J. Natn. Sci. Coun. Sri Lanka 1991 19 (1) : 53-62 FISHERY AND POPULATION DYNAMICS OF PANULIRUS HOMARUS (LINNAEUS) FROM MUTWAL, SRI LANKA. S. J. C. JAYAWICKREMA National Aquatic Resources Agency, Crow Island, Mattakkuliya, Colombo 15, Sri Lab. (Date of receipt : 05 July 1990) (Date of acceptance : 18 April 1991) Abstract: The spiny lobsters are caught at Mutwal by bottom set gillnets operated by 17'-22' mechanised fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) boats and nonmechanised canoes and wooden crafts (theppam). The mesh sizes of these nets vary from 90 mm to 180 mm. The mean catch per unit effort (CPUE) of mechanised boats was found to be higher than those of non-mechanised crafts. The mean CPUE of FRP boats, canoes and wooden crafts showed a ratio of 4:2:1. Production was found to be higher during the inter-monsoon period than during the monsoon period. The sex ratio appears to be approximately 1:l. The percentage of ovigerous females is higher just before and after the monsoon period. The calculated natural and total mortality coefficients were I.04 and 1.08 respectively giving an exploitation rate of 0.04. 1. Introduction Spiny lobsters (Family - Palinuridae) are widely distributed in the Indian Ocean. These are the most valuable of the crustaceans in wziters around Sri Lanka, India, Malaysia, South Africa and many other regions. This fishery is very important to Sri Lanka as it is a very good export earner. Spiny lobsters are exported mainly to Japan, France and the U.S.A. Six species of spiny lobsters have been recorded from Sri Lankan waters4 Out of these Panulirus hoinarus (Linnaeus), P. ornatus (Fabricius), P. versicolor (Latrielle) and P. peizicilliatus (Olivier) are caught off the waters at Mutwal. P. homarus forms the major constituent. The biology and the fishery of spiny lobsters have been described from many parts of the world as for exam le from haila and," ~ritain,'~ USA? Australia,13 yemen'' and Sri LanI~a.'",~.~~De Bruin studied the capture methods, ecology and distribution while Jayakody & Kensler described the fishery in the Southern coast of Sri Lanka. The present study deals with the fishery and some biological aspects such as sex ratio and population parameters such as asymptotic length (LQ), growth constant (K.), total mortality (Z), natural mortality (M) and the explo~tation rate (E) of P. homarus population from Mutwal, with the aim of understanding the status of the fishery of this stock of P. homarus.
2. Experimental The spiny lobsters are caught at Mutwal (Figure 1) by bottom set gillnets with mesh sizes ranging from 90 mm to 180 mm stretched mesh. These are operated in the same area by 17'-22' FRP boats powered by 6-25 HP out-board engines and non-mechanised canoes and wooden crafts made out of logs which are tied together (theppam). Most of the crafts take an average of 10 net pieces, each piece with a length of 1000-1500 meshes. The net is set in the evening and collected on the following morning. y Mutwol Cot om Fishery harbour Figure 1: Map of Sri Lqka showing the Mutwal fishery harbour.
Fishery of P. Homarus from Mutwal 55 This study is based on the data collected between January to December 1985. The landing site at Mutwal was visited once a week and the catch by weight of each species from different crafts was recorded. The total length to the nearest millimeter, sex and the maturity stage were recorded for all the available spiny lobsters. Monthly length frequency distribution was prepared by pooling length data for each month and grouping them into 1 cm length classes. The null hypothesis,: that the sexes are equally distributed, was tested by the log-likelihood ratio test.15 - The breeding cycle of female P. homarus was studied by calculating the percentage of ovigerous females among total number of females, for different months. The length frequency data were analysed using ELEFAN 0, 1 and 2 programs2 performed in an Apple I1 e micro-computer, to estimate the asymptotic length (L,), growth constant (K), total mortality (2) and the selectivity pattern. The theoretical age of fish when length is zero (to) was estimated using the formula9 : loglo (-to) = - 0.3922-0.2752 loglo L, - 1.038 loglo K (1) The natural mortality (M) was calculated using the formula (2) given below, taking the mean annual environmental temperature (T) as 28.S C. loglo M = - 0.0066-0.279 loglo La + 0.6543 loglo K + 0.4634 loglo T (2). The fishing mortality (F) was calculated from the relationship Z = F + M and the exploitation rate (E) was then determined. Where, 3.1 Fishery 3. Results Of the four species of spiny lobsters caught at Mutwal P. homarus contributed to 92% of the total lobster landings during the study period (Table 1). Table 1 : Weight of different species of spiny lobsters caught at Mutwal during 1985. Species P. lzomarus P. omatus P. versicolor P. penicilliatus Total weight (kg) % by weight 11928 92
S J. C. Jayawickrerna J F M A M J J A S O N D Figure 2: Variation of estimated total monthly production (kg) of P. Izot7~u1u.s by different crafts for 1985. The estimated total monthly production shows a peak in April (Figure 2) for FRP boats and canoes. For wooden crafts (theppams) the peak is in the month of January which is associated with an increase in the number of craft. In this case too, the estimated total monthly production was very high in April. But as a whole the catches decreased rapidly during the period of South-west monsoon. The mean CPUE for mechanised FRP boats, canoes and wooden crafts for the months fished are 1.72 kg, 0.81 kg, and 0.44 kg respectively showing a ratio of 4:2: 1 (Table 2). 3.2 Sex Ratio The results of the log-likelihood ratio test are given in Table 3: It can be concluded that both sexes are equally distributed. 3.3 Breeding Cycle. The percentage of ovigerous females is higher. just before and after the monsoon period which is from April to August (Table 4).
Fishery of P. Homarusfrorn Mutwal 57 Table 2 : The monthly variation of estimated production and effort for P. homarus from Mutwal by different gear types. Month FRP boats Canoes Wooden crafts Reduction Effon Production Effort Production EfIort (kg) @oat days) Wg) @oatdays) (kg) (boat days) January February March April May June July August September October November December 3.4 Growth and Mortality Paramaters The following values for La and K were obtained from the ELEFAN 1B program for the length frequency data of P. homarus. L, = 28.7 cm (Total length) K = 0.43Near E S,P - = 0.315 ASP The best growth curve points based on these La and K values were plotted on a sequentially arranged length frequency distribution (Figure 3). The to value was found to be 0.38 yrs. The length converted catch curve (Figure 4) gave a value of 1.08 for total mortality. The natural mortality was found to be 1.04 and hence a fishing mortality of 0.04. Therefore the exploitation rate was calculated as 0.04. The results of the selectivity pattern obtained based on the catch curve are as follows : Lmh = 11.5 cm., LC = 14;7 cm., L' = 16.5 cm. Where, L, = Length at first capture LC = Length at 50% probability of capture L' = Length at complete recruitment to the fishery
S. J. C. Jayawickrerna Lawh- (cn Figure 3: Length frequency distribution of P. homarus during 1985. with growth curves fitted by ELEFAN.IBL
Fishery ojp. Homnrus fiom Mcctwnl 3 - L 5 a.6 2-4 "3 6 I e I - a \ Z -2 $ S 0- Q4 I I 2 I Relat~ve age ( Years) -I - Figure 4: Length converted catch curve for P. homarus based on growth parameters estimated by ELEFAN 2 A.
60 S. J. C. Jayawickrema 4. Discussion Of the four species of spiny lobsters caught at Mutwa1,F'. homarus is the major constituent, contributing to 92% by weight. Although the monsoon period is the peak season for the lobster fishery in the western part of haila and," the monsoon period seems to be the lean period for the lobster fishery at Mutwal. A similar pattern had been reported earlier by de ruin^ and Jayakody & ~ensler' for the Sri Lankan lobster fishery. This variation in catch is possibly due either to the fact that crafts cannot be operated successfully in the rough seas during the monsoon period or because only few crafts operate during this time. The results indicate that the sex ratio of P. homarus is approximately 1:l. This agrees with the resu1,ts of other author^.^^^"^ The maximum percentage of ovigerous females was observed in September. According to de ruin^ the number of egg bearers are very low during the monsoon period which is confirmed by the present study. Published information on growth parameters of P. homarus stocks of Sri Lankan waters is not available. But a value 22.5 cm (tail length) has been recorded for P. homarus as asymptotic size from yemen.i2 The asymptotic size recorded in the present study is 28.7 cm (total length). When a regression of tail length and total length was carried out to find out the relationship between these two for comparison, a tail length of 22.7 cm corresponded to 36.8 cm. in total length (r = 0.98). Therefore the asymptotic size recorded in the present study seems to be very low. The largest specimen recorded from Mufwal was 28.5 cm (Total length). Jayakody and ~ensler' reported a maximum total length of 28.7 cm. As specimens having a total length as high as 36 cm have not been reported in Sri Lanka, the asymptotic size of 28.7 cma(total length) seems acceptable for Sri Lankan waters. Sanders and ~ ouhlec reported an annual growth constant of 0.45 for P. homorus from Yemen which is little higher than the -present value. The natural mortality coefficient is highe; than the value reported for P. homarus from Yemen.12 This may be attributed to the fact thacthe mean annual enviornmental temperature of Sri Lankan waters (28.5"C) is higher than that in Yemen, which has been taken as between 20 C-25 C. According to the empirical formula of Pauly,l0 which was used to calculate the natural mortality, a lower value of L, results in a higher value of M. Beverton and ~ o lsuggest t ~ that the M/K should lie in the range of 1.5-2.5. In this study a M/K value of 2.42 has been recorded which agrees with the suggestion of Beverton and Holt. The total mortality value and hence the exploitation rate seems to be very low at Mutwal. This low exploitation rate is to be expected for this lobster fishery because lobsters do not form the Main constituent of the bottom set gillnet fishery at Mutwal. The lobster exports however, bring a high amount of foreign exchange to the country. Since the exploitation rate is very low, the lobster fishery can be further expanded in Mutwal. However, neccessary steps should be taken to monitor and manage the fishery so as to prevent the fishing
Fishery of P. Hornarus from Mutwal 61 of under sized individuals and berried females. With proper management measures a further expansion af this fishery, within sustainable limits, can be recommended. Acknowledgements I would like to thank the Director General, National Aquatic Resources Agency (NARA) of Sri Lanka for providing me facilities to carry out this study. I am also thankful to the technical staff of NARA for assisting me-in collecting data and my colleagues, who helped me in various ways during the preparation of this paper. Table 3 : Results of the log-likelihood ratio test for P. hornarus from Mutwal in 1985. (d.f. = 1, critical value = 3.841 (P = 0.05) = 6.635 (P = 0.01) Month January February March April May June July August' September October November December TOTAL Value 0 0.008 ~. 4.89 0.017 9.7. 0.25 1.33 8.49 1.73 6.25 0.58 5.47 Probability P > 0.05 P > 0.05 P> 0.05 0.05 >. P > 0.01 P >.0.05 P> 0.01 P > 0.05 P > 0.05 P< 0.01 P> 0.05. 0.05 > P > 0.01 P> 0.05 0.05 > P > 0.01.
62 S. J. C. Jayawickrema Table 4 : Percentage of ovigerous females found among the female P. homarus from Mutwal during 1985. Month January. February March April May June July August September October November December No. of females % of ovigerou females References 1. BEVERTON, R.J.H. & HOLT, S.J. (1959) A review of the lifespans and mortality rates of fish in nature and their relation to growth and other physiological characteristics. Cibn Forirrrl. Colloq. on Ageirlg 142-180. 2. BREY, T. & PAULY, D. (1986) Electronic Length Frequency Analysis. A revised and Expanded User's Guide to ELEFAN 0, 1 and 2. Berichte aus dem Institute Fur Meereskunde an der Christian - Albrechts - Universitat, Kiel. 149: 1-50. 3. DE BRUIN, G.H.P. (1960) Bull. Fish. Res. Strt. Ceylor~ 9: 1-18. 4. DE BRUIN, G.H.P. (1962) Bull. Fislt. Res. SIN. Ceylon 14: 1-28. 5. DE BRUIN, G.H.P. (1969) Bull. Fish. Res. Stn. Ceylon 21 (1): 33-34. 6. DE BRUIN, G.H.P. (1970) Bull. Fislt. Res. Stir Ceylo~t 21 (1): 33-34. 7. GREGORY, D.R. (Jr.)., LABISKY, R.F. &COMBS, C.L. (1982) Reproductive dynamics of spiny lobster Pnrtulirurargus in South Florida. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society. 111: 575-584. 8. JAYAKODY, D.S. & KENSLER, C.B. (1986) Proc. Sri Lanko Assoc. Adv. Sci. 42 : 1 I. 9. PAULY, D. (1979) Theory and management of ropical multispecies stocks: a review, with emphasis on the Southeast ~ s i k demersal fisheries. ICLARM Studies and Reviebr-s 1:35p. International Centre for Living Aquatic Resources Management, Manila, Philippines.., 10. PAULY, D. (1980) Qn the Interrelationships between natural mortality, growth parameters and mean enviornmental temperature in 175 fish stocks. J. Con., Coils. lilt. Explor. Mer. 39 (3) : 175-192... 11. RONGMUANGSART, S. & LUVIRA, 0. (1973) Pltuket Marine Biological Center Research Bulletbr 2:22p. 12. SANDERS, M.J. & BOUHLEL, M. (1984) Stock assessment of the rock lobster (Panulir~rs I~ornarus) inhabiting the coastal waters of the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen. FA0 of the United Nations. RAB/S1/002RI : 67p. 13. SHEARD, K. (1949) Coinmonwealtlr. Sci. Ifrd. Res. Org. Austr. Bull. 247: 1-45. 14. THOMAS, H.J. (1985) J. Cons., Cofrs. lilt. Explor. Mer. 24 (1) : 147-154. 15. ZAR, J.H. (1974) Biostatisticd Analysis. Prentice Hall. Inc. Engleweod Cliffs, NJ. : 620p.