Study of Railway Fatalities in Barpeta, Assam

Transcription

1 Study of Railway Fatalities in Barpeta, Assam Manoj Kumar Singha* Department of Forensic Medicine, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed Medical College and Hospital, Barpeta, Assam, India Abstract Indian railway is one of the largest railway networks in the world. Although the fatalities are less than the road traffic accidents, railway accidents have a major impact in victims lives. A total of 58 cases of death due to railway incidences were studied in the dept. of forensic medicine, FAAMCH, Barpeta, Assam, during the years 2015 and The demographic patterns including injuries, time of death and causes of deaths were studied. Males outnumbered the female victims. The majority of the railway accident cases are in the age group of 31 to 40 years. The patterns of injuries in death due to railway accident may vary according to the position or the different situations where accidents struck. The majority of deaths were due to head injury. Keywords: Railway, accident, injury, fatalities *Author for Correspondence drmanojsingha@gmail.com INTRODUCTION The rail transport system first appeared in England in the year 1820s. The railway was first introduced to India in 1853 from Bombay to Thane. The United States has world s no. 1 largest railway network and India is on the 4th position after Russia and China. In Indian railways, more than 22.2 million passengers travelled per day or billion passengers annually during [1]. Indian railway ran, on average, passenger trains daily in Mail or express trains are most common type [2]. According to NCRB, a total of cases of railway accidents were reported in the year 2015 and cases were deaths [3]. Fall from trains or collision with people at track constituted majority of railway accidents (72.5%). A total of 2669 cases of railway crossing accidents were reported, which caused 2650 deaths and 123 persons injured during Haryana has reported the maximum cases of railway crossing accidents (48.5% deaths of total RA fatalities). Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh had highest fatalities in railway accidents, accounting for 18.1 and 17.2% of total deaths in railway accidents respectively. In Assam, 10 persons (8 males and 2 females) died due to railway crossing accidents and 664 (males 603 and females 61) died due to railway accidents during the year 2015 [3]. In the year 2015, 3304 numbers of death cases were recorded in Mumbai local train (The Hindu). In the United States, train related accidents account for more than injuries and 1200 fatalities annually [4]. There are 43 nonsuicide fatalities and 314 were suicidal fatalities recorded in the Great Britain railway network during There were no passenger fatalities in train accident in Great Britain during [5]. Most railway disasters (74%) during , occurred in Asia and Africa, whereas Europe and Americas have experienced a decreasing trend. On the Asian Continent, India reported the most railway disasters (45%). In Europe, Russia reported the most railway disasters (18%) [6]. In China, 1336 people died in railroad accidents in 2013 and 1232 people died in the year 2014 [7]. The development of railway sector has resulted in the increase in the train traffic throughout the world. Simultaneously, numbers of accidents also increased in railway sectors. Indian railway has played a key role in India s social and economic development. It is a cheap and affordable means of transportation for millions of passengers. Barpeta Road RRJoT (2017) STM Journals All Rights Reserved Page 16

2 Study of Railway Fatalities in Barpeta, Assam Singha Manoj Kumar railway station is a main railway station in Barpeta district, Assam. It serves Barpeta Road as well as Barpeta Town. MATERIAL AND METHOD The present study of 58 death cases of railway incidence brought for post mortem examination by GRPS, Barpeta Road, has been carried out in the dept. of Forensic Medicine, FAAMCH, Barpeta, Assam, in a period of two years from 1st January 2015 to 31st December The data were collected from police, relatives and the autopsy findings. All the data were analyzed and findings were recorded. The post mortem examination was done as per the standard. RESULT AND OBSERVATIONS A total 1022 cases of post mortem examination were carried out in the Department of Forensic Medicine during the years 2015 and 2016; out of which 58 (5.7%) numbers of cases were deaths due to railway accidents (Figure 1). Maximum numbers among the cases were males, that is 37 (63.8%) and 21 (36.2%) were females. Male and female ratio was 1.8:1. Maximum victims (34.5%) were years old, followed by years of age group that is 25.9% (Table 1). Table 1: Age and Sex Distribution. S. No. Age Group Male Female Total % Total Maximum cases (96.6%) were died on the spot and only 3.4% cases were death on the way to health center. Maximum numbers of incidents, that is, 26 (44.8%) occurred in between 6am and 12noon. 20, 7 and 5 numbers of cases occurred in between 12noon and 6pm, 6pm and 12 midnight, and 12night to 6am respectively. The maximum cases were found in summer season, that is, 21 (36.2%), followed by autumn (27.6%), spring (19%) and winter (17.2%) (Figure 2). INCIDENCE OF RAILWAY FATALITIES 5.7% 94.3% OTHER AUTOPSY CASES RAILWAY FATALITIES Fig. 1: Incidence of Railway Fatalities. Table 2: External Injuries. Injury Head Neck Upper Limbs Lower Limbs Chest Abdomen Pelvic Ab Con Lac Cr Ab: Abrasion, Con: Contusion, Lac: Laceration and Cr: Crush. RRJoT (2017) STM Journals All Rights Reserved Page 17

3 Different types of injuries are described in the Tables 2 and 3; the maximum numbers have been highlighted. The maximum numbers of injuries were found in head followed by upper limbs and lower limbs. Separation of bodies was found in 3 (5.2%) cases and all the cases separated at the level of abdomen. Table 3: Internal Organ Injuries. Organ Contusion Laceration % Lung % Heart % Liver % Spleen % Kidney % Stomach % Intestine % Bladder % It was found that 17 (29.3%) cases were suicidal deaths and 41 (70.7%) were accident deaths. 8 (13.8%) cases of accidents occurred due to hit by train while they were walking along the side or through the track, 11 (19%) cases were accidental fall and 9 (15.5%) cases were deaths due to jump from the train while moving. 13 (22.4%) cases were those with history of crossing the track. Maximum cases were deaths due to head injuries, that is, 31 (53.5%) followed by instantaneous deaths (29.3%) and hemorrhage and shock (17.2%). DISCUSSION In the study, 58 (5.7%) cases of railway incidences among a total 1022 autopsies at Barpeta during the years 2015 and 2016 were considered. In India, a total of traffic accidents were reported during the year 2015, which include 2669 (0.5%) railway crossing accidents and (5.9%) were railway accidents. The percentage share of deaths in railway accidents and railway crossing accidents was reported as 14.7% (26066 deaths) and 1.5% (2650 deaths) respectively during 2015 (NCRB) [3]. Similar findings on railway incidences were observed by Wasnik (5.99%) [8], Bose et al. (6.11%) [9], Hussaini et al. (4.51%) [10], Chandru et al. (4.65%) [11], and Dalal et al. (15.53%) [12]. In the study, males 37 (63.8%) outnumbered the female (36.2%) victims. The maximum numbers of victims were in the age group 31 to 40 (34.5%), followed by 21 to 30 (25.9%). In India, maximum numbers of cases, both railway accidents and railway crossing accidents were age group in between 30 and 45 years, followed by 18 and 30 years [3]. Ozdogan et al. observed that majority of the fatalities were males (77%) for every types of incidents, and train pedestrian accidents were the most common causes of fatalities for all age groups [13]. Silla et al. observed that 51.4% of all accidents happened to people aged 10 to 29 years and 44.3% of the suicidal victims age group were 20 to 39 years [14] DISTRIBUTION OF CASES ACCORDING TO TIME OF INCIDENT AM-12PM 12PM-6PM 6PM-12AM 12AM-6AM Fig. 2: Distribution of Cases according to Time of Incident. RRJoT (2017) STM Journals All Rights Reserved Page 18

4 Study of Railway Fatalities in Barpeta, Assam Singha Manoj Kumar Majority of victims (96.6%) died on the spot. It was due to severe injuries or sometimes incidence took place in remote area. Washik observed that 96.53% cases died on the spot [8]. Hussaini et al. observed that majority of victims died on the spot (91.37%) [10]. In the study, majority of fatalities (44.8%) occurred in between 6am and 12noon, followed by 12noon and 6pm (34.5%). According to NCRB report in India, most of the railway accidents (4966 out of 28366) were reported during 6 to 9 h, 17.5% of total railway accidents were reported during 9 to 12 h. Silla and Luoma observed that suicide occurred mostly in afternoon, evening and midnight; on the other hand, maximum accidents occurred during rush hour that is 3pm to 6pm. In the study, maximum cases were found in summer season (36.2%) [14]. Similar findings were observed by Ozdogan et al. and Hussaini et al. in their studies [13, 10]. According to NCRB in India, most of railway accidents were reported in the month of August, contributing 8.7% of total railway accidents. Silla and Luoma observed that 52% of suicide cases were found in May, July, August, November and December; and most of the accidents occurred in the month of March and Nov [14]. Caird et al. observed that maximum cases were found in December and January, and less fatality occurred in July [15]. They also observed that 40% of fatalities occurred in between 9.30am and 3.30pm. There were maximum 25 numbers of lacerated injuries and 14 crush injuries present over the head, followed by injuries present in both upper and lower limbs. Valsala et al. classified the victims in to two groups: one, pedestrian walking along the side of or through the track and second, pedestrian while crossing the rail track [16]. They observed that head injuries were maximum in both groups that is 82.3 and 91% respectively. Hussaini et al. observed that commonest involved region was head (54.31%) followed by upper and lower limbs (63.79%) [10]. In the study, maximum numbers of contusion and laceration injuries were found in lungs, liver and both kidneys. Wasnik observed that maximum numbers of injuries were found in lungs (88.65%) followed by liver (41.75%) [8]. In the study, 70.7% of cases were accidental deaths and 29.3% of cases were suicidal in nature. Similar findings were observed by Chandru et al. (accidental deaths 86.15% and suicidal 13.85%) [11], Roopkumar et al. (accidental deaths 71% and suicidal 29%) and Ozdogan et al. (accidents deaths 76.4% and suicidal 21.8%) [17, 13]. The accident rate is high due to carelessness, ignorance of the people or disobeying traffic rule or safety rule. But Silla and Luoma observed that suicidal incidences were 84.9% [14]. In England and Wales railway suicides account for 90% of total railway fatalities during the year 2014 to Taylor et al. observed that railway suicide accounted 4.1% of all suicide in England and Wales during the period 2000 to 2013 [18]. They observed that proportion of railway suicide was higher in other Western European countries than Great Britain; it accounted for 5% of all suicides in Belgium, 7% of all suicides in Germany and 11.5% of all suicides in the Netherland. It is observed that railway suicide is a highly lethal suicidal method [19 21]. In the study, 11 (19%) cases were deaths due to fall, 9 (15.5%) cases were deaths due to jump from the train while moving, 8 (13.8%) cases deaths due to hit by the train and 13 (22.4%) cases were history of crossing train. Ozdogan et al. observed that 42.4% of railway fatalities occurred due to train pedestrian accidents, 5.9% cases deaths due to falling from the train and 28.1% fatalities were due to level crossing accidents [13]. Silla and Luoma observed maximum cases (10 out of 35) were deaths during the crossing the tracks. In our study, two cases were fatalities which occurred during crossing the tracks while they were using mobile headphones [14]. In the study, causes of maximum deaths were due to head injuries, that is, 53.5%, followed by instantaneous deaths, that is, 29.3% and lastly, hemorrhage and shock (17.2%). Wasnik observed that 64.73% of fatalities were due to injuries to vital organs, followed by 19.65% due to hemorrhage and shock and 15.02% were due to head injuries [8]. CONCLUSION Most of the railway fatalities were accidental in nature. Males outnumbered the females and maximum fatalities were in between 21 and 40 years of age group. Maximum causes of RRJoT (2017) STM Journals All Rights Reserved Page 19

5 deaths were due to head injuries. The railway authority should take some steps to prevent the accidents by strict law enforcement, training and awareness of staff as well as the public. Where the population density is high and train traffic is dense, limitation of pedestrian access to the tracks by using fencing and physical barriers, monitoring and detection systems like motion detectors, video cameras, infrared cameras and speakers should be introduced. High-risk location should be identified. REFERENCES 1. Indian Railways Statistical Publications Statistical Summary. Ministry of Railway. Retrieved 26th Feb Indian Railways Statistical Publications Year Book Ministry of Railway, 62p. Retrieved 26th Feb NCRB. Accidental Deaths and Suicide in India Goldbarg BA, et al. Train Accidents Involving Pedestrians, Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles. Am J Orthop. 1996; 27: p. 5. Peter Moran. Rail Safety Statistics G. Britain and Europe: Annual Statistical Release; Sep Rebecca Forsberg. Train Crashes- Consequences for Passengers. Dept. of Surgical and Perioperative Sci., Umea University, Sweden Lu Binyang (a Caixin Staff Reporter). Why China does not Publish Fatal Train Crush Data. Caixin: Jan 19, Ramesh Nanaji Wasnik. Analysis of Railway Fatalities in Central India. JIAFM. 2010; 32(4): p. 9. Basu R, et al. Railway Fatalities: A Retrospective Study. Forensicon Bulletin, Kolkata Hussaini SN, et al. Patterns of Railway Fatalities in Western Vidarbha Region of India. IJFMT. Jul Dec 2014; 8(2): 77 80p. 11. Chandru K, et al. Analysis of Fatal Railway Accidents in District Hospital South India: A Retrospective Study. IJFMT. Jul Dec 2014; 8(2): 52 54p. 12. Dalal JS, et al. Homicide Cases Reported as Railway Accidents. JIAFM. 2006; 28(4). 13. Mehmet Ozdogan, et al. The Epidemiology of the Railway Related Casualties. Turkish J of T and E Surgery. 2006; 12(3): p. 14. Anne Silla, Juha Luoma. Accidents Analysis and Prevention. Elsevier. 2012; 45: 61 66p. 15. Caird JK, et al. A Human Factors Analysis of Highway-Railway Grade Crossing Accidents in Canada. 4th Workshop on Highway-Railway Grade Crossing Research. Montreal, Quibec Valsala K, et al. An Autopsy Based Comparative Study of Pattern of Injuries in Pedestrians Involved in Railway Track Deaths. Int J of Adv R. 2017; 5(1): p. 17. Roopkumar KM, et al. A Study on Patterns of Injuries due to Railway Accidents Occurring at Khammam Region, Andhra Pradesh. IJFMT. Jul Dec 2014; 8(2): 72 76p. 18. Taylor Anna K, et al. Railway Suicide in England and Wales, : A Time Trends Analysis. BMC Public Health. 2016; 16: 270p. 19. Meltem Akkas, et al. 10 Years Evaluation of Train Accidents. Turkish J of T and E Surgery. 2011; 17(5): p. 20. Silji Storveen. Evaluation and Learning after Major Railway Accidents. Norwegian University of Sci. and Tech Siti Baharah I. The Development of Railway Level Crossing Fatality Assessment Model. 29th Conference of Australian Institutes of Transport Research, Adelaide. 5th 7th Dec Cite this Article Manoj Kumar Singha. Study of Railway Fatalities in Barpeta, Assam. Research & Reviews: A Journal of Toxicology. 2017; 7(2): 16 20p. RRJoT (2017) STM Journals All Rights Reserved Page 20