PT 168 Benoa Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership

Transcription

1 PT 168 Benoa Semester Report of Seafood Savers Membership Summary of improvement development Handline Tuna, Malang, East Java January Juni 2016 Muhammad Maskur Tamanyira Seafood Savers Officer

2 General Information 1. Location : Coastal Fishing Port (PPP) Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru, Malang, East Java First Surey : April 2015 Number of farmers/fishermen : The number of total fleets that were recorded as active members of PT. 168 Benoa supply chain in 2015 were 40 fleets categorized as canoe and all of them were already registered to DKP East Java Province 2. Fishing Method - Minimum harvest size : Juvenile tuna, about kg (weight is an estimate, as tuna weighing less than 20 kg are not weighed individually) - Method of capture : Handline, with fishing fleets GT Price range : Rp / Kg In Sendangbiru, the type of fish that has become a commodity is Tuna, such as the Yellow Fin Tuna (Thunnus albacares). Caught by handlining fishing techinique, Tuna has become a major target of importers from the surrounding area. The transaction process is by way of auction which is organized by local port authorities. 3. Production Capacity Generally, the total tuna landed in PPP Pondokdadap reached up to tons with the value of Rp 55,244,988,963. The production of Tuna, Skipjack and Mackerel amounted to tons equaled to 64.06% of the total production of fish landed in PPP Pondokdadap. The types of Tuna caught were Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares), Bigeye (Thunnus obesus) and Albacore (Thunnus alalunga) which reached tons (19.19%). Meanwhile, Skipjack (Katsuwonus pelamis) amounted to tons (11.39%) and Mackerel tons (33.48%) (PPP Pondokdadap 2012, in Annual report LOKA Tuna Benoa 2013). Based on the information submitted, 168 Benoa took advantage of 51,359 Kg madidihana from Sendangbiru. This number was obtained from purchasing activities performed in January to June This number was also gained from 24 Tuna fishing fleets or canoe with 17 fleets that were fully operated in Sendangbiru 4. Additional Information

3 PT. 168 Benoa and PT. Hatindo Makmur cooperate in the Seafood Savers scheme and work toward improving tuna fishing in Sendangbiru. In September 2015, PT. 168 Benoa reported changes in the number of fleets under their production chain. In addition, information was given on the number of catches which were purchased by 168 in Sendangbiru. An action that should be appreciated. Periodic reporting of this kind, is an important aspect for improving future FIPs.

4 Data Recap of fleet and amount of fishing: Date Big Tuna Total NO Fleet Name Port Base Fleet Information YFT (kg) Depart Return 1 MANDIRI 275 SENDANG BIRU GT. 12 NO. 1214/Mp 8-Jul Jul-16 3,742 2 ALIF JAYA SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2,129 3 TELUK BONE 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 1,924 4 INDRIANI 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 7 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 2,317 5 BERKAT ILAHI 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 J.113 NO Jul Jul-16 2,315 6 BERKAH ALAM 06 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 11 NO Jul Jul-16 2,413 7 BERKAT ILAHI 02 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2,131 8 BERKAT ILAHI 04 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO Jul-16 21/17/16 2,002 9 BERKAH ILAHI 05 SENDANG BIRU GT. 7 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 2, TELUK BONE 09 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 1, TIGA PUTRA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 2, TITIPAN ILAHI 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, CAHAYA MURNI 03 SENDANG BIRU 128 SB. J Jul Jul-16 3, RESKI 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, ADITIA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, TELUK BONE 07 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, LIMA PUTRA SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, RAMA JAYA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 2, PENJURU BINTANG 04 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, PENJURU BINTANG 05 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, TIGA PUTRA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO Jul Jul-16 2, DUA PUTRA SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2, SARINAH 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 11 NO. 1268/Mp 12-Jul Jul-16 3, WAHYU RESKI 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO Jul Jul-16 2,145

5 V A N C Details of PT 168 Benoa's membership evaluation, based on the Fisheries Improvement Program (FIP) that has been implemented: SEAFOOD SAVERS stage OUTPUT AND DETAIL ACTION ACTION / INDIKATOR FOR (for the Seafood ACTION LEAD EVALUATION RESULT FOLLOW-UP E TASK ACTION/TASK Savers member) & PARTNERS PLAN/DIFFICULTIES 1. GOVERNANCE AND DEFINITION OF NATIONAL FISHERY MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVES 1.1. Refine Mechanism to objectives to potentially ensure that extend the facilitate EAFM for Tuna fishing has priority is current law to the been studied jointly by the given to prioritise development College of Fisheries, sustainable fisheries process of EAFM Jakarta and WWFfisheries and sustainability, and or other SDI, P4KSI Indonesia and will be the ecosystem against regulations presented in the National approach to production and which promotes Tuna Symposium, 2014 fisheries growth sustainable objectives, and fishery principles at national accommodate and local level EAFM principles

6 develop company regulation to support the implementation of EAFM and or Company other regulations which promotes sustainable fishery principles EAFM for Tuna fishing has been studied jointly by the College of Fisheries, Jakarta and WWF- Indonesia and will be presented in the National Tuna Symposium, 2014 Difficulties: All fishery 1.2. Extension principles, of the including precautionary system to local approach should level be extended to provincial and district levels; Information in the facilitates the logbook has not been standardized. In many Province/District cases, local names for regulation as SDI, P4KSI, various fish types are still interpretation of Agency of used in the logs. ministerial MAF in Coastal Fishing Port of Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru, decree on Province & has maintained a logbook record for tuna fishing fishery District, PLN, PSDP Recommended solution: plan, which Create a standard for include Harvest logging, involving the local Control Rule provincial office and/or the marine and fisheries ministry

7 Company implement measures regulated in Province/District fishery plan as a patron on the development and implementation in the area. The plan will have harvest control rule with sustainable principles involve e.g. minimum capture size, adjusting the number of effort following the stock carrying capacity facilitate the province/district Company Coastal Fishing Port of Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru, has maintained a logbook record for tuna fishing Difficulties: Information in the logbook has not been standardized. In many cases, local names for various fish types are still used in the logs. Recommended solution: Create a standard for logging, involving the local provincial office and/or the marine and fisheries ministry SDI, Agency EAFM for Tuna fishing has of MAF in regulation as an been studied jointly by the Province & extention of College of Fisheries, District EAFM regulation Jakarta and WWFand or other Indonesia and will be

8 national presented in the National regulations Tuna Symposium, 2014 which promotes sustainable tuna fishery principles Company implement measures regulated in Indonesian EAFM for Tuna fishing has EAFM guideline been studied jointly by the and or other College of Fisheries, national Jakarta and WWFregulations Indonesia and will be which promotes presented in the National Company sustainable tuna Tuna Symposium, 2014 fishery principles as a patron for the development and implementation of EAFM in Province/District level

9 Company proactively suport Indonesia to be WCPFC So far, PT. 168 Benoa member (e.g. actively participates in Company Sending letter to events held by WWF, MMAF, especially during visits or attending information sharing to To continue the WCPFC meetings stakeholders 1.3. Indonesia process to if required) becomes a full become full Member of member of WCPFC and is WCPFC Monitor instrumental and provide in formulating support on Indonesia has become a KKP (SDI, strong ensuring the member of the WCPFC. P4KSI, precautionary continuation PUSKITA), policies at process of In addition, PT. 168 Benoa KTI, KEMLU, both RFMOs Indonesia - fishes in the Indian Ocean, SetKab and becoming full which is under the implements member of jurisdiction of the Indian decisions WCPFC Ocean Tuna Commission Ensuring Actively the Decree 12/2012 and participated in precautionary 30/2012 regarding the adoption principles is requirement to land a full process of adopted in body of shark with fins precautionary SDI, P4KSI national attached in a case where a policies in the regulations (e.g. shark is incidentally fishery Ministerial caught in the ZEEI and free in decrees, fishery waters area RFMOs

10 plan) Promoting Decree 12/2012 and the 30/2012 regarding the precautionary requirement to land a full principles SDI, P4KSI, body of shark with fins adoption in PLN attached in a case where a RFMOs following shark is incidentally international caught in the ZEEI and free conventions waters area Indonesia Preparing report Indonesia sends a Regular and attendance representative annually to attendance at meeting of the SDI, P4KSI attend RFMO (Indian meetings WCPFC and Ocean and Pacific Ocean) others rellevant RFMOs Definition of SDI, P4KSI, goals and PUP, PSDP, objectives, KTI dan Adherence to Tuna stakeholder RFMO National action plan for Development lainnya conventions, Skipjack Tuna is available of fisheries plan document (ASTUIN, Implementing (Decree 107/ 2015). The specific development ATLI, Agency national tools action plan was released following FIP of MAF in and HCRs (See in August 2015 plans suggestions Province & also 3.4 below), District, dll) implementing and precautionary WWF/SFP.

11 measures, Adoption developing of the tuna bycatch National action plan for SDI, Agency mitigation plan principles Skipjack Tuna is available of MAF in strategies (3.5), into existing (Decree 107/ 2015). The Province & Applying MCS, area based action plan was released District and reviewing fishery in August 2015 strategies plan Company proactively support and implement the So far, PT. 168 Benoa plan (e.g. actively participates in Company Provide letter on events held by WWF, on the especially during visits or information sharing to plan, proactively stakeholders attend meetings if required) 2. STRENGTHENING THE INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK 2.1. Decision Facilitate Forum for the Legalize FKPPS making and the availability coordination of the and the consultation of regulation and Management processes (e.g. ministrial SDI, Agency utilization of Fish Committee as a consolidated decrees) which of MAF in resources (FKPPS) exists, formal apex through FKPPS promotes FKPPS Province & but still largely institution for and the Tuna and or national District, volunterary, and there is Indonesian Management stakeholder, no binding decisions from fishery Committee, authority (e.g. FKPPS meetings managemet role which KTI, task force) as defined implements to responsible

12 strategies in territorial, archipelagic and EEZ waters on the tuna fishery Monitor and evaluate the performance of FKPPS and or national authority (e.g. KTI, task force) conducted by internal and external agencies of MMAF to be responsible on the tuna fishery Facilitate the SDI, Agency of MAF in Province & District, stakeholder, Decisions implemented centrally, and establishment of SDI, Agency not at authority to of MAF in decentralized implement Province & level. Provinsi measures in District, and District area based stakeholder, implement fishery policy, but not responsible for plan (RPP WPP) FKPPS exists, but still largely volunterary, and there is no binding decisions from FKPPS meetings FKPPS exists, but still largely volunterary, and there is no binding decisions from FKPPS meetings

13 formulating and in making decisions Province/District which are at variance with national requirements Monitor and evaluate the performance of Province/District authority which conducted by internal and external agencies of MMAF-MAF of Province/District to be responsible on the tuna fishery Allow for active engagement from stakeholders in decision making. SDI, Agency of MAF in Province & District, stakeholder, FKPPS exists, but still largely volunterary, and there is no binding decisions from FKPPS meetings SDI, P4KSI, PUP, PSDP, Actively KTI dan involve industry, So far, PT. 168 Benoa stakeholder research agency, actively participates in lainnya NGOs in events held by WWF, (ASTUIN, meetings related especially during visits or ATLI, Agency to the fishery information sharing to of MAF in decision making stakeholders Province & District, dll)

14 2.1.6 Company proactively supported and involved in the decision making process in national and province/district levels (e.g attending meetings) Company So far, PT. 168 Benoa actively participates in events held by WWF, especially during visits or information sharing to stakeholders Facilitate the availability Difficulties: of regulation Iinformation in the 2.2. Allocation of (e.g. ministerial logbook has not been Identification tasks to specific decrees, SDI, Agency standardized. In many of stakeholders; directorate of MAF in cases, local names for responsibility Tuna Fisheries general decrees) Province & various fish types are still and capacity Satker, KKP, DKP on tasks District, Coastal Fishing Port of Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru, used in the logs. building across Provinsi and allocation with stakeholder s has maintained a logbook record for tuna fishing the range of District and specific job as described Recommended solution: implementing Community description to above. Create a standard for bodies groups the right agency logging, involving the local to support the provincial office and/or fishery the marine and fisheries ministry 3. RESEARCH ACTIVITIES

15 3.1.1 Workshop to identify and ensure the authority who is in charge to do stock National action plan for assessment P4KSI, BPPL, 3.1. National Skipjack Tuna is available analysis, KOMNAS scientific stock (Decree 107/ 2015). The Human capacity strengthened KAJISKAN, assessment action plan was released building in stock and agreed on BPSDM. capacity in August 2015 assessment and the strengthened establishing methodology to to support regio specifc do assessment research (which also taking onto stations at address the MSC account the Benoa and needs) major Bitung biological factors Training on stock P4KSI, BPPL, Indonesia through P4KSI assessment, KOMNAS (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and fisheries biology KAJISKAN, LOKA Tuna Benoa) and fishing BPSDM. participated and wrote a capacity series of record to be reported for RFMO 3.2. Indonesia Sampling Stock strengthens its methodology abundance, commitment module Fleet to data development P4KSI, BPPL, Indonesia through P4KSI composition, collection and and conduct SDI (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and Stock collation, training on tuna LOKA Tuna Benoa) productivity, especially in Stock participated and wrote a Stock structure the form of abundance, series of record to be

16 stock Fleet reported for RFMO structure, composition, stock Stock abundance productivity, and fleet Stock structure composition Increase private awareness and participation in the tuna data collection by facilitating research activities and providing access to their production facilities Research on tuna Stock abundance, Fleet composition, Stock productivity, Stock structure using the agreed methodology P4KSI, BPPL, SDI, industry (direct and via industry associations) P4KSI, BPPL, KOMNAS KAJISKAN Indonesia through P4KSI (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and LOKA Tuna Benoa) participated and wrote a series of record to be reported for RFMO Indonesia through P4KSI (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and LOKA Tuna Benoa) participated and wrote a series of record to be reported for RFMO

17 3.2.4 Increase research activities of the newly established research institute for indian tuna in benoa and encourage the establishment of the institute in bitung P4KSI, BPPL, KOMNAS KAJISKAN Indonesia through P4KSI (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and LOKA Tuna Benoa) participated and wrote a series of record to be reported for RFMO National action plan for Skipjack Tuna is available Conduct (Decree 107/ 2015). The 3.3. Indonesia stock P4KSI, BPPL, action plan was released should adopt assessment for KOMNAS in August 2015 its own LRPs tuna (YFT, SKJ, KAJISKAN Indonesia will build HCR based on BET and others) national waters. In national and accordance with guidance RFMO advice Stock from CSIRO (WCPFC) so that stocks assessment Company are strengthened participation in National action plan for maintained (YFT, SKJ, BET the tuna data Skipjack Tuna is available above the and others) collection by P4KSI, BPPL, (Decree 107/ 2015). The biomass levels facilitating SDI, industry action plan was released providing research (direct and in August 2015 maximum activities and via industry Indonesia will build HCR sustainable providing access associations) national waters. In yield Points to their accordance with guidance production from CSIRO (WCPFC) facilities (e.g.

18 Logbook, onboard observer, gonad sampling, annual catch data etc) National action plan for Skipjack Tuna is available Develop P4KSI, BPPL, (Decree 107/ 2015). The draft on national KOMNAS action plan was released level Reference KAJISKAN, in August 2015 Points for each SDI Indonesia will build HCR tuna species national waters. In accordance with guidance Setting national from CSIRO (WCPFC) level Reference Points for each species establish National action plan for regulation on Skipjack Tuna is available the national (Decree 107/ 2015). The P4KSI, SDI level Reference action plan was released Points for each in August 2015 tuna species Indonesia will build HCR national waters. In accordance with guidance from CSIRO (WCPFC) Recommend to develop WCPFC and IOTC policy paper on to have a regional LRP that SDI, WWF regional LRP should be set on National action plan for

19 biological Skipjack Tuna is available carrying capacity (Decree 107/ 2015). The action plan was released in August proactively National action plan for advocates SDI, P4KSI, Skipjack Tuna is available WCPFC and IOTC KTI, WWF (Decree 107/ 2015). The to have regional action plan was released LRP in August 2015 Indonesia will build HCR national waters 3.4. Formal MMAF develops Support harvest Harvest Strategy P4KSI on the strategy linked to CMM development of adopted for for National action plan for scientific paper Indonesian EEZ/YFT and BET Skipjack Tuna is available with regard to Pacific and activities and (Decree 107/ 2015). The tuna resources SDI, FKKP, KTI Indian Ocean restrictions on action plan was released and fisheries as tunas linked to effort capped at in August 2015 a basis to a set of Indonesia will build HCR develop the (National or levels, In national waters. In policy paper RFMO) Limit addition, the accordance with guidance document Reference spirit of the from CSIRO (WCPFC)

20 Points, measures (i.e Directorate covering the effort General of range of control/capacity Capture fisheries reduction in Fisheries of (including territorial MMAF develops those < 30 GT /archipelagic Harvest Strategy and 5 GT). The waters if linked to CMM object should interactions with for National action plan for be consistent juvenile YFT/BET EEZ/YFT and BET Skipjack Tuna is available with RFMO are significant activities and (Decree 107/ 2015). The advice, which restrictions on action plan was released in the case of effort capped at in August 2015 the Pacific, is Indonesia will build HCR SDI, FKKP, KTI to limit effort levels, In national waters. In to 2004 levels, addition, the accordance with guidance and to reduce spirit of the from CSIRO (WCPFC) effort on YFT measures (i.e and BET by effort 30% control/capacity reduction in territorial /archipelagic waters if interactions with juvenile YFT/BET are significant 3.5. Fisheries Develop Facilitate SDI, P4KSI, specific fisheries specific the Agency of development National action plan for MAF in plans set plan (national process on tuna Skipjack Tuna is available Province & encompassing fishery (Decree 107/ 2015). The District, PLN, a set of well regulation in action plan was released KKJI, PSDP defined plan for Tuna) Indonesia which in August 2015

21 control rules controls the Indonesia will build HCR limiting effort harvest (HCR) national waters. In (by restricted following the accordance with guidance entry sustainable from CSIRO (WCPFC) licensing, principles, especially at restrict entry provincial licensing level) and the especially at impact of provincial level, juvenile BET reducing impact (restrictions of juvenile BET on the use of (through e.g. FADs (across al restrictions on levels of the use of FADs Government), across all levels raising the of Government), minimum raising the mesh size, minimum mesh closed areas size, closed and others). areas and The tools used others). The should take tools used into account uncertainties should take into account uncertainties

22 3.5.2 Company participation to support tuna plan which mentioning on Harvest Control Rule e.g. minimum size limit; adjusting the number of effort following the carrying capacity and regulation; completion of all fishing licenses, FADs; using environmentally friendly fishing gears; fishing in the right lozation etc Conduct a review of available information on Company PT. 168 Benoa and its supply chain have not established regulations regarding their involvement in the improvement program, in both national and local levels. Review of available information on Bycatch data of small stock status P4KSI, 3.6. By catch stock status scale handline tuna including bait KOMNAS data collection including bait fisheries has not been fisheries, sharks, KAJISKAN fisheries, sharks, fully recorded marlins and marlins and other 'main' other 'main' pelagic species pelagic species

23 3.6.2 Company Provide information on stock status including bait fisheries, sharks, marlins and other 'main' pelagic species (e.g via log book and or research forms) Company Bycatch data recording in small scale tuna fisheries has not been implemented in both national and company levels Improve the existing observer training module, Bycatch data recording in Development of especially on small scale tuna fisheries observe training bycatch data P4KSI, BPPL, has not been module (from recording (need SDI, industry, implemented in both WWF/SPC to be detailed WWF/NGO, national and company examples) and than the current universities, levels. training of data available) SPC observers and implement Observer program based on the improved modul

24 Bycatch data recording in Company small scale tuna fisheries implement has not been observer implemented in both Company program for national and company their fishing levels. fleet Requires monitoring aggregate fish densities and size on FADs over periods to determine the likely impact on associated fish species conduct study and monitoring on the status and impact of the aggregate fish densities, size and associated fish species on FADs RPP Tuna is not yet available, and the Limit Reference needs have not been discussed in the P4KSI, BPPL, national level. Regulation SDI, industry, regarding Fish Aggregating WWF/NGO, Devices (FADs) have been universities, made available, under SPC Decree 30/ year 2004, however the implementation of compliance in the field remains unknown

25 RPP Tuna is not yet Company available, and the Limit provide Reference needs have not information and been discussed in the conduct national level. Regulation monitoring on regarding Fish Aggregating the impact of Company Devices (FADs) have been the FAD to made available, under aggregate fish Decree 30/ year 2004, densities, size however the and associated implementation of fish species compliance in the field remains unknown encourage RFMO to Modeling of conduct the fishery removals No available ecosystem modeling of to assess the model to be used as a fishery removals impact on the P4KSI, SPC, basis to assess the ecosystem using CSIRO impact on the existing SPC ecosystem using tools ECOPATH existing SPC etc tools ECOPATH etc

26 3.7. Completion of a risk based framework for retained and bycatch species (skipjack. Small tunas, mahimahi, kawakawa, sharks) and Bait fish. Requires independent research to collect qualitative and quantitative information to perform a risk based approach covering SICA and PSA P4KSI, BPPL, Stakeholders SDI, PSDP, receive training industry, Conduct in risk WWF/NGO, RBF assessment has training for assessment and University, revealed plenty of room stakeholders for participate in multi- WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using for improvement risk assessment method specific stakeholder PSA of MSC to determine workshops to involvement, RBF can be implemented risk to non determine risk RFMOs, per certification unit target species. to non target external species. research bodies conduct RBF assessment has undertake the revealed plenty of room Risk Based WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using for improvement Assessment to P4KSI, BPPL PSA of MSC determine risk RBF can be implemented to non target per certification unit species Company Drawing from support RBF assessment has the information informatin revealed plenty of room in 4.1 and needed for the WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using for improvement undertake a risk Risk Based Company PSA of MSC assessment Assessment to RBF can be implemented determine risk per certification unit to non target species strategy RBF assessment has development on revealed plenty of room P4KSI, BPPL, WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using using the data for improvement WWF PSA of MSC from RBA for MSC evaluation RBF can be implemented

27 per certification unit No existing regulation regarding the use of 3.8. National bycatch on the national limits for ETP Develop level(except for turtles) interactions NPOA of ETP set and species in In SDI, FKPPS, independent Indonesia KTI data collected (sharks, turtles, on ETPs limits NPOAs finalised cetaceans and to ensure that or amended to birds) bycatches are take account of within WCPFC CMMs national and (sharks, turtles, Company international cetaceans and National action plan for provide requirements. birds) Skipjack Tuna is available information and This may (Decree 107/ 2015). The implement require action plan was released NPOA of ETP observers to Company in August Stating species In be present that Indonesia will create Indonesia across a range a bycatch mitigation (sharks, turtles, of fisheries program cetaceans and birds) Developing a P4KSI will National action plan for provide scientific Skipjack Tuna is available strategy for paper with 3.9. (Decree 107/ 2015). The bycatch species regard to tuna SDI, FKPPS, Management action plan was released and baitfish to resources and KTI, KAPI, strategy and in August Stating be incorporated fisheries as a P4KSI mitigation that Indonesia will create into a basis to develop a bycatch mitigation the policy paper program plan (1.4) document

28 National action plan for Company Skipjack Tuna is available provide (Decree 107/ 2015). The information needed to action plan was released develop the in August Stating scientific paper Company that Indonesia will create on a bycatch mitigation strategy and program mitigation for bycatch and No existing regulation baitfish fisheries regarding the use of fish bait on the national level Capture National action plan for DG - fishery Skipjack Tuna is available resources (Decree 107/ 2015). The action plan was released Directorate will in August Stating develop SDI, KAPI, that Indonesia will create P4KSI a bycatch mitigation strategy and program mitigation document for No existing regulation bycatch and regarding the use of fish baitfish fisheries bait on the national level

29 3.9.4 Company have policies to support the No existing regulation regarding bycatch strategy and Company mitigation or the use of mitigation fish bait on the national document for level bycatch and baitfish fisheries Information workshop gathering to on information determine data gathering to Indonesian gaps, tactical determine data Research Plan focus on critical gaps, tactical prepared to target stocks focus on critical take account (and not target stocks of national confined to (and not and current FMA confined to So far, PT. 168 Benoa international review process), current FMA actively participates in P4KSI, demands and Cost effective review process), events held by WWF, (BPPL.,BBRSE, obligations risk assessment Cost effective especially during visits or KAPI) with ingrained into risk assessment information sharing to appropriate analytical tools, ingrained into stakeholders budget application of analytical tools, funding ecosystem application of secured from models, capacity ecosystem industry, building to models, capacity government support the building to and donors. above, support the awareness above, raising of awareness

30 activites undertaken and periodic review (includingsubject to external scrutiny). raising of activites undertaken and periodic review (includingsubject to external scrutiny) Company So far, PT. 168 Benoa provide actively participates in information Company events held by WWF, needed for the especially during visits or workshop information sharing to stakeholders

31 P4KSI to seek Indonesia through P4KSI have cooperation (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and cooperation with SPC/CSIRO LOKA Tuna Benoa) with SPC/CSIRO P4KSI with respect to participated and wrote a with respect to ecosystem data series of record to be ecosystem data collection reported for RFMO collection involve SDI, P4KSI, the stakeholders Agency of in national, Activities related to this MAF in incorporate districts on Province & program have not been raising research plan District, PLN, fully implemented awareness of socialization and KKJI, PSDP the research implementation plan to improve SDI, P4KSI, sharing understanding the result of Agency of Activities related to this among MAF in research to the program have not been stakeholders in Province & national and fully implemented national, districts District, PLN, provincial and KKJI, PSDP district level Company Activities related to this involving in Company program have not been research fully implemented extend internal review process (e.g. research, ) incorporating inputs from provincial and district levels extend internal review process (e.g. SDI, P4KSI, research, Agency of Activities related to this ) MAF in program have not been incorporating Province & fully implemented inputs from District provincial and district levels

32 4.1. Compliance action to be implemented based on risk analysis and determine enforcement priorities across the range of tuna fisheries to plan an to plan an external review external review process, as well process, as well Activities related to this as the as the BPK, KTI program have not been monitoring of monitoring of fully implemented implementation implementation of plan of plan 4. COMPLIANCE STRENGTHENING Initiate the development of compliance plans (incl PSDP, Agency activity, partner, Compliance of MAF in POKMASWAS pioneer budget) plans are Province & group has not been involving developed in District / identified national, conjunction with POKMAS provincial, national, district and provincial, community district and organizations community PSDP, Agency organizations of MAF in Dissemination of POKMASWAS pioneer Province & compliance group has not been District / plans for tuna identified POKMAS, fisheries associations

33 4.1.3 Company develop policy ensuring the adoption and implementation of the plan POKMASWAS pioneer Company group has not been identified 4.2. Strengthtening the legislation on sanctions Facilitate the government Upgrading on improving Updated regulations existing the sanctions of PSDP/MMAF related to supervision and violations regulations, Legal sanction has not been schedules to improving the Department established account for surveillance application to mechanism, and new enforcement to law violations measures and across the range Socialization of PSDP/MMAF Updated regulations of fisheries (EEZ, legislation on Legal related to supervision and archipelagic and sanctions for Department, sanction has not been coastal) tuna fisheries associations established stakeholders

34 4.2.3 Company develop policy on the implementation of the legislation Company Updated regulations related to supervision and sanction has not been established Training on measures (e.g. target species, bycatch reduction and 4.3. Education Applied to all consequences of BMP training Tuna handline, Sendangbiru, 2 PSDP, BPSDM process for stakeholder ecosystem November 2015 KP, SDI, fishers on groups, and interactions) for Participants who attended the fishermen, collectors, Companies or collectors P4KSI, KAPI, extended to the fishers: KUD Minajaya Sendangbiru, superintendent of should ensure fishing Agency of measures for POKMAS - using BMP for fisheries, water police and navy task force. With a practices in the field are as MAF in target species, network. sustainable total number of participants (based on attendance) per training. Henceforth, Province & bycatch Requires fishing practices as many as 27 people. monitoring will be District, reduction and considerable - using BMP for Info about activity can be seen di: performed a year after the Processors, consequences buy in from increase high training middlemen of ecosystem middlemen and fish quality to awal-pt-hatindo-sukses%20makmur-dan-pt-168- and WWF. interactions processors. reduce Benoa-Sebagai-Anggota-Seafood-Savers overfishing - using BMP for bycatch mitigation - traceability record

35 4.3.2 Ensures fishermen Training Tuna BMPs have been implemented. Ensure the conducting the implementation of sustainable Company corrective measures in the fishing practices BMP by collectors in the as trained on the field Facilitate the establishment of PokMasWas, PSDP, Agency prepared with of MAF in POKMASWAS pioneer surveillance and Province & group has not been monitoring plan District, all identified Arguably on fishing stakeholder 4.4. existing on some practices (incl. Strengthen basis already, Institutional and Community but requires capacity based considerable building) strengthening of Monitor PSDP, Agency systems for PokMasWas the performance of MAF in POKMASWAS pioneer hand-line and dedicated of PokMasWas Province & group has not been other coastal functions, as part of District, all identified fisheries. resourcing and stakeholder support. system Company develop policy to support the establishment and operation of PokMasWas POKMASWAS pioneer Company group has not been identified

36 4.5.1 Facilitate the collection of report on regulation compliance PSDP, Agency of MAF in Province & District Updated regulations related to supervision and sanction has not been established Reports are 4.5. Reports prepared and prepared and identifying the publicly result of Facilitate PSDP, Agency Updated regulations available inspection the report of MAF in related to supervision and identifying activities, uploading to the Province & sanction has not been violations especially in MMAF website District established detected relation with fishing activities Company develop policy on supporting datac ollectiona dn report preparation on regulation violation Company Updated regulations related to supervision and sanction has not been established 4.6. Train and Upgrading of Training on improve the existing PSDP surveillance to effectiveness training PokMasWas and of programme, but PSDP in the enforcement extended to provincial and PSDP, Agency Updated regulations of MAF in related to supervision and Province & sanction has not been District established

37 officers and Provincial and districts add District supporting participation. hardware Facilitate the workplan synchronization with other surveillance stakeholders to improve the surveillance and enforcement PSDP, Agency of MAF in Province & District, all stakeholder Updated regulations related to supervision and sanction has not been established Company develop policy on supporting enforcement officers work in the field Company Updated regulations related to supervision and sanction has not been established