Presented to the Israel Annual Conference on Aerospace Sciences, 2009 RISK-ANALYSIS A SUPPLEMENT TO DAMAGE-TOLERANCE ANALYSIS
|
|
- Magnus Wilcox
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 RISK-ANALYSIS A SUPPLEMENT TO DAMAGE-TOLERANCE ANALYSIS Abraham Brot Engineering Division Israel Aerospace Industries Ben-Gurion Airport, Israel abrot@iai.co.il ABSTRACT Risk-analysis, based on probabilistic considerations, has been developed to determine the risk of a fatigue failure as a function of inspection methods and intervals. If the risk is found to be very small, this may allow the delaying of certain inspections. Risk-analysis can also be used to evaluate the effect of aging on the increased risk of operation. The use of risk-analysis applies a "systems type approach" to fatigue life substantiation. This paper compares two very different risk-analysis computer programs to evaluate the risk of increasing inspection intervals for a typical aircraft structure. It was concluded that riskanalysis can often be used to obtain more favorable inspection thresholds and intervals compared to classical damage-tolerance analysis, without subjecting the structure to excessive risk. Risk-analysis can also be used to evaluate the effect of service life extension on the increased probability of failure. INTRODUCTION Damage-tolerance has been used to substantiate civilian and military aircraft structures for fatigue life for more than 30 years. For the most part, the damage-tolerance approach has proved to be successful in avoiding fatigue failures. At times, aircraft must be inspected earlier, or more often than planned, due to fatigue test findings or changes to the operating mission-mix or loading spectrum. This can be very expensive to the customer, and can have a severe effect on aircraft availability. Risk-analysis, based on probabilistic considerations, can be used to determine the risk of a fatigue failure (at a specific location) as a function of inspection methods and intervals. If the risk is found to be very small, this may allow the delaying of certain inspections. Riskanalysis can also be used to evaluate the effect of aging on the increased risk of operation. The use of risk-analysis applies a "systems type approach" to fatigue life substantiation. Although risk-analysis has been primarily used for military aircraft, the FAA encourages the use of risk-analysis for certain specific instances on civilian aircraft [1]. This paper compares two very different risk-analysis computer programs to evaluate the risk of increasing inspection intervals for a typical aircraft structure. 1
2 CLASSICAL DAMAGE-TOLERANCE ANALYSIS Figure 1 describes the geometry and spectrum loading for an aluminum lug. A classical damage-tolerance analysis (DTA) was performed for the lug using NASGRO v.5 software, and the results are shown in Figure 2. The classical DTA is based on the assumption that the lug has an initial crack of 0.050", and a critical crack length, under a 30 ksi limit load, of 0.119". Inspections are specified to be performed using the "high-frequency eddy-current" (HFEC) method, which has a 90% probability of detection for a crack size of 0.105". The classical DTA method arrives at an initial (threshold) inspection at 3800 flights and subsequent inspection intervals of 500 flights. This inspection schedule will be extremely difficult and costly for the operator. The question is raised whether the inspection intervals can be increased without significantly putting the aircraft at risk? Figure 3 examines the sources of conservatism that are built-in the classical DTA, and identifies three very conservative assumptions: 1. Studies have shown that the probability that an initial crack is equal or greater than 0.050" is less than one in a million. 2. The HFEC method begins to detect cracks much smaller than 0.105" with a 20% probability of detection (POD) for a crack of 0.053" and a 50% POD for a crack of 0.070". 3. The probability that a limit load stress of 30 ksi will occur when the crack size is only 0.119" is highly unlikely. Risk-analysis software can be used to evaluate these (and other) sources of conservatism and calculate the resulting probabilities of failure if these sources of conservatism are relaxed. Gross Stress - (ksi) Exceedances per 20,000 Flights Lug Loading Spectrum P E-01 1.E+00 1.E+01 1.E+02 1.E+03 1.E+04 1.E+05 1.E+06 Exceedances Gross Stress Material: 7050-T7351; Required Residual Strength: 30 ksi D = 0.25 ; W = 0.75 ; t = 0.25 Figure 1: Test Case for Analysis 2
3 Crack Size (in) Initial Crack (0.050 ) Crack Growth, Initial to Critical (NASGRO Run) Detectable Crack Size (90% POD) using HFEC (0.105 ) Flights 1000 Flights Critical Crack Size under limit load of 30 ksi (0.119 ) Figure 2: Classical Damage-Tolerance Analysis (Resulting in an initial inspection at 3800 flights and subsequent inspections every 500 flights) Crack Size (in) Probability that initial crack is less than 1 in a million 20% POD Crack Growth, Initial to Critical (NASGRO Run) Detectable Crack Size (90% POD) using HFEC (0.105 ) 50% POD Flights 1000 Flights Critical Crack Size under limit load of 30 ksi (0.119 ) Limit load is unlikely to occur Figure 3: Sources of Conservatism in the Classical Damage-Tolerance Analysis PERFORMING RISK-ANALYSIS USING PROF SOFTWARE PRobability Of Fracture (PROF) risk-analysis software was developed by the University of Dayton Research Institute (UDRI). PROF is based solely on crack growth and it establishes the probabilities of failure mathematically. PROF was specifically developed for the use of the USAF, but is commercially available for other users. (Version 3 was released in December 2005.) The basic principle of the methodology used in PROF is shown schematically in Figure 4. An initial crack size statistical distribution is assumed by the user to be representative of the fleet for a specific location on the aircraft. These cracks grow under spectrum loading, as is shown schematically in Figure 4. During periodic inspections, some of the cracks are detected and the parts are repaired. A small portion of the cracks may reach their critical size, and may fail if a sufficiently high overload occurs. 3
4 Figure 4: Basic Methodology used in PROF Several studies have been performed to establish the equivalent initial flaw size (EIFS) distribution for typically manufactured aircraft structures [2], [3]. Some of the results of these studies are shown in Figures 5 7. Equivalent initial flaw sizes were determined by the USAF and others using fractographic analysis of aircraft fatigue failures and crack growth calculations. These are called equivalent flaws or cracks, because they are so small that the rules of linear elastic fracture mechanics do not apply. Figure 5: Distribution of Initial Flaw Sizes for A-7D and F-4C/D Aircraft [2] Figure 6: Distribution of Initial Flaw Size for Reamed Countersunk Fastener Holes [2] 4
5 Figure 7: Equivalent Initial Flaw Sizes Found by NAVAIR on P-3C Fleet [3] Figure 8 shows a family of two-parameter Weibull distributions that can be used to characterize the EIFS distributions. The AB-1 distribution was recommended as a conservative yet realistic standard (having a probability of 1 in a million for exceeding a initial crack.) [4]. Distributions AB-2 or AB-3 are more compatible with the USAF s A-7D and F-4 C/D data, as is shown in Figure 8. This present study used all five EIFS distributions shown in Figure 8. Table 1 contains the Weibull parameters that define these distributions. Table 1: Weibull Parameters Defining the Distributions Distribution Alpha Beta (in) AB AB AB AB AB Failure criteria were established for the risk-analysis by extending the loading spectrum to a level that can be expected to be exceeded once every ten lifetimes, as is shown in Figure 9. A Gumbel extreme-value distribution was used to extrapolate the spectrum data, as shown in Figure 9. The probability of crack detection (POD) distribution used in the risk-analysis for the highfrequency eddy-current (HFEC) inspection method is based on tests sponsored by the FAA [5]. This distribution is shown in Figure 10. 5
6 Exceedance Probability 1.E+00 50% 1.E-01 Exceedance Probability 1.E-02 1.E-03 1.E-04 1.E-05 AB-5 A-7D Data F-4C/D Data AB-1 Initial Cracks AB-2 Initial Cracks AB-3 Initial Cracks AB-4 Initial Cracks AB-5 Initial Cracks AB-4 AB-3 AB-2 AB-1 1.E Crack Size - in Figure 8: Initial Crack Exceedance Distributions Exceedances per 20,000 Flights Extrapolated Data using Gumbel Extreme Value Distribution Gross Stress - (ksi) Loading Spectrum E-01 1.E+00 1.E+01 1.E+02 1.E+03 1.E+04 1.E+05 1.E+06 Exceedances Figure 9: Loading Spectrum Extended Using a Gumbel Extreme-Value Distribution 6
7 Probability of Crack Detection POD Crack size (inches) Figure 10: Probability of Detection Distribution for HFEC Inspections [5] The crack growth characteristics were calculated by NASGRO v.5 software, starting from a " equivalent crack, and including estimated retardation effects. Crack growth, under the lug spectrum shown in Figure 1, will require about 180,000 flights to grow from " to 0.173", with about 166,000 flights required to grow up to a crack size of 0.010". The principal output of PROF is the hazard-rate (Figure 11) and the probability of failure since the previous inspection (Figure 12). The hazard-rate is defined as the probability of failure during next flight. The USAF has established hazard-rate criteria as 10-7 being a totally acceptable hazard rate. Hazard rate peaks ranging from 10-7 to 10-5 can be acceptable if their occurrences are limited, while hazard-rates that exceed 10-5 are never acceptable [6]. The hazard-rate function, shown in Figure 11 exhibits a saw-tooth behavior. This is due to the periodically scheduled inspections for cracks. At each inspection, the probability of crack detection is governed by the distribution shown in Figure 10. As a result of the detection of the largest cracks (and their repair), the hazard-rate drops significantly and then begins to increase again as the aircraft accumulates additional flights. At the next inspection, the process repeats. The probability of failure since the previous inspection, shown in Figure 12, behaves in a similar manner, with the same saw-tooth behavior. The USAF has not defined criteria for acceptable probabilities of failure. Another important parameter, the overall probability of failure (from time zero) is not displayed by PROF, but it can be calculated from the individual probabilities of failure that are displayed in the output. This function increases monotonically, as is shown in Table 3. 7
8 Figure 11: Hazard-Rate as a Function of Service Life (PROF Output) Figure 12: Probability of Failure as a Function of Service Life (PROF Output) 8
9 Table 2: PROF Results for Lug Analysis Based on a 30,000 Flight Service Life Initial Crack Distribution Peak Hazard Rate * Overall Probability of Failure * AB E % AB E % AB E % AB E % * - Based on an inspection threshold of 10,000 flights and an inspection interval of 2,000 flights. Spectrum overloads, per Gumbel Distribution are included. Table 3: PROF Results for Lug Analysis Based on AB-2 Initial Crack Distribution Service Life (Flights) Peak Hazard Rate * Overall Probability of Failure * 15, E % 20, E % 25, E % 30, E % * - Based on the AB-2 initial crack distribution, an inspection threshold of 10,000 flights and an inspection interval of 2,000 flights. Spectrum overloads, per Gumbel Distribution, are included. The results of the risk-analysis, performed for the lug test case, are shown in Tables 2 and 3. Table 2 shows the peak hazard-rate and the overall probability of failure of the lug, for four equivalent initial crack distributions, AB-1 to AB-4, for a 30,000 flight service life. (AB-5 was found to be extremely mild, so the results are not shown.) All the PROF analyses were based on an initial HFEC inspection at 10,000 flights and subsequent intervals of 2,000 flights. All four distributions meet the USAF hazard-rate criterion (peak hazard rate less than 10-5 ), but the overall probability of failure seems excessive (1.21%) for distribution AB-1. Table 3 shows the peak hazard-rate and overall probability of failure for distribution AB-2, as a function of service life. As expected, both the peak hazard-rate and overall probability of failure increase with increased service life. The results shown in Table 3 indicate that very reasonable results can be obtained by limiting the service life of the lug to 20,000 flights. The PROF risk-analysis results show that inspection thresholds and intervals (10,000 and 2,000 flights respectively) can be significantly increased above those determined through classical damage-tolerance analysis (3,800 and 500 flights respectively), without exposing the structure to excessive risk. Risk-analysis also provides a tool to evaluate the effect of service life on the risk of failure, a parameter that is totally absent in the classical damage-tolerance analysis. It should be noted that the initial crack distribution is not accurately known for any specific application and can only be estimated. Therefore, risk-analysis can be a valuable tool when it 9
10 is used in a comparative study. When one needs to perform an absolute study, it is best to use a family of initial crack distributions, such as those shown in Figure 8, and try to draw conclusions from the results of all of the distributions. This procedure was followed for the results shown in Table 2. PERFORMING RISK-ANALYSIS USING INSIM SOFTWARE INspection SIMulation (INSIM) risk-analysis software was developed by IAI. It uses probabilistic (Monte-Carlo) simulations to establish the probability of failure for a specific location. INSIM considers the crack-initiation life in addition to the crack growth life. (Version 2.4 of INSIM was released in August 1995.) A detailed description of INSIM can be found in [7] and [8]. Figure 13 contains a typical output from an INSIM run. In order to perform the INSIM run for this application, it was necessary to calculate the mean crack-initiation life of the lug. The stress-concentration factor (based on the net-stress) was calculated to be 4.61, and the mean crack-initiation life was calculated, using a strain-life analysis, as 46,000 flights, based on the spectrum shown in Figure 1. Two primary differences exist between PROF and INSIM, making a comparison of results difficult: PROF considers crack growth life only while INSIM considers both crack-initiation and crack growth effects, with a transition at a crack size of 0.010". PROF calculates hazard-rate and probability of failure as a function of service life while INSIM calculates only the overall probability of failure. Figure 13: INSIM Run Output Containing the Results of One Million Simulations 10
11 In order to reconcile these differences, the following operations were performed: Each initial crack distribution has a median crack size (50% of cracks exceed this value), as is shown in Table 4 and Figure 8. Using the crack growth curve from the lug analysis, the number of flights required for a median crack to grow to 0.010" was calculated. This value is also shown in Table 4, and is assumed to be comparable to the crack-initiation life used in INSIM. The comparison between PROF and INSIM results were based on the overall probability of failure which is output by INSIM and can be calculated from the PROF results. Table 4: Median Crack Size and Crack Growth Life for Each Distribution Initial Crack Distribution Median Crack Size (inches) Crack Growth Life (Median Crack to 0.01") AB ,000 flights AB ,000 flights AB ,000 flights AB ,000 flights On this basis, the comparison between the PROF and INSIM results were calculated and are shown in Figure 14. The results, presented in Figure 14 show reasonable correlation between both methods of analysis % INSIM Solution 1.000% AB-1 PROF Solution Probability of Failure 0.100% AB-2 AB % 0.001% 10,000 30,000 50,000 70,000 90, , ,000 AB-4 Crack-Initiation Life [INSIM] or Crack Growth Life from a Median Initial Crack until 0.01" [PROF] (Flights) Figure 14: Comparison of Results for Risk-Analysis Performed by PROF and INSIM 11
12 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS Risk-analysis can often be used to obtain more favorable inspection thresholds and intervals compared to classical damage-tolerance analysis, without subjecting the structure to excessive risk. Risk-analysis can be used to evaluate the effect of service life extension on the increased probability of failure. PROF and INSIM results showed reasonable correlation when compared on the basis of crack-initiation life (for INSIM) and crack growth life from a median crack to inch (for PROF). RERERENCES [1] FAA Advisory Circular C, "Damage Tolerance and Fatigue Evaluation of Structure", Federal Aviation Administration, [2] Swift, T., "Verification Methods for Damage Tolerance Evaluation of Aircraft Structures", Proceedings of the 12 th Symposium of the International Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue (ICAF), Toulouse, [3] Iyyer, N. et al "Managing Aging Aircraft Using Risk Assessment Models Lessons Learned from P-3C Fleet", Proceedings of the 24 th Symposium of the International Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue (ICAF), Naples, [4] Torng, T. Y. et al, "B1 Maintenance Schedule Impact Based on Risk Assessment Results", Proceedings of the 2007 USAF Aircraft Structural Integrity Program (ASIP) Conference, Palm Springs, [5] Spencer, F. W., "Eddy Current Inspection Reliability at Airline Inspection Facilities", Proceedings of the 1994 USAF Aircraft Structural Integrity Program (ASIP) Conference, San Antonio, [6] Gallagher, J. P., "A Review of the Philosophies, Processes, Methods and Approaches that Protect In-Service Aircraft from the Scourge of Fatigue Failures", Proceedings of the 24 th Symposium of the International Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue (ICAF), Naples, [7] Brot, A., "Evaluating Strategies for Minimizing Fatigue Failures in Metallic Structures", Proceedings of the 2004 USAF Aircraft Structural Integrity Program (ASIP) Conference, Memphis, [8] Brot, A., "Using Probabilistic Simulations in Order to Minimize Fatigue Failures in Metallic Structures", Proceedings of the 45 th Israel Annual Conference on Aerospace Sciences,
ASSESSING THE RELIABILITY OF FAIL-SAFE STRUCTURES INTRODUCTION
ASSESSING THE RELIABILITY OF FAIL-SAFE STRUCTURES Abraham Brot * Abstract: A computer simulation method is described, that can be used to assess the reliability of a dual-path fail-safe design. The method
More informationPC-21 A Damage Tolerant Aircraft. Paper presented at the ICAF 2009 Symposium by Lukas Schmid
PC-21 A Damage Tolerant Aircraft Paper presented at the ICAF 2009 Symposium by Lukas Schmid PC-21 A Damage Tolerant Aircraft 12.05.2009 2 Acknowledgment Markus Gottier, Gottier Engineering Dave Boorman,
More informationDamage Tolerance Inspection Methodology for Slow Crack Growth Metallic Structure
Structures Bulletin ASC/EN Bldg 28, 2145 Monahan Way WPAFB, OH 45433-7101 Phone 937-656-9956 Number: EN-SB-12-003 Date: 19 July 2012 Subject: Damage Tolerance Inspection Methodology for Slow Crack Growth
More informationRisk-Based Condition Assessment and Maintenance Engineering for Aging Aircraft Structure Components
Risk-Based Condition Assessment and Maintenance Engineering for Aging Aircraft Structure Components Dr. Dan M. Ghiocel* and Dr. Letian Wang Ghiocel Predictive Technologies Inc. 6 South Main St., 2 nd Floor,
More informationDAMAGE-TOLERANCE SUBSTANTIATION OF THE GALAXY EXECUTIVE JET
Presented to the ICAF 1999 Conference, Seattle, WA, 1999 DAMAGE-TOLERANCE SUBSTANTIATION OF THE GALAXY EXECUTIVE JET Abraham Brot, Shmaryahu Afnaim and Zvi Granot * SYNOPSIS This paper describes the fatigue
More informationFailure Data Analysis for Aircraft Maintenance Planning
Failure Data Analysis for Aircraft Maintenance Planning M. Tozan, A. Z. Al-Garni, A. M. Al-Garni, and A. Jamal Aerospace Engineering Department King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals Abstract This
More informationNASA AEROSPACE PRESSURE VESSEL SAFETY STANDARD
NSS/HP-1740.1 This Standard was CANCELLED on Jul 30 2002 22 FEBRUARY 1974 NASA AEROSPACE PRESSURE VESSEL SAFETY STANDARD OFFICE OF SAFETY AND RELIABILITY AND QUALITY ASSURANCE NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND
More informationFATIGUE, FAIL-SAFE, AND DAMAGE TOLERANCE EVALUATION OF METALLIC STRUCTURE FOR NORMAL, UTILITY, ACROBATIC, AND COMMUTER CATEGORY AIRPLANES
AC 23-13A FATIGUE, FAIL-SAFE, AND DAMAGE TOLERANCE EVALUATION OF METALLIC STRUCTURE FOR NORMAL, UTILITY, ACROBATIC, AND COMMUTER CATEGORY AIRPLANES September 29, 2005 For sale by the Superintendent of
More informationSELECTED ASPECTS RELATED TO THE APPLIED LOADS CONTROL DURING FATIGUE TESTS OF A METALLIC AIRFRAME
Fatigue of Aircraft Structures Vol. 1 (2014) 102-106 10.1515/fas-2014-0010 SELECTED ASPECTS RELATED TO THE APPLIED LOADS CONTROL DURING FATIGUE TESTS OF A METALLIC AIRFRAME Józef Brzęczek Jerzy Chodur
More informationABS TECHNICAL PAPERS 2005
OTC 17535 Structural Reliability Applications in Risk-Based Inspection Plans and Their Sensitivities to Different Environmental Conditions A. P. Ku and R. E. Spong, Energo Engineering; C. Serratella, ABS
More informationAn Investigation of Small-Crack Effects in Various Aircraft Engine Rotor Materials
An Investigation of Small-Crack Effects in Various Aircraft Engine Rotor Materials Propulsion Safety and Affordable Readiness (P-SAR) Conference Jacksonville, Florida March 20-22, 2012 Craig McClung Vikram
More informationPolicy for Evaluation of Certification Maintenance Requirements
Circular No. 1-319 Policy for Evaluation of Certification Maintenance Requirements April 11, 2013 First Issue Airworthiness Division, Aviation Safety and Security Department Japan Civil Aviation Bureau
More informationNKS PODRIS project. Importance of inspection reliability assumptions on piping failure probability estimates
NKS PODRIS project Importance of inspection reliability assumptions on piping failure probability estimates Kaisa Simola, Otso Cronvall & Ilkka Männistö (VTT) Jens Gunnars, Peter Dillström & Lars Averlind
More informationDiscussion on the Selection of the Recommended Fish Passage Design Discharge
Discussion on the Selection of the Recommended Fish Passage Design Discharge Introduction The provision of fish passage is a requirement for most proposed culvert and bridge installations in Alberta, depending
More informationCOMPUTATION of life expectancy of structural components is
JOURNAL OF AIRCRAFT Vol. 45, No. 1, January February 2008 Efficient Reliability-Based Design and Inspection of Stiffened Panels Against Fatigue Amit A. Kale, Raphael T. Haftka, and Bhavani V. Sankar University
More information(DD/MMM/YYYY): 10/01/2013 IP
Title: Submitter: CPCP for Safe Life Items EASA, MRB Section Applies To: Vol 1: Vol 2: Both: X Issue: Problem: A Corrosion Prevention and Control Programme (CPCP) is required for all primary aircraft structure
More informationJustification of Risk Reduction through In-Service Inspection / REDUCE
NUGENIA+ WP6.12 Justification of Risk Reduction through In-Service Inspection / REDUCE Jens Gunnars Inspecta Technology AB jens.gunnars@inspecta.com WP6.12 Task Leader NUGENIA+ Final Seminar, Helsinki
More informationMIL-STD-883G METHOD
STEADY-STATE LIFE 1. PURPOSE. The steady-state life test is performed for the purpose of demonstrating the quality or reliability of devices subjected to the specified conditions over an extended time
More information3. Real-time operation and review of complex circuits, allowing the weighing of alternative design actions.
PREFERRED RELIABILITY PAGE 1 OF 5 PRACTICES VOLTAGE & TEMPERATURE MARGIN TESTING Practice: Voltage and Temperature Margin Testing (VTMT) is the practice of exceeding the expected flight limits of voltage,
More informationA FINITE ELEMENT PROCEDURE TO MODEL THE EFFECT OF HYDROSTATIC TESTING ON SUBSEQUENT FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH
Proceedings of the International Pipeline Conference & Exposition IPC216 September 26-3, 216, Calgary, Alberta, Canada IPC216-64563 A FINITE ELEMENT PROCEDURE TO MODEL THE EFFECT OF HYDROSTATIC TESTING
More informationAnalysis of Operating Loads on an Aircraft s Vertical Stabilizer on the Basis of Recorded Data
A publication of CHEMICAL ENGINEERING TRANSACTIONS VOL. 33, 2013 Guest Editors: Enrico Zio, Piero Baraldi Copyright 2013, AIDIC Servizi S.r.l., ISBN 978-88-95608-24-2; ISSN 1974-9791 The Italian Association
More informationDetermination of the Design Load for Structural Safety Assessment against Gas Explosion in Offshore Topside
Determination of the Design Load for Structural Safety Assessment against Gas Explosion in Offshore Topside Migyeong Kim a, Gyusung Kim a, *, Jongjin Jung a and Wooseung Sim a a Advanced Technology Institute,
More informationThe risk assessment of ships manoeuvring on the waterways based on generalised simulation data
Safety and Security Engineering II 411 The risk assessment of ships manoeuvring on the waterways based on generalised simulation data L. Gucma Maritime University of Szczecin, Poland Abstract This paper
More informationAssessment of correlations between NDE parameters and tube structural integrity for PWSCC at U-bends
Assessment of correlations between NDE parameters and tube structural integrity for PWSCC at U-bends S. Bakhtiari, T. W. Elmer, Z. Zeng and S. Majumdar Nuclear Engineering Division Argonne National Laboratory
More informationAutomated Design-Based Compaction Criteria for Airport Pavements Using FAARFIELD
Automated Design-Based Compaction Criteria for Airport Pavements Using FAARFIELD D. R. Brill Federal Aviation Administration, Airport Technology R&D Branch, ANG-E262, William J. Hughes Technical Center,
More informationThe Use of ILI In Dent Assessments
The Use of ILI In Dent Assessments Prepared for: 2014 CRUG Conference Date: 11 September 2014 Prepared by: Rhett Dotson, PE Contributions from Dr. Chris Alexander and Markus Ginten Contents Current Dent
More informationEMERGENCY AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVE
EASA EMERGENCY AIRWORTHINESS DIRECTIVE AD No.: 2007 0108 -E Date: 18 April 2007 No person may operate an aircraft to which an Airworthiness Directive applies, except in accordance with the requirements
More informationASSESSMENT AND ANALYSIS OF PIPELINE BUCKLES
ASSESSMENT AND ANALYSIS OF PIPELINE BUCKLES GE Oil & Gas PII Pipeline Solutions Inessa Yablonskikh Principal Consultant Aberdeen, November, 14 th 2007 Assessment And Analysis Of Pipeline Buckles Introduction
More informationCONVECTION SECTION FAILURE ANALYSIS AND FITNESS-FOR-SERVICE ASSESSMENT
ASSET INTEGRITY INTELLIGENCE CONVECTION SECTION FAILURE ANALYSIS AND FITNESS-FOR-SERVICE ASSESSMENT JAMES R. WIDRIG, Manager Advanced Engineering at Quest Integrity Group VOLUME 23, ISSUE 6 NOVEMBER DECEMBER
More informationA method for evaluation of in-service fatigue cracks
Engineering Failure Analysis 12 (2005) 13 24 www.elsevier.com/locate/engfailanal A method for evaluation of in-service fatigue cracks L. Molent a, *, R. Singh b, J. Woolsey c a Air Vehicles Division, Defence
More informationSafety-Critical Systems
Software Testing & Analysis (F22ST3) Safety-Critical Systems Andrew Ireland School of Mathematical and Computer Science Heriot-Watt University Edinburgh Software Testing & Analysis (F22ST3) 2 What Are
More informationFLIGHT TEST RISK ASSESSMENT THREE FLAGS METHOD
FLIGHT TEST RISK ASSESSMENT THREE FLAGS METHOD Author: Maximilian Kleinubing BS. Field: Aeronautical Engineering, Flight Test Operations Keywords: Flight Test, Safety Assessment, Flight Test Safety Assessment
More informationPressure Strength Test Requirements for Hermetic Refrigerant Compressor Housings Using Fatigue Analysis
Purdue University Purdue e-pubs International Compressor Engineering Conference School of Mechanical Engineering 1998 Pressure Strength Test Requirements for Hermetic Refrigerant Compressor Housings Using
More informationSample Applications of the Second Generation Intact Stability Criteria Robustness and Consistency Analysis
Proceedings of the 16 th International Ship Stability Workshop, 5-7 June 2017, Belgrade, Serbia 1 Sample Applications of the Second Generation Intact Stability Criteria Robustness and Consistency Analysis
More informationEvaluation of Alternative Life Assessment Approaches Using P-3 SLAP Test Results
Evaluation of Alternative Life Assessment Approaches Using P-3 SLAP Test Results David Mongru, Phil Jackson, Kai Maxfield and Chris Wallbrink Air Vehicles Division Defence Science and Technology Organisation
More informationRELIABILITY-CENTERED MAINTENANCE (RCM) EVALUATION IN THE INDUSTRY APPLICATION, CASE STUDY: FERTILIZER COMPANY, INDONESIA
RELIABILITY-CENTERED MAINTENANCE (RCM) EVALUATION IN THE INDUSTRY APPLICATION, CASE STUDY: FERTILIZER COMPANY, INDONESIA Rahayu Khasanah Department of Industrial Engineering, Institute of Science and Technology
More informationAdvisory Circular (AC)
Advisory Circular (AC) Certification of Large Aeroplanes in the Restricted Category, Used for Special Purpose Operations File No. 5009-6-525 AC No. 525-012 RDIMS No. 1140123-V1 Issue No. 02 Issuing Branch
More informationBatch centrifuge basket design.
1. Abstract. Batch centrifuge basket design. G.C.Grimwood. Director. A.Ainsworth. Chief Engineer. Thomas Broadbent & Sons Ltd. tbs@broadbent.co.uk A short overview of batch centrifuge basket design is
More informationStandard Pneumatic Test Procedure Requirements for Piping Systems
the pressure equipment safety authority Standard Pneumatic Test Procedure Requirements for Piping Systems AB-522 Edition 2, Rev. 1 Issued 2016-10-24 Table of Contents FOREWORD... 1 1.0 INTRODUCTION...
More informationSpecial edition paper
Development of a Track Management Method for Shinkansen Speed Increases Shigeaki Ono** Takehiko Ukai* We have examined the indicators of appropriate track management that represent the ride comfort when
More informationREGULATORY OBSERVATION
RO unique no.: REGULATORY OBSERVATION REGULATOR TO COMPLETE RO-ABWR-0046 Date sent: 20 th April 2015 Acknowledgement required by: 08 th May 2015 Agreement of Resolution Plan required by: 14 th May 2015
More informationAutodesk Moldflow Communicator Process settings
Autodesk Moldflow Communicator 212 Process settings Revision 1, 3 March 211. Contents Chapter 1 Process settings....................................... 1 Profiles.................................................
More informationDefense Technical Information Center Compilation Part Notice
UNCLASSIFIED Defense Technical Information Center Compilation Part Notice ADPO 11090 TITLE: Altitude Decompression Sickness Risk Prediction Research DISTRIBUTION: Approved for public release, distribution
More informationSubject: Structural Certification Criteria Date: 10/11/18 Policy No: PS-AIR for Antennas, Radomes, and Other External Modifications
Policy Statement Subject: Structural Certification Criteria Date: 10/11/18 Policy No: PS-AIR-25-17 for Antennas, Radomes, and Other External Modifications Initiated By: AIR-675 Summary This policy statement
More informationSafety Standards Acknowledgement and Consent (SSAC) CAP 1395
Safety Standards Acknowledgement and Consent (SSAC) CAP 1395 Contents Published by the Civil Aviation Authority, 2015 Civil Aviation Authority, Aviation House, Gatwick Airport South, West Sussex, RH6 0YR.
More informationInvestigation of Inspection Performance on Cracked Railway Axles
ECNDT 2006 - Fr.1.3.2 Investigation of Inspection Performance on Cracked Railway Axles John RUDLIN, Amin MUHAMMED, Charles SCHNEIDER TWI Limited, Cambridge, UK Abstract. Failure of railway axles, although
More informationPre Feasibility Study Report Citiwater Cleveland Bay Purification Plant
SOLAR POWER SPECIALISTS.Pure Power ACN 074 127 718 ABN 85 074 127 718 POWER MAGIC PTY LTD 245 INGHAM RD GARBUTT QLD 4814 Phone: 1800 068 977 Fax: 07 4725 2479 Email: FNQSOLAR@bigpond.com Pre Feasibility
More informationCertification Memorandum. Parts Detached from Aeroplanes
Certification Memorandum Parts Detached from Aeroplanes EASA Proposed CM No.: CM 21.A-A-001 Issue 01 issued 20 April 2018 Regulatory requirement(s): 21.A.3B (b), AMC&GM 21.A.3B (b) EASA Certification Memoranda
More informationDEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY NAVAL AIR SYSTEMS COMMAND RADM WILLIAM A. MOFFEIT BUILDING BUSE ROAD, BLDG 2272 PATUXENT RIVER, MARYLAND,
- DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY NAVAL AIR SYSTEMS COMMAND RADM WILLIAM A. MOFFEIT BUILDING 47123 BUSE ROAD, BLDG 2272 PATUXENT RIVER, MARYLAND, 20670-1547 NAVAIRINST 4790.20C AIR-6.0 NA VAIR INSTRUCTION 4790.20C
More informationFinite Element Analysis of an Aluminium Bike Frame
Finite Element Analysis of an Aluminium Bike Frame Word Count: 1484 1 1. Introduction Each new bike model must pass a series of structural tests before being released for public retail. The purpose of
More informationAirport Forecasting Prof. Richard de Neufville
Airport Forecasting Prof. Richard de Neufville Istanbul Technical University Air Transportation Management M.Sc. Program Airport Planning and Management / RdN Airport Planning and Management Module 07
More informationLife Extension of Mobile Offshore Units
Life Extension of Mobile Offshore Units Operation of classified aging units Sigmund Røine DNV Mobile Offshore Units in Operation Presentation content MOU integrity during operation Survey Principles for
More informationSafety Analysis: Event Classification
IAEA Training Course on Safety Assessment of NPPs to Assist Decision Making Safety Analysis: Event Classification Lecturer Lesson IV 1_2 Workshop Information IAEA Workshop City, Country XX - XX Month,
More informationCFD Based Approach for VCE Risk Assessment
CFD Based Approach for VCE Risk Assessment 2009 MKOPSC International Symposium Anna Qiao, Steven Zhang, Asmund Huser DNV Energy Objective Determine the maximum design load at a specified frequency Provide
More informationReliability predictions in product development. Proof Engineering Co
Reliability predictions in product development Proof Engineering Co Contents Review of reliability theory Ways to predict part reliability Converting parts reliability into a system reliability Ways to
More informationA quantitative software testing method for hardware and software integrated systems in safety critical applications
A quantitative software testing method for hardware and software integrated systems in safety critical applications Hai ang a, Lixuan Lu* a a University of Ontario Institute of echnology, Oshawa, ON, Canada
More informationPOWER Quantifying Correction Curve Uncertainty Through Empirical Methods
Proceedings of the ASME 2014 Power Conference POWER2014 July 28-31, 2014, Baltimore, Maryland, USA POWER2014-32187 Quantifying Correction Curve Uncertainty Through Empirical Methods ABSTRACT Christopher
More informationSECTION 2 HYDROLOGY AND FLOW REGIMES
SECTION 2 HYDROLOGY AND FLOW REGIMES In this section historical streamflow data from permanent USGS gaging stations will be presented and discussed to document long-term flow regime trends within the Cache-Bayou
More informationRegional Analysis of Extremal Wave Height Variability Oregon Coast, USA. Heidi P. Moritz and Hans R. Moritz
Regional Analysis of Extremal Wave Height Variability Oregon Coast, USA Heidi P. Moritz and Hans R. Moritz U. S. Army Corps of Engineers, Portland District Portland, Oregon, USA 1. INTRODUCTION This extremal
More informationFuselage, Wings and Stabilising Surfaces
Fuselage, Wings and Stabilising Surfaces Chapter 1 DESIGN PHILOSOPHIES The aircraft manufacturer will attempt to design an aircraft to take into account all the loads that it may experience in flight.
More informationA hose layline contains important information for specifying the replacement assembly: manufacturer, hose trade name, working pressure and hose ID.
CONTENTS Introduction Pressure Pressure Drop Temperature Rating Bend Radius Conclusion Additional Information SIDEBAR: Understanding Hydraulic Hose Reinforcement INTRODUCTION Hydraulic hose has a finite
More informationEvery things under control High-Integrity Pressure Protection System (HIPPS)
Every things under control www.adico.co info@adico.co Table Of Contents 1. Introduction... 2 2. Standards... 3 3. HIPPS vs Emergency Shut Down... 4 4. Safety Requirement Specification... 4 5. Device Integrity
More informationHIGH FLOW PROTECTION FOR VARIABLE SPEED PUMPS
Proceedings of the First Middle East Turbomachinery Symposium February 13-16, 2011, Doha, Qatar HIGH FLOW PROTECTION FOR VARIABLE SPEED PUMPS Amer A. Al-Dhafiri Rotating Equipment Engineer Nabeel M. Al-Odan
More informationEnergy Output. Outline. Characterizing Wind Variability. Characterizing Wind Variability 3/7/2015. for Wind Power Management
Energy Output for Wind Power Management Spring 215 Variability in wind Distribution plotting Mean power of the wind Betz' law Power density Power curves The power coefficient Calculator guide The power
More informationFatigue Life Evaluation of Cross Tubes of Helicopter Skid Landing Gear System
IJSRD - International Journal for Scientific Research & Development Vol. 3, Issue 04, 2015 ISSN (online): 2321-0613 Fatigue Life Evaluation of Cross Tubes of Helicopter Skid Landing Gear System Madhu S
More informationMIKE NET AND RELNET: WHICH APPROACH TO RELIABILITY ANALYSIS IS BETTER?
MIKE NET AND RELNET: WIC APPROAC TO RELIABILITY ANALYSIS IS BETTER? Alexandr Andrianov Water and Environmental Engineering, Department of Chemical Engineering, Lund University P.O. Box 124, SE-221 00 Lund,
More informationForecasting. Forecasting In Practice
ing Dr. Richard de Neufville Professor of Engineering Systems and Civil and Environmental Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology ing In Practice Objective: To present procedure. Topics: 1. Premises
More informationESTIMATION OF THE DESIGN WIND SPEED BASED ON
The Seventh Asia-Pacific Conference on Wind Engineering, November 8-12, 2009, Taipei, Taiwan ESTIMATION OF THE DESIGN WIND SPEED BASED ON UNCERTAIN PARAMETERS OF THE WIND CLIMATE Michael Kasperski 1 1
More informationHelicopter Safety Recommendation Summary for Small Operators
Helicopter Safety Recommendation Summary for Small Operators Prepared by the International Helicopter Safety Team September 2009 Introduction This document is intended to provide a summary of the initial
More informationGeometric Categories as Intersection Safety Evaluation Tools
Geometric Categories as Intersection Safety Evaluation Tools John R. Campbell Ayres Associates N19 W24075 Riverwood Drive, Suite 300 Waukesha, WI 53188 campbellj@ayresassociates.com Keith K. Knapp Engineering
More informationAnalysis of Variance. Copyright 2014 Pearson Education, Inc.
Analysis of Variance 12-1 Learning Outcomes Outcome 1. Understand the basic logic of analysis of variance. Outcome 2. Perform a hypothesis test for a single-factor design using analysis of variance manually
More informationReliability Analysis of the LabTecta Bearing Protector
Reliability Analysis of the LabTecta Bearing Protector This article examines the statistical life expectancy of the LabTecta bearing protector, supplied by AESSEAL. The LabTecta is an IEEE 841-2001 and
More informationAn Investigation of a Safety Level in Terms of. Excessive Acceleration in Rough Seas
Proceedings of the h International Conference on the Stability of Ships and Ocean Vehicles, 4-9 June 5, Glasgow, UK. An Investigation of a Safety Level in Terms of Excessive Acceleration in Rough Seas
More informationUKOPA Dent Management Strategy
UKOPA Dent Management Strategy 1 Background Pipelines are thin shell structures which are susceptible to geometric distortions and dents during handling, construction, and operation. These dents and distortions,
More informationAvailability analysis of railway track circuit
Availability analysis of railway track circuit A P Patra * and U Kumar Luleå Railway Research Center, Division of Operation and Maintenance Engineering, Luleå University of Technology, Sweden Abstract:
More informationKiefner & Associates, Inc.
Kiefner & Associates, Inc. KAPA FAQs What does KAPA stand for? KAPA is an acronym for Kiefner & Associates Pipe Assessment. What does KAPA do? KAPA calculates an estimated failure pressure of a pipe affected
More informationStudy to Establish Relations for the Relative Strength of API 650 Cone Roof Roof-to-Shell and Shell-to- Bottom Joints
Thunderhead Engineering Consultants I N C O R P O R A T E D 1006 Poyntz Ave. Manhattan, KS 66502-5459 785-770-8511 www. thunderheadeng.com Study to Establish Relations for the Relative Strength of API
More informationJ. J. Daly Metal Improvement Company Paramus New Jersey USA
Shot Peening-Current Trends, Future Prospects J. J. Daly Metal Improvement Company Paramus New Jersey USA The shot peening process is sparingly used compared to other processes such as heat treating, plating,
More informationDATA ITEM DESCRIPTION Title: Failure Modes, Effects, and Criticality Analysis Report
DATA ITEM DESCRIPTION Title: Failure Modes, Effects, and Criticality Analysis Report Number: Approval Date: 20160106 AMSC Number: N9616 Limitation: No DTIC Applicable: Yes GIDEP Applicable: Yes Defense
More informationFatigue Analysis of a LUG Assembly
LESSON 9 Fatigue Analysis of a LUG Assembly Objectives: Use all three methods of Fatigue life estimation to design the lug assembly. Use the total life method to estimate the fatigue life of the weld.
More informationQuality Planning for Software Development
Quality Planning for Software Development Tom Walton Alcatel Networks tom.waltoniliiialcatel.com Abstract A historical project is used as a reference model for the verification planning process. The planning
More informationPACIFIC BLUEFIN TUNA STOCK ASSESSMENT
PACIFIC BLUEFIN TUNA STOCK ASSESSMENT SUMMARY 19-21 December 2012 Webinar PACIFIC BLUEFIN TUNA STOCK ASSESSMENT SUMMARY 1. Stock Identification and Distribution Pacific bluefin tuna (Thunnus orientalis)
More informationAcoustic Emission Testing of The Shell 0f Electromagnetic Valve
17th World Conference on Nondestructive Testing, 25-28 Oct 2008, Shanghai, China Acoustic Emission Testing of The Shell 0f Electromagnetic Valve guozhen XU 1, yiwei CHEN 1, zhihua CAO 2 ABSTRACT Shanghai
More informationPresented to the International Technical Rescue Symposium, November Abstract
Presented to the International Technical Rescue Symposium, November 21 Presented by: Chuck Weber, PMI Quality Manager Abstract This paper presents the results of 162 individual drop tests performed at
More informationCorrelation Between the Fluid Structure Interaction Method and Experimental Analysis of Bending Stress of a Variable Capacity Compressor Suction Valve
Purdue University Purdue e-pubs International Compressor Engineering Conference School of Mechanical Engineering 24 Correlation Between the Fluid Structure Interaction Method and Experimental Analysis
More informationSTD-3-V1M4_1.7.1_AND_ /15/2015 page 1 of 6. TNI Standard. EL-V1M4 Sections and September 2015
page 1 of 6 TNI Standard EL-V1M4 Sections 1.7.1 and 1.7.2 September 2015 Description This TNI Standard has been taken through all of the voting stages and has received consensus approval by the TNI membership.
More information2600T Series Pressure Transmitters Plugged Impulse Line Detection Diagnostic. Pressure Measurement Engineered solutions for all applications
Application Description AG/266PILD-EN Rev. C 2600T Series Pressure Transmitters Plugged Impulse Line Detection Diagnostic Pressure Measurement Engineered solutions for all applications Increase plant productivity
More informationAirfield Pavement Smoothness Airport Pavement Workshop. Michael Gerardi APR Consultants
Airfield Pavement Smoothness Airport Pavement Workshop Michael Gerardi APR Consultants Presentation Overview Why is Smoothness Important New Pavement Acceptance Criteria - (FAA AC 150/5370) 16-Foot Straightedge
More informationTRAFFIC STUDY GUIDELINES Clarksville Street Department
TRAFFIC STUDY GUIDELINES Clarksville Street Department 9/1/2009 Introduction Traffic studies are used to help the city determine potential impacts to the operation of the surrounding roadway network. Two
More informationGravity Probe-B System Reliability Plan
Gravity Probe-B System Reliability Plan Document #P0146 Samuel P. Pullen N. Jeremy Kasdin Gaylord Green Ben Taller Hansen Experimental Physics Labs: Gravity Probe-B Stanford University January 23, 1998
More informationFATIGUE LIFE EVALUATION OF CRITICAL LOCATIONS IN AIRCRAFT STRUCTURES USING VIRTUAL FATIGUE TEST
ICAS2002 CONGRESS FATIGUE LIFE EVALUATION OF CRITICAL LOCATIONS IN AIRCRAFT STRUCTURES USING VIRTUAL FATIGUE TEST Jarkko Tikka Patria Keywords: fatigue life, finite element method, operational loads measurement
More informationReliability Analysis Including External Failures for Low Demand Marine Systems
Reliability Analysis Including External Failures for Low Demand Marine Systems KIM HyungJu a*, HAUGEN Stein a, and UTNE Ingrid Bouwer b a Department of Production and Quality Engineering NTNU, Trondheim,
More informationSIL Safety Manual. ULTRAMAT 6 Gas Analyzer for the Determination of IR-Absorbing Gases. Supplement to instruction manual ULTRAMAT 6 and OXYMAT 6
ULTRAMAT 6 Gas Analyzer for the Determination of IR-Absorbing Gases SIL Safety Manual Supplement to instruction manual ULTRAMAT 6 and OXYMAT 6 ULTRAMAT 6F 7MB2111, 7MB2117, 7MB2112, 7MB2118 ULTRAMAT 6E
More informationSPE The paper gives a brief description and the experience gained with WRIPS applied to water injection wells. The main
SPE 102831 Online Water-Injection Optimization and Prevention of Reservoir Damage Bjørn Øyvind Bringedal, Svein Arne Morud, Nicolas Alexander Hall, ABB; Gary Huseman, Shell Copyright 2006, Society of Petroleum
More informationUpdated Roundabout Analysis Methodology
Updated Roundabout Analysis Methodology In 1998, the Transportation Planning Analysis Unit (TPAU) working as part of the Roundabout Task Group selected the interim roundabout methodologies of the SIDRA
More informationAUTOMATED ULTRASONIC INSPECTION FOR CRACK DETECTION AT F-111 LOWER WING SKIN FASTENER HOLES
12 th A-PCNDT 2006 Asia-Pacific Conference on NDT, 5 th 10 th Nov 2006, Auckland, New Zealand AUTOMATED ULTRASONIC INSPECTION FOR CRACK DETECTION AT F-111 LOWER WING SKIN FASTENER HOLES Cayt Harding, Geoffrey
More informationSTRESS ANALYSIS OF BICYCLE PADDLE AND OPTIMIZED BY FINITE ELEMENT METHOD. S. Abeygunasekara 1, T. M. M. Amarasekara 2
- 96 - STRESS ANALYSIS OF BICYCLE PADDLE AND OPTIMIZED BY FINITE ELEMENT METHOD S. Abeygunasekara 1, T. M. M. Amarasekara 2 1 Faculty of Engineering & Technology, Colombo International Nautical Engineering
More informationIncompressible Potential Flow. Panel Methods (3)
Incompressible Potential Flow Panel Methods (3) Outline Some Potential Theory Derivation of the Integral Equation for the Potential Classic Panel Method Program PANEL Subsonic Airfoil Aerodynamics Issues
More informationy ) s x x )(y i (x i r = 1 n 1 s y Statistics Lecture 7 Exploring Data , y 2 ,y n (x 1 ),,(x n ),(x 2 ,y 1 How two variables vary together
Statistics 111 - Lecture 7 Exploring Data Numerical Summaries for Relationships between Variables Administrative Notes Homework 1 due in recitation: Friday, Feb. 5 Homework 2 now posted on course website:
More informationE. MENDOZA, C. KEMPEN, Y. ESTERKIN, S. SUN, K. SUSKO and J. GOGLIA
6th European Workshop on Structural Health Monitoring - Poster 20 Progress Towards the Development and Qualification of an All Optical Temperature and Pressure Compensated Fiber Optic Oxygen Sensor for
More information