SDDOT I-29 Exit 77 (41 st Street) Interchange Study and Environmental Assessment Carolyn Avenue Landowners Meeting Minutes Meeting Minutes Project: Subject: I-29 Exit 77 (41 st Street) Interchange Study and Environmental Assessment Carolyn Avenue Landowners Date: Tuesday, August 30, 2016 Location: Attendees: Kuehn Community Center Matt Campbell My Place Hotel Rick Lessatell McDonald s Bob Fischer Fryn Pan Dave Stukel Fryn Pan Chuck Gustafson Pizza Hut Jim Walden Walden Carpet Rickesh Patel Red Rock Inn Tom Morris LaQuinta Inn Shannon Ausen City of Sioux Falls Travis Dressen - SDDOT Jason Kjenstad, James Unruh (HDR) 1. Introduction and overview items by Jason Kjenstad 1.1 PowerPoint slides of I-29/41 st Street overall project (see ) 1.2 Animation of Diverging Diamond interchange 1.3 Video of 57 th Street/Western Avenue traffic with u-turn movements 1.4 Review of 41 st Street/Carolyn Avenue graphics with traffic volumes and crashes (see Attachment 2) 2. Discussion on 41 st Street improvements (see Attachment 3) 2.1 Proposed lane widths on 41 st Street will be 11 versus the existing 12 width; most new or reconstructed streets in urban settings are utilizing 11 lane widths to reduce costs and property impacts. SDDOT and the City have not seen any drawbacks to the narrower lane widths. Streets that are narrower than 11 do experience traffic and crash problems; an example of this is Hwy212 in Watertown. 2.2 August 28, 2015 rainfall event cause flooding at several properties in this area. Drainage items for any I-29/41 st Street improvements will be designed based on SDDOT and City of Sioux Falls drainage design standards. 2.3 Left-turning traffic at the 41 st Street/Carolyn Avenue intersection is a major safety problem; this movement will be eliminated with a center raised median for any I-29 interchange improvements. In general, the landowners recognized the safety concerns of the existing 41 st Street/Carolyn Avenue intersection. 2.4 The proposed raised median on 41 st Street is acceptable with the 3/4 movement allowance at the W. Empire Place entrance. This will allow left-in and u-turn movements for eastbound 41 st Street traffic wanting to get to the BP gas station, Fryn Pan Restaurant, Red Rock Inn with all of the Carolyn Avenue alternatives. 2.5 At W. Empire Place, a traffic signal will only be needed for eastbound 41 st Street traffic to allow left-turning traffic into the Empire Mall. 2.6 It was recommended that the 41 st Street eastbound left turn lane at the W. Empire Place driveway be extended as far as practical to allow for vehicle stacking. 2.7 The 41 st Street/Shirley Avenue intersection will be expanded which will make it more attractive for drivers to get to and from the Carolyn Avenue business via Shirley Avenue and then 38 th Street or 34 th Street. hdrinc.com 6300 S. Old Village Place, Suite 100, Sioux Falls, SD 57108-2102 (605) 977-7740 Page 1 of 2
SDDOT I-29 Exit 77 (41 st Street) Interchange Study and Environmental Assessment Carolyn Avenue Landowners Meeting Minutes 3. Discussion on Carolyn Avenue access alternatives 1 to 5 (see Attachment 3) 3.1 Alternative 1 (Right-in/right-out at 41 st and Carolyn) 3.1.1 This alternative was considered by the landowners in attendance as the least disruptive to Carolyn Avenue businesses from an access perspective. 3.1.2 The main problem with this alternative is that traffic turning right from Carolyn Avenue will be trapped in the turn lane going onto the I-29 northbound ramp. The 35 separation distance between Carolyn Avenue and the I-29 ramp is not adequate for traffic to shift to a westbound through lane. Therefore the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) has previously stated that this alternative will not be approved. 3.2 Alternative 2 (Right-in/right-out at 41 st and Carolyn with back access roadway through Red Rock Inn) 3.2.1 Realignment of Carolyn Avenue is necessary to provide FHWA required 100 separation to the I-29 ramp for traffic turning right from Carolyn Avenue onto 41 st Street. 3.2.2 Acquisition of the Red Rock Inn property would be necessary with this alternative. 3.2.3 Back access roadway was not seen as a benefit to the owners along 41 st Street represented at the meeting. 3.3 Alternative 3 (Right-in only at 41 st and Carolyn) 3.3.1 Adequate signing plan would be necessary to direct drivers to 38 th Street or 34 th Street from Carolyn Avenue. 3.3.2 Although the 82 separation distance from the I-29 northbound on-ramp to Carolyn Avenue does not meet the FHWA-required 100 separation distance, reconsideration could be requested because there would be no right-turning traffic from Carolyn Avenue to westbound 41 st Street. 3.3.3 It was noted by owners of the Red Rock Inn and My Place Hotel that more than 50% of their hotel guests utilize reservations and therefore would be able to plan their route to the their destination. 3.3.4 Most of the landowners in attendance considered this alternative as the most acceptable of the 5 alternatives reviewed because: The Red Rock Inn property is preserved Access to and from businesses along 41 st Street and Carolyn Avenue is considered reasonably adequate. 3.4 Alternative 4 (Cul-de-sac at south end of Carolyn Avenue) 3.4.1 Acquisition of the Pizza Hut property would be necessary with this alternative. 3.4.2 The cul-de-sac is necessary to allow for turnaround of emergency vehicles. 3.4.3 A concern with this alternative to the landowners was that the Red Rock Inn and BP lots would be become cut-through routes for Carolyn Avenue traffic attempting to get to 41 st Street. 3.5 Alternative 5 (Close Carolyn Avenue at 41 st Street with back access roadway through Red Rock Inn) 3.5.1 Most business owners did not favor this alternative because of the necessary acquisition of the Red Rock Inn. 3.5.2 Benefits of the back access roadway are considered minimal. 3.6 Next steps: 3.6.1 HDR and City to meet separately with the BP gas station owner to review the Carolyn Avenue access alternatives. 3.6.2 HDR, City, and SDDOT will request FHWA reconsideration and approval of Alternative 3. hdrinc.com 6300 S. Old Village Place, Suite 100, Sioux Falls, SD 57108-2102 (605) 977-7740 Page 2 of 2
I-29 Exit 77 (41 st Street) Interchange Study and Environmental Assessment PL0100(84) 3616 P, PCN 05MH IM0293(A6)77 3014 N, PCN 03RA Carolyn Avenue Access Discussion August 30 th, 2016 IM0293(A6)77 3011 N, PCN 03RA IM0293(A6)77 3145 N, PCN 03RA 2014 HDR, all rights reserved. 41 st Street Project Responsible Agencies City of Sioux Falls South Dakota Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration Metropolitan Planning Organization Lead Design Consultant HDR Attending Today Aug 30 th, 2016 James Unruh HDR Jason Kjenstad HDR Travis Dressen SDDOT Shannon Ausen City Same team as 2011/2012 Corridor Study Project Team 1
Study Roadway Purpose of Corridor Study: Identify traffic, safety, access problems Identify potential improvement options Develop approximate construction costs Prioritize construction timeframe 34 th St Kiwanis Ave 41 st Street Valley View Road Louise Ave 49 th St Location Map 2011/2012 Corridor Study 41 st Street - Marion Rd to Shirley Ave 2016-2017 Environmental Assessment 2023 construction (tentative) Location Map 2016 Projects 2
We developed alternatives in the 2011/2012 Corridor Study. We can add more alternatives, if necessary. Recommend a Preferred Alternative (March 2017) Environmental Assessment Same as 2011/2012 Corridor Study 3 lanes on 41 st St in each direction 41 st /Marion Rd intersection would be similar to 12 th /Marion Rd intersection 41 st Street Improvement Alternatives Marion Road to I-29 3
Empire Mall 41 st Street Improvement Alternatives I-29 Interchange Same as 2011/2012 Corridor Study I-29/41 st Street Improvement Alternatives Single Point Interchange 4
Same as 2011/2012 Corridor Study At least 60 DDI built in USA DDI good for left turning traffic I-29/41 st Street Improvement Alternatives Diverging Diamond Interchange Shirley Ave revisions from 2011/2012 Corridor Study Louise Ave intersection not included 41 st Street Improvement Alternatives I-29 to east of Shirley Avenue 5
Same 5 alternatives as 2011/2012 Corridor Study May add another alternative We will Discuss Today!!! 41 st Street Improvement Alternatives At Carolyn Avenue 2012-2015 Pavement and concrete joint rehabilitation Identify funding and year of construction 2016 Begin Environmental Assessment Hold 2 public meetings Hold 2 sets of landowner meetings 2017 2018-2019 2019-2022 Hold 1 public meeting Release Environmental Assessment Recommend preferred alternative Select preferred alternative Finalize environmental approvals and permits Prepare detailed design plans Purpose of public and landowner meetings is to: Provide you with project information Receive your feedback on the project 2023 Begin construction (pending funding availability); no-build alternative would include replacing 41 st Street pavement. Project Schedule 6
STUDY INFORMATION 41 ST STREET PROJECT SDDOT Project Manager Steve Gramm, PE Project Development, Data Analysis Engineer Steve.gramm@state.sd.us Phone: 605-773-6641 Study Website www.41ststudy.com City of Sioux Falls Project Manager Shannon Ausen, PE Traffic Engineering Division sausen@siouxfalls.org Phone: 605-367-8607 CONSULTANT Team Project Manager James Unruh, PE HDR Engineering, Sioux Falls James.Unruh@hdrinc.com Phone: 605-977-7740 7
26th Street 21,900 23,500 SCALE IN FEET 0 250 500 Century Theatre Domino's Legend 27,300 Daily Traffic Volume (2004-2009 average) Carnavale Cracker Barrel 27,300 Daily Traffic Volume (2011-2015 average) Outback River Plaza Get-n-Go Post Office Signalized Intersection Access Easement Hampton Inn Swenson Dr. Slumberland Holiday Inn Express 18,840 Culvers 21,760 Big Sioux River Staybridge Suites Foley's Home Depot SF Fed Credit Union 6000 MS Society 5840 the Vault Star Perf. Buffalo Wild Wings 18,500 20,320 18,900 HOM 20,320 I-29 Brick Co. Sturdevants Northern Tool Agan Drywall Sonic 2200 Harold's Stucco & Stone Showroom 34th Street 3700 Chevy's Abra Michaels INTERSTATE 29 Rainbow Carolyn Avenue Menards Empire Transmission Shirley Avenue Sams 24,980 23,200 Microtel Inn 38th Street Bridal Gallery Radco 2797 2700 Walden Carpets Strip M al Savers 8160 7600 Wal-Mart Xcite Family Fun Scarlett O'Hara's Comfort Suites Dashboard Elec. Louise Avenue 8000 8800 9000 8600 31,280 29,100 Pizza Hut 4469 2200 Comfort Inn Red Rock Inn Fryn' Pan 32,660 28,460 bp Gas Best Western Super 8 Davids Bridal McDonalds 41st Street Chili's Arby's 30,480 27,600 Barnes & Noble Drawn By: Date: Chked By: Date: Revision: 1/30/12 1/30/12 B.Miller J.Unruh 8/30/16 Existing Conditions - 41st St to 26th St Carolyn Avenue Access Analysis I-29 Exit 77 (41st Street) Interchange Modification Study Sioux Falls, SD 8/30/16 Carolyn Avenue Landowners Mtg Attachment 2 Figure 1
Scarlett O'Hara's Comfort Suites Dashboard Elec. Carolyn Avenue Legend Access Easement 0 SCALE IN FEET 50 100 Direction of Vehicle Comfort Inn Existing Right-of-Way AM PM Existing Peak Hour Traffic Volumes Signalized Intersection Golf USA 4/30/2007 Date of Traffic Count 27,300 Daily Traffic Volume (2004-2009 average) 27,300 Daily Traffic Volume (2011-2015 average) I-29 NB on-ramp Red Rock Inn Fryn' Pan 2007 to 2009 2010 to 2015 15 38 bp Gas Pizza Hut 22 35 4 41 2 75 Arrows depict type of crash, not the direction of traffic. 32,660 28,460 41st Street 4/30/2007 108 16 37 8 I-29 NB off-ramp 60 62 31 82 14161388 641 1980 3/10/2016 65 14 49 14 58 128 51 63 14101318 560 1849 Drawn By: Date: Chked By: Date: Revision: 1/30/12 1/30/12 B.Miller J.Unruh 8/30/16 Existing Conditions at 41st St / Carolyn Ave Carolyn Avenue Access Analysis I-29 Exit 77 (41st Street) Interchange Modification Study Sioux Falls, SD 8/30/16 Carolyn Avenue Landowners Mtg Attachment 2 Figure 2