October 13, 2016 Delegates to PHRF of the Chesapeake, The annual Board of Delegates meeting will be held on Saturday, 12 November 2016, at the Hilton Garden Inn in Fredricksburg, VA. Please contact the Secretary on the PHRF phone at or via e-mail to secretary@phrfchesbay.org no later than November 5th, if you plan to be at the meeting, so that I may inform the restaurant of the number attending. The meeting will begin promptly at 11:00am. Please arrive early and allow time to sign-in. Delegates must sign in prior to the meeting so that a quorum for voting may be determined. If you are unable to attend this year s meeting, a proxy may represent your club. You must do this in writing, and the proxy must bring a copy of the proxy assignment letter to the meeting. The letter must identify (by name) the proxy, who must also be a current member of PHRF of the Chesapeake. Clubs with five (5) or more 2016 members of PHRF are eligible to appoint delegates. Clubs having less than five (5) members are represented by the Vice President of the region in which the club is located. Please review the enclosed agenda, and proposals for the meeting. If you plan to present new proposals, or counter proposals, to those enclosed, please notify me at 757-722-7861 or via e- mail, not later than 5 November, so that you may be scheduled into the agenda. I request that you bring copies (approximately 30) of any proposals not on the enclosed agenda for the other delegates and to be published in the minutes. If you have any questions, please contact me at 757-722-7861 or via e-mail. I look forward to seeing you at this year s meeting. Steve Taylor President Steve.taylor@wartsiladefense.com Encl: Agenda and Proposals for the 2016 Annual Meeting
1030 Begin Check In 1100 Call to Order and Roll Call Agenda for 2016 Annual Board of Delegates Meeting 12 November 2016 1130 President's Report (Steve Taylor) 1140 Treasurer s Report (Bob Thomas) 2016 report 2017 budget 1200 US Sailing Report (Bruce Bingman) 1215 Chief Handicapper Reports (Randy Richter & Alan Bomar) 1225 Executive Secretary Report (Glenn Harvey) 1230 Scorer s Report 1240 LUNCH BREAK 1315 New Business: See attached proposals (Must vote on the 2017 Class Splits at this meeting) 1500 Election of Officers for 2017 1515 Appointments by 2016 President Chief Handicapper, Northern Bay Chief Handicapper, Southern Bay US Sailing Representative to Offshore Committee PHRF Representative to CBYRA Executive Secretary At Large Representatives to High Point Committee PHRF Fleet Captains 1530 Adjourn
Proposals for 2016 Annual Meeting 1. Administrative change, no vote required, effective January 1, 2017: PHRF Certificate Valid Date - For all certificates renewed prior to 4/1 of each year the valid date shall be 4/1. For all certificates renewed after 4/1 and all modified certificates the valid date shall be the date the certificate becomes effective. 2. Proposed changes to Article VI, Section 6.1 of the By-Laws: Section 6.1 The Regional Vice Presidents shall appoint two Chief Handicappers for their respective regions, to be approved by the Board of Delegates at the Annual Meeting: one from Region IV and one from the remaining regions as defined by CBYRA. If a Chief Handicapper chooses not to continue, he shall notify the President at least sixty days before the Annual Meeting. The Chief Handicappers may be Area Handicappers, but need not be. The duties of each Chief Handicapper shall be to preside at meetings of the Board of Handicappers and to make final decisions with respect to handicaps in case of irreconcilable conflict among the Board of Handicappers. A Chief Handicapper may not serve more than three yearly terms successively. The qualifications for Chief Handicapper nominees including their sailing, racing and handicapping expertise to include analytical and administrative abilities shall be provided to the Board of Delegates 30 days prior to the Annual Delegates Meeting for review and discussion prior to the Executive Board initiating a vote to accept. 3. Proposed change to Article VI, Section 6.2 of the By-Laws: Section 6.2 The Chief Handicappers shall appoint such numbers of Area Handicappers as may in their judgment be appropriate to handicap member yachts, to be approved by the Board of Delegates at the Annual Meeting. Each Area Handicapper so appointed shall be responsible for handicapping the yachts in a specific area assigned to him/her. The numbers and qualifications for Area Handicapper nominees including their sailing, racing and handicapping expertise to include analytical and administrative abilities shall be provided to the Board of Delegates 30 days prior to the Annual Delegates Meeting for review and discussion prior to the Executive Board initiating a vote to accept. 4. Proposed change to Article VI, Section 6.3 of the By-Laws: Section 6.3 The Handicappers appointed pursuant to Sections 6.1 and 6.2 shall constitute a Board of Handicappers for Region IV and a Board of Handicappers for the remaining Regions and each shall meet periodically to establish or confirm handicaps for new yachts located within their Regions, to consider old handicaps previously granted. Establishment or change of handicaps shall be by majority vote. If the Board of Handicappers shall establish two different ratings for the same kind of boat, the two Chief Handicappers shall resolve the difference, and insure the final base rating falls in the
normally prescribed rating differential. The Boards of Handicappers will provide objective evidence to the Board of Delegates describing the sources of data used in their handicapping, analytical processes followed for new yachts as well as any consideration for previously granted handicaps, basis for final determinations and verification/validation of handicaps assigned to yachts in this region. The Board of Delegates will review this information to audit the activities of the Handicappers it has empowered on behalf of the Membership of this Association. 5. Proposed change to Article VII, Section 7.1 of the By-Laws: Section 7.1 Handicaps shall be based primarily on the performance potential of yachts. A handicap assigned to a yacht of a type not previously rated may be based on any data or formula the Area Handicapper deems appropriate, including the measurements of the yacht as submitted by the yacht or comparable yachts. Base handicaps shall be in three second increments. The Boards of Handicappers will provide documentation to the Board of Delegates describing the sources of performance potential data used in their handicapping, analytical processes followed for new yachts, comparable yachts used for reference or comparison and consideration for previously granted handicaps, basis for final determinations and verification/validation of handicaps assigned to yachts in this region. 6. Proposed change to Article VII, Section 7.2 of the By-Laws: Section 7.2 Handicaps shall be assigned to yachts by the Area Handicapper for the area in which the boat is located. If a yacht is different from one previously rated by the Association, the Area Handicapper shall present the application at the next Board of Handicappers meeting, with his recommendation for a Valid Rating. If the yacht is a standard class yacht, the Area Handicapper may assign a Provisional Rating Certificate, which is valid until the next Board of Handicappers meeting or an issue of a new Provisional Rating Certificate. Handicaps may not be assigned by an Area Handicapper for a new class of boat, a one-of-a-kind boat or an Unconventional Craft until approved at a Board of Handicappers meeting. The Boards of Handicappers will provide to the Board of Delegates documentation describing the information used by the Area Handicapper as the basis for the recommended Valid or Provisional Rating of new or existing yachts. 7. Proposed change to the Introduction paragraph in the Fleet Policy: Introduction. Rating by performance handicap is a method of providing equitable time allowances for sailboats of different designs racing against each other. Numerous systems have been employed; some were methods of handicapping boats, some handicapped skippers, and some combined both systems. The increased interest in the racing of cruiser/racer type sailboats has produced the Performance Handicap Racing Fleet. Measurement-based rating formulas with the attending rapid changes in sailboats design
have turned many skippers to the performance based handicap system. Performance handicap emerges as the best assurance of continued opportunity to compete fairly against all designs, both new and old. As a result, the PHRF system, begun almost two decades ago in California, has spread to the Pacific Northwest, the Great Lakes, and the Gulf and Atlantic coasts. In 1976, PHRF was sanctioned by CBYRA. In 1981, USYRU (now US Sailing) recognized PHRF as a full committee under its Offshore Racing Council. PHRF of the Chesapeake is the largest sanctioned class in the CBYRA Handicap Division. A member of the Division Class with the largest membership Chairs the Handicap Division and represents all Handicap Racing as a voting member at monthly CBYRA Board Meetings. The President of PHRF of the Chesapeake will appoint a member to represent our class and be the communications conduit between the two organizations. 8. Proposed addition of the paragraph Participation to the Fleet Policy: Participation. In accordance with the prime objective of the PHRF of the Chesapeake, to promote the sport of handicap racing of sailing yachts for the exclusive enjoyment of its members, the President and Vice Presidents will appoint representatives to increase interest and coordinate participation. These representatives will coordinate Organizing Authority race schedules to current and prospective members and collect participation intentions to participate and suggested improvements to race events from the membership by PHRF Fleet Class. These initial quantities of interested race participants will be provided to CBYRA Organizing Authority member clubs at the earliest possible convenience to support a wide range of race event planning but no later than the January CBYRA Race Scheduling meeting for sanctioned high point events. These representatives will report monthly to the fleet s Handicap Division Representative to CBYRA, the President and Vice Presidents of PHRF of the Chesapeake on efforts to improve participation and net effects of those efforts. This information will be included in website updates for Delegates and membership to promote grass-roots participation motivation by the fleet. 9. Proposal to allow asymmetrical spinnakers to be tacked to the anchor roller support. Add sentence e to paragraph B2 of the Effects of Boat Modifications on Ratings : e) Asymmetrical spinnakers may be tacked to the anchor roller support without penalty, provided that the length of the support does not exceed 25% of J. 10. Proposal to increase the fixed propeller rating adjustments shown in paragraph F of the Effects of Boat Modifications on Ratings. Increase each credit shown in sentences 1, 2, 3 & 4 by 3 seconds.
11. Proposal to increase the rating adjustment for roller furling genoa/jibs shown in paragraph E of the Effects of Boat Modifications on Ratings. For sails constructed from woven materials with UV protection on the leech and foot, increase the adjustment from 6 seconds to 9 seconds. No increase is proposed for sails constructed of laminate materials. 12. 2017 PHRF Class Splits. The following splits are proposed for 2017. The regional delegates must vote to approve these splits, or any changes, for 2017. Region Class Proposed 2017 Splits IIIAW A0 up to 047 IIIAW A1 048 to 077 IIIAW A2 078 to 109 I, II, IIISE A Up to 109 I, II, IIIAW, IIISE B 110 to 145 I, II, IIIAW, IIISE C 146 and up IIIPR Spinnaker All IV North A Up to 109 IV North B 110 to 160 IV North C 161 and up IV South A Up to 109 IV South B 110 to 163 IV South C 164 and up All regions I-IV Sport Boat All All regions I-IV Non Spinnaker All All regions I-IV Corinthian All Election of 2017 PHRF Officers The delegates must vote to elect the officers of PHRF of the Chesapeake. The nominations provided for 2017 officers are as follows: President Marc Briere VP Region I-III TBD VP Region IV -- John Blais Secretary/Treasurer Jim Raper Appointments by 2017 President Chief Handicapper, Northern Bay Chief Handicapper, Southern Bay US Sailing Representative to US Sailing Offshore Council PHRF Representative to CBYRA Executive Secretary At large representatives to High Point committee Fleet Captains
2016 Annual Board of Delegates Meeting 12 November 2016 Amendment No. 1 Additional Proposals for the 2016 Annual Meeting 1. Proposed changes to Article VII, Section 7.3 of the By-Laws: Section 7.3 The Executive Secretary shall maintain a list of handicaps and valid certificates for yachts rated by the Board of Handicappers which shall be kept current, and sent to participating members on the Subscription List updated and made available to the Board of Handicappers, the Board of Delegates, Organizing Agencies and membership using the association website. 2. Proposed changes to Article VII, Section 7.4 of the By-Laws: Section 7.4 Each Area Handicapper shall keep a record of the performance of yachts listed in the area assigned to him and he shall make such record available to the Board of Handicappers, the Board of Delegates and membership using the association website. 3. Proposed changes to Article VII, Section 7.5 of the By-Laws: Section 7.5 Changes in handicaps shall be made whenever the results of racing or other data indicate an adjustment is necessary in order to provide equitable handicap racing. The Area Handicapper is responsible for tracking and reporting these results, the analytical process followed and the results and determinations using the association website. Any rating assigned by the Handicappers may be appealed by the member owning the yacht involved or any other member, therefore full disclosure of the basis for handicap must be maintained on the association website and be made available to all members. Appeals must be in writing and must be supported by data regarding the performance of the yacht involved and other pertinent information, as prescribed in the appeal section of the association website. 4. Proposed changes to Article VII, Section 7.7 of the By-Laws: Section 7.7 PHRF of the Chesapeake retains the right to revise, refuse, or revoke a rating certificate. Refusal or revocation of rating certificates shall not be without sufficient cause and justification. A boat found to be sailing in violation of the agreement on the current rating certificate is subject to review. Any action to refuse or revoke a rating certificate shall be based on a detailed review by an ad hoc committee, appointed by the President. The ad hoc committee shall determine any justification for such action and report their findings and recommendations to the President. The President shall present the findings of the committee to the Officers of the Association, who shall determine if any final action is required. Final action, depending on the severity of the violation, may include
refusal or revocation of the rating certificate through the remainder of the current year, or up to the end of the following year. The members of the ad hoc committee shall be chosen from the Officers, Delegates, and Handicappers of the Association representing the region in which the boat under review sails. The ad hoc committee shall include the regional Vice President, at least two (2) delegates, the regional Chief Handicapper, and the Area Handicapper familiar with the boat under review. All actions to refuse or revoke a rating certificate may be may be appealed to PHRF, after the end of the period of exclusion, by reapplication for a new valid certificate. Actions by PHRF of the Chesapeake to refuse or revoke a rating certificate shall be forwarded to CBYRA and made available including and rationale/justification to the Board of Handicappers, Board of Delegates and membership on the association website. 5. Proposed changes to Article IX, Section 9.1 of the By-Laws: Section 9.1 The President may appoint such committees as he may deem necessary or desirable to assist him/her in the performance of his/her duties or to study and report with respect to any matter relating to the purposes or business of the Association. A technical committee will review race results annually and submit its report for review by the Board of Delegates prior to the Annual Meeting. 6. Proposed addition to Article II of the By-Laws: Section 2.2 The Association will promote the sport of handicap racing of sailing yachts by following fleet policies approved and adopted by the Board of Delegates at the Annual Meeting. 7. Proposed addition to Article IV of the By-Laws: Section 4.4.2 The Board of Delegates will appoint representatives to fulfill the roles and responsibilities described in our Fleet Policies and promote participation of PHRF of the Chesapeake members in the sport of handicap racing of sailing yachts. End of Amendment No. 1
2016 Annual Board of Delegates Meeting 12 November 2016 Amendment No. 2 Additional Proposals for the 2016 Annual Meeting 1. Proposed addition to Effects of Boat Modifications on Ratings : Add paragraph K, to read as follows: K. Boats that are dry-sailed during the racing season, including frost-biting, shall receive a 3 second/mile penalty. 2. Proposed change to the 2016 High Point and PHRF Distance Series Scoring Rules and Exceptions : Change paragraph 4, item a, to read as follows: 4. Qualification for High Point awards: a. Spinnaker sections - To be considered for any High Point award, a yacht/owner must have been scored in at least five (5) sanctioned events three (3) of which that started or finished in his/her declared region. A race that transits multiple regions may be scored as a home qualifying event in any of the transited regions. Wild card races may count as one of the five qualifying events. 3. Proposed change to the 2016 High Point and PHRF Distance Series Scoring Rules and Exceptions : Change paragraph 7, to read as follows: 7. An event does not contribute to the record for High Point awards if the first yacht to finish averages less than the required speed 2.0 knots over the course to satisfy the sanctioned race s time limit. End of Amendment No. 2