Sustainability Benefits Of Network Wide Roundabout Use Case Study of Carmel, Indiana Presented By: Michael McBride PE Carmel City Engineer Carmel, Indiana Carmel, Indiana 1996 Carmel, Indiana Population 38,000 up from 25,000 in 1990 Jurisdictional Area of 13 Square Miles Rapid Population Growth was Expected to Continue Population Growth Means Growth in Traffic An Abundance of 4-Way Stop Controlled Intersections and some Signalized Intersections were Contributing to Congestion in Peak Hours. Mayor Jim Brainard Takes Office Of Mayor Illinois Street and 126 th Street Westfield Boulevard and 96 th Street Carmel Introduces Roundabouts 1997 Mayor Jim Brainard Proved Quickly to be a Driven Leader With Exceptional Vision Clear Understanding That Safe, Efficient Transportation Infrastructure Promotes Quality of Life & Successful Economic Development Awareness of Roundabout Success in Other Areas (England and Vail, CO) Insisted on Inclusion of Roundabouts In Hazel Dell Project In Spite of Opposition from Outspoken Minority Carmel s First Roundabouts Hazel Dell Parkway Corridor Constructed in 1998 Two Intersections Along This 5-Mile, Four-Lane Boulevard Were Chosen to be Controlled by Multi- Lane Roundabouts Limited Roundabout Design Guidance Available Designers Referenced British and Australian Standards Designs Were Reviewed by Vail Roundabout Designers as well as British Designers Hazel Dell Pkwy Video Clip 1
Roundabout Benefits Recognized Safety! Safety! Safety! Less Severe Crashes Means Lower Cost Crashes Construction and Operation Cost Savings Efficiency Benefits of Roundabouts Environmental Benefits Aesthetic & Quality of Life Benefits Roadway Improvements Present Opportunity To Enhance Property Value & Encourage Private Investment First Roundabouts A Success Hazel Dell Roundabout Considered a Great Success Roundabouts Gain Public Acceptance In Carmel Four Roundabouts Constructed in Brainard s First Term ( 96-99) Success Of Early Roundabouts Prompt City Officials to Rethink Use of Roundabouts in Comprehensive Plan Planning Incorporates Roundabouts One Mile Grid Public Land Survey Road System Blank Slate for Development Planning Incorporates Roundabouts Subdivision Infill With Internal Street Connectivity Despite Connectivity Traffic Grows on Primary Road Grid Planning Incorporates Roundabouts Greater Capacity Needed on Primary Grid Streets But No One Wants to Live Next to a Highway Roundabouts The Obvious Choice Desire to FULLY and Safely Utilize the City s Existing Grid System of Streets City Land Use Plans Encouraged Traditional Neighborhood Development, Wide Nodes, Narrow Roads Concept Equally Functional System of Parallel Roads That Maximizes Single Lane Capacity. Pedestrian and Bicycle Friendly Transportation Corridors Maintain Residential Roadway Experience When Possible 2
Roundabout Implementation Plan Carmel Roundabout Locations Access Management Preservation of Residential Roadway Feel Requires Strict Access Management Policy in Conjunction with Roundabouts Access Management Roundabouts at Blvd. Street Junctions Provide Safe U-Turn Opportunity Access Management Quality of Life Benefits 3
Quality of Life Benefits Westfield Blvd. & 96 th St. Signal Conversion Video Comparison Before & After Carmel Experiences Safety Benefits City Wide Crash Data 2002 2006 Accident Damage Cost Savings Average Cost of Accident Signal $10,500 % Accidents With Injury at All Intersections 29% % Accidents % Accidents With Injury at With Injury at Single Lane Roundabouts Dual Lane Roundabouts 4% 7% vs. Roundabout $2,500 Average Cost of Accident has been Reduced by $3,000 (Statistics from Carmel Police Dept. 2007) Carmel, Indiana Carmel s Population Grew from 38,000 in 1996 to 80,000 in 2010 Over the past 8 years, Carmel has invested over $500 Million in transportation infrastructure Carmel currently has 67 roundabouts in place, and another 16 that are currently in design. City named one of best places to live in America (Money Magazine Dec. 2003) Illinois Street and 126 th Street Westfield Boulevard and 96 th Street City Wide Accident Reduction Carmel roundabout now number 63 and signalized intersections have been decreased to only 39. What has been the impact on the safety of Carmel s roadway network as a whole. 2003 Data Carmel Road Miles = 220 Total Injury Accidents = 252 2008 Data Carmel Road Miles = 395 Total Injury Accidents = 223 51% Decrease in Injury Accidents/Road Mile 4
Roundabout WILL Be Option #1 Lessons Learned Hazel Dell Parkway Geometric Adjustments 2020 design AADT s were projected to be 12,840 Hazel Dell currently carries more than 25,000 VPD Flat entry paths allowed for higher entry speeds Entry path overlap also observed as an issue Frequency of minor accidents higher than desired Injury accidents still consistent with other roundabouts Hazel Dell & 126 th St. Roundabout Current Configuration Hazel Dell & 126 th St. Roundabout Hazel Dell & 131 st St. Roundabout Proposed Configuration Completed 2010 5
Hazel Dell & Cherry Creek Blvd. Roundabout Carmel s First Roundabout Interchanges 2010 Construction Existing Keystone Avenue Looking South at Carmel Drive and 116 th Street Intersections Keystone Parkway (Formerly SR 431) US 31 Existing Corridor Keystone Avenue Existing Traffic Conditions Corridor Formed a Significant Barrier Dividing the Community Safety and Quality of Life Concerns All intersections operating at a LOS D or worse State s Plan Was to Add Travel Lanes Adding travel lanes would only improve corridor to LOS D Grade separations warranted, but funding focused on Parallel US 31 Corridor Improvements Keystone Avenue and 96 th Street Keystone Avenue and 126 th Street 106 th St. & Keystone Pkwy 106 th St. & Keystone Pkwy Before After 6
126 th St. & Keystone Pkwy 126th St. & Keystone Pkwy Before After Integration of VISSIM with 3D Modeling Fifty Mile Radius and Beyond 99 Roundabouts By 2011 Questions? Mike McBride, PE One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 (317) 571-2441 mmcbride@camel.in.gov 7
Loveland, Colorado Sweet Heart City Roundabout-Sustainability Solving Access Needs The 2010 Experience - 2 Interchanges/ 1 Intersection High Growth Burst - Long term savings along the Gateway to the Rockies 1
ROCKY MOUNTAIN AVE Loveland Intersections Modern Roundabouts 20/2011 up from 6 in 2005 and 0 in 997 Traffic Signals: 49 in1995 now 93 70,000 People up from 50,000 in 2000 High Growth >>> Lifestyles Mall + Regional Hospital + Motorplex + Events Ctr.+ Budweiser Events Ctr.+++ Roundabout #1 Designed and Constructed 1998 Problem solved Spacing/Stacking Ourston and Doctors Design 5 accidents 1 injury crash reported by 2005 Saved 65 w/9 injury crashes (est.) 4400 5300 FOXTRAIL DR N 2300 6300 Intersection Differences for Sustainability I-25/Crossroads 0 signals I-25/US 34 2 Signals Madison/US 34 CFI 3 Signals Support Systems for Signals Operations Maintenance Computers/Communications/IT 2
Wide Roads, Narrow Nodes? New Interchange Roundabouts Right Thru Left 0 min. 42 70 10 122 15 min. 40 67 7 114 30 min. 45 61 12 118 45 min. 32 59 7 98 Total 159 257 36 452 Modified + 2 Signals 0 15 30 45 Total min. min. min. min. 0 min. 15 min. 30 45 min. min. Total Left 25 30 22 23 100 9 7 7 10 33 Right Thru 13 16 15 17 61 8 9 8 8 33 Thru Right 60 68 65 47 240 37 36 40 46 159 Left 98 114 102 87 401 54 52 55 64 225 Left Thru Right Total 0 min. 50 70 67 187 15 min. 53 59 62 174 30 min. 42 67 72 181 45 min. 51 52 59 162 Total 196 248 260 704 Total Entering Roundabout 0 min. 461 15 min. 454 30 min. 456 45 min. 411 Total 1782 3
Madison Ave./ US 34 CFI 4
Traffic Operations Center Contact Information Bill Hange, PE, PTOE City of Loveland City Traffic Engineer hangeb@ci.loveland.co.us Office Phone # 970-962-2528 5