorial (1906) RPS 1350 Kingston hunting and fishing lodge RPS 1351 Kingston farmhouse in ruins RPS 1352 Water Fountain RPS 1353 Former Kingston Arms Hotel RPS 1354 Former Vicerage RPS 1355 18th Century Kingston Farmhouse RPS 1356 Demesne castle gardens and buildings Kilshanny Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Kildrum Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Church St/ Lr. Cork St Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 New Square Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 New Square Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 George St Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Pollardstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Brigown/Upper Cork St Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 New Square Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Glennahulla Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Cloghleafin Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 King Square Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 King Square Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Marshalstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Marshalstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Mitchelstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Cork County Council 5

County Development Plan Review Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Volume 1 Part C November 2008 RPS 1357 Mitchelstown Castle stableyard RPS 1358 Killee Country House RPS 1359 Carillon Lodge RPS 1307 Clonteadmore House RPS 1308 Ard na Greine RPS 1311 Rockville RPS 1317 Former Railway Bridge RPS 1309 Gateway RPS 1305 Thatched House RPS 1310 St. Joseph s Church RPS 1360 Former Dispensary RPS 1316 Parochial House RPS 1315 Former Railway Station RPS 1314 3 storey building RPS 1313 Ardfield former school house, Mountain Common RPS 1304 Monkstown Presbytery RPS 1361 Mitchelstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Killee Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Courtmacsherry Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Harbour Clonteadmore Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Mitchelstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Station Road, Carrigtwohill Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballyhooly Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Ballinglanna Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Monabricka Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Donoughmore Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Station Road, Carrigtwohill Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Carrigtwohill Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Carrigtwohill Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Main Street, Carrigtwohill Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Carhoo Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 Monkstown Text: Add new structure to table 1.1 6 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members November 2008 County Development Plan Review Volume 1 Part C Deletions: Cottage (RPS 01282) Reananerree Text: Delete proposed structure RPS01282 from table 1.1 (chapter 1) volume 2 of Plan Map: Delete structure from Heritage and Scenic Maps Thatched House (RPS1115) Gortmore Text: Delete existing structure RPS1115 from table 1.1 (chapter 1) volume 2 of Plan Map: Delete structure from Heritage and Scenic Maps Rossmore House (RPS00515) 3-Bay, 2-Storey Dwelling RPS 01267 Rossmore Tramway Terrace, Douglas Text: Delete existing structure from table 1.1 Map: Delete structure from Heritage and Scenic Maps Text: Delete existing structure from table 1.1 Map: Delete structure from Heritage and Scenic Maps * In this regard it is proposed that the structure RPS1115 is to be deleted from the Record of Protected Structures and it is noted that no notification is to be served on the basis that a) the structure is not currently in existence and b) there is no known owner/occupier. Text/Map Changes: Glebe House (RPS1280) Killingley Text: Amend table 1.1 (chapter 1) volume 2 of Plan to replace townland Killingley with Killanully. Mitchelstown library & Courthouse (RPS 00098) Mitchelstown Map: Map structure correctly as an RPS (00098) Ardskeagh Church Ardskeagh Map: Map structure correctly as an RPS (RPS016) Ardfield Catholic Chapel and Hall (RPS0801) Carhoo (00016) Text: Amend table 1.1 (chapter 1) volume 2 of Plan to exclude the words and hall (Note: The school hall referred to in the previous description is to be listed on its own as a protected structure and is proposed as a further addition to the RPS.) Watchtower (RPS0810) Castletownsend Text: Change table 1.1 (chapter 1) volume 2 of Plan text relating to townland from Castletownsend to Gortacrossig Thatched House (RPS0812) Gortmore Map structure correctly as RPS0812 NOTE: THESE CHANGES REFERS TO TEXT AND MAPS OF THE PLAN. Cork County Council 7

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Section B: GENERAL SUBMISSIONS RELATING TO RECORD OF PROTECTED STRUCTURE 2040 2788 The submission supports and welcomes the addition of structures to the RPS the proposed amendment change of the Plan. The Submission from the DOEHLG relates to the issue that structures should not be removed from the RPS unless the structure no longer possesses the special interest that caused it to be included in the RPS in the first instance. While on the other hand the submission agrees that if structures have lost their special interest that they should be removed from the RPS. It does however state that removing a protected structure from the RPS does not in itself alter the intrinsic architectural merit or character of the particular structure. This approach will be considered at the next stage of considering the Record of Protected Structures. The other general submission was received from Mitchelstown Heritage Society which supports the addition of structures to the RPS proposed as part of Submission No. 1150 received on the Draft plan. No Change Recommended 8 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume Section C: Manager s Response on Submissions Received on Individual Structures relating to Proposed Change 7.5 Proposed Change Relating To Kilmacoom House and Gateposts, Kilmacoom RPS 1363 2033 The submission requests the removal of the proposed RPS. It is recommended that the building is included on the RPS in recognition of its architectural merit. No change recommended to the proposed change. Cork County Council 9

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Proposed Change Relating to the Former Fever Hospital, Brigown, Mitchelstown RPS 1318 2039 2036 The submission requests the removal of the proposed RPS. It is considered that the building should remain on the RPS for historical reasons. Recommend no change to the proposed amendment 10 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume Proposed Change Former Workhouse wall/entrance, Mitchelstown RPS 1326 2514 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS or amend the description in line with the NIAH. It is recognised that there are no longer workhouse buildings located within the site. However, the surrounding boundary wall does merit protection. It is considered that the description former Workhouse Wall is more accurate and clear and it is recommended that the wording be amended be to say Former Workhouse Wall in place of Former Workhouse. MODIFY THE PROPOSED CHANGE AS FOLLOWS: RPS Description Former Workhouse Wall Cork County Council 11

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Proposed Change Relating to Former CBS Monastery, Brigown, Mitchelstown RPS 1331 2037 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. Recommendation: The Christian Brothers Monastery forms part of a wider ecclesiastical complex comprising of church, graveyard, convent, schools and Legion of Mary Hall. Although no longer in use the building makes a significant contribution to the town as the monastery for the adjacent Christian Brothers School. The building is both of architectural, historical and cultural merit and should be added to the Record of Protected Structures. Inclusion supported by Ministerial Recommendation. No change recommended to the proposed amendment. 12 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO PAROCHIAL HOUSE, BRIGOWN, MITCHELSTOWN RPS 1332 2038 The submission raises the matter of the implications of having a structure included as a proposed RPS in relation to proposed work to be carried out to the church. It is considered that the inclusion of the structure as a proposed RPS does not necessarily preclude such work; it is therefore recommended that the building is included as a RPS in recognition of its architectural merit. No change recommended to the proposed change.. Cork County Council 13

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Proposed Change Relating to CBS School Entrance Gates, Brigown, Mitchelstown RPS 1336 2017 2073 2075 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with the removal of the proposed RPS. The Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government recommends the gate pillars for inclusion in the Record of Protected Structures and the Heritage Unit concurs with this recommendation. The gate piers are a fine example of excellent craftsmanship. They consist of large ashlar blocks with rustication and ribbon dressing. The gate piers are currently in good condition and do not require any works. No change recommended to the proposed amendment. 14 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume Proposed Change Relating to Kents Farmhouse, Ballynamona RPS 1338 2003 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. This building warrants inclusion in the Record of Protected Structures in recognition of its vernacular architectural features. The building contains a very steeply pitched roof, sash windows of varying types, which add interest to the main elevations of the building, while the building position relative to the road and the general group of outbuildings creates a strong focal point in the landscape. However, the notification letter was issued to a John Kent, therefore it is accepted that adequate notification was not given. It light of this it is recommended that the building is not added to the Record of Protected Structures in this instance. It should be noted that consideration may be given to its proposed addition at a future date and is included on the National Inventory of the Architectural Heritage. Recommend to reject the proposed change from the proposed amendments. REJECT THE PROPOSED. Cork County Council 15

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO JOHN MULLINS THATCHED FARMHOUSE BALLYBEG RPS 1339 2047 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with the removal of the proposed RPS. The thatch house has a high level of intactness and should be included in the Record of Protected Structures. However, the notification was sent to a John Mullins and the submission has identified Mr Daniel Mullins as the owner. On the basis of the issue with the notification, it is considered that this structure cannot therefore be added to the Record of Protected Structures at this time. It should be noted that consideration may be given to its proposed addition at a future date. Recommend to reject proposed change REJECT THE PROPOSED. 16 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO 18TH CENTURY KINGSTON FARMHOUSE KILSHANNY RPS 1342 2438 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with the removal of the proposed RPS. The case has been put forward that the building has been altered by modern interventions and therefore does not warrant inclusion in the Record of Protected Structures. On the basis of the information received and that the structure does not feature on the NIAH it is recommended to remove the proposed structure from the RPS. Recommend to reject proposed change. REJECT THE PROPOSED. Cork County Council 17

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO FORMER TOLL HOUSE CHURCH ST/ LR. CORK ST, MITCHELSTOWN RPS 1344 2100 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. The building is now located within a Proposed Architectural Conservation Area. It is considered that this provides sufficient protection of the structure. Furthermore on the basis of the information received in the submission, and it is recommended that the proposed structure be removed from the Record of Protected Structures. Recommend to reject proposed change. REJECT THE PROPOSED. 18 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume PROPOSED CHANGE WESTON VILLA, GEORGE ST, MITCHELSTOWN RPS 1347 2002 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. While it is acknowledged that the building internally lacks any significant original features, the remainder of the building does have architectural merit and unusual features, and also contributes to the streetscape. It is therefore recommended that the building be added to the Record of Protected Structures. This is also a recommendation from the Minister of Environment, Heritage and Local Government. Recommend no change to the proposed amendment Cork County Council 19

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Proposed Change relating to 18th Century Kingston farmhouse Pollardstown RPS 1348 2784 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. On the basis of the information received in the submission it is recommended that the building be removed as a proposed Record of Protected Structures. Recommend To Reject The Proposed Amendment. REJECT THE PROPOSED. 20 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume Proposed Change relating to Former Railway Hotel, Brigown/Upper Cork St RPS 1349 2000 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. This building has a number of unusual architectural features. It is a corner site, five-bay, two storey structure, with attic accommodation over. Original features include, rendered chimney stacks, terracotta chimney pots, rendered walls, rusticated quoins, decorative cornices and keystones and moulded rendered surrounds. It is therefore recommended that this building be added to the Record of Protected Structures in recognition of its architectural and historic merit. The Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government has also included this building within his Ministerial Recommendations. Recommend no change to the proposed amendment. Cork County Council 21

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO KINGSTON HUNTING AND FISHING LODGE, GLENNAHULLA RPS 1351 2158 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS. On the basis of the information received in the submission it is recommended that the building be removed as a proposed Record of Protected Structures. Recommend to reject the proposed amendment REJECT THE PROPOSED. 22 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO MITCHELSTOWN CASTLE STABLEYARD, MITCHELSTOWN RPS 1358 2513 The relevant planning issues in this case are concerned with - the removal of the proposed RPS based on a number of issues or amend in accordance with the NIAH survey. Taking into consideration the submission and the NIAH survey it is recommend that the front elevation of the stable yard building be included on the RPS. This is a pedimented three bay entrance breakfront to centre having occlus to pediment. It is recommend that the proposed change be amended by changing the description of the proposed RPS to Farmyard Complex as per NIAH. Recommend to modify the proposed change. MODIFY THE PROPOSED CHANGE AS FOLLOWS: RPS Description Mitchelstown Castle Farmyard Complex Cork County Council 23

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Proposed Change Relating to Carillon Lodge, Courtmacsherry Harbour RPS 1307 2030 2181 2180 The submissions support the inclusion of Carillon Lodge as a proposed RPS. The building has been included as a proposed Record of Protected Structures in recognition of its architectural merit and historical associations. Carillon Lodge is a very unusual octagonal gate lodge with gothic style windows and is associated with Courtmacsherry House. It is therefore recommended that the building be added to the Record of Protected Structures. No changed recommended to the proposed change. 24 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume Proposed change Relating to Rockville Station Road, Carrigtwohill RPS 1317 2006 The submission requests the removal of the proposed RPS. This house consists of a primary residential house, which incorporates an earlier vernacular dwelling, and a series of significant outbuildings to the rear and side of the existing dwelling. This complex of buildings has significant architectural merit and contributes to the overall streetscape along Station Road, which contains a number of historic structures. It is therefore recommended that this building is added to the Record of Protected Structures. No change recommended to the proposed amendment. Cork County Council 25

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Proposed Change Relating to St. Joseph s Church, Donoughmore RPS 1360 2785 The submission requests the removal of the proposed RPS. This church dates to 1840. While it has obviously undergone some changes it still retains much of its original historic fabric. The building is also of historical merit being built on the site of an earlier church. It is therefore recommended that the building is added to the Record of Protected Structures. No change recommended to the proposed amendment. : 26 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume PROPOSED CHANGE RELATING TO FORMER RAILWAY STATION, CARRIGTWOHILL RPS 1314 2165 The submission requests the removal of the proposed RPS based on a number of issues including incorrect notification. The incorrect notification is acknowledged and it is recommended that this structure be removed as a proposed RPS at this time. Recommend the proposed change be rejected. REJECT THE PROPOSED. Cork County Council 27

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Section D: Summary Table of Manager s Response Structure Description Templebreedy Fort Templebreedy RPS 1364 Kilmacoom House and Gateposts Kilmacoom RPS 1363 Glebe House, Ballyvourney RPS 1306 Porridge House, Ballyvourney RPS 1362 Former Fever Hospital, Brigown RPS 1318 PA Roches office, former bank Bank Place, Mitchelstown RPS 1319 Farmyard buildings and residences Mitchelstown Demesne RPS 1320 White Bridge over the Rr. Funcheon, Mitchelstown Demesne built 1840's RPS 1321 Black bridge over the River Funcheon Mitchelstown Demesne RPS 1322 17th Century Bridge, Ballypooreen Road Brigown/ Kilshanny RPS 1323 18th Century Bridge, Araglin Road Brigown/ Ballinamona RPS 1324 Kingston Farmhouse Kilshanny RPS 1325 Former Workhouse wall/entrance, Kilshanny RPS 1326 Ballaghderg Bridge, Garrane 17th Century (by Golf Club) RPS 1327 Gate lodge Garrane RPS 1328 Garrane House (Linen Mill) Garrane RPS 1329 RDC House on corner George St/James St RPS 1330 Former CBS Monastery, Brigown Submissions Received YES YES YES YES Recommendation MODIFY THE PROPOSED CHANGE AS FOLLOWS: Former Workhouse Wall 28 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C County Development Plan Volume RPS 1331 Parochical House, Brigown RPS 1332 Former Dispensary doctor's residence Ballinwillin RPS 1311 Entrance gate to Church Brigown/ Church Hill RPS 1333 Entrance gate to Church Brigown/ Convent Hill RPS 1334 Thatched Cottage Curragh More RPS 1335 CBS School entrance gates, Brigown RPS 1336 18th Century Kingston farmhouse Coolenave RPS 1337 Kents Farmhouse Ballynamona RPS 1338 John Mullins thatched farmhouse Ballybeg RPS 1339 Catholic Chapel of ease Ballygiblin built 1840's RPS 1340 Chapel of ease Killacluig Mitchelstown RPS 1341 18th Century Kingston farmhouse, Kilshanny RPS 1342 Robinsons farmhouse, Kildrum 19th Century RPS 1343 Former toll house Church St/ Lr. Cork St RPS 1344 Former orphanage, New Square RPS 1345 Former orphanage, New Square RPS 1346 Weston Villa, George St RPS 1347 18th Century Kingston farmhouse, Pollardstown RPS 1348 Former Railway Hotel, Brigown/Upper Cork St RPS 1349 John Mandeville Memorial (1906) New Square RPS 1350 Kingston hunting and fishing lodge, Glennahulla YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES REJECT THE PROPOSED REJECT THE PROPOSED REJECT THE PROPOSED REJECT THE PROPOSED REJECT THE PROPOSED REJECT THE PROPOSED Cork County Council 29

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November RPS 1351 Kingston farmhouse Cloghleafin in ruins RPS 1352 Water Fountain King Square RPS 1353 Former Kingston Arms Hotel King Square RPS 1354 Former Vicerage Marshalstown RPS 1355 18th Century Kingston Farmhouse Marshalstown RPS 1356 Demesne castle gardens and buildings Mitchelstown RPS 1357 Mitchelstown Castle stableyard, Mitchelstown RPS 1358 YES MODIFY THE PROPOSED CHANGE AS FOLLOWS: Mitchelstown Castle Farmyard Complex Killee Country House Killee RPS 1359 Carillon Lodge, YES Courtmacsherry Harbour RPS 1307 Clonteadmore House Clonteadmore RPS 1308 Ard na Greine Mitchelstown RPS 1311 Rockville Station Road, YES Carrigtwohill RPS 1317 Former Railway Bridge Ballyhooly RPS 1309 Gateway Ballinglanna RPS 1305 Thatched House Monabricka RPS 1310 St. Joseph s Church YES Donoughmore RPS 1360 Former Dispensary Station Road, Carrigtwohill RPS 1316 Parochial House Carrigtwohill RPS 1315 Former Railway Station, YES REJECT THE PROPOSED Carrigtwohill RPS 1314 3 storey building Main Street, Carrigtwohill RPS 1313 Ardfield former school house, Mountain Common Carhoo RPS 1304 Monkstown Presbytery 30 Cork County Council

Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to Members Review November 2008 1 Part C Monkstown RPS 1361 County Development Plan Volume Cork County Council 31

County Development Plan Review Members Volume 1 Part C 2008 Section 12 (8) Manager s Report to November Deletions: Cottage (RPS 01282) Reananerree Thatched House Gortmore (RPS1115) Rossmore House Rossmore (RPS00515) 3-Bay, 2-Storey Dwelling Tramway Terrace, Douglas RPS 01267 Text/Map Changes: Glebe House Killingley (RPS1280) Mitchelstown library & Courthouse Mitchelstown (RPS 00098) Ardskeagh Church Ardskeagh (RPS016) Ardfield Catholic Chapel and Hall Carhoo (RPS0801) Watchtower Castletownsend (RPS0810) Thatched House Gortmore (RPS0812) 32 Cork County Council