CoPulsation tm Milking System The only humane way to milk a dairy animal with a machine www.dairysolutions.nl www.copulsation.com www.facebook.com/copulsation
Mastitis Root Cause Bacteria responsible for udder infections Milking machine is the delivery system Core of the milking machine (liner, pulsation) provide the cow to milking system interface The design and performance of milking system affects teat condition, milking action and cow behavior Evidence proves that an incorrectly designed milking system significantly increases mastitis Creates environment for bacteria to enter the teat sinus and udder
Milking Machine Delivery System Dr. Derek Forbes research proves liner pinch forces bacteria up teat sinus Cornell University research proves conventional pulsation causes 16X more Staph aureus infections than CoPulsation Dr. Sybren Reitsma shows short D phase increases new infections Teagasc proves teats swollen and injured by conventional milking machines More claw vacuum fluctuation events with alternating and sequential pulsation the milking machine is one of the best washing machine ever built, the teats are bathed with milk during the milking process Dr. Andy Johnson: 2000 NMC Annual Meeting Atlantic Vet College research shows >23% of teats not sealed 6 weeks after dry off
Dr. Forbes Research Milk samples extracted from teat end and directly from teat sinus Bacteria present in teat end for many days no mastitis Teat end pinched by liner forced bacteria up sinus causing new infection The pinching action of conventional milking machines can be felt with your fingers in the liner
Cornell University Research Compared GEA to CoPulsation 30 best cows from CU herd selected 15 cows in each group milked 6 months and switched First group milked by CoPulsation started with 5 Staph AU cases caused by?? Final result: 1 new Staph AU infection with CoPulsation and 16 new infections with GEA Supports Forbes research Study duration to short for teat health improvement based on averages.02 new IMI per 100 d.31 new IMI per 100 d.31/.02 = 16 16X MORE NEW INFECTIONS with conventional
Dr. Reitsma Research D duration Compared infection rates for different liner closure (D phase) durations Short D phase causes more infections Consider the following: Anatomy of teat and time for blood recirculation requires D phase of.4 to.5 seconds Example: tightly squeeze your forearm, release and note time it takes for redness to go away
Teagasc Research Research at Teagasc in Ireland proves conventional milking machines cause teat swelling and teat sinus injury Evidence that conventional milking machines cause the teat to swell (congestion) while milking and experience physical damage to the teat canal and teat sinus
Simultaneous vs. Alternating Pulsation 2 x more vacuum fluctuation events with alternating Claw vacuum fluctuation during milking interrupts milk flow and causes backwash (video) Alternating originally designed to allow front quarters to milk 50:50 and rear 60:40 and never reduced mastitis as claimed no one uses alternating pulsation as originally intended Claw vacuum stability with simultaneous is as good or better than alternating with proper venting and claw volume
Objective Observations Many facts can be visually observed proving that conventional milking machines cause physical harm, pain and result in high rates in new infections Teats soaked in milk backwash Teats swollen and reddened Teat sinus injury lightly pinch and roll teat end and fell scar tissue within teat (video) Milk flow never stops during the rest phase, it only slows down (video) Feel pinching action of liner with your finger Research and observations exist to support the fact that conventional milking machines are the delivery system for bacteria causing the conventional milking system to be responsible for new infections
1960 1963 1966 1969 1972 1975 1978 1981 1984 1987 1990 1993 1996 1999 2002 2005 2008 Percent Replaced Dairy Industry has focused on the bacteria and cleanliness to solve mastitis Impact: US cull rate doubled in 50 years Average US dairy cow production life = 1,8 lactations Replacement Rate 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Year
CoPulsation Eliminates the delivery system The CoPulsation Milking System solves the problems created by conventional milking machines Simultaneous pulsation with a long D phase Eliminates liner pinch Eliminates backwash (video) Eliminates teat swelling, injury and pain (video) Provides a true rest phase with no milk flow (video)
Conventional Pulsation Fresh air enters top High restriction to fresh air flow A and C phase: 120 to 160 millisecond range
CoPulsation Eliminates restriction to fresh air flow A and C phase: 40 to 60 millisecond range
Conventional Performance Difference Liner crawl Rest Phase Comparison No liner crawl CoPulsation Pinched teat Vacuum pull Massaged teat No vacuum Milk flow No milk flow Teat canal stressed and damaged with scar tissue Healthy teat canal
Conventional Milking Machine Reverse Milking Action Research by Dr Derek Forbes demonstrated that the pinching action forces non-motile bacteria up the teat canal Bacteria forced up New infections result Liner pinch can be felt with your finger
CoPulsation Gentle Massage Liner closes about full length of teat Eliminates pinch Provide gentle compressive massage similar to calf or hand milking action
Recognize Damage of Conventional Milking Machines Cow at Eurotier 10 From website for conventional milking machine company Cow featured in ad for California Dairy Advertisement udder damage obvious
Evidence of performance difference with CoPulsation tm Change in liner wear No teat swelling No teat wetting Improved teat end health Reduced SCC Increased production Increased duration of peak flow rate
Summary Significant proof exists showing that conventional milking machines are the delivery system for mastitis CoPulsation solves the problems caused by conventional milking machines Quality milk, low antibiotic use and low cull rates can only be achieved with CoPulsation It is important that the other parts of the milking facility be correct vacuum regulation, detacher settings, pipe size and design Milk must flow freely from the cow Vacuum supply must be proper and consistent
Lameness a result of mastitis? Mastitis causes udder pain Udder pain causes cows to hold feet further apart Utrecht Mastitis Conf. 2011 Incorrect hoof placement damages hoof causing lameness Typical lame cow Farmer in Ireland first noted significant hoof improvement with CoPulsation. Recent email from Ireland: Don t forget to tell the Dutch about the cows feet, that is a big problem as well over there
Known Problems with Conventional Alfa Laval Agri United States Patent 5,697,323 Issued December 16, 1997 In milking machines currently marketed by Alfa Laval, the pulsation chamber. The relatively strong milking vacuum is needed primarily for ensuring a safe attachment of the teat cups to the teats and, secondary, for achieving a rapid milking and a high milk yield. However, a disadvantage of such a strong milking vacuum is that it might treat the teats roughly, especially at the beginning and at the end of the milking interval when there is no or insignificant milk flow through one or more teats. Attempts have been made to eliminate this disadvantage by milking according to different WestfaliaSurge patent application: During traditional manual milking, which is a pressure milking method, almost the entire amount of milk present in the udder can be milked. In the machine suctional milking method there is a problem, first of all some quarters are milked too long although no more milk flow is present, and, on the other hand, in individual quarters, the milking process is ended too soon and therefore residual milk remains in the udder. Delaval, WestfaliaSurge, Boumatic and others have known for many years that problems exist with their milking machines. They have made many attempts to solve those problems with no success. Goran Olofsson, past VP Engineering for Delaval: you have done what I have tried to do for over 25 years
Liner Wear Evidence Massage action from CoPulsation tm changes liner wear Liner wear shows outline of teat Conventional pulsation does not change liner shape Left two liners used with CoPulsation tm, right liner used with conventional pulsation
Teat Study Before milking: 30 mm After milking: 25 mm Details published in International Dairy Topics
Teats not milk-wetted Teats wetted with milk during milking process contaminated with bacteria Since the milking machine is one of the best washing machine ever built, the teats are bathed with milk during the milking process. Dr. Andy Johnson, 2000 NMC Annual Meeting CoPulsation does not wash the teat in milk Glooved hand applied to teat just after machine removal no milk present on teat
Improved Teat End Health Teat end condition improved as pinching is eliminated Teat canal health also improved as scar tissue no longer created Cow teat with Delaval Same teat with CoPulsation 8 weeks later
SCC Reduced SCC reduced as animals are consistently milked out each milking Bacteria not forced up teat canal Teat canal healthy and closes after milking SCC data original test farm SCC Data for small commercial herd
Udder Infections Reduced Small commercial herd Multi-year side-byside study Significant reduction in both contagious and environmental mastitis Milking System Cow Number Pathogen CoPulsation tm Milking System 1 none CoPulsation tm Milking System 2 Staph aureus CoPulsation tm Milking System 3 Strep Species CoPulsation tm Milking System 4 none CoPulsation tm Milking System 5 none CoPulsation tm Milking System 6 Staph species CoPulsation tm Milking System 7 none CoPulsation tm Milking System 8 none CoPulsation tm Milking System 9 Staph species, C. bovis CoPulsation tm Milking System 10 Staph species Conventional 11 Staph aureus, Staph species Conventional 12 Staph aureus Conventional 13 none Conventional 14 Staph aureus, Strep species, G. bacillus Conventional 15 Staph aureus, Staph species Conventional 16 Staph aureus Conventional 17 Staph aureus, C. bovis Results published in International Dairy Topics
1 4 7 10 13 16 19 22 25 H e rd Av e ra g e Increased Production Production and butterfat increase with full milkout Empty udder keeps animal at peak production longer Highest butterfat in last milk removed 23500 23000 22500 22000 21500 21000 20500 20000 C o P u ls a tio n In s ta lle d M o n th s C o n v e n tio n a l R e -in s ta lle d Production data: GEA to CoPulsation to GEA 800 cow herd: within two months production increased 2.2kg and butterfat increased.3% yielding increased revenue of $8000US per month Goat herd consisting of 54 goats: 40600kg in 2010, 50430kg in 2011 providing a 20% increase
Additional Herd Production Data
Pounds, Milk Pounds, Milk Milk Flow Rate teat damage and irritation damage and liner crawl 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Time, Minutes Conventional 11.7 kg yield Time, Minutes CoPulsation tm Milking System 12.3 kg yield CoPulsation provides a sustained peak let down. Liner crawl and liner squall eliminated as cows milk quickly in comfort CoPulsation cows achieve milk flow rates as high as 4.5 to 6 kg/minute
Cull Rate Reduced Cull rate reduced with fewer udder infections 20 per month prior 12 per month after 7 months Udders remain healthy Cow remains healthy Data for 400 cow herd switching to CoPulsation Monthly cull rate data
Scientific Evidence University study (Journal of Dairy Science) 16:1 reduction in new Staph aureus infections Study duration (1 year) too short to evaluate environmental mastitis, more time required to improve teat canal health Multi-year side-by-side study (Int l Dairy Topics) Small commercial herd University based data SCC levels reduced 75% with CoPulsation tm Overall mastitis levels reduced 50% with CoPulsation tm Contagious mastitis virtually eliminated with CoPulsation tm Teat condition study (Int l Dairy Topics) No teat swelling caused by CoPulsation tm Milk flow study (Int l Dairy Topics) Peak flow rate maintained for about 2/3 of milking duration to only about 1/3 of duration for conventional Milking time about 10% to 20% faster with CoPulsation tm
Performance benefits Compressive liner action massages teat for a gentle, pain free milking No teat swelling, no canal damage, no milk wetting of teat Eliminates teat end pinching by liner, prevents reverse milking action by not forcing bacteria through the teat canal Calm cows, no liner crawl/squall Milk flow fully stops during rest phase allowing tissue around the teat canal to rest No teat canal damage, canals close quickly No milk back flow Prevents bacteria contamination of teat Teats dry when machine is removed Efficient milk let down Longer duration at peak let down Quick completion of milk out works well with auto-detachers
CoPulsation Milking System Pulsators Electronics Shells Liners Splitter Tees Parlor Style Pipeline Style
Installations
Cows milked with CoPulsation tm Even udders that remain high and not dropped down
Goats Milked with CoPulsation tm Goats milk quickly, no stepping, no pulling down on cluster SCC reduced, less than 500,000 all year achievable Increased production, less dumped milk 20% increase in production for John Hall herd, SCC data below 2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 SCC 2010 SCC 2011 600 400 200 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 2010: GEA 2011: CoPulsation tm Milking System
Questions to ask How will you cut antibiotic use by 50% in two years? How will you increase the average life of a dairy cow by 2 lactations by 2020? How will you prevent udder and teat damage?
Summary Consider two conclusions: Mastitis is a symptom of management (Utrecht Mastitis Conference 2011) Mastitis is a result of a failure to provide the cow with the proper milking environment Given the information provided, which conclusion best supports the evidence and experience on dairy farms? The dairy industry has taken the path of focusing on management for 50 years and still mastitis is the most expensive problem on the dairy farms
CoPulsation tm Milking System Improves udder health of dairy herd in an animal friendly manner Making quality milk a priority!
Period 2011 Period 2012 W.Schep, 140 cow herd, 2 x 6 DeLaval, since 04-2012
No clinical cases during lactation for half a year Wim Bakker, 130 cow herd, 2 x 10 DeLaval Since 04-2012 Constant scc, antibiotics on udderhealth cut in half Jan Brugging, 130 cow herd, 2 x 12 GEA Since 05-2012 From one day to the other they stopped kicking.. Hans Scholman, 100 cow herd, 2 x 8 Manus Since 06-2012 Dunno why, but there s no mastitis anymore Hans Scholman
References 1. Machine Milking, Irish Veterinary Journal, Volume 56, January 2003, author: Dr Eddie O Callaghan, Teagasc, Moorepark, Fermoy, Co Cork, Ireland 2. Effect of liner design, pulsator setting, and vacuum level on bovine teat tissue changes, Irish Veterinary Journal, Volume 57, May 2004 3. Fluid Dairy Product Quality, Boor, Journal Dairy Science 84:1-11 4. See www.copulsation.com website and click on Mastitis Conference Information & Research
Conventional milking machines proven to cause problems Teat damage & teat swelling Irish studies show conventional milking systems cause teat swelling and physical damage (references 1, 2) One in four teat canals remain open during the dry period per Randy Dingwell, Atlantic Vet. College Teats wetted with milk and bacteria Since the milking machine is one of the best washing machine ever built, the teats are bathed with milk during the milking process. Dr. Andy Johnson, NMC meeting 2000 More mastitis since converting from simultaneous to alternating pulsation (USDA replacement data) Teat ends pinched during liner closure (Dr. Forbes) Pushes bacteria up teat canal
Studies Proving Problems R. Dingwell teat ends do not close Teagasc teat swelling, canal damage U of Wash., Fox Staph aureus spread G. Mein flow rate slow down Forbes reverse milk action U. MI increase mastitis, lameness w/robot Udder dissection video