THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK

Transcription

1

2 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK

3 5. Evaluating Eligibility Eligibility for the Hawaii or National Registers of Historic Places is what determines whether or not a resource should be considered significant and the threshold for whether or not National or State laws governing historic property apply. In addition to the national guidelines on how to evaluate the significance and integrity of a resource, it should be noted that evaluation is always done through the eyes of the reviewer; any bias will come from their own background knowledge and experience. This report and the following guidance is an attempt to standardize the process for reviewers. The outline below is the National Park Service criteria to evaluate the eligibility of resources. For a property to be considered eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places, it must possess qualities of historic integrity and that: A. Are associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history; or B. Are associated with the lives of significant persons in or past; or C. Embody the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction, or that represent the work of a master, or that possess high artistic values, or that represent a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction; or D. Have yielded or may be likely to yield, information that is important in history or prehistory. In addition to the national guidelines, criteria for the Hawaii register include: 1. Environmental impact, i.e., whether the preservation of the building, site, structure, district, or object significantly enhances the environmental quality of the State; 2. The social, cultural, educational and recreational value of the building, site, structure, district, or object, when preserved, presented, or interpreted, contributes significantly to the understanding and enjoyment of the history and culture of Hawaii, the Pacific area, or the nation. The majority of Hawaii s present built environment was constructed during the period from 1939 to With the exceedingly large number of historic resources developed during the period , and the high number which appears to meet the criteria for listing in the Hawaii and National Registers of Historic Places, historic significance may not be the best means to determine historic preservation priorities with regards to the allocation of resources, time, and effort. Rather than talk merely in terms of significance or eligibility as determined by the National Register, historic preservation advocates need to consider preservation value. In addition to evaluating the integrity and historic significance of a modern building, these properties should also be assessed as to whether they have high or low historic preservation value. To make such judgments, design qualities need to be taken into consideration. The property will need to be placed within a context(s) based on comprehensive inventories and studies developed to understand its property type, distinctive design characteristics and 5-1

4 materials, the body of work of its designer, and any historic associations related to its development. Below is the chart to evaluate the architectural significance. Also, see the following website for national guidelines for evaluating resources

5 Properties Identified in the Report as Having High Preservation Value The properties listed in this table represent a small sampling of the numerous modern buildings which have high preservation value. The list should in no way be considered comprehensive in character, as none of the building types identified in the report have undergone a complete inventory study. Due to travel restrictions, few examples of neighbor island works are included. Cemetery Byodoin Robert Katsuyoshi Kaneohe, Valley of the 3-28 Temples. Oahu Hawaiian Memorial Park Wimberly & Cook Kaneohe, Oahu 4-49 Chapel Kinkaku-Ji Robert Katsuyoshi Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave Makai Chapel Ossipoff, Snyder, Mililani Cemetery. Oahu 4-49 Punchbowl Rowland & Goetz Thompson & Thompson Punchbowl, Oahu Government Board of Water Supply Wood Honolulu, Beretania St 3-27 Chinese Consulate Wong & Wong Honolulu, Pali Hwy 3-28 Department of Law & Wilson Honolulu, Punchbowl St Transportation Building Hawaii County Building Oka Hilo, Hawaii 4-41 Island of Hawaii State Anbe Hilo, Hawaii 4-41 Building Kauai State Building 4-41 Maui State Building Wailuku, Maui 4-41 State Capitol Warnecke, and Belt, Lemmon & Lo Honolulu, S. Beretania St High Rise Apartment 1350 Ala Moana Yamasaki Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd Ala Wai Plaza DMJM Honolulu, University Ave Angaroa Roger Lee Honolulu, Nohea St Canterbury Place Boone Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd Consulate Honolulu, Makiki St Diamond Head Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Ambassador Diamond Head Ossipoff Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Apartments Diamond Head Vista Boone Honolulu, Pualani Way 4-33 Discovery Bay Boone Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd Hale Aloha University of Hawaii 4-4 Hale O Kalani Honolulu, Kewalo St Holiday Manor Lemmon, Freeth & Kanunu St

6 Holiday Village Apts. Honolulu, Amana St Jade Apartments Honolulu, 9 th Ave. 4-4 Manoalani Johnson & Perkins Honolulu, Punahou St Marco Polo Sutton, Lemmon, Belt & Lo Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd Palo Alto Wells Honolulu, Punahou St Pomaikai Sam Chang Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd Princess Leilani Honolulu, Kanunu St Punahou Circle Park Associates Honolulu, S. Beretania St Queen Emma Gardens Yamasaki Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave 4-32 Rosalei Honolulu, Kaiolu St Royal Iolani Boone Honolulu, University Ave Royal Vista Rummell Honolulu, Prospect St Sandalwood Bassetti, Morse & Honolulu, Ahana Lane 4-32 Tatom Wailana Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd High Rise Commercial Ala Moana Building Graham Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd American Savings Bank Hogan & Chapman Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd Amfac Honolulu, Bishop St Atlas Building Ernest Hara Honolulu, S. King St Bishop Honolulu, Bishop St Bishop Trust Cann Honolulu, Bishop St Campbell Estate Wou Honolulu, Fort St City Bank Anbe Honolulu, Queen St Davies Pacific Center Donaldson, Au, Cutting & Smith Honolulu, Bishop St Financial Plaza Wou Honolulu, Bishop St Grosvenor Center Architects Hawaii Honolulu, Bishop St Hawaiian Telephone Hogan & Chapman Honolulu, Bishop St HGEA Anbe Honolulu, Queen St Pioneer Plaza Honolulu, Fort St Waikiki Business Plaza Bauer Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Hotel Ala Moana Honolulu, Atkinson Blvd Breakers Bauer Honolulu, Beachwalk 4-43 Foster Tower Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Hawaiiana Bauer Honolulu, Beachwalk

7 Hawaiian King George Lee Honolulu, Nohonani St Hawaiian Regent Chamberlain, Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Tatom Hotel Molokai Roberts Kaunakakai, Molokai 4-43 Hyatt Regency Waikiki Wimberly, Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Whisenand, Alison, Tong and Goo Ilikai Graham Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd Kahala Hilton Killingsworth Honolulu, Kahala Ave Kona Hilton Wimberly Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Mauna Kea Beach SOM South Kohala, Hawaii Princess Kaiulani Dailey Honolulu, Kaiulani Ave Queen Kapiolani Ernest Hara Honolulu, Kapahulu Ave Rainbow Tower Honolulu, Kalia Rd Sheraton Waikiki WWATG Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Surfrider Roehrig, Onodera & Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Kinder Waikiki Circle Hotel Unknown Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave. 4-4 Waikiki Holiday Inn Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave White Sands Honolulu, Dukes Ln Low Rise Apartment Continental Honolulu, Kaheka St Diamond Head Gardens Lemmon, Freeth, & Jones Honolulu, Pualei Circle Diamond Head Alii Lemmon, Freeth, Honolulu, Pualei Circle 4-15 & Jones Diamond Head Surf Lemmon, Freeth, Honolulu, Pualei Circle 4-15 & Jones Diamond Head Lanai Lemmon, Freeth, Honolulu, Pualei Circle 4-15 & Jones Fukumoto Apartments Kunimoto Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd

8 Gregg Apartments Lemmon, Freeth, & Jones Honolulu, Pualei Circle Hawaiian Holiday City Mill Honolulu, Wilder St Heulu Aotani Honolulu, Heulu St Janda Apartments Kim Honolulu, Liholiho St Kahala Beach Killingsworth Honolulu, Kahala Ave Condominiums 2459 Kapiolani Oyakawa Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd Kilsby Apartments unknown Honolulu, Kinau St Maile Terrace Lemmon, Freeth & Honolulu, Makiki St Makiki Apartments Howard Wong Honolulu, Wilder Ave Makiki Bel Air Matsushita Honolulu, Makiki St Makiki Palms Ernest Hara Honolulu, Kewalo St Oahuan Bauer Honolulu, Makiki St Pawaa Garden Harr Honolulu, Young St Punahou Terrace Miyamasa & Mori Honolulu, Makiki St Punakiki Izata Honolulu, Dominis St Savannah Apartments Miller Honolulu, Liholiho St Seaside Apartments Dahl & Conrad Honolulu, Seaside Ave Shinshu Kiyokai Katsuyoshi Honolulu, Beretania St Takara Apartments Oyakawa Honolulu, Dominis St Teruya Apartments Nakamura Honolulu, Pensacola St Treehouse Tatom Honolulu, Waikiki Wilder Walter Wong Honolulu, Wilder Ave Low Rise Commercial Aiea Commercial Center Ernest Hara Aiea, Moanalua Rd Aiea Shopping Center Ernest Hara Aiea, Moanalua Rd American Security Bank Waipahu, Oahu Bank of Hawaii Honolulu, Kahala Mall 4-4 Boysen Paint Store Lemmon & Freeth Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd C. Q. Yee Hop Hsi Honolulu, N King St C.S. Wo Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd Central Pacific Bank Ernest Hara Honolulu, King St Continental Hawaii Bauer Honolulu, S King St. 4-8 First Hawaiian Bank Phillip Mapunapuna, Oahu 3-34 Flamingo s Akiyama Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd. 4-2 Foodland Wimberly & Cook Kaneohe, Oahu

9 Gold Bond Hsi Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd Hawaiian Life Bldg. Ossipoff Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd. 4-2 Hawaiian Trust Co. Wimberly & Cook Honolulu, S King St. 4-8 Holiday Mart Unknown Honolulu, Makaloa St IBM Building IBM Honolulu, Ala Moana Blvd ILWU Bldg Preis Honolulu, Atkinson Blvd Kawaiahao Plaza Tsugawa Honolulu, S. King St Kenrock Bldg Lemmon, Freeth & Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd King Center Anbe Honolulu, S King St S. King Honolulu, King St S. King Honolulu, King St S. King Makino Honolulu, King St. 4-5 Liberty Bank Ossipoff Honolulu, N. King St Liliha St Comm Dist Honolulu, Liliha St. 4-6 Medical Arts Bldg. Onodera Honolulu, S. King St 4-3 Miyamoto Bldgs Sato Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave. 4-3 Niu Center Bauer Honolulu, Kalanaianaole 4-11 Hwy Nuuanu Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave. 4-3 Nuuanu Clinic Lemmon, Freeth & Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave. 4-3 Occidental Life Lemmon, Freeth, Honolulu, S. Piikoi St. 4-3 Insurance Bldg., & Jones Pacific Development Co. Kim Honolulu, Pensacola St. 4-3 Pensacola & King Honolulu, King St. 4-5 Piikoi Parkway Young Honolulu, Piikoi St Professional Center Ernest Hara Honolulu, King St Seaboard Finance Merrill, Simms & Honolulu, Kapiolani Blvd. 4-2 Roehrig 920 Sheridan Akagi Honolulu, Sheridan St. 4-3 State Savings Plaza Johnson-Reese Kaneohe, Kamehameha 4-1 Hwy. Trophy House Nishida Honolulu, King St. 4-5 Ushijima Store Funai Kawanui, Hawaii 4-7 Varsity Bldg. Wimberly & Cook Honolulu, University Ave

10 Waimalu Shopping Sato Pearl City, Kamehameha 4-11 Center Hwy. Ward Plaza Au, Cutting & Smith Honolulu, Ward Ave Ward Warehouse Au, Cutting & Smith Honolulu, Ward Ave Westgate Center Matsushita Waipahu, Oahu 4-12 Parks Comfort Stations Ala Wai Litaker & Pursel Honolulu, University Ave Dole Lemmon, Freeth & Honolulu, Magellan St Iliahi Iwanaga Kahaluu Koizumi Kahaluu, Oahu Kahana Bay Law Kahana, Oahu Kamamalu Oka Honolulu, Queen Emma St Kaneohe Community Sullam Kaneohe, Oahu Kualoa Sato Kualoa, Oahu Liliuokalani Gardens Seckel Honolulu, School St Makapuu Dennis Makapuu, Oahu Mililani Waena Sullam Mililani, Oahu Nuuanu Valley Rothwell, Lester & Honolulu, Pali Hwy Phillips Pacific Palisades Akagi and Takawa Pearl City, Oahu Pokai Bay Gallion Makaha, Oahu Punaluu Iwanaga Punaluu, Oahu Puuloa Naito Ewa Beach, Oahu Swanzy Hogan & Chapman Kaaawa, Oahu Thomas Square Wells Honolulu, Victoria St Waimanalo Slavsky Waimanalo, Oahu Waimea Bay McAuliffe Waimea, Oahu Rec Centers, Park and Playground Haleiwa Beach Park, Haleiwa, Oahu War Memorial Honolulu Zoo Entrance Preis Honolulu, Kapahulu Ave Kanewai Rec Center Hara Pearl City, Oahu Kapaolono Kaimuki, Oahu Momilani Recreation Hara Pearl City, Oahu Center Palolo Valley District Bradley, Lee & Palolo Valley, Oahu Park (1960) Wong Waikiki Shell Law & Wilson Kapiolani Park, Oahu

11 Parking Lot Marks Garage Roehrig, Onodera & Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave Kinder Municipal Anbe, Ishizu, Aruga Honolulu, Beretania St Religious Aiea Korean United Ossipoff Aiea, Oahu 4-49 Methodist Central Baptist Honolulu, Nehoa St Central Union Windward Kailua, Oahu 4-47 Church of World Katsuyoshi Honolulu, Pali Hwy Messianity Community Church of Honolulu Wong & Wong Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave Church of the Nativity Law & Wilson Aina Haina, Oahu First Christian Church of Lester & Phillips Honolulu, Kewalo St Honolulu First Church of the Honolulu, Judd St Nazarene First Presbyterian Lemmon, Freeth & Honolulu, Keeaumoku St First United Methodist Preis Honolulu, S. Beretania St Hanapepe United Hanapepe, Kauai 4-45 Church of Christ Harris Memorial Law & Wilson Honolulu, Vineyard Blvd Holy Nativity Law & Wilson Aina Haina 4-46 Honolulu Honpa Onodera Honolulu, Pali Hwy Hongwanji Honolulu Myohoji Robert Katsuyoshi Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave 4-50 Kailua Baptist Wimberly & Cook Kailua, Oahu 4-49 Kalihi Union Law & Wilson Honolulu, N. King St Kapaa First Hawaiian Kapaa, Kauai 4-45 Church Kilohana Mathodist Leemon, Freeth, Niu Valley, Oahu 4-46 & Jones Kuan Yin Clifford Young and Honolulu, Vineyard Blvd Sam Chang Lahaina Jodo Gumi Lahaina, Maui 4-50 Lihue United Church of Christ Wood Lihue, Kauai Manoa Valley Church Wong & Wong Honolulu, Haupala St

12 Mystical Rose Chapel Rothwell St. Louis, Oahu Nuuanu Congregational Kobayashi & Nishida Honolulu, Pali Hwy Our Lady of Good Pearl City, Oahu 4-47 Counsel Our Redeemer Bauer Honolulu, University Ave Evangelical Pearl Harbor Memorial Clifford Young Honolulu, Bougainville 4-48 Community Church Drive St. Anthony s Catholic McAuliffe Kailua, Oahu St. Augustine s Catholic McLaughlin Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave St. Elizabeth s Episcopal Bauer Honolulu, N. King St St. Luke s Episcopal Lemmon, Freeth & Honolulu, Judd St St. Pius X Law & Wilson Manoa, Oahu 4-46 St. Stephen s Catholic Roger Lee Honolulu, Pali Hwy St. Sylvester s Catholic McAuliffe and Bauer Kilauea, Kauai 4-46 Seicho-No-Ie Honolulu, Matlock Ave Soto Zen Temple Fuchino Honolulu, Nuuanu Ave Southern Baptist Pearl City, Oahu 4-49 Star of the Sea Merrill, Simms & Waialae, Oahu 4-47 Roehrig Temple Emmanu-El Sullam Honolulu, Pali Hwy Thurston Memorial Ossipoff Honolulu, Punahou St Waiola Sato Lahaina, Maui 4-49 Waiokeola Lemmon, Freeth, Waialae-Kahala 4-47 & Jones Waipahu Hongwanji Fuchino Waipahu, Oahu 4-49 Wesley Methodist Lemmon, Freeth & Waialae-Kahala, Oahu Schools Bachman Hall Ossipoff University of Hawaii, Oahu East-West Center Pei University of Hawaii, Oahu 3-31 Laupahoehoe School Preis Laupahoehoe, Hawaii

13 Social/Entertainment Bay Club Restaurant Springer Kapalua, Maui 4-44 Buck Toy Society Hall Akagi Honolulu, Vineyard Blvd Neal Blaisdell Center Merrill, Simms, Honolulu, King St Roehrig Outrigger Canoe Club Ossipoff Honolulu, Kalakaua Ave Pacific Club Ossipoff Honolulu, Queen Emma St Royal Kaanapali Golf Clubhouse WWATG and Ossipoff Kaanapali, Maui Teshima s Restaurant unknown Honalo, Hawaii 4-7 United Chinese Society Clifford Young Honolulu, N. King St