Gordon Food Service Market Updates for January 25, 2019

Similar documents
Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for March 8, 2019

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for March 15, 2019

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for March 1, 2019

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for February 8, 2019

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for March 22, 2019

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for December 7, 2018

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for December 14, 2018

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for April 5, 2019

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for November 9, 2018

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for October 26, 2018

Turkey Aggressive retail features including BOGOs are giving the industry hope that large turkey inventories may get cleaned up.

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Market Update July 14, 2017

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for July 6, 2018

Gordon Food Service Market Updates

Global Supply Conditions

Global Supply Conditions

Global Supply Conditions

SLADE GORTON & CO SEAFOOD MARKET REPORT June 2014

Slade Gorton s Monthly Market Report

BMO Capital Markets 2014 Farm to Market Conference New York, New York. May 21, 2014

Fishery. Fishing vessels (Dept. of Finance)

D&K FOODS 766 SO. GLADYS AVE. LOS ANGELES CA 90021

Atlantic Canada lobster industry: structure & markets

Livestock and Dairy Market Outlook

7 th Dec: TRENDS & FORWARD PROSPECTS FOR SCOTTISH COD, HADDOCK, WHITING, SAITHE Fishing & Uptake

BMO Capital Markets New York Road Show New York, New York. December 5, 2013

THE BORNSTEIN REPORT March 2017

Responsible sourcing is a journey and a destination. Panamei embraces a love for the ocean and for the culinary experiences it provides.

Goldman Sachs Eighteenth Annual Agribusiness Conference New York, New York. March 12, 2014

Outlook for the U.S. Livestock and Poultry Sectors in 2011

the taste of fresh BISTRO SENSATIONS SEAFOOD BISTRO SELECTIONS

BMO Capital Markets 2013 Farm to Market Conference New York, New York. May 14, 2013

Goldman Sachs U.S. Emerging/SMID Cap Growth Conference. New York, New York

Steaks, frozen Whole, fresh Whole, frozen

Cattle Market Situation and Outlook: 2015 and Beyond

J.P. Morgan New York Non-Deal Road Show. New York, New York

Sidoti & Company, LLC West Coast Road Show. San Francisco, California

Winter 2015/ Halibut & Blackcod Market Bulletin

Shrimp Production Review

Goldman Sachs Agricultural Biotech Forum New York, NY. March 7, 2012

ARTIC CHAR FILLET SKIN ON 1/10 LB BARRAMUNDI FILLET SKIN OFF 6-8 z HC 1/10 LB BARRAMUNDI FILLET SKIN ON 7-9 z HC 1/10 LB

Georgia Commercial Aquaculture Update Gary Burtle University of Georgia Animal & Dairy Science, Tifton

Fishery. Harvesting. Snow Crab Professional Fish Harvesters Certification Board

Outlook for the U.S. Livestock and Poultry Sectors in 2012 Presented By Shayle D. Shagam World Agricultural Outlook Board, USDA

ALLIGATOR TL MEAT RNDM FZN RAW 1/5 LB

Outlook for U.S. Retail Food Prices and Inflation in 2009

Change, Challenges and Opportunities for Wild Fisheries

Frozen fish fillets for sale

From the Ocean To the Plate

Presentation from the USDA Agricultural Outlook Forum 2017

OUTLOOK FOR US AGRICULTURE. Rob Johansson Acting Chief Economist 19 February 2015

Prepared by: McDowell Group, Inc. Andy Wink CAP Meeting

Sulphur Market Outlook

SUSTAINABILITY CRITERIA FOR FISHERIES SUBSIDIES: THE LATIN AMERICAN CONTEXT

Recent Events in the Market for Canadian Snow Crab

Herein are two reports provided to the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador by The McDowell Group of Alaska. This company was contracted by the

Aquaculture, Fisheries and the

Frozen Seafood Order Online

Outlook for Livestock and Poultry. Michael Jewison World Agricultural Outlook Board, USDA

U.S. Global Position (Imports/Exports) Dermot Hayes Iowa State University

Agricultural Outlook: Rebalancing U.S. Agriculture

Trade Winds in Agriculture

Cattle Market Outlook & Important Profit Factors for Cattle Producers

Beef Outlook. Regional Dealer Event. February 9, Dr. Scott Brown Agricultural Markets and Policy Division of Applied Social Sciences

Seafood Industry. The 2012 Juneau and Southeast Alaska Economic Indicators 11/1/12 Page 60

In each summer issue of Lake

Provide a brief introduction to the U.S. seafood industry

Commodity Market Outlook: Corn, Forage, Wheat & Cattle

Year Avg. TAC Can Others Totals

Catalogue no X. Cattle Statistics

STORM FORECASTS: The only independent source of animal health and animal agriculture historical market data and forecasts

Fish & Seafood. A Quick Guide on Preparing Your Seafood Counter. Seafood Counter Setup 2012 Seacore Seafood Inc.

REQUEST FOR BIDS SEALED BIDS ARE REQUESTED FOR: 2018 SEAFOOD PURCHASES. Point Defiance Zoo & Aquarium 5400 N. Pearl St.

Mercury Levels in Commercial Fish and Shellfish

Learn and develop motor skills. Recognize that fish and other seafood are an important part of a healthy diet. Be active and have fun.

2019 Global Travel Forecast: Air, Hotel and Ground Prices

Fishing Industry in Prince Edward Island January 2009

Human Impact in Aquatic Systems: Fish Catching vs. Fish Raising

World supply and demand of tilapia

One Year Later A regional assessment of seafood consumption patterns after the Gulf oil spill

Agriculture and the Economy: A View from the Chicago Fed

Key Whitefish FIP Updates

HADDOCK ON THE SOUTHERN SCOTIAN SHELF AND IN THE BAY OF FUNDY (DIV. 4X/5Y)

Oil Prices: Past, Present, & Future

Delivering on Seafood Traceability Under the Seafood Import Monitoring Program

Fastmarkets RISI Global Boxboard Outlook

Pacific Halibut. Pacific Halibut. Pacific Halibut. Range. Life Cycle

10/18/2015. Outline. Commodity Outlook

Livestock, Poultry, and Dairy: Situation and Outlook

Aquaculture growth potential in Azerbaijan

Global Containerboard Outlook

Your Seafood Processor

Transcription:

Gordon Food Service Market Updates for January 25, 2019 Dairy Cheese The Block and Barrel Markets have continued to be bearish. Speculators feel this will continue with the current environment trades are being made in. The weather has been mild with no current effect on milk production. Last week: Block- Up Barrel-Down This Week: Block- Down Barrel-Down Dairy Eggs Retail demand good. Supplies tight. Market firm.

Last week: Large - Up Medium - Up Small - Up This Week: Large - Up Medium - Up Small - Up Dairy Butter Butter manufacturers continue to their seasonal building for later use, especially summer.demand is up across markets and a bit higher than it traditionally is for this time in the year. Spot pricing remains relatively steady while futures are showing increases going in to the back half of the year. Last week: Butter - Up This Week: Butter - Down Grocery & Bakery Wheat Wheat futures recovered as rumors that Russia may slow exports circulate. Grocery & Bakery Soybean Oil

Soybean oil prices are approaching the middleof the USDA's $0.28-$0.32/lb range. Reports that hot dry weather is shrinking Brazil's soybean crop triggered some price recovery. Grocery & Bakery Sugar Beet sugar.prices are inching higher as available supplies tighten. Meat Beef Cattle slaughter is down 5% from pre-holiday peaks; cattle prices have stalled as demand slows. Smaller supplies will likely support beef prices. Ground Beef: Smaller production and lighter cattle (with less fat) are shrinking the supply of 50% trimmings. Ground beef prices are edging higher. Ribs: Rib prices are at the upper end of where they usually trade this time of year. Packers are holding to list prices; discounting only after product is over 21 days age. Briskets: Prices often drift lower in January and this year appears to be no exception. While prices have declined from recent peakswe are still sitting 14% higher than last January. Rounds: Round prices dipped last week, but supplies have since cleaned up and prices are firming. Strips:

Prices have been trading sideways, typical for this time of year. Tenders: Tender prices are holding at the high end of their historical range for this time of year. Packers are discounting forward sales to keep spot supplies tight. Thin Meats: Seasonally-declining beef production is usually price supportive for thin meats in the winter. Prices are higher than last January. Meat Pork Packers have been cranking out 5% more pork in the last few weeks as strong bacon prices support margins. Winter storms and deteriorating margins are starting to trigger more downtime; supplies should shrink. Butts: Butt prices are at the lowest level since 2011.Prices should lift as output is cut back. Hams: Ham prices are mostly sideways at 10-year lows as big production keeps pipelines full. Bacon/Bellies: Belly prices were lifted by QSR promotionswhich tightened supply considerably. As promotions wind down buyers have turned cautious and prices are slipping. Ribs: Rib prices have been mostly sideways as big production puts a lid on prices. Reduced output should allow the seasonal uptrend to resume in coming weeks. Loins:

Bome-in loin prices are steady; boneless loin prices are stuck at 26-year lows. Poultry Chicken The Government shutdown has stopped reports on poultry productionbut we had been trending close to unchanged in recent weeks. While whole bird demand is OK discounts are still required to move larger sizes. Breast and Tenders: Both jumbo and medium breast meat is well cleared; chicken breast prices are now above all-time lows for the first time in months. Strong demand for tenders by boneless wing processors have kept prices in an uptrend. Wings: Wing prices may be close to peaking as we approach Super Bowl. Dark Meat: Strong export demand has yet to lift leg quarter prices back to where they were last year -- probably the result of Mexico's tariffs. Leg meat and thigh meat prices are firm. Poultry Turkey Hens and smaller sized toms are in great shape; larger toms are still a little pushy. Bone-in breast prices are steady. Seafood Finfish Cod, Alaskan 1x: Supply remains tight and costs are firm as we head into the firstof the year. The Alaskan cod quotahas been reduced by 18,000 tons and with reductions in quota on

other white fishspeciesas well.poor environmental conditions, lack of incomingrecruitment are just two of the reasons for the lowered quota.theend result will be increased costs on cod overall. Cod, Atlantic 1x: The 1x frozen Atl. cod loins are firm on cost and could increase further. Recentadverse weather andreduced quotahave resulted in limited catchesfor the fishermen at this time.the smaller 4 oz size has been the most effected as the current harvesthas yielded larger fish and therefore larger loins. We hope to minimize any out of stocks on this item but it could be hit or miss.expect this trend to continue at leastthrough Lent and possibly through June. Cod, Atlantic 2x: 2019 Total Allowable Catch is announced at 6.5% lower than 2018. Prices will remain firm. Cod, Pacific 2x: Due to lower catch announced from Atlantic cod. Pacific cod raw material price remains high. Pollock, Atlantic 1x: The overall Pollock quotahas remainedfairly stable. Reductionin quotaoutof the Gulf of Alaska has been offsetby increases out of the Eastern Bering Sea for the most part. However it has also been noted that there are limited holdover inventories for the start of 2019 that could pushup costs pre-lent. Pollock, Pacific 2x: Firming of pricing as expectation of drop in pollock biomass. Starting to see substitution demand from cod and haddock users. Haddock: 15% decrease of Total Allowable Catch announced for haddock. Price is still cheaper than cod. Expectation of cod substitution to continue. Domestic Lake Fish:

Supply of Yellow Lake Perch, Walleye, Whitefish and Smelt has been plentiful on all sizes and is expectedto remain so through Lent. Costs have stabilized as of late. Canadian bluegill continues to be a problem as the resource has experienced limitedcatches and is awaiting the start of the new seasonafter the first of the year.the sub for this item is the Chinese offering of bluegill. This is the same species asthe Canadian just grown out in Asia and is a great option to the former. Euro Lake Fish & Zander: Supply is good and costs have softened some but are expected to remain stable for LentThis is a more cost effective substitute for the higher priced domestic lake fish items where applicable. Currently there is stockon all sizesof pikeperch and Europeanperch for Lent. Mahi Mahi: Mahi Mahi costs have continued to soften as the season has resumed out of Peru and Ecuadordown to 2013 and 2014 levels. Reportsindicate thereis left over product fromthe 2018 season both domesticallyand over seas, leaving the market in flux. Current harvests now have yielded larger fish in the 6 and 8 oz portion levels where there has been limited production of the 4 oz size at this time. Expectthe market tobe unstable at least through the spring where we can gauge if the excess inventorieshavebeen flushed out of the market. Frozen Tuna, Swordfish : At the end of the calendar year there is minimal harvestof tuna out of most regions. As we move intothe new year Thailand production increaseswith VietNam close behind it.for now costs are stable and supply is adequate for a relativelyactive demand. Costshave firmed on Swordfish from Indonesia, withhigh demand from the European market and stricter regulations overseas. Demand remains strong from both retail and food service customers Swai: Reports of more consistent swai supply from producing countries. Tilapia:

The tariffwar has increased costs of product by 10%. The potential foranother 15% increase has now been delayed until thebeginning of March by the Trump administration. Seafood Shrimp Imported Black Tiger: Black Tiger shrimp prices are stable and supply is good on small and middle sizes. There are shortages of large sizes due to limited production (2-4 through 13-15) and heavy demand. Imported White: White shrimp supply is somewhat sporadic with shipments being late due to heavy demand overseas. Market values are good and offer great opportunities to menu shrimp this summer. Expect supply to be better as we roll into the late summer months as production catches up. Latin White: Latin White shrimp are firm with replacement prices firming. Supply is good for the time being. Domestic White & Brown: Domestic Brown shrimp are steady in price as we roll into the new season for Texas. Larger sizes of white and brown headless shrimp should begin to land over the next few months. Domestic PUD: Domestic PUD production has slowed on smaller shrimp. While boats begin to target larger whites and browns where available, we should see better production in larger and middle size peeled shrimp. Domestic Rock & Pink: Rock & Pink shrimp are both in good supply.

Seafood Lobster North Atlantic: Lobster tail costs have firmed as the landings from Mainewere not stellar this summer and the late fall Nova Scotia seasonhas been down between 20-50%. The majority of the larger sizes tails are harvested during this season and to date it has been considered a bust. Weather delaysand colder than normal temperatureshave impacted this resource. Currently there are limited supplies of the larger 6/7 and8/10 oz tails and this is expected to be a challenge into the summer season. Meat has been softeningover time and has startedto level off, supply is good. Warm Water: Supply has been short on warm water tails after a late start to the season this summer. Poor catches, increased demand out of Asia and retailers taking a stronger positionon the markethave resulted in a firm undertone.this trend continued through the holidays and is expected to remain firm until new season suppliesstart to arrive in July. The WW tails in the 6 and 8 oz sizes might bea viableoptionto the lack of larger N Atl tails but costs are a trade off as both species report a firmmarket and overall lack of supply. Seafood Crab Snow Crab: The global shortage of snow crab has continued through the fall.alaska did announce their recent findings on their biomass survey of the Bering sea and the resultsare favorable for more quotafor this regioncome this winter.the survey showed a 60 percent boost in market sized males and nearly the same for females. However..many are predicting a largereduction in the snowcrab quota out of Newfoundland come spring. This will outweighany increase out of Alaska and in the end, snow crab is still expected to be short. To date prices have leveled off on Canadian crabon the larger 8 and 10 up products withlimited offerings. However the5/8 size hassoftened someas processors and brokers look at moving off the balance of their inventory prior to new season..

King Crab: This market has remained unchanged in regardto supply Allking crab sizes remain tight, especially on 14/17 ct, 16/20 ct and 20/+ ct. Thesethree sizes haveseen the biggest issue with availability and as a result costs are firm.we do not expect any relief on supply for months, possibly even through summer 2019as the recentannouncement outof Alaska was not positive. For red king crab at the eastern portion of the Bering Sea more commonly called Bristol Bay, numbers of mature males dropped more than 40 percent from last year and mature females were down 54 percent. Buyers need to consider gold king crab as a viable optionfor the 2019 season. Note howeverdue to the lack of overallsupply for reds the costs of golds are starting to increase as well. Red Swimming Crab: A new 10% tariff on all seafood items should go into effect in August. The market is still uncertain however, between high market prices, and limited supply, cost might go up. This coupled with the void in the market on red swimming crab only strengthens this possibility. We are still expected to start receiving shipments on red crab in October. The main crab harvest is October December. Blue Swimming Crab: Prices are still high with great inventory. There has been a slight decrease in pricing from Indonesia while Philippines and India move up to be more in line with Indo. For the next 60-90 days prices will stay level to a possible dip however, Q4 is expected to pick back up. With the red swimming still high with limited supply, this too drives the price up. Overall prices will come down a bit. Seafood Scallops The scallop marketas of late has taken some significantincreases on the larger U- 10, U-12 and 10-20 ct sizes. Strong demandhas impactedcost and these are expected to remain elevated at least until after Feb as manystartto to move off any 2018 inventory in preparation for the startof the 2019 spring season.for now expect firming prices and adequate supply.

Chinese Flounder and Ocean Perch: 10% tariff duty has been applied. The possible added 15% has now been pushed back to the beginning of March when the Trumpadministration will decideon a final ruling. Seafood Finfish Cod, Alaskan 1x: Supply remains tight and costs are firm as we head into the firstof the year. The Alaskan cod quotahas been reduced by 18,000 tons and with reductions in quota on other white fishspeciesas well.poor environmental conditions, lack of incomingrecruitment are just two of the reasons for the lowered quota.theend result will be increased costs on cod overall. Cod, Atlantic 1x: The 1x frozen Atl. cod loins are firm on cost and could increase further. Recentadverse weather andreduced quotahave resulted in limited catchesfor the fishermen at this time.the smaller 4 oz size has been the most effected as the current harvesthas yielded larger fish and therefore larger loins. We hope to minimize any out of stocks on this item but it could be hit or miss.expect this trend to continue at leastthrough Lent and possibly through June. Cod, Atlantic 2x: 2019 Total Allowable Catch is announced at 6.5% lower than 2018. Prices will remain firm. Cod, Pacific 2x: Due to lower catch announced from Atlantic cod. Pacific cod raw material price remains high. Pollock, Atlantic 1x: The overall Pollock quotahas remainedfairly stable. Reductionin quotaoutof the Gulf of Alaska has been offsetby increases out of the Eastern Bering Sea for the most

part. However it has also been noted that there are limited holdover inventories for the start of 2019 that could pushup costs pre-lent. Pollock, Pacific 2x: Firming of pricing as expectation of drop in pollock biomass. Starting to see substitution demand from cod and haddock users. Haddock: 15% decrease of Total Allowable Catch announced for haddock. Price is still cheaper than cod. Expectation of cod substitution to continue. Domestic Lake Fish: Supply of Yellow Lake Perch, Walleye, Whitefish and Smelt has been plentiful on all sizes and is expectedto remain so through Lent. Costs have stabilized as of late. Canadian bluegill continues to be a problem as the resource has experienced limitedcatches and is awaiting the start of the new seasonafter the first of the year.the sub for this item is the Chinese offering of bluegill. This is the same species asthe Canadian just grown out in Asia and is a great option to the former. Euro Lake Fish & Zander: Supply is good and costs have softened some but are expected to remain stable for LentThis is a more cost effective substitute for the higher priced domestic lake fish items where applicable. Currently there is stockon all sizesof pikeperch and Europeanperch for Lent. Mahi Mahi: Mahi Mahi costs have continued to soften as the season has resumed out of Peru and Ecuadordown to 2013 and 2014 levels. Reportsindicate thereis left over product fromthe 2018 season both domesticallyand over seas, leaving the market in flux. Current harvests now have yielded larger fish in the 6 and 8 oz portion levels where there has been limited production of the 4 oz size at this time. Expectthe market tobe unstable at least through the spring where we can gauge if the excess inventorieshavebeen flushed out of the market. Frozen Tuna, Swordfish :

At the end of the calendar year there is minimal harvestof tuna out of most regions. As we move intothe new year Thailand production increaseswith VietNam close behind it.for now costs are stable and supply is adequate for a relativelyactive demand. Costshave firmed on Swordfish from Indonesia, withhigh demand from the European market and stricter regulations overseas. Demand remains strong from both retail and food service customers Swai: Reports of more consistent swai supply from producing countries. Tilapia: The tariffwar has increased costs of product by 10%. The potential foranother 15% increase has now been delayed until thebeginning of March by the Trump administration. Seafood Shrimp Imported Black Tiger: Black Tiger shrimp prices are stable and supply is good on small and middle sizes. There are shortages of large sizes due to limited production (2-4 through 13-15) and heavy demand. Imported White: White shrimp supply is somewhat sporadic with shipments being late due to heavy demand overseas. Market values are good and offer great opportunities to menu shrimp this summer. Expect supply to be better as we roll into the late summer months as production catches up. Latin White: Latin White shrimp are firm with replacement prices firming. Supply is good for the time being. Domestic White & Brown:

Domestic Brown shrimp are steady in price as we roll into the new season for Texas. Larger sizes of white and brown headless shrimp should begin to land over the next few months. Domestic PUD: Domestic PUD production has slowed on smaller shrimp. While boats begin to target larger whites and browns where available, we should see better production in larger and middle size peeled shrimp. Domestic Rock & Pink: Rock & Pink shrimp are both in good supply. Seafood Lobster North Atlantic: Lobster tail costs have firmed as the landings from Mainewere not stellar this summer and the late fall Nova Scotia seasonhas been down between 20-50%. The majority of the larger sizes tails are harvested during this season and to date it has been considered a bust. Weather delaysand colder than normal temperatureshave impacted this resource. Currently there are limited supplies of the larger 6/7 and8/10 oz tails and this is expected to be a challenge into the summer season. Meat has been softeningover time and has startedto level off, supply is good. Warm Water: Supply has been short on warm water tails after a late start to the season this summer. Poor catches, increased demand out of Asia and retailers taking a stronger positionon the markethave resulted in a firm undertone.this trend continued through the holidays and is expected to remain firm until new season suppliesstart to arrive in July. The WW tails in the 6 and 8 oz sizes might bea viableoptionto the lack of larger N Atl tails but costs are a trade off as both species report a firmmarket and overall lack of supply.

Seafood Crab Snow Crab: The global shortage of snow crab has continued through the fall.alaska did announce their recent findings on their biomass survey of the Bering sea and the resultsare favorable for more quotafor this regioncome this winter.the survey showed a 60 percent boost in market sized males and nearly the same for females. However..many are predicting a largereduction in the snowcrab quota out of Newfoundland come spring. This will outweighany increase out of Alaska and in the end, snow crab is still expected to be short. To date prices have leveled off on Canadian crabon the larger 8 and 10 up products withlimited offerings. However the5/8 size hassoftened someas processors and brokers look at moving off the balance of their inventory prior to new season.. King Crab: This market has remained unchanged in regardto supply Allking crab sizes remain tight, especially on 14/17 ct, 16/20 ct and 20/+ ct. Thesethree sizes haveseen the biggest issue with availability and as a result costs are firm.we do not expect any relief on supply for months, possibly even through summer 2019as the recentannouncement outof Alaska was not positive. For red king crab at the eastern portion of the Bering Sea more commonly called Bristol Bay, numbers of mature males dropped more than 40 percent from last year and mature females were down 54 percent. Buyers need to consider gold king crab as a viable optionfor the 2019 season. Note howeverdue to the lack of overallsupply for reds the costs of golds are starting to increase as well. Red Swimming Crab: A new 10% tariff on all seafood items should go into effect in August. The market is still uncertain however, between high market prices, and limited supply, cost might go up. This coupled with the void in the market on red swimming crab only strengthens this possibility. We are still expected to start receiving shipments on red crab in October. The main crab harvest is October December. Blue Swimming Crab:

Prices are still high with great inventory. There has been a slight decrease in pricing from Indonesia while Philippines and India move up to be more in line with Indo. For the next 60-90 days prices will stay level to a possible dip however, Q4 is expected to pick back up. With the red swimming still high with limited supply, this too drives the price up. Overall prices will come down a bit. Seafood Scallops The scallop marketas of late has taken some significantincreases on the larger U- 10, U-12 and 10-20 ct sizes. Strong demandhas impactedcost and these are expected to remain elevated at least until after Feb as manystartto to move off any 2018 inventory in preparation for the startof the 2019 spring season.for now expect firming prices and adequate supply. Chinese Flounder and Ocean Perch: 10% tariff duty has been applied. The possible added 15% has now been pushed back to the beginning of March when the Trumpadministration will decideon a final ruling.