NOAA Fisheries Effects of Changing Ocean Conditions on Marine Food Webs, Salmon and Other Things Bill Peterson Oceanographer and Senior Scientist Northwest Fisheries Science Center Newport OR 1
Local winds drive currents and cause upwelling along the coasts of Washington, Oregon and California
We are contributing to salmon management by studying the ocean Large phase scale forces of their acting life at history the and by developing outlooks local scale can influence biological on future process adult important returns for salmon based on a suite of physical, biological and ecological indicators of ocean conditions Alaska PDO and NPGO British Columbia 65N 60 55 50 TOP-DOWN PROCESSES Local Conditions Upwelling Spring Transition Coastal currents ENSO U.S.A. 45 40 35 30 25 170 W 160 150 140 130 120 110 Our work is an example of one (of several) ways of taking an ecosystem approach to management BOTTOM-UP PROCESSES Local Biological Conditions: The Food Chain
North Pacific SST patterns and the Pacific Decadal Oscillation Blue is anomalously cold water Red is anomalously warm water The PDO refers to the spatial pattern of SST variability. It has two phases, negative and positive. SST anomaly patterns result from winds blowing across the eastern North Pacific Ocean: W ly and NW ly [negative phase] and SW ly [positive phase].
PDO Index (sum of May-Sept) PDO: May-Sep Average, 1925-2015 Recall that red = warm water off our coast; blue = cold water off our coast 15 10 5 0-5 -10 Warm Regime Cool Regime Warm Regime C W C W -15 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 From 1925-1998, PDO shifted every 20-30 years. Some refer to these as salmon regimes (cool) and sardine regimes (warm). Warming during the 1990s led to the listing of many salmon as threatened or endangered. There have been four shifts of 4-5 years duration recently: 1999-2002, 2003-2007, 2008-2013, and now 2014-, thus we have a natural experiment to test the affects of PDO on marine food chains.
NOAA Fisheries What we do at Newport Long-term ocean observations from ship-board surveys, fortnightly, since 1996. Track oceanographic and ecosystem conditions Temperature, salinity, oxygen, nutrients, aragonite saturation Collect samples and enumerate to species phytoplankton, zooplankton (copepods and krill) and fish eggs/larvae With such data, we can follow the development of unusual events (Blob, El Niño, HABs) before, during and after such events. From these data we provide outlooks of the number of adult salmon returning to the Columbia and coastal rivers, 1-2 years in advance. 6
NOAA Fisheries We focus on copepods and krill because (1) they are the chief link in the food chaibetween the tiny phyto-plankton and fishes, seabirds and some whales, but also because (2) copepods are also the most abundant metazoans on the planet. Copepods and Krill
NOAA Fisheries Lipid content is perhaps the most important attribute of copepods and krill COPEPODS Omega-3 fatty acids KRILL
OCEANOGRAPHY 101: OCEAN SURFACE CURRENTS
NOAA Fisheries To understand copepod ecology (and the food chain) you need to know about local ocean circulation 1. Subarctic Coastal Currents bring cold water and large lipid-rich northern copepod species to the N. California Current; (Cheeseburgers) 2. A weak California Current and/or onshore flow of the West Wind Drift brings warm subtropical water and small lipid-poor subtropical southern copepods to the NCC (Celery) 3. Therefore, bioenergetics of the food chain is affected by the source waters which feed the Calif. Current
What has been going on over the past three years? Blob begins to form in Nov 2013 Sea surface temperature anomalies of + 4 C in large regions of the North Pacific By July 2015, an el Niño event was firmly established at the equator.
NOAA Fisheries Daily sea surface temperatures anomalies at the NOAA Buoy 20 miles off Newport: Jan 2013 May 2016 6 4 SST NOAA 20 miles off Newport 14 Sep 14 SST Anomaly 2 0-2 -4 Aug-Sep 2013-6 Jan Jul Jan Jul Jan Jul Jan Jul 2013 2014 2015 2016 14 Sep 14 N ly winds weakened, the Blob came onshore and SST jumped 6 C in 5 hr Summer 2015: strongest N ly winds in 20 years but minimal signature in SST ; May 2016: Still warm although N ly winds starting to cool the coastal waters a bit
PDO, ONI (upper) and Northern Copepods (lower) PDO & ONI 3 2 1 0-1 -2 PDO and ONI Warm Cold -3 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0-0.5-1.0-1.5 Northern Copepod Anomaly Lipid-rich Lipid-poor 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 Think of the PDO and ONI as measures of temperature anomalies: Blue is cold water (= GOOD); Red is warm water (= BAD). When the ocean is cold, cold-water/lipid rich copepods dominate. 13
NOAA Fisheries PDO & ONI (upper) and Copepod Species Richness (lower) PDO (colors) and ONI (line) Copepod Species Richness Anomaly 4 3 2 1 0-1 -2-3 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 12 10 8 6 4 2 0-2 -4-6 -8 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 YEAR Greater species diversity when PDO is positive because subtropical water is transported to coastal waters off Oregon at such times --diversity is naturally higher in these waters (and the tropics in general). Twice as many species in 2015 suggesting different origin of warm source waters
NOAA Fisheries Biomass of two krill species and abundance of doliolids off Newport Euphausia pacifica have been on a downward trend since 2008, but extremely low in 2015. Thysanoessa spinifera are abundant only when the ocean is in cool phase. Doliolids are indicators of oligotrophic ( blue water ) ocean conditions [purple water on the beach]
The 2015 Pseudo-nitzschia (PN) bloom Wide-spread from CA to Alaska Long duration (April-October) Very toxic domoic acid, a neurotoxin Synchronous throughout west coast (indicating a response to a common coast-wide trigger) From end of April 2015, increasing PN cells at Newport; May 14th, entire Oregon coast closed to razor clamming; In early May, high levels of DA detected in Monterey Bay along with high concentrations of PN cells. In early May, increasing PN cell concentration also seen on Washington coastal beaches, razor clamming closed. Closure of Dungeness Crab harvest in December 2015 We usually get toxic P-n blooms when the PDO is positive; for the 2015 bloom we think that the Blob was the common trigger.
May 19 June 28 Aug 26 Xiuning Du
PDO Anomaly of number of adults returning to spawn (thousands) OPIH coho survival (%) 15 Pacific Decadal Oscillation 10 5 0-5 -10 300 200 100 0-100 600 400 200 0-200 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Spring Chinook Salmon 116,245 average count Fall Chinook salmon 262,358 average count 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Coho salmon 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Adult Chinook salmon counts at Bonneville Dam and coho OPIH compared to the PDO since 1965 Note that from 1976 through 1997, PDO was positive. Poor salmon returns (blue bars) are related to positive PDO (red bars) but with a 1 to 3 year lag (a function of how many years they spend at sea). Since 1998, PDO has been oscillating every 5 years as have Chinook salmon returns. Coho returns have been on a downward trend since 2009. Spring Chinook run is average this year
NOAA Fisheries Impacts of the Blob on Fisheries For salmon, early indicators are not good: Coho salmon that went to sea in spring 2014 returned in fall 2015 at one of the lowest rates since the 1998 El Niño For spring Chinook that went to sea in spring 2014, a total of 137,176 adults returned. This is just a bit above average. For salmon that went to sea in 2015 (the year of even worse ocean conditions), we will not know how runs were impacted until autumn 2016 for coho, and until spring 2017 for Columbia River spring Chinook, and until fall 2018 for Columbia River and Sacramento River fall Chinook. Sockeye returns in summer 2015 failed due to warm Columbia River Hake (whiting) harvest in 2015 poor Opening of Dungeness Crab fishery of OR and WA delayed until Jan 2016 due to the massive harmful algal bloom which impacted local economy in December; fishery just now (in May) opening in California. Shrimp fishery this year doing poorly
Other effects of warm water on Pacific salmon in 2015 Washington, Oregon: - Puget Sound coho returns extremely low, very small-bodied Alaska - Alaskan sockeye had average adult numbers but extremely small bodied (smallest in >20 yrs) Fraser River - Sockeye and pink half the number expected - Adult coho returns low and small body size Columbia River - Adult fall Chinook and sockeye returns extremely high but sockeye suffered huge in-river mortality - Coho returns low
NOAA Fisheries Expectations for 2016 Copepod species richness is still very high The food chain is still dominated by small, warm water, lipid-poor copepods. In the past there has been a 4-6 month lag between change in sign of the PDO and the appearance of a different copepod community. Given that the PDO is now in an extremely positive state, it is highly unlikely that the food chain will transition to a cold-water lipid-rich state until next year. What about the Monster El Niño event? SSTs are still very warm. Will the El Niño ever get here? Was it here and now gone? Given that the food chain has been in a lipid-depleted state for 20 months (since September 2014) and is not showing any signs of improving, will we one day conclude that the Blob + El Niño gave rise to an environmental disaster?
So.how do we come up with forecasts or outlooks of salmon returns?
Stoplight Chart 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 PDO-Wi 16 6 3 12 7 17 11 15 13 9 5 1 14 4 2 8 10 18 PDO-su 10 4 6 5 11 15 14 16 12 13 2 9 7 3 1 8 17 18 ONI 18 1 1 6 12 14 13 15 8 11 3 10 16 4 5 7 9 17 46050 15 8 3 4 1 7 18 14 5 16 2 9 6 10 11 12 13 17 T-20 Wi 17 11 8 10 6 14 15 12 13 5 1 9 16 4 3 7 2 18 T-20 Su 14 11 13 4 1 3 18 16 7 8 2 5 12 10 6 15 17 9 Deep T 18 6 8 4 1 9 12 14 10 5 2 7 13 11 3 17 16 15 Deep S 18 3 7 4 5 14 15 8 6 1 2 11 16 10 9 13 17 12 Cope Rich 17 3 1 7 6 13 12 16 14 11 8 10 15 4 5 2 9 18 N-Cope 17 13 9 10 3 15 12 18 14 11 6 8 7 1 2 4 5 16 S-Cope 18 2 5 4 3 13 14 17 12 10 1 7 15 9 8 6 11 16 Biol Trans 17 11 6 7 8 12 10 16 15 3 1 2 14 4 9 5 13 18 Ichthyo 18 9 2 5 7 16 15 11 14 13 1 10 3 12 8 6 17 4 PDO Value 4 Rank 18 5 3 6 2 13 15 17 11 10 1 7 12 7 4 7 13 16 3 2 1 0-1 -2-3 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 Year BAD GOOD
Rank of Indicators 2014 ocean entry Spring Chinook Ranks = 115,000 PC1 = 120,000 Actual = 137,176 2015 ocean entry Coho OPIH Ranks = not significant PC1 1.5% Actual 1.3% 2015 Mean rank = 14.3
Counts of Adult Salmon at Bonneville Dam (thousands; 2 year lag) Adult Spring Chinook at Bonneville Dam 1000 800 600 400 200 500000 400000 300000 200000 100000 Fall Chinook R 2 = 0.74; p < 0.001 0-1.0-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 Northern Copepod Biomass Anomaly 0 Since 1980 r = 0.81, w/o 2013-10 -5 0 5 10 15 PDO (May-September) Pacific Decadal Oscillation OPIH Coho Survival (%; 1 year lag) Salmon vs PDO and copepods 7 6 5 4 3 2 Coho R 2 = 0.30; p = 0.02 excl. 2013, 2011* 2013 1 2011 0-1.0-0.8-0.6-0.4-0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 Northern Copepod Biomass Anomaly (Log10 May - Sept average)
NOAA Fisheries Brief Summary To understand what is meant by the term ocean conditions, you need to know ocean currents: where did the water and plankton come from, and why? If water comes from the north = cheeseburgers If water comes from the south or offshore = celery, popcorn But why the different sources? Important to track changes in the food chain for at least two good reasons: Local salmon go to sea to get fat in support of their migration back home Many long distance migrators come up here each summer to feed: whiting (hake)m sardines, shearwaters, albatross, whales and when it is really warm, turtles and apparently sea snakes! 26
During a normal year, sardines and hake migrate to Oregon in spring to take advantage of the lipid-rich food chain and bountiful harvest; salmon of course migrate to the ocean at the same time for the same reasons
Other long distance migrants include: Sooty shearwaters from New Zealand Black Footed and Laysan Albatross from Hawaii Gray Whales from Mexico Humpback whales from Peru The occasional leatherback turtle from New Guinea A sea snake from central America
NOAA Fisheries Other unusual tropical critters that appeared off the OR coast in 2015: Green turtles off WA, OR and CA Opah caught off Depoe Bay Sea snakes off Los Angeles and one spotted 14 miles off Newport August 2015 Giant Ocean sunfish in the Gulf of Alaska and off OR and WA Vellella (by-the-wind sailors) Mole crabs (Emerita) and Green crabs both had extraordinarily high recruitment 29
July 2015 Things are looking up May 2016
NOAA Fisheries Our Center s webpage www.nwfsc.noaa.gov has two buttons that should be of interest: Newportal (a Blog Site) Salmon Forecasting
Funding Sources over the past 20 years
PDO Value 4 3 2 1 0-1 Pacific Decadal Oscillation PDO compared to SST -2 Monthly Temperature Anomaly -3 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 Year 6 Sea Surface Temperature Stonewall Bank Buoy 46050 4 2 0-2 -4 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 Year
Unusual sightings in 2015 7 swordfish caught along Oregon coast Humpback whales in Columbia estuary Warm water species we ve seen before but earlier or unusually abundant Thresher sharks Skinny coho & Chinook in ocean Pacific butterfish Opah caught off Oregon Coast Jack & Pac mackerel
Record numbers of CA sea lions in the Columbia and along the WA/OR coast Sea lion pups on San Miguel Island (S CA) had low weight in Dec 2014; even lower in Dec 2015! Astoria East Mooring basin
Sep Cassin s Auklet Wreck of 2014-15 {Julia Parrish} Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar 2014-15 monthly mean long-term average 8-31 beaches 2001-2015 7-36 beaches 2002-2015 7-46 beaches 2002-2015.025 2.5 5-22 beaches 2006-2015.25 25 7-26 beaches 2007-2015 3-6 beaches 2014-2015 16-37 beaches 1994-2015 Figure from Julia Parrish, UW/Fisheries data from: COASST - Neah Bay to Mendocino, BeachWatch Mendocino to San Francisco