Colombo Business Journal
|
|
- Myra Dennis
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Colombo Businss Journal Faculty of Managmnt & Financ Vol. 07, No. 01, Jun, 2016 Univrsity of Colombo Intrnational Journal of Thory & Practic Economtric Analysis of Trad Opnnss and Economic Growth for Dvloping Countris Muhammad Tahira1, Mohammad Sad Lodhib a,b Dpartmnt of Managmnt Scincs, COMSATS Institut of Information Tchnology, Pakistan Abstract This papr has xamind th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth in th dvloping countris in ordr to hav a bttr undrstanding of th trad-growth rlationship. Empirical analyss ar carrid out through panl fixd ffcts stimation procdur, and data ar utilizd for two sampls of th dvloping countris for th priod Th ndognity issu of trad opnnss is handld through instrumntal variabl. Our main finding is that th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth is positiv and statistically significant. Th impact of domstic invstmnt, labour forc, ducation, and dmocracy on conomic growth is also positiv and statistically significant. Th rsults also show that uncrtain policis such as frqunt fluctuations in prics ar dtrimntal to long-run conomic growth. It rcommndd that th dvloping countris should libraliz intrnational trad, nsur macroconomic stability, and pay favourabl attntion to othr dtrminants of conomic growth in ordr to grow fastr in th long-run. Kywords: Trad Opnnss, Growth, Fixd Effcts Modls, Endognity, Instrumntal Variabls 1. Introduction Th impact of trad opnnss on conomic growth has attractd much attntion in litratur during th last coupl of dcads. Intrnational trad opnnss is considrd a ky dtrminant of conomic growth in rcnt tims. Intrnational organizations such as World Trad Organization (WTO) and Intrnational Montary Fund (IMF) ar constantly advising th dvloping countris to mov towards mor libral rgim. Th spctacular growth xprinc of th Tigr conomis of Asia (Singapor, South Kora, Taiwan, and Hong Kong) ovr th yars, and th rcnt growth xprinc of som of th dvloping countris such as India and China, aftr moving towards libral rgim, hav forcd policy makrs spcially in th dvloping world to implmnt outward-orintd policis. Such policis ar xpctd to influnc th growth procss of th dvloping countris positivly. Whil thr is a vry rich mpirical litratur on th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth, th positivnss and th ngativity of th rlationship ar still dbatabl, owing to 1 Corrsponding Author: tahirm@ciit.nt.pk
2 mixd mpirical vidnc. Som studis such as Dollar (1992), Sachs and Warnr (1995) and Edwards (1998) hav providd sound vidnc in favour of th positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth. On th othr hand, rsarchrs such as Rodrik and Rodriguz (2000) and Rodriguz (2007) ar scptical of th positiv trad-growth rlationship. Thir criticism mainly applis to th mthodologis and masurs of trad opnnss usd. This papr aims at contributing to th mpirical vidnc rgarding th trad - growth rlationship in th dvloping countris in various ways. To do this, first, th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth for a sampl of 67 dvloping countris, which consists of 14 low-incom, 27 lowr-middl-incom and 26 uppr-middl- incom conomis is tstd. Scond, uppr-middl conomis ar xcludd from th initial sampl to nabl us focus on lowr - middl - incom and low - incom conomis. Th rational bhind doing this is to xamin th rol of trad opnnss for conomic growth in th lowr-middl-incom and low-incom conomis. Th dvloping countris nd policy lssons rgarding intrnational trad in ordr to implmnt and xcut appropriat policis to spd up growth procss. It has bn obsrvd, ovr th yars, that th dvloping countris ar rluctant to opn thir markts to th intrnational trad bcaus of prsistnt confusion cratd by mixd mpirical rsarch. This study provids comprhnsiv policy lssons for th dvloping countris rgarding intrnational trad policy. In this papr, w hav brifly rviwd both thortical and mpirical litratur on th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth, to provid a prlud for subsqunt discussions in sction 2. Nxt, w prsnt a summary of statistics on trad opnnss and pr capita GDP. Furthr, spcification of modl, sampl and data, ndognity issu and stimating mthodology ar dalt with. Discussion of th main findings is includd in th pnultimat sction. Th papr nds with conclusions and rcommndations. 2. Litratur Rviw 2.1 Thortical Litratur Intrnational trad opnnss and its rlationship with conomic growth is a wll-rsarchd topic in trad-growth litratur. Thoris of intrnational trad strongly support th hypothsis that incrasd opnnss to intrnational trad can influnc conomic growth positivly. According to th absolut advantag thory of intrnational trad, intrnational trad givs accss to xtndd intrnational markts and improvs productivity through division of labour (Smith, 1776). Small siz of th domstic markt acts as a hurdl to conomic growth particularly in th dvloping countris. Thirlwall (2000) argus that th major dynamic bnfit of intrnational trad is that domstic producrs gt accss to widnd markts. Th comparativ advantag thory blivs that intrnational trad is bnficial and brings production gains and consumption gains to trading partnrs (Ricardo, 1817). In th sam way, Carbaugh (2005) has argud that, in th framwork of nw trad thory, conomis with similar rsourc ndowmnts and ngligibl comparativ advantag may bnfit from th intrnational trad bcaus of massiv conomis of scal. Additionally, thortical litratur has indicatd that trad opnnss has th capacity to acclrat and sustain long-run conomic growth by improving productivity, incrasing comptitiv prssur among th domstic producrs and channls of domstic invstmnt (Dobr, 2008). Grossman and Hlpman (1994) hav argud that opn conomis can accss largr tchnical knowldg bas than 25
3 closd conomis. Furthr, thy hav argud that in th procss of tchnological dissmination, trad can play a vital rol. In thortical litratur, Fistas (2005) has documntd that libralization of intrnational trad stimulats incom and long-run conomic growth. It is worth noting that thortical litratur on trad opnnss has documntd that trad opnnss improvs conomic growth. According to Lopz (2005) and Lin (2000), this improvmnt in conomic growth occurs through nhancing th allocativ fficincy and channlling of forign dirct invstmnt. In rcnt tims howvr, som controvrsis hav bn raisd among rsarchrs on trad-growth rlationship in th framwork of trad thoris. In a rcnt papr, Bajona, Gibson, Kho, and Ruhl (2010) hav analysd various static and dynamic modls of intrnational trad; thy conclud trad modls only prdict that trad opnnss can improv social wlfar, but not ncssarily conomic growth. Furthr, thortical litratur dos not provid a dcisiv answr to th trad-growth rlationship (Ulasan, 2012). 2.2 Empirical Litratur Extnsiv studis hav bn conductd on th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth during th last coupl of dcads. Empirical vidnc rgarding th trad-growth rlationship in th contxt of dvloping countris is mixd. Som rsarchrs such as Dollar (1992), Sachs and Warnr (1995), and Frankl and Romr (1999) ar vry much convincd about th positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth. Rodrik and Rodriguz (2000), howvr, hav cast doubts on th positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth by highlighting problms rlatd to applid mthodologis and th way trad opnnss is masurd. For instanc, Rodriguz (2007) has focusd on rcnt mpirical studis (Dollar & Kraay, 2002; Warnr, 2003; Wacziarg & Wlch, 2003) and concludd that standard masurs of trad policy ar not rlatd to conomic growth. On th othr hand, Bhagwati and Srinivasan (2001) hav analysd th criticism Rodrik and Rodriguz (2000) hav mad about th positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth and commntd that th criticism is unprsuasiv. Warnr (2003) has commntd that th crucial vidnc is ignord and indd thr was a ngativ rlationship btwn trad rstrictions and conomic growth. In a rcnt study, Panagariya (2004), has also paid attntion to th criticism mad by Rodrik and Rodriguz (2000) about th positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth, and documntd that th vidnc from cross country growth rgrssion is not wak and thrfor, outward-orintd policis could not b rjctd. Mor to th point, Fistas (2005) hav argud that dspit mthodological issus, thr is no vidnc that trad libralization is harmful for conomic growth. Tahir and Norulazidah (2013), Tahir and Khan (2014) and Tahir (2013) rportd a positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth for both dvlopd and dvloping countris. Again, Tahir and Norulazidah (2014) rviwd both th thortical and mpirical litratur on trad opnnss and conomic growth and concludd that indd thr is a positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth. With rfrnc to th dvloping countris, Sachs and Warnr (1995) found that opn dvloping conomis grw fastr than th closd dvloping conomis ovr th yars. It follows, that intgration to th world conomy is in th intrst of th dvloping countris from growth prspctiv. Dollar (1992) proposd two indics for masuring trad libralization and found that thr is a positiv rlationship btwn trad libralization and conomic prformanc. Th study conductd by Yanikkaya (2003) has qustiond th convntional wisdom rgarding th rlationship 26
4 btwn trad rstrictions and conomic growth in th contxt of th dvloping countris. Ackah (2008) has argud that trad libralization influncs conomic growth positivly in rlativly richr conomis. On th contrary, Dowrick and Golly (2004) commntd that most of th bnfits of trad libralization hav occurrd in th dvlopd countris post 1980s. Dava (2012) has argud that th dbat on th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth has not yt bn sttld. In th sam way, Ulasan (2012) commntd that th dbat on tradgrowth rlationship is controvrsial and th availabl litratur has not providd convincing and robust vidnc. Furthr, it is argud that thory dos not provid a dcisiv answr about th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth. Also, Stnsns (2006) has rightly assrtd that a robust rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth has not bn stablishd yt, and th rlationship btwn trad opnnss and growth should b dtrmind mpirically bcaus of ambiguitis in th thortical modls. Thr ar diffrnt factors xplaining why rsarchrs hav not bn abl to provid an xplicit answr to th qustion of whthr trad opnnss rally mattrs for achiving a highr conomic growth. Firstly, th quality of data may b poor spcially in th contxt of low-incom dvloping countris. Scondly, sampl htrognity is also a potntial factor bhind mixd mpirical vidnc. Th prsnc of both th dvlopd and dvloping countris in th sam sampl might b mislading, and hnc gnralization basd on such analysis might b doubtful. This might imply that such an xrcis might not uncovr th tru rlationship. Thirdly, a clar cut mchanism by which trad opnnss influncs conomic growth is ambiguous. Thrfor, th only option rsarchrs do hav is to dal with th trad growth rlationship mpirically. 3. Som Obsrvations on Trad Opnnss and Economic Growth Intrnational trad has incrasd spcially among th dvloping countris ovr th last fw dcads. According to Tabl 1, prcntag incras of 28 prcnt in avrag trad opnnss can b sn for th dvloping countris during 1990 to Arguably, this incras in trad opnnss has also contributd significantly to conomic growth. Similarly, th avrag pr capita GDP in purchasing powr parity has also incrasd for th dvloping countris from in 1990 to in 2009, showing an incras of almost of prcnt. In addition, a scattr diagram in Figur 1 dpicts th growth of ral pr capita GDP during 1990 to 2009 of th ntir sampl. In Figur 1, th actual opnnss is plottd on horizontal axis whil th growth of pr capita GDP is masurd on vrtical axis. Th scattr diagram shows a positiv rlationship btwn pr capita GDP growth and trad opnnss. Simpl corrlation btwn th growth of pr capita GDP and th dgr of trad opnnss is Th obsrvd positiv rlationship is not vry strong and it could b du to sampl siz and its rprsntativnss. Thr ar diffrnt groups of dvloping countris and hnc thir dgr of trad opnnss may b significantly diffrnt. 27
5 Figur 1: Th Rlationship btwn Pr Capita GDP and Trad Opnnss ) (1 P D G ta i p a C r P l a R f o t a R h t w o r G Actual Trad Opnnss ( ) Sourc: Hston, Summrs & Atn, 2011 [Pnn World Tabls, Vrsion: 7] As mntiond in Tabl 1, thr ar significant variations in th dgr of trad opnnss of upprmiddl incom, lowr-middl incom and low incom countris. Owing to ths apparnt diffrncs in trad opnnss, w could not s a strong rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth as shown in Figur 1. Th sub division of th sampl (as shown in Tabl 1) shows that th opnnss dgr is incrasd from to for uppr middl conomis, from to for lowr-middl-incom conomis, and from to for low-incom conomis from th priod 1990 to Tabl 1, also rports changs in pr capita GDP for diffrnt sts of th dvloping countris. Tabl 1: Th Rlationship btwn Trad Opnnss and Pr Capita GDP ( ) Countris Trad opnnss (1990) Pr capita GDP (1990) Trad opnnss (2009) Pr capita GDP (2009) Prcntag chang in opnnss Prcntag chang in pr capita GDP Whol sampl (67) % % % % % % % % Uppr-middlincom (26) Lowr- middl incom (27) Low incom (14) Sourc: Hston, Summrs & Atn, 2011 [Pnn World Tabls, Vrsion: 7] Tabl 1, shows that among th dvloping countris, low-incom conomis ar still far bhind in trms of opnnss compard to uppr-middl and lowr-middl-incom conomis. Th dgr of trad opnnss is for lowr-middl-incom countris, prcnt for uppr-middl-incom 28
6 countris, and only for th low-incom countris in Th possibl rason for th abov obsrvation might b that th low-incom countris ar far bhind in trms of pr capita GDP. Furthr, Tabl 1 shows changs in pr capita GDP for diffrnt sts of countris includd in th sampl. Thr is a clos rlationship btwn th changs in opnnss and changs in pr capita GDP. Th countris with low opnnss dgr ar also having low lvl of pr capita GDP. Th upprmiddl-incom and lowr-middl-incom countris ar much mor opn than low-incom countris, and hnc thir pr capita is also high compard to low-incom countris. Th low-incom countris hav achivd an incras of prcnt in GDP pr capita during th priod from Data shows that th dgr of trad opnnss has incrasd by prcnt for th low-incom countris, but furthr incras is rquird as th opnnss in 2009 is 61.85, which is still far bhind as compard to uppr-middl-incom and lowr-middl-incom countris. 4. Modl, Mthodology, Sampl, and Data Sourcs 4.1 Th Modl Trad thoris and growth thoris support th hypothsis that trad opnnss nhancs conomic growth. This hypothsis is tstd with th hlp of standard panl conomtric tchniqus in ordr to control for th unobsrvd factors. Howvr, conomic growth is indd a complx procss and hnc cannot b xplaind by a singl dtrminant of conomic growth such as trad opnnss or invstmnt. Economic growth can b influncd by various dtrminants. Both domstic invstmnt and labour forc dtrmin th productiv capacity of an conomy, and ar considrd to b th ky dtrminants of growth. Human capital or simply ducation also influncs conomic growth by improving th productiv fficincy. Furthr, macroconomic nvironmnt also mattrs for th smooth functioning of an conomy. Frqunt fluctuations in macroconomic variabls advrsly affct conomic activitis. Similarly, uncrtainty in policis shattrs confidnc of invstors, and hnc growth rat dclins. In addition, sound institutional systm is also qually important for achiving highr conomic growth lik all othr dtrminants. Sound institutions affctivly coordinat among diffrnt sctors of th conomy and furthr provid a platform to all stakholdrs to play thir part in th national dvlopmnt procss. Howvr, institutions ar indd difficult to masur. Thrfor, w captur th ovrall impact of institutional factors through dmocratic systm with th assumption that only dmocratic govrnmnt can nhanc th quality of institutions. In othr words, th prsnc of dmocratic govrnmnt is an indication of good institutions. Th following modl is spcifid for analysis: ℎ = (1) Th subscript ( ) rprsnts cross sctional dimnsion of th data and ( ) stands for th tim dimnsion of th data. Th trm ( ℎ ) stands for th dpndnt variabl and masurs growth of ral pr capita GDP in purchasing powr parity. ( ) dnots domstic capital formation and is usd as a proxy for invstmnt. Trad opnnss is dnotd by ( ) and is calculatd by dividing th sum of xports plus imports on GDP ( / ). All quantitis ar in ral trms. Th trm ( ) stands for th growth of labour forc, which is calculatd as th growth rat of population aging btwn 15 to 64 yars. For ducation ( ), gross nrolmnt ratio at scondary lvl is usd rgardlss of ag group, and ( ) rfrs to inflation volatility which is 29
7 masurd as th standard dviation of inflation, whil stands for dmocracy, which masurs institutional aspct and it has bn approximatd by an indx which rangs from 10 (Dmocratic) to -10 (Autocratic). 4.2 Sampl and Data Sourcs Kping in mind th objctiv of th papr, a list of countris basd on pr capita GDP has bn collctd from th World Bank. Th World Bank has catgorizd countris in to diffrnt groups basd on pr capita GDP. Basd on data availability, only 67 dvloping countris ar chosn for th sampl, which consists of 14 lowr-incoms, 27 lowr-middl-incom and 26 uppr-middl-incom countris (s appndix for th list of countris). Th uppr middl- incom countris ar thos whr pr capita GDP is ranging btwn 3976 to dollars. Th countris whr pr capita GDP is gratr than 1006 dollars and lss than 3975 dollars, ar namd as lowr-middl-incom countris. Th third group of countris among th dvloping countris ar namd as low-incom countris, whr pr capita GDP is only 1005 dollars or lss. Data ranging from 1990 to 2009, ar convrtd to 5 yar avrags in ordr to avoid th short run fluctuations that could affct th rlationship btwn th indpndnt variabls and th dpndnt variabl (Harrison, 1995). Data on GDP pr capita, trad opnnss and population ar takn from Pnn World Tabls (Hston t al., 2011). Data on gross fixd capital formation as a ratio of GDP, inflation rat and labour forc ar obtaind from World Bank dvlopmnt indicators (World Bank, ). Educational and dmocracy data ar obtaind from CANA databas (Castllacci & Natra, 2011). 4.3 Th Endognity Problm Th convntional masur of trad opnnss (xports plus imports as a ratio of GDP) which is also usd in this papr is ndognous in th growth quation (1). It is bcaus of th fact that forign trad pattrn of a country can also b affctd by its siz rgardlss of its trad policy. Rsarchs hav also highlightd th ndognity issus associatd with th masur of trad opnnss (Frankl & Romr; 1999, Wintrs; 2004). W assum that siz of a country can influnc its forign trad pattrn. Howvr, th point w want to mak hr is that th rlationship btwn siz of a country and its forign trad also dpnds on th productiv capacity of domstic conomy. To put it diffrntly, a country with vn a high population may trad mor if it is incapabl to produc nough to mt th dmands of its domstic consumrs and producrs. It may trad lss, if it producs sufficint to fulfil th domstic dmands of its consumrs and producrs. This implis that th productiv capacity of an conomy plays a significant rol in dtrmining its pattrn of forign trad. It is, thrfor, important to adjust th crud trad opnnss of ach country for its siz in ordr to liminat th impact of siz of th country on its dgr of trad opnnss. To do this, 20 yars data on trad opnnss is rgrssd on 20 yars data on a total population of includd countris in th sampl. Th fittd valus ar collctd and convrtd to 5 yars avrags. Ths avrags ar in turn usd as an instrumnt for trad opnnss in th growth rgrssion. Th simpl corrlation cofficint btwn th actual trad opnnss and th fittd valus is (0.93), which shows th strngth of th instrumnt. Th actual trad opnnss is plottd against th instrumntd trad opnnss in Figur 2 as bllow: 30
8 Figur 2: Th Rlationship btwn th Actual Trad Opnnss and Instrumntd Trad Opnnss s s n n p O d ra T d t n m u rt s n I Actual Trad Opnnss In Figur 2, th actual trad opnnss and instrumntd trad opnnss ar plottd on horizontal axis and vrtical axis rspctivly. Th Figur displays a strong positiv rlationship btwn th actual trad opnnss and instrumntd trad opnnss. Both quantitis ar moving in th sam dirction. Most of th data points ar ovrlapping, showing th validity of th instrumnt. Tabl 2: Main Growth Rgrssion Rsults Variabls Constant Whol Sampl (67) Uppr-middlincomLowr-middl incomlow incom countris Fixd Effcts Fixd Effcts * (IV) 10 Statistical critria Sub Sampl (41) Low-incomLowr-middlincom countris Fixd Effcts Fixd Effcts *** 0.10*** 0.22*** 0.12*** 0.12*** 0.07** 0.08** 0.71*** 0.67*** 0.89*** 0.86*** 0.09*** 0.09*** 0.10*** 0.12*** -0.04*** 0.003*** -0.04*** 0.003*** -0.05*** *** R2 = 0.68; Adj- R2= 0.50; SER = 0.09; F = 3.76 R2 = 0.69; Adj- R2= 0.51; SER = 0.09; F = 3.79 R2 = 0.69; Adj- R2= 0.50; SER = 0.09; F = 3.56 R2 = 0.70; Adj- R2= 0.50; SER = 0.09; F =
9 Not: Th dpndnt variabl is th growth of ral pr capita GDP. (***), (**) and (*) stands for 1%, 5% and 10% lvl of significanc. In th last sction, an instrumnt for trad opnnss is constructd in ordr to addrss th likly ndognity of trad opnnss. Bfor stimating th modls, F-tst is conductd to s whthr, indd, panl data tchniqus ar ncssary or not. Also, th Hausman tst is prformd to choos btwn th fixd ffcts and random ffcts modl. Th F-tst displayd th prsnc of fixd ffcts, whil th Hausman spcification tst (1978) prfrrd th fixd ffcts modl ovr random ffcts modl. Thrfor, poold last squar stimation and random ffcts stimation ar not appropriat. Th htroscdasticity problm is corrctd by stimating modls with Whit (1980) robust stimator. Two rgrssion modls, on with actual trad opnnss, and on with instrumntd trad opnnss ar stimatd for th ntir sampl of 67 dvloping countris as wll as for th subsampl of 41 dvloping countris. Rgrssion rsults ar displayd in Tabl Rsults and Discussion Th rsults basd on fixd ffcts stimation sms to b consistnt with conomic thory and also with past mpirical rsarch. Th actual trad opnnss is significantly diffrnt from zro at 10 prcnt lvl for th whol sampl of 67 dvloping countris and at 1 prcnt lvl for 41 lowincom and lowr-middl-incom dvloping countris. Also, th instrumntd trad opnnss is statistically significant at 1 prcnt lvl for both sampls. This might suggst that opn trad policis ar rlvant for acclrating conomic growth in th dvloping countris. It is, thrfor, in th intrst of th dvloping countris to spd up th procss of trad libralization in ordr to grow fastr and match with th conomic growth of richr countris. Th rsults suggst that th dvloping countris in gnral should not worry about th wak argumnts favouring protctionism. It has bn obsrvd ovr th yars that th dvloping countris, particularly, th lss dvloping countris ar rluctant to opn up thir markts in to th global conomy. Howvr, survival without intgrating into th global ntwork is almost impossibl in today s complx world. Thrfor, th dvloping countris ar suggstd to spcializ according to th thory of comparativ advantag in ordr to achiv both production gains and consumption gains. Th production and consumption gains ovr th yars would contribut to th growth procss of th dvloping countris rmarkably. Th domstic invstmnt and labour forc, which ar considrd as drivrs of conomic growth in both thortical and mpirical litratur, hav rportd positiv cofficints and ar statistically significant at standard lvls. Th dvloping countris, thrfor, ar suggstd to pay favourabl attntion to th basic dtrminants of conomic growth such as invstmnt and labour forc in ordr to improv thir growth rats. Th surplus and idl labour forc, spcially in th lss-dvloping countris could b tackld through ncouraging additional invstmnt in th domstic conomy. Human capital, which is approximatd by gross nrolmnt rats at scondary lvl, bars a positiv sign in th stimatd rgrssion modls and it is also statistically significant. Th rsults suggst that th dvloping countris nd to invst in human capital. For instanc, ducating mor popl will boost th growth procss, spcially in th dvloping countris. It is an undniabl fact that ducatd labour forc can play its part in th procss of production mor fficintly compard to th ordinary labour forc. 32
10 Inflation volatility is also highly significant at 1 prcnt lvl and carris a ngativ cofficint, confirming that frqunt fluctuations in prics ar dtrimntal to conomic growth. Likwis, th issu of uncrtainty in policis is harmful to conomic growth. Th policis, spcially in dvloping countris, ar unstabl and unprdictabl. This suggsts that macroconomic policis should b proprly managd and xcutd in ordr to liminat its harmful ffcts on conomic growth. Furthr, it is found that th impact of dmocracy, which is bing usd as a proxy for institutional factor, is not only positiv, but also, statistically significant. This implis that th dvloping countris should rjct infficint forms of govrnmnts such as dictatorship and mov towards dmocratic rgims. Th impact of dmocracy on conomic growth howvr, is positiv; although it is also statistically insignificant for low-incom and lowr-middl-incom countris. Th poor natur of dmocratic govrnmnts and its involvmnt in corrupt practics could xplain th insignificant impact of dmocracy on conomic growth in th contxt of low-incom and lowr-middl-incom conomis. Adjustd R-squard for th whol sampl of 67 dvloping countris is 0.50, 0.51 for th modls with actual trad opnnss and instrumntd trad opnnss rspctivly, indicating that 50 prcnt variation in th growth of pr capita GDP is xplaind by th fittd modls. For th sub-sampl sampl of 41 lowr-middl and low-incom countris, th fittd modls can xplain 50 prcnt variation in growth procss. F-statistic is also statistically significant in all cass at 1 prcnt lvl, indicating that th stimatd modls fit th data wll. 6. Concluding Rmarks and Policy Rcommndations This papr has xamind th impact of trad opnnss on conomic growth for th dvloping countris. First, mpirical analyss ar carrid out for th whol sampl of 67 dvloping countris, consisting of uppr-middl-incom, lowr-middl-incom, and low-incom dvloping countris. Scond, th trad-growth rlationship is also tstd for low-incom and lowr-middl-incom dvloping countris togthr. Howvr, du to small sampl siz, rgrssions modls ar not stimatd sparatly for lowr middl incom and low incom dvloping countris. Not running sparat rgrssions for diffrnt groups of countris is a limitation of th papr, spcially givn that th bhaviour of th data dos not appar to b similar (i.., in lowr-middl incom countris, thr is a larg chang in growth corrsponding to a small chang in opnnss, whras in low incom countris thr is only a small chang in growth corrsponding to a larg chang in opnnss; s Tabl 1). Panl conomtric tools ar applid using data from for th mpirical analysis. Th rsults show that opnnss to intrnational trad mattrs for achiving highr conomic growth in th dvloping countris. Furthrmor, it is found that th positiv rlationship btwn trad opnnss and conomic growth is applicabl to th lowr-middl-incom and low-incom dvloping countris. Howvr, givn th abov statd limitation, th lattr is not a clar finding. In addition, a positiv rlationship is obsrvd btwn domstic invstmnt, labour forc, ducation, dmocracy, and conomic growth. A ngativ rlationship is found btwn inflation volatility and conomic growth for both sampls. Th dvloping countris in gnral ar suggstd to spd up th procss of trad libralization in ordr to grow fastr in th long run. Also th lowr middl incom countris and low incom countris should also tak appropriat stps in ordr to nsur gratr participation in global trad. Howvr, it should also b notd that th suggstd rcommndations ar not vry conclusiv du to 33
11 th fact that sparat rgrssion modls ar not stimatd owing to small sampl siz. Similarly, a favourabl attntion could b mad by th dvloping countris in gnral to th basic dtrminants of conomic growth if thy want to improv thir conomic conditions. Furthr, fforts ar rquird on th part of policy makrs to nsur macroconomic stability. Lastly, an fficint dmocratic govrnmnt will also contribut to th growth procss of th dvloping countris. Rfrncs Ackah, C. (2008). For richr or poorr: Trad policy and growth in dvloping countris. Papr prsntd at UNECA Ad-hoc Exprt Group Mting on Macroconomic Policy Productiv Capacity and Growth in Africa, Addis Ababa. Bajona, C., Gibson, M. J., Kho, T. J., & Ruhl, K. J. (2010). Trad libralization, growth, and productivity. Papr prsntd at Nw dirctions in intrnational trad thory. Univrsity of Nottingham. Bhagwati, J., & Srinivasan, N. (2001). Outward-orintation and dvlopmnt: Ar rvisionists right? (Discussion Papr No. 806). Economic Growth Cntr. Castllacci, F., & Natra, J. M. (2011). A nw panl datast for cross-country analyss of national systms, growth and dvlopmnt (CANA) (MPRA Papr No ). Munich Prsonal RPEc Archiv Carbaugh, J. R. (2005). Intrnational conomics. Unitd Stats: Thomson South-Wstron. Dava, E. (2012, Sptmbr). Trad libralization and conomic growth in th SADC: A diffrnc-indiffrnc alnalysis. Papr prsntd at Moçambiqu: Acumulação Transformação Contxto d Cris Intrnacional Dobr, C. (2008). Th rlationship btwn opnnss to trad and conomic growth. Anall Stiinłific Al Univrsităłii Alxandru ioan Cuza Din IASI, Dollar, D. (1992). Outward-orintd conomis rally do grow mor rapidly: Evidnc from 95 LDCs. Economic Dvlopmnt and Cultural Chang, 40(3), Dollar, D., & Kraay, A. ( 2002). Trad, growth, and povrty. Economic Journal 114 (493), Dowrick, S., & Golly, J. (2004). Trad opnnss and growth: Who bnfits? Oxford Rviw of Economic Policy, 20(1), Edwards, S. (1998). Opnnss, productivity and growth: What do w rally know? Th Economic Journal, 108, Fistas, I. (2005). Th ffcts of trad libralization on growth, povrty and inquality. CILAE Nota técnica NT/04/05. Frankl, A. J., & Romr, D. (1999). Dos trad caus growth? Th Amrican Economic Rviw, 89(3), Grossman, M., & Hlpman, E. (1994). Endognous innovation in th thory of growth. Th Journal of Economic Prspctivs, 8(1), Harrison, A. (1995). Opnnss and growth: A tim sris, cross-country analysis for dvloping countris (NBER Working Papr No. 5221). Cambridg, MA: National Burau of Economic Rsarch Hausman, J. (1978). Spcification tsts in conomtrics. Economtrica, 46 (6), Hston, A., Summrs, R., & Atn, B. (2011). Pnn World Tabl Vrsion 7.0. Cntr for Intrnational Comparisons of Production, Incom and Prics at th Univrsity of Pnnsylvania. Rtrivd from Lin, S. (2000). Forign trad and China s conomic dvlopmnt: A tim-sris analysis. Journal of Economic Dvlopmnt, 25(1),
12 Lopz, A. (2005). Trad and growth: Rconciling th macroconomic and microconomic vidnc. Journal of Economic Survys, 19(4), Panagariya, A. (2004). Miracls and dbacls: In dfnc of trad opnnss. World Economy, 27(8). Rodríguz, F. (2007). Opnnss and growth: What hav w larnd? (DESA Working Papr No. 51). Rodrik, D., & Rodriguz, F. (2000). Trad policy and conomic growth: A skptics guid to th crossnational vidnc (NBER Working Papr No. 7081). Cambridg, MA: National Burau of Economic Rsarch Ricardo, D. (1817). Th principls of political conomy and taxation. London: Evryman, Smith, A. (1976). An inquiry into th natur and causs of th walth of nations. Oxford: Clarndon Prss. Sachs, D. J., & Warnr, A. (1995). Economic rforms and th procss of global intgration. Brooking Paprs on Economic Activity, 1995(1), Stnsns, K. (2006). Trad opnnss and conomic growth do institutions mattr? (Papr No. 702). Norwgian Institut of Intrnational Affairs Tahir, M. (2013). Import opnnss and conomic growth: Cross sctional vidnc from OECD. Intrnational Journal of Economics and Rsarch, 4(1), 1-7. Tahir, M., & Khan, I. (2014). Trad opnnss and conomic growth in th Asian rgion. Journal of Chins Economic and Forign Trad Studis, 7(3), Tahir, M., & Norulazidah, H. (2014). Trad opnnss and conomic growth: A rviw of th litratur. Asian Social Scinc, 10(9), p Tahir, M., & Norulazidah, H. (2013). Th rlationship btwn trad and incom: Th cas of dvlopd countris. Intrnational Rsarch Journal of Financ and Economics, (111), Thirlwall, P. (2000). Trad libralisation and conomic growth: Thory and vidnc (Economic rsarch papr No. 63). African Dvlopmnt Bank. Ulaşan, B. (2012). Opnnss to intrnational trad and conomic growth: A cross-country mpirical invstigation. Economics, / Wacziarg, R., & Wlch, H. K. (2003). Trad libralization and conomic growth: Nw vidnc (NBER Working Papr No ). Cambridg, MA: National Burau of Economic Rsarch Warnr, A. (2003). Onc mor in to th brach: Economic growth and intgration (Working Papr No. 34). Cntr for Global Dvlopmnt. Whit, H. (1980). A htrokdasticity-consistnt covarianc matrix stimator and a dirct tst for htrokdasticity. Economtica, 48(2), Wintrs, A. (2004). Trad libralization and conomic prformanc: An ovrviw. Th Economic Journal, 114, World Bank ( ). World dvlopmnt indicators. Rtrivd from data-catalog/world-dvlopmnt-indicators Yanikkaya, H. (2003). Trad opnnss and conomic growth: A cross-country mpirical invstigation. Journal of Dvlopmnt Economics, 72, doi: /s (03)
13 Appndics Appndix 1: List of th Total Sampl (67 Dvloping Countris) Albania Algria Angola Bolivia Botswana Brazil Bulgaria Camroon Chil China Colombia Cot d`ivoir Dominican Rpublic Egypt El Salvador Fiji Gabon Ghana Guatmala Guyana Honduras India Indonsia Iran Lbanon Lsotho Malaysia Mauritania Mauritius Mxico Mongolia Morocco Namibia Nicaragua Pakistan Panama Paraguay Pru Philippins Romania Russia Sngal South Africa Sri Lanka Sudan Swaziland Thailand Tunisia Turky Uruguay Uzbkistan Vnzula Zambia Bangladsh Bnin Chad Ethiopia Guina Knya Madagascar Malawi Mozambiqu Npal Rwanda Sirra Lon Tanzania Uganda Appndix 2: Lowr-Middl-Incom and Low-Incom Dvloping Countris (41 Countris) Angola Bolivia Camroon Cot d`ivoir Egypt El Salvador Fiji Ghana Guatmala Guyana Honduras India Indonsia Lsotho Mauritania Mongolia Morocco Nicaragua Pakistan Paraguay Philippins Sngal Sri Lanka Sudan Swaziland Uzbkistan Zambia Bangladsh Bnin Chad Ethiopia Guina Knya 36 Madagascar Malawi Mozambiqu Npal Rwanda Sirra Lon Tanzania Uganda
SUMMARY Estimated Future Tax Evasion under the Income Tax System and Prospects for Tax Evasion under the FairTax: New Perspectives
SUMMARY Estimatd Futur Tax Evasion undr th Incom Tax Systm and Prospcts for Tax Evasion undr th FairTax: Nw Prspctivs By Richard J. Cbula, Ph.D. Fiorntina AngjllariDajci, Ph.D. March 1, 2017 Purpos of
More informationOn the decomposition of life expectancy and limits to life
On th dcomposition of lif xpctancy and limits to lif Ls Mayhw and David Smith Faculty of Actuarial Scinc Cass Businss School Longvity 10 Sptmbr 2014 Santiago Chil Som ky dmographic issus What do trnds
More informationOn the decomposition of life expectancy and limits to life
On th dcomposition of lif xpctancy and limits to lif Ls Mayhw and David Smith Faculty of Actuarial Scinc Cass Businss School ARC Confrnc 2014 Santa Barbara Som ky dmographic issus What do trnds in lif
More informationPsychometric Properties of the Level of Knowledge Use Survey (LOKUS) Tool
Psychomtric Proprtis of th Lvl of Knowldg Us Survy (LOKUS) Tool (Shrya Tlang, Machiko Tomita, Vathsala Ston) Prsntr: Vathsala I. Ston vston@buffalo.du Univrsity at Buffalo/Cntr on Knowldg Translation for
More informationStructural design and motion analysis of Hexapod Bionic walking. device. Zhu Zhifang12
4th Intrnational Confrnc on Machinry, Matrials and Computing Tchnology (ICMMCT 016) Structural dsign and motion analysis of Hxapod Bionic walking dvic Zhu Zhifang1 1.Jiangxi Provinc Ky Laboratory of prcision
More informationMULTIAXIAL FATIGUE OF A RAILWAY WHEEL STEEL
Journal of Enginring Scinc and Tchnology Vol. 10, No. 9 (2015) 1215-1223 School of Enginring, Taylor s Univrsity MULTIAXIAL FATIGUE OF A RAILWAY WHEEL STEEL CHIN-SUNG CHUNG 1, HO-KYUNG KIM 2, * 1 R&D Cntr,
More informationHUDDERSFIELD NEW COLLEGE FURTHER EDUCATION CORPORATION
HUDDERSFIELD NEW COLLEGE FURTHER EDUCATION CORPORATION Stakholdr Engagmnt Framwork Huddrsfild Nw Collg Corporation blivs that it is ssntial to know th viws and xprincs of studnts, thir parnts, staff and
More informationResearch Article Modeling the Perceptions and Preferences of Pedestrians on Crossing Facilities
Discrt Dynamics in Natur and Socity, Articl ID 949475, 8 pags http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/949475 Rsarch Articl Modling th Prcptions and Prfrncs of Pdstrians on Crossing Facilitis Hongwi Guo, 1 Fachng
More informationNOVEL AIRFOIL DESIGN FOR SMALL HORIZONTAL AXIS WIND TURBINE: A PRELIMINARY RESULT
SASEC2015 Third Southrn African Solar Enrgy Confrnc 11 13 May 2015 Krugr National Park, South Africa NOVEL AIRFOIL DESIGN FOR SMALL HORIZONTAL AXIS WIND TURBINE: A PRELIMINARY RESULT 1* Ajayi Olusyi O,
More informationTHE VALUE ADDED OF CONDUCTING REGIONAL VERSUS LOCAL STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT IN EVALUATING TECHNOLOGY ACCEPTANCE
7536Y6--ay PNL-SA-25948 THE VALUE ADDED OF CONDUCTNG REGONAL VERSUS LOCAL STAKEHOLDER NVOLVEMENT N EVALUATNG TECHNOLOGY ACCEPTANCE G. H. McCab s Jun 1995 Prsntd at th Air and Wast Managmnt Association
More informationSelection Protocol BC Snowboard Provincial Freestyle Team July 15, 2015
Slction Protocol 2015-2016 BC Snowboard Provincial Frstyl Tam July 15, 2015 Background Th BC Snowboard Provincial Frstyl Tam Slction Protocol is dsignd to outlin tam slction for th rstructurd BC Snowboard
More informationINDIAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL EDUCATION, SPORTS AND APPLIED SCIENCE, VOL.8, NO.4,October,2018
Availabl Onlin www.sportscintistsviws.com Journal DOI-05-2016-44975451 Scintific Journal Impact Factor-4.917 BAREFOOT, SHOD AND SHOE SPIKE: WHICH IS MORE EFFICIENT? Dr. Kuldp Singh 1 Mahipal 2 Affiliations:
More informationSlowing Women s Labor Force Participation: The Role of Income Inequality
Slowing Womn s Labor Forc Participation: Th Rol of Incom Inquality Stfania Albansi, Univrsity of Pittsburgh María José Praos, USC ESSIM in Tarragona - May 24-26, 2017 1 / 61 Trns in LFP an Wags Slowing
More informationOwner s Manual. Model Number: 73654
Ownr s Manual Modl Numbr: 73654 Fishr-Pric, Inc., a subsidiary of Mattl, Inc., East Aurora, NY 14052 U.S.A. 2002 Mattl, Inc. All Right Rsrvd. and dsignat U.S. tradmarks of Mattl, Inc. Printd in China.
More informationACTIVITY SHAPING THE TALLEST PEAK ON EARTH
gography standards 1, 4, 7, 17; scinc standard d-3; social studis standard 3 ACTIVITY SHAPIG THE TALLEST PEAK O EARTH 1H MOUT EVEREST, PART OF THE HIMALAYA MOUTAI RAGE, was cratd 30 to 50 million yars
More informationLesson Plans Unit 1 Assessment Focus
g E n P i l n r a a c r al l dn i v r al r l a n o ti o m, f i y l c a d r n a t i t l r l po ca i S s, y E h P p n i th hiv n r ac ld i o h t c ll ls l a i k g s n k u. Givi hinking o c t. n t d pm an
More informationUniform illumination for slim, shallow box signs
Uniform illumination for slim, shallow box signs Koldo Affinium postrbox s (LPM300), spcially dsignd for shallow box signs Uniform illumination for slim, shallow box signs Koldo Affinium postrbox s (LPM300)
More informationGEF-6 INDICATIVE STAR ALLOCATIONS
GEF Council Meeting October 28 30, 2014 Washington, D.C. GEF/C.47/Inf.08 July 01, 2014 GEF-6 INDICATIVE STAR ALLOCATIONS INTRODUCTION 1. In May 2014, the GEF Council adopted the paper GEF/C.46/05/Rev.01,
More informationDepartament de Ciència Animal i dels Aliments, Facultat de Veterinària, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Spain;
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 Articl Modlling for th inhritanc of ndangrd quid multipl births and
More informationTRANSPORTATION IMPACT STUDY HYATT PLACE HOTEL EXPANSION AND OLD DAVIS ROAD EXTENSION
TRANSPORTATION IMPACT STUDY HYATT PLACE HOTEL EXPANSION AND OLD DAVIS ROAD EXTENSION Prpard for: Submittd by: 2990 Lava Ridg Ct. Suit 200 Rosvill, CA. 95661 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction... 1 Projct
More informationSlowing Women's Labor Force Participation: The Role of Rising Income Inequality
Slowing Womn's Labor Forc Participation: Th Rol of Rising Incom Inquality Stfania Albansi, FRBNY an CEPR Mará José Praos, USC USC - Octobr 2, 2014 Th viws xprss hr ar thos of th authors an o not ncssarily
More informationAn Experimental Study on Properties of Fly ash Aggregate Comparing with Natural Aggregate
Print ISSN : 2349-8404; Onlin ISSN : 2349-879X; Volum 2, Numbr 11; April Jun, 201 pp 4 8 Krishi Sanskriti Publications http://www.krishisanskriti.org/jct.html An Exprimntal Study on Proprtis of Fly ash
More informationHealth Advice on Eating Fish You Catch
Fingr Laks Rgion Halth Advic on Eating Fish You Catch MAP INSIDE Including Allgany, Broom, Cayuga, Chmung, Cortland, Livingston, Monro, Onondaga, Ontario, Schuylr, Snca, Stubn, Tioga, Tompkins, Wayn, and
More informationSTUDY ON ANCHOR BEHAVIOR OF CFRP PLATE TO CONCRETE
Octor -7, 8, Bijing, China STUDY ON ANCHOR BEHAVIOR OF CFRP PLATE TO CONCRETE Kntaro MATSUNAGA and Tsutomu YANO and Hiroyuki NAKAMURA and Nouhiro HISABE and Toshiyuki KANAKUBO Graduat Studnt, Graduat School
More informationHydraulic modeling summary for Sodom Dam Alternatives Feasibility Study
Tchnical Mmorandum DATE: Novmbr 24, 2009 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Ms. Dnis Hoffrt-Hay Sodom Dam Projct Managr Calapooia Watrshd Council Rivr Dsign Group, Inc. 311 SW Jffrson Avnu Corvallis, Orgon 97333 Hydraulic
More informationJournal of Energy Technologies and Policy ISSN (Paper) ISSN (Online) Vol.4, No.6, 2014
Dsign and Simulation of Hybrid Wind Disl Systm Softwar Prof.Sursh Mashyal (Corrsponding author Maratha Mandal Enginring Collg R.S.No.104 Halbhai, P.O. Nw Vantmuri ia Kakati, Blgaum-591113, Karnataka Stat,
More informationSome aspects of spawning season and biology of Indian Oil sardine, Sardinella longiceps along, Goa Karwar sector of West Coast of India
Indian Journal of Go Marin Scincs Vol. 45 (11), Novmbr 2016, pp. 1481-1486 Som aspcts of spawning sason and biology of Indian Oil sardin, Sardinlla longicps along, Goa Karwar sctor of Wst Coast of India
More informationWind Forced Motion. Equation of motion a=σf/ρ 12/09/11. What forces might cause a parcel of water to accelerate?
Physical ocanography, MSCI 3001 Ocanographic Procsss, MSCI 5004 Dr. Alx Sn Gupta a.sngupta@unsw..au Wind Forcd Motion Equation of motion aσf/ρ What forcs might caus a parcl of watr to acclrat? Movmnt of
More informationFull-Time Visa Enrolment by Countries
Page 1 of 32 All Students Afghanistan Albania Algeria Andorra Antigua Argentina Armenia Australia Austria Azerbaidjan Bahamas Bahrain Bangladesh Barbados Belarus Belgium Belize Benin (Dahomey) Bermuda
More informationFact sheet on elections and membership
Commission on Narcotic Drugs Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Fact sheet on elections and membership States members of the CCPCJ and CND (and other functional commissions of the Economic
More informationAmbulatory Physical Activity in Swiss Army Recruits
716 Training & Tsting Amulatory Physical Activity in Swiss Army Rcruits Authors Affiliation T. Wyss, J. Schfflr, U. Mädr Swiss Fdral Institut of Sports Magglingn SFISM, Sport and Prformanc Unit, Magglingn,
More informationAfrica on the Rise: Opportunities and Challenges
1 Africa on the Rise: Opportunities and Challenges African Development Bank Group Domenico Fanizza Executive Director October 2018 Africa: a vast and fragmented continent The Africa Rising Story.. SSA
More informationComposition of the UNICEF Executive Board
The dates reflect years of membership in the Executive Board and not necessarily terms of office. 1 Afghanistan 1960 1963; 1965 1967; 1977 1980 Albania 2012 2014 Algeria 1971 1974; 1982 1985; 2004 2006
More informationTable 2. ARD Mortality Rate by Country and Disease (from GBD Study 2016)*
Lung cancer Asbestosis United Kingdom 4.34 21.50 0.32 1.43 27.59 0.04 27.63 Netherlands 3.73 22.43 0.07 0.97 27.21 0.04 27.25 Italy 2.81 21.17 0.17 1.30 25.44 0.05 25.49 Belgium 2.45 21.04 0.22 0.87 24.58
More informationPower Supply in Package (PSiP) Power Supply on Chip (PwrSoC) Update 2010
Powr Supply in Packag (PSiP) Powr Supply on Chip (PwrSoC) Updat 2010 Controllr Protction Drivr Drivr By Arnold Aldrman, Anagnsis, Inc. And Cian O Mathuna, Tyndall National Institut Controllr Outlin 1.
More informationAPPENDIX A: MIDDLE-INCOME COUNTRIES SELECTED INFORMATION
APPENDIX A: MIDDLE-INCOME COUNTRIES SELECTED INFORMATION Table A.1: Regional Distribution of Middle-Income Countries and 2004 GNI per Capita Table A.2: Economic, Social, and Governance Indicators Table
More information2018 Daily Prayer for Peace Country Cycle
2018 Daily Prayer for Peace Country Cycle Monday January 1, 2018 All Nations Tuesday January 2, 2018 Ghana Wednesday January 3, 2018 Nigeria Thursday January 4, 2018 Costa Rica Friday January 5, 2018 Turkmenistan
More informationIR-Pay Go Rates. There are three pricing groups for Pay Go rates for International Roaming as follows:
IR-Pay Go Rates A. IR Pay Go Rate Summary There are three pricing groups for Pay Go rates for International Roaming as follows: Sr IR Pay Go Rate Group 1 Rs 2 2 2 2 Rs 10 10 10 3 Rs 50 600 25 Applicable
More informationPolitical stability and absence of violence/terrorism index* 2010
Data Tables II 321 This appendix provides tables for each of the 84 indicators that make up the Global Innovation Index 2012 (GII). Structure Each table is identified by indicator number, with the first
More informationKids Sea Camp. Please see the Kids Sea Camp dive agenda attached.
Wlcom to Kids Sa Camp Thank you for choosing to di with Scuba St. Lucia. Th following information is about our oprating procdurs and schdul. Bfor diving with us, plas rviw this pamphlt thoroughly. Fill
More informationA modified experiment of Oersted
A modifid xprimnt of Orstd Dimitar G STOYANOV Faculty of Enginring and Pdagogy in Slivn, Tchnical Univrsity of Sofia 59, Bourgasko Shauss Blvd, 88 Slivn, BULGARA E-mail: dgstoyanov@abvbg Abstract Simpl
More informationContents. Special Feature. T h e. D e n t. C a. t y C r e a. t e. v a l u e. 014 Dentsu Integrated Report 2016
T h D n t s u C a p a G b r i o l u i p t ' s y C r a t t o v a l u s 014 Dntsu Intgratd Rport 2016 OUTPUT Th Dntsu Group s Capability to Crat Valus Valu cration Th Dntsu Group s Valu Crating Procss Dntsu
More informationTransition Modeling and Econometric Convergence Tests
Transition Modeling and Econometric Convergence Tests Donggyu Sul University of Auckland With Peter C.B. Phillips Time Varying Common Factor Representation Panel Data: Yes, no index No. I am not covering
More informationmissed. The football you ve
Th football you v missd. Rmmbr th glory days. Grass in bad conditions, rain mudding th rough pitch. Elvn tough guys a sid that will transform a gam in an pic battl that maks you long for match day all
More informationBasic Horse Genetics.
A l a b a m a A & M a n d A u b u r n U n i v r s i t i s Basic Hors Gntics ANR-1420 Undrstanding th basic principls of gntics and gn-slction mthods is ssntial for popl in th hors-brding businss and is
More informationSession 4. Growth. The World Economy Share of Global GDP Year 2011 (PPP)
Session 4. Growth Stylized Facts on Standards of Living across Countries Characterizing Growth over 1 Years: The US Economy Growth Dynamics of the G7 Countries and the OECD Economies Characterizing Growth
More informationDinosaur Tributary Inventory and Feasibility
Pac Projct Watr Us Plan Dinosaur Tributary Invntory and Fasibility GMSWORKS #9 Rcommndations for Improving Accss or Enhancing Habitat on Dinosaur Rsrvoir Tributaris Study Priod: Jun 2009 to Novmbr 2009
More informationGETTING STARTED INSTALLATION GUIDE HID CONVERSION KIT. Please make sure all parts are included in your HID kit.
v1.0 030718 HI ONVRSION KIT INSTLLTION UI Profssional installation is rcommndd. LL HI KITS R INSTLL T YOUR OWN RISK! OPT7 and its affiliats will not b hld liabl for any damag or cost associatd with installation
More informationR Framework Developments - All SSBs
R0226 - Framwork Dvlopmnts - All SSBs 01 Novmbr 2014 to 30 Novmbr 2014 Pag 1 of 63 Framwork Dvlopmnts is a rport listing th nw, rviwd and xpiring standards, qualifications and Consnt and Modration Rquirmnt
More informationCoordination Commission. Games of the XXX Olympiad, London 2012
Final Rport of th IOC Coordination Commission Inspir a gnration 0 Tabl of Contnts Mssag from th Prsidnt of th Intrnational Olympic Committ, Jacqus Rogg London 0 dlivrd th Happy and Glorious Gams a clbration
More informationquebec open 2011 djudo competition din 2010 several countries participated: October 8th and 9th Centre Pierre-Charbonneau Montreal
qubc opn 2011 Octobr 8th and 9th Cntr Pirr-Charbonnau Montral djudo comptition U15, U17, U20, snior and mastrs din 2010 svral countris participatd: V rs i n ón n l vrd s int pa r n ño ior l USA, Franc,
More informationBow Tie Wedding SVG Set.
Bow Ti Wdding SVG St d i u G ct Proj www.dcipollodsigns.com Introduction This wdding stationary st has a traditional and lgant dsign in th popular layrd styl, using svral layrs of your favorit pattrnd
More informationNUMBER OF UTILITY PATENT APPLICATIONS FILED IN THE UNITED STATES, BY COUNTRY OF ORIGIN CALENDAR YEAR 1965 TO PRESENT
NUMBER OF UTILITY PATENT APPLICATIONS FILED IN THE UNITED STATES, BY COUNTRY OF ORIGIN CALENDAR YEAR 1965 TO PRESENT July 1999 OFFICE FOR PATENT AND TRADEMARK INFORMATION U.S. PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
More informationUrbanization and sustainable development David Satterthwaite, IIED
Urbanization and sustainable development David Satterthwaite, IIED How can urbanization be a problem if All rich nations are highly urbanized; all the poorest nations predominantly rural All the most successful
More informationPRELIMINARY ANALYSIS ON THE INFLUENCE OF THE LINK CONFIGURATION ON SEISMIC PERFORMANCES OF MRF-EBF DUAL SYSTEMS DESIGNED BY TPMC
Intrnational Journal of Earthquak Enginring Num. Anno XXXIII Spcial CTA Num. PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS ON THE INFLUENCE OF THE LINK CONFIGURATION ON SEISMIC PERFORMANCES OF MRF-EBF DUAL SYSTEMS DESIGNED BY
More informationUncle John's Choupique Road - Sulphur, LA 70665
Uncl John's 5229 Choupiqu Road - Sulphur, LA 70665 Thank you for purchasing my plans. Should you hav any qustions whil building your Jon-boat don't hsitat to mail, uncljohn@uncljohns.com or call, 337-570-1486.
More informationQuestions and Answers
Questions and Answers What are the key objectives of this initiative? To unify 6 different handicap systems into a single World that will: enable golfers to play and compete anywhere around the world on
More informationINTERNATIONAL STUDENT STATISTICAL SUMMARY Spring 2017 (Final)
INTERNATIONAL STUDENT STATISTICAL SUMMARY Spring 2017 (Final) Prepared By: Mr. Jay Ward, Associate Director Office of International Programs San Francisco State University Non-Matriculated SP 17 SP 16
More informationASSEMBLY 39TH SESSION
International Civil Aviation Organization WORKING PAPER 10/6/16 ASSEMBLY 39TH SESSION ADMINISTRATIVE COMMISSION Agenda Item 52: Assessments to the General Fund for 2017, 2018 and 2019 DRAFT SCALES OF ASSESSMENT
More informationSustainability. In Plain English. Alaska Seafood
ALASKA SEAFOOD MARKETING INSTITUTE www.alaskasafood.org 800-478-2903 Intrnational Markting Offic& Administration: 311 N. Franklin St., Suit 200, Junau, AK 99801 U.S. Markting Offic: 150 Nickrson Strt,
More informationHealth workforce, infrastructure, essential medicines
Health workforce, infrastructure, essential medicines Data on the resources available to the health system are essential to enable governments to determine how best to meet the health-related needs of
More informationGETTING STARTED HID CONVERSION KIT INSTALLATION GUIDE. Please make sure all parts are included in your HID kit.
v1.0.031318 HI ONVRSION KIT INSTLLTION UI Profssional installation is rcommndd. LL HI KITS R INSTLL T YOUR OWN RISK! OPT7 and its affiliats will not b hld liabl for any damag or cost associatd with installation
More informationFCCC/SBI/2013/INF.15. United Nations. Status of contributions as at 31 October 2013
United Nations FCCC/SBI//INF.15 Distr.: General 7 November English only Subsidiary Body for Implementation Thirty-ninth session Warsaw, 11 16 November Item 18(a) of the provisional agenda Administrative,
More informationProfile of GMAT Testing 2017
Profile of GMAT Testing 2017 Profile of GMAT Testing: Five-Year Summary, TY2013 - TY2017 November 2017 Globally, more than 1.2 million Graduate Management Admission Test (GMAT ) exams have been taken over
More informationCodebook for Democratic Electoral Systems Around the World,
Codebook for Democratic Electoral Systems Around the World, 1946-2000 Matt Golder March 26, 2007 Department of Politics, New York University, 726 Broadway, 7th Floor, New York, NY 10003. E-mail: mrg217@nyu.edu.
More informationINFLUENCE OF DAMPING ON THE ROLL MOTION OF SHIPS
INFLUENE OF MPING ON THE ROLL MOTION OF SHIPS Er PESMN, niz YRKTR and Mtin TYLN STRT This papr analyzs th ffct of daping on nonlinar roll otion of ships advancing in ba sas. s it is known, roll daping
More informationVISA REQUIREMENTS. Office Processing Application. Albania Yes Geneva, Switzerland. Andorra Yes Geneva, Switzerland. Angola Yes Windhoek, Namibia
VISA REQUIREMENTS This information is provided solely as a guide. Every effort has been made to ensure it is accurate and up-to-date. As visa requirements may change at short notice user are advised to
More informationCAADP Implementation and Achievement of Outcomes. Sam Benin, IFPRI
CAADP Implementation and Achievement of Outcomes Sam Benin, IFPRI Introduction and Objectives Last 2 days: learned about significant growth and poverty reduc7on in Africa in recent decades Ques6on: how
More informationAnnex 1.List of IIAs, at end May 2015 a
ANNEX TABLES 1 Annex 1.List of IIAs, at end May 2015 a Afghanistan 3 4 7 Albania 43 7 50 Algeria 47 8 55 Angola 8 7 15 Anguilla 0 1 1 Antigua and Barbuda 2 9 11 Argentina 58 15 73 Armenia 42 4 46 Aruba
More informationUK Trade Statistics 2016
Value ( million) Rate of Exchange (USD against GBP) ORNAMENTAL AQUATIC TRADE ASSOCIATION LTD. "The Voice of the Ornamental Fish Industry" 1 st Floor Office Suite, Wessex House 4 Station Road, Westbury,
More informationFavourable youth labour market (15-24) relative to EU
Education and th Labour Markt- Autrian Youth in comparion with th EU Gudrun Biffl Kynot Spch at th Intrnational Confrnc on Youth Employmnt Ljubljana, 13./14. Dcmbr 2007 Favourabl youth labour markt (15-24)
More informationRole Models and Women s Political Representation
Role Models and Women s Political Representation Fabrizio Gilardi Department of Political Science University of Zurich swissnex Boston April 23, 2015 (Updated April 23, 2015) 1 / 39 Outline The Problem
More informationOffice of Institutional Research
ri a l C ty Consistency Sim p li c it y Office of Institutional Research Place of Residence for International Students by Gender: Published October 2012 OIR Staff: Peggy Johnson - Associate Director Miriam
More informationFCCC/SBI/2013/INF.10. United Nations. Status of contributions as at 15 May 2013
United Nations FCCC/SBI//INF.10 Distr.: General 24 May English only Subsidiary Body for Implementation Thirty-eighth session Bonn, 3 14 June Item 18(a) of the provisional agenda Administrative, financial
More informationGoverning Body 332nd Session, Geneva, 8 22 March 2018
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE Governing Body 332nd Session, Geneva, 8 22 March 2018 Programme, Financial and Administrative Section PFA FOR INFORMATION Programme and Budget for 2018 19: Collection of contributions
More informationThe IB Middle Years Programme Statistical Bulletin. June 2016 Examination Session. Education for a better world
The IB Middle Years Programme Statistical Bulletin June 2016 Examination Session Education for a better world TheIBMiddleYearsProgrammeStatisticalBuletin,June2016ExaminationSession. InternationalBaccalaureate
More informationStatus of submission of overdue reports by States parties under article 18 of the Convention
[Informal document] Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women Status of submission of overdue reports by States parties under article 18 of the Convention Report of the Secretariat of
More informationFreshwater Withdrawal by Country and Sector
D a t a T a b l e 2 Freshwater Withdrawal by Country and Sector Description The use of water varies greatly from country to country and from region to region. Data on water use by regions and by different
More informationEconomic freedom advanced this year,
Executive Highlights Economic freedom advanced this year, regaining much of the momentum lost during the fiscal crisis and global recession. Many governments around the world have rededicated themselves
More information2018 FIFA WORLD CUP RUSSIA
2018 FIFA WORLD CUP RUSSIA GROUP MATCHES & FINAL ROUND SERIES PACKAGES Wondrful Russia will b th warm Host of th 21st dition of th FIFA World Cup for a tournamnt which promiss to b uncomparabl. From 14th
More informationSome Facts About Output
Some Facts About Output GNP as a Percentage of GDP in 2009 Country % Kuwait 110,38 United Kingdom 102 Japan 103,14 United States 99,24 China 100,87 Germany 101,41 Mexico 98,34 Poland 96,76 Ireland 81,19
More informationLong Distance Rate by Zone
Long Distance Rate by Zone Country Long Distance Rates ZONE 1 United States, China, Hong Kong, Germany, France, India, Italy, Ireland, Switzerland, Australia, New Zealand, Pakistan, Poland, Netherlands,
More informationNEVIS EXPORTS SERVICE CAPABILITY AND RATING ZONES
NEVIS EXPORTS SERVICE CAPABILITY AND RATING ZONES DOC = document contents only Afghanistan 9 Albania 9 Algeria 9 American Samoa 9 Andorra 9 Angola 9 Anguilla 1 Antigua 1 Argentina 8 Armenia 9 Aruba 4 Australia
More informationCalgary Islamic School Omar Bin Al Khattab Campus. School Goals Palliser Regional Schools
Calgar Islamic School Omar Bin Al Khattab Campus School Goals Pallisr Rgional Schools 2017-2018 Accountabilit Pillar Ovrall Summar 3-Yar Plan - Ma 2017 School: 1722 Calgar Islamic School, Omar Bin Al-Khattab
More informationWorst economic crisis since WWII and lack of funds posing internal and external barriers to internationalisation
Hot Topics Dr Janet Ilieva International Education Intelligence Unit Setting the context Worst economic crisis since WWII and lack of funds posing internal and external barriers to internationalisation
More informationQuestions and Answers
Questions and Answers 1. What are the key objectives of this initiative? To unify 6 different handicap systems into a single World Handicap that will: enable golfers to play and compete anywhere around
More informationNITROGEN CHARGING KIT type PC 11.1 E 01-12
NITROGEN CHARGING KIT type PC 11.1 E 01-12 11.1.1 TECHNICAL DATA MAX OPERATING PRESSURE (PS): 600 BAR PRESSURE TEST (PT): 1.43 PS SCALE OF PRESSURE GAUGE: 4-10 - 16-25 - 60-100 - 250 (std.) - 400-600 bar
More informationNITROGEN CHARGING KIT type PC 11.1 E 04-11
NITROGEN CHARGING KIT type PC 11.1 E 04-11 11.1.1 TECHNICAL DATA MAX OPERATING PRESSURE (PS): 600 BAR PRESSURE TEST (PT): 1.43 PS SCALE OF PRESSURE GAUGE: 4-10 - 16-25 - 60-100 - 250 (std.) - 400-600 bar
More informationUFC Fight Night: Belfort vs Gastelum March 11 Fortaleza, Brazil
UFC Fight Night: Belfort vs Gastelum March 11 Fortaleza, Brazil Fight Pass Prelims (#1-2) Featured bout: Jason vs Kennedy Time (EST) 7:00 PM Time (GMT) 12:00 AM ONLINE: Brazil, Barbados, Jamaica, - Blocked
More informationu Calls that you make whilst roaming u Calls you receive while roaming u Data you use and text/sms messages you send
Information for customers INTERNATIONAL ROAMING with Bendigo Telco s DataMax Mobile Plan Customer Acknowledgement Signature Date What is international roaming? The term international roaming is used to
More informationProduction, trade and supply of natural gas Terajoules
Terajoules Table Notes Production includes quantities from other sources, which would include any quantities of biogas, LPG or manufactured gas blended with natural gas. Please refer to the Definitions
More informationThe International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (ILGA)
The International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association (ILGA) 2017-2018 Deadlines relating to the UN Treaty Bodies* Below is a list of 2018 2019 deadlines for UN Treaty Bodies (Italic:
More informationUK Trade Statistics 2017
Value ( million) Rate of Exchange (USD against GBP) ORNAMENTAL AQUATIC TRADE ASSOCIATION LTD. "The Voice of the Ornamental Fish Industry" 1 st Floor Office Suite, Wessex House 4 Station Road, Westbury,
More informationIBSA Goalball World Rankings 31 December 2017 Men's Division
IBSA Goalball World Rankings 31 December 2017 Men's Division Rank No v Oc t Se p Au g Ju l Team Region Score Goal Diff Results Gol p Gme Last Plyd Weight 1st 5 6 6 1 2 Brazil Americas 661.802 4.564 0.872
More informationAfrica s Third Liberation? 21 st Century Development Drivers. Greg Mills SIDA
THEBRENTHURST FOUNDATION Africa s Third Liberation? 21 st Century Development Drivers Greg Mills SIDA 19 January 2012 Point of Departure: Six Di Drivers People. Growth and Differentiation. Democracy
More informationGlobal growth forecasts Key countries/regions,
Global growth forecasts Key countries/regions, 2014-2018 Percent 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Developing Asia Sub-Saharan Africa Middle East and North Africa Latin America and the Caribbean United States Euro area
More informationCMMI Maturity Profile Report. 30 June 2017
CMMI Maturity Profile Report 30 June 2017 Executive Summary Appraisals increased 14% 1 Jan 30 Jun 17 Companies who reappraise continue to increase, currently at 74% 10% of reported appraisals are high
More informationMay 7-8, GRAND HYATT WASHINGTON Washington, DC
CISTS: A M R A H TION P to ATTEN f fo r t s it s and and dfic dicar S oaring M in y gun on ady b s a v m lr a ac y id hav M dica y pharm it n u m co m ucial! to sting c is cr n a d n t yo u r a t May 7-8,
More informationPortuguese, English, and. Bulgarian, English, French, or
Country Language Fiber Content Algeria Arabic Angola Portuguese, English, and French (optional) Optional Argentina Spanish Armenia Armenian Optional Australia English Austria German Bahrain Arabic or English
More informationISO is the world s largest developer of voluntary international standards
The ISO Survey ISO and The ISO Survey ISO is the world s largest developer of voluntary international standards for business, government and society. Its portfolio in October 2007 comprised more than 16
More information