PROPOSAL: PROPOSED BY VOTED? VOTE CAST MGMT. PROPOSAL #1a: ELECT DIRECTOR JAIME ARDILA ISSUER YES FOR FOR

Transcription

1 UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C FORM N-PX ANNUAL REPORT OF PROXY VOTING RECORD OF REGISTERED MANAGEMENT INVESTMENT COMPANIES INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT FILE NUMBER: NAME OF REGISTRANT: VANGUARD TRUSTEES' EQUITY FUND ADDRESS OF REGISTRANT: PO BOX 2600, VALLEY FORGE, PA NAME AND ADDRESS OF AGENT FOR SERVICE: ANNE E. ROBINSON PO BOX 876 VALLEY FORGE, PA REGISTRANT'S TELEPHONE NUMBER, INCLUDING AREA CODE: (610) DATE OF FISCAL YEAR END: OCTOBER 31 DATE OF REPORTING PERIOD: JULY 1, JUNE 30, 2017 FUND: VANGUARD INTERNATIONAL VALUE FUND ISSUER: Accenture plc TICKER: ACN CUSIP: G1151C101 MEETING DATE: 2/10/2017 PROPOSAL #1a: ELECT JAIME ARDILA ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1b: ELECT CHARLES H. GIANCARLO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1c: ELECT HERBERT HAINER ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1d: ELECT WILLIAM L. KIMSEY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1e: ELECT MARJORIE MAGNER ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1f: ELECT NANCY MCKINSTRY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1g: ELECT PIERRE NANTERME ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1h: ELECT GILLES C. PELISSON ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1i: ELECT PAULA A. PRICE ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1j: ELECT ARUN SARIN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1k: ELECT FRANK K. TANG ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: ADVISORY VOTE TO RATIFY NAMED EXECUTIVE ISSUER YES FOR FOR OFFICERS' COMPENSATION PROPOSAL #3: ADVISORY VOTE ON SAY ON PAY FREQUENCY ISSUER YES ONE YEAR FOR PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE KPMG LLP AS AUDITORS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUTHORIZE BOARD TO FIX THEIR REMUNERATION

2 PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES WITH PRE PROPOSAL #6: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE PROPOSAL #7: DETERMINE THE PRICE RANGE AT WHICH ISSUER YES FOR FOR ACCENTURE PLC CAN RE-ISSUE SHARES THAT IT ACQUIRES AS TREASURY STOCK ISSUER: Adecco Group AG TICKER: ADEN CUSIP: H MEETING DATE: 4/20/2017 PROPOSAL #1.1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.1: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF CHF 1.50 PER SHARE PROPOSAL #2.2: APPROVE EUR 154 MILLION REDUCTION IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARE CAPITAL AND CAPITAL REPAYMENT OF EUR 0.90 PER SHARE PROPOSAL #2.3: AMEND ARTICLES RE: THRESHOLD TO SUBMIT ISSUER YES FOR FOR ITEMS TO AGENDA PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF BOARD AND SENIOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL #4.1: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE AMOUNT OF CHF 4.7 MILLION PROPOSAL #4.2: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF EXECUTIVE ISSUER YES FOR FOR COMMITTEE IN THE AMOUNT OF CHF 34.8 MILLION PROPOSAL #5.1.1: REELECT ROLF DOERIG AS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR AS BOARD CHAIRMAN PROPOSAL #5.1.2: REELECT JEAN-CHRISTOPHE DESLARZES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.1.3: REELECT ALEXANDER GUT AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.1.4: REELECT DIDIER LAMOUCHE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.1.5: REELECT DAVID PRINCE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.1.6: REELECT WANDA RAPACZYNSKI AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.1.7: REELECT KATHLEEN TAYLOR AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.1.8: ELECT ARIANE GORIN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.2.1: APPOINT ALEXANDER GUT AS MEMBER OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE PROPOSAL #5.2.2: APPOINT JEAN-CHRISTOPHE DESLARZES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEMBER OF THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE PROPOSAL #5.2.3: APPOINT WANDA RAPACZYNSKI AS MEMBER ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE PROPOSAL #5.2.4: APPOINT KATHLEEN TAYLOR AS MEMBER OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE PROPOSAL #5.3: DESIGNATE ANDREAS KELLER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR INDEPENDENT PROXY PROPOSAL #5.4: RATIFY ERNST & YOUNG AG AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR

3 PROPOSAL #6.1: APPROVE PARTIAL CANCELLATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CONDITIONAL CAPITAL PROPOSAL #6.2: APPROVE CREATION OF CHF 855,780 POOL ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF CAPITAL WITHOUT PRE PROPOSAL #7: ESTABLISH RANGE FOR BOARD SIZE ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: CHANGE LOCATION OF REGISTERED ISSUER YES FOR FOR OFFICE/HEADQUARTERS TO ZURICH, SWITZERLAND PROPOSAL #9: TRANSACT OTHER BUSINESS (VOTING) ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST ISSUER: Aegon NV TICKER: AGN CUSIP: N MEETING DATE: 5/19/2017 PROPOSAL #3.4: ADOPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3.5: APPROVE DIVIDENDS OF EUR 0.26 PER ISSUER YES FOR FOR COMMON SHARE AND EUR PER COMMON SHARE B PROPOSAL #4: RATIFY PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS PROPOSAL #5.1: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF MANAGEMENT BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5.2: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF SUPERVISORY BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6.1: REELECT DONA YOUNG TO SUPERVISORY ISSUER YES FOR FOR BOARD PROPOSAL #6.2: ELECT WILLIAM CONNELLY TO SUPERVISORY ISSUER YES FOR FOR BOARD PROPOSAL #6.3: ELECT MARK ELLMAN TO SUPERVISORY BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7.1: ELECT MATTHEW RIDER TO MANAGEMENT ISSUER YES FOR FOR BOARD PROPOSAL #8.1: GRANT BOARD AUTHORITY TO ISSUE SHARES ISSUER YES FOR FOR UP TO 10 PERCENT OF ISSUED CAPITAL PLUS ADDITIONAL 10 PERCENT IN CASE OF TAKEOVER/MERGER PROPOSAL #8.2: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO EXCLUDE PREEMPTIVE ISSUER YES FOR FOR RIGHTS FROM SHARE ISSUANCES PROPOSAL #8.3: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO ISSUE SHARES UP TO ISSUER YES FOR FOR 1 PERCENT OF ISSUED CAPITAL UNDER INCENTIVE PLANS PROPOSAL #8.4: AUTHORIZE REPURCHASE OF UP TO 10 ISSUER YES FOR FOR PERCENT OF ISSUED SHARE CAPITAL ISSUER: Alliance Global Group, Inc. TICKER: AGI CUSIP: Y MEETING DATE: 9/29/2016 PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE ANNUAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR STOCKHOLDERS MEETING HELD ON SEPT. 15, 2015 PROPOSAL #5: APPOINT INDEPENDENT AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: RATIFY ACTS OF THE BOARD OF S, ISSUER YES FOR FOR BOARD COMMITTEES, AND OFFICERS PROPOSAL #7.1: ELECT ANDREW L. TAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR

4 PROPOSAL #7.2: ELECT KINGSON U. SIAN AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #7.3: ELECT KATHERINE L. TAN AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #7.4: ELECT WINSTON S. CO AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #7.5: ELECT KEVIN ANDREW L. TAN AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #7.6: ELECT SERGIO R. ORTIZ-LUIS, JR. AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7.7: ELECT ALEJO L. VILLANUEVA, JR. AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: Anheuser-Busch InBev SA TICKER: ABI CUSIP: B6399C107 MEETING DATE: 9/28/2016 PROPOSAL #A.1: APPROVE MATTERS RELATING TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR ACQUISITION OF SABMILLER PLC BY ANHEUSER-BUSCH INBEV PROPOSAL #B.4: APPROVE TRANSFER OF ASSETS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR LIABILITIES RE: SABMILLER PLC AND ANHEUSER-BUSCH INBEV SA TRANSACTION PROPOSAL #B.5: APPROVE DELISTING RE: SABMILLER PLC ISSUER YES FOR FOR AND ANHEUSER-BUSCH INBEV SA TRANSACTION PROPOSAL #C.6: AUTHORIZE IMPLEMENTATION OF APPROVED ISSUER YES FOR FOR RESOLUTIONS AND FILING OF REQUIRED DOCUMENTS/FORMALITIES AT TRADE REGISTRY ISSUER: Anheuser-Busch InBev SA TICKER: ABI CUSIP: B639CJ108 MEETING DATE: 4/26/2017 PROPOSAL #A1.b: RENEW AUTHORIZATION TO INCREASE SHARE ISSUER YES FOR FOR CAPITAL UP TO 3 PERCENT OF ISSUED SHARE CAPITAL PROPOSAL #B3: APPROVAL OF THE ACCOUNTS OF THE OLD AB ISSUER YES FOR FOR INBEV PROPOSAL #B4: APPROVE DISCHARGE TO THE S OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE OLD AB INBEV PROPOSAL #B5: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF AUDITORS OF THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR OLD AB INBEV PROPOSAL #B.9: ADOPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B10: APPROVE DISCHARGE TO THE S ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B11: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B12.a: ELECT M.J. BARRINGTON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B12.b: ELECT W.F. GIFFORD JR. AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B12.c: ELECT A. SANTO DOMINGO DAVILA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B13.a: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #B13.b: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S ISSUER YES FOR FOR

5 PROPOSAL #B13.c: APPROVE NON-EXECUTIVE STOCK ISSUER YES FOR FOR OPTION GRANTS PROPOSAL #C1: AUTHORIZE IMPLEMENTATION OF APPROVED ISSUER YES FOR FOR RESOLUTIONS AND FILING OF REQUIRED DOCUMENTS/FORMALITIES AT TRADE REGISTRY ISSUER: Aon plc TICKER: AON CUSIP: G0408V102 MEETING DATE: 6/23/2017 PROPOSAL #1.1: ELECT LESTER B. KNIGHT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.2: ELECT GREGORY C. CASE ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.3: ELECT JIN-YONG CAI ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.4: ELECT FULVIO CONTI ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.5: ELECT CHERYL A. FRANCIS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.6: ELECT J. MICHAEL LOSH ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.7: ELECT ROBERT S. MORRISON ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.8: ELECT RICHARD B. MYERS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.9: ELECT RICHARD C. NOTEBAERT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.10: ELECT GLORIA SANTONA ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.11: ELECT CAROLYN Y. WOO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: ADVISORY VOTE TO RATIFY NAMED EXECUTIVE ISSUER YES FOR FOR OFFICERS' COMPENSATION PROPOSAL #3: ADVISORY VOTE ON SAY ON PAY FREQUENCY ISSUER YES ONE YEAR FOR PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: ADVISORY VOTE TO RATIFY S' ISSUER YES FOR FOR REMUNERATION REPORT PROPOSAL #6: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: RATIFY ERNST & YOUNG LLP AS AON'S ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS PROPOSAL #8: RATIFY ERNST & YOUNG LLP AS AON'S U.K. ISSUER YES FOR FOR STATUTORY AUDITOR PROPOSAL #9: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO FIX REMUNERATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS PROPOSAL #10: AUTHORISE SHARES FOR MARKET PURCHASE ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: ISSUE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY-LINKED ISSUER YES FOR FOR SECURITIES WITH PRE- PROPOSAL #12: ISSUE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY-LINKED ISSUER YES FOR FOR SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE- PROPOSAL #13: APPROVE POLITICAL DONATIONS ISSUER YES FOR FOR

6 ISSUER: ArcelorMittal TICKER: MT CUSIP: L0302D129 MEETING DATE: 5/10/2017 PROPOSAL #I: APPROVE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR STATEMENTS PROPOSAL #II: APPROVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #III: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #IV: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #V: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF S ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #VI: REELECT LAKSHMI N. MITTAL AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #VII: REELECT BRUNO LAFONT AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #VIII: REELECT MICHEL WURTH AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #IX: RATIFY DELOITTE AS AUDITOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #X: APPROVE 2017 PERFORMANCE SHARE UNIT PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #I: APPROVE REVERSE STOCK SPLIT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #II: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE PROPOSAL #III: AMEND ARTICLES 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11, 13, ISSUER YES FOR FOR 14 AND 15 RE: REFLECT CHANGES IN LUXEMBOURG LAW PROPOSAL #IV: APPROVE CONVERSION OF REGISTERED SHARES ISSUER YES FOR FOR INTO DEMATERIALIZED SHARES ISSUER: Ashtead Group plc TICKER: AHT CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 9/7/2016 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE FINAL DIVIDEND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: RE-ELECT CHRIS COLE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: RE-ELECT GEOFF DRABBLE AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT BRENDAN HORGAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT SAT DHAIWAL AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT SUZANNE WOOD AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT IAN SUTCLIFFE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: RE-ELECT WAYNE EDMUNDS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR

7 PROPOSAL #12: ELECT LUCINDA RICHES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: ELECT TANYA FRATTO AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: REAPPOINT DELOITTE LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: AUTHORISE BOARD TO FIX REMUNERATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS PROPOSAL #16: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE ISSUER: Assa Abloy AB TICKER: ASSA B CUSIP: W0817X204 MEETING DATE: 4/26/2017 PROPOSAL #2: ELECT CHAIRMAN OF MEETING ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: PREPARE AND APPROVE LIST OF SHAREHOLDERS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE AGENDA OF MEETING ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: DESIGNATE INSPECTOR(S) OF MINUTES OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING PROPOSAL #6: ACKNOWLEDGE PROPER CONVENING OF MEETING ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9a: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9b: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF SEK 3.00 PER SHARE PROPOSAL #9c: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF BOARD AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PRESIDENT PROPOSAL #10: DETERMINE NUMBER OF MEMBERS (9) AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DEPUTY MEMBERS (0) OF BOARD; PROPOSAL #11: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE AMOUNT OF SEK 2 MILLION FOR CHAIRMAN, SEK 850,000 FOR VICE CHAIRMAN, AND SEK 600,000 FOR OTHER S; APPROVE REMUNERATION FOR COMMITTEE WORK; APPROVE REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS PROPOSAL #12: REELECT LARS RENSTRÖM, CARL DOUGLAS, ISSUER YES FOR FOR ULF EWALDSSON, EVA KARLSSON, BIRGITTA KLASÉN, EVA LINDQVIST, JOHAN MOLIN AND JAN SVENSSON AS S; ELECT SOFIA SCHÖRLING HÖGBERG AS NEW S; RATIFY PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS AS AUDITORS PROPOSAL #13: ELECT CARL DOUGLAS, MIKAEL EKDAHL, ISSUER YES FOR FOR LISELOTT LEDIN, MARIANNE NILSSON, AND ANDERS OSCARSSON AS MEMBERS OF NOMINATING COMMITTEE PROPOSAL #14: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY AND OTHER ISSUER YES FOR FOR TERMS OF EMPLOYMENT FOR EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL #15: AUTHORIZE SHARE REPURCHASE PROGRAM AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR REISSUANCE OF REPURCHASED SHARES

8 PROPOSAL #16: APPROVE 2017 LTI SHARE MATCHING PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: Associated British Foods plc TICKER: ABF CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 12/9/2016 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE FINAL DIVIDEND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: RE-ELECT EMMA ADAMO AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: RE-ELECT JOHN BASON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT RUTH CAIRNIE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT TIMOTHY CLARKE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT JAVIER FERRAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT WOLFHART HAUSER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: ELECT RICHARD REID AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: RE-ELECT CHARLES SINCLAIR AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: RE-ELECT GEORGE WESTON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: REAPPOINT ERNST & YOUNG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: AUTHORISE THE AUDIT COMMITTEE TO FIX ISSUER YES FOR FOR REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS PROPOSAL #16: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE PROPOSAL #19: APPROVE 2016 LONG TERM INCENTIVE PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: Astellas Pharma Inc. TICKER: 4503 CUSIP: J MEETING DATE: 6/19/2017 PROPOSAL #1: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME, WITH A ISSUER YES FOR FOR FINAL DIVIDEND OF JPY 17 PROPOSAL #2.1: ELECT HATANAKA, YOSHIHIKO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.2: ELECT YASUKAWA, KENJI ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.3: ELECT OKAJIMA, ETSUKO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.4: ELECT AIZAWA, YOSHIHARU ISSUER YES FOR FOR

9 PROPOSAL #2.5: ELECT SEKIYAMA, MAMORU ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.6: ELECT YAMAGAMI, KEIKO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE ANNUAL BONUS ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: AstraZeneca plc TICKER: AZN CUSIP: G0593M107 MEETING DATE: 4/27/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE DIVIDENDS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPOINT PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS PROPOSAL #4: AUTHORISE BOARD TO FIX REMUNERATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS PROPOSAL #5a: RE-ELECT LEIF JOHANSSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5b: RE-ELECT PASCAL SORIOT AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5c: RE-ELECT MARC DUNOYER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5d: RE-ELECT GENEVIEVE BERGER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5e: ELECT PHILIP BROADLEY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5f: RE-ELECT BRUCE BURLINGTON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5g: RE-ELECT GRAHAM CHIPCHASE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5h: RE-ELECT RUDY MARKHAM AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5i: RE-ELECT SHRITI VADERA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5j: RE-ELECT MARCUS WALLENBERG AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: APPROVE EU POLITICAL DONATIONS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR EXPENDITURE PROPOSAL #9: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #12: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE ISSUER: Axa TICKER: CS CUSIP: F MEETING DATE: 4/26/2017

10 PROPOSAL #1: APPROVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR STATEMENTS AND PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF EUR 1.16 PER SHARE PROPOSAL #4: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR HENRI DE CASTRIES, CHAIRMAN AND CEO UNTIL AUGUST 31, PROPOSAL #5: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR DENIS DUVERNE, VICE CEO UNTIL AUGUST 31, 2016 PROPOSAL #6: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR DENIS DUVERNE, CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD OF S SINCE SEPTEMBER 1, 2016 PROPOSAL #7: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR THOMA BUBERL, CEO SINCE SEPTEMBER 1, 2016 PROPOSAL #8: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY OF CHAIRMAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF THE BOARD PROPOSAL #9: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY OF CEO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: APPROVE AUDITORS' SPECIAL REPORT ON ISSUER YES FOR FOR RELATED-PARTY TRANSACTIONS PROPOSAL #11: APPROVE ADDITIONAL SOCIAL BENEFITS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AGREEMENT WITH THOMAS BUBERL, CEO PROPOSAL #12: APPROVE SEVERANCE AGREEMENT WITH THOMAS ISSUER YES FOR FOR BUBERL PROPOSAL #13: REELECT DEANNA OPPENHEIMER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: REELECT RAMON DE OLIVEIRA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: RATIFY APPOINTMENT OF THOMAS BUBERL AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #16: RATIFY APPOINTMENT OF ANDRÉ FRANÇOIS- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PONCET AS PROPOSAL #17: AUTHORIZE REPURCHASE OF UP TO 10 ISSUER YES FOR FOR PERCENT OF ISSUED SHARE CAPITAL PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORIZE CAPITALIZATION OF RESERVES OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR UP TO EUR 1 BILLION FOR BONUS ISSUE OR INCREASE IN PAR VALUE PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES WITH PRE UP TO AGGREGATE NOMINAL AMOUNT OF EUR 2 BILLIONS PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE UP TO AGGREGATE NOMINAL AMOUNT OF EUR 550 MILLION PROPOSAL #21: APPROVE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES FOR PRIVATE PLACEMENTS, UP TO AGGREGATE NOMINAL AMOUNT OF EUR 550 MILLION PROPOSAL #22: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO SET ISSUE PRICE FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR 10 PERCENT PER YEAR OF ISSUED CAPITAL PURSUANT TO ISSUE AUTHORITY WITHOUT PRE PROPOSAL #23: AUTHORIZE CAPITAL INCREASE OF UP TO EUR ISSUER YES FOR FOR 550 MILLION FOR FUTURE EXCHANGE OFFERS PROPOSAL #24: AUTHORIZE CAPITAL INCREASE OF UP TO 10 ISSUER YES FOR FOR PERCENT OF ISSUED CAPITAL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS IN KIND PROPOSAL #25: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY UPON ISSUER YES FOR FOR CONVERSION OF A SUBSIDIARY'S EQUITY-LINKED SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE FOR UP TO EUR 550 MILLION

11 PROPOSAL #26: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY UPON ISSUER YES FOR FOR CONVERSION OF A SUBSIDIARY'S EQUITY-LINKED SECURITIES WITH PRE FOR UP TO EUR 2 BILLION PROPOSAL #27: AUTHORIZE CAPITAL ISSUANCES FOR USE IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR EMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE PLANS PROPOSAL #28: AUTHORIZE CAPITAL ISSUANCES FOR USE IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR EMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE PLANS RESERVED FOR EMPLOYEES OF INTERNATIONAL SUBSIDIARIES PROPOSAL #29: AUTHORIZE UP TO 1 PERCENT OF ISSUED ISSUER YES FOR FOR CAPITAL FOR USE IN STOCK OPTION PLANS PROPOSAL #30: AUTHORIZE DECREASE IN SHARE CAPITAL VIA ISSUER YES FOR FOR CANCELLATION OF REPURCHASED SHARES PROPOSAL #31: AUTHORIZE FILING OF REQUIRED ISSUER YES FOR FOR DOCUMENTS/OTHER FORMALITIES ISSUER: Banca Mediolanum S.p.A TICKER: BMED CUSIP: T1R88K108 MEETING DATE: 4/5/2017 PROPOSAL #1.1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.1: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.2: APPROVE SEVERANCE PAYMENTS POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3.1: APPROVE EXECUTIVE INCENTIVE BONUS PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3.2: AUTHORIZE SHARE REPURCHASE PROGRAM AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR REISSUANCE OF REPURCHASED SHARES TO SERVICE EXECUTIVE INCENTIVE BONUS PLAN PROPOSAL #4: ELECT ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #5.1: APPOINT INTERNAL STATUTORY AUDITOR ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #5.2: APPOINT CHAIR OF THE BOARD OF ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST STATUTORY AUDITORS PROPOSAL #5.3: APPOINT ALTERNATE INTERNAL STATUTORY ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST AUDITOR PROPOSAL #A: DELIBERATIONS ON POSSIBLE LEGAL ACTION ISSUER YES AGAINST N/A AGAINST S IF PRESENTED BY SHAREHOLDERS ISSUER: Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria, S.A. TICKER: BBVA CUSIP: E MEETING DATE: 3/16/2017 PROPOSAL #1.1: APPROVE CONSOLIDATED AND STANDALONE ISSUER YES FOR FOR FINANCIAL STATEMENTS PROPOSAL #1.2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #1.3: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.1: REELECT JOSE MANUEL GONZALEZ-PARAMO ISSUER YES FOR FOR MARTINEZ-MURILLO AS

12 PROPOSAL #2.2: REELECT CARLOS LORING MARTINEZ DE ISSUER YES FOR FOR IRUJO AS PROPOSAL #2.3: REELECT SUSANA RODRIGUEZ VIDARTE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.4: REELECT TOMAS ALFARO DRAKE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2.5: REELECT LOURDES MAIZ CARRO AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: AUTHORIZE CAPITALIZATION OF RESERVES FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR SCRIP DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #4: AUTHORIZE INCREASE IN CAPITAL UP TO 50 ISSUER YES FOR FOR PERCENT VIA ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY-LINKED SECURITIES, EXCLUDING PRE OF UP TO 20 PERCENT PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF CONVERTIBLE BONDS, ISSUER YES FOR FOR DEBENTURES, WARRANTS, AND OTHER DEBT SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE UP TO EUR 8 BILLION PROPOSAL #6: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: FIX MAXIMUM VARIABLE COMPENSATION RATIO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: APPOINT KPMG AUDITORES AS AUDITOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO RATIFY AND EXECUTE ISSUER YES FOR FOR APPROVED RESOLUTIONS PROPOSAL #10: ADVISORY VOTE ON REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: Banco de Sabadell S.A TICKER: SAB CUSIP: E MEETING DATE: 3/29/2017 PROPOSAL #1: APPROVE CONSOLIDATED AND STANDALONE ISSUER YES FOR FOR FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND DISCHARGE OF BOARD PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #3.1: ELECT ANTHONY FRANK ELLIOTT BALL AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3.2: RATIFY APPOINTMENT OF AND ELECT MANUEL ISSUER YES FOR FOR VALLS MORATO AS PROPOSAL #3.3: REELECT MARIA TERESA GARCIA-MILA ISSUER YES FOR FOR LLOVERAS AS PROPOSAL #3.4: REELECT JOSE LUIS NEGRO RODRIGUEZ AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: AUTHORIZE INCREASE IN CAPITAL UP TO 50 ISSUER YES FOR FOR PERCENT VIA ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY-LINKED SECURITIES, EXCLUDING PRE OF UP TO 20 PERCENT PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF CONVERTIBLE BONDS, ISSUER YES FOR FOR DEBENTURES, WARRANTS, AND OTHER DEBT SECURITIES UP TO EUR 2 BILLION WITH EXCLUSION OF PRE UP TO 20 PERCENT OF CAPITAL PROPOSAL #6: AUTHORIZE SHARE REPURCHASE AND CAPITAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR REDUCTION VIA AMORTIZATION OF REPURCHASED SHARES PROPOSAL #7: APPROVE SHARE APPRECIATION RIGHTS PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: FIX MAXIMUM VARIABLE COMPENSATION RATIO ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST OF DESIGNATED GROUP MEMBERS

13 PROPOSAL #9: ADVISORY VOTE ON REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #10: RENEW APPOINTMENT OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS AS AUDITOR PROPOSAL #11: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO RATIFY AND EXECUTE ISSUER YES FOR FOR APPROVED RESOLUTIONS ISSUER: Banco Santander S.A. TICKER: SAN CUSIP: E MEETING DATE: 4/6/2017 PROPOSAL #1.A: APPROVE CONSOLIDATED AND STANDALONE ISSUER YES FOR FOR FINANCIAL STATEMENTS PROPOSAL #1.B: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #3.A: RATIFY APPOINTMENT OF AND ELECT ISSUER YES FOR FOR HOMAIRA AKBARI AS PROPOSAL #3.B: REELECT JOSE ANTONIO ALVAREZ ALVAREZ ISSUER YES FOR FOR AS PROPOSAL #3.C: REELECT BELEN ROMANA GARCIA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3.D: REELECT ANA PATRICIA BOTIN-SANZ DE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SAUTUOLA Y O'SHEA AS PROPOSAL #3.E: REELECT RODRIGO ECHENIQUE GORDILLO AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3.F: REELECT ESTHER GIMENEZ-SALINAS I ISSUER YES FOR FOR COLOMER AS PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE CAPITAL RAISING ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORIZE INCREASE IN CAPITAL UP TO 50 ISSUER YES FOR FOR PERCENT VIA ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY-LINKED SECURITIES, EXCLUDING PRE OF UP TO 20 PERCENT PROPOSAL #6: AUTHORIZE CAPITALIZATION OF RESERVES FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR SCRIP DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #7: AUTHORIZE ISSUANCE OF NON-CONVERTIBLE ISSUER YES FOR FOR DEBT SECURITIES UP TO EUR 50 BILLION PROPOSAL #8: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: FIX MAXIMUM VARIABLE COMPENSATION RATIO ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11.A: APPROVE DEFERRED MULTIYEAR OBJECTIVES ISSUER YES FOR FOR VARIABLE REMUNERATION PLAN PROPOSAL #11.B: APPROVE DEFERRED AND CONDITIONAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR VARIABLE REMUNERATION PLAN PROPOSAL #11.C: APPROVE BUY-OUT POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11.D: APPROVE EMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: AUTHORIZE BOARD TO RATIFY AND EXECUTE ISSUER YES FOR FOR APPROVED RESOLUTIONS PROPOSAL #13: ADVISORY VOTE ON REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR

14 ISSUER: Barclays plc TICKER: BARC CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 5/10/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: ELECT MARY FRANCIS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: ELECT SIR IAN CHESHIRE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: RE-ELECT MIKE ASHLEY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT TIM BREEDON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT CRAWFORD GILLIES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT SIR GERRY GRIMSTONE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT REUBEN JEFFERY III AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: RE-ELECT JOHN MCFARLANE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: RE-ELECT TUSHAR MORZARIA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: RE-ELECT DAMBISA MOYO AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: RE-ELECT DIANE SCHUENEMAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: RE-ELECT JAMES STALEY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #16: APPOINT KPMG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: AUTHORISE THE BOARD AUDIT COMMITTEE TO ISSUER YES FOR FOR FIX REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS PROPOSAL #18: APPROVE EU POLITICAL DONATIONS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR EXPENDITURE PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #21: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR IN CONNECTION WITH AN ACQUISITION OR OTHER CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROPOSAL #22: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY IN RELATION ISSUER YES FOR FOR TO ISSUANCE OF CONTINGENT EQUITY CONVERSION NOTES PROPOSAL #23: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR IN RELATION TO THE ISSUANCE OF CONTINGENT EQUITY CONVERSION NOTES PROPOSAL #24: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #25: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE PROPOSAL #26: AMEND LONG-TERM INCENTIVE PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR

15 ISSUER: Bayer AG TICKER: BAYN CUSIP: D0712D163 MEETING DATE: 4/28/2017 PROPOSAL #1: RECEIVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR ; APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND DIVIDENDS OF EUR 2.70 PER SHARE FOR FISCAL 2016 PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF MANAGEMENT BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2016 PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF SUPERVISORY BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2016 PROPOSAL #4.1: ELECT WERNER WENNING TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD PROPOSAL #4.2: ELECT PAUL ACHLEITNER TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD PROPOSAL #4.3: ELECT NORBERT W. BISCHOFBERGER TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD PROPOSAL #4.4: ELECT THOMAS EBELING TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD PROPOSAL #4.5: ELECT COLLEEN A. GOGGINS TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD PROPOSAL #4.6: ELECT KLAUS STURANY TO THE SUPERVISORY ISSUER YES FOR FOR BOARD PROPOSAL #5: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF SUPERVISORY ISSUER YES FOR FOR BOARD PROPOSAL #6: APPROVE AFFILIATION AGREEMENTS WITH ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUBSIDIARIES BAYER CROPSCIENCE AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT PROPOSAL #7: RATIFY DELOITTE GMBH AS AUDITORS FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR FISCAL 2017 ISSUER: Bayerische Motoren Werke AG (BMW) TICKER: BMW CUSIP: D MEETING DATE: 5/11/2017 PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF EUR 3.52 PER PREFERRED SHARE AND EUR 3.50 PER ORDINARY SHARE PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF MANAGEMENT BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2016 PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF SUPERVISORY BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2016 PROPOSAL #5: RATIFY KPMG AG AS AUDITORS FOR FISCAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR 2017 PROPOSAL #6: ELECT HEINRICH HIESINGER TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD

16 ISSUER: BB Seguridade Participacoes S.A. TICKER: BBSE3 CUSIP: P1R1WJ103 MEETING DATE: 4/20/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL YEAR ENDED DEC. 31, 2016 PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #3: ELECT FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBERS ISSUER NO N/A N/A PROPOSAL #3.1: ELECT GIORGIO BAMPI AS FISCAL COUNCIL SHAREHOLDER YES FOR N/A MEMBER AND PAULO ROBERTO FRANCESCHI AS ALTERNATE APPOINTED BY MINORITY SHAREHOLDER PROPOSAL #4: ELECT S ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #4.1: ELECT ISABEL DA SILVA RAMOS AS SHAREHOLDER YES FOR N/A APPOINTED BY MINORITY SHAREHOLDER PROPOSAL #5: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF FISCAL COUNCIL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEMBERS PROPOSAL #6: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF COMPANY'S ISSUER YES FOR FOR MANAGEMENT PROPOSAL #7: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF AUDIT COMMITTEE ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEMBERS ISSUER: BB Seguridade Participacoes S.A. TICKER: BBSE3 CUSIP: P1R1WJ103 MEETING DATE: 4/20/2017 PROPOSAL #1: APPROVE BONUS MATCHING PLAN ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: BHP Billiton Limited TICKER: BHP CUSIP: Q1498M100 MEETING DATE: 11/17/2016 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPOINT KPMG LLP AS AUDITOR OF THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR COMPANY PROPOSAL #3: AUTHORIZE THE BOARD TO FIX REMUNERATION ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF THE AUDITORS PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE GENERAL AUTHORITY TO ISSUE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES IN BHP BILLITON PLC PROPOSAL #5: APPROVE GENERAL AUTHORITY TO ISSUE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES IN BHP BILLITON PLC FOR CASH PROPOSAL #6: APPROVE THE REPURCHASE OF SHARES IN BHP ISSUER YES FOR FOR BILLITON PLC PROPOSAL #7: APPROVE THE REMUNERATION REPORT OTHER ISSUER YES FOR FOR THAN THE PART CONTAINING THE S' REMUNERATION POLICY

17 PROPOSAL #8: APPROVE THE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: APPROVE THE GRANT OF AWARDS TO ANDREW ISSUER YES FOR FOR MACKENZIE, EXECUTIVE OF THE COMPANY PROPOSAL #10: ELECT KEN MACKENZIE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: ELECT MALCOLM BRINDED AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: ELECT MALCOLM BROOMHEAD AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: ELECT PAT DAVIES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: ELECT ANITA FREW AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: ELECT CAROLYN HEWSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #16: ELECT ANDREW MACKENZIE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: ELECT LINDSAY MAXSTED AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #18: ELECT WAYNE MURDY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #19: ELECT SHRITI VADERA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #20: ELECT JAC NASSER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: BHP Billiton plc TICKER: BLT CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 10/20/2016 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: REAPPOINT KPMG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: AUTHORISE THE RISK AND AUDIT COMMITTEE ISSUER YES FOR FOR TO FIX REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS PROPOSAL #4: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #7: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT FOR UK LAW ISSUER YES FOR FOR PURPOSES PROPOSAL #8: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUSTRALIAN LAW PURPOSES PROPOSAL #9: APPROVE GRANT OF AWARDS UNDER THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR GROUP'S LONG TERM INCENTIVE PLAN TO ANDREW MACKENZIE PROPOSAL #10: ELECT KEN MACKENZIE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: RE-ELECT MALCOLM BRINDED AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: RE-ELECT MALCOLM BROOMHEAD AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: RE-ELECT PAT DAVIES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: RE-ELECT ANITA FREW AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: RE-ELECT CAROLYN HEWSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR

18 PROPOSAL #16: RE-ELECT ANDREW MACKENZIE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: RE-ELECT LINDSAY MAXSTED AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #18: RE-ELECT WAYNE MURDY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #19: RE-ELECT SHRITI VADERA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #20: RE-ELECT JAC NASSER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR ISSUER: BNP Paribas SA TICKER: BNP CUSIP: F1058Q238 MEETING DATE: 5/23/2017 PROPOSAL #1: APPROVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR STATEMENTS AND PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF EUR 2.70 PER SHARE PROPOSAL #4: ACKNOWLEDGE AUDITORS' SPECIAL REPORT ON ISSUER YES FOR FOR RELATED-PARTY TRANSACTIONS PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORIZE REPURCHASE OF UP TO 10 PERCENT ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF ISSUED SHARE CAPITAL PROPOSAL #6: REELECT JEAN LEMIERRE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: REELECT MONIQUE COHEN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: REELECT DANIELA SCHWARZER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: REELECT FIELDS WICKER-MIURIN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: ELECT JACQUES ASCHENBROICH AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD PROPOSAL #12: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY FOR CEO AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR VICE-CEO PROPOSAL #13: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR JEAN LEMIERRE, CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD PROPOSAL #14: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR JEAN-LAURENT BONNAFE, CEO PROPOSAL #15: NON-BINDING VOTE ON COMPENSATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR PHILIPPE BORDENAVE, VICE-CEO PROPOSAL #16: NON-BINDING VOTE ON THE OVERALL ISSUER YES FOR FOR ENVELOPE OF COMPENSATION OF CERTAIN SENIOR MANAGEMENT, RESPONSIBLE OFFICERS AND THE RISK-TAKERS PROPOSAL #17: AUTHORIZE DECREASE IN SHARE CAPITAL VIA ISSUER YES FOR FOR CANCELLATION OF REPURCHASED SHARES PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORIZE FILING OF REQUIRED ISSUER YES FOR FOR DOCUMENTS/OTHER FORMALITIES

19 ISSUER: BP plc TICKER: BP. CUSIP: MEETING DATE: 5/17/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: RE-ELECT BOB DUDLEY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: RE-ELECT DR BRIAN GILVARY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: ELECT NILS ANDERSEN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT PAUL ANDERSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT ALAN BOECKMANN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT FRANK BOWMAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT IAN DAVIS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: RE-ELECT DAME ANN DOWLING AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: ELECT MELODY MEYER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: RE-ELECT BRENDAN NELSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: RE-ELECT PAULA REYNOLDS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: RE-ELECT SIR JOHN SAWERS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #16: RE-ELECT CARL-HENRIC SVANBERG AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: REAPPOINT ERNST & YOUNG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AND AUTHORISE THEIR REMUNERATION PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORISE EU POLITICAL DONATIONS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR EXPENDITURE PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #21: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR IN CONNECTION WITH AN ACQUISITION OR OTHER CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROPOSAL #22: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #23: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE ISSUER: BP plc TICKER: BP. CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 5/17/2017

20 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: RE-ELECT BOB DUDLEY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5: RE-ELECT DR BRIAN GILVARY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: ELECT NILS ANDERSEN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT PAUL ANDERSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT ALAN BOECKMANN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT FRANK BOWMAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT IAN DAVIS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: RE-ELECT DAME ANN DOWLING AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: ELECT MELODY MEYER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: RE-ELECT BRENDAN NELSON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: RE-ELECT PAULA REYNOLDS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: RE-ELECT SIR JOHN SAWERS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #16: RE-ELECT CARL-HENRIC SVANBERG AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: REAPPOINT ERNST & YOUNG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AND AUTHORISE THEIR REMUNERATION PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORISE EU POLITICAL DONATIONS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR EXPENDITURE PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #21: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR IN CONNECTION WITH AN ACQUISITION OR OTHER CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROPOSAL #22: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #23: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE ISSUER: British American Tobacco plc TICKER: BATS CUSIP: G1510J102 MEETING DATE: 4/26/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE FINAL DIVIDEND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: REAPPOINT KPMG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR

21 PROPOSAL #5: AUTHORISE THE AUDIT COMMITTEE TO FIX ISSUER YES FOR FOR REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS PROPOSAL #6: RE-ELECT RICHARD BURROWS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT NICANDRO DURANTE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT SUE FARR AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT ANN GODBEHERE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT SAVIO KWAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #11: RE-ELECT DR PEDRO MALAN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #12: RE-ELECT DIMITRI PANAYOTOPOULOS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #13: RE-ELECT KIERAN POYNTER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: RE-ELECT BEN STEVENS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #15: ELECT DR MARION HELMES AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #16: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #17: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORISE EU POLITICAL DONATIONS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR EXPENDITURE PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORISE THE COMPANY TO CALL GENERAL ISSUER YES FOR FOR MEETING WITH TWO WEEKS' NOTICE ISSUER: Canadian National Railway Company TICKER: CNR CUSIP: MEETING DATE: 4/25/2017 PROPOSAL #1.1: ELECT SHAUNEEN BRUDER ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.2: ELECT DONALD J. CARTY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.3: ELECT GORDON D. GIFFIN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.4: ELECT JULIE GODIN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.5: ELECT EDITH E. HOLIDAY ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.6: ELECT LUC JOBIN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.7: ELECT V. MAUREEN KEMPSTON ISSUER YES FOR FOR DARKES PROPOSAL #1.8: ELECT DENIS LOSIER ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.9: ELECT KEVIN G. LYNCH ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.10: ELECT JAMES E. O'CONNOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.11: ELECT ROBERT PACE ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.12: ELECT ROBERT L. PHILLIPS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.13: ELECT LAURA STEIN ISSUER YES FOR FOR

22 PROPOSAL #2: RATIFY KPMG LLP AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3: ADVISORY VOTE ON EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION ISSUER YES FOR FOR APPROACH ISSUER: Canadian Natural Resources Limited TICKER: CNQ CUSIP: MEETING DATE: 5/4/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ELECT CATHERINE M. BEST, N. MURRAY ISSUER YES FOR FOR EDWARDS, TIMOTHY W. FAITHFULL, GARY A. FILMON, CHRISTOPHER L. FONG, GORDON D. GIFFIN, WILFRED A. GOBERT, STEVE W. LAUT, FRANK J. MCKENNA, DAVID A. TUER, AND ANNETTE M. VERSCHUREN AS S PROPOSAL #1.1: ELECT CATHERINE M. BEST ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.2: ELECT N. MURRAY EDWARDS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.3: ELECT TIMOTHY W. FAITHFULL ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.4: ELECT GARY A. FILMON ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.5: ELECT CHRISTOPHER L. FONG ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.6: ELECT GORDON D. GIFFIN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.7: ELECT WILFRED A. GOBERT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.8: ELECT STEVE W. LAUT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.9: ELECT FRANK J. MCKENNA ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.10: ELECT DAVID A. TUER ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.11: ELECT ANNETTE M. VERSCHUREN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS AND AUTHORIZE BOARD TO FIX THEIR PROPOSAL #3: ADVISORY VOTE ON EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION ISSUER YES FOR FOR APPROACH ISSUER: Carlsberg TICKER: CARL B CUSIP: K MEETING DATE: 3/30/2017 PROPOSAL #2: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR ; APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S; APPROVE DISCHARGE OF MANAGEMENT AND BOARD PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF DKK 10 PER SHARE PROPOSAL #4a: APPROVE GUIDELINES FOR INCENTIVE-BASED ISSUER YES FOR FOR COMPENSATION FOR EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT AND BOARD PROPOSAL #4b: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF S IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE AMOUNT OF DKK 1.85 MILLION FOR CHAIRMAN, DKK 618,000 FOR VICE CHAIR, AND DKK 412,000 FOR OTHER S; APPROVE REMUNERATION FOR COMMITTEE WORK PROPOSAL #4c: AMEND ARTICLES RE: COMPANY ISSUER YES FOR FOR ANNOUNCEMENTS IN ENGLISH ONLY

23 PROPOSAL #4d: AMEND ARTICLES RE: ABOLISH THE USE OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR THE DANISH BUSINESS AUTHORITY'S IT SYSTEM FOR CONVENING AND ANNOUNCING ANNUAL GENERAL MEETINGS PROPOSAL #5a: REELECT FLEMMING BESENBACHER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5b: REELECT LARS REBIEN SORENSEN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5c: REELECT RICHARD BURROWS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5d: REELECT DONNA CORDNER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5e: REELECT CORNELIUS JOB VAN DER GRAAF AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5f: REELECT CARL BACHE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5g: REELECT SOREN-PETER FUCHS OLESEN ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5h: REELECT NINA SMITH AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5i: REELECT LARS STEMMERIK AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #5j: ELECT NANCY CRUICKSHANK AS NEW ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #6: RATIFY PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS ISSUER: Carnival plc TICKER: CCL CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 4/5/2017 PROPOSAL #1: RE-ELECT MICKY ARISON AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #2: RE-ELECT JONATHON BAND AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #3: ELECT HELEN DEEBLE AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #4: RE-ELECT ARNOLD DONALD AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #5: RE-ELECT RICHARD GLASIER AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #6: RE-ELECT DEBRA KELLY-ENNIS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #7: RE-ELECT JOHN PARKER AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #8: RE-ELECT STUART SUBOTNICK AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #9: RE-ELECT LAURA WEIL AS OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PROPOSAL #10: RE-ELECT RANDALL WEISENBURGER AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION AND AS A OF CARNIVAL PLC PROPOSAL #11: ADVISORY VOTE TO RATIFY NAMED EXECUTIVE ISSUER YES FOR FOR OFFICERS' COMPENSATION PROPOSAL #12: ADVISORY VOTE ON SAY ON PAY FREQUENCY ISSUER YES ONE YEAR FOR PROPOSAL #13: APPROVE REMUNERATION REPORT ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #14: APPROVE REMUNERATION POLICY ISSUER YES FOR FOR

24 PROPOSAL #15: REAPPOINT PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR INDEPENDENT AUDITORS OF CARNIVAL PLC; RATIFY THE SELECTION OF THE U.S. FIRM OF PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP AS THE INDEPENDENT REGISTERED CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM OF CARNIVAL CORPORATION PROPOSAL #16: AUTHORISE THE AUDIT COMMITTEE OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR CARNIVAL PLC TO FIX REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS PROPOSAL #17: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #18: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITH PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #19: AUTHORISE ISSUE OF EQUITY WITHOUT PRE- ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #20: AUTHORISE MARKET PURCHASE OF ORDINARY ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES ISSUER: Cielo SA TICKER: CIEL3 CUSIP: P2859E100 MEETING DATE: 4/12/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL YEAR ENDED DEC. 31, 2016 PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE CAPITAL BUDGET, ALLOCATION OF ISSUER YES FOR FOR INCOME AND DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE REMUNERATION OF COMPANY'S ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST MANAGEMENT AND FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBERS ISSUER: Cielo SA TICKER: CIEL3 CUSIP: P2859E100 MEETING DATE: 4/12/2017 PROPOSAL #1.1: ELECT MARCELO AUGUSTO DUTRA LABUTO AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.2: ELECT ROMULO DE MELLO DIAS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #1.3: ELECT ALBERTO MONTEIRO DE QUEIROZ ISSUER YES FOR FOR NETTO AS PROPOSAL #2.1: ELECT EDMAR JOSE CASALATINA AS FISCAL ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.2: ELECT FLAVIO SABA SANTOS ESTRELA AS ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST ALTERNATE FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.3: ELECT JOEL ANTONIO DE ARAUJO AS FISCAL ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.4: ELECT SIGMAR MILTON MAYER FILHO AS ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST ALTERNATE FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.5: ELECT HERCULANO ANIBAL ALVES AS FISCAL ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.6: ELECT KLEBER DO ESPIRITO SANTO AS ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST ALTERNATE FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.7: ELECT MARCELO SANTOS DALL'OCCO AS ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER

25 PROPOSAL #2.8: ELECT CARLOS ROBERTO MENDONCA DA SILVA ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST AS ALTERNATE FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.9: ELECT HAROLDO REGINALDO LEVY NETO AS ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.10: ELECT MILTON LUIZ MILIONI AS ISSUER YES ABSTAIN AGAINST ALTERNATE FISCAL COUNCIL MEMBER PROPOSAL #2.11: ELECT MARIO DAUD FILHO AS FISCAL SHAREHOLDER YES FOR N/A COUNCIL MEMBER AND CHARLES RENE LEBARBENCHON AS ALTERNATE APPOINTED BY MINORITY SHAREHOLDER PROPOSAL #3: AUTHORIZE CAPITALIZATION OF RESERVES FOR ISSUER YES FOR FOR BONUS ISSUE PROPOSAL #4: AMEND ARTICLE 7 TO REFLECT CHANGES IN ISSUER YES FOR FOR CAPITAL AND CONSOLIDATE BYLAWS ACCORDINGLY ISSUER: CK Hutchison Holdings Limited TICKER: 1 CUSIP: G MEETING DATE: 5/11/2017 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE FINAL DIVIDEND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3a: ELECT KAM HING LAM AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #3b: ELECT EDITH SHIH AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #3c: ELECT CHOW KUN CHEE, ROLAND AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #3d: ELECT CHOW WOO MO FONG, SUSAN AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #3e: ELECT CHENG HOI CHUEN, VINCENT AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3f: ELECT LEE WAI MUN, ROSE AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #3g: ELECT WILLIAM SHURNIAK AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #3h: ELECT WONG CHUNG HIN AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE AUDITOR AND AUTHORIZE BOARD TO ISSUER YES FOR FOR FIX THEIR REMUNERATION PROPOSAL #5.1: APPROVE ISSUANCE OF EQUITY OR EQUITY- ISSUER YES FOR FOR LINKED SECURITIES WITHOUT PRE PROPOSAL #5.2: AUTHORIZE REPURCHASE OF ISSUED SHARE ISSUER YES FOR FOR CAPITAL PROPOSAL #5.3: AUTHORIZE REISSUANCE OF REPURCHASED ISSUER YES FOR FOR SHARES ISSUER: Commerzbank AG TICKER: CBK CUSIP: D172W1279 MEETING DATE: 5/3/2017 PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR OMISSION OF DIVIDENDS PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF MANAGEMENT BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2016

26 PROPOSAL #4: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF SUPERVISORY BOARD ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2016 PROPOSAL #5: RATIFY PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS GMBH AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR AUDITORS FOR FISCAL 2017 PROPOSAL #6: RATIFY ERNST & YOUNG GMBH AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR THE FIRST QUARTER OF FISCAL 2018 PROPOSAL #7: RATIFY ERNST & YOUNG GMBH AS AUDITORS ISSUER YES FOR FOR FOR FISCAL 2018 PROPOSAL #8.1: ELECT TOBIAS GULDIMANN TO THE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD PROPOSAL #8.2: ELECT ROGER MUELLER AS ALTERNATE ISSUER YES FOR FOR SUPERVISORY BOARD MEMBER PROPOSAL #9: AMEND ARTICLES RE: GERMAN ACT ON ISSUER YES FOR FOR REORGANIZATION OF THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE FEDERAL AGENCY FOR STABILIZATION OF THE FINANCIAL MARKETS ISSUER: Compagnie Financiere Richemont SA TICKER: CFR CUSIP: H MEETING DATE: 9/14/2016 PROPOSAL #1: ACCEPT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #2: APPROVE ALLOCATION OF INCOME AND ISSUER YES FOR FOR DIVIDENDS OF CHF 1.70 PER REGISTERED A SHARE AND CHF 0.17 PER REGISTERED B SHARE PROPOSAL #3: APPROVE DISCHARGE OF BOARD OF S ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.1: REELECT JOHANN RUPERT AS AND ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST BOARD CHAIRMAN PROPOSAL #4.2: REELECT YVES-ANDRE ISTEL AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.3: REELECT JOSUA MALHERBE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.4: REELECT JEAN-BLAISE ECKERT AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #4.5: REELECT BERNARD FORNAS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.6: REELECT RICHARD LEPEU AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.7: REELECT RUGGERO MAGNONI AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.8: REELECT SIMON MURRAY AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.9: REELECT GUILLAUME PICTET AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.10: REELECT NORBERT PLATT AS ISSUER YES AGAINST AGAINST PROPOSAL #4.11: REELECT ALAN QUASHA AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.12: REELECT MARIA RAMOS AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.13: REELECT LORD RENWICK OF CLIFTON AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.14: REELECT JAN RUPERT AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.15: REELECT GARY SAAGE AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR PROPOSAL #4.16: REELECT JURGEN SCHREMPP AS ISSUER YES FOR FOR