Cruise Report for Patterns in Deep-Sea Corals Expedition 2016: NOAA ship Shearwater SW-16-08 NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS NCCOS 233 August 2017
Disclaimer: This publication does not constitute an endorsement of any commercial product or intend to be an opinion beyond scientific or other results obtained by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). No reference shall be made to NOAA, or this publication furnished by NOAA, to any advertising or sales promotion which would indicate or imply that NOAA recommends or endorses any proprietary product mentioned herein, or which has as its purpose an interest to cause the advertised product to be used or purchased because of this publication. The recommended citation for this report is: Etnoyer PJ, Shuler AJ, Frometa J, Lauermann A, & Rosen D (2017). Cruise Report for Patterns in Deep-Sea Corals Expedition 2016: NOAA ship Shearwater SW-16-08. NOS NCCOS 233, NOAA National Ocean Service, Charleston, SC 29412. 21 pp. Cover image credit: Marine Applied Research and Exploration/NOAA.
Cruise Report for Patterns in Deep-Sea Corals Expedition 2016: NOAA ship Shearwater SW-16-08 Peter Etnoyer 1, Andrew Shuler 2, Janessy Frometa 2, Andrew Lauermann 3, Dirk Rosen 3 1 NOAA National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science, 219 Fort Johnson Rd., Charleston, SC 29412 2 JHT, Inc, 219 Fort Johnson Rd., Charleston, SC 29412 3 Marine Applied Research and Exploration. 1230 Brickyard Cove Road #101, Richmond, CA 94801 NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS NCCOS 233 August 2017 United States Department of Commerce Wilbur Ross Secretary of Commerce National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Benjamin Friedman Deputy Under Secretary for Operations and Acting Administrator National Ocean Service Russell Callender Assistant Administrator i
Table of Contents 1. Expedition Overview... 1 2. Narrative of Cruise Results... 1 2.1 Objective 1: recover previously deployed temperature loggers... 1 2.2 Objective 2: conduct ROV seafloor surveys... 1 2.3 Objective 3: collect live Acanthogorgia sp. corals for laboratory studies... 1 3. Discussion... 2 4. Acknowledgements... 2 5. References... 2 6. Tables... 3 7. Figures... 6 8. Appendices... 10 Appendix A: Operational Notes... 10 Appendix B: Individual temperature logger site information, images and data.... 12 ii
Cruise Report for Patterns in Deep-Sea Corals Expedition 2016: NOAA ship Shearwater SW-16-08 1. Expedition Overview The 2016 Patterns in Deep-Sea Corals expedition set out aboard the NOAA Ship Shearwater in August to study the distribution, ecology, and health of deep-water (30-300 m) gorgonian corals in response to the 2015 El Niño event. The research team consisted of staff from NOAA National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science (NCCOS) and Marine Applied Research and Education (MARE; Table 1). The study used the remotely operated vehicle (ROV) Beagle to recover previously deployed temperature loggers (Caldow et al. 2015) and to conduct video transects for the purpose of density estimation and health assessments. The primary scientific objectives of the expedition were to: 1) recover temperature loggers that were deployed in the spring and fall of 2015 in order to assess temperature anomalies; 2) characterize deepsea coral ecosystems in newly mapped areas of the Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary (CINMS) (Figures 1-4); and 3) collect live Acanthogorgia sp. corals for laboratory studies on temperature. 2. Narrative of Cruise Results The expedition s scientific objectives were successfully met thanks in large part to good weather and few technical difficulties. In addition to the scientific objectives, several outreach activities were completed during the expedition, including. A dockside presentation for six people in Santa Barbara Harbor, and an at sea day for seven people, during which they were able to come aboard the NOAA Ship Shearwater and participate in a ROV dive. The VIP party included representatives from Conservation International, Rockefeller Foundation, Coral Reef Watch, and others. 2.1 Objective 1: Recover previously deployed temperature loggers The ROV recovered all four temperature loggers from depths ranging between 20-100 m. Data was successfully downloaded from each logger, and plotted across time (Figure 5 and Appendix A). Temperatures averaged between 14-15 ⁰C at 20 m, with a maximum of 19 ⁰C in July. Temperatures at 50 m exceeded 15 ⁰C on average, but never reached the 19 ⁰C threshold observed at 20 m. Temperatures showed little temporal variation at 100 m, and ranged between ~10-12 ⁰C. In the future, this temperature data will be analyzed in more detail in order to identify trends and anomalies. This analysis will also incorporate temperature data collected from CTD casts near the Channel Islands, and other sources. 2.2 Objective 2: Conduct ROV seafloor surveys Of the 14 ROV dives conducted over the course of the expedition, the majority took place over the newly mapped areas north and south of Santa Island (Figures 2-4; Table 3). The total bottom time was 17 hours and 51 minutes, during which 30 video transects were completed (Table 4). Video data collected during the ROV transects will be analyzed in order to determine species composition, health and densities of deep-water corals. This data will become publicly available within one year through the NOAA Deep Sea Coral Data Portal (https://deepseacoraldata.noaa.gov/). 2.3 Objective 3: Collect live Acanthogorgia sp. corals for laboratory studies The team successfully collected two live colonies of Acanthogorgia sp. octocorals from 200 m. Upon 1
retrieval from the ROV, each colony was split into six fragments. Coral fragments were shipped to both the Claremont College in California, and the Deep Coral Ecology Laboratory in Charleston, SC. The live corals arrived at their respective institutions within 24 h of shipment, and were successfully acclimated into an aquarium environment (Figures 7-8). While the original goal was to collect four small colonies, the colonies collected were large enough to provide enough material for laboratory experimentation. 3. Discussion The successful recovery of all temperature loggers is an important accomplishment, particularly since three of the four loggers were deployed from a ship. Additionally, we were able to successfully download data from all temperature loggers, indicating that they hold up well under the conditions and duration of our deployment. It is important to point out that the temperature logger deployed at the shallowest depth (20 m) had substantial overgrowth by encrusting fauna, whereas overgrowth was minimal in the other three loggers. Therefore, future deployments of these devices at depths shallower than 50 m should consider providing some means to deter fouling, with either external housing or antifouling paint. The ROV dives focused on habitat characterization and dive time was split between transects and exploration. This split approach allowed the science team to obtain quantitative information on the coral communities during transects, as well as provided time to explore the newly-mapped environment more freely. The use of dedicated transects also facilitated the process of estimating octocoral density, by ensuring consistent speed, altitude, and direction. The collection of live corals from deeper than 50 m is another important accomplishment of this expedition. One of the dives was dedicated exclusively for specimen collections, and this approach was critical in reducing undue stress to the organisms. Future collections of live material should consider a similar approach. 4. Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the support and guidance of the Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary staff especially Chris Caldow, Julie Bursek, and Ryan Freedman. It is also important to note the skill and expertise of the crew of the NOAA Ship Shearwater, specifically Captain Terrance Shinn, First Mate Charles Lara, and Lieutenant junior grade Elizabeth Mackie. Equally as important were team members Steve Holz and Rick Botman of Marine Applied Research and Exploration for their critical support to this mission. These individuals were instrumental to the smooth deployment and operation of the ROV Beagle and the success of this expedition. 5. References Caldow, C., P. J. Etnoyer, L. Kracker. 2015. Cruise Report for Patterns in Deep-Sea Corals Expedition: NOAA ship Bell M. Shimada SH-15-03. NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS NCCOS 200. 15 pp. Silver Spring, MD. OSPAR. 2010. Background Document for Coral Gardens. Publication number 486. OSPAR Biodiversity Series. https://www.ospar.org/documents?v=7217 2
6. Tables Table 1. List of science participants for the Patterns in Deep-Sea Coral Expedition in August 2016. Name Title Affiliation Botman, Rick ROV operator Marine Applied Research and Exploration Group Etnoyer, Peter Chief Scientist NOAA National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science Frometa, Janessy Marine Biologist NOAA Contractor with JHT, Inc. Holz, Steve ROV Operator Marine Applied Research and Exploration Group Lauermann, Andy ROV operator Marine Applied Research and Exploration Group Rosen, Dirk ROV operator Marine Applied Research and Exploration Group Shuler, Andrew Marine Biologist NOAA Contractor with JHT, Inc. Table 2. List of samples collected during the expedition using the ROV Beagle, including previously deployed temperature loggers and live coral samples. Locality Anacapa (AI-1) Anacapa (AI-1) Anacapa (AI-1) Anacapa (Footprint) Anacapa (Footprint) Anacapa (Footprint) Collection date (GMT) Collection Time (GMT) Sample ID Depth (m) Latitude Longitude August 2, 2016 0:41:44 Logger P 20 34.01736-119.44072 August 2, 2016 0:48:45 Logger B 20 34.01736-119.44072 August 2, 2016 2:12:05 Logger D 52 34.02115-119.44729 August 2, 2016 3:12:00 Logger C 100 33.96468-119.48490 August 4, 2016 22:03 Acanthogorgia sp. 201 33.95948-119.47541 August 4, 2016 22:10 Acanthogorgia sp. 200 33.95948-119.47541 3
Table 3. Table of waypoints (wpt) visited during the Patterns in Deep-Sea Coral 2016 Expedition, aboard NOAA Ship Shearwater. Two differing coordinates are associated with Logger C, including the location reported in Caldow et al. (2015) (wpt. 1) and the location from the NOAA Ship Shearwater s onboard navigation system (wpt 2). Locality Date (GMT) MAREDi ve # DCEL Dive # Site wpt Latitude Longitude Anacapa (AI-1) August 2, 2016 25 16-213A Loggers B/P 1 34.0174-119.4407 Anacapa (AI-1) August 2, 2016 26 16-213B Logger D 1 34.0212-119.4473 Anacapa (Footprint) August 2, 2016 27 16-213C Logger C 1 33.9635-119.4896 Anacapa (Footprint) August 2, 2016 27 16-213C Logger C 2 33.9647-119.4849 North Santa August 2, 2016 28 16-214A NS-A1 1 34.0820-120.2810 North Santa August 2, 2016 28 16-214A NS-A1 2 34.0750-120.2840 North Santa August 2, 2016 28 16-214A NS-A1 3 34.0700-120.2920 North Santa August 2, 2016 28 16-214A NS-A1 4 34.0660-120.2910 North Santa August 2, 2016 29 16-214B NS-2 1 34.0750-120.2460 North Santa August 2, 2016 29 16-214B NS-2 2 34.0660-120.2530 North Santa August 2, 2016 29 16-214B NS-2 3 34.0620-120.2450 North Santa August 2, 2016 29 16-214B NS-2 4 34.0600-120.2500 North Santa August 2, 2016 30 16-214C NS-B3 1 34.0830-120.2170 North Santa August 2, 2016 30 16-214C NS-B3 2 34.0690-120.2080 August 3, 2016 31 16-215A SS-1 1 33.8310-120.0390 August 3, 2016 31 16-215A SS-1 2 33.8450-120.0560 August 3, 2016 32 16-215B SS-4 1 33.8520-120.0810 August 3, 2016 32 16-215B SS-4 2 33.8580-120.0620 August 3, 2016 33 16-215C SS-A2 1 33.8470-120.0250 August 3, 2016 33 16-215C SS-A2 2 33.8520-120.0250 August 3, 2016 33 16-215C SS-A2 3 33.8550-120.0190 August 3, 2016 33 16-215C SS-A2 4 33.8570-120.0180 August 3, 2016 34 16-215D SS-A6 1 33.8450-120.0380 August 3, 2016 34 16-215D SS-A6 2 33.8520-120.0320 August 4, 2016 35 16-216A SS-A9 1 33.8370-120.0580 August 4, 2016 35 16-216A SS-A9 2 33.8400-120.0540 August 4, 2016 36 16-216B SS-A7 1 33.8680-119.9580 August 4, 2016 36 16-216B SS-A7 2 33.8750-119.9710 Anacapa (Footprint) August 4, 2016 37 16-216C Footprint 1 33.9595-119.4754 Anacapa (Footprint) August 5, 2016 VIP NA NMFS sled 1 33.9647-119.4849 4
DCEL Dive # Table 4. Inventory of ROV transects conducted during the 2016 Patterns in Deep-Sea Coral Expedition aboard NOAA Ship Shearwater. 16-214A SW-16-214A-15min-NS-A1-a 16-214A SW-16-214A-15min-NS-A1-b 16-214A SW-16-214A-15min-NS-A1-c 16-214A SW-16-214A-15min-NS-A1-d 16-214B SW-16-214B-15min-NS-2-a 16-214B SW-16-214B-15min-NS-2-b 16-214B SW-16-214B-15min-NS-2-c 16-214B SW-16-214B-15min-NS-2-d 16-214C SW-16-214C-15min-NS-3B-a 16-214C SW-16-214C-15min-NS-3B-b 16-214C SW-16-214C-15min-NS-3B-c 16-214C SW-16-214C-15min-NS-3B-d 16-215A SW-16-215A-15min-SS-1-a 16-215A SW-16-215A-15min-SS-1-b 16-215A SW-16-215A-15min-SS-1-c 16-215A SW-16-215A-15min-SS-1-d 16-215A SW-16-215A-15min-SS-1-e 16-215B SW-16-215B-15min-SS-4-a 16-215B SW-16-215B-15min-SS-4-b 16-215B SW-16-215B-15min-SS-4-c 16-215C SW-16-215C-15min-SS-A2-a 16-215C SW-16-215C-15min-SS-A2-b 16-215C SW-16-215C-15min-SS-A2-c 16-215D SW-16-215D-15min-SS-A6-a 16-215D SW-16-215D-15min-SS-A6-b 16-215D SW-16-215D-15min-SS-A6-c 16-216A SW-16-216A-15min-SS-A9-a 16-216A SW-16-216A-15min-SS-A9-b 16-216B SW-16-216B-15min-SS-A7-a 16-216B SW-16-216B-15min-SS-A7-b Transect ID Locality Date (GMT) North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa North Santa Start Time (GMT) Start Latitude Start Longitude End Latitude End Longitude Min. Depth (m) August 2, 2016 18:05:25 34.08213-120.28100 34.08001-120.28183 81 83 August 2, 2016 18:24:30 34.08001-120.28183 34.07779-120.28281 77 81 August 2, 2016 18:48:45 34.07779-120.28281 34.07643-120.28507 75 76 August 2, 2016 19:15:55 34.07643-120.28507 34.07613-120.28815 73 75 August 2, 2016 20:22:45 34.07613-120.28815 34.08021-120.24213 74 73 August 2, 2016 20:45:00 34.08021-120.24213 34.07573-120.24557 67 74 August 2, 2016 21:03:40 34.07573-120.24557 34.07309-120.24756 64 67 August 2, 2016 21:20:00 34.07309-120.24756 34.07064-120.24952 60 64 August 2, 2016 22:20:48 34.07064-120.24952 34.08171-120.21714 70 60 August 2, 2016 22:39:55 34.08171-120.21714 34.07905-120.21570 67 70 August 2, 2016 22:58:10 34.07905-120.21570 34.07617-120.21357 62 67 August 2, 2016 23:15 34.07617-120.21357 34.07365-120.21219 60 62 August 3, 2016 15:53:20 33.83155-120.03971 33.83383-120.04236 97 99 August 3, 2016 16:14:40 33.83463-120.04373 33.83592-120.04499 95 94 August 3, 2016 16:30:50 33.83596-120.04507 33.83754-120.04682 88 94 August 3, 2016 16:50:35 33.83789-120.04735 33.83937-120.04906 81 86 August 3, 2016 17:19:10 33.84072-120.05092 33.84204-120.05291 94 92 Max Depth (m) August 3, 2016 18:26:20 33.85217-120.08044 33.85346-120.07667 100 104 August 3, 2016 18:42:45 33.85345-120.07629 33.85459-120.07298 97 99 August 3, 2016 19:02 33.85499-120.07164 33.85610-120.06866 92 95 August 3, 2016 20:39:45 33.84766-120.02549 33.85002-120.02514 79 80.9 August 3, 2016 21:31:10 NA NA NA NA NA NA August 3, 2016 21:59:15 NA NA NA NA NA NA August 3, 2016 23:11:10 33.84518-120.03800 33.84720-120.03633 81 87 August 3, 2016 23:29:02 33.84751-120.03616 33.84919-120.03456 84 82 August 3, 2016 23:45:31 33.84950-120.03442 33.85094-120.03295 82 83 August 4, 2016 15:19:45 33.83725-120.05805 33.83798-120.05682 91 98 August 4, 2016 15:37:30 33.83809-120.05662 33.83888-120.05544 86 92 August 4, 2016 16:52:10 33.86799-119.95872 33.86901-119.96047 76 83 August 4, 2016 17:14:20 33.86964-119.96113 33.87170-119.96495 77 80 5
7. Figures Figure 1. Overview map of areas surveyed by the NOAA Ship Shearwater with ROV Beagle aboard the Patterns in Deep-Sea Coral Expedition, August 1-5, 2016. Figure 2. Overview maps of ROV dives 16-213A to 16-216B near Santa Island overlaid on multibeam echosounder maps generated during Bell M. Shimada cruise SH-15-03 and reported in Caldow et. al, 2015, which identifies hard-bottom features from 8-m resolution backscatter data. 6
Figure 3. Map of ROV dives 16-214A, 16-214B and 16-214C north of Santa Island overlaid on multibeam echosounder maps generated during Bell M. Shimada cruise SH-15-03 and reported in Caldow et. al, 2015, which identifies hard-bottom features from 8-m resolution backscatter data. Figure 4. Map of ROV dives 16-215A to 16-216B south of Santa Island overlaid on multibeam echosounder maps generated during Bell M. Shimada cruise SH-15-03 and reported in Caldow et. al, 2015, which identifies hard-bottom features from 8-m resolution backscatter data. 7
Figure 5. Line graph of temperature data collected from two HOBO and two STAR-ODDI temperature loggers deployed at depths ranging from 20 to 100 m in Southern California s Channel Islands. Temperatures shown here are limited to an 8-month period from the fall of 2015 to summer 2016. Figure 6. Heathy coral garden surveyed off Island on August 3, 2016. 8
Figure 7. Live Acanthogorgia sp. octocoral at 200 m depth at Footprint ridge collected for laboratory assays. Figure 8. Live Acanthogorgia sp. octocoral from Footprint ridge in aquaria in Charleston, SC. 9
8. Appendices Appendix A: Operational notes July 31, 2016. Mobilization began at 0830 at Santa Barbara Harbor. JHT/NOAA staff members loaded science gear and purchased food. MARE staff members loaded and set up the ROV and associated equipment. After mobilization was complete, Rosen and Etnoyer provided an outreach event for six current and potential MARE donors on the NOAA Ship Shearwater dock, which included a presentation of the mission goals. August 1, 2016. The expedition got off to a rough start, as the vessel hit a piling and bent the tracking pivot irreparably. Ed Liquorek, the brother of a local angler, fabricated a new pivot. The NOAA Ship Shearwater left the dock at 1300 and transited to the north side of Anacapa Island, arriving by 1530. The ROV was deployed by 1630 to retrieve temperature loggers at 20 m. The ROV encountered a large black seabass as soon as the ROV reached bottom. The team retrieved two temperature loggers (B and P) during the first dive. A large air bubble seeped into the main tether compensator overnight. Lauermann and Rosen had purged the bubble prior to the ROV deployment, but it reappeared after the 20 m dive, 55 m dive (logger D retrieval), and 110 m dive (logger C retrieval at NMFS sled site). This marked the first use of HD video for the live feed from the ROV. The focus was acceptable, but the color appeared washed out at times. Overall, it was much improved over standard definition. The final ROV dive of the day was completed by 2000 and the manipulator skid was removed since all temperature loggers had been recovered. The NOAA Ship Shearwater transited to to anchor overnight. August 2, 2016. The tether compensator was purged of air in transit to the north side of Santa. The ROV was first deployed at 0800. Three dives were conducted through the course of the day, for a total of 12 transects of 15-minute duration each, in addition to general exploration at three different sites. The three dives were at 80 m, 70 m and 65 m. The tether needed to be purged after each dive, because the piston completely bottomed out after each dive. To improve the quality of the HD feed and video, the white balance was adjusted using white plastic bags on the clump shroud. This improved the color of the video. During the dives, some Adelogorgia gorgonians were noted on ridges, along with an abundance of Eugorgia gorgonians, both of which appeared healthy. In addition to these corals, the team noted a few spots with many lingcod, copper, starry, and a few gopher rockfish, bocaccio and sheephead. ROV pilots noted that moving the vertical thruster forward this winter helped make the ROV perform better straight up and down, and moving the altimeter forward improved auto-altitude function over moderate terrain. The HMI lights on the ROV became erratic through the course of the day and did not stay on. With the low light HD camera, and the reds of the tungsten light still allowing for good photos to be captured, the need for the HMIs was questionable. The ROV team used a new AA Beacon, and it performed adequately down to 70 m. The ROV was recovered and operations were concluded by 1800. The NOAA Ship Shearwater anchored at Johnsons Lee, Santa for the evening. Elephant seals were heard billowing throughout the night. August 3, 2016. The weather remained good allowing for continued exploration of new SE Santa sites. The ROV was first deployed at at 0800 and conducted four dives with 14 transects of 15-minute duration at four different localities at depths of 95m, 105m, 85m and 90m.. Many corals were observed, several at densities consistent with Coral Gardens (1/m 2 over distances of at least 100 m) (OSPAR 2010). There was some noticeable injury to gorgonians from zooanthids, some toppled colonies were documented, as well as two white nudibranchs, and a crab photographed 10
utilizing sponges. These dives also documented several ledges and uplifted shelves that made great coral habitat. Fish documented on these dives included two cowcod, a wolf eel, and many rockfish. The last dive of the day had good visibility (30 m) at 0200. During dive operations there was one ROV power outage, however, the team recovered from this within 2 min. The main pressure balance oil filled junction was still taking in air, but not as much as previous days, though the piston bottomed out each dive. The use of HMIs was abandoned. Weather deteriorated throughout the day. August 4, 2016. Deployed ROV at at 0800. ROV Beagle completed dives over areas that had previously been mapped with backscatter and contained substantial hard-bottom habitats. One dive started at 85 m, and another dive at 110 m. Conducted four transects of 15-minutes duration near during these two dives. A few potential coral gardens were identified, but several of these showed signs of injury and yellow zooanthid overgrowth. Then the ship moved to 220 m to collect two live Acanthogorgia sp. colonies. The ROV camera flooded with oil and as a result the first attempt was aborted. The ROV team then replaced the flooded HD camera with a Sidus standard definition video camera and finished the job. The second attempt resulted in the collection of two Acanthogorgia colonies. Upon successful collection of these colonies, the ROV was recovered and back aboard by 1500. The NOAA Ship Shearwater transited to Ventura Harbor and arrived at 1700. August 5, 2016. In an effort to further the outreach efforts of the expeditions, VIPs Boltz, Hannah, Teplitz, Ledvina, Graham, Chacin, Robertson, and MARE Director of Donor Relations Phil Stevens, boarded the ship by 0800, and departed for Anacapa Island to explore the Anacapa/Footprint essential fish habitat (EFH) by 0900. The team deployed the ROV at Footprint and conducted an approximately two hour dive up to the NMFS sled, then moved to the lee side of Anacapa, near the net in order to let the VIPs operate the ROV under supervision of the ROV team. Each guest steered the ROV for 4-5 min, which received an enthusiastic response. The NOAA Ship Shearwater returned to Ventura by 1700 to drop off the VIPs, and then the vessel returned to Santa Barbara for its next expedition. 11
Appendix B: Individual temperature logger site information, images and data. Shallow target: Loggers B (Star-Oddi logger, silver) and P (Hobo logger, black) Site: AI-1 Line: 100 Depth: 21 m Latitude: 34.017364 Longitude: -119.440728 Deployment Method: Shipside Deployment Date: November 12, 201515 Appendix B: Figure 1. Dense Leptogorgia chilensis aggregation taken near proposed site location. Photo taken by Marine Applied Research and Exploration. 12
Appendix B: Figure 2. Black and white in-situ image of temperature logger B (top) and graph of temperature data collected from site AI-1 at the shallow target of 21 m depth (bottom). 13
Appendix B: Figure 3. Black and white in-situ image of temperature logger P (top) and graph of temperature data collected from site AI-1 at the shallow target of 21 m depth (bottom). 14
Page left intentionally blank 15
Deep target: Logger D (Hobo logger, black) Site: AI-1 Line: 710 Depth: 52.5 m Latitude: 34.021159 Longitude: -119.447291 Deployment Method: Shipside Deployment Date: November 12, 2015 Appendix B: Figure 4. Eugorgia rubens aggregation taken near proposed site location. Photo taken by Marine Applied Research and Exploration. 16
Appendix B: Figure 5. Black and white in-situ image of temperature logger D (top) and graph of temperature data collected from site AI-1 at the shallow target of 52.5 m depth (bottom). 17
Deep target: Logger C (Star Oddi, Silver) Site: AI-1 Line: NA Depth: 104 m Latitude: 33.96468 Longitude: -119.48490 Deployment Method: ROV Deployment Date: August 4, 2015 Appendix B: Figure 6. Lophelia pertusa aggregation taken near proposed site location. Photo taken by Marine Applied Research and Exploration. 18
Appendix B: Figure 7. Black and white in-situ image of temperature logger C (top) and graph of temperature data collected from site AI-1 at the deep target location of 104 m depth (bottom). 19
Page Left Intentionally Blank 20
United States Department of Commerce Wilbur Ross Secretary of Commerce National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Benjamin Friedman Deputy Under Secretary for Operations and Acting Administrator National Ocean Service Russell Callender Assistant Administrator