AYSO Region 34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016) i
Table of Contents Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS II AYSO R34 GUIDELINES FOR ALL STAR TEAM FORMATION 1 1. Performance Evaluation 1 2. Draft Process 1 3. In case of Two Teams per Division 2 4. Coach Selection 3 5. Pulling from Alternates 4 6. General 4 ii AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016)
AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation 1. Performance Evaluation (a) All Star Formation is applicable to competitive divisions only, U10 U14. (b) Coaches will be asked to circle 2 players-of-the-game (POG) after each game of the regular season, with the suggestion of looking for both attacking and defending skills. (c) The Draft Manager (DM) and the Division Captains (DC s) will ask coaches to submit likely nominations with names and jersey numbers about 2/3 s of the way through the season. (d) The comprehensive list of nominees will be distributed to the coaches so that they can take extra care to watch for key players as the season goes into the final weeks before Beach Cup. (e) At the end of the season, each coach will be asked to rank his players. (f) The DM will create a card for each player showing coach ranking as well as scoring and POTG stats for the season. (g) Any player who did not make 2/3 s of their regular season and Beach Cup games, other than due to injury, is not eligible for All Stars. 2. Draft Process (a) The DM will schedule an All Star draft for each division which will be attended by the DC and the head coaches, as well as any other Board Member as needed. (b) The process starts with the nominees cards being laid out on the table roughly in formation of their various soccer positions. (c) At this point, coaches can start talking about various strengths and weaknesses of the nominees. (d) Any information on a player, whether good or bad, may be presented and can involve aspects other than just soccer skills, such as attendance, behavior issues, scheduling conflicts. (e) Coaches may also choose to withdraw a nominee or nominate other players from the floor. A coach can nominate from the floor a player on another coach s team. (f) Once the nomination pool is set, coaches will be asked to vote for a certain number players. (g) The DM and DC will tally the votes and announce who has made the team in that round, if any. (h) The number of votes cast for each round and the criteria for making the cut will vary depending on the number of coaches and nominees, and will be decided accordingly by the DM and DC for each round. (i) Cards for players making the cut will be pulled from the nominee pool and placed in a separate pool roughly in formation of their various soccer positions. AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016) 1
(j) The DM and DC may go right into the next round of voting or may encourage further discussion among coaches to analyze team needs and strength and weaknesses of remaining nominees. (k) As the rounds continue, the DM and DC may determine that there is clear agreement after a round of voting who has made the cut and who should be the alternates. (l) If there is not a clear consensus on the last one or two spots, them DM and DC may choose, with input from the coaches, to do any of the following: i. pull out the nominee(s) with the least votes and revote; ii. disclose to the coaches the relative votes for each remaining nominee and revote; iii. leave the last position open and allow the coach to pull from the pool of agreed upon alternates (the coach can decide later but must fill it at some point). 3. In case of Two Teams per Division (a) The RC and CA, with input from other board members and coaches as needed, will determine the number of teams that compete at the Area 1D tournament, as well as in which flight, if multiple lights are offered. In some instances, the number of teams by region is not known until late in the season. Placement into various Area flights will be based on space available at Area and ability to form competitive teams. (b) If both teams are in the same tier, the teams must be balanced, but can be formed as an A and B if one team is in each tier. (c) If balancing: i. If a division has 2 flights a. and then flights are deemed balanced, the coaches and DC may choose for each flight to conduct their own separate draft according to the Draft Process above, b. but if the flights are deemed unbalanced, the coaches and DC may choose to combine all nominees in one pool and proceed as if there was only one flight. c. If no clear consensus, simple majority vote by the coaches can be used. ii. If a division has one flight or 2 flights have been combined into one pool: a. The draft process will be conducted according to the Draft Process above, except voting will continue until there are enough players who made the cut plus alternates to form 2 teams. b. After coaches have been decided, any players affiliated with an All Star selected coach are pulled from the pool, and coaches will determine who picks first by such method as a flip of a coin. c. Coaches will then starting drafting kids from the main pool alternating one pick at a time until each coach has a full team. 2 AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016)
(d) If forming A and B teams: i. The draft process will be conducted according to the Draft Process above until the first team is completely formed with no open spots. ii. The draft process will resume for the second team and continue until there are no open slots or with one open slot left to the discretion of the coach to fill from remaining alternates. 4. Coach Selection (a) Toward the end of the season, the DC should inquire with coaches as to their interest in coaching their division s All Star team, and any interested coach should reply by completing All- Star coach application form provided by DC. (b) The coach selection committee, comprising mainly the CA and RC, along with the DC for each division, will select the coach based on the following criteria: i. Having demonstrated adherence to the AYSO philosophies, especially sportsmanship; ii. Having exemplified the values of a volunteer; iii. Having demonstrated qualities of a successful coach, which may have nothing to do with wins and losses. (c) The coach selection committee will also determine alternate coaches should the first choice decline the offer. (d) It is not a requirement that a coach have a child on the All Star team, nor is it a requirement that the coach to have been a coach during the regular season. (e) Coach s children are not guaranteed to be placed on All Star team. They must be selected for the team the same way all players are selected (as described in this document). (f) The All Star coach is not announced until the All Star draft is completed, except in the case of a two pool balanced teams, where the coaches are announced after the main pool selection, but before the final draft. (g) If a coach declines the offer, then the offer will go to the next coach on the alternate list. (h) Both head coach and assistant coach must be age appropriate certified. (i) In the case of multiple teams in a division: i. For balanced teams, the board will announce coaches for each team. If coaches have players affiliated with teams, they will be assigned to the team their child/affiliated player resides. If both coach s players are on same team, the DM will work with the two coaches to maintain balance and will shift two players to ensure each team has a coach. ii. For teams split into A and B, the board will announce coaches for each team. If coaches have players affiliated with teams, they will be assigned to the team their child/affiliated player resides. If both coach s players are on same team, board will work with the two coaches to maintain balance and will shift two players to ensure each team has a coach. AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016) 3
iii. The head All Star coach is free to select his own assistant coach, as long as that coach is age appropriate certified, although an assistant with a child on the team is recommended. 5. Pulling from Alternates (a) The pool of alternates is determined the final stages of the draft. (b) Players in the draft are considered equal and are not ranked or prioritized. (c) If a player declines the offer to join the All Star Team leaving an open slot, the coach must fill that slot from the pool of alternates. If there are no more candidates remaining in the pool, the coach is free to invite any eligible player from the nominee list after obtaining approval from DM or CA. (d) The DM and CA should be made aware of all declines and subsequent invitations to alternates. (e) In the case of multiple teams: i. For balanced teams, either coach can approach an alternate, but must obtain approval from DM or CA first.. a. In the case where both coaches want the same player, the DM or CA will approach the player (not the coaches). b. Once an alternate accepts an invitation, they are no longer considered an alternate. ii. For A and B teams: a. If an A team has an open slot, the A team coach has one week from the draft date to invite any B players to shift to the A team. b. The A coach should work closely with the post season DM and B coach to make these transitions as smooth as possible. c. Either coach is free to invite players from the pool of alternates, although priority is given to the A coach in the first week after the draft. Coaches must obtain approval from DM or CA first, to eliminate duplicate requests to same player. 6. General (a) It is in the best interest of the All Star coach to notify their players of their selection to the All Star Team, preferably within one day of receiving player contact information provided by DM or post season coordinator. (b) While the overall All Star selection process is publicized and coaches are free to discuss at a high level, coaches must refrain from discussing any specifics of voting or comments about players made during the draft. (c) If a parent asks a coach why their child did not make the All Star team, the coach is encouraged to offer recommendations for improvement and to provide a possible path to post season play the following year. 4 AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016)
(d) Players may be asked by their coach to sign a letter of commitment as provided by the Region. (e) It is up to each coach to set expectations for attendance and time commitment. (f) If a player has significant conflicts with the All Star season, such as playing another soccer club or playing other sports, they coach may request approval from the DM or CA to rescind the invitation to the player. (g) Each player will be responsible for covering the cost of their uniform and any outside tournament fees (the Area 1D tournament has no fees). (h) Scholarships for the All Star team will be considered on a case by case situation. (i) Players are not required to purchase an All Star jacket. (j) Only one coach per team allowed at the draft. If a head coach cannot make it, an assistant coach may take the place of a head coach with the prior approval of the DC. AYSO R34 Guidelines for All Star Team Formation (05/2016) 5