Annie Mercier Jean-François Hamel Memorial University / Ocean Sciences Centre Society for the Exploration & Valuing of the Environment
The sea cucumber Isostichopus fuscus has been intensively fished along the coasts of Mexico, mainland Ecuador and the Galapagos Islands, where efforts at management have typically met strong opposition from local communities. Wild populations of I. fuscus have thus been severely depleted over the past decades. Until recently, aquaculture in Latin America has been largely focused on shrimp, but the emergence of viral diseases has harmed the industry and forced numerous farms to close down. Ecuador and Mexico now have a lot of facilities that could be used to cultivate other species, such as sea cucumbers A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 2
1. Can I. fuscus be cultivated in land-based systems (using shrimp-farming installations). 2. What are the optimal conditions to grow juveniles to the exportable size (in tanks, shrimp ponds or cages at sea). A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 3
A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 4
A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 5
Spawning periodicity of I. fuscus follows a lunar cycle. From Mercier et al. 2007 A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 6
Quality of feed for larvae is of primary importance. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 7
Larval rearing tanks (cones). Experimental tanks (aquariums). A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 8
Newly fertilized eggs 2-cell (~50 min) Gastrula (~6-10 h) Auricularia (~3-15 d) Doliolaria (~19-24 d) Early pentactula (~21-26 d) A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 9
From Becker et al. 2009 A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 10
Solution: decrease temperature of seawater and increase air bubbling. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 11
Sheets of fabric mesh 500-1000 µm conditioned for ~3 weeks. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 12
Settlement (~22-27 d) 1.5-mm juvenile (~28 d) 15-mm juvenile (~50 d) 13
A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 14
Size (µm) 34x10 3 32x10 3 f=1658-321x+11x 2 30x10 3 28x10 3 r 2 =0.99 26x10 3 24x10 3 22x10 3 20x10 3 18x10 3 16x10 3 14x10 3 12x10 3 10x10 3 8x10 3 6x10 3 4x10 3 2x10 3 0 0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52 56 60 64 68 72 Time (d) A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 15
In Ecuador & Mexico: Hatchery-reared sea cucumbers were placed in shrimp ponds. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 16
In Ecuador: The animals were placed in cages of 1 m² to facilitate recapture for weekly controls. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 17
In Ecuador: The sea cucumbers in the farm grew an average of 17 g/week. 300 250 GRAMS 200 150 100 50 0 Cage 1 Cage 2 Cage 3 Cage 4 Week 1 week 2 week 3 week 4 A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 18
Survival rate was high (to 98%) in the absence of skin disease A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 19
In Mexico: The animals were placed directly in the ponds and assessed every 15 d. NOUMEA, A. MERCIER NEW - NOUMEA CALEDONIA 2011 2011 20
In Mexico: Growth in ponds was fast (1 g/day) but survival was often low mainly due to skin disease. Skin can repair with antibiotics in tanks (but long and costly) NOUMEA, A. MERCIER NEW - NOUMEA CALEDONIA 2011 2011 21
Growth was slower but survival much better in cages at sea Individuals initially affected by skin disease recovered When juveniles were transferred at size of 3-5 mm, survival was between 30-50% Weight increment from 2.66 g to 26.92 g in 3 months Main problems: crabs and fouling NOUMEA, A. MERCIER NEW - NOUMEA CALEDONIA 2011 2011 22
24-cm long sea cucumbers were obtained randomly NOUMEA, A. MERCIER NEW - NOUMEA CALEDONIA 2011 2011 23
1. A good portion of the effort has been placed on adapting shrimp farm equipment and larval rearing conditions to fit the needs of I. fuscus. 2. The species has been found to follow a predictable lunar spawning cycle which facilitates the collection of mature gametes (oocytes and spermatozoa). 3. A larval rearing protocol has been developed using flow-through systems, an optimal micro-algal diet as well as water quality management and disease control. 4. Maximum survival rates of juveniles were typically 30-50%. 5. Based on the best growth rates, juveniles can reach 8 cm (~25 g) in 110 days in shrimp ponds in Ecuador and 90 days in cages in Mexico. 6. While grow-out of sea cucumbers in tanks and shrimp ponds appears to be promising under optimal conditions, sea farming might be a more reliable and simple option (disease-free). A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 24
Cultivating a reef species in a sandy environment is challenging A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 25
More R&D needed to optimize use of shrimp installations A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 26
1. Research on diets and on conditioning adults to spawn when maintained in tanks to avoid having to continuously collect from wild populations (to become independent of wild stocks). 2. Fine-tune hatchery and larval rearing protocols to maximize commercial mass-production. 3. Experiment with grow-out techniques to determine the best diet, substrates and location to grow the juveniles. 4. Determine the commercial and ecological prospects for hatcheryproduced I. fuscus. 5. Optimize the control of larval and juvenile parasitic infestations and infections. 6. Compare with culture away from shrimp habitat / installations. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 27
This work was conducted in collaboration with: Roberto H. Ycaza, Investigaciones Especies Acuaticas, Ecuador Ramon Espinoza, Acuacultura dos Mil S.A. de C.V., Mexico We would like to acknowledge the assistance of Victor M. Ariaga Haro, (Organización y Fomento de la Comisión Nacional de Acuacultura y Pesca, Mexico), the hard work and technical assistance of Jorge Jaramillo, Jose Pico, Pedro Gonsaby and Maricela Garcia during the course of the laboratory work in Ecuador as well as Ramon Cota, Cesar E. Magallanes Raygoza, Cristian Eden Sagueiro Beltran, Karla Marina Garcia Quiroz, Juan Jose Beltran Sanchez, Javier Cervantes Zambrano in Mexico. A. MERCIER - NOUMEA 2011 28