the Story of the 30s & 70s Bus Lines James Hamre - WMATA

Transcription

1 Evaluation of a Service Restructuring: the Story of the 30s & 70s Bus Lines James Hamre - WMATA

2 Metrorail is the second largest rail transit system in the nation 230 million annual riders 780,000 weekday riders Metrobus is the fifth largest bus network in the nation 124 million annual ULPT 416,000 weekday ULPT 1500 buses/ 165 Lines MetroAccess is eighth in the nation serving Background About Metro 2.33 million riders in FY

3 WMATA Compact Service Area Metro serves a geographic area covering 1,500 square miles Eight compact member jurisdictions s plus 3 state DOTs Service area population of over 3.5 million 2 commuter rail systems 12 local bus systems 3

4 What is a Priority Corridor? 4

5 Metrobus Priority Corridor Network Plan 1. Columbia Pike (Pike Ride) 2. Richmond Highway Express (REX) 3. Georgia Ave./7 th St. 4. Crystal City Potomac Yard 5. Southern Ave. Metro National Harbor 6. Wisconsin Ave./Pennsylvania Ave. 7. University it Blvd./East-West thighway 8. Sixteenth St. (DC) 9. Leesburg Pike 10. Veirs Mill Rd. 11. New Hampshire Ave. 12. H St./Benning Rd. 13. Georgia Ave. (MD) 14. Greenbelt-Twinbrook 15. East-West Highway (Prince George s) 16. Anacostia-Congress Heights 17. Little River Tpke./Duke St. 18. Rhode Island Ave. Metro to Laurel 19. Mass Ave./U St./Florida Ave./8 th St./MLK Ave. 20. Rhode Island Ave. 21. Eastover-Addison Road Metro 22. Colesville Rd./Columbia Pike - MD US Fourteenth St. (DC) 24. North Capitol St. 5

6 Corridor Plans Address All Elements of Service Corridor Design Factors 1. Service Plan (type, frequency, span, coverage) 2. Customer Information Systems 3. Bus Stops and Facilities 4. Service Personnel and Operations Strategies 5. Traffic Operations and Management Strategies 6. Vehicle Design, Features and Amenities 7. Safety, Security and Incident Response 8. Fare Payment Strategies 6

7 30s and 70s Lines Service Areas Routes 31, 32, 34, 36, 37, 39, M6 Routes 70, 71, 79 7

8

9 30s Line Recommended Improvements Implemented in 2008 Created Route 31 Potomac Park to Friendship Heights Created Route M5 from Eastern Market to Naylor Rd Created Routes 37 and 39 Limited Stop Services Eliminated Routes 30, 34, & 35 Supervisor and driver training Updated schedule information at stops 9

10 Subsequent 30s Line Improvements Adjustments in 2009 Extended M5 from Eastern Market to Archives Renamed Route M5 to Route 34 Added trips to Route 32 to increase capacity 10

11 What is the Purpose of the Evaluation? Assess whether goals and objectives are being met Evaluate effectiveness of improvements Refine improvements Revisit mid- and longterm planned recommendations 11

12 Georgia Avenue and 30s Lines Evaluation Study Who is involved? Metro and the District of Columbia Department of Transportation (DDOT) and original implementation team. What was evaluated? Improvements implemented in 2007 and Why were these corridors chosen for evaluation? They are the first two lines studied as part of the Priority Corridor Network. When did the evaluation take place? From August 2009 to January 2010.

13 Evaluation Process 1. Public feedback 2. Assess bus operations 3. Assess street operations 4. Evaluate improvements made to the line 5. Recommend further improvements/refinements t 6. Update implementation strategies 13

14 How Did Bus Riders and the Public Participate? Rider Survey Public Workshops Comment Sheets Project Hot Line Website 14

15 How Was Public Input Used? Identify and prioritize issues for technical evaluation Provide background for issue analysis and draft recommendations Form a consensus on what issues need to be addressed Ideas/suggestions about further changes or improvements to the line 15

16 Driver and Supervisor Feedback on 30s Line Shorter routes (31,34,37,39) ) have helped reliability Congestion in Georgetown, at H and I Sts NW, and Sousa Bridge SE remain a problem Need to advance signal and runningway improvements Driver training is essential Traffic and parking enforcement needs to be stronger 16

17 Driver and Supervisor Feedback on 70s Line

18 Project Measures of Effectiveness Goal Evaluation Criteria Improve Schedule Adherence and Maintain Headway 1. Bus Bunching and Headway Separation Separation 2. On-Time Performance 3. Driver and Supervisor Feedback Reduce Travel Times and Improve Travel Speed 1. Bus Travel Time 2. Bus Travel Speed 3. Scheduled Transit Travel Times Reduce Overcrowding 1. Passenger Loads Per Trip Enhance Customer Experience 1. Customer Comments 2. Driver/Supervisor Comments 3. Bus Stop Improvements and Amenities Improve Efficiency and Productivity 1. Daily Ridership 2. Ridership by Stop 3. Passenger Boarding s Per Revenue Hour 4. Cost Per Boarding 5. Change in Fare Payment Type Achieve Appropriate Balance of Service 1. Level of Service on Different Sections of the Corridor Relative to Demand

19 Summary of Study Findings Wisconsin Ave. - Pennsylvania Ave. 30s Line 30s Line 1. Ridership remained steady 2. Bus bunching declined partially 3. On-Time performance improved Westbound but declined Eastbound 4. Bus travel speed and times have not changed except for route 37 and No overcrowding except on some trips due to schedule adherence problems 6. Productivity and efficiency declined 7. Customers experience enhanced partially

20 70s Line Summary of Study Findings Georgia Avenue 70s Line 1. Ridership remained steady 2. Schedule adherence has improved partially but headway separation problem remains 3. Good overall On-Time performance but deteriorating slightly nearer to the end terminal in the peak direction 4. Bus travel speed and times has not improved with the exception of route Overcrowding reduced on the 70 and 71 but problem remains on route Productivity and efficiency declined 7. Customers experience enhanced partially

21 Limited Stop Services Achieved Travel Time Savings Travel time savings were realized for all three lines Routes 37 & 39 Travel Time vs Routes 32,3636 Route 37 26% Route 39 25% Route 79 Peak 22% Base 26% Route 79 Travel Time vs Routes 70,71

22 Reliability Was Improved by Service Management On-time Performance of 30s Line Early (Prior to Change) Exact (Prior to Change) 1 5 min Late (Prior to Change) > 5 min Late (Prior to Change) Early (Current) Exact (Current) 1 5 min Late (Current) > 5 min Late (Current) 70% 65% 68% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 43% 39% 37% 36% 33% 31% 32% 32% 30% 26% 26% 23% 23% 24% 21% 20% 18% 18% 19% 15% 14% 14% 10% 9% 8% 5% 3% 0% 0% AM Eastbound AM Westbound PM Eastbound PM Westbound WISCONSIN AVE & ALBEMARLE ST NW 47% 22

23 30s Line Recommendations Recommendation Benefit Cost Estimate 1. Reinstate Dedicated Improve Reliability Supervisors 2. Expedite Running Way Improvements Improve I Headway Separation Improve Travel Time and Speed Helps to Improve Headway Separation Implementation Time Period $400,000 Short Term $100,000 Short Term 3. Marketing Campaign for Route 37 and 39 Improve Awareness of the services Increase Ridership $20,300 Short Term 4. Modify Supervisor Playbook Improve Service Management $3,400 Short Term 5. Expand Driver Training Improve Drivers Knowledge Improve Customer Experience $33,400 Short Term 6. Implement Dedicated Traffic Control Officers and Parking Enforcement Staff 7. Implement 30s Line Operation Center Improve Travel Time and Speed Improve Reliability Improve Headway Separation Assist Supervisors in addressing reliability and line management issues $688,500 Medium Term $160,000 Long Term Total $1,405,600

24 Georgia Avenue 70s Recommendations Recommendation Benefit Cost Estimate 1. Reinstate Dedicated Improve Reliability Supervisors 2. Add Peak Period Capacity on Route Expedite Proposed Running Way Improvements Improve Headway Separation Relieve Overcrowding in the Peak Periods Improve Slow Travel Times Improve Headway Separation 4. Design Bus Stop Bulbouts, Improve Slow Travel Times Improve Service Reliability Enhance TSP / Study Restricting Peak Period Parking Improve Headway Separation Implementation Time Period $320,000 Short Term $372,200 Short Term None Short Term $30,000 Short Term 5. Develop 70s Line Supervisor Improve Service Management $5,300 Short Term Playbook 6. Expand Driver Training Improve Drivers Knowledge Improve Customer Experience $28,000 Short Term 7. Implement Dedicated Traffic Control Officers and Parking Enforcement Staff Improve Travel Time and Speed Improve Reliability Improve Headway Separation Total $1,214,500 $459,000 Medium Term

25 For more information metrobus-studies.com or About Metro / Planning & Development 25

26 30s Line Ridership by Route by Year

27 70s Line Ridership by Route by Year

28 30s Line Survey Results

29 Georgia Avenue Line Survey Results Shift in Mode/Market On-Time Reliability Travel Time Improvement Passenger Crowding